Giv Battles Gurvi
16 verbatim couplets/32 lines. Published index and live boundaries verified. Retained same-day HTML supplies exact line capture. Next C3.31 Guraza Battles Siamak.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 16 verbatim couplets/32 lines. |
| Moscow | V191–192:1844–1858;15 main units. English9 actual192n10 IV full addition,not main. Poison1845;leopard1847;bound1849. |
| Mohl | III285:1875–1890;16 main units. Ox-head mace/leopard-roar1883 in running text. Dust1876;nahang1878;alive1880. PDF291. |
| Ganjoor | sh22:1–15 poem body;15 units. English9 checked local gap8–9. Poison2;leopard4;bound6. Prose/commentary excluded. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV118–119:1857–1871;15 main units. English9 checked1864–1865 gap;full local apparatus equivalent unverified. Poison1858;leopard1860;bound1862. PDF134–135. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The duel and Giv’s purpose
English 1–6;individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V191:1844 running text · Mohl III285:1875 running text · Khaleghi IV118:1857 running text · Ganjoor sh22:1 poem body · Moscow V192:1845 running text;زهر poison · Mohl III285:1876 running text;خاک dust · Khaleghi IV118:1858 running text;زهر poison · Ganjoor sh22:2 poem body · Moscow V192:1846 running text · Mohl III285:1877 running text · Khaleghi IV119:1859 running text · Ganjoor sh22:3 poem body · Moscow V192:1847 running text;پلنگ leopard · Mohl III285:1878 running text;نهنگ nahang · Khaleghi IV119:1860 running text;پلنگ leopard · Ganjoor sh22:4 poem body · Moscow V192:1848 running text · Mohl III285:1879 running text · Khaleghi IV119:1861 running text · Ganjoor sh22:5 poem body · Moscow V192:1849 running text;بسته bound · Mohl III285:1880 running text;زنده alive · Khaleghi IV119:1862 running text;بسته bound · Ganjoor sh22:6 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all identify Giv explicitly as Gudarz’s son, but Gurvi Zereh is a compound designation without the corresponding son formula. The English genealogy therefore retains the local qualification already recorded for this name; the present passage does not independently settle it. English’s dust mingled with blood follows Mohl’s خاک, whereas Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi read زهر, poison, giving the fighting a more venomous image. Conversely, the charging leopards follow Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi against Mohl’s nahang. These mixed agreements show why neither primary edition alone should define the English’s source profile. The falling spear becomes plural scattered spearheads, a more specific picture of fragmentation. All four then establish Giv’s purpose: capture his opponent alive and present him to Khosrow. English’s living gift is especially close to Mohl’s alive wording, while the other three explicitly describe the intended prisoner as bound.
7–11The dropped bow and the ox-head mace
English 7–11;individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V192:1850 running text · Mohl III285:1881 running text · Khaleghi IV119:1863 running text · Ganjoor sh22:7 poem body · Moscow V192:1851 running text · Mohl III285:1882 running text · Khaleghi IV119:1864 running text · Ganjoor sh22:8 poem body · Moscow V192:1851–1852 checked main gap;actual V192n10 IV branch full ox-head mace/leopard-roar unit · Mohl III285:1883 running text · Khaleghi IV119:1864–1865 checked main gap;full ox-head mace/leopard-roar unit unverified in inspected local apparatus · Ganjoor sh22:8–9 checked local gap;no full ox-head mace/leopard-roar unit · Moscow V192:1852 running text · Mohl III285:1884 running text · Khaleghi IV119:1865 running text · Ganjoor sh22:9 poem body · Moscow V192:1853 running text · Mohl III285:1885 running text · Khaleghi IV119:1866 running text · Ganjoor sh22:10 poem body
Across Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh, Gurvi loses his bow in fear, reaches for his sword and faces Giv’s continuing charge. English keeps those agents clear. The following ox-head mace and leopard roar are fully printed in Mohl’s running text and in the separately identified IV addition at Moscow V192n10. Moscow’s main sequence, Ganjoor’s body and Khaleghi’s inspected main passage proceed directly to the blow. No full equivalent was verified in the inspected Khaleghi apparatus; its local absence is not a claim about the entire edition. This distinction positively supports the English without pretending that all four main texts contain its weapon description. All four do contain the blow to the head and helmet, the blood descending to the face and Giv’s powerful seizure from the saddle. Crushing to the breast expresses restraint within the announced live-capture purpose, rather than contradicting it by asserting a fatal wound.
12–16A living captive and the victory signal
English 12–16;individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V192:1854 running text · Mohl III285:1886 running text · Khaleghi IV119:1867 running text · Ganjoor sh22:11 poem body · Moscow V192:1855 running text · Mohl III285:1887 running text · Khaleghi IV119:1868 running text · Ganjoor sh22:12 poem body · Moscow V192:1856 running text · Mohl III285:1888 running text · Khaleghi IV119:1869 running text · Ganjoor sh22:13 poem body · Moscow V192:1857 running text · Mohl III285:1889 running text · Khaleghi IV119:1870 running text · Ganjoor sh22:14 poem body · Moscow V192:1858 running text · Mohl III285:1890 running text · Khaleghi IV119:1871 running text · Ganjoor sh22:15 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh share the sequence of Gurvi weakening, falling unconscious, being bound and being driven ahead of the mounted Giv. English preserves the change from close physical struggle to control of a living prisoner. Its plain account of binding omits the leopard metaphor for the dismounting warrior and the stone-like firmness of the bonds, making the mechanics easier to follow while reducing the source’s animal and material imagery. The return to his comrade is explicit in all four; the English does not invent a new destination or identify that comrade beyond the local text. The banner and ascent fulfill the agreed public signal, and the shout lowering the mountain retains the epic hyperbole. Finally, English names Gudarz where the sources bless the pahlavan in conjunction with the monarch’s victory. That identification is contextual clarification, not a newly attested personal name in the closing couplet.
