Afrasiab Replies to Piran
68 verbatim couplets. Published index title:Afrasiab Replies to Piran. The prior checkpoint used a shortened next-title;this package uses the full index title. Begins return commission;ends Piran’s equivalence of life and death. Next C3.24 Iran and Turan Fight a Pitched Battle begins morning battle.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 68 verbatim couplets. The prior checkpoint used a shortened next-title;this package uses the full index title. Begins return commission;ends Piran’s equivalence of life and death. |
| Moscow | V165–169:1403–1469;67 main units. English8 actual165n22,English29–30 actual166n34. English9/10 reversed in main relative to English. S1–S3 main1445/1447/1448. English53–54 shares1455. Prayer1463 precedes condition1464–1465. Ten thousand1439,actual167n22 thirty;army/country1435,actual167n15 mother. |
| Mohl | III266–268:1417–1483;67 main units. Fuller praise1424,denial1445,Tus1446 in main. English9/10 and62–64 follow Mohl order. S1 checked gap1461–1462;S2/S3 checked gap1462–1463. English53–54 shares1469. Thirty thousand1456. English36:1452 parvaresh wording,not explicit mother;referent qualified. |
| Ganjoor | 12rokh sh17:2–68;67 body units. Main order follows Moscow. English8 gap8–9;English29–30 gap28–29. Source-only44/46/47. Shared54 at English53–54. Ten thousand38;army/country34. Prayer62 precedes condition63–64. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV89–94:1413–1480;68 main units. English8 actual90n6;denial1440/Tus1441 main. S1 main gap1456–1457 with actual92n27;S2/S3 main1458–1459. Shared1466 at English53–54. Ten thousand1451;no thirty reading certified. Mourner1447,actual92n8 mother. Retreat1463 differs from depletion. Prayer1474 precedes condition1475–1476. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6A servant made into royal armor
English 1–6; individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V165:1403 running text · Mohl III266:1417 running text · Khaleghi IV89:1413 running text · Ganjoor sh17:2 poem body · Moscow V165:1404 running text · Mohl III266:1418 running text · Khaleghi IV89:1414 running text · Ganjoor sh17:3 poem body · Moscow V165:1405 running text · Mohl III266:1419 running text · Khaleghi IV89:1415 running text · Ganjoor sh17:4 poem body · Moscow V165:1406 running text · Mohl III266:1420 running text · Khaleghi IV89:1416 running text · Ganjoor sh17:5 poem body · Moscow V165:1407 running text · Mohl III266:1421 running text · Khaleghi IV90:1417 running text · Ganjoor sh17:6 poem body · Moscow V165:1408 running text · Mohl III266:1422 running text · Khaleghi IV90:1418 running text · Ganjoor sh17:7 poem body
Moscow and Mohl both begin with the envoy’s return commission and the king’s affectionate praise; Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh preserve the same progression. The English adds the brightness of Piran’s counsel to the opening identification, anticipating the esteem developed in the reply rather than translating a separate image there. More substantially, it keeps the extraordinary protective metaphor: Piran is the king’s jowshan, with his life offered as a shield. This joins intimacy to dependence, making royal praise acknowledge the bodily risk carried by the servant. The English distributes body and life between armor and shield, whereas the Persian also stresses self-sacrifice. Its final claim about keeping the kingdom free interprets the political purpose of Piran’s expenditure; the source explicitly names his wealth and chosen hardship.
