Praise for Mahmud the Great King
Published C7.1, 25 couplets, preserved verbatim.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | Published C7.1, 25 couplets, preserved verbatim. |
| Moscow | Volume VI, pp.166–167:24 running couplets; additional catalogue in actual p.166 n5. |
| Mohl | Persian volume IV reprint, pp.245–246:1534–1558; 25 running couplets. Reprint imprint remains unverified. |
| Ganjoor | Seven Stages, sh1:1–24; poem body only, no summaries or comments. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | Volume V, p.218:1534–1537 and pp.219–220:1–20; actual p.218 n18 catalogue. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5A catalogue preserved outside the main text
Moscow VI166:1–4 and actual n5; Mohl IV245:1534–1538; Ganjoor sh1:1–4 with local gap for English2; Khaleghi V218:Goshtasb1534–1537 and actual n18.
Moscow printed p.166 · Mohl printed p.245 · Khaleghi printed p.218 · Ganjoor passage
The English opening presents the coming narrative as an act of renewal rather than merely announcing its subject. Its added gold metaphor anticipates the praise of generosity, although the shared Persian praises the freshness and quality of the words without that material image. The catalogue that follows has a firm textual basis in Mohl, with related verses actually printed below the main text in Moscow and Khaleghi. Its absence from Ganjoor therefore cannot establish an English invention. The English places this catalogue before the conditional appeal to fortune, following Mohl’s sequence. Royal backing then connects poetic ambition with patronage, while the retained farr and crown preserve the specifically regal terms of authorization.
6–9The sun’s crown and divided flower imagery
Moscow VI166:5–8 and nn10–15; Mohl IV245:1539–1542; Ganjoor sh1:5–8; Khaleghi V219:1–4 and nn2–9.
Moscow printed p.166 · Mohl printed p.245 · Khaleghi printed p.219 · Ganjoor passage
The movement from the king’s crown to the sun’s crown lets the panegyric grow out of the spring landscape. The English keeps Aries recognizable through the Ram, then adds renown to the joy of east and west, lending the astronomical scene a stronger courtly accent. The flowers are less uniform across editions. Mohl gives the tulip patience, which supports the English calmness, but assigns allure to the narcissus. The other three main texts give narcissus the threatening quality represented by its English scowl. The translation thus combines features distributed across witnesses. Flaming hyacinths, however, replaces the source’s contentious personification with a visual effect; no checked local reading establishes literal flame there.
10–14Storm, painting and the voice of love
Moscow VI166:9–10, VI167:11–13 and n10; Mohl IV245:1543–1547; Ganjoor sh1:9–13; Khaleghi V219:5–7, V220:8–9.
Moscow printed p.167 · Mohl printed p.245 · Khaleghi printed p.219 · Ganjoor passage
Fire and water occupy the same cloud, so the English storm keeps the source’s deliberately contrary emotions together. Its musical language is warranted by the printed musical clause, though that clause alone does not justify assigning the scene a particular religious ceremony. The awakened spectator then finds the world transformed into silk and painting. Making Mani’s art an explicit comparison clears the compressed Persian construction without requiring a specific historical artwork. Finally, the tears acquire an affectionate explanation. The English first person agrees particularly well with Mohl and Khaleghi. Its unspecified speaking presence allows the flowers and weather to remain connected, although it settles the grammatical voice more decisively than the participial wording in Moscow and Ganjoor.
15–19Generosity greater than seasonal rain
Moscow VI167:14–18 and actual n18 to v17; Mohl IV245:1548–1552; Ganjoor sh1:14–18; Khaleghi V220:10–14.
Moscow printed p.167 · Mohl printed p.245 · Khaleghi printed p.220 · Ganjoor passage
The landscape becomes an argument about royal generosity: rain sustains the earth, yet its season limits its service. The English makes the implied superiority unusually direct by promising daily bounty. That sharpens the praise without documenting a literal calendar of gifts. Its next comparison returns to the sun and extends illumination toward human recipients, preserving the passage’s progression from weather to benefaction. Gold is supported by Mohl and Khaleghi, as well as an actual Moscow apparatus variant; the pearls of Moscow’s main text and Ganjoor are not the only evidence. The door and hall supply a concrete courtly setting absent from these local verses, while the inclusion of poor and powerful remains faithful to all four accounts.
20–23Open-handedness and the condition of submission
Moscow VI167:19–22; Mohl IV245:1553–1554, IV246:1555–1556; Ganjoor sh1:19–22; Khaleghi V220:15–18.
Moscow printed p.167 · Mohl printed p.245 · Khaleghi printed p.220 · Ganjoor passage
The praise crosses a moral division when gifts reach both the pure and the impious. The English reinforces that breadth through a second antithesis, making the generosity sound comprehensively inclusive. The martial continuation nevertheless imposes a political condition: treasure goes to those who bow. All four texts sustain this combination of liberality and domination, so the passage should not be read as an unconditional rejection of coercion. The English makes the seizure of rulers’ heads into humbling them, softening bodily menace while retaining conquest. It also locates the king’s disregarded toil in the field, a plausible inference from the adjacent battle but a narrower circumstance than the Persian explicitly supplies.
24–25From the patron’s justice to the elder’s story
Moscow VI167:23–24; Mohl IV246:1557–1558; Ganjoor sh1:23–24; Khaleghi V220:19–20. The following narrative opening is outside C7.1.
