New Naqqaliشاهنامه
Critical Commentary · C6.12

The Opening of the Battle

35 published couplets; sunrise through Shidasp’s final lament.

F&R English · 35 couplets · 6 commentary entries

Printed verse collation

The chapter in five texts

TextChapter treatment and distinctive choices
F&R English35 published couplets; sunrise through Shidasp’s final lament.
MoscowVI97–99:466–501;36 main units;actual paternal lament at99n5.
MohlPersian IV200–202:482–518;37 main units including the paternal refrain.
GanjoorGoshtasb sh12:1–36;36 reference units allocated once.
Khaleghi-MotlaghV120–123:472–508;37 main units and12 individually registered actual supplementary verses.

Parallel text

English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.

1–6+
When night had passed and day began to shine,
The world-bright sun rose over battle’s line.
The troops on either side their saddles gained,
While Shah Goshtasb upon the height remained.
When from the mountain he beheld the field,
And warriors armed with spear and sword and shield,
He called for black Behzad, that mighty horse,
Like Mount Bistoon in stature and in force.
They clad the horse in armor; then he rode;
The lines below in ordered battle flowed.
The armies faced each other on the ground;
From elephants rang brazen karnays’ sound.
چو اندر گذشت آن شب و بود روز
بتابید خورشید گیهان فروز
به زین بر نشستند هر دو سپاه
همی دید زان کوه گشتاسپ شاه
چو از کوه دید آن شه بافرین
کجا برنشستند گردان به زین
سیه رنگ بهزاد را پیش خواست
تو گفتی که بیستونست راست
برو بر فگندند برگستوان
برو بر نشست آن شه خسروان
چو هر دو برابر فرود آمدند
ابر پیل بر نای رویین زدند
Ganjoor Ganjoor Goshtasb sh12:1; running poem body
7–12+
When ranks were set and champions challenged loud,
A storm of arrows darkened every cloud.
They fell like springtime hail across the fight,
Until the sun’s own course was lost to sight.
Few could believe that storm of arrow-rain,
Unless they stood themselves upon the plain.
The sun was veiled; the arrowheads flashed bright,
Like ocean waters glittering in the light.
The sky seemed overcast from first to last,
As diamond rain fell sparkling and fast.
The gorz-men and the spearmen clashed and surged;
A night of dust above the plain emerged.
یکی رزمگاهی بیاراستند
یلان هم نبردان همی خواستند
بکردند یک تیرباران نخست
بسان تگرگ بهاران درست
بشد آفتاب از جهان ناپدید
چه داند کسی کان شگفتی ندید
بپوشیده شد چشمهٔ آفتاب
ز پیکانهاشان درفشان چو آب
تو گفتی جهان ابر دارد همی
وزان ابر الماس بارد همی
وزان گرزداران و نیزه‌وران
همی تاختند آن برین این بران
Ganjoor Ganjoor Goshtasb sh12:7; running poem body
13–18+
The earth was drowned in gore from side to side,
And darkness spread across that crimson tide.
First came Ardeshir, the great Shah’s son,
A horseman fair, with battle just begun.
Like some mad elephant he crossed the field;
He seemed like Tus beneath his lifted shield.
He wheeled before the battle-line below;
He did not know what Fate would soon bestow.
An arrow pierced his waist through jowshan’s scale,
And from his bay he tumbled, pierced and pale.
Dust mixed with blood to mar his former grace;
