Piran Exhorts His Champions
45 verbatim couplets. Title and boundaries checked against current published index/live poem. Retained same-day HTML supplies exact whitespace. First Turanian grief,last Piran’s arrival;next C3.28 begins meeting Gudarz.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 45 verbatim couplets. |
| Moscow | V184–187:1727–1769;43 main units. Family/retreat sequence1742–1743 reversed in English16–17. Actual186n27 full Time-teacher unit. Actual184n17 turning-sphere alternative. Main great/small1738 and fear1741;smoke1765. |
| Mohl | III280–281:1750–1793;44 main units. English order16–17 matches1765–1766. Time-teacher1790 running. Visible/hidden1761;fear1764;retreat1788 emphasizes fortune reversal without smoke. |
| Ganjoor | sh18:257–298 plus sh19:1;43 body units. English42 checked gap296–297. Shared285 for29/30 and293 for37/38;English32 uses287–288. Last Englishcouplet crosses digital section break. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV110–113:1739–1781;43 main units. English16–17 order matches1754–1755. Actual113n3 full Time-teacher unit,not main. Main deception1753 versus actual111n16 fear. Main visible/hidden1750;actual111n11 great/small. Main one occasion1747;actual111n5 battle. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Grief before exhortation
English 1–6;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V184:1727 running text · Mohl III280:1750 running text · Khaleghi IV110:1739 running text · Ganjoor sh18:257 poem body · Moscow V184:1728 running text · Mohl III280:1751 running text · Khaleghi IV110:1740 running text · Ganjoor sh18:258 poem body · Moscow V184:1729 running text;local main differs;actual V184n17 turning-sphere alternative · Mohl III280:1752 running text;turning heavens main · Khaleghi IV110:1741 running text;turning heavens main · Ganjoor sh18:259 poem body · Moscow V184:1730 running text · Mohl III280:1753 running text · Khaleghi IV110:1742 running text · Ganjoor sh18:260 poem body · Moscow V184:1731 running text · Mohl III280:1754 running text · Khaleghi IV110:1743 running text · Ganjoor sh18:261 poem body · Moscow V184:1732 running text · Mohl III280:1755 running text · Khaleghi IV110:1744 running text · Ganjoor sh18:262 poem body
The chapter begins with Turanian grief before allowing Piran to demand renewed courage. Moscow and Mohl both describe fathers mourning sons and brothers mourning brothers; Ganjoor and Khaleghi retain those relationships. English pale faces carries the yellow-faced image into ordinary English, while its turning heavens follows the explicit celestial language in Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi; Moscow’s main wording differs locally and its actual note records a turning-sphere alternative. The wounded flock and ravening wolf are common to all four, making the army’s vulnerability visible before its chief speaks. English5 places the address within the summons and develops it into an appeal for strength. The following old-and-young address keeps the breadth of the source audience: Piran is speaking to experienced survivors across generations, not merely to an untouched reserve.
7–12Past honor and the terror of retreat
English 7–12;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V184:1733 running text · Mohl III280:1756 running text · Khaleghi IV110:1745 running text · Ganjoor sh18:263 poem body · Moscow V184:1734 running text;desire then name · Mohl III280:1757 running text;desire then name · Khaleghi IV111:1746 running text;name then desire · Ganjoor sh18:264 poem body · Moscow V185:1735 running text;one battle · Mohl III280:1758 running text;one battle · Khaleghi IV111:1747 running text;one occasion main;actual IV111n5 battle · Ganjoor sh18:265 poem body · Moscow V185:1736 running text · Mohl III280:1759 running text · Khaleghi IV111:1748 running text · Ganjoor sh18:266 poem body · Moscow V185:1737 running text · Mohl III280:1760 running text · Khaleghi IV111:1749 running text · Ganjoor sh18:267 poem body · Moscow V185:1738 running text;great/small · Mohl III280:1761 running text;visible/hidden · Khaleghi IV111:1750 running text;visible/hidden;actual IV111n11 great/small alternative · Ganjoor sh18:268 poem body
Piran reminds the chiefs of their standing before Afrasiab and then predicts annihilation if they flee. Moscow and Mohl both preserve that progression, as do Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English8 develops the spreading name into rising fire, an added image rather than a separately attested event. Khaleghi reverses the positions of name and desire within its corresponding unit, without removing either idea. English9’s one defeat has the more specific battle wording of Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; Khaleghi’s main has one occasion, with the battle alternative in actual111n5. The pursuers’ heavy maces are explicit, but striking fleeing backs develops the implication of pursuit. English12’s great and small follows Moscow and Ganjoor; Mohl and Khaleghi instead speak of visible and hidden. Both formulations intensify Piran’s forecast, which remains a coercive prediction rather than a narrated outcome.
