Goshtasb Battles Ilyas
25 published couplets: dawn, battle, capture, reception and reflection.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 25 published couplets: dawn, battle, capture, reception and reflection. |
| Moscow | VI53–54:712–734,23 running units; English24–25 actual54n22. |
| Mohl | Persian IV170–171:721–745,25 running units. |
| Ganjoor | Lohrasp sh14:3–25,23 running units; final two English units have terminal gaps. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | V56–58:725–747,23 running units; final two English units have checked747→748 gap. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Dawn and the disputed deployment
English 1–5; individually linked edition accounts in the register.
Moscow VI53:712 (running text) · Mohl IV170:721 (running text) · Khaleghi V56:725 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:3 running poem body · Moscow VI53:713 (running text) · Mohl IV170:722 (running text) · Khaleghi V56:726 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:4 running poem body · Moscow VI53:714 (running text) · Mohl IV170:723 (running text) · Khaleghi V56:727 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:5 running poem body · Moscow VI53:715 (running text) · Mohl IV171:724 (running text) · Khaleghi V56:728 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:6 running poem body · Moscow VI53:715→716 (checked local gap) · Mohl IV171:724→725 (checked local gap) · Khaleghi V56n17 (actual addition after728) · Ganjoor sh14:6→7 (checked local gap for this supplement) · Moscow VI53:716 (running text) · Mohl IV171:725 (running text) · Khaleghi V56:729 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:7 running poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all open with the sun rising from the Bow or Archer, but Moscow and Ganjoor connect its awareness to the struggle, whereas Mohl and Khaleghi refer to the covering or curtain. The English’s awareness of what awaits preserves the personification without reproducing that distinction. Amber daylight and sounding horns and drums are common; tabiras and karnays specify the instruments more closely than the generic source terms. The deployment requires a firmer qualification. Mohl and Khaleghi place Sakil on the left and Caesar with drums and elephants on the right; Moscow and Ganjoor reverse those assignments. English5 follows the former for Sakil, but its center wing is not supported by these checked readings. It creates an additional spatial arrangement rather than resolving the right/left variant. The English remains unchanged, with that departure explicitly recorded.
6–10The dragon and the reason for tribute
English 6–10; individually linked edition accounts in the register.
Moscow VI53:717 (running text) · Mohl IV171:726 (running text) · Khaleghi V56:730 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:8 running poem body · Moscow VI53:718 (running text) · Mohl IV171:727 (running text) · Khaleghi V56:731 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:9 running poem body · Moscow VI53:719 (running text) · Mohl IV171:728 (running text) · Khaleghi V56:732 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:10 running poem body · Moscow VI53:720 (running text) · Mohl IV171:729 (running text) · Khaleghi V56:733 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:11 running poem body · Moscow VI53:721 (running text) · Mohl IV171:730 (running text) · Khaleghi V57:734 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:12 running poem body
All four sources place Goshtasb before the ranks with a horse beneath him and a dragon in his hand. The English preserves that compressed martial image rather than converting it into another literal monster episode. The weapon’s dragonlike force also prepares Ilyas’s recognition that Caesar’s demand rests on this champion. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh retain the association, although their second line about Caesar’s confidence differs in wording. Trusts his arm to crush us turns that confidence into an explicit prediction of defeat, an intelligible English expansion rather than a separately printed promise. The sun and moon seeming to collide likewise preserves the cosmic scale of the armies’ clamor. Goshtasb’s decision that his abilities must no longer remain hidden becomes the more direct hour to prove my strength. It keeps the action moving while narrowing the plural arts or prowess to strength.
11–15The hand wound and the captive
English 11–15; individually linked edition accounts in the register.
