Esfandiyar Slays Arjasp
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The concealed warriors receive both air and instructions
Moscow: VI202:628 running text | VI202:629 running text | VI202:630 running text | VI202:631 running text | VI202:632 running text | VI202:633 running text; Mohl: IV271:2164 running text | IV271:2165 running text | IV271:2166 running text | IV271:2167 running text | IV271:2168 running text | IV271:2169 running text; Ganjoor: sh12:1, sh12:2, sh12:3, sh12:4, sh12:5, sh12:6; Khaleghi: V271:627 running text | V271:628 running text | V271:629 running text | V271:630 running text | V271:631 running text | V271:632 running text
Moscow p.202 · Mohl p.271 · Khaleghi p.271 · Ganjoor passage
All four open the chest fastenings so that air reaches the hidden men, then provide food, drink and battle clothing. English chest-lids makes the opening mechanically specific; the source does not provide enough construction detail to reconstruct the containers. The wine allowance differs: Moscow and Ganjoor give three cups, while Mohl and Khaleghi give a cup to each man. English follows Moscow’s count. The address joins danger, reputation and dependence on Yazdan. English lasting fame expands the prospect of gaining a name, while stand fast expresses the demand for effort. Refreshment therefore precedes a deliberately organized attack rather than an uncontrolled emergence from concealment.
7–12Three assignments convert a banquet into a targeted assault
Moscow: VI202:634 running text | VI202:635 running text | VI202:636 running text | VI202:637 running text | VI202:638 running text | VI202:639 running text; Mohl: IV271:2170 running text | IV271:2171 running text | IV271:2172 running text | IV271:2173 running text | IV271:2174 running text | IV272:2175 running text; Ganjoor: sh12:7, sh12:8, sh12:9, sh12:10, sh12:11, sh12:12; Khaleghi: V271:633 running text | V271:634 running text | V271:635 running text | V272:636 running text | V272:637 running text | V272:638 running text
Moscow p.202 · Mohl p.271 · Mohl p.272 · Khaleghi p.271 · Khaleghi p.272 · Ganjoor passage
The division into three bands appears in all four presentations: one fights inside, another controls the gate, and the third seeks the former drinking guests. The first instruction to that third band differs in polarity. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi tell it to find their trace; Mohl tells it to leave no trace, supporting the English’s negative formulation. The subsequent beheading order is shared, so the local difference does not erase the violence of the assignment. English none must live or flee intensifies its comprehensiveness. The prince takes twenty warriors himself, separating the attack on Arjasp from the other tasks distributed through the fortress.
13–18The sisters are directed away from the decisive encounter
Moscow: VI202:640 running text | VI202:641 running text | VI202:642 running text | VI202:643 running text | VI203:644 running text | VI203:645 running text; Mohl: IV272:2176 running text | IV272:2177 running text | IV272:2178 running text | IV272:2179 running text | IV272:2180 running text | IV272:2181 running text; Ganjoor: sh12:13, sh12:14, sh12:15, sh12:16, sh12:17, sh12:18; Khaleghi: V272:639 running text | V272:640 running text | V272:641 running text | V272:642 running text | V272:643 running text | V272:644 running text
Moscow p.202 · Moscow p.203 · Mohl p.272 · Khaleghi p.272 · Ganjoor passage
The lion-like approach brings Homahyi and Bih Afrid toward their brother in all four sources. Their faces remain obscured by bloody tears, even though the simile of new spring briefly restores the language of beauty. English fresh as spring should not be mistaken for a medical or emotional recovery from captivity. The order to run like dust points them toward the market quarters where gold and silver are stored. That destination gives the merchant disguise one final practical use as a place of refuge. English leave my side makes the separation explicit, while preserving the prince’s refusal to let them remain amid the impending combat.
