The Dragon of the Third Stage
46 published couplets; ends with Gorgsar’s grief.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 46 published couplets; ends with Gorgsar’s grief. |
| Moscow | 50 running units and actual rescue apparatus. |
| Mohl | 52 running units, with fuller rescue and mountain fall. |
| Ganjoor | 50 declared units; local rescue gap and separate divine address. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | 52 running units; green fluid main, blood apparatus; fuller rescue main. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Wine, hostility and the appeal to fortune
Moscow: VI173:126 running text | VI173:127 running text | VI173:128 running text | VI174:129 running text | VI174:130 running text | VI174:131 running text; Mohl: IV250:1663 running text | IV250:1664 running text | IV250:1665 running text | IV250:1666 running text | IV250:1667 running text | IV250:1668 running text; Ganjoor: sh4:1, sh4:2, sh4:3, sh4:4, sh4:5, sh4:6; Khaleghi: V230:124 running text | V230:125 running text | V230:126 running text | V230:127 running text | V231:128 running text | V231:129 running text
Moscow p.173 · Moscow p.174 · Mohl p.250 · Khaleghi p.230 · Khaleghi p.231 · Ganjoor passage
The three cups repeat the pattern of interrogation without turning the captive into a willing companion. All four texts connect Gorgsar’s pleasure to an explicit Ahriman comparison; English instead brightens his darkened heart, making the change more psychological and less overtly demonic. His warning then acknowledges the hero’s previous achievements before urging restraint. That rhetorical order matters: praise makes the proposed retreat sound prudent rather than merely cowardly. English anticipates the retreat in the sixth couplet, where the Persian immediately asks pity for wakeful fortune. The later advice supplies that direction, so the anticipation changes emphasis and pacing without inventing a different route or decision.
7–12The warning recruits the army as an argument
Moscow: VI174:132 running text | VI174:133 running text | VI174:134 running text | VI174:135 running text | VI174:136 running text | VI174:137 running text; Mohl: IV250:1669 running text | IV250:1670 running text | IV250:1671 running text | IV250:1672 running text | IV251:1673 running text | IV251:1674 running text; Ganjoor: sh4:7, sh4:8, sh4:9, sh4:10, sh4:11, sh4:12; Khaleghi: V231:130 running text | V231:131 running text | V231:132 running text | V231:133 running text | V231:134 running text | V231:135 running text
Moscow p.174 · Mohl p.250 · Mohl p.251 · Khaleghi p.231 · Ganjoor passage
The dragon’s breath is first represented through impossible scale: it can draw fish from the sea, issue fire and inhabit a mountainlike body. Both primaries and the two later comparisons support those features. English deep bed and furnace make the physical setting more concrete, while awe states an effect on observers that the shared mountain comparison leaves implicit. Gorgsar’s argument then widens from the prince’s life to the assembled army. Esfandiyar answers by insisting that the captive will accompany him in bonds. The exchange therefore does not end in reassurance or voluntary agreement. English preserves that coercive turn, and its promise of overcoming the foe anticipates the next boast.
13–18A tested device rather than an unexplained victory
Moscow: VI174:138 running text | VI174:139 running text | VI174:140 running text | VI174:141 running text | VI174:142 running text; VI174:143 running text | VI174:143 running text; VI174:144 running text; Mohl: IV251:1675 running text | IV251:1676 running text | IV251:1677 running text | IV251:1678 running text | IV251:1679 running text; IV251:1680 running text | IV251:1680 running text; IV251:1681 running text; Ganjoor: sh4:13, sh4:14, sh4:15, sh4:16, sh4:17, sh4:18, sh4:19; Khaleghi: V231:136 running text | V231:137 running text | V231:138 running text | V232:139 running text | V232:140 running text; V232:141 running text | V232:141 running text; V232:142 running text
Moscow p.174 · Mohl p.251 · Khaleghi p.231 · Khaleghi p.232 · Ganjoor passage
The construction sequence gives the coming success a material preparation: heavy timber, a wheeled frame, surrounding blades, a box and two horses. All four sources also include a trial ride. English makes the trial’s purpose explicit as testing strength, which is a reasonable inference rather than an additional inspection described by the Persian. Its account of the box likewise explains protection through the action of sitting inside. Armor and the Kabul dagger belong to the shared equipment list, although jowshan specializes the general armor term and in hand fixes a position not separately stated. The ingenuity remains the hero’s preparation without replacing the carpenters’ actual work.
