Giv’s Visit to Piran
42 verbatim couplets;published title Giv’s Visit to Piran;ends before C3.6 The Armies Are Set in Array.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | — |
| Moscow | V98–100:210–251 main;12,000 at217;actual98n13 cry,98n14 ney,98n15 number,99n5 Iran,99n14 rider/blood-river. Pursuit250 main. |
| Mohl | III215–217:211–252 main;full musical217–218,110,000 at219,Iran227/234,blood-river235,battle-death248. Local pursuit gap251–252. |
| Ganjoor | 12rokh sh4:64–105 poem body. Shorter musical unit70;12,000 at71;Turan86;cruelty87;pursuit104. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV16–18:210–251 plus IV19:266 relocated pursuit main.110,000 at218;Iran226/233;blood-river234. Actual16n23,17n1/24 variants. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Bitter words travel toward the opposing camp
English 1–5;individual source accounts and inspected page links. Running text,actual apparatus,relocated running text and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V98:210 running text · Moscow V98:211 running text · Moscow V98:212 running text · Moscow V98:213 running text · Moscow V98:214 running text · Mohl III215:211 running text · Mohl III216:212 running text · Mohl III216:213 running text · Mohl III216:214 running text · Mohl III216:215 running text · Khaleghi IV16:210 running text · Khaleghi IV16:211 running text · Khaleghi IV16:212 running text · Khaleghi IV16:213 running text · Khaleghi IV16:214 running text · Ganjoor sh4:64 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:65 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:66 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:67 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:68 poem body
All four begin with Giv carrying his father’s bitter words to Balkh, preserving the emotional character of the message before any reply is heard. English makes his continued remembrance explicit, so the instructions remain a burden carried through the journey. The halt, dispatched messenger and nighttime assembly then establish an orderly diplomatic approach. English riding hard intensifies the travel, while the banners around Piran add visible military staging not separately named in the corresponding source unit. Piran’s interest in Iran’s crown and throne is nevertheless shared by all four. That ambition stands behind the meeting before he speaks. The envoy’s arrival and view of the troops therefore connect the remembered words of negotiation with a force already directed toward a rival political claim.
6–10The summons and its competing troop totals
English 6–10;individual source accounts and inspected page links. Running text,actual apparatus,relocated running text and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V98:215 running text · Moscow V98:216 running text;actual98n13 cry variant · Moscow V98:216 running text;actual98n14 full ney unit;local main gap216–217 for separate unit · Moscow V98:217 running text;actual98n15 number variant · Moscow V98:218 running text · Mohl III216:216 running text · Mohl III216:217 running text · Mohl III216:218 running text · Mohl III216:219 running text · Mohl III216:220 running text · Khaleghi IV16:215 running text · Khaleghi IV16:216 running text;actual16n23 koust variant · Khaleghi IV16:217 running text · Khaleghi IV17:218 running text;actual17n1 number variant · Khaleghi IV17:219 running text · Ganjoor sh4:69 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:70 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:70 poem body;hoof-blackening only;separate ney unit absent locally70–71 · Ganjoor sh4:71 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:72 poem body
The musical summons and troop count require distinctions between main text and apparatus. Mohl gives the warriors’ cry and then a separate brazen-ney couplet; Khaleghi also preserves that fuller sequence. Moscow’s main unit joins the summons to hoof-blackened earth, while its actual apparatus records both the cry and the additional musical unit. Ganjoor follows the shorter sequence. English preserves the fuller soundscape but leaves out the second unit’s renewed fastening of the koust. The ensuing hundred and ten thousand is printed in Mohl and Khaleghi and appears in Moscow’s apparatus; Moscow and Ganjoor main instead give twelve thousand. English therefore follows an attested large total. Its division into two-thirds left behind interprets the shared two-part formula, without turning either troop total into independently verified history.
11–15Negotiation takes place behind a wall of spears
English 11–15;individual source accounts and inspected page links. Running text,actual apparatus,relocated running text and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V98:219 running text · Moscow V98:220 running text · Moscow V98:221 running text · Moscow V98:222 running text · Moscow V99:223 running text · Mohl III216:221 running text · Mohl III216:222 running text · Mohl III216:223 running text · Mohl III216:224 running text · Mohl III216:225 running text · Khaleghi IV17:220 running text · Khaleghi IV17:221 running text · Khaleghi IV17:222 running text · Khaleghi IV17:223 running text · Khaleghi IV17:224 running text · Ganjoor sh4:73 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:74 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:75 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:76 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:77 poem body
All four put Piran’s force on Jihun’s bank and make the spears a wall when the commanders meet. English adds a clear arrangement from front to rear, developing military order while retaining the striking barrier image. Two weeks of discussion then interrupt the momentum toward battle. The sources describe the desired avoidance of an unjust war; English needless fight emphasizes avoidability, slightly reducing the explicit moral accusation carried by the adjective. The next line restores a strong moral verdict when Turanian guilt emerges. English makes that finding impossible to deny, which is firmer than simply saying it became apparent. The Iranian leaders’ subsequent advantage is rhetorical: they press the opportunity to speak. English makes the weakened position of their opponents explicit without inventing a victory in arms.
