Kay Khosrow Sends Gudarz against Turan
90 verbatim couplets;published title Kay Khosrow Sends Gudarz against Turan;ends before C3.4.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | — |
| Moscow | V90–94:62–147 main;selected actual91n4 ancestry,93n1 Garcha,93n14 Shapur,93n20 partial evil prohibition. |
| Mohl | III209–213:62–146 main;ancestral council list,golden crowns,Faramarz order,Garcha,honor130,justice135 before envoy,house145. |
| Ganjoor | 12rokh sh3:1–85 plus sh4:1. Main poem text;section boundary does not match English ending. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV7–12:60–144 main;actual8n15 roster alternatives,10n17 Garcha,11n4 Shapur. Two departure units136–137 retained. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Intelligence converts menace into numbers
English 1–5;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V90:62 running text · Moscow V90:63 running text · Moscow V90:64 running text · Moscow V90:65 running text · Moscow V90:66 running text · Mohl III209:62 running text · Mohl III209:63 running text · Mohl III209:64 running text · Mohl III209:65 running text · Mohl III209:66 running text · Khaleghi IV7:60 running text · Khaleghi IV7:61 running text · Khaleghi IV7:62 running text · Khaleghi IV7:63 running text · Khaleghi IV7:64 running text · Ganjoor sh3:1 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:2 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:3 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:4 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:5 poem body
All four sources begin with intelligence reaching the Shah, then identify Afrasiab’s hostility, injured reputation, poisoned spear and immense cavalry force. The English turns the first report of arrival into a force drawing near, preserving urgency while making the danger prospective. Its division between daytime rest and nighttime sleep gives the enemy’s agitation a continuous rhythm. The poisoned spear and redirected rein then bring intention into physical objects before the numerical announcement. Three hundred thousand remains the reported strength in all four, not an independently confirmed military census. English adds lifted spears and dust to this announcement, anticipating the following image of the army’s dust reaching heaven. The result is a coherent threatening speech whose embellishments should remain distinct from separately attested weapon or numerical variants.
6–10Noise and fear inside the report
English 6–10;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V90:67 running text · Moscow V90:68 running text · Moscow V90:69 running text · Moscow V90:70 running text · Moscow V90:71 running text · Mohl III209:67 running text · Mohl III210:68 running text · Mohl III210:69 running text · Mohl III210:70 running text · Mohl III210:71 running text · Khaleghi IV7:65 running text · Khaleghi IV7:66 running text · Khaleghi IV7:67 running text · Khaleghi IV7:68 running text · Khaleghi IV7:69 running text · Ganjoor sh3:6 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:7 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:8 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:9 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:10 poem body
The report magnifies Turanian strength through dust, sleepless warriors, instruments and the imagined defeat of a lion. All four preserve this progression, and English keeps the royal court as the place where tabira prevents sleep. Its account of fear spreading through a crowd explains the Persian image of a heart displaced by sound. That clarification makes the emotional response accessible but reduces the bodily strangeness of the original figure. The lion comparison remains conditional: it belongs to the messengers’ assessment of what this army could do. The chapter has not yet endorsed that assessment through combat. Piran’s appointment then brings the report back to command structure. English retains the understated description of his army as substantial through the negative formula of no small force.
11–15The king listens before he answers
English 11–15;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V90:72 running text · Moscow V90:73 running text · Moscow V90:74 running text · Moscow V90:75 running text · Moscow V90:76 running text · Mohl III210:72 running text · Mohl III210:73 running text · Mohl III210:74 running text · Mohl III210:75 running text · Mohl III210:76 running text · Khaleghi IV7:70 running text · Khaleghi IV7:71 running text · Khaleghi IV8:72 running text · Khaleghi IV8:73 running text · Khaleghi IV8:74 running text · Ganjoor sh3:11 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:12 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:13 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:14 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:15 poem body
All four give Shideh fifty thousand fighters, a sword capable of taking fire’s heart, and an army likened to intoxicated elephants. English preserves the numerical and personal information while translating intoxication into madness and mountain lowering into leveling. Its scimitar narrows the general sword term without requiring a claim about a specific historical weapon. The narrative then changes tempo: Khosrow sits with the intelligence and thinks before responding. English weighing makes that deliberation explicit. The words he subsequently offers are attributed to Mobadan in all four, so royal confidence emerges through remembered counsel rather than an unexplained prophetic announcement. The sequence matters: the threatening report is fully heard before the king interprets it, and the English maintains that interval of considered response.
