How Zangeh, Son of Shavaran, Battles Awkhast
20 verbatim couplets/40 lines. Published index/title/boundaries verified. Retained same-day HTML capture compared with live poem. Next C3.37 Gorgin Battles Andariman.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 20 verbatim couplets/40 lines. |
| Moscow | V198–199:1930–1949;20 unique main units. Lineage wording1931;thirst1936;horses’ feet bound1939;ascent1947. No sword specified1938. |
| Mohl | III289–290:1957–1976;20 unique main units. Direct Awkhast naming1958;thirst1963;horses’ feet bound1966;ascent1974. No sword specified1965. PDF295–296. |
| Ganjoor | sh28:1–20 body;20 unique units. Lineage2;thirst7;hobbling10;ascent18. No sword specified9. Prose/commentary excluded. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV124–125:1939–1958;20 unique main units.124n24 lineage,125n5 tired and125n14 bound-feet actual variants. Main1948 sits down;1956 ascends. No sword specified1947. PDF140–141. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5A duel that exhausts the horses
English 1–5;individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V198:1930 running text · Mohl III289:1957 running text · Khaleghi IV124:1939 running text · Ganjoor sh28:1 poem body · Moscow V198:1931 running text;of Awkhast’s stock · Mohl III289:1958 running text;names Awkhast directly · Khaleghi IV124:1940 running text;bakht main;actual IV124n24 tokhm variant · Ganjoor sh28:2 poem body · Moscow V198:1932 running text · Mohl III289:1959 running text · Khaleghi IV124:1941 running text · Ganjoor sh28:3 poem body · Moscow V198:1933 running text · Mohl III289:1960 running text · Khaleghi IV125:1942 running text · Ganjoor sh28:4 poem body · Moscow V198:1934 running text · Mohl III289:1961 running text · Khaleghi IV125:1943 running text · Ganjoor sh28:5 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh agree on Zangeh’s place as the eighth champion and on the heavy maces, prolonged pounding and exhausted horses. English preserves the unusually physical image of veins that seem unable to stir, giving the mounts’ collapse more force than a general statement of fatigue. Its gorzes keep the encounter’s opening weapon distinct from the spears used later. The opponent’s introduction varies: Mohl directly names Awkhast, while Moscow and Ganjoor describe his stock or lineage. Khaleghi prints a different first-hemistich reading and records the lineage word in its actual apparatus. English follows Mohl’s straightforward identification. Its long years of strife infer a veteran’s history from the claim that he had never drawn back from battle; they are not separately narrated years.
6–10Thirst, a truce and the horses’ feet
English 6–10;individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V198:1935 running text · Mohl III289:1962 running text · Khaleghi IV125:1944 running text · Ganjoor sh28:6 poem body · Moscow V198:1936 running text · Mohl III289:1963 running text · Khaleghi IV125:1945 running text;thirsty main;actual IV125n5 tired variant · Ganjoor sh28:7 poem body · Moscow V198:1937 running text · Mohl III289:1964 running text · Khaleghi IV125:1946 running text · Ganjoor sh28:8 poem body · Moscow V198:1938 running text;return to battle,no sword specified · Mohl III289:1965 running text;return to battle,no sword specified · Khaleghi IV125:1947 running text;return to battle,no sword specified · Ganjoor sh28:9 poem body · Moscow V198:1939 running text;bound horses’ feet · Mohl III289:1966 running text;bound horses’ feet · Khaleghi IV125:1948 running text;sat down main;actual IV125n14 bound-feet variant · Ganjoor sh28:10 poem body
The iron-hot plain, burning liver and negotiated rest occur in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh. English preserves the bodily heat but generalizes the warriors’ expressly stated thirst into exhaustion; Khaleghi’s apparatus also records a tired reading. The distinction matters because the rest responds to physical limits shared by enemies. All four main texts propose returning to battle, without specifying a sword. English supplies that weapon, although the resumed action uses spears. This specificity remains flagged rather than silently repaired. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor then bind the horses’ feet. Khaleghi’s running text instead has the men sit down; its actual apparatus prints the bound-feet variant. Thus the English hobbling has direct primary support and additional printed apparatus support, not four identical running-text attestations.