Woe for the moonlike beauty of his face!
هوازی جهان بود شبگون شده
زمین سربسر پاک گلگون شده
بیامد نخست آن سوار هژیر
پس شهریار جهان اردشیر
به آوردگه رفت نیزه به دست
تو گفتی مگر طوس اسپهبدست
برین سان همی گشت پیش سپاه
نبود آگه از بخش خورشید و ماه
بیامد یکی ناوکش بر میان
گذارنده شد بر سلیح کیان
ز بور اندر افتاد خسرو نگون
تن پاکش آلوده شد پر ز خون
دریغ آن نکو روی همرنگ ماه
که بازش ندید آن خردمند شاه
Ganjoor Ganjoor Goshtasb sh12:13; running poem body
19–24+
The wise Shah never would behold him more;
Then Hormizd, brave and fair, rode out to war.
His cheeks like tulips glowed a fiery red;
A poisoned khanjar in his hand, he sped.
He roared as lions roar before they bring
Wild asses down beneath their deadly spring.
For that slain prince he made the foemen pay:
A thousand enemy riders fell that day.
But as he turned back from the furious fray,
The earth lay red with blood along his way.
An arrow struck his nape and laid him low;
The noble prince fell dead beneath the blow.
بیامد بر شاه شیر اورمزد
کجا زو گرفتی شهنشاه پزد
ز پیش اندر آمد به دشت اندرا
به زهر آب داده یکی خنجرا
خروشی برآورد برسان شیر
که آورد خواهد ژیان گور زیر
ابر کین آن شاهزاده سوار
بکشت از سواران دشمن هزار
به هنگامهٔ بازگشتن ز جنگ
که روی زمین گشته بد لاله رنگ
بیامد یکی تیرش اندر قفا
شد آن خسرو شاهزاده فنا
Ganjoor Ganjoor Goshtasb sh12:20; running poem body
25–30+
His father would not see his son again;
Then Prince Shidasp rode forward toward the men.
Moon-faced, of royal mien and warrior pride,
He sat an indigo steed, huge in stride.
His horse had all an elephant’s great might,
And sped like wind as he rode out to fight.
He wheeled and brandished high the lance in hand,
Then checked his charger, shouting his demand:
“Where is Kuhram, that mighty warrior? Where
Is he whose form both wolf and tiger share?”
A Div replied, “I am!” His challenge rang:
“I fight the hungry lion, fang to fang!”
دریغ آن نبرده گرانمایه گرد
که نادیده او را پدر خود بمرد
بیامد پسش باز شیدسپ شاه
که مانندهٔ شاه بد همچو ماه
یکی دیزه‌ای بر نشسته چو نیل
به تگ همچو آهو به تن همچو پیل
به آوردگه گشت و نیزه بگاشت
چو لختی بگردید نیزه بداشت
کدامست گفتا کهرم سترگ
کجا پیکرش پیکر پیر گرگ
بیامد یکی دیو گفتا منم
که با گرسنه شیر دندان زنم
Ganjoor Mohl IV201:507; running lament; normalized transcription. Shidasp arrival shared with English26.
31–35+
Shidasp’s lance unhorsed him; he took his head,
And cast his golden belt beside the dead.
Before the men of Chin, Shidasp wheeled round,
A mountain in the saddle, iron-bound.
No eye had seen his like; his beauty drew
The evil eye upon him as he flew.
A Turk then drew his bow; the arrow sped,
And struck the prince, who fell among the dead.
Alas, that gently nurtured prince died then;
His father would not see his face again.
به نیزه بگشتند هر دو چو باد
بزد ترک را نیزهٔ شاهزاد
ز باره در آورد و ببرید سر
به خاک اندر افگنده زرین کمر
همی گشت بر پیش گردان چین
بسان یکی کوه بر پشت زین
همانا چنو نیز دیده ندید
ز خوبی کجا بود چشمش رسید
یکی ترک تیری برو برگماشت
ز پشتش سر تیر بیرون گذاشت
دریغ آن شه پروریده به ناز
بشد روی او باب نادیده باز
Ganjoor Ganjoor Goshtasb sh12:31, sh12:32; running poem body

