Lohrasp Falls at Balkh
53 published couplets; Lohrasp Falls at Balkh.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 53 published couplets; Lohrasp Falls at Balkh. |
| Moscow | VI138–141:34–89,56 running units; plunder-preparation is actual139n6 apparatus, not main text. |
| Mohl | IV225–228:1070–1126,57 running units; includes plunder-preparation1087 and final mobad/killer reading1126. |
| Ganjoor | Goshtasb sh27:1–56,all56 units allocated once; shared clauses explicitly cross-referenced. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | V178–183:1063–1119,57 running units;includes1080 plunder-preparation,with selected actual apparatus separate. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The renewed tale and Arjasp’s orders
Moscow and Mohl individually checked at the linked printed pages; Ganjoor sh27 and Khaleghi main/apparatus accounts appear separately in the register. Shared units and local gaps are explicitly labeled.
Moscow printed p.138 · Mohl printed p.225 · Mohl printed p.226 · Khaleghi printed p.178 · Khaleghi printed p.179 · Ganjoor sh27 aligned passage
All four reopen the war through a garden-clearing image, so English ‘root to core’ belongs to poetic renewal rather than military destruction. Kuhram is then appointed, described as the elder son and ordered to choose suitable riders. The English captures that hierarchy but omits the thousand specified by every source; it should not be treated as an exact rendering of the troop instruction. ‘Sword in hand’ makes a sword-striker’s epithet physical, while Iran anticipates the destination. The dark and bitter days caused by Balkh become damaged hopes and gall. Finally, Arjasp’s hostile labels for fire-worshippers gain an ancestral-gods explanation in English. That explanation is interpretive, and the invective remains the enemy speaker’s perspective.
7–12Threats, a captive and promised conquest
Moscow and Mohl individually checked at the linked printed pages; Ganjoor sh27 and Khaleghi main/apparatus accounts appear separately in the register. Shared units and local gaps are explicitly labeled.
Moscow printed p.138 · Mohl printed p.226 · Khaleghi printed p.179 · Ganjoor sh27 aligned passage
The four texts explicitly command beheading and burning, with night replacing bright day and palace smoke reaching the blue sky. English flame ‘licking’ develops the tongue image without changing the target. The order against Esfandiyar is conditional: finding him bound would permit his execution. English divides that threat across two couplets, and none should be read as an actual death in this chapter. Khaleghi’s named-renown wording helps explain the English insertion of Kuhram’s name. The sword-and-sheath metaphor makes conquest sound effortless, still in Arjasp’s speech. His promised arrival names Khallokh in all four, but Khaleghi expressly refuses delay where Moscow and Ganjoor allow a short time. English ‘fair’ supplies color without independently locating the place.
13–18A pledge and the invading army
Moscow and Mohl individually checked at the linked printed pages; Ganjoor sh27 and Khaleghi main/apparatus accounts appear separately in the register. Shared units and local gaps are explicitly labeled.
Moscow printed p.138 · Moscow printed p.139 · Mohl printed p.226 · Khaleghi printed p.179 · Khaleghi printed p.180 · Ganjoor sh27 aligned passage
Calling in scattered troops and distributing amassed treasure reverse two kinds of concentration in all four accounts. Mohl then gives the life-as-hostage pledge preserved by English; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi make obedience a joy to the soul. The sun’s drawn sword is shared, although night either disappears as an army or gathers its skirt. English turns this into flight before light. Mohl and Khaleghi support marching to Iran against Moscow and Ganjoor’s departure from Turan. The English storm-clouds and dust replace the Persian complexion simile while retaining darkness. At the frontier, the sources differ between fire-worshippers, Mohl’s hostile religious labels and Khaleghi’s general victims. ‘God’s own servants’ is the English narrator’s sympathetic identification, not their shared literal wording.