16–20Piran reports upward and pledges his life
English 16–20;individual source accounts and inspected page links. Running text,actual apparatus,relocated running text and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V99:224 running text · Moscow V99:225 running text;actual99n5 Iran variant · Moscow V99:226 running text · Moscow V99:227 running text · Moscow V99:228 running text · Mohl III216:226 running text · Mohl III216:227 running text · Mohl III216:228 running text · Mohl III216:229 running text · Mohl III216:230 running text · Khaleghi IV17:225 running text · Khaleghi IV17:226 running text · Khaleghi IV17:227 running text · Khaleghi IV17:228 running text · Khaleghi IV17:229 running text · Ganjoor sh4:78 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:79 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:80 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:81 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:82 poem body
The dispatch to Afrasiab turns the local encounter into a decision for the ruler. All four preserve Piran’s report of Gudarz’s authority and the arrival of his chosen son. The seat named in the report varies: Mohl and Khaleghi explicitly give Iran’s throne, while Moscow and Ganjoor use the warriors’ throne formulation. Actual Moscow apparatus also preserves Iran. English follows that specific national reading, making the reported authority unmistakable. Piran then binds hearing, attention and life to Afrasiab’s command. English loyalty expresses the pledge plainly, though the Persian makes the life itself a hostage to the covenant. That promise anticipates his later refusal to surrender relatives as hostages. The ruler’s choice of reinforcements follows the report, moving the narrative from negotiation toward military reassurance.
21–25Reinforcement carries a command to destroy
English 21–25;individual source accounts and inspected page links. Running text,actual apparatus,relocated running text and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V99:229 running text · Moscow V99:230 running text · Moscow V99:231 running text · Moscow V99:232 running text · Moscow V99:233 running text;actual99n14 full rider/blood-river variant · Mohl III216:231 running text · Mohl III216:232 running text · Mohl III216:233 running text · Mohl III216:234 running text · Mohl III216:235 running text · Khaleghi IV17:230 running text · Khaleghi IV17:231 running text · Khaleghi IV17:232 running text · Khaleghi IV17:233 running text · Khaleghi IV17:234 running text;actual17n24 cruelty variant · Ganjoor sh4:83 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:84 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:85 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:86 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:87 poem body
All four send thirty thousand selected sword-bearing riders and accompany them with an exterminating command. English makes the sweep of clearing the earth explicit through the demand that no enemy survive, then retains the named targets while rearranging their order. The explanation for this response differs in its political object. Mohl and Khaleghi give Iran’s throne as the attackers’ aim; Moscow and Ganjoor give Turan’s seat. English Iran’s victory follows the former orientation but converts a throne claim into success in battle. The next threat also follows Mohl and Khaleghi: Turanian riders will make Iran run with blood. Moscow’s main text instead announces cruelty and impatience for bloodshed, but its actual apparatus prints the complete rider-and-blood-river alternative. The English’s sharper scene thus has direct textual support.
26–30New strength changes Piran’s judgment
English 26–30;individual source accounts and inspected page links. Running text,actual apparatus,relocated running text and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V99:234 running text · Moscow V99:235 running text · Moscow V99:236 running text · Moscow V99:237 running text · Moscow V99:238 running text · Mohl III216:236 running text · Mohl III217:237 running text · Mohl III217:238 running text · Mohl III217:239 running text · Mohl III217:240 running text · Khaleghi IV17:235 running text · Khaleghi IV18:236 running text · Khaleghi IV18:237 running text · Khaleghi IV18:238 running text · Khaleghi IV18:239 running text · Ganjoor sh4:88 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:89 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:90 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:91 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:92 poem body
The ruler’s boast about raising dust against Khosrow leads into the sight of the reinforcing army. All four compare those fighters to bloodthirsty wolves and connect Piran’s altered conduct with his new strength. English preserves that causal sequence: military confidence precedes the moral reversal. Its honor and spite concentrate the broader source contrast between virtues and faults into a recognizable loss of standing and a hostile choice. Mohl describes the formerly wise-minded heart, whereas Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi describe its former good nature; English once-kind follows the latter reading. The change is consequently more than an order mechanically obeyed. The narrative depicts an inward surrender to warfare. Piran’s instruction that Giv return to Gudarz then makes the failed diplomacy visible through the envoy’s dismissal.
