The Wolves of the First Stage
75 published couplets, verbatim; ends with the golden table.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 75 published couplets, verbatim; ends with the golden table. |
| Moscow | VI167–172:75 declared running units, plus selected actual apparatus. Grief99 reserved for C7.3. |
| Mohl | IV246–249:1559–1636;78 running units. Fuller departure and itinerary. Reprint imprint unverified. |
| Ganjoor | sh2:1–74 and sh3:2;75 declared units. sh3:1 reserved for C7.3. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | V221–228:21–96 and98;77 running units plus selected actual apparatus.97 reserved for C7.3. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Who holds the golden goblet
Moscow VI167:25–28, VI168:31 and actual167n30; Mohl IV246:1559–1564; Ganjoor sh2:1–4,7; Khaleghi V221:21–24,27 and actual221n7.
Moscow p.167 · Moscow p.168 · Mohl p.246 · Khaleghi p.221 · Ganjoor passage
The opening turns the laid table into a figure for storytelling, but the goblet’s position changes who appears to hold it. Mohl places the golden cup immediately after the dehqan’s introduction, making the English attribution intelligible. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi put it later, after the warriors sit at Esfandiyar’s table. The English therefore follows a printed alternative rather than inventing the performance. Its emotional preparation is freer: bitter speech and spirit become grief and wrath, while the explicit arrival at Balkh is shifted into the next couplet. Departure from the father has Mohl running support and actual apparatus parallels. These adjustments make a continuous narrative while reducing the other sequence’s change of speaker.
7–12Hospitality used to secure a guide
Moscow VI168:29–36 and actualn4; Mohl IV246:1565–1571; Ganjoor sh2:5–6,8–12; Khaleghi V221:25–31,V222:32 and actual221n13.
Moscow p.168 · Mohl p.246 · Khaleghi p.221 · Khaleghi p.222 · Ganjoor passage
The feast creates a setting for negotiation without making the captive an equal guest. Four cups precede the offer of political advancement, and the source’s repeated bonds remain consequential. The English foregrounds his suffering and gives the assembled chiefs a more explicitly ordered seating arrangement. Those details reinforce the distance between royal abundance and captive dependence, although proper seats and physical soreness are not independently specified. The promised crown and Turkish realm are securely shared across all four sources. English redistributes the conditional truth requirement and the later elevation image, allowing the offer to unfold across successive couplets. The resulting generosity must be read with its conditions intact, not as an accomplished grant of kingship.
13–18Protection and the threat of dismemberment
Moscow VI168:35–41; Mohl IV246:1570–1576; Ganjoor sh2:11–17; Khaleghi V221:31,V222:32–37.
Moscow p.168 · Mohl p.246 · Khaleghi p.221 · Khaleghi p.222 · Ganjoor passage
Victory and truthful guidance govern the promise, while protection extends beyond Gorgsar to the relations of his children. The English preserves that unusually broad assurance, giving the captive a concrete family interest in compliance. It also preserves the opposing penalty: division at the waist before an intimidated assembly. Calling the weapon a knife is less specific than the source’s dagger, but neither softens the method nor transfers the threat to someone else. Gorgsar’s response asks the ruler to behave as kingship requires. English wisdom makes that appeal sound like prudent personal judgment, whereas the Persian also invokes the obligations of royal status. All four texts support this exchange of protection, intimidation and conditional obedience.
19–24The fortress questioned and the journeys timed
Moscow VI168:42–46,VI169:47; Mohl IV246:1577,IV247:1578–1584; Ganjoor sh2:18–23; Khaleghi V222:38–42,V223:43–45.
Moscow p.168 · Moscow p.169 · Mohl p.246 · Mohl p.247 · Khaleghi p.222 · Khaleghi p.223 · Ganjoor passage
Esfandiyar asks practical questions before choosing his trial: location, routes, distance, danger, garrison and height. The English keeps that sequence of inquiry, though its guarded space broadens the final architectural question. Repeating the three roads across two couplets makes their number prominent without adding a fourth alternative to the earlier fork. The stated durations require care. The first journey takes three months and the second two; the fuller Mohl and Khaleghi passages help distinguish the itineraries compressed in Moscow and Ganjoor. English take two months away can mean that the second journey consumes two months, but it might also suggest a saving of two months. Only the former interpretation matches the checked sources.
25–30A fertile road and a consequential negation
Moscow VI169:47–51 and actualn5; Mohl IV247:1583–1588; Ganjoor sh2:23–27; Khaleghi V223:44–49.
