Bijan Urges Giv to Fight
53 verbatim couplets;Bijan Urges Giv to Fight;ends before C3.8 Houman Seeks Leave for Battle.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 53 verbatim couplets;Bijan Urges Giv to Fight;ends before C3.8 Houman Seeks Leave for Battle. |
| Moscow | V105–108:349–401;front359,mountain369,affirmative readiness375,blade/stone377;actual107n1 heaven,107n17 cold/battle. |
| Mohl | III221–223:347–399;rear357,heavens367,negative readiness373,snow/battle375,enemies395. Boundary corrected from inherited candidate349. |
| Ganjoor | 12rokh sh5:98–107 and sh6:1–43;front sh6:1,mountain11,affirmative readiness17,blade/stone19,Turks39. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV25–28:352–404;rear362,heavens372,negative readiness378,constriction/stone380;actual26n25 snow and related alternatives;enemies400. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Stillness rests on a tactical calculation
English 1–5;individual printed-source locators and linked evidence. Character speech,main text,actual apparatus and unverified spelling remain distinct.
Moscow V105:349 running text;V105:350 running text · Moscow V105:351 running text · Moscow V105:352 running text · Moscow V106:353 running text · Mohl III221:347 running text;III221:348 running text · Mohl III221:349 running text · Mohl III221:350 running text · Mohl III221:351 running text · Khaleghi IV25:352 running text;IV25:353 running text · Khaleghi IV25:354 running text · Khaleghi IV25:355 running text · Khaleghi IV25:356 running text · Ganjoor sh5:98 · Ganjoor sh5:99 · Ganjoor sh5:100 · Ganjoor sh5:101 · Ganjoor sh5:102
All four open with the armies facing one another and remaining silent for three days and nights. English redistributes the duration and the notable warriors into its first couplet, then joins the facing armies to the unspoken silence in the second. The suggestion of concealed will interprets what those silent lips withhold. Gudarz’s explanation immediately supplies a practical reason for delay: advancing would expose his rear. English calls that contemplated advance rash, making the tactical judgment overt. The empty-hand image becomes a prize of wind and dust, preserving the futility while adding visible battlefield matter. His subsequent search for a favorable hour generalizes the sources’ named sun and moon, but retains the conjunction of military caution and celestial reckoning.
6–10Both commanders wait for an opening
English 6–10;individual printed-source locators and linked evidence. Character speech,main text,actual apparatus and unverified spelling remain distinct.
Moscow V106:354 running text · Moscow V106:355 running text · Moscow V106:356 running text · Moscow V106:357 running text · Moscow V106:358 running text · Mohl III221:352 running text · Mohl III221:353 running text · Mohl III221:354 running text · Mohl III222:355 running text · Mohl III222:356 running text · Khaleghi IV25:357 running text · Khaleghi IV25:358 running text · Khaleghi IV25:359 running text · Khaleghi IV25:360 running text · Khaleghi IV25:361 running text · Ganjoor sh5:103 · Ganjoor sh5:104 · Ganjoor sh5:105 · Ganjoor sh5:106 · Ganjoor sh5:107
All four have Gudarz ask which day and whose movement will be favored, then seek a wind capable of driving dust into the riders’ eyes. English identifies those riders as hostile, clarifying the intended use of weather without inventing a new maneuver. Its tempest intensifies the wind-like advance that would follow. Piran meanwhile waits for anger to move his opponent. English wounded pride supplies a psychological cause that the sources leave unspecified. The anticipated attack has different textual emphasis: Moscow and Ganjoor describe an army coming behind the advancing army, while Mohl and Khaleghi explicitly name the ambush brought into the route. English combines the exposed rear with hidden troops. That account is tactically intelligible, while its precise staging remains an interpretation of the coordinated threat.
11–15Bijan turns waiting into an accusation
English 11–15;individual printed-source locators and linked evidence. Character speech,main text,actual apparatus and unverified spelling remain distinct.
Moscow V106:359 running text · Moscow V106:360 running text · Moscow V106:361 running text · Moscow V106:362 running text · Moscow V106:363 running text · Mohl III222:357 running text · Mohl III222:358 running text · Mohl III222:359 running text · Mohl III222:360 running text · Mohl III222:361 running text · Khaleghi IV25:362 running text · Khaleghi IV25:363 running text · Khaleghi IV25:364 running text · Khaleghi IV26:365 running text · Khaleghi IV26:366 running text · Ganjoor sh6:1 · Ganjoor sh6:2 · Ganjoor sh6:3 · Ganjoor sh6:4 · Ganjoor sh6:5
Bijan arrives on the fourth day in all four, but his point of departure differs. Mohl and Khaleghi send him from the rear, which English follows; Moscow and Ganjoor have the front. His torn clothing and earth thrown skyward make the protest bodily before he speaks. English scorn identifies the emotion more narrowly than the gesture alone requires. The challenge to his experienced father then treats standing still as purposeless instruction in rest. All four move from the fourth-day arrival to a complaint mentioning the fifth day. English retains that chronological tension instead of harmonizing it. The sun’s failure to see swords and the absence of dust dramatize inactivity; English scimitars specifies the sources’ broader word for swords.
