Foruhil Battles Zangula
12 verbatim couplets/24 lines. Published index/title/boundaries verified against current live poem. Exact capture from retained same-day HTML. Next C3.33 Rohham Battles Barman.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 12 verbatim couplets/24 lines. |
| Moscow | V193–194:1871–1883;13 unique main units.1874–1875 grouped at English4;1879 shared at English8–9;1883 source-only. Actual194n5 evil-day variants. |
| Mohl | III286–287:1903–1913;11 unique main units.1910 shared at English8–9. Horse-first1907 and evil-day1909 in running text. Separate advance and final royal cry locally absent. PDF292–293. |
| Ganjoor | sh24:1–13 body;13 unique units.4–5 grouped;9 shared;13 source-only. Thigh-first6 and never-born8. Prose/commentary excluded. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV120–121:1884–1895;12 unique main units.1887–1888 grouped;1892 shared. Evil-day1891 main. Actual121n6 prints royal cry outside main. PDF136–137. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The archer and the arrow’s path
English 1–6;individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V193:1871 running text · Mohl III286:1903 running text · Khaleghi IV120:1884 running text · Ganjoor sh24:1 poem body · Moscow V193:1872 running text · Mohl III286:1904 running text · Khaleghi IV120:1885 running text · Ganjoor sh24:2 poem body · Moscow V193:1873 running text · Mohl III286:1905 running text · Khaleghi IV120:1886 running text · Ganjoor sh24:3 poem body · Moscow V193:1874,1875 running text · Mohl III286:1906 running text;checked local gap1905–1906 for separate shaft-drawing/advance unit · Khaleghi IV120:1887,1888 running text · Ganjoor sh24:4;sh24:5 poem body · Moscow V194:1876 running text;thigh first · Mohl III286:1907 running text;horse first · Khaleghi IV120:1889 running text;thigh first · Ganjoor sh24:6 poem body · Moscow V194:1877 running text · Mohl III286:1908 running text · Khaleghi IV120:1890 running text · Ganjoor sh24:7 poem body
Moscow and Mohl, followed by Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh, establish Foruhil as the unmatched archer and the attacker who sees the grim Turk. English changes that seeing construction into the Turk coming into sight. Its following He can consequently suggest the Turk as bowman until the next couplet’s attack on Zangula restores the intended agent. This is a local clarity qualification, not evidence of a different combatant in the Persian sources. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also retain a separate shaft-drawing and advance unit before the arrow-rain; Mohl’s checked passage moves directly to that rain. The English likewise concentrates the action. Crucially, its horse-first strike has positive support in Mohl’s running text. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi instead name the thigh first, though all four describe the shaft passing through both man and horse. The subsequent falling horse and pale rider retain the common result, while the English leaves the horse’s explicit pain implicit.
7–12Death, trophies and the victory signal
English 7–12;individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V194:1878 running text;as if never born;actual V194n5 IV/VI evil-day variants · Mohl III286:1909 running text;evil-day birth · Khaleghi IV121:1891 running text;evil-day birth · Ganjoor sh24:8 poem body · Moscow V194:1879 running text;shared by English8–9 · Mohl III286:1910 running text;shared by English8–9 · Khaleghi IV121:1892 running text;shared by English8–9 · Ganjoor sh24:9 poem body;shared by English8–9 · Moscow V194:1879 running text;shared by English8–9 · Mohl III286:1910 running text;shared by English8–9 · Khaleghi IV121:1892 running text;shared by English8–9 · Ganjoor sh24:9 poem body;shared by English8–9 · Moscow V194:1880 running text · Mohl III287:1911 running text · Khaleghi IV121:1893 running text · Ganjoor sh24:10 poem body · Moscow V194:1881 running text · Mohl III287:1912 running text · Khaleghi IV121:1894 running text · Ganjoor sh24:11 poem body · Moscow V194:1882 running text · Mohl III287:1913 running text · Khaleghi IV121:1895 running text · Ganjoor sh24:12 poem body · V194:1883 running royal acclamation · III287:1913–1914 checked local gap before Rohham heading · sh24:13 poem body · IV121:1895–1896 checked main gap;actual IV121n6 prints royal acclamation under additions
The English’s evil-day birth follows Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh in their running texts and actual variants in Moscow’s apparatus. Moscow’s main text and Ganjoor instead imagine that Zangula had never been born. The former wording makes birth tragically destined for this death; the latter erases the life retrospectively. All four then join decapitation and removal of the Roman khaftan within one Persian couplet. English expands that unit into two, giving the stripping its own beat and making the bared body explicit. The saddle-bound head, captured horse, leopard-like ascent and blood on breast, blade and hand remain recognizable across all four presentations. English closes at the auspicious banner and fulfilled desire, as do Mohl’s and Khaleghi’s main passages. Moscow and Ganjoor add a royal victory cry, also actually printed in Khaleghi’s local apparatus. That extra unit is registered separately rather than silently assigned to the English’s final couplet. The ending therefore follows a verified shorter sequence without suppressing the fuller witnesses.