13–18Divine victory, unstable fortune and the order of appeal
English 13–18;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V185:1739 running text · Mohl III280:1762 running text · Khaleghi IV111:1751 running text · Ganjoor sh18:269 poem body · Moscow V185:1740 running text;chief of Mobadan · Mohl III280:1763 running text;Mobadan · Khaleghi IV111:1752 running text;chief of Mobadan · Ganjoor sh18:270 poem body · Moscow V185:1741 running text;fear · Mohl III280:1764 running text;fear · Khaleghi IV111:1753 running text;deception main;actual IV111n16 fear · Ganjoor sh18:271 poem body · Moscow V185:1743 running text;follows family appeal1742 · Mohl III280:1765 running text;precedes family appeal1766 · Khaleghi IV111:1754 running text;precedes family appeal1755 · Ganjoor sh18:273 poem body · Moscow V185:1742 running text;precedes retreat recollection1743 · Mohl III280:1766 running text;follows retreat recollection1765 · Khaleghi IV111:1755 running text;follows retreat recollection1754 · Ganjoor sh18:272 poem body · Moscow V185:1744 running text · Mohl III280:1767 running text · Khaleghi IV111:1756 running text · Ganjoor sh18:274 poem body
The counsel to expel fear leads into a religious maxim and then the appeal to protect family and homeland. Moscow and Mohl each attest the sequence of ideas, while Ganjoor and Khaleghi provide corresponding units. The English renders God’s enduring victoriousness as victory belonging to God, a shift from an attribute to a statement of ultimate control. Its plural Mobadan also broadens the singular chief-of-Mobadan attribution in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi; Mohl directly attributes the saying to the Mobadan. English15’s fear agrees with Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor. Khaleghi’s running1753 instead has deception, while actual111n16 prints the fear alternative. English16–17 orders the enemy’s former retreat before the family appeal, following Mohl and Khaleghi. Moscow and Ganjoor place those units in the reverse order. The translation’s sequence therefore has independent textual support.
19–24The compact and two possible outcomes
English 19–24;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V185:1745 running text · Mohl III280:1768 running text · Khaleghi IV111:1757 running text · Ganjoor sh18:275 poem body · Moscow V185:1746 running text · Mohl III280:1769 running text · Khaleghi IV111:1758 running text · Ganjoor sh18:276 poem body · Moscow V185:1747 running text · Mohl III280:1770 running text · Khaleghi IV111:1759 running text · Ganjoor sh18:277 poem body · Moscow V185:1748 running text · Mohl III280:1771 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1760 running text · Ganjoor sh18:278 poem body · Moscow V185:1749 running text · Mohl III280:1772 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1761 running text · Ganjoor sh18:279 poem body · Moscow V185:1750 running text · Mohl III281:1773 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1762 running text · Ganjoor sh18:280 poem body
All four sources preserve Piran’s report of Gudarz’s compact: selected chiefs should meet individually while the armies rest. English19 makes the selection into a clear administrative act, although setting their stations develops the source’s simpler choosing of chiefs. The conditional structure matters more than the added detail. Moscow and Mohl both allow for the possibility that the agreement is kept or that the whole enemy army advances; Ganjoor and Khaleghi retain that alternative. The English keeps both branches, so Piran’s acceptance is contingent rather than unquestioning. Birth and death compress the argument for risking one’s life, and the two faces of fortune prevent the threat of defeat from becoming certainty. The heads on high retain the source’s display of enemy leaders on the gallows, though the English makes the apparatus of that display less explicit.