7–12An amplified and reordered encomium
English 7–12; individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V165:1409 running text · Mohl III266:1423 running text · Khaleghi IV90:1419 running text · Ganjoor sh17:8 poem body · Moscow V165:1409–1410 checked local running gap;actual V165n22 full praise unit · Mohl III266:1424 running text · Khaleghi IV90:1419–1420 checked local running gap;actual IV90n6 full praise unit · Ganjoor sh17:8–9 checked local running gap · Moscow V165:1411 running text · Mohl III266:1425 running text · Khaleghi IV90:1420 running text · Ganjoor sh17:10 poem body · Moscow V165:1410 running text · Mohl III266:1426 running text · Khaleghi IV90:1421 running text · Ganjoor sh17:9 poem body · Moscow V166:1412 running text · Mohl III266:1427 running text · Khaleghi IV90:1422 running text · Ganjoor sh17:11 poem body · Moscow V166:1413 running text · Mohl III266:1428 running text · Khaleghi IV90:1423 running text · Ganjoor sh17:12 poem body
The additional praise of Piran as earth’s foremost leader and recipient of a thousand blessings stands in Mohl’s running text. Moscow prints it in its actual apparatus, as does Khaleghi-Motlagh; Ganjoor has a checked local gap at that point. The English therefore preserves a verified fuller encomium rather than merely repeating the surrounding compliments. Its next two couplets follow Mohl and Khaleghi’s order: the comparison with Tur and Pashang precedes the unmatched commander. Moscow and Ganjoor reverse those units. The English’s temporal phrasing makes the ancestral comparison readily intelligible, while the sources retain a more compressed formulation involving the ancestral names and heaven. The shift from praise to Piran’s confessed fault then follows in all four, revealing why this reassurance has been so emphatic.
13–18Absolution and the denial of kinship
English 13–18; individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V166:1414 running text · Mohl III266:1429 running text · Khaleghi IV90:1424 running text · Ganjoor sh17:13 poem body · Moscow V166:1415 running text · Mohl III266:1430 running text · Khaleghi IV90:1425 running text · Ganjoor sh17:14 poem body · Moscow V166:1416 running text · Mohl III266:1431 running text · Khaleghi IV90:1426 running text · Ganjoor sh17:15 poem body · Moscow V166:1417 running text · Mohl III266:1432 running text · Khaleghi IV90:1427 running text · Ganjoor sh17:16 poem body · Moscow V166:1418 running text · Mohl III266:1433 running text · Khaleghi IV90:1428 running text · Ganjoor sh17:17 poem body · Moscow V166:1419 running text · Mohl III267:1434 running text · Khaleghi IV90:1429 running text · Ganjoor sh17:18 poem body
All four presentations release Piran from the king’s resentment, attribute the event to divine determination, and refuse to credit Khosrow’s royal radiance to Afrasiab. The English preserves the uncomfortable adjacency of pardon and repudiation: benevolence toward the general does not soften the attack on the grandson. Its reference to gold makes the Persian alchemical expression concrete. That is a defensible interpretation of the figurative search for value in the kinship, but the source does not separately name a gold payment or inheritance. The statement that no one taught the evil is similarly kept within the king’s account of providence, not certified as the narrator’s moral verdict. Across Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh, the final refusal to contend with the world-ruler places human blame beneath divine agency.
19–24Fortune as consolation and evasion
English 19–24; individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V166:1420 running text · Mohl III267:1435 running text · Khaleghi IV91:1430 running text · Ganjoor sh17:19 poem body · Moscow V166:1421 running text · Mohl III267:1436 running text · Khaleghi IV91:1431 running text · Ganjoor sh17:20 poem body · Moscow V166:1422 running text · Mohl III267:1437 running text · Khaleghi IV91:1432 running text · Ganjoor sh17:21 poem body · Moscow V166:1423 running text · Mohl III267:1438 running text · Khaleghi IV91:1433 running text · Ganjoor sh17:22 poem body · Moscow V166:1424 running text · Mohl III267:1439 running text · Khaleghi IV91:1434 running text · Ganjoor sh17:23 poem body · Moscow V166:1425 running text · Mohl III267:1440 running text · Khaleghi IV91:1435 running text · Ganjoor sh17:24 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all move from the dismissal of Piran’s guilt to the changing fortunes of warfare. The English retains the numbered reply and its cosmic vocabulary, so the answer remains visibly responsive to Piran’s earlier report. The dust of battle and the darkening sun and moon lead into ascent, descent, pleasure and affliction. The English sharpens the downward movement into dust and shame and renders alternating happiness and distress through clearing clouds. Those are interpretive developments of the contrast, not additional military events. Wine and music remain concrete signs of the fortunate interval. In the king’s mouth, this broad account of change offers real consolation while also reducing specific losses to the ordinary alternation of war, preparing the command to turn grief toward revenge.