Couplet commentary

Quoted text · evidence · interpretation
1–6The king mounts beneath the rising sun
1–6
When night had passed and day began to shine,
The world-bright sun rose over battle’s line.
The troops on either side their saddles gained,
While Shah Goshtasb upon the height remained.
When from the mountain he beheld the field,
And warriors armed with spear and sword and shield,
He called for black Behzad, that mighty horse,
Like Mount Bistoon in stature and in force.
They clad the horse in armor; then he rode;
The lines below in ordered battle flowed.
The armies faced each other on the ground;
From elephants rang brazen karnays’ sound.
چو اندر گذشت آن شب و بود روز
بتابید خورشید گیهان فروز
به زین بر نشستند هر دو سپاه
همی دید زان کوه گشتاسپ شاه
چو از کوه دید آن شه بافرین
کجا برنشستند گردان به زین
سیه رنگ بهزاد را پیش خواست
تو گفتی که بیستونست راست
برو بر فگندند برگستوان
برو بر نشست آن شه خسروان
چو هر دو برابر فرود آمدند
ابر پیل بر نای رویین زدند
Ganjoor Ganjoor Goshtasb sh12:1; running poem body

English 1–6; individual four-source accounts and actual apparatus linked below. Provisional supplementary readings excluded from confident interpretation.

Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi share sunrise, the armies mounting, Goshtasb’s elevated view, black Behzad, the mountain comparison, horse armor and horns sounding from elephants. English makes the preparations more visibly martial by supplying spear, sword and shield in the king’s view. That inventory is an expansion, whereas the horse armor is explicit and should not be questioned merely because the English names it directly. Stature and force unfolds the Bistoon simile into size and power. Then he rode advances the source’s mounting into movement, while the ordered lines below preserve the larger setting. Brazen karnays specifies the metal horn wording and retains the elephants as the instruments’ platform, carrying the scene from royal observation toward engagement.

7–12Arrow rain and the limits of sight
7–12
When ranks were set and champions challenged loud,
A storm of arrows darkened every cloud.
They fell like springtime hail across the fight,
Until the sun’s own course was lost to sight.
Few could believe that storm of arrow-rain,
Unless they stood themselves upon the plain.
The sun was veiled; the arrowheads flashed bright,
Like ocean waters glittering in the light.
The sky seemed overcast from first to last,
As diamond rain fell sparkling and fast.
The gorz-men and the spearmen clashed and surged;
A night of dust above the plain emerged.
یکی رزمگاهی بیاراستند
یلان هم نبردان همی خواستند
بکردند یک تیرباران نخست
بسان تگرگ بهاران درست
بشد آفتاب از جهان ناپدید
چه داند کسی کان شگفتی ندید
بپوشیده شد چشمهٔ آفتاب
ز پیکانهاشان درفشان چو آب
تو گفتی جهان ابر دارد همی
وزان ابر الماس بارد همی
وزان گرزداران و نیزه‌وران
همی تاختند آن برین این بران
Ganjoor Ganjoor Goshtasb sh12:7; running poem body

English 7–12; individual four-source accounts and actual apparatus linked below. Provisional supplementary readings excluded from confident interpretation.

All four present ordered ranks, challenges, a hail-like volley, the hidden sun, glittering arrowheads, diamond rain and the opposing mace-bearers and spearmen. English redistributes the volley and vanished sunlight across adjacent couplets, leaving the eyewitness challenge to stand separately. Few could believe changes the Persian question about knowing into a question about belief, sharpening the marvelous scale of the storm. Ocean waters has direct support in Mohl and a Khaleghi variant; the other main texts offer the broader water comparison. The diamond image therefore remains part of the poem’s linked weather metaphors, not ornamental invention by the translation. Dust supplies an explanation for the nightlike atmosphere, which the source names without specifying its cause in that unit.

