The Sisters Recognize Esfandiyar
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Recognition begins with an effort not to be seen
Moscow: VI196:535 running text | VI196:536 running text | VI196:537 running text | VI196:538 running text | VI197:539 running text | VI197:540 running text; Mohl: IV267:2073 running text | IV267:2074 running text | IV267:2075 running text | IV267:2076 running text | IV267:2077 running text | IV267:2078 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:1, sh10:2, sh10:3, sh10:4, sh10:5, sh10:6; Khaleghi: V264:534 running text | V264:535 running text | V264:536 running text | V264:537 running text | V264:538 running text | V264:539 running text
Moscow p.196 · Moscow p.197 · Mohl p.267 · Khaleghi p.264 · Ganjoor passage
Sunset empties the market before the sisters enter it, so the commercial disguise meets a private obligation at the end of the working day. All four place jars on their shoulders and tears on their faces. The prince initially conceals himself rather than announcing rescue. English deep dismay gives the emotional force of his fear without deciding that he fears the women themselves. Moscow and Ganjoor place his face beneath gelim; Mohl and Khaleghi specify a sleeve of that material. English coarse wool gown generalizes the covering. The concealment therefore belongs to the immediate action, while its precise tailoring should not be reconstructed from the translation.
7–12The women frame captivity through a broken royal relationship
Moscow: VI197:541 running text; VI197:542 running text | VI197:543 running text | VI197:544 running text | VI197:545 running text | VI197:546 running text | VI197:546 running text; VI197:547 running text; Mohl: IV267:2079 running text; IV267:2079–2080 checked local caravan-origin question gap | IV267:2080 running text | IV268:2081 running text | IV268:2082 running text | IV268:2083 running text | IV268:2083 running text; IV268:2084 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:7, sh10:8, sh10:9, sh10:10, sh10:11, sh10:12, sh10:13; Khaleghi: V264:540 running text; V264:541 running text | V264:542 running text | V264:543 running text | V265:544 running text | V265:545 running text | V265:545 running text; V265:546 running text
Moscow p.197 · Mohl p.267 · Mohl p.268 · Khaleghi p.264 · Khaleghi p.265 · Ganjoor passage
Mohl addresses the merchant’s wealth without the separate question about his caravan’s origin found in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English follows that shorter address, then retains the blessing and request for news. Asking whether their brother is well makes welfare explicit within the source’s more general inquiry. Their royal identity does not protect them from water carrying or public exposure. All four contrast the father’s comfortable days and nights with the daughters’ condition. English unveiled renders bareheaded, but does not establish a particular garment or legal convention. The force of the passage is familial and political abandonment, expressed through bodily labor and the reversal of royal status.
13–18The offered cure provokes an apparently hostile answer
Moscow: VI197:547 running text | VI197:548 running text | VI197:549 running text | VI197:550 running text | VI197:551 running text | VI197:552 running text; Mohl: IV268:2084 running text | IV268:2085 running text | IV268:2086 running text | IV268:2087 running text | IV268:2088 running text | IV268:2089 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:13, sh10:14, sh10:15, sh10:16, sh10:17, sh10:18; Khaleghi: V265:546 running text | V265:547 running text | V265:548 running text | V265:549 running text | V265:550 running text | V265:551 running text
Moscow p.197 · Mohl p.268 · Khaleghi p.265 · Ganjoor passage
All four make the shroud preferable to continued public exposure. English blame gives the social humiliation a sharper explanatory term, while preserving the deathward direction of the wish. The healer metaphor then turns the merchant’s possible knowledge into a remedy: information from home could counter the poison of captivity. His sudden shout appears to refuse that role. The curse against Esfandiyar is self-directed under disguise, and the accompanying attack on Goshtasb preserves the scene’s bitter accusation. English perish extends the preceding curse into the father’s sentence. The crown and belt remain signs of a kingship whose justice the speaker is explicitly challenging.