19–24The attack interrupts a palace still governed by sleep
Moscow: VI203:646 running text | VI203:646–647 checked local gap; VI203:n6 actual additional unit | VI203:647 running text | VI203:648 running text | VI203:649 running text | VI203:650 running text; Mohl: IV272:2182 running text | IV272:2183 running text | IV272:2184 running text | IV272:2185 running text | IV272:2186 running text | IV272:2187 running text; Ganjoor: sh12:19, sh12:20, sh12:21, sh12:22, sh12:23; Khaleghi: V272:645 running text | V272:645–646 checked local gap; V272:n21 actual additional unit | V272:646 running text | V273:647 running text | V273:648 running text | V273:649 running text
Moscow p.203 · Mohl p.272 · Khaleghi p.272 · Khaleghi p.273 · Ganjoor passage
The alternative of losing a head or gaining a crown leaves the outcome open in all four accounts. Mohl then explicitly turns the prince away from his sisters toward Arjasp’s gate; Moscow and Khaleghi print that unit in actual apparatus, while Ganjoor passes directly to the sword attack. English follows Mohl’s fuller transition. The blocked court and turbulent sea of wounded and dead retain the sources’ violent scale. English every rank and sort broadens the description beyond its local wording. Arjasp wakes to the tumult, so the narrative contrasts the prepared attackers with a ruler whose knowledge of the danger arrives only after the interior assault has begun.
25–30The merchant’s promised gift becomes a weapon
Moscow: VI203:651 running text; VI203:652 running text | VI203:652 running text | VI203:653 running text | VI203:654 running text | VI203:655 running text | VI203:656 running text; Mohl: IV272:2188 running text; IV272:2189 running text | IV272:2189 running text | IV272:2190 running text | IV272:2191 running text | IV272:2192 running text | IV272:2193 running text; Ganjoor: sh12:24, sh12:25, sh12:26, sh12:27, sh12:28; Khaleghi: V273:650 running text; V273:651 running text | V273:651 running text | V273:652 running text | V273:653 running text | V273:654 running text | V273:655 running text
Moscow p.203 · Mohl p.272 · Khaleghi p.273 · Ganjoor passage
All four arm Arjasp with a Roman helmet and kheftan, followed by a dagger; English jowshan makes the armor more specific. The prince’s spring from the palace is printed in both primaries and Khaleghi but absent from the checked Ganjoor transition. Mohl gives him a khanjar there, while Moscow and Khaleghi give a poison-bearing sword; English Indian sword recalls the earlier weapon. The merchant announces a gift associated with Lohrasp and sealed by Goshtasb. English blade of vengeance interprets that commercial metaphor, making its retaliatory purpose explicit. The subsequent combat abandons the disguise while preserving its language as an accusation directed at Arjasp.
31–36The king’s death is certain, the end of conflict is not
Moscow: VI203:657 running text; VI203:658 running text | VI203:658 running text; VI203:659 running text | VI203:659 running text | VI204:661 running text | VI204:662 running text | VI204:663 running text; Mohl: IV272:2194 running text; IV272:2195 running text | IV272:2195 running text; IV272:2196 running text | IV272:2196 running text | IV272:2197 running text | IV272:2198 running text | IV272:2199 running text; Ganjoor: sh12:29, sh12:30, sh12:31, sh12:33, sh12:34, sh12:35; Khaleghi: V273:656 running text; V273:657 running text | V273:657 running text; V273:658 running text | V273:658 running text | V273:659 running text | V273:660 running text | V273:661 running text
Moscow p.203 · Moscow p.204 · Mohl p.272 · Khaleghi p.273 · Ganjoor passage
The repeated blows, weakening body and explicit beheading are shared across all four presentations. English the empire’s power dead gives the death a political conclusion that the immediate action does not fully establish: armed resistance continues outside. Moscow and Ganjoor add a lament from the women’s palace, absent in Mohl’s local main sequence and printed in Khaleghi’s actual apparatus. That unit remains separately visible. The reflection on sweetness, poison and temporary dwelling then interrupts triumph with mortality. English spare yourself toil interprets the injunction against distress or labor. The uproar reaching Saturn returns the narration from that general reflection to the scale of the victor’s presence.