16–20Bereavement becomes Bijan’s explanation for restraint
English 16–20;individual printed-source locators and linked evidence. Character speech,main text,actual apparatus and unverified spelling remain distinct.
Moscow V106:364 running text · Moscow V106:365 running text · Moscow V106:366 running text · Moscow V106:367 running text · Moscow V106:368 running text · Mohl III222:362 running text · Mohl III222:363 running text · Mohl III222:364 running text · Mohl III222:365 running text · Mohl III222:366 running text · Khaleghi IV26:367 running text · Khaleghi IV26:368 running text · Khaleghi IV26:369 running text · Khaleghi IV26:370 running text · Khaleghi IV26:371 running text · Ganjoor sh6:6 · Ganjoor sh6:7 · Ganjoor sh6:8 · Ganjoor sh6:9 · Ganjoor sh6:10
All four show armored riders whose blood has not stirred, then recall Gudarz’s standing immediately after Rostam among Iran’s warriors. English makes that former superiority explicitly a fighting power. Bijan attributes the change to battle, slaughter and the loss of sons, so the account of incapacity remains a character’s accusation rather than an independent narrative verdict. The printed place-name at the sons’ deaths is a Lavan form in the four inspected main texts. English Ladan is preserved, but its exact consonantal support remains unverified and no geographical equivalence is asserted. The wounded inner organ and lost way then become a wounded heart unable to bear battle. English turns unwillingness into psychological inability, strengthening the grief-based explanation that Giv will shortly contest.
21–25The same stars can signify age or judgment
English 21–25;individual printed-source locators and linked evidence. Character speech,main text,actual apparatus and unverified spelling remain distinct.
Moscow V107:369 running text;actual107n1 heaven alternative · Moscow V107:370 running text · Moscow V107:371 running text · Moscow V107:372 running text · Moscow V107:373 running text · Mohl III222:367 running text · Mohl III222:368 running text · Mohl III222:369 running text · Mohl III222:370 running text · Mohl III222:371 running text · Khaleghi IV26:372 running text · Khaleghi IV26:373 running text · Khaleghi IV26:374 running text · Khaleghi IV26:375 running text · Khaleghi IV26:376 running text · Ganjoor sh6:11 · Ganjoor sh6:12 · Ganjoor sh6:13 · Ganjoor sh6:14 · Ganjoor sh6:15
The image of Gudarz’s raised head varies. Moscow and Ganjoor point him toward a high mountain, whereas Mohl and Khaleghi direct him toward the high heavens. Moscow’s actual apparatus also records the heaven reading. English follows that skyward orientation, making the subsequent star-counting seem a natural continuation. All four contrast the neglected count of soldiers with stars around the moon. English no longer presents this as a decline from earlier practice, and its cold blood and lost strength give physical form to the accusation. Bijan excuses the elder as detached from the world, then turns his wonder against Giv. The lion seeking skill from the father becomes an animal seeking guidance, increasing the pressure on Giv to act as a leader.
26–30The pleasant season threatens to close
English 26–30;individual printed-source locators and linked evidence. Character speech,main text,actual apparatus and unverified spelling remain distinct.
Moscow V107:374 running text · Moscow V107:375 running text · Moscow V107:376 running text · Moscow V107:377 running text;actual107n17 cold/battle alternative · Moscow V107:378 running text · Mohl III222:372 running text · Mohl III222:373 running text · Mohl III222:374 running text · Mohl III222:375 running text · Mohl III222:376 running text · Khaleghi IV26:377 running text · Khaleghi IV26:378 running text · Khaleghi IV26:379 running text · Khaleghi IV26:380 running text;actual26n25 snow and other alternatives · Khaleghi IV26:381 running text · Ganjoor sh6:16 · Ganjoor sh6:17 · Ganjoor sh6:18 · Ganjoor sh6:19 · Ganjoor sh6:20
All four have two armies watching Giv and urge sharper judgment together with anger. The current season, however, supports opposing readings: Moscow and Ganjoor use affirmative wording about battle gaining readiness, while Mohl and Khaleghi negate it. English no battle follows the negative orientation. The approaching cold then hardens earth like steel and freezes hands upon spears. Mohl places snow behind and battle ahead, directly supporting English. Moscow and Ganjoor instead place blade behind and stone ahead; Khaleghi’s main text has constriction behind and stone ahead. The actual apparatus records related alternatives, including cold in Moscow and snow in Khaleghi. English then follows the three other combat questions where Khaleghi asks who would remain at ease. The seasonal argument makes delay seem an increasingly costly choice.