Moscow printed p.167 · Mohl printed p.246 · Khaleghi printed p.220 · Ganjoor passage
The closing prayer asks that Mahmud govern and that generosity and justice exist through him. The English retains justice but turns the other virtue into prosperity, emphasizing a public consequence rather than the act of giving itself. This is an intelligible culmination of the rain and sunlight imagery, though the distinction matters when describing the political ideal expressed by the Persian. The final couplet then changes the source of authority from royal patron to experienced storyteller. English hear preserves the invitation, while learn of the stronghold reduces the separate injunction to learn from the elder. Keeping this turn within the praise chapter respects the published boundary and leaves the dehqan’s narrative staging for C7.2.
Source record and limits
Published scope and boundaries
C7.1 only: 25 English couplets; Moscow VI166–167:1–24 plus actual166n5; Mohl IV245–246:1534–1558; Ganjoor Seven Stages sh1:1–24; Khaleghi V218:Goshtasb1534–1537 plus actual218n18, V219–220:Seven Stages1–20. The first English couplet announces the Seven Stages; the last invites the elder’s story of Ruyin Dezh. Moscow’s next v25, Mohl’s next v1559 and Ganjoor sh2:1 begin the dehqan’s table. Khaleghi’s section heading falls after four opening couplets and must not be substituted for the English boundary. All 24 declared main units in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi and all 25 in Mohl are allocated once in the register. No source-only running unit remains.
Moscow evidence
The consulted Moscow volume VI file prints pp.166–167 on PDF pages166–167. Its running text comprises vv.1–24. Page166 n5 actually prints the additional catalogue associated with English2; n6 has further catalogue variants, whose complete wording is not adopted as the Persian reference. Page167 n18 explicitly records زر against main در, supporting gold at English18. Page167 n10 records a first-person crying variant. These are printed apparatus readings, not main text and not an unprinted notice of addition.
Mohl evidence
The consulted Persian volume IV reprint prints pp.245–246 on PDF pages251–252. The full running sequence1534–1558 is included. Verse1535 is the catalogue,1539 the sun,1542 the different flower attributes,1547 the first-person tears,1551 gold and musk,1558 the elder. The next verse1559 begins the dehqan’s table and is excluded. The volume identification and printed pagination are visible; the particular reprint’s bibliographic imprint remains unverified. No Mohl apparatus or appendix reading is invoked.
Ganjoor evidence
The complete declared reference is the 24 couplets of Seven Stages sh1, captured from the poem body. English2 has no counterpart between the first announcement and the conditional appeal in sh1:1–2; this is a checked local running-text gap, not evidence of absence from every witness. The remaining English couplets map one-to-one to these24 units. Ganjoor supplies the displayed Persian except for English2, whose Persian is separately labeled as Mohl running text.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
The consulted volume V prints pp.218–220 on PDF pages234–236. Goshtasb1534–1537 precede the Seven Stages heading, followed by newly numbered1–20. The actual apparatus at218n18 prints several catalogue versions corresponding to English2, including the Mohl-type ordering; the main sequence has a checked local gap for that unit. Page219:4 differs from Mohl’s flower attributes;220:9 has explicit first-person tears;220:13 has gold. Page220n21 also prints a dinar-request addition and220n25 an old-age alternative; these additional apparatus items are not declared running units, not used as positive support for English and not exhaustively collated here.
Selected readings and interpretive limits
English9 combines Mohl’s calm tulip with the threatening narcissus of the other three main texts. Its flaming hyacinth remains unsupported within the checked local passage; no speculative botanical or manuscript explanation is supplied. English18 gold is positively supported by Mohl1551, Khaleghi13 and actual Moscow167n18. English22 softens head-taking to humbling; English24 substitutes prosperity for explicit giving. These findings preserve the English unchanged. The musical clause is not treated as proof of a particular ritual; the Mani comparison is not identification of a surviving painting. No appendix has supplied evidence, and no volume-wide appendix absence claim is made. Selected apparatus only, not a complete diplomatic apparatus transcription.
C7.1 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI166:1 running text | IV245:1534 running text |
| 2 | VI166:n5 actual printed apparatus; running gap between vv.1–2 | IV245:1535 running text |
| 3 | VI166:2 running text | IV245:1536 running text |
| 4 | VI166:3 running text | IV245:1537 running text |
| 5 | VI166:4 running text | IV245:1538 running text |
| 6 | VI166:5 running text | IV245:1539 running text |
| 7 | VI166:6 running text | IV245:1540 running text |
| 8 | VI166:7 running text | IV245:1541 running text |
| 9 | VI166:8 running text | IV245:1542 running text |
| 10 | VI166:9 running text | IV245:1543 running text |
| 11 | VI166:10 running text | IV245:1544 running text |
| 12 | VI167:11 running text | IV245:1545 running text |
| 13 | VI167:12 running text | IV245:1546 running text |
| 14 | VI167:13 running text | IV245:1547 running text |
| 15 | VI167:14 running text | IV245:1548 running text |
| 16 | VI167:15 running text | IV245:1549 running text |
| 17 | VI167:16 running text | IV245:1550 running text |
| 18 | VI167:17 running text | IV245:1551 running text |
| 19 | VI167:18 running text | IV245:1552 running text |
| 20 | VI167:19 running text | IV245:1553 running text |
| 21 | VI167:20 running text | IV245:1554 running text |
| 22 | VI167:21 running text | IV246:1555 running text |
| 23 | VI167:22 running text | IV246:1556 running text |
| 24 | VI167:23 running text | IV246:1557 running text |
| 25 | VI167:24 running text | IV246:1558 running text |
New Naqqali