16–20Cosmic assurance and the danger of injustice
English 16–20;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V90:77 running text · Moscow V90:78 running text · Moscow V90:79 running text · Moscow V91:80 running text · Moscow V91:81 running text · Mohl III210:77 running text · Mohl III210:78 running text · Mohl III210:79 running text · Mohl III210:80 running text · Mohl III210:81 running text · Khaleghi IV8:75 running text · Khaleghi IV8:76 running text · Khaleghi IV8:77 running text · Khaleghi IV8:78 running text · Khaleghi IV8:79 running text · Ganjoor sh3:16 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:17 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:18 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:19 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:20 poem body
The king’s answer first opposes the Turkish moon to Iran’s sun, then turns to the black snake and the ruler who plants injustice. All four attest this movement from cosmic hierarchy to dangerous creature to moral consequence. English preserves the celestial injury but makes the snake image more physically explicit by giving it a raised, poisonous head. The poison is not separately printed in the inspected main units; it develops the creature’s familiar menace. The Persian wording also carries an ominous sense of the snake approaching its end, which becomes straightforward motion in English. The tree of injustice then gives the king’s confidence an ethical condition. Summoning the Mobadan and sharing the report returns this compressed wisdom to collective deliberation rather than leaving it as an isolated maxim.
21–25A council assembled through differing rosters
English 21–25;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V91:82 running text; V91:83 running text · Moscow V91:82 running text · Moscow V91:84 running text · Moscow V91:83 running text;actual91n4 ancestry variant · Moscow V91:85 running text · Mohl III210:82 running text · Mohl III210:83 running text · Mohl III210:84 running text · Mohl III210:85 running text · Khaleghi IV8:80 running text · Khaleghi IV8:81 running text · Khaleghi IV8:80–81 checked local main gap;actual8n15 roster alternatives · Khaleghi IV8:82 running text · Ganjoor sh3:21–22 poem body;Rostam at22 · Ganjoor sh3:21 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:23 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:22 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:24 poem body
The English roster redistributes names across four couplets, so one-to-one numbering alone would misrepresent its source relations. Mohl and Khaleghi place Rostam beside Dastan in the first naming unit; Moscow and Ganjoor put him in the following one. All four preserve the separate group containing Bijan, Gostaham, Gorgin, Zangeh and Gazhdaham. English follows Mohl by giving that group before Tus and Fariborz. Its ancestry for those two is also printed in Mohl and in actual Moscow apparatus, while Khaleghi records alternatives below a main sequence that lacks this separate unit. Shapur, present in the Moscow and Ganjoor council list, is not separately retained here. The closing flock image survives in all four and preserves the king’s pastoral authority over this otherwise martial assembly.
26–30The assembly becomes a public muster
English 26–30;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V91:86 running text · Moscow V91:87 running text · Moscow V91:88 running text · Moscow V91:89 running text · Moscow V91:90 running text · Mohl III210:86 running text · Mohl III210:87 running text · Mohl III210:88 running text · Mohl III210:89 running text · Mohl III210:90 running text · Khaleghi IV8:83 running text · Khaleghi IV8:84 running text · Khaleghi IV8:85 running text · Khaleghi IV9:86 running text · Khaleghi IV9:87 running text · Ganjoor sh3:25 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:26 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:27 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:28 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:29 poem body
All four move from council to preparation through the enemy’s sharpened claws, royal instruments, the open field and an elephant-mounted seat. English expands the threatened royal position into crown and throne, giving the political object a more concrete double emblem. The instrument names preserve the ceremonial texture of the summons; their proclamation of royal state is an interpretation of their function. The king’s movement outside the palace then makes deliberation publicly visible. English describes the throne as bound to the elephant, specifying how the prepared seat might be secured without citing a separate fastening verb. Finally, it names the Shah as the sounding bowl’s striker from narrative context. This action shares a Persian couplet with the indigo earth image that the English unfolds in the following couplet.