31–35An offer to attack the ambush wins paternal approval
English 31–35;individual printed-source locators and linked evidence. Character speech,main text,actual apparatus and unverified spelling remain distinct.
Moscow V107:379 running text · Moscow V107:380 running text · Moscow V107:381 running text · Moscow V107:382 running text · Moscow V107:383 running text · Mohl III222:377 running text · Mohl III222:378 running text · Mohl III222:379 running text · Mohl III223:380 running text · Mohl III223:381 running text · Khaleghi IV26:382 running text · Khaleghi IV27:383 running text · Khaleghi IV27:384 running text · Khaleghi IV27:385 running text · Khaleghi IV27:386 running text · Ganjoor sh6:21 · Ganjoor sh6:22 · Ganjoor sh6:23 · Ganjoor sh6:24 · Ganjoor sh6:25
Bijan proposes a thousand chosen riders and boasts of casting the hidden enemy’s heads above the moon. All four preserve that disproportionate confidence, while English shifts the plural boast toward personal agency. The address differs at the fear of ambush: Moscow and Ganjoor use the third person, Mohl and Khaleghi the second. English keeps the grandfather-directed accusation through its third-person phrasing. The offered solution is therefore also a claim that youthful action can answer the elder’s caution. Giv’s laughter and praise initially reward that energy. English brings the turn to prayer into the same couplet, then expands the son’s recognition of good into practical knowledge of what must be done. Approval precedes correction, making the coming rebuke more measured than an immediate dismissal.
36–40Inherited courage does not authorize disrespect
English 36–40;individual printed-source locators and linked evidence. Character speech,main text,actual apparatus and unverified spelling remain distinct.
Moscow V107:384 running text · Moscow V107:385 running text · Moscow V107:386 running text · Moscow V108:387 running text · Moscow V108:388 running text · Mohl III223:382 running text · Mohl III223:383 running text · Mohl III223:384 running text · Mohl III223:385 running text · Mohl III223:386 running text · Khaleghi IV27:387 running text · Khaleghi IV27:388 running text · Khaleghi IV27:389 running text · Khaleghi IV27:390 running text · Khaleghi IV27:391 running text · Ganjoor sh6:26 · Ganjoor sh6:27 · Ganjoor sh6:28 · Ganjoor sh6:29 · Ganjoor sh6:30
The praise of Bijan draws on different distributions of qualities. Moscow and Ganjoor emphasize intelligence, strength for vengeance, practical knowledge and pursuit of religion. Mohl and Khaleghi include glory and religion with strength, then pursuit of vengeance. English gathers wisdom, strength, glory, faith, skill and vengeance into a fuller list rather than reproducing one witness’s sequence. Giv’s recognition of himself in the son then becomes an expectation of what a champion’s child should be. All four support that expectation with the lion’s threat to sever affection and kinship from a cowardly cub, leaving sea and earth as substitute parents. English preserves the fierce image, then turns with the sources to restraint of speech. Its public audience is added, but the distinction between courage and disrespect remains clear.
41–45Giv restores the value of experience
English 41–45;individual printed-source locators and linked evidence. Character speech,main text,actual apparatus and unverified spelling remain distinct.
Moscow V108:389 running text · Moscow V108:390 running text · Moscow V108:391 running text · Moscow V108:392 running text · Moscow V108:393 running text · Mohl III223:387 running text · Mohl III223:388 running text · Mohl III223:389 running text · Mohl III223:390 running text · Mohl III223:391 running text · Khaleghi IV27:392 running text · Khaleghi IV27:393 running text · Khaleghi IV27:394 running text · Khaleghi IV27:395 running text · Khaleghi IV27:396 running text · Ganjoor sh6:31 · Ganjoor sh6:32 · Ganjoor sh6:33 · Ganjoor sh6:34 · Ganjoor sh6:35
All four answer Bijan’s diagnosis with the grandfather’s experience, superior knowledge and authority over the force. English develops that authority into careful command and a seasoned eye and heart. The sources’ claim that a veteran needs no teacher thus becomes an account of practiced perception, directly opposing Bijan’s portrayal of a distracted star-counter. Giv also rejects the assumption that only Iran bears hardship. The Turks are no more comfortable, and their wounded hearts and bloody eyes support the English emphasis on despair. Calling those eyes universally tearful makes the suffering more explicit. The explanation then returns to strategy: the elder wants the Turks to move first. English adds a wish to prove strength, but the decisive shared point is the order of movement.