31–35The hostage demand becomes an assault on kinship
English 31–35;individual source accounts and inspected page links. Running text,actual apparatus,relocated running text and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V99:239 running text · Moscow V99:240 running text · Moscow V100:241 running text · Moscow V100:242 running text · Moscow V100:243 running text · Mohl III217:241 running text · Mohl III217:242 running text · Mohl III217:243 running text · Mohl III217:244 running text · Mohl III217:245 running text · Khaleghi IV18:240 running text · Khaleghi IV18:241 running text · Khaleghi IV18:242 running text · Khaleghi IV18:243 running text · Khaleghi IV18:244 running text · Ganjoor sh4:93 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:94 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:95 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:96 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:97 poem body
Piran begins his reply by invoking what wise people could approve, making judgment itself the ground of resistance. All four reject the surrender of noble leaders and then enumerate the demanded resources and family members. English throne agrees with Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor where Khaleghi lists treasure in that position. The brother who lights Piran’s world and the chosen son turn the political terms into intimate losses. English light of soul internalizes the brother’s value, while the singular brother follows the reply’s own wording even though the previous demand named two. That asymmetry should remain visible rather than be repaired by harmonization. The repeated appeal to wisdom closes the passage by branding the proposal crude, presenting refusal as rational dignity as well as familial attachment.
36–40Death is preferable to nominal command
English 36–40;individual source accounts and inspected page links. Running text,actual apparatus,relocated running text and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V100:244 running text · Moscow V100:245 running text · Moscow V100:246 running text · Moscow V100:247 running text · Moscow V100:248 running text · Mohl III217:246 running text · Mohl III217:247 running text · Mohl III217:248 running text · Mohl III217:249 running text · Mohl III217:250 running text · Khaleghi IV18:245 running text · Khaleghi IV18:246 running text · Khaleghi IV18:247 running text · Khaleghi IV18:248 running text · Khaleghi IV18:249 running text · Ganjoor sh4:98 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:99 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:100 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:101 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:102 poem body
All four expose the contradiction of remaining a chief while accepting bondage. English chief in name clarifies the difference between a retained title and lost independence, then preserves the leopard and lion as the speakers of the supporting proverb. The formulation of death differs: Mohl explicitly locates the killing in battle, whereas Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi emphasize name or honor against a life of disgrace. English follows Mohl’s battle wording while retaining the shared rejection of dishonor. Piran finally adds the king’s command and the arriving army as another reason for war. That final appeal does not erase his preceding personal argument. Giv’s departure with his force closes the exchange without a negotiated settlement or an additional promise that the sources do not provide.
41–42The encampment closes a broken embassy
English 41–42;individual source accounts and inspected page links. Running text,actual apparatus,relocated running text and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V100:249 running text · Moscow V100:250 running text;pursuit before Kanabad · Moscow V100:251 running text · Mohl III217:251 running text · Mohl III217:251–252 checked local main gap;battle intent proceeds to Kanabad · Mohl III217:252 running text · Khaleghi IV18:250 running text · Khaleghi IV19:266 relocated running text;pursuit after Giv’s return report;actual18n28 and19n25 placement notes · Khaleghi IV18:251 running text · Ganjoor sh4:103 poem body · Ganjoor sh4:104 poem body;pursuit before Kanabad · Ganjoor sh4:105 poem body
After Giv leaves, all four turn Piran toward battle and place his force beneath the mountain at the named encampment. English expands the roaring intention into a call to arms and sounding alarms, making the transition audible. Moscow and Ganjoor insert a separate lion-like pursuit of Giv before that arrival. Mohl moves directly to the encampment, as does English. Khaleghi likewise omits the pursuit at this immediate junction but prints the actual couplet later, after Giv’s report to his father. That later running text was inspected directly; the placement notices alone were not used as proof of its wording. A source-only row preserves the difference without folding pursuit silently into English alarms. The chapter therefore ends with military positioning after the embassy’s failure, while the editions’ different narrative ordering remains recoverable.
Source record and limits
C3.5 only:42 English couplets. Moscow V98–100:210–251 (42 main units);Mohl III215–217:211–252 (PDF221–223,42 main units);Ganjoor12rokh sh4:64–105 (42 main units);Khaleghi IV16–18:210–251 plus actual relocated IV19:266 (PDF32–35,43 main units). All declared units accounted. Source-only S1 preserves the pursuit;Moscow216/Ganjoor70 are shared across English7–8 with separately identified actual apparatus support.
The existing complete PDF source files were reused. Moscow V98–100 and Mohl III215–217 were read individually as PNG facsimiles first,then Ganjoor sh4 and Khaleghi IV16–19. All42 English couplets have primary-source accounts. Persian reference text is the named Ganjoor unit except the explicitly labeled Mohl217/218 musical pair. No transcript was reconstructed from English.
- F&R English: 42 verbatim couplets;published title Giv’s Visit to Piran;ends before C3.6 The Armies Are Set in Array.