25–30Obedience secured by threat and remembered service
English 25–30;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V185:1751 running text · Mohl III281:1774 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1763 running text · Ganjoor sh18:281 poem body · Moscow V186:1752 running text · Mohl III281:1775 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1764 running text · Ganjoor sh18:282 poem body · Moscow V186:1753 running text · Mohl III281:1776 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1765 running text · Ganjoor sh18:283 poem body · Moscow V186:1754 running text · Mohl III281:1777 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1766 running text · Ganjoor sh18:284 poem body · Moscow V186:1755 running text · Mohl III281:1778 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1767 running text · Ganjoor sh18:285 poem body · Moscow V186:1755 shared with English29;allocated once there · Mohl III281:1778 shared with English29;allocated once there · Khaleghi IV112:1767 shared with English29;allocated once there · Ganjoor sh18:285 shared with English29;allocated once there
Piran’s threat to behead anyone who disregards his words is present in Moscow and Mohl, with equivalent force in Ganjoor and Khaleghi. The English preserves the threat’s severity, while before he turns away adds immediacy rather than a separately specified deadline. The reply then invokes Piran’s treasure, labor and family sacrifices. These details are attested across all four, preventing the scene from being reduced to obedience produced by fear alone. English29–30 expands a single Persian unit: the refusal to turn aside and the question of what royal servants are for. Bringing their lives to war makes the implied answer explicit. The register allocates that source unit once at29 and marks30 as shared, distinguishing a sustained interpretive expansion from a newly attested Persian couplet or a second independent pledge.
31–36Night preparation and an iron-covered earth
English 31–36;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V186:1756 running text · Mohl III281:1779 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1768 running text · Ganjoor sh18:286 poem body · Moscow V186:1757,1758 running text · Mohl III281:1780,1781 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1769,1770 running text · Ganjoor sh18:287,sh18:288 poem body · Ganjoor sh18:287,sh18:288 poem body · Moscow V186:1759 running text · Mohl III281:1782 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1771 running text · Ganjoor sh18:289 poem body · Moscow V186:1760 running text · Mohl III281:1783 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1772 running text · Ganjoor sh18:290 poem body · Moscow V186:1761 running text · Mohl III281:1784 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1773 running text · Ganjoor sh18:291 poem body · Moscow V186:1762 running text · Mohl III281:1785 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1774 running text · Ganjoor sh18:292 poem body
Moscow and Mohl both move from the chiefs’ response to preparation through the night, dawn instruments, mounted warriors and the mass of horses. Ganjoor and Khaleghi preserve the same sequence. English32 joins the completion of the commander’s arrangements and the dawn music, drawing on two Persian units that are recorded together. The named shaypur and ney retain the source instruments, while ringing through the plain generalizes the more specific tents or quarters from which the sound rises. The iron cloth is not an invented material transformation: it carries the source’s visual hyperbole of the ground covered by horses’ hooves. Piran’s instructions to Farshidvard and Lahhak then narrow the focus from spectacle to command. Reversing the order of their names in English does not change the joint responsibility assigned to them.