Moscow VI53:722 (running text) · Mohl IV171:731 (running text) · Khaleghi V57:735 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:13 running poem body · Moscow VI53:723 (running text) · Mohl IV171:732 (running text) · Khaleghi V57:736 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:14 running poem body · Moscow VI53:724 (running text) · Mohl IV171:733 (running text) · Khaleghi V57:737 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:15 running poem body · Moscow VI53n25 unit1 (actual addition after724) · Mohl IV171:733→734 (checked local gap) · Khaleghi V57:737→738 (checked local gap) · Ganjoor sh14:15→16 (checked local gap for this supplement) · Moscow VI53n25 unit2 (actual addition after724) · Mohl IV171:733→734 (checked local gap) · Khaleghi V57:737→738 (checked local gap) · Ganjoor sh14:15→16 (checked local gap for this supplement) · Moscow VI53:725 (running text) · Mohl IV171:734 (running text) · Khaleghi V57:738 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:16 running poem body · Moscow VI54:726 (running text) · Mohl IV171:735 (running text) · Khaleghi V57:739 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:17 running poem body · Moscow VI54:726→727 (checked local gap) · Mohl IV171:735→736 (checked local gap) · Khaleghi V57n11 (actual addition after739) · Ganjoor sh14:17→18 (checked local gap for this supplement)
The duel’s broad sequence agrees across Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh: arrow, countering spear, unhorsing, hand-grip and delivery to Caesar. Its detail does not. Mohl explicitly refers to Goshtasb’s hand being wounded, supporting English12’s bodily location; Moscow and Ganjoor instead describe Ilyas’s purpose of bringing him low, while Khaleghi’s main reading speaks of the warrior being wounded without that same specificity. The English makes the injury an accomplished event. English13’s iron scales supplies an armor construction beyond the corresponding jowshan and wounded-body wording. Dazed in14 effectively renders the comparison with drunkenness while retaining capture rather than killing. Moscow’s actual apparatus adds two alternative combat verses between the spear-wound and unhorsing units; these are recorded separately, not inserted as another attack in the English. The final dragging and surrender establish Ilyas as a living prize, despite the broader rhetoric of destruction.
16–20Victory, slaughter and the return
English 16–20; individually linked edition accounts in the register.
Moscow VI54:727 (running text) · Mohl IV171:736 (running text) · Khaleghi V57:740 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:18 running poem body · Moscow VI54:728 (running text) · Mohl IV171:737 (running text) · Khaleghi V57:741 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:19 running poem body · Moscow VI54:729 (running text); VI54n7/8 actual look-back/return alternative · Mohl IV171:738 (running text) · Khaleghi V57:742 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:20 running poem body · Moscow VI54:730 (running text) · Mohl IV171:739 (running text) · Khaleghi V57:743 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:21 running poem body · Moscow VI54:731 (running text) · Mohl IV171:740 (running text) · Khaleghi V57:744 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:22 running poem body
After the capture, all four sources have Goshtasb advance with the army and then return to Caesar. English17 follows Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh in placing the world’s amazement beside the killing and taking of enemies. Moscow and Ganjoor instead give a second clause in which those who fall into the fighters’ hands are killed. The English therefore chooses an attested response of astonishment rather than simply suppressing a unanimous massacre clause. The return also differs: Mohl and Khaleghi have Goshtasb look back and turn around, supporting English18’s explicit glance; Moscow and Ganjoor’s main wording gives departure or return without that glance, though Moscow records the alternative. The troops’ raised heads preserve the victory posture. English20 makes the hero’s exalted arrival explicit, while the Persian foregrounds Caesar seeing him and coming out joyfully with the army. Both versions make the reception public.
21–25Royal reception and the unstable world
English 21–25; individually linked edition accounts in the register.
Moscow VI54:732 (running text) · Mohl IV171:741 (running text) · Khaleghi V57:745 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:23 running poem body · Moscow VI54:733 (running text) · Mohl IV171:742 (running text) · Khaleghi V58:746 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:24 running poem body · Moscow VI54n19 (actual addition after733) · Mohl IV171:742→743 (checked local gap) · Khaleghi V58:746→747 (checked local gap) · Ganjoor sh14:24→25 (checked local gap for this supplement) · Moscow VI54:734 (running text) · Mohl IV171:743 (running text) · Khaleghi V58:747 (running text) · Ganjoor sh14:25 running poem body · Moscow VI54n22 unit1 (actual apparatus after734, not running text) · Mohl IV171:744 (running text) · Khaleghi V58:747→748 (checked local gap; no matching local apparatus verse) · Ganjoor sh14 ends at25 (checked terminal gap for this closing unit) · Moscow VI54n22 unit2 (actual apparatus after734, not running text) · Mohl IV171:745 (running text) · Khaleghi V58:747→748 (checked local gap; no matching local apparatus verse) · Ganjoor sh14 ends at25 (checked terminal gap for this closing unit)
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all give the kiss, remembrance of the Creator, joyful return, royal headgear and Roman gifts. The English adds face to the stated head and eyes and interprets remembrance as thanks. It leaves the crowning agent implicit, where the Persian identifies the commander putting on the crown; the context supports reading this as Goshtasb’s honor without turning it into his Iranian accession. The final two English couplets have a narrower textual distribution. Mohl prints the decorated world, wine, musicians and sweetness–poison reflection in its running text; Moscow actually prints both below the text. Ganjoor ends its section after the gifts, and Khaleghi moves from gifts to the next episode, with checked local gaps for these closing units. Their reflective ending is thus positively witnessed. Sweetness and poison qualify the celebration through worldly instability, not through a prediction of a particular next calamity.