31–35Color, animal force and compulsory service
English 31–35;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V91:90 running text · Moscow V91:91 running text · Moscow V91:92 running text · Moscow V91:93 running text · Moscow V91:94 running text · Mohl III210:90 running text · Mohl III210:91 running text · Mohl III210:92 running text · Mohl III211:93 running text · Mohl III211:94 running text · Khaleghi IV9:87 running text · Khaleghi IV9:88 running text · Khaleghi IV9:89 running text · Khaleghi IV9:90 running text · Khaleghi IV9:91 running text · Ganjoor sh3:29 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:30 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:31 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:32 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:33 poem body
The indigo coating expands into its own English couplet, followed by the blue sky, multicolored earth and leopard-like warriors shared by all four sources. English gathering ranks and plain locate the color within the muster, while the next sea image gains a storm absent from the explicit boiling-water comparison. These expansions turn a compact sequence of impressions into a more continuous scene. The proclamation then interrupts spectacle with obligation. Anyone who knows rein and stirrup must answer the summons instead of remaining comfortably at home. English adds gain as a possible motive for staying, broadening the prohibition beyond repose. The movement from dazzling ranks to the demand for service remains intact: military grandeur rests on an order directed at every person capable of riding.
36–40A wide summons with a fixed deadline
English 36–40;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V91:95 running text · Moscow V91:96 running text · Moscow V92:97 running text · Moscow V92:98 running text · Moscow V92:99 running text · Mohl III211:95 running text · Mohl III211:96 running text · Mohl III211:97 running text · Mohl III211:98 running text · Mohl III211:99 running text · Khaleghi IV9:92 running text · Khaleghi IV9:93 running text · Khaleghi IV9:94 running text · Khaleghi IV9:95 running text · Khaleghi IV9:96 running text · Ganjoor sh3:34 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:35 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:36 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:37 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:38 poem body
All four summon selected mounted men from Rum and Hind, then Arab fighters likened to fierce lions. The English preserves this breadth without turning the list into a new account of the empire’s exact borders. Its desert is more geographically specific than the Persian plain associated with spear-bearing horsemen. The demanded three hundred thousand answers the scale of the enemy force already reported, creating a deliberate symmetry of mobilization. Forty days defines the attendance deadline, while the threatened loss of headgear becomes loss of a crown in English. That choice stresses rank and royal recognition; it should not be converted into a claim that the inspected verse explicitly orders execution. Riders carrying written commands then connect the central proclamation to distant military households.
41–45Mobilization is measured in time and wealth
English 41–45;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V92:100 running text · Moscow V92:101 running text · Moscow V92:102 running text · Moscow V92:103 running text · Moscow V92:104 running text · Mohl III211:100 running text · Mohl III211:101 running text · Mohl III211:102 running text · Mohl III211:103 running text · Mohl III211:104 running text · Khaleghi IV9:97 running text · Khaleghi IV9:98 running text · Khaleghi IV9:99 running text · Khaleghi IV9:100 running text · Khaleghi IV9:101 running text · Ganjoor sh3:39 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:40 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:41 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:42 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:43 poem body
The two-week response does not replace the earlier forty-day deadline. All four distinguish the elapsed interval from the time allowed for attendance, and the English keeps both. Country and world then seem to boil and cry out as troops move, followed by the concrete daily signal of cockcrow and drums. English thunder extends that sound without obscuring its time of day. Provincial leaders converge on the royal gate, changing the scattered response into a visible concentration. The old treasuries are opened to pay the troops, and English brings gold into the first payment couplet by anticipating the dinars of the next. The logistical sequence remains clear: orders travel outward, armies move inward, and accumulated wealth becomes the means of supporting the assembled force.
