The Witch of the Fourth Stage
55 published couplets; waterside camp through crown-fire.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 55 published couplets; waterside camp through crown-fire. |
| Moscow | 57 running units; actual garment and beauty variants. |
| Mohl | 56 running units; two cups, woodland and heart/soul prayer; local protection gap. |
| Ganjoor | 57 declared units; protection statement retained separately. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | 57 running units; actual garment, woodland and prayer alternatives. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6A toast and a changing number of cups
Moscow: VI176:176 running text | VI176:177 running text | VI176:178 running text | VI177:179 running text | VI177:180 running text | VI177:181 running text; Mohl: IV252:1715 running text | IV252:1716 running text | IV252:1717 running text | IV252:1718 running text | IV252:1719 running text | IV253:1720 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:2, sh5:3, sh5:4, sh5:5, sh5:6, sh5:7; Khaleghi: V235:176 running text | V235:177 running text | V235:178 running text | V235:179 running text | V235:180 running text | V235:181 running text
Moscow p.176 · Moscow p.177 · Mohl p.252 · Mohl p.253 · Khaleghi p.235 · Ganjoor passage
The waterside camp reestablishes royal sociability after the dragon’s violent defeat. The English names Goshtasb as the toast’s recipient, while the shared Persian refers to the world-ruler without repeating that name. Its two cups are a more definite textual choice: Mohl prints two, against three in the Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi running texts. This difference should be recorded without forcing a uniform drinking ritual across the stages. The prince’s laughter and reference to the dragon then make his question a taunt as well as an inquiry. English dark design gives the dragon an intention; the Persian principally recalls the defeated creature and its drawing breath.
7–12The warning exchanges strength for sorcery
Moscow: VI177:182 running text | VI177:183 running text | VI177:184 running text | VI177:185 running text | VI177:186 running text | VI177:187 running text; Mohl: IV253:1721 running text | IV253:1722 running text | IV253:1723 running text | IV253:1724 running text | IV253:1725 running text | IV253:1726 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:8, sh5:9, sh5:10, sh5:11, sh5:12, sh5:13; Khaleghi: V235:182 running text | V235:183 running text | V235:184 running text | V235:185 running text | V235:186 running text | V235:187 running text
Moscow p.177 · Mohl p.253 · Khaleghi p.235 · Ganjoor passage
The captive begins with favorable stars, but that praise frames an appeal to abandon the route. All four accounts describe a witch untroubled by armies, able to turn desert into sea and extend to the height of the sun. English makes her magical agency explicit through at will and skill. The word guest brings her promised greeting into the language of hospitality, preparing the later encounter without making her harmless. Naming Ghul retains a term whose force here comes from the warning and trap. The final appeal to keep the hero’s name out of dust concerns reputation as well as bodily danger. English preserves that double pressure rather than reducing the warning to physical size alone.
13–18Defiance proceeds under divine patronage
Moscow: VI177:188 running text | VI177:189 running text | VI177:190 running text | VI177:191 running text | VI177:192 running text; VI177:193 running text | VI177:193 running text; VI177:194 running text; Mohl: IV253:1727 running text | IV253:1728 running text | IV253:1729 running text | IV253:1730 running text | IV253:1731 running text; IV253:1732 running text | IV253:1732 running text; IV253:1733 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:14, sh5:15, sh5:16, sh5:17, sh5:18, sh5:19, sh5:20; Khaleghi: V235:188 running text | V235:189 running text | V235:190 running text | V236:191 running text | V236:192 running text; V236:193 running text | V236:193 running text; V236:194 running text
Moscow p.177 · Mohl p.253 · Khaleghi p.235 · Khaleghi p.236 · Ganjoor passage
Esfandiyar’s reply turns tomorrow into a demonstration that the captive will have to recount. The promised breaking of witches’ backs and hearts extends the consequence beyond one adversary, and English proud and quake amplify that collective humiliation. Yet the next line gives victory to the one God; the boast is not narrated as autonomous human power. Both primaries and the later comparisons retain this combination of confidence and dependence. The sunset, baggage and night march then return the speech to action. English makes remembrance of divine generosity into praise and gives the sun a martial helm where the Persian has a golden cap. The shared astronomical transition remains intact.