Source record and limits
Published boundary and composite reference
C5.15 is Goshtasb Battles Ilyas: 25 published English couplets, beginning with dawn from the Archer and ending with the sweetness–poison reflection. C5.16 Caesar Demands Iran’s Tribute begins with the passage of time and is excluded. The Persian reference uses Ganjoor sh14:3–25, Mohl’s two closing units744–745 and five separately labeled apparatus records. Thus 30 register rows comprise 25 English accounts and five source-only records. Ganjoor sh14:1–2 belong to the preceding chapter and are not included again.
Moscow running text and actual apparatus
Moscow VI53:712–725 and VI54:726–734 give 23 running units, individually mapped to English1–23. No scoped main unit is bracketed. English24–25 are positively supported by the two actual additions printed at54n22 after734. They are not Moscow running text. Actual53n25 prints two supplementary combat units, S1–S2, after724;54n19 prints the commander/support speech S3 after733. Actual54n7/8 records the look-back and return alternative relevant to English18. The Khaleghi formation and concealed-captive additions have checked local gaps at715→716 and726→727. No appendix evidence is used or certified.
Mohl running text and local gaps
Persian IV170:721–723 and IV171:724–745 give 25 running units, one numbered counterpart for every English couplet. Main725 puts Sakil on the left and Caesar with drums and elephants on the right. Main732 explicitly names the hand in the wound clause;737 has the world’s amazement;738 has the look back and return. Main744–745 contain celebration and the sweetness–poison reflection absent from the other two running sequences. Source-only S1–S5 have individually identified checked local gaps. These are bounded observations, not manuscript-wide claims. The reprint imprint remains independently unverified.
Ganjoor scope and terminal gaps
Only Lohrasp sh14:3–25 belongs to this chapter: 23 units allocated once to English1–23. Its first two units are the preceding nightfall and are excluded. The page ends after the Roman gifts; English24–25 have checked terminal gaps, positively supplemented from Mohl and Moscow apparatus rather than reconstructed. Ganjoor agrees with Moscow’s Sakil-right/Caesar-left layout, the purpose of bringing Goshtasb low in the arrow verse, and the second killing clause after the main capture/slaughter statement. It does not independently verify the English hand wound, center wing or final two units. Comments and generated prose are excluded.
Khaleghi running text and actual apparatus
Khaleghi V56:725–733, V57:734–745 and V58:746–747 give 23 running units, individually mapped to English1–23. No scoped main unit is bracketed. The next main748 begins the following episode, leaving a checked747→748 gap for English24–25 with no matching local apparatus verses. Actual56n17 adds the formation unit S4 after728;57n11 adds the hidden-captive/end-of-greatness unit S5 after739. Moscow’s combat supplement has a checked737→738 gap and its commander/support speech a746→747 gap. Main729 gives Sakil-left/Caesar-right;736’s main wound formulation lacks Mohl’s hand specificity;741 gives worldly amazement and742 the look back. No appendix evidence or unprinted notice is certified.