46–50Celestial reckoning serves a planned advance
English 46–50;individual printed-source locators and linked evidence. Character speech,main text,actual apparatus and unverified spelling remain distinct.
Moscow V108:394 running text · Moscow V108:395 running text · Moscow V108:396 running text · Moscow V108:397 running text · Moscow V108:398 running text · Mohl III223:392 running text · Mohl III223:393 running text · Mohl III223:394 running text · Mohl III223:395 running text · Mohl III223:396 running text · Khaleghi IV27:397 running text · Khaleghi IV27:398 running text · Khaleghi IV27:399 running text · Khaleghi IV27:400 running text · Khaleghi IV27:401 running text · Ganjoor sh6:36 · Ganjoor sh6:37 · Ganjoor sh6:38 · Ganjoor sh6:39 · Ganjoor sh6:40
All four require the opposing force to leave the mountain behind before Gudarz brings his own army forward. English preserves that spatial condition, showing why the earlier refusal to expose the rear can coexist with readiness to attack. Gudarz’s gopal then sweeps across the land in the sources; English places it in his hand and makes battle itself roll through the terrain. The celestial calculation is now explained as part of judgment rather than evidence of decline. English constellations and alignment specify the more general reckoning of stars and heaven’s movement. Mohl and Khaleghi promise a world cleared of enemies, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor name Turks. English foes follows the general formulation before Bijan’s renewed address shifts a universal champion’s title into fame reaching the sky.
51–53Bijan accepts the plan through a defiant pause
English 51–53;individual printed-source locators and linked evidence. Character speech,main text,actual apparatus and unverified spelling remain distinct.
Moscow V108:399 running text · Moscow V108:400 running text · Moscow V108:401 running text · Mohl III223:397 running text · Mohl III223:398 running text · Mohl III223:399 running text · Khaleghi IV28:402 running text · Khaleghi IV28:403 running text · Khaleghi IV28:404 running text · Ganjoor sh6:41 · Ganjoor sh6:42 · Ganjoor sh6:43
All four let Bijan answer the grandfather’s strategy by questioning the need for a Roman garment and proposing to remove armor, drink wine and return when required. English identifies the garment as jowshan through the following disarming context, although the immediate source word is the more general coat. The next source unit does expressly name jowshan and helmet, so the interpretation remains grounded without treating the two terms as identical. The faded face reddened by wine becomes rosy cheeks in English, retaining the restoration of color. His final promise is still military: he will come belted for battle. English generalizes the named world-champion’s need into being needed, leaving the authority less explicit while preserving readiness beneath the petulant withdrawal.
Source record and limits
C3.7 only:53 English couplets. Moscow V105–108:349–401;Mohl III221–223:347–399(PDF227–229);Ganjoor12rokh sh5:98–107 and sh6:1–43;Khaleghi IV25–28:352–404(PDF41–44).53 unique running units in each presentation,all accounted. English1–2 redistribute two shared source units;no source-only units.
The existing Moscow V and Mohl III files were inspected individually as PNG facsimiles before Ganjoor and Khaleghi IV. Mohl’s printed marginal numbers were enlarged to verify347–399 independently. All53 English couplets have separate Moscow and Mohl accounts. Ganjoor poem-body text supplies the labeled Persian reference;the first two English couplets share the two source units they redistribute.
- F&R English: 53 verbatim couplets;Bijan Urges Giv to Fight;ends before C3.8 Houman Seeks Leave for Battle.
- Moscow: V105–108:349–401;front359,mountain369,affirmative readiness375,blade/stone377;actual107n1 heaven,107n17 cold/battle.
- Mohl: III221–223:347–399;rear357,heavens367,negative readiness373,snow/battle375,enemies395. Boundary corrected from inherited candidate349.
- Ganjoor: 12rokh sh5:98–107 and sh6:1–43;front sh6:1,mountain11,affirmative readiness17,blade/stone19,Turks39.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV25–28:352–404;rear362,heavens372,negative readiness378,constriction/stone380;actual26n25 snow and related alternatives;enemies400.