25–30The disputed report of Khosrow’s approach
English 25–30; individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V166:1426 running text · Mohl III267:1441 running text · Khaleghi IV91:1436 running text · Ganjoor sh17:25 poem body · Moscow V166:1427 running text · Mohl III267:1442 running text · Khaleghi IV91:1437 running text · Ganjoor sh17:26 poem body · Moscow V166:1428 running text · Mohl III267:1443 running text · Khaleghi IV91:1438 running text · Ganjoor sh17:27 poem body · Moscow V166:1429 running text · Mohl III267:1444 running text · Khaleghi IV91:1439 running text · Ganjoor sh17:28 poem body · Moscow V166:1429 to V167:1430 checked local running gap;actual V166n34 full denial unit · Moscow V166:1429 to V167:1430 checked local running gap;actual V166n34 full denial unit · Mohl III267:1445 running text · Khaleghi IV91:1440 running text · Ganjoor sh17:28–29 checked local running gap · Moscow V166:1429 to V167:1430 checked local running gap;actual V166n34 full Tus/Dehestan unit · Moscow V166:1429 to V167:1430 checked local running gap;actual V166n34 full Tus/Dehestan unit · Mohl III267:1446 running text · Khaleghi IV91:1441 running text · Ganjoor sh17:28–29 checked local running gap
All four sources pair the futility of speech about the dead with an injunction not to abandon vengeance for the brother. The English keeps this pressure on Piran, then gives the grief a bodily seriousness that the physician cannot cure. Care and cost extend the English formulation; the source’s explicit failed remedy is medical treatment. The next distinction is textual: Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh print the denial that Khosrow is approaching and the identification of Tus advancing toward Dehestan in their running texts. Moscow prints both full units in its actual apparatus, while Ganjoor passes directly from the reported approach to the king’s determination to act first. The English thus follows a verified fuller reply. Afrasiab’s assertion remains a character’s intelligence claim, not independent confirmation of the military situation.
31–36The king’s threat reaches into the family
English 31–36; individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V167:1430 running text · Mohl III267:1447 running text · Khaleghi IV91:1442 running text · Ganjoor sh17:29 poem body · Moscow V167:1431 running text;from here;actual V167n2 dawn · Mohl III267:1448 running text;dawn · Khaleghi IV91:1443 running text;dawn · Ganjoor sh17:30 poem body · Moscow V167:1432 running text · Mohl III267:1449 running text · Khaleghi IV91:1444 running text;army and kous;actual IV91n37 buq alternative · Ganjoor sh17:31 poem body · Moscow V167:1433 running text · Mohl III267:1450 running text · Khaleghi IV92:1445 running text · Ganjoor sh17:32 poem body · Moscow V167:1434 running text · Mohl III267:1451 running text · Khaleghi IV92:1446 running text · Ganjoor sh17:33 poem body · Moscow V167:1435 running text;army/country;actual V167n15 mother · Mohl III267:1452 running text;parvaresh wording,not explicit mother;interpretation qualified · Khaleghi IV92:1447 running text;mourner;actual IV92n8 mother · Ganjoor sh17:34 poem body
The king’s wish to act before his enemy, his intended Jihun crossing and his threat against Iranian sovereignty appear in all four presentations. The English’s dawn departure follows Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh; Moscow’s running text instead speaks of leading the army from here, with dawn in an actual alternative, while Ganjoor retains the latter wording. The threat against Khosrow’s mother is more selective. Moscow and Ganjoor’s main texts make the army and country weep; Khaleghi’s main text names a mourner, with mother in its actual apparatus. Mohl’s printed wording refers to nurture or a nurturer without explicitly printing mother. Moscow’s apparatus does name her. The English makes that supported familial threat explicit, intensifying Afrasiab’s repudiation of kinship; the following qualification about heaven limits his boast.