19–24A reversed formation amid the night journey
Moscow: VI174:145 running text; VI174:146 running text | VI174:146 running text; VI174:147 running text | VI174:147 running text; VI175:148 running text | VI175:148 running text; VI175:149 running text | VI175:149 running text; VI175:150 running text | VI175:150 running text; VI175:151 running text; Mohl: IV251:1682 running text; IV251:1683 running text | IV251:1683 running text; IV251:1684 running text | IV251:1684 running text; IV251:1685 running text | IV251:1685 running text; IV251:1686 running text | IV251:1686 running text; IV251:1687 running text | IV251:1687 running text; IV251:1688 running text; Ganjoor: sh4:20, sh4:21, sh4:22, sh4:23, sh4:24, sh4:25, sh4:26; Khaleghi: V232:143 running text; V232:144 running text | V232:144 running text; V232:145 running text | V232:145 running text; V232:146 running text | V232:146 running text; V232:147 running text | V232:147 running text; V232:148 running text | V232:148 running text; V232:149 running text
Moscow p.174 · Moscow p.175 · Mohl p.251 · Khaleghi p.232 · Ganjoor passage
The night’s darkness, moon in Aries and named mount preserve the sources’ transition from preparation to travel. One directional word changes the formation: English puts the army before the prince, whereas Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all place it behind him. That reversal is a substantive local departure and should remain visible beside otherwise close narrative agreement. At dawn, the entourage varies. Moscow and Ganjoor name a son with a brother; Mohl and Khaleghi give a son with grandees and kinsmen. English follows the latter social grouping while leaving the son unmentioned. The next delegation and entry into the box retain the separation between command of the army and personal combat.
25–30The dragon perceives the approaching trap
Moscow: VI175:152 running text | VI175:153 running text | VI175:154 running text | VI175:155 running text | VI175:158 running text | VI175:156 running text; Mohl: IV251:1689 running text | IV251:1690 running text | IV251:1691 running text | IV251:1692 running text | IV251:1693 running text | IV251:1694 running text; Ganjoor: sh4:27, sh4:28, sh4:29, sh4:30, sh4:33, sh4:31; Khaleghi: V233:150 running text | V233:151 running text | V233:152 running text | V233:153 running text | V233:154 running text | V233:155 running text
Moscow p.175 · Mohl p.251 · Khaleghi p.233 · Ganjoor passage
The dragon is an observer before it becomes a victim: it hears the carriage and sees the horses moving. English wheels resound identifies the source of the sound, while its snare labels the construction by its eventual function. The dark mountain and bloody eyes maintain the bodily scale shared across all four accounts. The open jaws come earlier in Mohl and Khaleghi than in Moscow and Ganjoor; English follows that earlier position, completing the beast’s portrait before the hero holds his breath and seeks divine refuge. This ordering lets description lead directly into response. Caverns and anxious sharpen the scene’s spatial and emotional detail without supplying a new action.
31–36Suction turns the beast’s own force against it
Moscow: VI175:157 running text; VI175:159 running text | VI175:159 running text; VI175:160 running text | VI175:160 running text | VI175:161 running text; VI175:162 running text | VI175:163 running text | VI175:164 running text; Mohl: IV251:1695 running text; IV251:1696 running text | IV251:1696 running text; IV251:1697 running text | IV251:1697 running text | IV252:1698 running text; IV252:1699 running text | IV252:1700 running text | IV252:1701 running text; Ganjoor: sh4:32, sh4:34, sh4:35, sh4:36, sh4:37, sh4:38, sh4:39; Khaleghi: V233:156 running text; V233:157 running text | V233:157 running text; V233:158 running text | V233:158 running text; V233:n17 actual blood variant | V233:159 running text; V233:160 running text | V233:161 running text | V233:162 running text
Moscow p.175 · Mohl p.251 · Mohl p.252 · Khaleghi p.233 · Ganjoor passage
The mechanism works through the dragon’s inhalation, which takes both horses and carriage into its mouth. English compresses the successive suction statements but does not remove the animals from the action. Blades lodge, the mouth becomes their sheath, and the beast loses strength before the hero emerges. That order makes the sword attack the completion of an engineered encounter. The expelled fluid differs: both primaries and Ganjoor give blood, while Khaleghi’s main text gives a green sea and records blood in actual apparatus. English therefore has direct primary support. Its sheath of pain preserves the central weapon analogy while emphasizing the dragon’s suffering before the brain is cut.