19–24Lohrasp hears and prays
Moscow and Mohl individually checked at the linked printed pages; Ganjoor sh27 and Khaleghi main/apparatus accounts appear separately in the register. Shared units and local gaps are explicitly labeled.
Moscow printed p.139 · Mohl printed p.226 · Khaleghi printed p.180 · Ganjoor sh27 aligned passage
The separate preparation for killing and plunder is Mohl and Khaleghi running text and actually printed Moscow apparatus; Ganjoor lacks that unit locally. English adds vengeance and wrath to its deliberate preparation. The next couplet compresses bitter enemy speech and Lohrasp’s grief, then expands the prayer’s declaration that God stands above time into a wise word ruling its turns. Moscow and Ganjoor support ‘enduring’ where Mohl and Khaleghi have other divine attributes. Faith moves from the following source unit into English22, while bodily and mental protection fill23. Mohl, Moscow and Ganjoor support God as strength or support; Khaleghi instead expressly rejects fear in the plea. These distributions preserve a continuous prayer without inventing separate divine answers.
25–30The retired king returns to battle
Moscow and Mohl individually checked at the linked printed pages; Ganjoor sh27 and Khaleghi main/apparatus accounts appear separately in the register. Shared units and local gaps are explicitly labeled.
Moscow printed p.139 · Mohl printed p.226 · Mohl printed p.227 · Khaleghi printed p.180 · Khaleghi printed p.181 · Ganjoor sh27 aligned passage
All four distinguish the missing mace-bearing elite from a thousand men of the marketplace. English combines those details and then follows Mohl’s explicit judgment of military unfitness; Khaleghi likewise says they had not seen battle. This defensive thousand is separate from the invading thousand omitted earlier. Lohrasp leaves worship in war armor and a Kayanian helmet, keeping his religious and royal identities together. The elephant’s roar and ox-shaped mace are distributed across two English couplets. Mohl’s several chiefs support the plural opponents where the other texts retain a sorcerous fighter. The resemblance to Esfandiyar is also significant: Mohl and Khaleghi compare the stroke, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor identify the warrior as Esfandiyar. English wisely follows the comparative wording.
31–36Encirclement defeats individual prowess
Moscow and Mohl individually checked at the linked printed pages; Ganjoor sh27 and Khaleghi main/apparatus accounts appear separately in the register. Shared units and local gaps are explicitly labeled.
Moscow printed p.140 · Mohl printed p.227 · Khaleghi printed p.181 · Ganjoor sh27 aligned passage
Two source units become the English dust-and-blood charge and broken courage, preserving both visible violence and the psychological force of Lohrasp’s voice. Kuhram’s answer is collective tactics: every source forbids individual combat, demands enclosure and invokes a fierce lion’s cry. English redistributes the roar and surrounding order across32–33; they remain one tactical sequence, not two separate attacks. Axe blows and riders’ cries then close the ring. Lohrasp’s helpless invocation of God is explicit in all four, while ‘old and faithful’ recalls his established identity. Age, sunlight and sleeping fortune combine in the sources; English makes the distress affect breathing and anticipates death. These additions intensify exhaustion without replacing the assailants’ responsibility.
37–42Death and the discovery of age
Moscow and Mohl individually checked at the linked printed pages; Ganjoor sh27 and Khaleghi main/apparatus accounts appear separately in the register. Shared units and local gaps are explicitly labeled.
Moscow printed p.140 · Mohl printed p.227 · Khaleghi printed p.182 · Ganjoor sh27 aligned passage
Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi expressly wound Lohrasp with Turkish arrows; Mohl names the Turks without specifying that weapon. English therefore has direct support for the fatal arrows while making their mortal outcome explicit. The gathered horsemen and sword-cut body are common to all four. Their assumption that the victim is young fails when the helmet is removed. Camphor hair appears throughout, but Moscow and Ganjoor also contrast an initially ruby face with its blackening by iron; Mohl and Khaleghi omit that initial color clause. English ‘once bright’ interprets the contrast. The ensuing wonder at an old swordsman is posthumous recognition, not a revival. ‘Youthful strength’ carries forward the attackers’ mistaken estimate of his age.