19–24A feast deliberately carried into danger
Moscow: VI177:194 running text; VI177:195 running text | VI177:195 running text; VI177:196 running text | VI177:196 running text | VI178:197 running text | VI178:198 running text | VI178:199 running text; Mohl: IV253:1733 running text; IV253:1734 running text | IV253:1734 running text; IV253:1735 running text | IV253:1735 running text | IV253:1736 running text | IV253:1737 running text | IV253:1738 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:20, sh5:21, sh5:22, sh5:23, sh5:24, sh5:25; Khaleghi: V236:194 running text; V236:195 running text | V236:195 running text; V236:196 running text | V236:196 running text | V236:197 running text | V236:198 running text | V236:199 running text
Moscow p.177 · Moscow p.178 · Mohl p.253 · Khaleghi p.236 · Ganjoor passage
Delegating the army leaves the prince free to approach with equipment for pleasure: a golden wine cup and tanbur. All four texts explicitly contrast approaching battle with his desire for a feast. English wine and strings explains that contrast through the objects he carries, preserving the deliberate incongruity instead of making the music an accidental discovery. The wood’s Paradise comparison, heavenly tulips and rosewater springs intensify the apparent welcome. English scarcely lets a little sunlight through where the source says it is unseen under the trees. The spring’s cool shade is a plausible expansion of the setting, but no separate source description measures its temperature or identifies a real location.
25–30The song makes companionship the missing reward
Moscow: VI178:200 running text | VI178:201 running text | VI178:202 running text | VI178:203 running text | VI178:204 running text | VI178:205 running text; Mohl: IV253:1739 running text | IV253:1740 running text | IV253:1741 running text | IV253:1742 running text | IV253:1743 running text | IV253:1744 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:26, sh5:27, sh5:28, sh5:29, sh5:30, sh5:31; Khaleghi: V236:200 running text | V237:201 running text | V237:202 running text | V237:203 running text | V237:204 running text | V237:205 running text
Moscow p.178 · Mohl p.253 · Khaleghi p.236 · Khaleghi p.237 · Ganjoor passage
The song names the lack of a drinking companion before opposing pleasure to lions, dragons and recurring trials. English no friend personalizes that absence, while still ahead shifts the emphasis toward further labor rather than the source’s inability to escape trouble. All four preserve the central desire for a beautiful companion and the condition that God should grant it. English guest makes companionship spatially immediate, as someone who might join this feast. Its moon-faced beauty substitutes one familiar image for the Persian fairy-faced description without changing the desired person into a named character. The lament thus supplies the witch with a role to perform, whether or not every spoken longing is strategically sincere.
31–36The witch enters the role the song has supplied
Moscow: VI178:206 running text | VI178:207 running text | VI178:208 running text; VI178:n15 actual garment variant | VI178:209 running text | VI178:210 running text | VI178:211 running text; VI178:n25 actual garden/flowers variant; Mohl: IV254:1745 running text | IV254:1746 running text | IV254:1747 running text | IV254:1748 running text | IV254:1749 running text | IV254:1750 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:32, sh5:33, sh5:34, sh5:35, sh5:36, sh5:37; Khaleghi: V237:206 running text | V237:207 running text | V237:208 running text; V237:n14 actual garment variant | V237:209 running text | V237:210 running text | V237:211 running text
Moscow p.178 · Mohl p.254 · Khaleghi p.237 · Ganjoor passage
The desired cypress stature, radiant face and hair reaching the feet provide the terms of the witch’s disguise. Her pleasure at hearing the song is a flower comparison; English specifies a red rose and dew beyond the common spring bloom. The trap speech varies in a small but significant detail: Mohl gives a garment where the other main texts give song, and Moscow and Khaleghi actually record the garment variant. English robe therefore has primary support. Her approach also follows Mohl and Khaleghi’s gardenlike cheeks and flowers at the breast rather than Moscow and Ganjoor’s explicit seating on grass. The beautiful appearance is the result of narrated transformation, not the narrator’s independent endorsement of her character.