Moscow p.169 · Mohl p.247 · Khaleghi p.223 · Ganjoor passage
The first road’s water, grazing and settlements are genuinely printed in Mohl and Khaleghi, with actual Moscow apparatus support, although Ganjoor lacks that fuller unit. The next route has scarce food and nowhere suitable to halt, yet all four running texts explicitly allow grass and water for animals. English denies both, converting a difficult provisioning problem into a more completely barren passage. The negative lodging clause cannot supply textual support for that change of polarity. The third route exchanges duration for danger, reaching the fortress on the eighth day. Its witch warning follows the clearer Mohl and Khaleghi syntax, which places her deception above the other dangers; that clarity should not be imposed silently on every reading.
31–36Reported marvels and a water-bound fortress
Moscow VI169:52–57; Mohl IV247:1589–1594; Ganjoor sh2:28–33; Khaleghi V223:50–51,V224:52–55.
Moscow p.169 · Mohl p.247 · Khaleghi p.223 · Khaleghi p.224 · Ganjoor passage
These marvels are still Gorgsar’s report. The witch can raise a victim toward the moon or cast one into a well, and the hero has not yet witnessed either act. English keeps the contrast between elevation and overthrow before passing through cold, wind and the Simorgh toward the fortress. The tower above the cloud continues the report’s extravagant scale. Weapons and troops are explicit, while stored supplies are an understandable anticipation of the later self-sufficiency claim. Similarly, the river’s width and clarity are English visual details rather than separate source specifications. The boat crossing for hunting remains concrete and shared: water protects the fortress but also governs ordinary movement between enclosure and surrounding plain.
37–42The shortest road chosen despite fear
Moscow VI169:58–60,VI170:61–64; Mohl IV247:1595–1601; Ganjoor sh2:34–40; Khaleghi V224:56–62.
Moscow p.169 · Moscow p.170 · Mohl p.247 · Khaleghi p.224 · Ganjoor passage
The century of endurance concerns the fortress’s ability to dispense with outside supplies. English broadens that boast into freedom from any need for the outer world, while its fields, fruit trees and mill preserve the material explanation. Esfandiyar’s troubled reaction matters: choosing the short route follows distress, not ignorance of danger. The warning that follows speaks of people who have effectively resigned themselves to death. English translates this as failure to survive, making the implication accessible, but substitutes skill for renown and restricts the general warning to kings. The hero’s answer then appropriates demonic power as a boast about courage. Neither that comparison nor his anxiety cancels the deliberately risky character of his choice.
43–48Wolves described before they are encountered
Moscow VI170:65–71; Mohl IV247:1602,IV248:1603–1608; Ganjoor sh2:41–47; Khaleghi V224:63,V225:64–69 and actual225n19.
Moscow p.170 · Mohl p.247 · Mohl p.248 · Khaleghi p.224 · Khaleghi p.225 · Ganjoor passage
Gorgsar’s description gives the wolves their composite anatomy before the encounter: male and female, elephantine bodies and tusks, staglike horns, broad upper bodies and lean waists. The English redistributes these traits across its couplets in the horn-before-tusk order found in Mohl and Khaleghi. Their longing for lion combat further establishes aggression without narrating an earlier battle with lions. Gorgsar remains bound when removed, so the wine has not secured his freedom. The following Kayanian cap is a particularly clear instance of positive Mohl support, reinforced by an actual Khaleghi apparatus reading. The other main texts describe observation of the feast instead. The English ceremonial detail should therefore be treated as a selected reading, not an unsupported ornament.
49–54A martial morning and a delegated command
Moscow VI170:72–77; Mohl IV248:1609–1614; Ganjoor sh2:48–53; Khaleghi V225:70–71,V226:72–75.
Moscow p.170 · Mohl p.248 · Khaleghi p.225 · Khaleghi p.226 · Ganjoor passage
The sunrise’s crown continues the royal imagery, but the English simplifies the strange disclosure between sky and earth into clear illumination. The next image abruptly darkens and hardens the world: iron below and ebony above suggest the massed army and its movement. The drum name is less exact. All four checked running texts give kus; tabiras is an English substitution without verified support in the local apparatus. The army’s good condition and joy remain shared, while long columns specify its arrangement. Choosing Bishutan then turns the scene from spectacle to responsibility. The published spelling is retained, and the man’s vigilance and protection of the troops identify his role without requiring a different character.