13–18Ardeshir’s splendor and the first death
13–18
The earth was drowned in gore from side to side,
And darkness spread across that crimson tide.
First came Ardeshir, the great Shah’s son,
A horseman fair, with battle just begun.
Like some mad elephant he crossed the field;
He seemed like Tus beneath his lifted shield.
He wheeled before the battle-line below;
He did not know what Fate would soon bestow.
An arrow pierced his waist through jowshan’s scale,
And from his bay he tumbled, pierced and pale.
Dust mixed with blood to mar his former grace;
Woe for the moonlike beauty of his face!
هوازی جهان بود شبگون شده
زمین سربسر پاک گلگون شده
بیامد نخست آن سوار هژیر
پس شهریار جهان اردشیر
به آوردگه رفت نیزه به دست
تو گفتی مگر طوس اسپهبدست
برین سان همی گشت پیش سپاه
نبود آگه از بخش خورشید و ماه
بیامد یکی ناوکش بر میان
گذارنده شد بر سلیح کیان
ز بور اندر افتاد خسرو نگون
تن پاکش آلوده شد پر ز خون
دریغ آن نکو روی همرنگ ماه
که بازش ندید آن خردمند شاه
Ganjoor Ganjoor Goshtasb sh12:13; running poem body

English 13–18; individual four-source accounts and actual apparatus linked below. Provisional supplementary readings excluded from confident interpretation.

Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi set blood-dark earth against Ardeshir’s distinguished entrance and moonlike beauty. English mad elephant follows Mohl and actual Moscow and Khaleghi variants, although the other main readings give him a lance; the lifted shield is an additional specification. Fate compresses the dispensation of sun and moon into an immediately intelligible power. The fatal waist wound, armor penetration and fall from a bay horse are all supported, but jowshan scales specify a construction that the checked readings do not name. Dust mixed with blood follows Mohl’s explicit wording. Khaleghi’s supplementary reflections and extended lament are registered separately, with difficult passages left provisional, so the translation’s shorter grief is compared with actual evidence rather than reconstructed additions.

19–24Hormizd’s revenge repeats the catastrophe
19–24
The wise Shah never would behold him more;
Then Hormizd, brave and fair, rode out to war.
His cheeks like tulips glowed a fiery red;
A poisoned khanjar in his hand, he sped.
He roared as lions roar before they bring
Wild asses down beneath their deadly spring.
For that slain prince he made the foemen pay:
A thousand enemy riders fell that day.
But as he turned back from the furious fray,
The earth lay red with blood along his way.
An arrow struck his nape and laid him low;
The noble prince fell dead beneath the blow.
بیامد بر شاه شیر اورمزد
کجا زو گرفتی شهنشاه پزد
ز پیش اندر آمد به دشت اندرا
به زهر آب داده یکی خنجرا
خروشی برآورد برسان شیر
که آورد خواهد ژیان گور زیر
ابر کین آن شاهزاده سوار
بکشت از سواران دشمن هزار
به هنگامهٔ بازگشتن ز جنگ
که روی زمین گشته بد لاله رنگ
بیامد یکی تیرش اندر قفا
شد آن خسرو شاهزاده فنا
Ganjoor Ganjoor Goshtasb sh12:20; running poem body

English 19–24; individual four-source accounts and actual apparatus linked below. Provisional supplementary readings excluded from confident interpretation.

The four sources preserve Hormizd’s entry, poisoned dagger, lionlike roar, revenge for the fallen prince, thousand slain horsemen, return and fatal nape wound. English tulip cheeks follows Mohl and actual Moscow and Khaleghi variants; the difficult alternative main wording about the king remains explicitly provisional. Thus the attractive portrait has independent support even where another reading cannot be confidently explained. Wild asses and the deadly spring develop the lion comparison into a fuller hunting action. Made the foemen pay keeps vengeance central rather than presenting the thousand deaths as an unrelated feat. Blood-red ground selects the martial force of the color imagery, and fell dead states the outcome plainly. The first prince’s paternal lament leads directly into a second comparable loss.