46–50Equipment makes division of command possible
English 46–50;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V92:105 running text · Moscow V92:106 running text · Moscow V92:107 running text · Moscow V92:108 running text · Moscow V92:109 running text · Mohl III211:105 running text · Mohl III211:106 running text · Mohl III211:107 running text · Mohl III211:108 running text · Mohl III211:109 running text · Khaleghi IV10:102 running text · Khaleghi IV10:103 running text · Khaleghi IV10:104 running text · Khaleghi IV10:105 running text · Khaleghi IV10:106 running text · Ganjoor sh3:44 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:45 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:46 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:47 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:48 poem body
Mohl gives golden headgear where Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give jeweled headgear, providing direct support for the English crowns’ material. The next image joins horse armor and body armor to a mountain-like collective mass. Iron wording is explicit in Mohl and Khaleghi, so the English iron-bodied mountain need not be treated as an unsupported invention from the armor alone. All four then conclude the work of equipping the troops and release the Shah’s concern. This completion is the precondition for dividing the army into commands. The first selected force contains thirty thousand sword-bearing horsemen and goes to Rostam. English separates that assignment from the opening address, making the transfer of responsibility visible before the geographical instructions begin.
51–55Conquest, succession and the shared watering place
English 51–55;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V92:109–110 running text;address and command · Moscow V92:111 running text · Moscow V92:113 running text · Moscow V92:112 running text · Moscow V92:114 running text · Mohl III211:109–110 running text;address and command · Mohl III211:111 running text · Mohl III211:112 running text · Mohl III211:113 running text · Mohl III211:114 running text · Khaleghi IV10:106–107 running text;address and command · Khaleghi IV10:108 running text · Khaleghi IV10:110 running text · Khaleghi IV10:109 running text · Khaleghi IV10:111 running text · Ganjoor sh3:48–49 poem body;address and command · Ganjoor sh3:50 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:52 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:51 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:53 poem body
All four direct Rostam through Sistan and Hind, connect Ghaznin with an upper route, and associate success with crown, throne and signet. English preserves that sequence without requiring a new geographical reconstruction. The placement of Faramarz’s installation differs: Mohl puts it before the leopard and lamb, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi put the peace image first. English follows Mohl, presenting delegated rule before the condition of settled coexistence. Its explicit peace explains what the shared watering place achieves politically, while retaining the striking equality of predator and prey. The departure instruments also vary in material. English brazen koust agrees with Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; Khaleghi prints golden. These are alternatives within the inspected texts, not a general historical classification of royal drums.
56–60Urgency and the next territorial commission
English 56–60;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V92:114 running text · Moscow V92:115 running text · Moscow V93:116 running text;actual93n1 Garcha variant · Moscow V93:116 running text · Moscow V93:117 running text · Mohl III211:114 running text · Mohl III211:115 running text · Mohl III211:116 running text · Mohl III211:117 running text · Khaleghi IV10:111 running text · Khaleghi IV10:112 running text · Khaleghi IV10:113 running text;actual10n17 Garcha variant · Khaleghi IV10:113 running text · Khaleghi IV10:114 running text · Ganjoor sh3:53 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:54 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:55 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:56 poem body
The prohibition on lingering in Kashmir and Kabul is shared by all four, but English makes a homeward destination explicit beyond that negative instruction. Khosrow’s following loss of food, sleep and rest explains why delay matters to him personally. The narrative then transfers attention to Lohrasp. English Garcha has main-text support in Mohl, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi use a different place-name in their main lines; the printed apparatuses of Moscow and Khaleghi preserve Garcha-type alternatives. This records textual support without asserting a new modern identification. English separates Lohrasp’s royal descent into a full address, expanding the territorial assignment’s second hemistich. The mountain-like selected army then repeats the chapter’s language of massed strength at the level of a distinct command.