19–24A voice creates knowledge that must remain secret
Moscow: VI197:553 running text | VI197:554 running text | VI197:555 running text | VI197:556 running text | VI198:557 running text | VI198:558 running text; Mohl: IV268:2090 running text | IV268:2091 running text | IV268:2092 running text | IV268:2093 running text | IV268:2094 running text | IV268:2095 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:19, sh10:20, sh10:21, sh10:22, sh10:23, sh10:24; Khaleghi: V265:552 running text | V265:553 running text | V265:554 running text | V265:555 running text | V265:556 running text | V265:557 running text
Moscow p.197 · Moscow p.198 · Mohl p.268 · Khaleghi p.265 · Ganjoor passage
The claim to work merely for food sustains the merchant’s performance even as his voice exposes him to Homahyi. All four let recognition restore her heart and require her to keep the knowledge hidden. English peace and brief release interpret that restoration without ending her distress: torn clothing, dusty feet and fear of Arjasp remain immediately visible. Her tears consequently do not mean failure to recognize him. The prince in turn recognizes her knowledge before uncovering his face. English veil refers to the existing covering in this sequence; it should not be treated as evidence for an additional costume item independent of the gelim already described.
25–30The purpose of arrival differs at the word of negation
Moscow: VI198:559 running text | VI198:560 running text | VI198:561 running text | VI198:562 running text | VI198:563 running text | VI198:564 running text; Mohl: IV268:2096 running text | IV268:2097 running text | IV268:2098 running text | IV268:2099 running text | IV268:2100 running text | IV268:2101 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:25, sh10:26, sh10:27, sh10:28, sh10:29, sh10:30; Khaleghi: V266:558 running text | V266:559 running text | V266:560 running text | V266:561 running text; V266:n7 actual positive war-reading alternatives | V266:562 running text | V266:563 running text
Moscow p.198 · Mohl p.268 · Khaleghi p.266 · Ganjoor passage
The sunlike face is revealed through tears, followed by lip-biting and a demand for silence. At the declaration of purpose, the sources divide materially. Mohl positively says that he came for war, supporting the English. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s running texts say that he did not come for war, while Khaleghi’s actual apparatus records positive alternatives. The following appeal to honor and shame remains shared, so the difference cannot be dismissed as decorative wording. The father’s sleep again contrasts with the children’s suffering. Replacing father and mother with sky and earth is an angry repudiation of failed kinship, not a literal revision of their genealogy.
31–36A merchant’s maritime ordeal prepares another stratagem
Moscow: VI198:565 running text; VI198:566 running text | VI198:567 running text | VI198:568 running text | VI198:569 running text | VI198:570 running text; Mohl: IV268:2102 running text; IV268:2103 running text | IV268:2104 running text | IV268:2105 running text | IV269:2106 running text | IV269:2107 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:31, sh10:32, sh10:33, sh10:34, sh10:35, sh10:36; Khaleghi: V266:564 running text; V266:565 running text | V266:566 running text | V266:567 running text | V266:568 running text | V266:569 running text
Moscow p.198 · Mohl p.268 · Mohl p.269 · Khaleghi p.266 · Ganjoor passage
All four move the prince rapidly from the sisters to Arjasp and give him a story about an unfamiliar deep sea and violent wind. This is speech delivered under an assumed identity; the narrative does not independently authenticate the voyage. English separates the storm from the boatman’s declaration, allowing the collective fear to unfold over successive couplets. Bodies roasted by suffering is a source image, with fire made explicit in English. The vow’s condition varies slightly: Mohl and Khaleghi stress returning alive to the place, Moscow and Ganjoor release from the sea’s danger. English escape alive combines those emphases while maintaining the supposed reason for gratitude.
37–42Generosity invites the men who must be disabled
Moscow: VI198:571 running text | VI198:572 running text | VI198:573 running text | VI199:574 running text | VI199:575 running text | VI199:576 running text; Mohl: IV269:2108 running text | IV269:2109 running text | IV269:2110 running text | IV269:2111 running text | IV269:2112 running text | IV269:2113 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:37, sh10:38, sh10:39, sh10:40, sh10:41, sh10:42; Khaleghi: V267:570 running text | V267:571 running text | V267:572 running text | V267:573 running text | V267:574 running text | V267:575 running text
Moscow p.198 · Moscow p.199 · Mohl p.269 · Khaleghi p.267 · Ganjoor passage
The promised feast and gifts to petitioners make the request appear to fulfill a religious obligation. All four include honor for the poor as well as the invitation to eminent warriors. English deeds and prowess explains why these men count as distinguished, while ornament of peace develops the source’s adornment of the soul. Arjasp’s pleasure is immediately judged through the image of a head filled with wind. English foolish pride interprets that image but keeps it visible. The scene thus allows the king to believe he is receiving a mark of respect while the reader recognizes that his approval gathers the very people whom the stratagem needs in one place.