55–60The leader exposes himself and protects the army
Moscow VI170:77–79,VI171:80–82; Mohl IV248:1614–1619; Ganjoor sh2:53–58; Khaleghi V226:75–80.
Moscow p.170 · Moscow p.171 · Mohl p.248 · Khaleghi p.226 · Ganjoor passage
Esfandiyar’s admission of disturbance belongs beside his resolve to go first. The English makes fear overt and spells out that the army should remain behind, preserving the practical purpose of the delegation: danger to the commander must not become disaster for his followers. His arming retains the dark horse and war coat, although saddling generalizes the source’s tightening of the girth. The encounter resumes the earlier elephant comparison. Mohl varies the description toward formidable jaws, while the other main texts support the English emphasis on overall size. The wolves inspect the warrior’s physique and mace before charging. Iron on the mace and madness in their charge add specificity beyond these particular source units.
61–65Arrows weaken the wolves before the sword finishes them
Moscow VI171:83–88; Mohl IV248:1620–1625; Ganjoor sh2:59–64; Khaleghi V226:81–83,V227:84–86 and actual227n3.
Moscow p.171 · Mohl p.248 · Khaleghi p.226 · Khaleghi p.227 · Ganjoor passage
The combat has an intelligible order: the bow is strung, arrows weaken the beasts, their condition is observed, and the sword completes the work. English compresses the observation into the couplet where the blade is drawn, but does not turn the sword into the opening attack. Steel is explicit for the arrowheads, unlike the earlier added metal of the mace. Calling the wolves Divs translates the demonic comparison without introducing two additional opponents. The beheading also has positive evidence: Mohl prints heads being cut, and Khaleghi records that wording in actual apparatus beside the more general slashing of its main text. Blood mixing with dust into mud remains shared across all four accounts.
66–70Victory answered by dependence and prayer
Moscow VI171:89–93; Mohl IV248:1626–1627,IV249:1628–1630; Ganjoor sh2:65–69; Khaleghi V227:87–91.
Moscow p.171 · Mohl p.248 · Mohl p.249 · Khaleghi p.227 · Ganjoor passage
Dismounting reverses the combat’s display of power into confessed dependence. The English retains washing the body and weapons and seeking a clean place before facing the sun, although it removes the thorn-ground setting found in three main texts. The bodily orientation is explicit evidence; it need not be expanded into a reconstructed ritual. Dust, pain and prayer show that the warrior does not treat victory as self-sufficient prowess. English redistributes the divine gifts and the request for guidance across three couplets, preserving strength and judgment. Its final ethical path is narrower than guidance through both good and bad circumstances, while its declaration of trust develops the prayer rather than reproducing a separate Persian clause.
71–75The army’s astonishment and the closing feast
Moscow VI171:94–96,VI172:97–98,100; Mohl IV249:1631–1636; Ganjoor sh2:70–74 and sh3:2; Khaleghi V227:92–94,V228:95–96,98.
Moscow p.171 · Moscow p.172 · Mohl p.249 · Khaleghi p.227 · Khaleghi p.228 · Ganjoor passage
The army arrives while the hero is at prayer, allowing gratitude and public acclaim to meet in the same scene. Its question about wolves or elephants echoes the earlier description and turns it into eyewitness astonishment. The blessing of heart, sword and hand then binds martial excellence to royal greatness. English makes the dependence personal through without him; its royal feast also has Mohl support where the other main texts refer to military custom. The closing meal follows Mohl’s sequence. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi insert Gorgsar’s grief before that meal, but the published English opens C7.3 with the grief. Reserving that unit for the next chapter preserves the rearrangement without falsely calling it an omission.
Source record and limits
Published scope and allocation
C7.2 only:75 published English couplets. Moscow VI167–172:25–98 plus100; Mohl IV246–249:1559–1636; Ganjoor sh2:1–74 plus sh3:2; Khaleghi V221–228:21–96 plus98. Gorgsar’s grief (Moscow99/Ganjoor sh3:1/Khaleghi97/Mohl1637) is reserved for C7.3. The index names The Wolves of the First Stage. The opening is the dehqan’s laid table; the final feast precedes Gorgsar’s grief in English and Mohl, but follows it in the other three sources. The declared ranges are intentionally discontinuous. All75 Moscow and Ganjoor units,78 Mohl units and77 Khaleghi units are assigned in the register; overlapping English sense-units retain references without double-counting source allocations.