61–65Separate fronts within one royal plan
English 61–65;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V93:118 running text · Moscow V93:119 running text · Moscow V93:120 running text · Moscow V93:121 running text · Moscow V93:122 running text · Mohl III212:118 running text · Mohl III212:119 running text · Mohl III212:120 running text · Mohl III212:121 running text · Mohl III212:122 running text · Khaleghi IV10:115 running text · Khaleghi IV10:116 running text · Khaleghi IV10:117 running text · Khaleghi IV10:118 running text · Khaleghi IV11:119 running text · Ganjoor sh3:57 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:58 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:59 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:60 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:61 poem body
All four require Lohrasp’s chosen cavalry to be battle-ready and capable of devastating the enemy. English grief and woe render the destructive aim as its human consequence. Ashkash’s assignment then receives its own number, thirty thousand, and its own animal imagery. Roaring lions become lion-hearted fighters in English, while the wolf-like army and great koust remain visible on the road to Khwarazm. The sources associate the camp there with Shideh, though Mohl characterizes him as ill-starred and the other main texts emphasize his warlike hostility. English makes fighting him explicit and adds the setting of his rule within halls; that interior is not separately attested here. The fourth force goes to Gudarz, whose appointment is distinguished immediately by the quantity of advice accompanying it.
66–70Names identify the fourth army’s leadership
English 66–70;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V93:123 running text · Moscow V93:124 running text;actual93n14 Shapur variant · Moscow V93:125 running text · Moscow V93:126 running text · Moscow V93:127 running text · Mohl III212:123 running text · Mohl III212:124 running text · Mohl III212:125 running text · Mohl III212:126 running text · Mohl III212:127 running text · Khaleghi IV11:120 running text · Khaleghi IV11:121 running text;actual11n4 Shapur variant · Khaleghi IV11:122 running text · Khaleghi IV11:123 running text · Khaleghi IV11:124 running text · Ganjoor sh3:62 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:63 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:64 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:65 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:66 poem body
The companions assigned to Gudarz again require attention to roster variants rather than simple name counting. All four preserve Gorgin, Zangeh and Gostaham. In the next unit Mohl supports the English combination of Fariborz’s connection with Kavus, Farhad, Giv, Guraza and Shapur. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi instead retain Zavareh and Rohham in their main formulation, although actual Moscow and Khaleghi apparatus includes Shapur. English therefore has an attested basis while leaving Zavareh unnamed in this assignment. Gudarz’s description as seasoned, shrewd and stern develops the source’s identification of him as Keshvad’s son among the chiefs. The subsequent mounting at the royal command places him visibly in front, making hierarchy an action after the roster has established the personnel.
71–75Restraint reaches households and noncombatants
English 71–75;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V93:128 running text · Moscow V93:129 running text · Moscow V93:129–130 checked local main gap;actual93n20 first hemistich only · Moscow V93:130 running text · Moscow V93:131 running text · Mohl III212:128 running text · Mohl III212:129 running text · Mohl III212:130 running text · Mohl III212:131 running text · Mohl III212:132 running text · Khaleghi IV11:125 running text · Khaleghi IV11:126 running text · Khaleghi IV11:126–127 checked local main gap;full honor wording not verified in selected apparatus · Khaleghi IV11:127 running text · Khaleghi IV11:128 running text · Ganjoor sh3:67 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:68 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:69 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:70 poem body
All four begin the campaign instructions by prohibiting injustice and the destruction of an inhabited, flourishing residence. English thriving home gives that protection a domestic scope without limiting it to a royal building. The additional warning about evil, house, name and shame is fully printed in Mohl. Moscow has only the first hemistich in actual apparatus at the checked location; Ganjoor and Khaleghi lack the full separate unit in the inspected main sequence. Those narrower forms of evidence cannot certify the complete honor formula. The following protection of anyone who does not gird for battle is shared by all four. English keeps it as an obligation on the army, grounded in divine disapproval of evil and the passing nature of human life.