11–15Renewed combat and the spear strike
English 11–15;individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V198:1940 running text · Mohl III289:1967 running text · Khaleghi IV125:1949 running text · Ganjoor sh28:11 poem body · Moscow V198:1941 running text · Mohl III289:1968 running text · Khaleghi IV125:1950 running text · Ganjoor sh28:12 poem body · Moscow V198:1942 running text · Mohl III289:1969 running text · Khaleghi IV125:1951 running text · Ganjoor sh28:13 poem body · Moscow V198:1943 running text · Mohl III289:1970 running text · Khaleghi IV125:1952 running text · Ganjoor sh28:14 poem body · Moscow V198:1944 running text · Mohl III289:1971 running text · Khaleghi IV125:1953 running text · Ganjoor sh28:15 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all resume the duel after rest, describe fiery mounted movement with a spear, and give Zangeh his opening. English’s plural riders makes the renewed exchange reciprocal before the narrative concentrates on Zangeh’s thrust. The blow at the waist and headlong fall preserve the decisive action in all four accounts. The following thunderlike cry and apparent rending of the field are likewise shared. Persian does not repeat the crier’s personal name in that unit; English’s continuous he keeps the shout attached to the attacking figure without adding an explicit speaker identification. The field’s apparent rupture functions as an image of overwhelming sound. The English’s seemed appropriately retains that comparison, preventing a literal reading that the ground physically split beneath the combatants.
16–20The trophy and the wolf banner
English 16–20;individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V198:1945 running text · Mohl III289:1972 running text · Khaleghi IV125:1954 running text · Ganjoor sh28:16 poem body · Moscow V198:1946 running text;onto saddle,no explicit binding · Mohl III289:1973 running text;onto saddle,no explicit binding · Khaleghi IV125:1955 running text;onto saddle,no explicit binding · Ganjoor sh28:17 poem body · Moscow V199:1947 running text;took height,not rein · Mohl III290:1974 running text;took height,not rein · Khaleghi IV125:1956 running text;took height,not rein · Ganjoor sh28:18 poem body · Moscow V199:1948 running text · Mohl III290:1975 running text · Khaleghi IV125:1957 running text · Ganjoor sh28:19 poem body · Moscow V199:1949 running text · Mohl III290:1976 running text · Khaleghi IV125:1958 running text · Ganjoor sh28:20 poem body
All four sources carry the fallen opponent through the hot dust face-first and cast him head-down onto the saddle. English preserves that harsh sequence, but its binding is additional practical detail: the local Persian unit does not explicitly tie him. Similarly, English next takes the rein where Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh say that the remounted victor takes the height or ascends. The checked local apparatus supplies no rein reading. English postpones explicit ascent to the following couplet, where all four present the mountain and wolf-emblazoned banner. Its astonishment at Turan’s fate preserves the narrative interruption between bodily handling and public triumph. Finally, crown stands for the king and high renown replaces the pahlavan’s territorial designation; the return among companions and the twofold blessing remain intact.
Source record and limits
C3.36 only:20 English couplets/40 lines. Moscow V198–199:1930–1949(20 main units);Mohl III289–290:1957–1976(PDF295–296;20 main units);Ganjoor12rokh sh28:1–20(20 body units);Khaleghi IV124–125:1939–1958(PDF140–141;20 main units). Direct one-to-one mapping;no shared or source-only main units,no checked local gaps. Khaleghi actual124n24 lineage variant,125n5 tired variant and125n14 bound-feet variant inspected. English10 hobbling is Moscow1939/Mohl1966/Ganjoor10 main and Khaleghi125n14 actual apparatus;Khaleghi1948 main instead sits down.
Inspection order:Moscow V198–199 PNG and Mohl III289–290 PNG individually first;then Ganjoor sh28 body and Khaleghi IV124–125 PNG. Existing PDFs reused. Same-file offsets verified:Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.
- F&R English: 20 verbatim couplets/40 lines. Published index/title/boundaries verified. Retained same-day HTML capture compared with live poem. Next C3.37 Gorgin Battles Andariman.