37–42Apparent death and the fuller rescue
Moscow: VI175:165 running text | VI176:166 running text; VI176:n1 actual printed distress unit | VI176:n1 actual printed lament/dismounting unit; main gap after166 | VI176:n1 actual printed rosewater unit; main gap after166 | VI176:167 running text | VI176:168 running text; Mohl: IV252:1702 running text | IV252:1703 running text; IV252:1704 running text | IV252:1705 running text | IV252:1706 running text | IV252:1707 running text | IV252:1708 running text; Ganjoor: sh4:40, sh4:41, sh4:42, sh4:43; Khaleghi: V233:163 running text; V233:n26 actual mountain-fall variant | V234:164 running text; V234:165 running text | V234:166 running text | V234:167 running text | V234:168 running text | V234:169 running text
Moscow p.175 · Moscow p.176 · Mohl p.252 · Khaleghi p.233 · Khaleghi p.234 · Ganjoor passage
Mohl supports the English mountainlike collapse where the other main texts emphasize loss of consciousness and strength; Khaleghi also prints the mountain alternative in its apparatus. The fuller rescue is equally consequential. Mohl and Khaleghi give tears, dismounting and rosewater in running text, and Moscow prints those actual units below its shorter narrative. Ganjoor has only the arrival before the eyes reopen. English is therefore not inventing the intervention, although face shifts the rosewater from the crown of the head. The hero’s explanation then distinguishes poison smoke from a direct wound. That local explanation should not be expanded into a general assertion that he cannot be injured.
43–46Recovery, dependence and the captive’s disappointment
Moscow: VI176:169 running text; VI176:170 running text | VI176:170 running text; VI176:171 running text | VI176:172 running text | VI176:173 running text; VI176:175 running text; Mohl: IV252:1709 running text; IV252:1710 running text | IV252:1710 running text; IV252:1711 running text | IV252:1712 running text | IV252:1713 running text; IV252:1714 running text; Ganjoor: sh4:44, sh4:45, sh4:46, sh4:47, sh4:48, sh5:1; Khaleghi: V234:170 running text; V234:171 running text | V234:171 running text; V234:172 running text | V234:173 running text | V234:174 running text; V234:175 running text
Moscow p.176 · Mohl p.252 · Khaleghi p.234 · Ganjoor passage
Recovery moves through fresh clothes, washing and prayer before the army’s acclaim. English compresses the move to water into the request for clothing, then retains head and body being washed. The twisting and weeping in dust become bowing and audible invocation, preserving dependence while modifying the gestures. All four give the hero’s question about who could kill the dragon without divine support. English then joins the army’s gratitude to Gorgsar’s disappointment at his survival. Moscow and Ganjoor additionally address God as pure and faultless; Mohl has a checked local gap and Khaleghi prints that address in apparatus. The separate source-only row preserves that theological detail without pretending it has an independent English equivalent.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
C7.4:46 English couplets. Moscow VI173–176:126–175 (50 running units); Mohl IV250–252:1663–1714 (52); Ganjoor sh4:1–49 plus sh5:1 (50); Khaleghi V230–234:124–175 (52). The final Gorgsar grief belongs to this English ending; the next waterside camp is excluded. S1 records the separate divine address absent as a distinct English unit.
Moscow evidence
Printed173–176 equals PDF173–176. The declared main sequence126–175 is continuous. Actual176n1 supplies separately identifiable distress, army dismounting and rosewater units beyond main166. These are printed verses, not an addition notice. Main147 puts the army behind the hero; main158 places the jaws after the first suction; main160 gives blood. Main174 is the separate divine address shown in S1.
Mohl evidence
Persian volume IV, printed250–252, equals PDF256–258. Running1663–1714 is continuous.1684 puts the army behind;1686 gives grandees and kinsmen;1693 places the jaws before prayer;1697 gives blood;1702 compares the fall to a mountain.1704–1706 print tears, dismounting and rosewater.1713 goes directly from army praise to grief1714, leaving a checked local gap for S1. The reprint imprint remains unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
The reference comprises sh4:1–49 and the opening grief of sh5:1. There is no separate rescue between sh4:41 and42 corresponding to Mohl1704–1706. The two English rows needing a complete displayed counterpart use explicitly labeled Mohl running readings. The final S1 prayer belongs to sh4:49, while Gorgsar’s grief at sh5:1 completes English46.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
Printed230–234 equals PDF246–250. Running124–175 is continuous.145 puts the army behind;147 gives grandees and kin;154 places the jaws before prayer. Main158 gives a green sea, while actual233n17 gives blood. Actual233n26 records the mountain fall.165–167 print the fuller rescue. Actual234n21 prints the divine-address addition corresponding to S1; it is not counted as a running unit.