43–48Kuhram interprets the victory
Moscow and Mohl individually checked at the linked printed pages; Ganjoor sh27 and Khaleghi main/apparatus accounts appear separately in the register. Shared units and local gaps are explicitly labeled.
Moscow printed p.140 · Moscow printed p.141 · Mohl printed p.227 · Khaleghi printed p.182 · Khaleghi printed p.183 · Ganjoor sh27 aligned passage
All four make the troops imagine the much harder encounter that Esfandiyar’s arrival would bring, then question their fewness through herdless grazing. English supplies the implied beasts and new pasture, without giving a fresh troop count. Kuhram responds by identifying the fallen king and presenting the hardest work as over. The English superlatives sharpen his reassurance; they are his claim, not a forecast certified by the narrative. Father and son are described in opposite grammatical directions across the sources but identify the same relationship. English combines divine farr, career and retirement. Mohl supports banquet beside the field, with banquet variants printed in Moscow and Khaleghi. The trembling crown translates Kuhram’s conclusion about lost support rather than recording Goshtasb’s immediate deposition.
49–53The temple and the uncertain killer
Moscow and Mohl individually checked at the linked printed pages; Ganjoor sh27 and Khaleghi main/apparatus accounts appear separately in the register. Shared units and local gaps are explicitly labeled.
Moscow printed p.141 · Mohl printed p.227 · Mohl printed p.228 · Khaleghi printed p.183 · Ganjoor sh27 aligned passage
The primary texts and Ganjoor bring the army into Balkh; Khaleghi names Arjasp. English follows the collective entrant and preserves killing, plunder and the gold-adorned temple. Burning the sacred text is unanimous, but the valuable objects divide the witnesses: Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi gather them, while Mohl burns them. English spoils follows the former three. Eighty worshippers are explicit; ‘priests’ interprets their setting and devotion rather than a separately assigned office for every man. The closing uncertainty is genuinely Mohl’s adopted reading, with printed Moscow and Khaleghi variants; their main texts and Ganjoor instead give the victims heaven. Blood extinguishes Zardosht’s fire in all four, but that possessive does not securely identify the singular killed mobad as Zardosht.
Source record and limits
Published chapter and boundaries
The current index and chapter identify C6.27 as Lohrasp Falls at Balkh, 53 couplets. Its first unit resumes the war with a garden image; its last extinguishes Zardosht’s fire and, in English, asks who killed the priest. MoscowVI138–141:34–89 has56 main units; MohlIV225–228:1070–1126 has57; GanjoorGoshtasb sh27 has56; KhaleghiV178–183:1063–1119 has57. Khaleghi places the first transition before its Kuhram/Lohrasp heading. The next chapter, News of Lohrasp’s Death Reaches Goshtasb, starts with the wise woman at Moscow90, Mohl1127, Khaleghi1120 and is excluded.
Alignment and completeness
All English units and every corresponding running Persian unit are accounted for. English16–17 share the marching/darkness verse; 19 uses the extra main verse in Mohl and Khaleghi and actual Moscow apparatus. English20, 25, 31 and52 compress pairs. Faith and bodily protection are distributed across22–23; the mace across28–29; the surrounding order across32–33; identity, farr and career across46–47. Cross-references may repeat, but the declared Ganjoor allocations do not. S1–S7 are selected actual apparatus only, not additional adopted events.