- Moscow: V198–199:1930–1949;20 unique main units. Lineage wording1931;thirst1936;horses’ feet bound1939;ascent1947. No sword specified1938.
- Mohl: III289–290:1957–1976;20 unique main units. Direct Awkhast naming1958;thirst1963;horses’ feet bound1966;ascent1974. No sword specified1965. PDF295–296.
- Ganjoor: sh28:1–20 body;20 unique units. Lineage2;thirst7;hobbling10;ascent18. No sword specified9. Prose/commentary excluded.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV124–125:1939–1958;20 unique main units.124n24 lineage,125n5 tired and125n14 bound-feet actual variants. Main1948 sits down;1956 ascends. No sword specified1947. PDF140–141.
All inherited provisional flags retained verbatim. NEW C3.36 qualifications:English9 sword specificity has no support in the checked four main texts or relevant printed apparatus;all say return to battle,followed by spear combat. English17 binding is supplied practical detail,not explicit in the local unit. English18 rein replaces took height/ascended in all four main texts;no rein variant found in checked local apparatus. Preserve these English readings verbatim and retain these qualifications in subsequent checkpoints. English7 generalizes thirst;Khaleghi125n5 tired variant noted. Running text,actual apparatus,appendix evidence,checked local gaps and unverified readings remain distinct. No appendix invoked,no unprinted addition notice counted,no global absence claim.
First:Eighth, Zangeh, son of Shavaran, rode out Last:And blessed the Pahlevan of high renown.. C3.37 Gorgin Battles Andariman opens Gorgin rode ninth to claim revenge in fight. Moscow V199:1950 and Mohl III290:1977(PDF296) local openings inspected;Khaleghi heading at IV125(PDF141) only. Ganjoor sh29 candidate not retrieved;full C3.37 scope unchecked.
- Mohl III289:1958 main;direct opponent identification — هماورد او را چو اوخاست بود
- Moscow V198:1931 main;lineage wording — که همرزمش از تخم اوخواست بود
- Khaleghi IV124n24 actual variant;lineage word — تخم
- Moscow V198:1936 main;thirst — چنان تشنه گشتند کز جای خویش
- Khaleghi IV125n5 actual variant;tired — خسته
- Mohl III289:1965 main;return to battle — پس آنگه سوی جنگ باز آمدن
- Moscow V198:1939 main;horses’ feet bound — فراز آوریدند و بستند پای
- Khaleghi IV125:1948 main;sitting down — فرازآوریدند و نشستند روی
- Khaleghi IV125n14 actual variant;bound feet — و بستند پای
- Mohl III290:1974 main;ascent — نشست از بر اسب بالا گرفت
- Moscow V199:1948 main;wolf banner — یکی گرگ پیکر درفشی بدست
C3.36 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V198:1930 running text | III289:1957 running text |
| 2 | V198:1931 running text;of Awkhast’s stock | III289:1958 running text;names Awkhast directly |
| 3 | V198:1932 running text | III289:1959 running text |
| 4 | V198:1933 running text | III289:1960 running text |
| 5 | V198:1934 running text | III289:1961 running text |
| 6 | V198:1935 running text | III289:1962 running text |
| 7 | V198:1936 running text | III289:1963 running text |
| 8 | V198:1937 running text | III289:1964 running text |
| 9 | V198:1938 running text;return to battle,no sword specified | III289:1965 running text;return to battle,no sword specified |
| 10 | V198:1939 running text;bound horses’ feet | III289:1966 running text;bound horses’ feet |
| 11 | V198:1940 running text | III289:1967 running text |
| 12 | V198:1941 running text | III289:1968 running text |
| 13 | V198:1942 running text | III289:1969 running text |
| 14 | V198:1943 running text | III289:1970 running text |
| 15 | V198:1944 running text | III289:1971 running text |
| 16 | V198:1945 running text | III289:1972 running text |
| 17 | V198:1946 running text;onto saddle,no explicit binding | III289:1973 running text;onto saddle,no explicit binding |
| 18 | V199:1947 running text;took height,not rein | III290:1974 running text;took height,not rein |
| 19 | V199:1948 running text | III290:1975 running text |
| 20 | V199:1949 running text | III290:1976 running text |
New Naqqali