37–42The watchman, the survivors and Time as teacher
English 37–42;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V186:1763 running text · Mohl III281:1786 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1775 running text · Ganjoor sh18:293 poem body · Moscow V186:1763 shared with English37;allocated once there · Mohl III281:1786 shared with English37;allocated once there · Khaleghi IV112:1775 shared with English37;allocated once there · Ganjoor sh18:293 shared with English37;allocated once there · Moscow V186:1764 running text · Mohl III281:1787 running text · Khaleghi IV112:1776 running text · Ganjoor sh18:294 poem body · Moscow V186:1765 running text;do not seek combat;smoke-speed retreat · Mohl III281:1788 running text;retreat with fortune reversed;no smoke in corresponding main · Khaleghi IV112:1777 running text;do not seek combat;smoke-speed retreat · Ganjoor sh18:295 poem body · Moscow V186:1766 running text;all killed except addressed survivors · Mohl III281:1789 running text;Time scatters fallen clan · Khaleghi IV113:1778 running text;all killed except addressed survivors · Ganjoor sh18:296 poem body · Moscow V186:1766–1767 checked main gap;actual V186n27 full Time-teacher unit · Mohl III281:1790 running text · Khaleghi IV113:1778–1779 checked main gap;actual IV113n3 full Time-teacher unit · Ganjoor sh18:296–297 checked local main gap;no full Time-teacher unit
English37–38 expands one source unit about a mountain watchman who guards by day and counts stars at night. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all supply that compact image; the two English couplets are therefore shared rather than separately matched. The contingency that follows concerns preserving the remaining force if fortune turns. Smoke-speed retreat in English40 follows Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi, while Mohl’s corresponding line emphasizes the reversal of fortune without that smoke comparison. The family’s devastation explains the order to survive, but should not be converted into a newly verified genealogy. English42’s saying about Time as teacher is running text in Mohl1790 and fully printed in actual Moscow186n27 and Khaleghi113n3. Ganjoor’s checked296–297 interval lacks it. The English thus preserves a documented fuller reading rather than inventing a farewell maxim.
43–45A farewell followed by the return to battle
English 43–45;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V186:1767 running text · Mohl III281:1791 running text · Khaleghi IV113:1779 running text · Ganjoor sh18:297 poem body · Moscow V186:1768 running text · Mohl III281:1792 running text · Khaleghi IV113:1780 running text · Ganjoor sh18:298 poem body · Moscow V187:1769 running text · Mohl III281:1793 running text · Khaleghi IV113:1781 running text · Ganjoor sh19:1 poem body;digital section break falls inside published English chapter
The embrace and tears precede Piran’s renewed movement toward the field in Moscow and Mohl, and the corresponding Ganjoor and Khaleghi units preserve that emotional sequence. English43’s rain comparison develops the weeping; it does not require an additional source unit. English44 makes the separation more explicit through parting from the ranks, whereas the source formulations principally describe turning away and raising cries. The final battle-shout is well grounded in the common description of Piran coming noisily or roaring to the place of combat. This turn does not cancel the farewell’s grief. It holds together the vulnerable family member and the commander intent on vengeance. Ganjoor places that final arrival at the start of its next section, so the commentary follows the published English boundary across the digital section break rather than dropping the last couplet.
Source record and limits
C3.27 only:45 English couplets/90 lines. Moscow V184–187:1727–1769(43 running units);Mohl III280–281:1750–1793(PDF286–287;44 running units);Ganjoor12rokh sh18:257–298 plus sh19:1(43 body units);Khaleghi IV110–113:1739–1781(PDF126–129;43 running units). English29/30 and37/38 share units in all four,allocated once at29 and37. English32 combines two units. English42 is Mohl1790 running,actual Moscow186n27 and Khaleghi113n3,with Ganjoor296–297 checked local gap. No source-only row in this scope. All declared main units allocated once. C3.26 closing Gostaham bridge remains allocated to C3.26,not recounted.
Inspection order:Moscow V184–187 and Mohl III280–281 individual PNG facsimiles first,then Ganjoor body and Khaleghi IV110–113 PNG. Existing retrieved source PDFs reused. Apparatus read directly,not inferred from notices. Source-only Gostaham bridge remains in previous chapter.
- F&R English: 45 verbatim couplets. Title and boundaries checked against current published index/live poem. Retained same-day HTML supplies exact whitespace. First Turanian grief,last Piran’s arrival;next C3.28 begins meeting Gudarz.
- Moscow: V184–187:1727–1769;43 main units. Family/retreat sequence1742–1743 reversed in English16–17. Actual186n27 full Time-teacher unit. Actual184n17 turning-sphere alternative. Main great/small1738 and fear1741;smoke1765.