Actual apparatus:Moscow107n1 prints heaven as the alternative to mountain;107n17 prints cold behind/battle ahead among alternatives to the main blade/stone reading. Khaleghi26n25 records multiple readings including snow. Mohl’s actual main snow/battle hemistich is direct support for English29;neither apparatus list nor a notice substitutes for it. No appendix evidence used. No local running-text gaps need source-only rows in this chapter.
English19 Ladan remains verbatim. All four main texts inspected here have Lavan/لاون-type spelling;exact Ladan support is unverified. This limitation is not counted as positive four-way agreement. Notes still qualify through explicit accounting of all four inspected readings. Gudarz’s alleged decline remains Bijan’s speech,not an independently accepted diagnosis.
Boundary correction:Mohl III221 starts this passage at347,not the inherited candidate349;the final current unit is399 and the next begins400. The prior package and its checkpoint are retained unchanged. Overlapping inherited numerical labels are not evidence of a repeated narrative unit,and no cumulative unique Mohl-source count is certified until the earlier locators are separately reviewed on instruction.
New qualification C3.7.19:exact support for published Ladan remains unverified against the inspected Lavan/لاون forms;no geographical equivalence asserted. Mohl start corrected from inherited candidate349 to printed347;end399,next400. Prior package retained unchanged;this boundary correction does not certify its earlier Mohl locators or a cumulative unique Mohl-unit total. Selected apparatus only:actual Moscow107n1 and107n17;Khaleghi26n25. No appendix evidence used,no unprinted addition notice treated as text. All inherited flags retained,including C3.4.55 Chakh.
Selected quotations are bounded readings,not full diplomatic transcriptions.
C3.7 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V105:349 running text;V105:350 running text | III221:347 running text;III221:348 running text |
| 2 | V105:349 running text;V105:350 running text | III221:347 running text;III221:348 running text |
| 3 | V105:351 running text | III221:349 running text |
| 4 | V105:352 running text | III221:350 running text |
| 5 | V106:353 running text | III221:351 running text |
| 6 | V106:354 running text | III221:352 running text |
| 7 | V106:355 running text | III221:353 running text |
| 8 | V106:356 running text | III221:354 running text |
| 9 | V106:357 running text | III222:355 running text |
| 10 | V106:358 running text | III222:356 running text |
| 11 | V106:359 running text | III222:357 running text |
| 12 | V106:360 running text | III222:358 running text |
| 13 | V106:361 running text | III222:359 running text |
| 14 | V106:362 running text | III222:360 running text |
| 15 | V106:363 running text | III222:361 running text |
| 16 | V106:364 running text | III222:362 running text |
| 17 | V106:365 running text | III222:363 running text |
| 18 | V106:366 running text | III222:364 running text |
| 19 | V106:367 running text | III222:365 running text |
| 20 | V106:368 running text | III222:366 running text |
| 21 | V107:369 running text;actual107n1 heaven alternative | III222:367 running text |
| 22 | V107:370 running text | III222:368 running text |
| 23 | V107:371 running text | III222:369 running text |
| 24 | V107:372 running text | III222:370 running text |
| 25 | V107:373 running text | III222:371 running text |
| 26 | V107:374 running text | III222:372 running text |
| 27 | V107:375 running text | III222:373 running text |
| 28 | V107:376 running text | III222:374 running text |
| 29 | V107:377 running text;actual107n17 cold/battle alternative | III222:375 running text |
| 30 | V107:378 running text | III222:376 running text |
| 31 | V107:379 running text | III222:377 running text |
| 32 | V107:380 running text | III222:378 running text |
| 33 | V107:381 running text | III222:379 running text |
| 34 | V107:382 running text | III223:380 running text |
| 35 | V107:383 running text | III223:381 running text |
| 36 | V107:384 running text | III223:382 running text |
| 37 | V107:385 running text | III223:383 running text |
| 38 | V107:386 running text | III223:384 running text |
| 39 | V108:387 running text | III223:385 running text |
| 40 | V108:388 running text | III223:386 running text |
| 41 | V108:389 running text | III223:387 running text |
| 42 | V108:390 running text | III223:388 running text |
| 43 | V108:391 running text | III223:389 running text |
| 44 | V108:392 running text | III223:390 running text |
| 45 | V108:393 running text | III223:391 running text |
| 46 | V108:394 running text | III223:392 running text |
| 47 | V108:395 running text | III223:393 running text |
| 48 | V108:396 running text | III223:394 running text |
| 49 | V108:397 running text | III223:395 running text |
| 50 | V108:398 running text | III223:396 running text |
| 51 | V108:399 running text | III223:397 running text |
| 52 | V108:400 running text | III223:398 running text |
| 53 | V108:401 running text | III223:399 running text |
New Naqqali