37–42Promises of overwhelming reinforcement
English 37–42; individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V167:1436 running text · Mohl III267:1453 running text · Khaleghi IV92:1448 running text · Ganjoor sh17:35 poem body · Moscow V167:1437 running text · Mohl III267:1454 running text · Khaleghi IV92:1449 running text · Ganjoor sh17:36 poem body · Moscow V167:1438 running text · Mohl III267:1455 running text · Khaleghi IV92:1450 running text · Ganjoor sh17:37 poem body · Moscow V167:1439 running text;ten thousand;actual V167n22 thirty · Mohl III267:1456 running text;thirty thousand · Khaleghi IV92:1451 running text;ten thousand;no thirty reading certified · Ganjoor sh17:38 poem body · Moscow V167:1440 running text · Mohl III267:1457 running text · Khaleghi IV92:1452 running text · Ganjoor sh17:39 poem body · Moscow V167:1441 running text · Mohl III267:1458 running text · Khaleghi IV92:1453 running text · Ganjoor sh17:40 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all retain the appeal to possible heavenly intervention, then praise Piran’s resources and promise fresh mounted support. Their numbers must not be conflated. Mohl’s running text gives thirty thousand, matching the English; Moscow gives ten thousand in its main text but records thirty in its actual apparatus. Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh’s main texts give ten thousand. No additional thirty-thousand reading is claimed for Khaleghi here. The English consequently makes a documented selection rather than introducing an unsupported force. All four continue with the extravagant comparison of one chosen rider to ten Iranians. That is recruiting rhetoric within the king’s message, not a measured ratio of fighting strength. The promise that reinforcement will lighten Piran’s darkness preserves the psychological purpose of the numerical boast.
43–48Orders transmitted and material left outside the English
English 43–48; individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V167:1442 running text · Mohl III268:1459 running text · Khaleghi IV92:1454 running text · Ganjoor sh17:41 poem body · Moscow V167:1443 running text · Mohl III268:1460 running text · Khaleghi IV92:1455 running text · Ganjoor sh17:42 poem body · Moscow V167:1444 running text · Mohl III268:1461 running text · Khaleghi IV92:1456 running text · Ganjoor sh17:43 poem body · Moscow V167:1445 running text;source-only · Mohl III268:1461–1462 checked local running gap;no corresponding full unit verified · Khaleghi IV92:1456–1457 checked local running gap;actual IV92n27 complete no-survivor unit · Ganjoor sh17:44 poem body;source-only · Moscow V168:1446 running text · Mohl III268:1462 running text · Khaleghi IV92:1457 running text · Ganjoor sh17:45 poem body · Moscow V168:1447 running text;source-only · Mohl III268:1462–1463 checked local running gap;no corresponding full unit verified · Khaleghi IV92:1458 running text;source-only · Ganjoor sh17:46 poem body;source-only · Moscow V168:1448 running text;source-only · Mohl III268:1462–1463 checked local running gap;no corresponding full unit verified · Khaleghi IV93:1459 running text;source-only · Ganjoor sh17:47 poem body;source-only · Moscow V168:1449 running text · Mohl III268:1463 running text · Khaleghi IV93:1460 running text · Ganjoor sh17:48 poem body · Moscow V168:1450 running text · Mohl III268:1464 running text · Khaleghi IV93:1461 running text · Ganjoor sh17:49 poem body
All four presentations order immediate action against Gudarz and describe bringing down his mountain refuge with warhorses. The English renders that impossible scale as an emphatic demand to root him out, preserving the king’s violence rather than turning it into a literal engineering instruction. Moscow and Ganjoor then add a separate injunction to leave none alive; Khaleghi prints that unit in its actual apparatus, and Mohl has a checked local running gap. It has no separate English counterpart. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also include the envoy’s bowed approach and an initial delivery of the message before the public recital; Mohl’s shorter sequence lacks those two local units. The English follows that shorter narrative transition. All three unmatched units are therefore registered independently rather than counted as translated material.
49–54Public courage and private dread
English 49–54; individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V168:1451 running text · Mohl III268:1465 running text · Khaleghi IV93:1462 running text · Ganjoor sh17:50 poem body · Moscow V168:1452 running text · Mohl III268:1466 running text · Khaleghi IV93:1463 running text;troops turn their backs on battle · Ganjoor sh17:51 poem body · Moscow V168:1453 running text · Mohl III268:1467 running text · Khaleghi IV93:1464 running text · Ganjoor sh17:52 poem body · Moscow V168:1454 running text · Mohl III268:1468 running text · Khaleghi IV93:1465 running text · Ganjoor sh17:53 poem body · Moscow V168:1455 running text · Mohl III268:1469 running text · Khaleghi IV93:1466 running text · Ganjoor sh17:54 poem body · Moscow V168:1455 shared running unit,allocated at English53;second hemistich · Mohl III268:1469 shared running unit,allocated at English53;second hemistich · Khaleghi IV93:1466 shared running unit,allocated at English53;second hemistich · Ganjoor sh17:54 shared running unit;allocated at English53
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all separate the army’s encouragement from Piran’s inward pain. The English preserves that double perspective, preventing the successful delivery of royal assurance from becoming an actual resolution of his fear. His perception of diminishing forces follows Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; Khaleghi’s running text instead describes the troops turning their backs on battle. That is a sharper military condition than mere depletion. The prayer then shifts the frame from Afrasiab’s confident will to divine sovereignty. English fifty-three and fifty-four expand one Persian couplet in each source, whose first half denies the fall of someone God has raised and whose second reserves sovereignty to God. The two English couplets make both propositions explicit without supplying two independent Persian units.