- Mohl: III280–281:1750–1793;44 main units. English order16–17 matches1765–1766. Time-teacher1790 running. Visible/hidden1761;fear1764;retreat1788 emphasizes fortune reversal without smoke.
- Ganjoor: sh18:257–298 plus sh19:1;43 body units. English42 checked gap296–297. Shared285 for29/30 and293 for37/38;English32 uses287–288. Last Englishcouplet crosses digital section break.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV110–113:1739–1781;43 main units. English16–17 order matches1754–1755. Actual113n3 full Time-teacher unit,not main. Main deception1753 versus actual111n16 fear. Main visible/hidden1750;actual111n11 great/small. Main one occasion1747;actual111n5 battle.
English42:Mohl III281:1790 contains the full Time-teacher unit in running text. Actual Moscow V186n27 and Khaleghi IV113n3 print it as additional textual evidence. Their inspected main gaps1766–1767 and1778–1779 do not contain it;Ganjoor sh18:296–297 also lacks the full unit locally. Khaleghi’s printed alternative has singular دانم,where Mohl/Moscow have plural دانیم. This supports English’s singular question without making the editions’ wording identical.
English12:great/small main Moscow/Ganjoor,actual Khaleghi111n11;visible/hidden main Mohl/Khaleghi. English15:fear main Moscow/Mohl/Ganjoor,actual Khaleghi111n16;deception in Khaleghi main1753. English16–17 order follows Mohl/Khaleghi versus reversed Moscow/Ganjoor. English40:smoke in Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi main;Mohl main emphasizes reversed fortune. The explicit injunction not to seek combat in Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi is not separately reproduced in English40.
English29–30 and37–38 share single source units in all four. English32 combines two source units. No main unit is duplicated. No source-only unit in this scope. Last English45 corresponds to Ganjoor sh19:1;section break is not the published chapter boundary.
All inherited provisional flags retained verbatim,including C3.26.60/C3.19.44 Pashan,C3.25.66 agency,C3.24.S2 syntax,C3.24.43 addressee,C3.23.36 parvaresh,C3.22.32 wounded denominator and every older flag. Prior English117 agency departure and Mohl C3.25 boundary correction retained. No new unresolved source qualification added in C3.27. Running text,actual printed apparatus,checked local gaps,appendix evidence and unverified readings remain distinct. No appendix evidence invoked and no volume-wide absence claim.
First line:Since that last fight had brought Turan despair, Last line:And reached the field with his loud battle-shout. C3.28 Gudarz and Piran Choose the Warriors opens when Gudarz sees Piran and the two speak. Opening candidates verified locally:Moscow V187:1770;Mohl III281:1794(PDF287);Khaleghi IV113:1782(PDF129);Ganjoor sh19:2. Ganjoor sh19:1 belongs to completed C3.27;do not recount.
Ganjoor sh19 opening. PDF offsets verified:Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.
