Gorgin Battles Andariman
13 verbatim couplets/26 lines. Published index/title/boundaries verified. Retained same-day HTML capture compared with live poem. Next C3.38 Borteh Battles Kuhram.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 13 verbatim couplets/26 lines. |
| Moscow | V199:1950–1962;13 unique main units. Kark shields1953–1954;head/chest1955. Actual199n9 VI breast,n11 VI head;n19 IV alternative close.1957/1959 shared across English rows. |
| Mohl | III290:1977–1989;13 unique main units. Gorg shields1980–1981;breast/head1982 with Roman helmet;faces1981.1984/1986 shared across English rows. PDF296. |
| Ganjoor | sh29:1–13 body;13 unique units. Kark shields4–5;head/chest6.8/10 shared across English rows. Prose/commentary excluded. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV126:1959–1971;13 unique main units. Gorg shields1962–1963;shield/head1964;actual126n10 breast and126n11 Roman/chest variants.1966/1968 shared across English rows. PDF142. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Broken spears and the disputed shield material
English 1–5;individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V199:1950 running text · Mohl III290:1977 running text · Khaleghi IV126:1959 running text · Ganjoor sh29:1 poem body · Moscow V199:1951 running text · Mohl III290:1978 running text · Khaleghi IV126:1960 running text · Ganjoor sh29:2 poem body · Moscow V199:1952 running text · Mohl III290:1979 running text · Khaleghi IV126:1961 running text · Ganjoor sh29:3 poem body · Moscow V199:1953 running text;kark shield · Mohl III290:1980 running text;gorg shield · Khaleghi IV126:1962 running text;gorg shield · Ganjoor sh29:4 poem body · Moscow V199:1954 running text;kark shield · Mohl III290:1981 running text;gorg shield · Khaleghi IV126:1963 running text;gorg shield · Ganjoor sh29:5 poem body · Dehkhoda,kark-espar:material and disputed wolf reading
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh agree on the ninth duel, the experienced opponents, broken spear combat and the change to bows. English makes the broken object the shafts, producing a clear transition between weapons. All four then give arrow rain and a hail comparison, but the shield wording needs qualification. Mohl and Khaleghi print gorg forms, compatible on their face with the English wolf reading; Moscow and Ganjoor print kark. Dehkhoda’s entry for kark-espar identifies a rhinoceros-hide shield and expressly disputes the wolf reading of this very phrase. Printed spelling therefore cannot alone certify the material intended. The English’s wolf-skin remains unchanged but carries that lexical qualification. In the next couplet, faces follows Mohl’s wording, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor refer to the Turk and helmet, and Khaleghi to headgear. English keeps the defensive action visible while selecting among these details.
6–9Breast, head and shield in the first arrow strike
English 6–9;individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V199:1955 running text;head/chest main;actual V199n9 VI breast and n11 VI head variants · Mohl III290:1982 running text;breast/head main,Roman helmet · Khaleghi IV126:1964 running text;shield/head main;actual IV126n10 breast and IV126n11 Roman/chest variants · Ganjoor sh29:6 poem body · Moscow V199:1956,1957 running text · Mohl III290:1983,1984 running text · Khaleghi IV126:1965,1966 running text · Ganjoor sh29:7,sh29:8 poem body · Moscow V199:1957 running text · Mohl III290:1984 running text · Khaleghi IV126:1966 running text · Ganjoor sh29:8 poem body · Moscow V199:1958 running text · Mohl III290:1985 running text · Khaleghi IV126:1967 running text · Ganjoor sh29:9 poem body
The English first arrow combines readings distributed across the editions. Mohl sends the shaft into the breast but then fastens the Roman helmet to the head. Moscow and Ganjoor begin with the head but end with the breast; Moscow’s actual apparatus also prints the breast variant for the first hemistich. Khaleghi’s main text instead starts at the shield and joins helmet, shield and head; its apparatus prints breast and Roman-helmet alternatives. Thus the English breast-to-chest description has printed support, but no identical running couplet in these four accounts establishes that entire formulation. The commentary records the combination without reconstructing a Persian couplet to match it. All four then give reeling, a second arrow, the fall, blood from the eyes and beheading. English anticipates the fall in its second-arrow couplet, so the register shares that source unit with the following English couplet and counts it only once.
10–13The severed head and victorious return
English 10–13;individual edition locators and evidence classes below.
Moscow V199:1959 running text · Mohl III290:1986 running text · Khaleghi IV126:1968 running text · Ganjoor sh29:10 poem body · Moscow V199:1959,1960 running text · Mohl III290:1986,1987 running text · Khaleghi IV126:1968,1969 running text;bow at arm,without explicit string wording · Ganjoor sh29:10,sh29:11 poem body · Moscow V199:1961 running text · Mohl III290:1988 running text · Khaleghi IV126:1970 running text · Ganjoor sh29:12 poem body · Moscow V199:1962 running text · Mohl III290:1989 running text · Khaleghi IV126:1971 running text · Ganjoor sh29:13 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh bind the trophy to the saddle straps and have Gorgin remount. English makes the severed head the explicit object, resolving the Persian’s carried-over referent. It moves the accompanying horse or rein detail into the ascent couplet, so the register shares that source unit across the two English couplets. The bow remains at the arm; Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor explicitly retain string wording, while Khaleghi’s main text does not. The English’s taut still gives that readiness a sustained visual emphasis. All four attribute success to divine strength or refuge and royal fortune before the victorious return and heart-lighting banner. English adds shield to the refuge metaphor. Moscow’s apparatus prints an alternative two-couplet close, kept distinct from the running text rather than counted as omitted English material.