55–60Khosrow’s rise and the torment of desire
English 55–60; individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V168:1456 running text · Mohl III268:1470 running text · Khaleghi IV93:1467 running text · Ganjoor sh17:55 poem body · Moscow V168:1457 running text · Mohl III268:1471 running text · Khaleghi IV93:1468 running text · Ganjoor sh17:56 poem body · Moscow V168:1458 running text · Mohl III268:1472 running text · Khaleghi IV93:1469 running text · Ganjoor sh17:57 poem body · Moscow V168:1459 running text;pursuit of greed · Mohl III268:1473 running text;free/noble man · Khaleghi IV93:1470 running text;pursuit of greed · Ganjoor sh17:58 poem body · Moscow V168:1460 running text · Mohl III268:1474 running text · Khaleghi IV93:1471 running text · Ganjoor sh17:59 poem body · Moscow V168:1461 running text · Mohl III268:1475 running text · Khaleghi IV93:1472 running text · Ganjoor sh17:60 poem body
All four sources invite attention to Khosrow’s unexpected royal emergence and to fortune’s transforming power. The English’s grief below develops the contrast between suffering and elevation; the thorns becoming roses and dust becoming musk preserve the source’s material images with particular clarity. The following account of torment is not identical across the editions. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh describe the man who pursues greed and keeps his heart in pain. Mohl’s running wording instead presents the free or noble man keeping his heart in pain, without the same explicit pursuit of greed. The English follows the former reading and adds gain as a paired motive. All four then confront the grandfather and grandson, opposing kings and armies, so the meditation returns from general desire to this particular family war.
61–64The conditional catastrophe and the prayer’s position
English 61–64; individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V168:1462 running text · Mohl III268:1476 running text · Khaleghi IV93:1473 running text · Ganjoor sh17:61 poem body · Moscow V168:1464 running text;prayer precedes condition · Mohl III268:1477 running text;condition precedes prayer · Khaleghi IV94:1475 running text;prayer precedes condition · Ganjoor sh17:63 poem body · Moscow V169:1465 running text;prayer precedes condition · Mohl III268:1478 running text;condition precedes prayer · Khaleghi IV94:1476 running text;prayer precedes condition · Ganjoor sh17:64 poem body · Moscow V168:1463 running text;prayer precedes condition · Mohl III268:1479 running text;condition precedes prayer · Khaleghi IV93:1474 running text;prayer precedes condition · Ganjoor sh17:62 poem body
The uncertainty about the battle’s outcome appears in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh, but the next movement is ordered differently. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi place Piran’s bitter appeal to the divine judge before the conditional prospect of Afrasiab and the Turanian leaders dying. Mohl places that appeal after the two conditional units, and the English follows Mohl’s order. This is relocation within a fully represented passage, not an omitted prayer. The English also introduces the condition as an inward thought and leaves it suspended before the cry. The printed sources do not separately mark those modern quotation boundaries. This presentation makes the imagined destruction interrupt Piran’s composure, but the distinction between silent thought and spoken prayer remains an English interpretation of the sequence.