37–42Gratitude and vigilance occupy the same scene
Moscow: VI178:212 running text | VI178:213 running text | VI178:214 running text | VI179:215 running text | VI179:216 running text | VI179:217 running text; Mohl: IV254:1751 running text | IV254:1752 running text | IV254:1753 running text | IV254:1754 running text | IV254:1755 running text | IV254:1756 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:38, sh5:39, sh5:40, sh5:41, sh5:42, sh5:43; Khaleghi: V238:212 running text | V238:213 running text | V238:214 running text; V238:n5 actual woodland variant | V238:215 running text; V238:n8 actual heart/soul prayer | V238:216 running text | V238:217 running text
Moscow p.178 · Moscow p.179 · Mohl p.254 · Khaleghi p.238 · Ganjoor passage
The prince intensifies music and drinking at the woman’s appearance, but the concealed chain soon shows that apparent welcome coexists with vigilance. English greater grace turns increased intensity into artistic refinement. The prayer also selects a particular reading: Mohl’s pure heart and worshipful soul, supported by actual Khaleghi apparatus, differs from the difficult cup-and-servant wording of the other main texts. The woodland setting in the preceding wish likewise has Mohl support. These choices give the English speech a coherent expression of grateful desire without proving that he is unaware of the disguise. Offering wine and watching the witch remain simultaneous parts of the encounter rather than mutually exclusive states.
43–47The inherited chain makes disguise ineffective
Moscow: VI179:218 running text | VI179:220 running text | VI179:221 running text | VI179:222 running text | VI179:223 running text; Mohl: IV254:1757 running text | IV254:1758 running text | IV254:1759 running text | IV254:1760 running text | IV254:1761 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:44, sh5:46, sh5:47, sh5:48, sh5:49; Khaleghi: V238:218 running text | V238:220 running text | V238:221 running text | V238:222 running text | V238:223 running text
Moscow p.179 · Mohl p.254 · Khaleghi p.238 · Ganjoor passage
All four presentations connect the chain with Zardosht, Paradise, Goshtasb and fastening on the arm. English charm identifies its protective function, but it omits the separate protection statement found in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi and absent at the checked Mohl transition. That statement is retained in the source-only row, with its scope distinguished from an unlimited doctrine of invulnerability. The chain then goes around the witch’s neck and removes her strength before she assumes a lion’s form. English adds calm bravery to the hero’s response, while preserving the challenge that even an iron mountain cannot harm him. His demand is for her actual appearance, not another impressive transformation.
48–51The killing disrupts the enchanted setting
Moscow: VI179:224 running text | VI179:225 running text | VI179:226 running text | VI179:227 running text; Mohl: IV254:1762 running text | IV254:1763 running text | IV254:1764 running text | IV254:1765 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:50, sh5:51, sh5:52, sh5:53; Khaleghi: V239:224 running text | V239:225 running text | V239:226 running text | V239:227 running text
Moscow p.179 · Mohl p.254 · Khaleghi p.239 · Ganjoor passage
The fetid old woman replaces the beautiful disguise through a stark contrast of white hair and black face. All four retain that revealed form and the blow to the head with a khanjar. English preserves the narrator’s unusual direct wish that the listener should not see the body, keeping the horror separate from the hero’s confidence. Death is explicit in the next unit, where darkness and bewildered sight follow. The black wind then hides both sun and moon. These effects belong to the narrated aftermath; the English does not need a modern weather explanation to connect the witch’s death with the collapse of the apparently hospitable landscape.