43–48The location serves both hospitality and signaling
Moscow: VI199:577 running text | VI199:578 running text | VI199:579 running text | VI199:580 running text | VI199:581 running text; VI199:n20 actual Tir variant | VI199:582 running text; Mohl: IV269:2114 running text | IV269:2115 running text | IV269:2116 running text | IV269:2117 running text | IV269:2118 running text | IV269:2119 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:43, sh10:44, sh10:45, sh10:46, sh10:47, sh10:48; Khaleghi: V267:576 running text | V267:577 running text | V267:578 running text | V267:579 running text | V267:580 running text; V267:n25 actual Tir variant | V267:581 running text
Moscow p.199 · Mohl p.269 · Khaleghi p.267 · Ganjoor passage
All four authorize the feast, permit intoxication and accept the proposed move from a cramped residence to the fortress height. English near the sky emphasizes elevation, but the rampart is already explicit. The seasonal claim needs a distinct qualification: all four checked main texts name Mehr, an autumn month. English summer is compatible with the Tir alternatives actually printed in Moscow’s and Khaleghi’s apparatus, not with those main readings. That difference remains visible rather than silently corrected in the English. The king’s permission to sit wherever the guest wishes supplies the practical freedom needed to light a conspicuous fire above the fortress.
49–53The feast’s smoke performs a second function
Moscow: VI199:583 running text | VI199:584 running text | VI199:585 running text | VI199:586 running text | VI199:587 running text; Mohl: IV269:2120 running text | IV269:2121 running text | IV269:2122 running text | IV269:2123 running text | IV269:2124 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:49, sh10:50, sh10:51, sh10:52, sh10:53; Khaleghi: V267:582 running text | V267:583 running text | V268:584 running text | V268:585 running text | V268:586 running text
Moscow p.199 · Mohl p.269 · Khaleghi p.267 · Khaleghi p.268 · Ganjoor passage
Firewood rises to the roof, horses and lambs are slaughtered, and smoke obscures the sky in all four presentations. English retains horse meat rather than substituting a more familiar banquet animal. The smoke also answers the daytime signal established earlier, so abundant hospitality doubles as military communication without requiring an additional speech of explanation. Wine follows food, and the guests depart intoxicated with narcissus in hand. English fair adds a descriptive flourish to the flower. The pleasing final image should not obscure the practical result: the invited nobles have been gathered, fed and made drunk while a visible signal has been produced above them.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
C7.10:53 English couplets from sunset and the sisters’ approach through the intoxicated guests’ departure. Moscow VI196–199:535–587, Ganjoor sh10:1–53 and Khaleghi V264–268:534–586 have53 running units. Mohl IV267–269:2073–2124 has52, lacking the separate caravan-origin question. The next section begins Moscow588/Mohl2125/Khaleghi587 with the nighttime fire.
Moscow evidence
Printed196–199 equals PDF196–199. Main542 asks the caravan’s origin;562 negates coming for war;581 reads Mehr. Actual199n20 prints Tir as an alternative. Main587 ends the feast;588 opens the nighttime signal.
Mohl evidence
Printed267–269 equals PDF273–275. Main2079–2080 moves directly from addressing the merchant to blessing him, a checked local gap for the separate origin question.2099 positively states coming for war.2118 reads Mehr. The reprint’s specific imprint remains unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
All53 sh10 units are allocated once, with repeated display references where English splits a source unit. Unit28 negates the war clause;47 reads Mehr. The reference is not silently altered to agree with English.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
Printed264–268 equals PDF280–284. Main561 negates the war clause; actual266n7 records positive alternatives. Main580 reads Mehr; actual267n25 records Tir alternatives. No appendix evidence is used.