Moscow running text and apparatus
Volume VI printed167–172 equals PDF167–172. Running25–98 and100 are declared;99 is reserved. Actual167n30 prints departure from the father toward the Turkish road. Actual168n4 prints the captive’s bonds. Actual169n5 prints the fuller first-road itinerary. These additions are printed Persian evidence, not merely addition notices. Other local variants are checked where relevant but no exhaustive apparatus transcription is claimed. Main73 names kus;88 describes slashing without independently specifying severed heads.
Mohl running text
Persian volume IV reprint printed246–249 equals PDF252–255. Running1559–1636 is declared.1560 moves the goblet into the introductory sequence;1563 adds departure with Gorgsar;1583–1584 elaborate the first and second roads;1608 explicitly has the Kayanian cap;1625 cuts the wolves’ heads;1634 has bazm, supporting feast;1636 supplies the closing meal before grief1637. The specific reprint imprint remains unverified. These are running readings, not apparatus or appendix.
Ganjoor reference scope
The poem-body capture supplies sh2:1–74 and sh3:2. The entire intervening grief sh3:1 is explicitly reserved for C7.3, whose English opening translates it. The displayed Persian uses this reference except for English5 and25, labeled Mohl running excerpts. English5 has a checked local gap between sh2:3–4; English25’s first-road description has a checked local gap at23–24. These gaps establish only the local digital sequence, not universal manuscript absence.
Khaleghi-Motlagh running text and apparatus
Volume V printed221–228 equals PDF237–244. Running21–96 and98 is declared;97 is reserved. Actual221n7 prints the departure pair,221n13 the bound captive,225n19 the cap alternative,227n3 the heads-cut alternative. The full first-road unit44 is running text, as is the second-road food shortage45. None of these actual readings is inferred from a bare notice. Other apparatus additions are not declared running units and are not exhaustively transcribed.
Material readings and limits
All four affirm grass and watering for animals on the second road: Moscow48, Mohl1585, Ganjoor sh2:24, Khaleghi46. English26 denies them; the shortage of food and lack of a halting place do not reverse that affirmation. English50 tabiras lacks positive support in the checked kus locus. English65 heads-cut has Mohl1625 and actual Khaleghi227n3 support. English48 cap has Mohl1608 and actual Khaleghi225n19 support. English24 two months away means a two-month journey if read consistently with the sources. English4 psychological bitterness,34 stores,35 clear/wide river,59 iron mace and60 mad charge are distinguished from source wording. No historical geography, specific ritual reconstruction or zoological identification is certified.
Evidence classes and textual limits
Running text, actual printed apparatus, checked local gaps, reserve-for-next-section readings and interpretation remain distinct. No appendix supplied evidence and no volume-wide appendix absence claim is made.
Moscow printed167 · Moscow printed168 · Moscow printed169 · Moscow printed170 · Moscow printed171 · Moscow printed172
Mohl printed246 · Mohl printed247 · Mohl printed248 · Mohl printed249
Khaleghi printed221 · Khaleghi printed222 · Khaleghi printed223 · Khaleghi printed224 · Khaleghi printed225 · Khaleghi printed226 · Khaleghi printed227 · Khaleghi printed228
C7.2 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI167:25 running text | IV246:1559 running text |
| 2 | VI168:31 running text | IV246:1560 running text |
| 3 | VI167:26 running text | IV246:1561 running text |
| 4 | VI167:27 running text | IV246:1562 running text |
| 5 | VI167:n30 actual printed departure apparatus; main gap between27–28 | IV246:1563 running text |
| 6 | VI167:28 running text | IV246:1564 running text |
| 7 | VI168:29 running text | IV246:1565 running text |
| 8 | VI168:30 running text | IV246:1566 running text |
| 9 | VI168:32 running text | IV246:1567 running text |
| 10 | VI168:33 running text | IV246:1568 running text |
| 11 | VI168:34 running text | IV246:1569 running text |
| 12 | VI168:35 running text; VI168:36 running text | IV246:1570 running text; IV246:1571 running text |
| 13 | VI168:35 running text; VI168:36 running text | IV246:1570 running text; IV246:1571 running text |