25–30Shidasp’s horse, weapons and challenge
25–30
His father would not see his son again;
Then Prince Shidasp rode forward toward the men.
Moon-faced, of royal mien and warrior pride,
He sat an indigo steed, huge in stride.
His horse had all an elephant’s great might,
And sped like wind as he rode out to fight.
He wheeled and brandished high the lance in hand,
Then checked his charger, shouting his demand:
“Where is Kuhram, that mighty warrior? Where
Is he whose form both wolf and tiger share?”
A Div replied, “I am!” His challenge rang:
“I fight the hungry lion, fang to fang!”
دریغ آن نبرده گرانمایه گرد
که نادیده او را پدر خود بمرد
بیامد پسش باز شیدسپ شاه
که مانندهٔ شاه بد همچو ماه
یکی دیزه‌ای بر نشسته چو نیل
به تگ همچو آهو به تن همچو پیل
به آوردگه گشت و نیزه بگاشت
چو لختی بگردید نیزه بداشت
کدامست گفتا کهرم سترگ
کجا پیکرش پیکر پیر گرگ
بیامد یکی دیو گفتا منم
که با گرسنه شیر دندان زنم
Ganjoor Mohl IV201:507; running lament; normalized transcription. Shidasp arrival shared with English26.

English 25–30; individual four-source accounts and actual apparatus linked below. Provisional supplementary readings excluded from confident interpretation.

The repeated paternal lament is running text in Mohl and Khaleghi and an actual Moscow apparatus verse; Ganjoor has a checked gap. English therefore preserves an attested refrain. All four then introduce moonlike Shidasp and an elephant-bodied horse. Indigo is independently supported by Moscow and Mohl, although Khaleghi marks its corresponding word as an editorial conjecture; wind-speed follows Mohl against the gazelle comparison elsewhere. The English lance follows Moscow, and checking the charger follows Mohl’s horse wording. Wolf and tiger likewise has Mohl and actual variant support, rather than only the old wolf of other main texts. The challenge names Kuhram, but the respondent is an unnamed Div; commentary must preserve that distinction instead of certifying Kuhram’s death from the exchange.

31–35Victory gives way to the evil eye
31–35
Shidasp’s lance unhorsed him; he took his head,
And cast his golden belt beside the dead.
Before the men of Chin, Shidasp wheeled round,
A mountain in the saddle, iron-bound.
No eye had seen his like; his beauty drew
The evil eye upon him as he flew.
A Turk then drew his bow; the arrow sped,
And struck the prince, who fell among the dead.
Alas, that gently nurtured prince died then;
His father would not see his face again.
به نیزه بگشتند هر دو چو باد
بزد ترک را نیزهٔ شاهزاد
ز باره در آورد و ببرید سر
به خاک اندر افگنده زرین کمر
همی گشت بر پیش گردان چین
بسان یکی کوه بر پشت زین
همانا چنو نیز دیده ندید
ز خوبی کجا بود چشمش رسید
یکی ترک تیری برو برگماشت
ز پشتش سر تیر بیرون گذاشت
دریغ آن شه پروریده به ناز
بشد روی او باب نادیده باز
Ganjoor Ganjoor Goshtasb sh12:31, sh12:32; running poem body

English 31–35; individual four-source accounts and actual apparatus linked below. Provisional supplementary readings excluded from confident interpretation.

Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi share the lance encounter, unhorsing, beheading, golden belt, mountainlike rider, extraordinary beauty and final arrow. English condenses two Persian units into the decisive actions, reducing the reciprocal maneuver without dropping the belt. Iron-bound adds an armor description to the secure mountain simile. The evil eye makes the adverse force of the beauty-and-eye idiom explicit, while the next couplet identifies the actual Turkish archer. Moscow and Ganjoor describe an arrowhead emerging through the prince’s back; Mohl and Khaleghi give a direct death formula, which English follows. The closing paternal lament restores the private cost after public prowess. Khaleghi’s further apparatus lament remains separately recorded, and Jamasp’s son begins the next chapter.

Source record and limits

Published scope and alignment

C6.12, The Opening of the Battle, contains 35 published English couplets, from sunrise over the armies through the final lament for Shidasp. C6.13, Girami and Nivzar Are Slain, begins with Jamasp’s son leaving the army. The 47 register records comprise 35 English accounts and 12 source-only apparatus units. All 36 Ganjoor sh12 units are allocated once. English17 groups its units17–18; English31 groups31–32. English25 uses Mohl’s running lament as its Persian reference, with Shidasp’s arrival cross-referenced to the next record. Shared half-lines and imagery are linked without recounting them.