Consequential choices and the center-wing qualification
English5’s Sakil-left reading follows Mohl and Khaleghi against Moscow/Ganjoor’s opposite assignment. Its center wing for the drums and elephants is not supported by the checked running text or local apparatus; those readings place that group on the other named wing. This remains a documented departure, not an invented consensus or silently corrected verse. English12’s hand-specific wound has positive Mohl support, while the English states the injury as an accomplished event. English17’s astonishment follows Mohl/Khaleghi rather than Moscow/Ganjoor’s further killing clause. English18’s glance follows Mohl/Khaleghi and actual Moscow variants. English24–25 follow Mohl running and actual Moscow apparatus, with Ganjoor/Khaleghi gaps explicitly retained.
Interpretation and inherited limits
The hand-held dragon is martial imagery, not a new monster episode. The English’s iron scales, low-held lance, added face in the kiss and explicit thanksgiving specify the source’s armor, spear, head/eyes and Creator-remembrance. Royal headgear at the Roman reception does not establish the Iranian accession. Supplementary combat, formation, praise and concealed-captive units remain separate witness evidence rather than cumulative new events. All inherited provisional flags remain unchanged, including C5.7.S4, C5.5.35 and C5.12.S12. Earlier chapters are untouched. The center-wing issue is retained in the checkpoint as a new chapter-specific qualification; no published English is revised.
Selected readings
| Locator and evidence class | Normalized excerpt |
|---|---|
| Mohl IV171:725 running; Sakil left | ابر میسره پور قیصر سقیل / ابر میمنه قیصر و کوس و پیل |
| Moscow VI53:716 / Ganjoor sh14:7 running; opposite wings | ابر میمنه پور قیصر سقیل / ابر میسره قیصر و کوس و پیل |
| Mohl IV171:732 running; hand-specific wound clause | که گشتاسپ از آن خسته گردد دست |
| Moscow VI53:723 / Ganjoor sh14:14 running; purpose of bringing low | که گشتاسپ را برکند کار پست |
| Khaleghi V57:736 running; warrior wounded | که گشتاسپ زان خسته گردد، نخست |
| Mohl IV171:737 / Khaleghi V57:741 running; amazement | جهانی بدو مانده اندر شگفت |
| Moscow VI54:728 / Ganjoor sh14:19 running; further killing | بکشتند مر هرک آمد به مشت |
| Mohl IV171:744 running / Moscow VI54n22 actual addition | جهانی به آیین بیاراستند / می و رود و رامشگران خواستند |
| Mohl IV171:745 running / Moscow VI54n22 actual addition | چنین است آیین گردنده دهر / گهی نوش یابی ازو گاه زهر |
Source links and detailed records
C5.15 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI53:712 (running text) | IV170:721 (running text) |
| 2 | VI53:713 (running text) | IV170:722 (running text) |
| 3 | VI53:714 (running text) | IV170:723 (running text) |
| 4 | VI53:715 (running text) | IV171:724 (running text) |
| 5 | VI53:716 (running text) | IV171:725 (running text) |
| 6 | VI53:717 (running text) | IV171:726 (running text) |
| 7 | VI53:718 (running text) | IV171:727 (running text) |
| 8 | VI53:719 (running text) | IV171:728 (running text) |
| 9 | VI53:720 (running text) | IV171:729 (running text) |
| 10 | VI53:721 (running text) | IV171:730 (running text) |
| 11 | VI53:722 (running text) | IV171:731 (running text) |
| 12 | VI53:723 (running text) | IV171:732 (running text) |
| 13 | VI53:724 (running text) | IV171:733 (running text) |
| 14 | VI53:725 (running text) | IV171:734 (running text) |
| 15 | VI54:726 (running text) | IV171:735 (running text) |
| 16 | VI54:727 (running text) | IV171:736 (running text) |
| 17 | VI54:728 (running text) | IV171:737 (running text) |
| 18 | VI54:729 (running text); VI54n7/8 actual look-back/return alternative | IV171:738 (running text) |
| 19 | VI54:730 (running text) | IV171:739 (running text) |
| 20 | VI54:731 (running text) | IV171:740 (running text) |
| 21 | VI54:732 (running text) | IV171:741 (running text) |
| 22 | VI54:733 (running text) | IV171:742 (running text) |
| 23 | VI54:734 (running text) | IV171:743 (running text) |
| 24 | VI54n22 unit1 (actual apparatus after734, not running text) | IV171:744 (running text) |
| 25 | VI54n22 unit2 (actual apparatus after734, not running text) | IV171:745 (running text) |
New Naqqali