- Moscow V184n17 actual apparatus;turning-sphere alternative — گردان سپهر
- Mohl III280:1752 main;turning heaven — گردان چرخ بلند
- Moscow V185:1738 main;great and small — نبیند کس از مهتران و کهان
- Mohl III280:1761 main;visible and hidden — آشکار و نهان
- Khaleghi IV111:1750 main;visible and hidden — آشکار و نهان
- Khaleghi IV111n11 actual apparatus;great/small alternative — مهتران و کهان
- Khaleghi IV111:1747 main;one occasion — به یک ره
- Khaleghi IV111n5 actual apparatus;battle alternative — رزم
- Moscow V185:1740 main;religious attribution — شه موبدان
- Mohl III280:1763 main;religious attribution — چنین داستان آمد از موبدان
- Khaleghi IV111:1753 main;deception — فریب
- Khaleghi IV111n16 actual apparatus;fear alternative — نهیب
- Moscow V186:1765 main;smoke-speed retreat — به توران شتابید برسان دود
- Mohl III281:1788 main;fortune reversal — که از ما بیکباره برگشت بخت
- Khaleghi IV112:1777 main;smoke-speed retreat — به توران شتابید برسان دود
- Mohl III281:1790 main;Time-teacher unit — چه دانیم کردن ابا روزگار / کز اول همو باشد آموزگار
- Moscow V186n27 actual apparatus;Time-teacher unit — چه دانیم کردن ابا روزگار / کز اول همو باشد آموزگار
- Khaleghi IV113n3 actual apparatus;Time-teacher unit — چه دانم کردن ابا روزگار / کز اول همو باشد آموزگار
- Ganjoor sh19:1 poem body;last English unit — پر از کینه سالار توران سپاه / خروشان بیامد به آوردگاه
C3.27 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V184:1727 running text | III280:1750 running text |
| 2 | V184:1728 running text | III280:1751 running text |
| 3 | V184:1729 running text;local main differs;actual V184n17 turning-sphere alternative | III280:1752 running text;turning heavens main |
| 4 | V184:1730 running text | III280:1753 running text |
| 5 | V184:1731 running text | III280:1754 running text |
| 6 | V184:1732 running text | III280:1755 running text |
| 7 | V184:1733 running text | III280:1756 running text |
| 8 | V184:1734 running text;desire then name | III280:1757 running text;desire then name |
| 9 | V185:1735 running text;one battle | III280:1758 running text;one battle |
| 10 | V185:1736 running text | III280:1759 running text |
| 11 | V185:1737 running text | III280:1760 running text |
| 12 | V185:1738 running text;great/small | III280:1761 running text;visible/hidden |
| 13 | V185:1739 running text | III280:1762 running text |
| 14 | V185:1740 running text;chief of Mobadan | III280:1763 running text;Mobadan |
| 15 | V185:1741 running text;fear | III280:1764 running text;fear |
| 16 | V185:1743 running text;follows family appeal1742 | III280:1765 running text;precedes family appeal1766 |
| 17 | V185:1742 running text;precedes retreat recollection1743 | III280:1766 running text;follows retreat recollection1765 |
| 18 | V185:1744 running text | III280:1767 running text |
| 19 | V185:1745 running text | III280:1768 running text |
| 20 | V185:1746 running text | III280:1769 running text |
| 21 | V185:1747 running text | III280:1770 running text |
| 22 | V185:1748 running text | III280:1771 running text |
| 23 | V185:1749 running text | III280:1772 running text |
| 24 | V185:1750 running text | III281:1773 running text |
| 25 | V185:1751 running text | III281:1774 running text |
| 26 | V186:1752 running text | III281:1775 running text |
| 27 | V186:1753 running text | III281:1776 running text |
| 28 | V186:1754 running text | III281:1777 running text |
| 29 | V186:1755 running text | III281:1778 running text |
| 30 | V186:1755 shared with English29;allocated once there | III281:1778 shared with English29;allocated once there |
| 31 | V186:1756 running text | III281:1779 running text |
| 32 | V186:1757,1758 running text | III281:1780,1781 running text |
| 33 | V186:1759 running text | III281:1782 running text |
| 34 | V186:1760 running text | III281:1783 running text |
| 35 | V186:1761 running text | III281:1784 running text |
| 36 | V186:1762 running text | III281:1785 running text |
| 37 | V186:1763 running text | III281:1786 running text |
| 38 | V186:1763 shared with English37;allocated once there | III281:1786 shared with English37;allocated once there |
| 39 | V186:1764 running text | III281:1787 running text |
| 40 | V186:1765 running text;do not seek combat;smoke-speed retreat | III281:1788 running text;retreat with fortune reversed;no smoke in corresponding main |
| 41 | V186:1766 running text;all killed except addressed survivors | III281:1789 running text;Time scatters fallen clan |
| 42 | V186:1766–1767 checked main gap;actual V186n27 full Time-teacher unit | III281:1790 running text |
| 43 | V186:1767 running text | III281:1791 running text |
| 44 | V186:1768 running text | III281:1792 running text |
| 45 | V187:1769 running text | III281:1793 running text |
New Naqqali