37–42Control of the palace differs from plundering it
Moscow: VI204:664 running text | VI204:665 running text | VI204:666 running text | VI204:667 running text; VI204:668 running text | VI204:670 running text | VI204:669 running text; Mohl: IV273:2200 running text | IV273:2201 running text | IV273:2202 running text | IV273:2203 running text; IV273:2204 running text | IV273:2205 running text | IV273:2206 running text; Ganjoor: sh12:36, sh12:37, sh12:38, sh12:39, sh12:40, sh12:42, sh12:41; Khaleghi: V274:662 running text | V274:663 running text; V274:n3 actual light-reading alternative | V274:664 running text | V274:665 running text; V274:666 running text | V274:668 running text | V274:667 running text
Moscow p.204 · Mohl p.273 · Khaleghi p.274 · Ganjoor passage
Candles illuminate the palace and the treasury is sealed in all four texts. The intervening harem line differs materially: Mohl takes away its light, supporting English, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi say that not even a thread is taken. Khaleghi’s actual apparatus also records the light reading. English left it bare therefore should not be treated as independent evidence that the harem was stripped of possessions. Selected Arab horses prepare the departure. Mohl mounts the sisters before the160 warriors leave, while the other sequences put their mounting after that departure unit. English follows Mohl’s order and accurately renders160 as eight score.
43–48The severed head is reserved for a public revelation
Moscow: VI204:671 running text | VI204:672 running text; VI204:673 running text; VI204:674 running text | VI204:675 running text | VI204:676 running text; VI204:678 running text | VI205:679 running text; VI205:680 running text; VI205:n3 actual Bahman unit | VI205:680 running text; VI205:681 running text; Mohl: IV273:2207 running text | IV273:2208 running text; IV273:2209 running text; IV273:2210 running text | IV273:2211 running text | IV273:2212 running text; IV273:2213 running text | IV273:2214 running text; IV273:2216 running text; IV273:2215 running text, Bahman subject | IV273:2216 running text; IV273:2217 running text; Ganjoor: sh12:43, sh12:44, sh12:45, sh12:46, sh12:47, sh12:48, sh12:50, sh12:51, sh12:52, sh12:53; Khaleghi: V274:669 running text | V274:670 running text; V274:671 running text; V274:672 running text | V274:673 running text | V274:674 running text; V274:676 running text | V275:677 running text; V275:678 running text; V275:n3 actual Bahman unit | V275:678 running text; V275:679 running text
Moscow p.204 · Moscow p.205 · Mohl p.273 · Khaleghi p.274 · Khaleghi p.275 · Ganjoor passage
All four leave Sawa with Iranian leaders, bar returning Turks and prescribe a proclamation praising Goshtasb. The head is to be cast before the retreating force, converting a private killing into public knowledge. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also retain a thanksgiving unit absent from Mohl’s checked transition and not separately rendered in English. Mohl adds Bahman’s killing of Turanian leaders as the party exits; actual apparatus in Moscow and Khaleghi prints that action. English swept the field keeps Esfandiyar as subject, so the Bahman unit cannot simply be attributed to him without qualification. Bishutan’s praise and the army’s wonder close the encounter in all four.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
C7.12:48 English couplets, arming the hidden force through Bishutan’s praise. Moscow VI202–205:628–681 has54 running units; Mohl IV271–273:2164–2217 has54 with distinct additions/gaps/order; Ganjoor sh12:1–53 has53; Khaleghi V271–275:627–679 has53. S1 preserves the women’s lament and S2 the thanksgiving. Next Moscow682/Mohl2218/Khaleghi680 begins the moonlit watch.
Moscow evidence
Printed202–205 equals PDF202–205. Main631 gives three cups. Actual203n6 prints the departure from sisters;653 retains the armed spring;660 retains the women’s lament.665 says not a thread was taken.676 retains thanksgiving. Actual205n3 prints Bahman’s additional action.
Mohl evidence
Printed271–273 equals PDF277–279.2167 gives one cup each;2173 leaves no trace.2183 explicitly leaves the sisters;2190 springs armed.2196–2197 lacks lament.2201 removes light;2205–2206 puts sisters before departing men.2212–2213 lacks thanksgiving.2215 names Bahman. Reprint imprint remains unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
All53 units are allocated, including source-only32 and49. Checked19–20 lacks the separate departure;25–26 lacks the armed spring.37 says not a thread was taken. Reference readings remain distinct from the English’s choices.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
Printed271–275 equals PDF287–291.630 gives one cup; actual272n21 prints departure;652 gives armed spring. Actual273n18 prints lament absent from main658–659.663 says not a thread, with light alternative in actual274n3.675 retains thanksgiving; actual275n3 prints Bahman’s action. No appendix evidence is used.