65–68A wish not to survive dispossession
English 65–68; individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V169:1466 running text · Mohl III268:1480 running text · Khaleghi IV94:1477 running text · Ganjoor sh17:65 poem body · Moscow V169:1467 running text · Mohl III268:1481 running text · Khaleghi IV94:1478 running text · Ganjoor sh17:66 poem body · Moscow V169:1468 running text · Mohl III268:1482 running text · Khaleghi IV94:1479 running text · Ganjoor sh17:67 poem body · Moscow V169:1469 running text · Mohl III268:1483 running text · Khaleghi IV94:1480 running text · Ganjoor sh17:68 poem body
All four presentations end this passage with Khosrow’s arrival and dominion, Piran’s willingness to die wounded in his armor, the wish not to witness another occupying his way and place, and the equivalence of life and death under adverse fortune. The English turns the armor unit into a direct request that the Maker take his soul, whereas the Persian formulation also permits the sense that such a death would be acceptable. Its torn body makes the wound more graphic without inventing a new weapon or assailant. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh support the closing desolation, but it remains Piran’s utterance under anticipated defeat. The published chapter stops there; the next chapter’s morning battle has a different opening treatment among the editions and is not included in this collation.
Source record and limits
C3.23 only:68 English couplets/136 lines. Moscow V165–169:1403–1469 (67 running units);Mohl III266–268:1417–1483 (PDF272–274;67 running units);Ganjoor12rokh sh17:2–68 (67 body units);Khaleghi IV89–94:1413–1480 (PDF105–110;68 running units). Three source-only rows:S1 no-survivor injunction,S2 bowed envoy,S3 initial message delivery. English53–54 shares one main unit in each source,allocated once at53. English8 is Mohl main and actual Moscow/Khaleghi apparatus;English29–30 is Mohl/Khaleghi main and actual Moscow apparatus. Every declared main unit allocated once.
Inspection sequence:individual MoscowV165–169 and MohlIII266–268 PNG facsimiles first;then fresh Ganjoor sh17 body and KhaleghiIV89–94 PNG facsimiles. Mohl1452 enlarged to check its actual wording. Existing source files retrieved;availability alone was not verification.
- F&R English: 68 verbatim couplets. Published index title:Afrasiab Replies to Piran. The prior checkpoint used a shortened next-title;this package uses the full index title. Begins return commission;ends Piran’s equivalence of life and death. Next C3.24 Iran and Turan Fight a Pitched Battle begins morning battle.
- Moscow: V165–169:1403–1469;67 main units. English8 actual165n22,English29–30 actual166n34. English9/10 reversed in main relative to English. S1–S3 main1445/1447/1448. English53–54 shares1455. Prayer1463 precedes condition1464–1465. Ten thousand1439,actual167n22 thirty;army/country1435,actual167n15 mother.
- Mohl: III266–268:1417–1483;67 main units. Fuller praise1424,denial1445,Tus1446 in main. English9/10 and62–64 follow Mohl order. S1 checked gap1461–1462;S2/S3 checked gap1462–1463. English53–54 shares1469. Thirty thousand1456. English36:1452 parvaresh wording,not explicit mother;referent qualified.
- Ganjoor: 12rokh sh17:2–68;67 body units. Main order follows Moscow. English8 gap8–9;English29–30 gap28–29. Source-only44/46/47. Shared54 at English53–54. Ten thousand38;army/country34. Prayer62 precedes condition63–64.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV89–94:1413–1480;68 main units. English8 actual90n6;denial1440/Tus1441 main. S1 main gap1456–1457 with actual92n27;S2/S3 main1458–1459. Shared1466 at English53–54. Ten thousand1451;no thirty reading certified. Mourner1447,actual92n8 mother. Retreat1463 differs from depletion. Prayer1474 precedes condition1475–1476.
English8:full Mohl1424 unit,actual Moscow165n22 and actual Khaleghi90n6;checked main gaps Moscow1409–1410,Khaleghi1419–1420,Ganjoor8–9. English29–30:Mohl1445–1446 and Khaleghi1440–1441 main;two complete actual Moscow166n34 units at gap1429–1430;Ganjoor gap28–29. No unprinted addition notice counted. No appendix evidence used.
S1:Moscow1445/Ganjoor44 main,Khaleghi actual92n27 at main gap1456–1457,Mohl checked gap1461–1462. S2/S3:Moscow1447–1448,Ganjoor46–47,Khaleghi1458–1459 main;Mohl checked gap1462–1463. These units have no separate English counterpart. English53–54 shares Moscow1455,Mohl1469,Ganjoor54,Khaleghi1466;references allocated at53 only. English9/10 follows Mohl/Khaleghi order against Moscow/Ganjoor;English62–64 follows Mohl condition-before-prayer against the other three.