Source record and limits
C3.37 only:13 English couplets/26 lines. Moscow V199:1950–1962(13 main units);Mohl III290:1977–1989(PDF296;13 main units);Ganjoor12rokh sh29:1–13(13 body units);Khaleghi IV126:1959–1971(PDF142;13 main units). Source8 shared acrossEnglish7–8 for anticipated fall;source10 shared acrossEnglish10–11 for moved horse/rein clause. Each counted once in unique source coverage. No source-only main units,no local gaps. English6:Mohl1982 breast/head;Moscow1955 and Ganjoor6 head/chest;Khaleghi1964 shield/head. Actual Moscow199n9 VI breast,n11 VI head;Khaleghi126n10 breast and126n11 Roman/chest variants inspected.
Inspection order:Moscow V199 PNG and Mohl III290 PNG individually first;then Ganjoor sh29 body and Khaleghi IV126 PNG. Existing PDFs reused. Same-file offsets verified:Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.
- F&R English: 13 verbatim couplets/26 lines. Published index/title/boundaries verified. Retained same-day HTML capture compared with live poem. Next C3.38 Borteh Battles Kuhram.
- Moscow: V199:1950–1962;13 unique main units. Kark shields1953–1954;head/chest1955. Actual199n9 VI breast,n11 VI head;n19 IV alternative close.1957/1959 shared across English rows.
- Mohl: III290:1977–1989;13 unique main units. Gorg shields1980–1981;breast/head1982 with Roman helmet;faces1981.1984/1986 shared across English rows. PDF296.
- Ganjoor: sh29:1–13 body;13 unique units. Kark shields4–5;head/chest6.8/10 shared across English rows. Prose/commentary excluded.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV126:1959–1971;13 unique main units. Gorg shields1962–1963;shield/head1964;actual126n10 breast and126n11 Roman/chest variants.1966/1968 shared across English rows. PDF142.
All inherited provisional flags retained verbatim,including C3.36.9 sword,C3.36.17 binding and C3.36.18 rein. NEW C3.37 qualifications:English4–5 wolf-skin has visible gorg spelling support in Mohl/Khaleghi but remains lexically contested;Moscow/Ganjoor kark and Dehkhoda kark-espar identify rhinoceros hide and dispute wolf. English6 combines breast first-hemistich support from Mohl/actual apparatus with chest second-hemistich support from Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi apparatus;do not describe this as an identical four-source running reading. Printed support does not resolve the physical trajectory. Preserve English verbatim. Moscow199n19 IV actually prints an alternative two-couplet close;not running text. Running text,actual apparatus,appendix evidence,checked local gaps and unverified readings remain distinct. No appendix invoked,no unprinted addition notice counted,no global absence claim.
Dehkhoda: kark-espar:lexical evidence for rhinoceros-hide and explicit dispute of wolf reading;not a fifth Persian edition.
First:Gorgin rode ninth to claim revenge in fight, Last:And raised his banner, filling hearts with light.. C3.38 Borteh Battles Kuhram opens In the tenth fight two leaders met as foes. Mohl III290:1990(PDF296) and Khaleghi IV126:1972(PDF142) local openings inspected;Moscow next page and Ganjoor sh30 not yet checked. Full C3.38 scope unchecked.
- Mohl III290:1982 main;breast strike — یکی تیر گرگین بزد بر برش
- Mohl III290:1982 main;Roman helmet/head — که بردوخت با ترگ رومی سرش
- Moscow V199:1955 main;head strike — یکی تیر گرگین بزد بر سرش
- Moscow V199:1955 main;Roman helmet/chest — که بر دوخت با ترگ رومی برش
- Moscow V199n9 VI actual variant;breast — برش
- Khaleghi IV126:1964 main;shield strike — یکی تیر گرگین بزد بر سپرش
- Khaleghi IV126:1964 main;helmet/shield/head — که با ترگ و با گرگ بردوخت سرش
- Khaleghi IV126n10 actual variant;breast — برش
- Khaleghi IV126n11 actual variant;Roman helmet/chest — که با ترگ بردوخت رومی برش
- Ganjoor sh29:4 body;kark shield — به روی اندر آورده کرگ اسپران
- Khaleghi IV126:1962 main;gorg spelling — به روی اندرآورده گرگاسپران
C3.37 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V199:1950 running text | III290:1977 running text |
| 2 | V199:1951 running text | III290:1978 running text |
| 3 | V199:1952 running text | III290:1979 running text |
| 4 | V199:1953 running text;kark shield | III290:1980 running text;gorg shield |
| 5 | V199:1954 running text;kark shield | III290:1981 running text;gorg shield |
| 6 | V199:1955 running text;head/chest main;actual V199n9 VI breast and n11 VI head variants | III290:1982 running text;breast/head main,Roman helmet |
| 7 | V199:1956,1957 running text | III290:1983,1984 running text |
| 8 | V199:1957 running text | III290:1984 running text |
| 9 | V199:1958 running text | III290:1985 running text |
| 10 | V199:1959 running text | III290:1986 running text |
| 11 | V199:1959,1960 running text | III290:1986,1987 running text |
| 12 | V199:1961 running text | III290:1988 running text |
| 13 | V199:1962 running text | III290:1989 running text |
New Naqqali