Source record and limits
C3.32 only:12 English couplets/24 lines plus source-only rowS1. Moscow V193–194:1871–1883(13 main units);Mohl III286–287:1903–1913(PDF292–293;11 main units);Ganjoor12rokh sh24:1–13(13 body units);Khaleghi IV120–121:1884–1895(PDF136–137;12 main units). English4 groups Moscow1874–1875/Ganjoor4–5/Khaleghi1887–1888;Mohl1905–1906 is the checked local gap for the separate advance unit. English8–9 share Moscow1879/Mohl1910/Ganjoor9/Khaleghi1892,each counted once in source coverage. S1 is Moscow1883/Ganjoor13 and actual Khaleghi121n6;Mohl1913–1914 checked local gap.
Inspection order:Moscow V193–194 PNG and Mohl III286–287 PNG individually first;then Ganjoor sh24 body and Khaleghi IV120–121 PNG. Existing PDFs reused. Same-file offsets verified:Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.
- F&R English: 12 verbatim couplets/24 lines. Published index/title/boundaries verified against current live poem. Exact capture from retained same-day HTML. Next C3.33 Rohham Battles Barman.
- Moscow: V193–194:1871–1883;13 unique main units.1874–1875 grouped at English4;1879 shared at English8–9;1883 source-only. Actual194n5 evil-day variants.
- Mohl: III286–287:1903–1913;11 unique main units.1910 shared at English8–9. Horse-first1907 and evil-day1909 in running text. Separate advance and final royal cry locally absent. PDF292–293.
- Ganjoor: sh24:1–13 body;13 unique units.4–5 grouped;9 shared;13 source-only. Thigh-first6 and never-born8. Prose/commentary excluded.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV120–121:1884–1895;12 unique main units.1887–1888 grouped;1892 shared. Evil-day1891 main. Actual121n6 prints royal cry outside main. PDF136–137.
All inherited provisional flags retained verbatim. New C3.32.3 local pronoun qualification:English He after nominative Turk can obscure Foruhil as the source’s archer;next couplet resolves the attack on Zangula. Horse-first English5 positively supported by Mohl1907;other three main texts thigh-first. Evil-day English7 supported by Mohl1909,Khaleghi1891 and actual Moscow194n5 variants. No new unverified reading relied upon. Running text,actual apparatus,appendix evidence,checked local gaps and unverified readings remain distinct. No appendix evidence invoked,no unprinted addition notice counted,no global absence claim.
First:Fourth, Foruhil and Zangula came to fight, Last:His heart rejoiced to gain the end he sought.. C3.33 Rohham Battles Barman opens Fifth,Rohham,son of Gudarz,took his place. Local openings verified:Moscow V194:1884;Mohl III287:1914(PDF293);Khaleghi IV121:1896(PDF137). Ganjoor sh25 candidate requires retrieval. Full C3.33 scope unchecked.
- Mohl III286:1907 main;horse-first — خدنگی بر اسبش برآمد چو باد / که بگذشت بر اسب و بر مرد شاد
- Moscow V194:1876 main;thigh-first — خدنگی به رانش برآمد چو باد
- Khaleghi IV120:1889 main;thigh-first — خدنگی به رانش برآمد چو باد
- Mohl III286:1909 main;evil-day birth — همانا که جز روز بد را نزاد
- Moscow V194n5 IV actual variant;evil-day birth — همانا که جز روز بد را نزاد
- Khaleghi IV121:1891 main;evil-day birth — همانا که جز روز بد را نزاد
- Ganjoor sh24:8 body;never-born — تو گفتی همانا ز مادر نزاد
- Moscow V194:1879 main;one unit for English8–9 — فروهل فروجست و ببرید سر / برون کرد خفتان رومی ز بر
- Moscow V194:1883 main;source-only cry — خروشید زان پس که پیروز باد / سر خسروان شاه فرخ نژاد
- Khaleghi IV121n6 actual addition;royal cry — خروشید زان پس که پیروز باد / سر خسروان شاه فرخ نژاد
C3.32 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V193:1871 running text | III286:1903 running text |
| 2 | V193:1872 running text | III286:1904 running text |
| 3 | V193:1873 running text | III286:1905 running text |
| 4 | V193:1874,1875 running text | III286:1906 running text;checked local gap1905–1906 for separate shaft-drawing/advance unit |
| 5 | V194:1876 running text;thigh first | III286:1907 running text;horse first |
| 6 | V194:1877 running text | III286:1908 running text |
| 7 | V194:1878 running text;as if never born;actual V194n5 IV/VI evil-day variants | III286:1909 running text;evil-day birth |
| 8 | V194:1879 running text;shared by English8–9 | III286:1910 running text;shared by English8–9 |
| 9 | V194:1879 running text;shared by English8–9 | III286:1910 running text;shared by English8–9 |
| 10 | V194:1880 running text | III287:1911 running text |
| 11 | V194:1881 running text | III287:1912 running text |
| 12 | V194:1882 running text | III287:1913 running text |
New Naqqali