52–55Public acclaim and a captive’s private fire
Moscow: VI179:228 running text; VI179:229 running text | VI179:230 running text | VI180:231 running text | VI180:232 running text; Mohl: IV254:1766 running text; IV254:1767 running text | IV254:1768 running text | IV254:1769 running text | IV255:1770 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:54, sh5:55, sh5:56, sh5:57, sh5:58; Khaleghi: V239:228 running text; V239:229 running text | V239:230 running text | V239:231 running text | V239:232 running text
Moscow p.179 · Moscow p.180 · Mohl p.254 · Mohl p.255 · Khaleghi p.239 · Ganjoor passage
The hero’s thunderous call brings Bishutan and the army, allowing public recognition to follow a solitary encounter. English combines the signal and arrival without transferring the killing to the troops. The catalogue of defeated opponents then follows Mohl and Khaleghi in naming a wolf where Moscow and Ganjoor have a Turk. English love in the next blessing is supported by Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi, even though Mohl varies the wording of the world’s need. Gorgsar’s final fire reverses that acclaim into private suffering. English raging ire interprets the extraordinary crown-fire as anger, preserving the image while naming an emotion the Persian leaves embodied in the heat.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
C7.5:55 English couplets. Moscow VI176–180:176–232 and Khaleghi V235–239:176–232 each supply57 running units; Mohl IV252–255:1715–1770 supplies56; Ganjoor sh5:2–58 supplies57. sh5:1 was allocated to C7.4. The final crown-fire closes C7.5; the following prayer opens C7.6. S1 records the separate chain-protection statement.
Moscow evidence
Printed176–180 equals PDF176–180. Main179 gives three cups,208 song,211 seating by the stream,215 the difficult cup/servant wording and230 Turk. Actual178n15 records the garment variant and178n25 the fuller garden-cheek/flower description. Main218 supplies the chain’s provenance;219 states its protection separately and is displayed as S1. Only identified printed apparatus is used.
Mohl evidence
Printed252–255 equals PDF258–261. Main1718 gives two cups;1747 garment;1750 gardenlike cheeks and flowers;1753 woodland desire;1754 pure heart and worshipful soul. Main1757 supplies provenance, followed directly by neck binding1758: the separate protection unit is absent at this checked local transition.1768 gives wolf;1770 closes with crown-fire. The specific reprint imprint remains unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
The poem-body reference is sh5:2–58, excluding the grief already used in C7.4. It has three cups, song in the trap speech, seating beside the stream, the separate chain-protection unit45 and Turk in56. It supplies the displayed Persian reference, including these disagreements with English selections from Mohl. S1 accounts for45 without fabricating a separate English equivalent.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
Printed235–239 equals PDF251–255. Main179 gives three cups;211 has gardenlike cheeks and flowers;215 has the cup/servant wording;219 retains the protection statement;230 gives wolf. Actual237n14 records garment,238n5 the woodland variant and238n8 the heart-and-soul prayer. Main provenance218 and protection219 must remain distinct. No appendix evidence is used.
Textual and interpretive limits
English2 names Goshtasb where the local source says world-ruler. English4 two cups follows Mohl. English33 robe,36 flowers and40 pure heart/soul have positive textual support. English42 vigilance does not independently prove a particular tactical intention behind every earlier love-song line. The chain’s efficacy is narrated but is not generalized into immunity to all injury. Fire, transformation and the dark storm are treated as narrative images; no physical diagnosis or historical reconstruction is asserted. Selected apparatus is not an exhaustive diplomatic collation.