Moscow: main text and actual variants

Moscow VI97:466–473, VI98:474–488 and VI99:489–501 supplies 36 unbracketed main units. Actual VI99n5 prints the father’s lament after Hormizd’s death, supporting English25 despite the main-text gap490→491. Actual98n18 supports the maddened-elephant reading;98n30 supports tulip cheeks;99n18 supports the tiger/wolf form. Main482 has armor penetration, without scales;483 has the fall from a bay;500 gives the arrowhead emerging through Shidasp’s back. Note99n35 discusses the alternate fatal formula. Khaleghi’s further additions have individually checked local gaps in this Moscow locus.

Mohl: continuous Persian sequence

The consulted Persian Mohl IV200:482–490, IV201:491–515 and IV202:516–518 supplies 37 unbracketed main units. Main491 has the sea-water comparison;496 the maddened elephant and Tus;499 dust and blood;501 Hormizd’s tulip cheeks;507 the repeated paternal lament. Main509 compares the horse’s speed to wind;510 has a mace and halting the horse;511 a tiger/wolf form. Main513–514 supplies the lance strike and beheading, so the earlier mace reading does not remove the later lance. Main517 states Shidasp’s death directly. The independent reprint imprint remains unverified; the actual Persian volume, pages and verse locators identify the inspected text.

Ganjoor: reference and bounded gap

Goshtasb sh12:1–36 supplies the complete running poem reference, excluding automated prose and reader comments. Units17–18 and31–32 are grouped under English17 and31. Its25→26 sequence lacks the separate paternal lament printed by Mohl and Khaleghi and in Moscow’s apparatus. Main10 has water rather than explicit sea;15 lance rather than maddened elephant;27 gazelle speed;29 old wolf;35 the arrowhead passing through the back. These differences are retained rather than treated as evidence against choices verified in the primary editions.

Khaleghi: running text, actual additions and conjecture

Khaleghi V120:472–478, V121:479–489, V122:490–498 and V123:499–508 supplies 37 unbracketed main units. Main497 is the paternal lament supporting English25. Actual121n26 prints three supplementary reflections after487;122n1 prints eight lament units after490;123n29 prints one further lament after508. They are individually registered as S1–S12. Actual120n15 prints a related mounting/watching unit at another placement, treated as alternate placement of the existing event. Actual121n7 supports sea;121n21 elephant;122n3 tulip cheeks;123n9 tiger/wolf. Main499’s نیل is marked an editorial conjecture at123n3, not an unqualified manuscript reading; Moscow and Mohl independently support the English color. Main507 gives the direct death formula.

Evidence classes and provisional passages

All numbered running units in this scope are unbracketed. Moscow99n5 is an actual printed verse supporting English25, not merely a notice of an addition. The twelve Khaleghi supplementary units are actual apparatus, separately transcribed; none is called appendix evidence. No appendix is used or certified. Khaleghi121n26 unit3 and122n1 units5,6,8 retain unresolved syntax or referents; confident readings are not manufactured from their context. Moscow485/Ganjoor20/Khaleghi491’s second half remains interpretively provisional; Hormizd’s identity and Mohl’s tulip-cheek alternative are independently verified. Checked local gaps refer only to the cited locus, not every manuscript.

English choices and retained qualifications

The horse armor at5, maddened elephant at15, ocean at10, dust and blood at18, tulip cheeks at20, paternal refrain at25, wind-speed at27 and wolf/tiger at29 have actual source support. English3 adds an equipment list;15 adds a lifted shield;17 specifies jowshan scales beyond the checked armor terms;32 adds iron-bound. The named challenge does not independently identify the slain respondent as Kuhram. English34 follows Mohl/Khaleghi’s direct death wording rather than the Moscow/Ganjoor through-back trajectory. Published English and every inherited provisional flag remain unchanged.