Interpretive and evidential limits
The army’s position in English21 reverses all four main texts. Rosewater in English40 has positive evidence but is applied to the head’s crown, not explicitly the face. Fear of death does not establish actual death. Poison smoke explains this particular collapse without certifying universal invulnerability. The construction is described without a modern mechanical reconstruction. Only identified apparatus readings are used; no exhaustive apparatus transcription or appendix evidence is claimed.
Moscow printed p.173 · Moscow printed p.174 · Moscow printed p.175 · Moscow printed p.176
Mohl printed p.250 · Mohl printed p.251 · Mohl printed p.252
Khaleghi printed p.230 · Khaleghi printed p.231 · Khaleghi printed p.232 · Khaleghi printed p.233 · Khaleghi printed p.234
C7.4 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI173:126 running text | IV250:1663 running text |
| 2 | VI173:127 running text | IV250:1664 running text |
| 3 | VI173:128 running text | IV250:1665 running text |
| 4 | VI174:129 running text | IV250:1666 running text |
| 5 | VI174:130 running text | IV250:1667 running text |
| 6 | VI174:131 running text | IV250:1668 running text |
| 7 | VI174:132 running text | IV250:1669 running text |
| 8 | VI174:133 running text | IV250:1670 running text |
| 9 | VI174:134 running text | IV250:1671 running text |
| 10 | VI174:135 running text | IV250:1672 running text |
| 11 | VI174:136 running text | IV251:1673 running text |
| 12 | VI174:137 running text | IV251:1674 running text |
| 13 | VI174:138 running text | IV251:1675 running text |
| 14 | VI174:139 running text | IV251:1676 running text |
| 15 | VI174:140 running text | IV251:1677 running text |
| 16 | VI174:141 running text | IV251:1678 running text |
| 17 | VI174:142 running text; VI174:143 running text | IV251:1679 running text; IV251:1680 running text |
| 18 | VI174:143 running text; VI174:144 running text | IV251:1680 running text; IV251:1681 running text |
| 19 | VI174:145 running text; VI174:146 running text | IV251:1682 running text; IV251:1683 running text |
| 20 | VI174:146 running text; VI174:147 running text | IV251:1683 running text; IV251:1684 running text |
| 21 | VI174:147 running text; VI175:148 running text | IV251:1684 running text; IV251:1685 running text |
| 22 | VI175:148 running text; VI175:149 running text | IV251:1685 running text; IV251:1686 running text |
| 23 | VI175:149 running text; VI175:150 running text | IV251:1686 running text; IV251:1687 running text |
| 24 | VI175:150 running text; VI175:151 running text | IV251:1687 running text; IV251:1688 running text |
| 25 | VI175:152 running text | IV251:1689 running text |
| 26 | VI175:153 running text | IV251:1690 running text |
| 27 | VI175:154 running text | IV251:1691 running text |
| 28 | VI175:155 running text | IV251:1692 running text |
| 29 | VI175:158 running text | IV251:1693 running text |
| 30 | VI175:156 running text | IV251:1694 running text |
| 31 | VI175:157 running text; VI175:159 running text | IV251:1695 running text; IV251:1696 running text |
| 32 | VI175:159 running text; VI175:160 running text | IV251:1696 running text; IV251:1697 running text |
| 33 | VI175:160 running text | IV251:1697 running text |
| 34 | VI175:161 running text; VI175:162 running text | IV252:1698 running text; IV252:1699 running text |
| 35 | VI175:163 running text | IV252:1700 running text |
| 36 | VI175:164 running text | IV252:1701 running text |
| 37 | VI175:165 running text | IV252:1702 running text |
| 38 | VI176:166 running text; VI176:n1 actual printed distress unit | IV252:1703 running text; IV252:1704 running text |
| 39 | VI176:n1 actual printed lament/dismounting unit; main gap after166 | IV252:1705 running text |
| 40 | VI176:n1 actual printed rosewater unit; main gap after166 | IV252:1706 running text |
| 41 | VI176:167 running text | IV252:1707 running text |
| 42 | VI176:168 running text | IV252:1708 running text |
| 43 | VI176:169 running text; VI176:170 running text | IV252:1709 running text; IV252:1710 running text |
| 44 | VI176:170 running text; VI176:171 running text | IV252:1710 running text; IV252:1711 running text |
| 45 | VI176:172 running text | IV252:1712 running text |
| 46 | VI176:173 running text; VI176:175 running text | IV252:1713 running text; IV252:1714 running text |
New Naqqali