Moscow printed p.176 · Moscow printed p.177 · Moscow printed p.178 · Moscow printed p.179 · Moscow printed p.180
Mohl printed p.252 · Mohl printed p.253 · Mohl printed p.254 · Mohl printed p.255
Khaleghi printed p.235 · Khaleghi printed p.236 · Khaleghi printed p.237 · Khaleghi printed p.238 · Khaleghi printed p.239
C7.5 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI176:176 running text | IV252:1715 running text |
| 2 | VI176:177 running text | IV252:1716 running text |
| 3 | VI176:178 running text | IV252:1717 running text |
| 4 | VI177:179 running text | IV252:1718 running text |
| 5 | VI177:180 running text | IV252:1719 running text |
| 6 | VI177:181 running text | IV253:1720 running text |
| 7 | VI177:182 running text | IV253:1721 running text |
| 8 | VI177:183 running text | IV253:1722 running text |
| 9 | VI177:184 running text | IV253:1723 running text |
| 10 | VI177:185 running text | IV253:1724 running text |
| 11 | VI177:186 running text | IV253:1725 running text |
| 12 | VI177:187 running text | IV253:1726 running text |
| 13 | VI177:188 running text | IV253:1727 running text |
| 14 | VI177:189 running text | IV253:1728 running text |
| 15 | VI177:190 running text | IV253:1729 running text |
| 16 | VI177:191 running text | IV253:1730 running text |
| 17 | VI177:192 running text; VI177:193 running text | IV253:1731 running text; IV253:1732 running text |
| 18 | VI177:193 running text; VI177:194 running text | IV253:1732 running text; IV253:1733 running text |
| 19 | VI177:194 running text; VI177:195 running text | IV253:1733 running text; IV253:1734 running text |
| 20 | VI177:195 running text; VI177:196 running text | IV253:1734 running text; IV253:1735 running text |
| 21 | VI177:196 running text | IV253:1735 running text |
| 22 | VI178:197 running text | IV253:1736 running text |
| 23 | VI178:198 running text | IV253:1737 running text |
| 24 | VI178:199 running text | IV253:1738 running text |
| 25 | VI178:200 running text | IV253:1739 running text |
| 26 | VI178:201 running text | IV253:1740 running text |
| 27 | VI178:202 running text | IV253:1741 running text |
| 28 | VI178:203 running text | IV253:1742 running text |
| 29 | VI178:204 running text | IV253:1743 running text |
| 30 | VI178:205 running text | IV253:1744 running text |
| 31 | VI178:206 running text | IV254:1745 running text |
| 32 | VI178:207 running text | IV254:1746 running text |
| 33 | VI178:208 running text; VI178:n15 actual garment variant | IV254:1747 running text |
| 34 | VI178:209 running text | IV254:1748 running text |
| 35 | VI178:210 running text | IV254:1749 running text |
| 36 | VI178:211 running text; VI178:n25 actual garden/flowers variant | IV254:1750 running text |
| 37 | VI178:212 running text | IV254:1751 running text |
| 38 | VI178:213 running text | IV254:1752 running text |
| 39 | VI178:214 running text | IV254:1753 running text |
| 40 | VI179:215 running text | IV254:1754 running text |
| 41 | VI179:216 running text | IV254:1755 running text |
| 42 | VI179:217 running text | IV254:1756 running text |
| 43 | VI179:218 running text | IV254:1757 running text |
| 44 | VI179:220 running text | IV254:1758 running text |
| 45 | VI179:221 running text | IV254:1759 running text |
| 46 | VI179:222 running text | IV254:1760 running text |
| 47 | VI179:223 running text | IV254:1761 running text |
| 48 | VI179:224 running text | IV254:1762 running text |
| 49 | VI179:225 running text | IV254:1763 running text |
| 50 | VI179:226 running text | IV254:1764 running text |
| 51 | VI179:227 running text | IV254:1765 running text |
| 52 | VI179:228 running text; VI179:229 running text | IV254:1766 running text; IV254:1767 running text |
| 53 | VI179:230 running text | IV254:1768 running text |
| 54 | VI180:231 running text | IV254:1769 running text |
| 55 | VI180:232 running text | IV255:1770 running text |
New Naqqali