Interpretive limits
English’s empire conclusion, left it bare and Esfandiyar-subject field sweeping exceed what the relevant local units establish. The completed beheading of Arjasp is explicit. Spring imagery for the sisters is figurative, and chest construction is not recoverable from the ventilation clause alone.
Moscow printed p.202 · Moscow printed p.203 · Moscow printed p.204 · Moscow printed p.205
Mohl printed p.271 · Mohl printed p.272 · Mohl printed p.273
Khaleghi printed p.271 · Khaleghi printed p.272 · Khaleghi printed p.273 · Khaleghi printed p.274 · Khaleghi printed p.275
C7.12 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI202:628 running text | IV271:2164 running text |
| 2 | VI202:629 running text | IV271:2165 running text |
| 3 | VI202:630 running text | IV271:2166 running text |
| 4 | VI202:631 running text | IV271:2167 running text |
| 5 | VI202:632 running text | IV271:2168 running text |
| 6 | VI202:633 running text | IV271:2169 running text |
| 7 | VI202:634 running text | IV271:2170 running text |
| 8 | VI202:635 running text | IV271:2171 running text |
| 9 | VI202:636 running text | IV271:2172 running text |
| 10 | VI202:637 running text | IV271:2173 running text |
| 11 | VI202:638 running text | IV271:2174 running text |
| 12 | VI202:639 running text | IV272:2175 running text |
| 13 | VI202:640 running text | IV272:2176 running text |
| 14 | VI202:641 running text | IV272:2177 running text |
| 15 | VI202:642 running text | IV272:2178 running text |
| 16 | VI202:643 running text | IV272:2179 running text |
| 17 | VI203:644 running text | IV272:2180 running text |
| 18 | VI203:645 running text | IV272:2181 running text |
| 19 | VI203:646 running text | IV272:2182 running text |
| 20 | VI203:646–647 checked local gap; VI203:n6 actual additional unit | IV272:2183 running text |
| 21 | VI203:647 running text | IV272:2184 running text |
| 22 | VI203:648 running text | IV272:2185 running text |
| 23 | VI203:649 running text | IV272:2186 running text |
| 24 | VI203:650 running text | IV272:2187 running text |
| 25 | VI203:651 running text; VI203:652 running text | IV272:2188 running text; IV272:2189 running text |
| 26 | VI203:652 running text | IV272:2189 running text |
| 27 | VI203:653 running text | IV272:2190 running text |
| 28 | VI203:654 running text | IV272:2191 running text |
| 29 | VI203:655 running text | IV272:2192 running text |
| 30 | VI203:656 running text | IV272:2193 running text |
| 31 | VI203:657 running text; VI203:658 running text | IV272:2194 running text; IV272:2195 running text |
| 32 | VI203:658 running text; VI203:659 running text | IV272:2195 running text; IV272:2196 running text |
| 33 | VI203:659 running text | IV272:2196 running text |
| 34 | VI204:661 running text | IV272:2197 running text |
| 35 | VI204:662 running text | IV272:2198 running text |
| 36 | VI204:663 running text | IV272:2199 running text |
| 37 | VI204:664 running text | IV273:2200 running text |
| 38 | VI204:665 running text | IV273:2201 running text |
| 39 | VI204:666 running text | IV273:2202 running text |
| 40 | VI204:667 running text; VI204:668 running text | IV273:2203 running text; IV273:2204 running text |
| 41 | VI204:670 running text | IV273:2205 running text |
| 42 | VI204:669 running text | IV273:2206 running text |
| 43 | VI204:671 running text | IV273:2207 running text |
| 44 | VI204:672 running text; VI204:673 running text; VI204:674 running text | IV273:2208 running text; IV273:2209 running text; IV273:2210 running text |
| 45 | VI204:675 running text | IV273:2211 running text |
| 46 | VI204:676 running text; VI204:678 running text | IV273:2212 running text; IV273:2213 running text |
| 47 | VI205:679 running text; VI205:680 running text; VI205:n3 actual Bahman unit | IV273:2214 running text; IV273:2216 running text; IV273:2215 running text, Bahman subject |
| 48 | VI205:680 running text; VI205:681 running text | IV273:2216 running text; IV273:2217 running text |
New Naqqali