Selected readings

Locator and evidence classNormalized excerpt
Moscow VI97:470 running; horse armorبرو بر فگندند برگستوان
Mohl IV201:491 running; ocean comparisonز پیکانهاشان چو دریای آب
Mohl IV201:496 running; elephantبآوردگه رفت چون پیل مست
Moscow VI98:482 running; armor without scalesگذارنده شد بر سلیح کیان
Mohl IV201:499 running; dust and bloodتن شاهوارش پر از خاک و خون
Mohl IV201:501 running; tulip cheeksدو رخساره چون لاله اندر فزرد
Mohl IV201:507 running; father’s lossکه نادیده او را پدر خود بمرد
Khaleghi V123:499 main; نیل marked conjectural at123n3یکی دیزه‌ای برنشسته نیل
Mohl IV201:509 running; wind-speedبه تندی چو باد و به تن کوه پیل
Mohl IV201:511 running; tiger and wolfکجا پیکرش پیکر ببر و گرگ
Moscow VI99:500 running; through-back woundز پشتش سر تیر بیرون گذاشت
Khaleghi V123:507 running; death formulaروا گشت زان تیر او شاهزاد

Source links and detailed records

English; Moscow; Mohl; Ganjoor; Khaleghi;

C6.12 · Printed verse collation

English coupletMoscowMohl
1VI97:466 (running text)IV200:482 (running text)
2VI97:467 (running text)IV200:483 (running text)
3VI97:468 (running text)IV200:484 (running text)
4VI97:469 (running text)IV200:485 (running text)
5VI97:470 (running text)IV200:486 (running text)
6VI97:471 (running text)IV200:487 (running text)
7VI97:472 (running text); VI97:473 (shared wording; see comparison)IV200:488 (running text); IV200:489 (shared wording; see comparison)
8VI97:473 (running text); VI98:474 (shared wording; see comparison)IV200:489 (running text); IV200:490 (shared wording; see comparison)
9VI98:474 (running text)IV200:490 (running text)
10VI98:475 (running text)IV201:491 (running text)
11VI98:476 (running text)IV201:492 (running text)
12VI98:477 (running text); VI98:478 (shared wording; see comparison)IV201:493 (running text); IV201:494 (shared wording; see comparison)
13VI98:478 (running text)IV201:494 (running text)
14VI98:479 (running text)IV201:495 (running text)
15VI98:480 (running text)IV201:496 (running text)
16VI98:481 (running text)IV201:497 (running text)
17VI98:482 (running text); VI98:483 (running text)IV201:498 (running text); IV201:499 (running text)
18VI98:484 (running text); VI98:483 (shared wording; see comparison)IV201:500 (running text); IV201:499 (shared wording; see comparison)
19VI98:485 (running text); VI98:484 (shared wording; see comparison)IV201:501 (running text); IV201:500 (shared wording; see comparison)
20VI98:486 (running text); VI98n30 (actual tulip-cheek variant)IV201:502 (running text); IV201:501 (tulip cheeks shared with English19)
21VI98:487 (running text)IV201:503 (running text)
22VI98:488 (running text)IV201:504 (running text)
23VI99:489 (running text)IV201:505 (running text)
24VI99:490 (running text)IV201:506 (running text)
25VI99n5 (actual printed addition after490); VI99:491 (arrival shared with English26)IV201:507 (running lament); IV201:508 (arrival shared with English26)
26VI99:491 (running text); VI99:492 (shared wording; see comparison)IV201:508 (running text); IV201:509 (shared wording; see comparison)
27VI99:492 (running text)IV201:509 (running text)
28VI99:493 (running text)IV201:510 (running text)
29VI99:494 (running text)IV201:511 (running text)
30VI99:495 (running text)IV201:512 (running text)
31VI99:496 (running text); VI99:497 (running text)IV201:513 (running text); IV201:514 (running text)
32VI99:498 (running text)IV201:515 (running text)
33VI99:499 (running text)IV202:516 (running text)
34VI99:500 (running text)IV202:517 (running text)
35VI99:501 (running text)IV202:518 (running text)