Source record and limits
C3.30 only:16 English couplets/32 lines. Moscow V191–192:1844–1858(15 main units);Mohl III285:1875–1890(PDF291;16 main units);Ganjoor12rokh sh22:1–15(15 body units);Khaleghi IV118–119:1857–1871(PDF134–135;15 main units). English9 is Mohl1883 running and actual Moscow192n10 IV addition;Moscow1851–1852,Ganjoor22:8–9,Khaleghi1864–1865 checked local main gaps. No source-only row or shared allocation. All declared main/body units uniquely allocated.
Inspection order:Moscow V191–192 PNG and Mohl III285 PNG individually first;then Ganjoor sh22 body and Khaleghi IV118–119 PNG. Existing PDFs reused. Same-file offsets verified:Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.
- F&R English: 16 verbatim couplets/32 lines. Published index and live boundaries verified. Retained same-day HTML supplies exact line capture. Next C3.31 Guraza Battles Siamak.
- Moscow: V191–192:1844–1858;15 main units. English9 actual192n10 IV full addition,not main. Poison1845;leopard1847;bound1849.
- Mohl: III285:1875–1890;16 main units. Ox-head mace/leopard-roar1883 in running text. Dust1876;nahang1878;alive1880. PDF291.
- Ganjoor: sh22:1–15 poem body;15 units. English9 checked local gap8–9. Poison2;leopard4;bound6. Prose/commentary excluded.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV118–119:1857–1871;15 main units. English9 checked1864–1865 gap;full local apparatus equivalent unverified. Poison1858;leopard1860;bound1862. PDF134–135.
English9 is supported by the full running Mohl1883 unit and full actual Moscow192n10 IV addition. It is not Moscow main text. Ganjoor22:8–9 and Khaleghi1864–1865 are bounded checked gaps. No full Khaleghi counterpart verified in the inspected local apparatus. English2 dust is Mohl main versus poison in the other three;English4 leopard agrees with Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi versus Mohl nahang. English6 alive is Mohl main versus bound in the other three. English1 Zereh-son genealogy remains locally unestablished,as in the inherited qualification.
All inherited flags retained verbatim. C3.30.1 retains the C3.28.38 local genealogy qualification:Zereh-son not independently established by the compound name. C3.30.9 full ox-head mace/leopard-roar unit not verified in inspected Khaleghi local apparatus;bounded main gap recorded. English2 dust follows Mohl;English4 leopard follows Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi;English6 living follows Mohl. Spearhead fragmentation and closing Gudarz identification are interpretive specifications. Running text,actual apparatus,appendix evidence,checked local gaps and unverified readings remain distinct. No appendix evidence invoked,no unprinted addition notice counted,no global absence claim.
First:Next Gurvi, Zereh’s son, rode forth to fight Last:And blessed Gudarz, his leader battle-tried.. C3.31 Guraza Battles Siamak opens Third,from Turan,Siamak rode to meet. Local opening:Moscow V192:1859;Khaleghi IV119:1872(PDF135). Mohl1891 and Ganjoor sh23 are candidates requiring next-chapter retrieval and verification. Full C3.31 scope unchecked.
- Moscow V191:1844 main;compound name — گروی زره
- Mohl III285:1876 main;dust — همی خاک با خون برآمیختند
- Moscow V192:1845 main;poison — همی زهر با خون برآمیختند
- Khaleghi IV118:1858 main;poison — همی زهر با خون برآمیختند
- Mohl III285:1878 main;nahang — یک اندر دگر تاختند چون نهنگ
- Moscow V192:1847 main;leopard — یک اندر دگر تاخته چون پلنگ
- Khaleghi IV119:1860 main;leopard — یک اندر دگر تاخته چون پلنگ
- Mohl III285:1880 main;alive — چنان زنده در پیش خسرو برد
- Moscow V192:1849 main;bound — چنان بسته در پیش خسرو برد
- Mohl III285:1883 main;ox-head mace and roar — یکی گرزه گاوپیکر به چنگ / خروشان به کردار شرزه پلنگ
- Moscow V192n10 IV actual addition;ox-head mace and roar — یکی گرزه گاوپیکر به چنگ / خروشان به کردار شرزه پلنگ
- Ganjoor sh22:14 body;victory signal — به بالا برآمد درفشی به دست / به نعره همی کوه را کرد پست
C3.30 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V191:1844 running text | III285:1875 running text |
| 2 | V192:1845 running text;زهر poison | III285:1876 running text;خاک dust |
| 3 | V192:1846 running text | III285:1877 running text |
| 4 | V192:1847 running text;پلنگ leopard | III285:1878 running text;نهنگ nahang |
| 5 | V192:1848 running text | III285:1879 running text |
| 6 | V192:1849 running text;بسته bound | III285:1880 running text;زنده alive |
| 7 | V192:1850 running text | III285:1881 running text |
| 8 | V192:1851 running text | III285:1882 running text |
| 9 | V192:1851–1852 checked main gap;actual V192n10 IV branch full ox-head mace/leopard-roar unit | III285:1883 running text |
| 10 | V192:1852 running text | III285:1884 running text |
| 11 | V192:1853 running text | III285:1885 running text |
| 12 | V192:1854 running text | III285:1886 running text |
| 13 | V192:1855 running text | III285:1887 running text |
| 14 | V192:1856 running text | III285:1888 running text |
| 15 | V192:1857 running text | III285:1889 running text |
| 16 | V192:1858 running text | III285:1890 running text |
New Naqqali