English36 mother:actual Moscow167n15 and Khaleghi92n8 explicitly support this;Moscow/Ganjoor main have army/country,Khaleghi main mourner,Mohl main parvaresh wording. Mohl’s precise personal referent remains qualified and is not counted as an explicit mother attestation. English40 thirty thousand:Mohl main1456 and actual Moscow167n22;the other three main texts give ten thousand. No Khaleghi thirty-thousand reading certified.
All inherited provisional flags retained verbatim,including C3.19.44 and the C3.22.32 wounded-denominator caution. New local qualification C3.23.36:Mohl1452 prints parvaresh wording,not explicit mother;its precise personal referent is not certified. English mother has actual Moscow167n15/Khaleghi92n8 support. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps,appendix evidence and unverified readings remain distinct. No appendix evidence used;no global absence claim. No unprinted addition notice counted positively. Modern geographic identifications not certified.
First English line:The monarch bade the messenger return, Last English line:No difference lies between his life and death.” C3.24 Iran and Turan Fight a Pitched Battle:opening source treatments differ. Mohl III269:1484(PDF275) has the morning brocade/battle sea;Moscow V169:1470 begins Iranian horns;Khaleghi IV94:1481 precedes its battle heading and has neither side remembering Keshvad. Ganjoor sh17:69 has horns before the next section.
PDF offsets:Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.
- Moscow V165n22 actual apparatus;full praise unit — تویی سرور و پهلوان زمین / که بادا به جانت هزار آفرین
- Mohl III266:1424 main;praise — تویی مهتر و پهلوان زمین / که بادا به جانت هزار آفرین
- Khaleghi IV90n6 actual apparatus;full praise unit — تویی سرور و پهلوان زمین / که بادا به جانت هزار آفرین
- Moscow V166n34 actual apparatus;denial — جز اینست کامد ترا آگهی / که کیخسرو آید به شاهنشهی
- Moscow V166n34 actual apparatus;Tus unit — که طوس سپهبد بدان با سپاه / سوی دهستان درآمد ز راه
- Moscow V167:1435 main;army and country — که گرید بدو لشکر و کشورش
- Moscow V167n15 actual apparatus;mother alternative — زار خود مادرش
- Mohl III267:1452 main;literal parvaresh wording;referent not certified — که گردد برو زار جان پرورش
- Khaleghi IV92:1447 main;mourner — که گرید برو زار مویگرش
- Khaleghi IV92n8 actual apparatus;mother alternative — مادرش
- Moscow V167:1439 main;ten thousand — ده هزار
- Moscow V167n22 actual apparatus;thirty — سی
- Mohl III267:1456 main;thirty thousand — یکی لشکری نامور سی هزار
- Khaleghi IV92:1451 main;ten thousand — یکی نامور لشکری ده هزار
- Moscow V167:1445 main;source-only injunction — ممان زنده ز ایشان به گیتی کسی / که نزد تو آید از ایشان بسی
- Khaleghi IV92n27 actual apparatus;full source-only injunction — ممان زنده ز ایشان به گیتی کسی / که نزد تو آید از ایشان بسی
- Moscow V168:1455 main;one unit expanded into English53–54 — کرا برکشیدی تو افگنده نیست / جز از تو جهاندار دارنده نیست
- Khaleghi IV93:1463 main;retreat — همه گشته پشت بر کارزار
- Mohl III268:1473 main;free or noble man — شگفتیتر از کار آزادمرد
- Moscow V168:1459 main;pursuit of greed — شگفتیتر آنک از پی آز مرد
C3.23 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V165:1403 running text | III266:1417 running text |
| 2 | V165:1404 running text | III266:1418 running text |
| 3 | V165:1405 running text | III266:1419 running text |
| 4 | V165:1406 running text | III266:1420 running text |
| 5 | V165:1407 running text | III266:1421 running text |
| 6 | V165:1408 running text | III266:1422 running text |
| 7 | V165:1409 running text | III266:1423 running text |
| 8 | V165:1409–1410 checked local running gap;actual V165n22 full praise unit | III266:1424 running text |
| 9 | V165:1411 running text | III266:1425 running text |
| 10 | V165:1410 running text | III266:1426 running text |
| 11 | V166:1412 running text | III266:1427 running text |
| 12 | V166:1413 running text | III266:1428 running text |