| 14 | VI168:37 running text | IV246:1572 running text |
| 15 | VI168:38 running text | IV246:1573 running text |
| 16 | VI168:39 running text | IV246:1574 running text |
| 17 | VI168:40 running text | IV246:1575 running text |
| 18 | VI168:41 running text | IV246:1576 running text |
| 19 | VI168:42 running text | IV246:1577 running text |
| 20 | VI168:43 running text | IV247:1578 running text |
| 21 | VI168:44 running text | IV247:1579 running text |
| 22 | VI168:45 running text; VI168:46 running text | IV247:1580 running text; IV247:1581 running text |
| 23 | VI168:46 running text | IV247:1581 running text |
| 24 | VI169:47 running text | IV247:1582 running text; IV247:1584 running text |
| 25 | VI169:n5 actual printed first-road itinerary; main gap after47 | IV247:1583 running text |
| 26 | VI169:47 running text; VI169:48 running text | IV247:1584 running text; IV247:1585 running text |
| 27 | VI169:48 running text | IV247:1585 running text |
| 28 | VI169:49 running text | IV247:1586 running text |
| 29 | VI169:50 running text | IV247:1587 running text |
| 30 | VI169:51 running text | IV247:1588 running text |
| 31 | VI169:52 running text | IV247:1589 running text |
| 32 | VI169:53 running text | IV247:1590 running text |
| 33 | VI169:54 running text | IV247:1591 running text |
| 34 | VI169:55 running text | IV247:1592 running text |
| 35 | VI169:56 running text | IV247:1593 running text |
| 36 | VI169:57 running text | IV247:1594 running text |
| 37 | VI169:58 running text | IV247:1595 running text |
| 38 | VI169:59 running text | IV247:1596 running text |
| 39 | VI169:60 running text | IV247:1597 running text |
| 40 | VI170:61 running text | IV247:1598 running text |
| 41 | VI170:62 running text; VI170:63 running text | IV247:1599 running text; IV247:1600 running text |
| 42 | VI170:64 running text | IV247:1601 running text |
| 43 | VI170:65 running text | IV247:1602 running text |
| 44 | VI170:66 running text; VI170:67 running text | IV248:1603 running text; IV248:1604 running text |
| 45 | VI170:67 running text; VI170:69 running text | IV248:1604 running text; IV248:1605 running text |
| 46 | VI170:68 running text; VI170:69 running text | IV248:1605 running text; IV248:1606 running text |
| 47 | VI170:70 running text | IV248:1607 running text |
| 48 | VI170:71 running text | IV248:1608 running text |
| 49 | VI170:72 running text | IV248:1609 running text |
| 50 | VI170:73 running text | IV248:1610 running text |
| 51 | VI170:74 running text | IV248:1611 running text |
| 52 | VI170:74 running text; VI170:75 running text | IV248:1611 running text; IV248:1612 running text |
| 53 | VI170:76 running text | IV248:1613 running text |
| 54 | VI170:77 running text | IV248:1614 running text |
| 55 | VI170:77 running text; VI170:78 running text | IV248:1614 running text; IV248:1615 running text |
| 56 | VI170:78 running text | IV248:1615 running text |
| 57 | VI170:79 running text | IV248:1616 running text |
| 58 | VI171:80 running text | IV248:1617 running text |
| 59 | VI171:81 running text | IV248:1618 running text |
| 60 | VI171:82 running text | IV248:1619 running text |
| 61 | VI171:83 running text | IV248:1620 running text |
| 62 | VI171:84 running text | IV248:1621 running text |
| 63 | VI171:85 running text | IV248:1622 running text |
| 64 | VI171:86 running text; VI171:87 running text | IV248:1623 running text; IV248:1624 running text |
| 65 | VI171:88 running text | IV248:1625 running text |
| 66 | VI171:89 running text; VI171:90 running text | IV248:1626 running text; IV248:1627 running text |
| 67 | VI171:90 running text; VI171:91 running text | IV248:1627 running text; IV249:1628 running text |
| 68 | VI171:91 running text; VI171:92 running text | IV249:1628 running text; IV249:1629 running text |
| 69 | VI171:93 running text | IV249:1630 running text |
| 70 | VI171:92 running text; VI171:93 running text | IV249:1629 running text; IV249:1630 running text |
| 71 | VI171:94 running text | IV249:1631 running text |
| 72 | VI171:95 running text; VI171:96 running text | IV249:1632 running text; IV249:1633 running text |
| 73 | VI171:96 running text; VI172:97 running text | IV249:1633 running text; IV249:1634 running text |
| 74 | VI172:97 running text; VI172:98 running text | IV249:1634 running text; IV249:1635 running text |
| 75 | VI172:100 running text | IV249:1636 running text |
New Naqqali