76–80Measured command precedes the embassy
English 76–80;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V93:132 running text · Moscow V93:133 running text · Moscow V93:136 running text · Moscow V93:134 running text · Moscow V93:135 running text · Mohl III212:133 running text · Mohl III212:134 running text · Mohl III212:135 running text · Mohl III212:136 running text · Mohl III212:137 running text · Khaleghi IV11:129 running text · Khaleghi IV11:130 running text · Khaleghi IV11:133 running text · Khaleghi IV11:131 running text · Khaleghi IV11:132 running text · Ganjoor sh3:71 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:72 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:75 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:73 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:74 poem body
The caution against a hot heart and the explicit example of Tus are common to all four. English recasts the warning as keeping cool and makes repeated provocations the occasions for rash drumming, slightly narrowing the sources’ broader warning against such display at every occasion. The position of the justice command is consequential. Mohl places it before selecting an envoy to Piran; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi put it after the cloak of kindness. English follows Mohl, so general right conduct frames the diplomatic task from the outset. The envoy must be experienced, attentive and able to remember. English then expands the opening of the ear through counsel into a full couplet about attending to words, preparing the separate treatment of kindness that follows.
81–85Kindness, obedience and ceremonial departure
English 81–85;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V93:135 running text · Moscow V94:137 running text · Moscow V94:138 running text · Moscow V94:139 running text · Moscow V94:140 running text · Moscow V94:141 running text · Moscow V94:142 running text · Mohl III212:137 running text · Mohl III212:138 running text · Mohl III212:139 running text · Mohl III212:139–140 checked local main gap;assent proceeds directly to sixty elephants · Mohl III212:140 running text · Mohl III212:141 running text · Khaleghi IV11:132 running text · Khaleghi IV11:134 running text · Khaleghi IV11:135 running text · Khaleghi IV11:136 running text · Khaleghi IV12:137 running text · Khaleghi IV12:138 running text · Khaleghi IV12:139 running text · Ganjoor sh3:74 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:76 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:77 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:78 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:79 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:80 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:81 poem body
The cloak of kindness is shared by all four and remains a material image in English. Its added prohibition on harsh words explains how that covering should work, without supplying a separately named Persian recipient for the pronoun. Gudarz’s assent places the royal command above sun and moon before affirming the king and servant relationship. After that response, Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi include two further units of drums, arriving troops and darkening dust. Mohl proceeds directly to the sixty elephants, as does English; the two unmatched units remain in source-only rows rather than disappearing from the accounting. The four selected elephants then distinguish a ceremonial vehicle within the larger elephant force. English superiority of the chosen animals is an intensification of selection, not a separate source claim.
86–90Royal display ends in a harmless march
English 86–90;individual source accounts and inspected page links below. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps and interpretive expansion kept distinct.
Moscow V94:143 running text · Moscow V94:144 running text · Moscow V94:145 running text · Moscow V94:146 running text · Moscow V94:147 running text · Mohl III212:142 running text · Mohl III213:143 running text · Mohl III213:144 running text · Mohl III213:145 running text · Mohl III213:146 running text · Khaleghi IV12:140 running text · Khaleghi IV12:141 running text · Khaleghi IV12:142 running text · Khaleghi IV12:143 running text · Khaleghi IV12:144 running text · Ganjoor sh3:82 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:83 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:84 poem body · Ganjoor sh3:85 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:1 poem body;across section boundary
All four place a golden throne on the elephants and order Gudarz onto it, giving the departing commander a conspicuous royal setting. Dust then rises when the animals move, and the movement is interpreted as a good omen. The threatened smoke differs in its object: Mohl and Khaleghi give Piran’s house, while Moscow and Ganjoor give his life or soul. English follows the house reading and retains the analogy with elephant dust. Its final harmless march is especially important after that destructive prediction. All four attest the stage-by-stage movement under Khosrow’s order, but Ganjoor places it at the beginning of the next section and Khaleghi under a new heading. English uses it as closure, showing the restraints just pronounced taking practical effect.
Source record and limits
C3.3 only:90 English couplets. Moscow V90–94:62–147 (86 main units);Mohl III209–213:62–146 (PDF215–219,85 main units);Ganjoor12rokh sh3:1–85 plus sh4:1 (86 main units);Khaleghi IV7–12:60–144 (PDF23–28,85 main units). All declared main units accounted. Two source-only rows S1/S2 preserve departure units missing locally in Mohl and without separate English counterparts.