- Moscow: V98–100:210–251 main;12,000 at217;actual98n13 cry,98n14 ney,98n15 number,99n5 Iran,99n14 rider/blood-river. Pursuit250 main.
- Mohl: III215–217:211–252 main;full musical217–218,110,000 at219,Iran227/234,blood-river235,battle-death248. Local pursuit gap251–252.
- Ganjoor: 12rokh sh4:64–105 poem body. Shorter musical unit70;12,000 at71;Turan86;cruelty87;pursuit104.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV16–18:210–251 plus IV19:266 relocated pursuit main.110,000 at218;Iran226/233;blood-river234. Actual16n23,17n1/24 variants.
Actual apparatus: Moscow98n13 prints the cry,98n14 the whole musical unit,98n15 the110,000 alternative,99n5 Iran,and99n14 the whole rider/blood-river alternative. Khaleghi16n23 records koust,17n1 the12,000 alternative,and17n24 the cruelty unit. Main and apparatus evidence are not interchangeable:the English’s large number and full musical sequence are directly in Mohl and Khaleghi main.
Source-only S1 preserves Moscow250/Ganjoor104 pursuit before the encampment. Mohl III217:251–252 passes directly from intent to encampment. Khaleghi IV18:250–251 does likewise locally,but actual IV19:266 prints the pursuit later after Giv’s return report. Its18n28 and19n25 notices establish editorial placement context,not wording by themselves.
Selected apparatus inspected,not exhaustive. No appendix evidence used. Khaleghi266 pursuit was read in actual relocated running text;18n28/19n25 notices are not substitutes for that inspection. Mohl III217:251–252 local gap checked;no edition-wide absence claimed. Moscow98n13/14/15,99n5/14 and Khaleghi16n23,17n1/24 distinguish variant words,numbers and full couplets from main readings. No new unverified reading counted positively;descriptive English amplification and interpreted troop proportions explicitly labeled. All inherited flags,including C3.4.55 Chakh,retained verbatim.
English begins Giv rode to Balkh, his father’s words in mind, and ends Below the mountain, with his gathered band.. These are boundary context only;Khaleghi266 is already accounted as a relocated source-only unit and must not be silently counted twice in a later cumulative scope.
Selected readings are bounded excerpts,not full diplomatic transcriptions. No historical troop census or independent geographical identification is claimed.
C3.5 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V98:210 running text | III215:211 running text |
| 2 | V98:211 running text | III216:212 running text |
| 3 | V98:212 running text | III216:213 running text |
| 4 | V98:213 running text | III216:214 running text |
| 5 | V98:214 running text | III216:215 running text |
| 6 | V98:215 running text | III216:216 running text |
| 7 | V98:216 running text;actual98n13 cry variant | III216:217 running text |
| 8 | V98:216 running text;actual98n14 full ney unit;local main gap216–217 for separate unit | III216:218 running text |
| 9 | V98:217 running text;actual98n15 number variant | III216:219 running text |
| 10 | V98:218 running text | III216:220 running text |
| 11 | V98:219 running text | III216:221 running text |
| 12 | V98:220 running text | III216:222 running text |
| 13 | V98:221 running text | III216:223 running text |
| 14 | V98:222 running text | III216:224 running text |
| 15 | V99:223 running text | III216:225 running text |
| 16 | V99:224 running text | III216:226 running text |
| 17 | V99:225 running text;actual99n5 Iran variant | III216:227 running text |
| 18 | V99:226 running text | III216:228 running text |
| 19 | V99:227 running text | III216:229 running text |
| 20 | V99:228 running text | III216:230 running text |
| 21 | V99:229 running text | III216:231 running text |
| 22 | V99:230 running text | III216:232 running text |
| 23 | V99:231 running text | III216:233 running text |
| 24 | V99:232 running text | III216:234 running text |
| 25 | V99:233 running text;actual99n14 full rider/blood-river variant | III216:235 running text |
| 26 | V99:234 running text | III216:236 running text |
| 27 | V99:235 running text | III217:237 running text |
| 28 | V99:236 running text | III217:238 running text |
| 29 | V99:237 running text | III217:239 running text |
| 30 | V99:238 running text | III217:240 running text |
| 31 | V99:239 running text | III217:241 running text |
| 32 | V99:240 running text | III217:242 running text |
| 33 | V100:241 running text | III217:243 running text |
| 34 | V100:242 running text | III217:244 running text |
| 35 | V100:243 running text | III217:245 running text |
| 36 | V100:244 running text | III217:246 running text |
| 37 | V100:245 running text | III217:247 running text |
| 38 | V100:246 running text | III217:248 running text |
| 39 | V100:247 running text | III217:249 running text |
| 40 | V100:248 running text | III217:250 running text |
| 41 | V100:249 running text | III217:251 running text |
| 42 | V100:251 running text | III217:252 running text |
New Naqqali