Primary support and consequential variants
Mohl supports the life pledge1083, arrival in Iran1085, military unfitness1095, comparison with Esfandiyar1100, banquet1118 and the final uncertain killer1126. Moscow139n6 actually prints English19’s plunder-preparation, also Mohl1087/Khaleghi1080 running text; Ganjoor17→18 lacks it locally. Arrows are explicit in Moscow71/Ganjoor38/Khaleghi1101 but not Mohl1108. Moscow/Ganjoor identify the fighter as Esfandiyar; Mohl/Khaleghi compare his stroke. Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi gather valuables whereas Mohl1123 burns them. Moscow89/Ganjoor56/Khaleghi1119 give the victims heaven; Mohl1126 instead asks who killed the mobad. Actual Moscow141n13 and Khaleghi183n13 record mobad/killer variants. These are not interchangeable evidence classes.
Omissions and interpretive expansions
The opening thousand selected invaders is explicit in all four and omitted in English4; it must not be confused with the thousand market defenders in25. English17 replaces a human-complexion simile with clouds and dust. English6’s ancestral gods and18’s God’s own servants interpret religious identity rather than reproduce a shared literal clause. Breath, pride, superlative hardest victory, once-bright face, and kneeling develop narrative implications. The source’s conditional killing order for Esfandiyar is not a completed event. Eighty worshippers are explicit; the English designation priests is interpretive. Zardosht’s named fire does not itself identify the singular mobad whose killer is unknown in Mohl.
Actual apparatus and checked local gaps
Khaleghi178n8 prints S1, an added report of Goshtasb in Sistan; 179n19 prints three scout/report/command additions S2–S4; 180n20 prints S5, a further location reminder; 181n19 prints two encirclement additions S6–S7. English19’s actual Moscow139n6 verse is assigned to its English row, not repeated as a source-only event. Moscow140n30 and Khaleghi182n28 record banquet variants; Moscow141n13/Khaleghi183n13 record the final mobad variants. Main transitions in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor are checked locally for each S-record. No separate appendix was used or certified. Arabic prose and manuscript omission/relocation notices are not treated as additional Persian verse verification.
Provisional readings and limits
S2 quotes only its verified first half; the second half remains unverified. S6 likewise quotes only the first half, while the second half’s father/Kuhram/king wording and agency remain provisional. Place-name forms are retained rather than harmonized into an independently verified route. The Mohl reprint imprint remains unverified. All inherited flags and prior limits are preserved verbatim in CHECKPOINT.txt.
Selected verified readings
| Locus | Reading |
|---|---|
| Moscow VI138:37 | ز ترکان شایسته مردی هزار |
| Mohl IV226:1083 | بگفتار تو جان گروگان کنم |
| Khaleghi V179:1074 | من اکنون به خلّخ نجویم زمان |
| Mohl IV226:1086 | کسی را که بد بددین و بت پرست |
| Moscow VI139n6 actual addition | همه دل ز نیکی بپیراستند / به تاراج و کشتن بیاراستند |
| Khaleghi V181:1093 | ندارد مگر زخم اسفندیار |
| Moscow VI140:71 | جهاندیده از تیر ترکان بخست |
| Mohl IV227:1108 | جهاندیده را هم ترکان بخست |
| Mohl IV227:1118 | همه کار او بزم و میدان بود |
| Mohl IV228:1126 | ندانم که این موبد را که کشت |
| Khaleghi V183:1119 | ندانم جز از جایشان در بهشت |
Source links and captures
Moscow p.138 · Moscow p.139 · Moscow p.140 · Moscow p.141 · Mohl p.225 · Mohl p.226 · Mohl p.227 · Mohl p.228 · Khaleghi p.178 · Khaleghi p.179 · Khaleghi p.180 · Khaleghi p.181 · Khaleghi p.182 · Khaleghi p.183