| 13 | V166:1414 running text | III266:1429 running text |
| 14 | V166:1415 running text | III266:1430 running text |
| 15 | V166:1416 running text | III266:1431 running text |
| 16 | V166:1417 running text | III266:1432 running text |
| 17 | V166:1418 running text | III266:1433 running text |
| 18 | V166:1419 running text | III267:1434 running text |
| 19 | V166:1420 running text | III267:1435 running text |
| 20 | V166:1421 running text | III267:1436 running text |
| 21 | V166:1422 running text | III267:1437 running text |
| 22 | V166:1423 running text | III267:1438 running text |
| 23 | V166:1424 running text | III267:1439 running text |
| 24 | V166:1425 running text | III267:1440 running text |
| 25 | V166:1426 running text | III267:1441 running text |
| 26 | V166:1427 running text | III267:1442 running text |
| 27 | V166:1428 running text | III267:1443 running text |
| 28 | V166:1429 running text | III267:1444 running text |
| 29 | V166:1429 to V167:1430 checked local running gap;actual V166n34 full denial unit | III267:1445 running text |
| 30 | V166:1429 to V167:1430 checked local running gap;actual V166n34 full Tus/Dehestan unit | III267:1446 running text |
| 31 | V167:1430 running text | III267:1447 running text |
| 32 | V167:1431 running text;from here;actual V167n2 dawn | III267:1448 running text;dawn |
| 33 | V167:1432 running text | III267:1449 running text |
| 34 | V167:1433 running text | III267:1450 running text |
| 35 | V167:1434 running text | III267:1451 running text |
| 36 | V167:1435 running text;army/country;actual V167n15 mother | III267:1452 running text;parvaresh wording,not explicit mother;interpretation qualified |
| 37 | V167:1436 running text | III267:1453 running text |
| 38 | V167:1437 running text | III267:1454 running text |
| 39 | V167:1438 running text | III267:1455 running text |
| 40 | V167:1439 running text;ten thousand;actual V167n22 thirty | III267:1456 running text;thirty thousand |
| 41 | V167:1440 running text | III267:1457 running text |
| 42 | V167:1441 running text | III267:1458 running text |
| 43 | V167:1442 running text | III268:1459 running text |
| 44 | V167:1443 running text | III268:1460 running text |
| 45 | V167:1444 running text | III268:1461 running text |
| 46 | V168:1446 running text | III268:1462 running text |
| 47 | V168:1449 running text | III268:1463 running text |
| 48 | V168:1450 running text | III268:1464 running text |
| 49 | V168:1451 running text | III268:1465 running text |
| 50 | V168:1452 running text | III268:1466 running text |
| 51 | V168:1453 running text | III268:1467 running text |
| 52 | V168:1454 running text | III268:1468 running text |
| 53 | V168:1455 running text | III268:1469 running text |
| 54 | V168:1455 shared running unit,allocated at English53;second hemistich | III268:1469 shared running unit,allocated at English53;second hemistich |
| 55 | V168:1456 running text | III268:1470 running text |
| 56 | V168:1457 running text | III268:1471 running text |
| 57 | V168:1458 running text | III268:1472 running text |
| 58 | V168:1459 running text;pursuit of greed | III268:1473 running text;free/noble man |
| 59 | V168:1460 running text | III268:1474 running text |
| 60 | V168:1461 running text | III268:1475 running text |
| 61 | V168:1462 running text | III268:1476 running text |
| 62 | V168:1464 running text;prayer precedes condition | III268:1477 running text;condition precedes prayer |
| 63 | V169:1465 running text;prayer precedes condition | III268:1478 running text;condition precedes prayer |
| 64 | V168:1463 running text;prayer precedes condition | III268:1479 running text;condition precedes prayer |
| 65 | V169:1466 running text | III268:1480 running text |
| 66 | V169:1467 running text | III268:1481 running text |
| 67 | V169:1468 running text | III268:1482 running text |
| 68 | V169:1469 running text | III268:1483 running text |
New Naqqali