Existing complete source PDFs were retrieved and reused. Moscow V90–94 and Mohl III209–213 were individually read in PNG facsimiles first,then Ganjoor sh3/sh4 and Khaleghi IV7–12. All90 English entries have distinct primary-source accounts;shared Persian units and moved units are explicitly numbered. English73 uses Mohl’s full main couplet as its Persian reference. English90 uses Ganjoor sh4:1 across the digital section boundary.
- F&R English: 90 verbatim couplets;published title Kay Khosrow Sends Gudarz against Turan;ends before C3.4.
- Moscow: V90–94:62–147 main;selected actual91n4 ancestry,93n1 Garcha,93n14 Shapur,93n20 partial evil prohibition.
- Mohl: III209–213:62–146 main;ancestral council list,golden crowns,Faramarz order,Garcha,honor130,justice135 before envoy,house145.
- Ganjoor: 12rokh sh3:1–85 plus sh4:1. Main poem text;section boundary does not match English ending.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV7–12:60–144 main;actual8n15 roster alternatives,10n17 Garcha,11n4 Shapur. Two departure units136–137 retained.
Actual apparatus used: Moscow91n4 and Khaleghi8n15 contain council ancestry alternatives;Moscow93n1 and Khaleghi10n17 contain Garcha-type place-name alternatives;Moscow93n14 and Khaleghi11n4 attest Shapur. Moscow93n20 prints only the evil-prohibition hemistich,not the full house/name/shame couplet. The full latter unit is Mohl III212:130. Local main gaps are Moscow129–130,Ganjoor sh3:68–69 and Khaleghi126–127. Khaleghi’s separate Tus/Fariborz roster unit is absent locally between80–81 but actual8n15 prints alternatives. None of these labels implies exhaustive apparatus or appendix coverage.
Source-only S1/S2:Moscow139–140,Ganjoor sh3:78–79,Khaleghi136–137 give the drums and troop arrivals before the elephants. Mohl III212:139–140 moves directly from assent to sixty elephants. English follows that shorter local sequence. These are checked local differences,not reconstructed Persian additions.
Selected apparatus inspected,not exhaustive. No appendix evidence used. Checked local gaps refer only to the identified neighboring running units. English73 full honor wording is verified in Mohl;Moscow93n20 supplies only its first hemistich and cannot certify the whole couplet. English poison-head,homeward direction,Shideh’s halls and several descriptive amplifications are interpretations,not newly verified variants. No independent geography or instrument taxonomy asserted. All inherited provisional flags remain verbatim.
English begins Then tidings reached the conquering Shah’s ear: and ends No harm was done wherever troops were sent.. Next candidate units:Moscow V94:148,Mohl III213:147,Ganjoor sh4:2,Khaleghi IV12:145;boundary context only.
Persian main-column text is the named Ganjoor reference except the explicitly labeled Mohl unit. Selected printed readings are bounded quotations,not full diplomatic transcriptions.