Interpretive limits
English summer has support in printed calendar variants, not the four main texts. The maritime ordeal is a disguised speaker’s account, not verified travel history. Bareheadedness does not independently establish a specific veil convention. The sisters’ despair is retained without turning their wish for a shroud into a completed action.
Moscow printed p.196 · Moscow printed p.197 · Moscow printed p.198 · Moscow printed p.199
Mohl printed p.267 · Mohl printed p.268 · Mohl printed p.269
Khaleghi printed p.264 · Khaleghi printed p.265 · Khaleghi printed p.266 · Khaleghi printed p.267 · Khaleghi printed p.268
C7.10 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI196:535 running text | IV267:2073 running text |
| 2 | VI196:536 running text | IV267:2074 running text |
| 3 | VI196:537 running text | IV267:2075 running text |
| 4 | VI196:538 running text | IV267:2076 running text |
| 5 | VI197:539 running text | IV267:2077 running text |
| 6 | VI197:540 running text | IV267:2078 running text |
| 7 | VI197:541 running text; VI197:542 running text | IV267:2079 running text; IV267:2079–2080 checked local caravan-origin question gap |
| 8 | VI197:543 running text | IV267:2080 running text |
| 9 | VI197:544 running text | IV268:2081 running text |
| 10 | VI197:545 running text | IV268:2082 running text |
| 11 | VI197:546 running text | IV268:2083 running text |
| 12 | VI197:546 running text; VI197:547 running text | IV268:2083 running text; IV268:2084 running text |
| 13 | VI197:547 running text | IV268:2084 running text |
| 14 | VI197:548 running text | IV268:2085 running text |
| 15 | VI197:549 running text | IV268:2086 running text |
| 16 | VI197:550 running text | IV268:2087 running text |
| 17 | VI197:551 running text | IV268:2088 running text |
| 18 | VI197:552 running text | IV268:2089 running text |
| 19 | VI197:553 running text | IV268:2090 running text |
| 20 | VI197:554 running text | IV268:2091 running text |
| 21 | VI197:555 running text | IV268:2092 running text |
| 22 | VI197:556 running text | IV268:2093 running text |
| 23 | VI198:557 running text | IV268:2094 running text |
| 24 | VI198:558 running text | IV268:2095 running text |
| 25 | VI198:559 running text | IV268:2096 running text |
| 26 | VI198:560 running text | IV268:2097 running text |
| 27 | VI198:561 running text | IV268:2098 running text |
| 28 | VI198:562 running text | IV268:2099 running text |
| 29 | VI198:563 running text | IV268:2100 running text |
| 30 | VI198:564 running text | IV268:2101 running text |
| 31 | VI198:565 running text; VI198:566 running text | IV268:2102 running text; IV268:2103 running text |
| 32 | VI198:567 running text | IV268:2104 running text |
| 33 | VI198:568 running text | IV268:2105 running text |
| 34 | VI198:568 running text | IV268:2105 running text |
| 35 | VI198:569 running text | IV269:2106 running text |
| 36 | VI198:570 running text | IV269:2107 running text |
| 37 | VI198:571 running text | IV269:2108 running text |
| 38 | VI198:572 running text | IV269:2109 running text |
| 39 | VI198:573 running text | IV269:2110 running text |
| 40 | VI199:574 running text | IV269:2111 running text |
| 41 | VI199:575 running text | IV269:2112 running text |
| 42 | VI199:576 running text | IV269:2113 running text |
| 43 | VI199:577 running text | IV269:2114 running text |
| 44 | VI199:578 running text | IV269:2115 running text |
| 45 | VI199:579 running text | IV269:2116 running text |
| 46 | VI199:580 running text | IV269:2117 running text |
| 47 | VI199:581 running text; VI199:n20 actual Tir variant | IV269:2118 running text |
| 48 | VI199:582 running text | IV269:2119 running text |
| 49 | VI199:583 running text | IV269:2120 running text |
| 50 | VI199:584 running text | IV269:2121 running text |
| 51 | VI199:585 running text | IV269:2122 running text |
| 52 | VI199:586 running text | IV269:2123 running text |
| 53 | VI199:587 running text | IV269:2124 running text |
New Naqqali