C6.27 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI138:34 (running text) | IV225:1070 (running text) |
| 2 | VI138:35 (running text) | IV225:1071 (running text) |
| 3 | VI138:36 (running text) | IV225:1072 (running text) |
| 4 | VI138:37 (running text) | IV225:1073 (running text) |
| 5 | VI138:38 (running text) | IV225:1074 (running text) |
| 6 | VI138:39 (running text) | IV226:1075 (running text) |
| 7 | VI138:40 (running text) | IV226:1076 (running text) |
| 8 | VI138:41 (running text) | IV226:1077 (running text) |
| 9 | VI138:42 (running text) | IV226:1078 (running text) |
| 10 | VI138:43 (running text) | IV226:1079 (running text) |
| 11 | VI138:44 (running text) | IV226:1080 (running text) |
| 12 | VI138:45 (running text) | IV226:1081 (running text) |
| 13 | VI138:46 (running text) | IV226:1082 (running text) |
| 14 | VI139:47 (running text) | IV226:1083 (running text) |
| 15 | VI139:48 (running text) | IV226:1084 (running text) |
| 16 | VI139:49 (running text) | IV226:1085 (running text) |
| 17 | VI139:49 (running text) | IV226:1085 (running text) |
| 18 | VI139:50 (running text) | IV226:1086 (running text) |
| 19 | VI139:50→51 checked local main gap; VI139n6 actual addition | IV226:1087 (running text) |
| 20 | VI139:51, VI139:52 (running text) | IV226:1088, IV226:1089 (running text) |
| 21 | VI139:53 (running text) | IV226:1090 (running text) |
| 22 | VI139:54, VI139:55 (running text) | IV226:1091, IV226:1092 (running text) |
| 23 | VI139:55 (running text) | IV226:1092 (running text) |
| 24 | VI139:56 (running text) | IV226:1093 (running text) |
| 25 | VI139:57, VI139:58 (running text) | IV226:1094, IV226:1095 (running text) |
| 26 | VI139:58, VI139:59 (running text) | IV226:1095, IV226:1096 (running text) |
| 27 | VI139:60 (running text) | IV226:1097 (running text) |
| 28 | VI139:61 (running text) | IV226:1098 (running text) |
| 29 | VI139:61, VI139:62 (running text) | IV226:1098, IV226:1099 (running text) |
| 30 | VI139:63 (running text) | IV227:1100 (running text) |
| 31 | VI140:64, VI140:65 (running text) | IV227:1101, IV227:1102 (running text) |
| 32 | VI140:66, VI140:67 (running text) | IV227:1103, IV227:1104 (running text) |
| 33 | VI140:67 (running text) | IV227:1104 (running text) |
| 34 | VI140:68 (running text) | IV227:1105 (running text) |
| 35 | VI140:69 (running text) | IV227:1106 (running text) |
| 36 | VI140:70 (running text) | IV227:1107 (running text) |
| 37 | VI140:71 (running text) | IV227:1108 (running text) |
| 38 | VI140:72 (running text) | IV227:1109 (running text) |
| 39 | VI140:73 (running text) | IV227:1110 (running text) |
| 40 | VI140:74 (running text) | IV227:1111 (running text) |
| 41 | VI140:75 (running text) | IV227:1112 (running text) |
| 42 | VI140:76 (running text) | IV227:1113 (running text) |
| 43 | VI140:77 (running text) | IV227:1114 (running text) |
| 44 | VI140:78 (running text) | IV227:1115 (running text) |
| 45 | VI140:79 (running text) | IV227:1116 (running text) |
| 46 | VI140:80, VI140:81 (running text) | IV227:1117, IV227:1118 (running text) |
| 47 | VI140:81, VI140:82 (running text); VI140n30 actual banquet variant | IV227:1118, IV227:1119 (running text) |
| 48 | VI141:83 (running text) | IV227:1120 (running text) |
| 49 | VI141:84 (running text) | IV227:1121 (running text) |
| 50 | VI141:85 (running text) | IV227:1122 (running text) |
| 51 | VI141:86 (running text) | IV227:1123 (running text) |
| 52 | VI141:87, VI141:88 (running text) | IV227:1124, IV228:1125 (running text) |
| 53 | VI141:89 (running text); VI141n13 actual mobad/killer variant | IV228:1126 (running text) |
New Naqqali