C3.3 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V90:62 running text | III209:62 running text |
| 2 | V90:63 running text | III209:63 running text |
| 3 | V90:64 running text | III209:64 running text |
| 4 | V90:65 running text | III209:65 running text |
| 5 | V90:66 running text | III209:66 running text |
| 6 | V90:67 running text | III209:67 running text |
| 7 | V90:68 running text | III210:68 running text |
| 8 | V90:69 running text | III210:69 running text |
| 9 | V90:70 running text | III210:70 running text |
| 10 | V90:71 running text | III210:71 running text |
| 11 | V90:72 running text | III210:72 running text |
| 12 | V90:73 running text | III210:73 running text |
| 13 | V90:74 running text | III210:74 running text |
| 14 | V90:75 running text | III210:75 running text |
| 15 | V90:76 running text | III210:76 running text |
| 16 | V90:77 running text | III210:77 running text |
| 17 | V90:78 running text | III210:78 running text |
| 18 | V90:79 running text | III210:79 running text |
| 19 | V91:80 running text | III210:80 running text |
| 20 | V91:81 running text | III210:81 running text |
| 21 | V91:82 running text; V91:83 running text | III210:82 running text |
| 22 | V91:82 running text | III210:82 running text |
| 23 | V91:84 running text | III210:83 running text |
| 24 | V91:83 running text;actual91n4 ancestry variant | III210:84 running text |
| 25 | V91:85 running text | III210:85 running text |
| 26 | V91:86 running text | III210:86 running text |
| 27 | V91:87 running text | III210:87 running text |
| 28 | V91:88 running text | III210:88 running text |
| 29 | V91:89 running text | III210:89 running text |
| 30 | V91:90 running text | III210:90 running text |
| 31 | V91:90 running text | III210:90 running text |
| 32 | V91:91 running text | III210:91 running text |
| 33 | V91:92 running text | III210:92 running text |
| 34 | V91:93 running text | III211:93 running text |
| 35 | V91:94 running text | III211:94 running text |
| 36 | V91:95 running text | III211:95 running text |
| 37 | V91:96 running text | III211:96 running text |
| 38 | V92:97 running text | III211:97 running text |
| 39 | V92:98 running text | III211:98 running text |
| 40 | V92:99 running text | III211:99 running text |
| 41 | V92:100 running text | III211:100 running text |
| 42 | V92:101 running text | III211:101 running text |
| 43 | V92:102 running text | III211:102 running text |
| 44 | V92:103 running text | III211:103 running text |
| 45 | V92:104 running text | III211:104 running text |
| 46 | V92:105 running text | III211:105 running text |
| 47 | V92:106 running text | III211:106 running text |
| 48 | V92:107 running text | III211:107 running text |
| 49 | V92:108 running text | III211:108 running text |
| 50 | V92:109 running text | III211:109 running text |
| 51 | V92:109–110 running text;address and command | III211:109–110 running text;address and command |
| 52 | V92:111 running text | III211:111 running text |
| 53 | V92:113 running text | III211:112 running text |
| 54 | V92:112 running text | III211:113 running text |
| 55 | V92:114 running text | III211:114 running text |
| 56 | V92:114 running text | III211:114 running text |
| 57 | V92:115 running text | III211:115 running text |
| 58 | V93:116 running text;actual93n1 Garcha variant | III211:116 running text |
| 59 | V93:116 running text | III211:116 running text |
| 60 | V93:117 running text | III211:117 running text |
| 61 | V93:118 running text | III212:118 running text |
| 62 | V93:119 running text | III212:119 running text |
| 63 | V93:120 running text | III212:120 running text |
| 64 | V93:121 running text | III212:121 running text |
| 65 | V93:122 running text | III212:122 running text |
| 66 | V93:123 running text | III212:123 running text |
| 67 | V93:124 running text;actual93n14 Shapur variant | III212:124 running text |
| 68 | V93:125 running text | III212:125 running text |
| 69 | V93:126 running text | III212:126 running text |
| 70 | V93:127 running text | III212:127 running text |
| 71 | V93:128 running text | III212:128 running text |
| 72 | V93:129 running text | III212:129 running text |
| 73 | V93:129–130 checked local main gap;actual93n20 first hemistich only | III212:130 running text |
| 74 | V93:130 running text | III212:131 running text |
| 75 | V93:131 running text | III212:132 running text |
| 76 | V93:132 running text | III212:133 running text |
| 77 | V93:133 running text | III212:134 running text |
| 78 | V93:136 running text | III212:135 running text |
| 79 | V93:134 running text | III212:136 running text |
| 80 | V93:135 running text | III212:137 running text |
| 81 | V93:135 running text | III212:137 running text |
| 82 | V94:137 running text | III212:138 running text |
| 83 | V94:138 running text | III212:139 running text |
| 84 | V94:141 running text | III212:140 running text |
| 85 | V94:142 running text | III212:141 running text |
| 86 | V94:143 running text | III212:142 running text |
| 87 | V94:144 running text | III213:143 running text |
| 88 | V94:145 running text | III213:144 running text |
| 89 | V94:146 running text | III213:145 running text |
| 90 | V94:147 running text | III213:146 running text |
New Naqqali