The Simorgh of the Fifth Stage
50 published couplets.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 50 published couplets. |
| Moscow | 51 running units; praise retained. |
| Mohl | 51 running units; shadows, horse, landscape blood and weeping. |
| Ganjoor | 51 declared reference units. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | 50 running units plus actual printed praise addition. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Thanksgiving gives way to another taunt
Moscow: VI180:233 running text | VI180:234 running text | VI180:235 running text | VI180:236 running text; VI180:237 running text | VI180:237 running text | VI180:238 running text; Mohl: IV255:1771 running text | IV255:1772 running text | IV255:1773 running text | IV255:1774 running text; IV255:1775 running text | IV255:1775 running text | IV255:1776 running text; Ganjoor: sh6:1, sh6:2, sh6:3, sh6:4, sh6:5, sh6:6; Khaleghi: V239:233 running text | V239:234 running text | V239:235 running text | V239:236 running text; V240:237 running text | V240:237 running text | V240:238 running text
Moscow p.180 · Mohl p.255 · Khaleghi p.239 · Khaleghi p.240 · Ganjoor passage
The prostration and fitting banquet place the hero’s success under divine patronage before he recalls the captive. Both primaries and both later comparisons give three cups, unlike the disputed number in the preceding stage. English divides the giving and its emotional effect between two couplets, turning the source’s gladness from ruby wine into warmth of heart. Its dread is interpretive: this local unit does not explicitly name fear. The executioner and displayed witch’s head make the welcome coercive. English magic now lies dead extends the beheading into a claim about her power, while the source leaves that conclusion embodied in the head on the tree.
7–12The scale of danger grows with the warning
Moscow: VI180:239 running text | VI180:240 running text | VI180:241 running text | VI180:242 running text; VI180:243 running text | VI180:243 running text | VI180:244 running text; Mohl: IV255:1777 running text | IV255:1778 running text | IV255:1779 running text | IV255:1780 running text; IV255:1781 running text | IV255:1781 running text | IV255:1782 running text; Ganjoor: sh6:7, sh6:8, sh6:9, sh6:10, sh6:11, sh6:12; Khaleghi: V240:239 running text | V240:240 running text | V240:241 running text | V240:242 running text; V240:243 running text | V240:243 running text | V240:244 running text
Moscow p.180 · Mohl p.255 · Khaleghi p.240 · Ganjoor passage
The prince remembers the witch’s extravagant powers as a measure for whatever comes next. All four witnesses retain the Pleiades and the question, so English preserves the taunt’s cosmic scale rather than replacing it with a general boast. Gorgsar answers by calling the prince a war elephant and demanding greater vigilance. English greater danger anticipates the warning, while brave and wise specifies the qualities of attention. The mountain then supplies a second scale for the bird: it is both a ruler of the height and a flying mountain. Warlike mind gives psychological force to the shared combat-seeking description without establishing a separate speech or intention by the bird.
13–18A shared arrow boast amid differing descriptions
Moscow: VI180:245 running text | VI180:246 running text | VI180:247 running text | VI181:248 running text | VI181:249 running text | VI181:250 running text; Mohl: IV255:1783 running text | IV255:1784 running text | IV255:1785 running text | IV255:1786 running text | IV255:1787 running text | IV255:1788 running text; Ganjoor: sh6:13, sh6:14, sh6:15, sh6:16, sh6:17, sh6:18; Khaleghi: V240:245 running text | V240:246 running text | V240:247 running text | V240:248 running text | V241:249 running text | V241:250 running text
Moscow p.180 · Moscow p.181 · Mohl p.255 · Khaleghi p.240 · Khaleghi p.241 · Ganjoor passage
The prey catalogue combines readings from the two primaries: Mohl supplies the leopard, while Moscow gives the height of the cloud and a lion. Ganjoor and Khaleghi follow the latter presentation at that point. English thus has support for its components without reproducing one edition word for word. All four agree that the burden causes no strain and that two young match the parent’s stature and counsel. English turns their counsel into aligned purpose. The threatened eclipse then provokes a precise answer: arrows will stitch the shoulders. That boast is present in both primaries as well as Ganjoor and Khaleghi; it is not an English invention or an absent Mohl line.
19–24The night march separates threat from execution
Moscow: VI181:251 running text | VI181:252 running text | VI181:253 running text | VI181:254 running text | VI181:254 running text; VI181:255 running text | VI181:255 running text; VI181:256 running text; Mohl: IV255:1789 running text | IV255:1790 running text | IV255:1791 running text | IV256:1792 running text | IV256:1792 running text; IV256:1793 running text | IV256:1793 running text; IV256:1794 running text; Ganjoor: sh6:19, sh6:20, sh6:21, sh6:22, sh6:23, sh6:24; Khaleghi: V241:251 running text | V241:252 running text | V241:253 running text | V241:254 running text | V241:254 running text; V241:255 running text | V241:255 running text; V241:256 running text
Moscow p.181 · Mohl p.255 · Mohl p.256 · Khaleghi p.241 · Ganjoor passage
The promised Indian sword and fallen head announce a direct assault, but the ensuing journey prepares a mechanical trap instead. All four retain the sword boast, sunset, army movement, overnight march and renewed daylight. English sky generalizes the source’s harshened heart of the east, retaining personification while making its location less specific. It also redistributes the sunrise and lamp of time across adjacent couplets, so the repeated light should not be counted as two separate dawns. Naming Bishutan at the delegation resolves the army commander from context. This clarification is narratively apt, though the local Persian unit itself gives the office rather than repeating his name.
25–30The cart arrives beneath a commanding height
Moscow: VI181:256 running text; VI181:257 running text | VI181:257 running text; VI181:258 running text | VI181:258 running text | VI181:259 running text | VI181:260 running text | VI181:261 running text; Mohl: IV256:1794 running text; IV256:1795 running text | IV256:1795 running text; IV256:1796 running text | IV256:1796 running text | IV256:1797 running text | IV256:1798 running text | IV256:1799 running text; Ganjoor: sh6:24, sh6:25, sh6:26, sh6:27, sh6:28, sh6:29; Khaleghi: V241:256 running text; V241:257 running text | V241:257 running text; V241:258 running text | V241:258 running text | V241:n21 actual printed addition; checked running-text gap between258–259 | V242:259 running text | V242:260 running text
Moscow p.181 · Mohl p.256 · Khaleghi p.241 · Khaleghi p.242 · Ganjoor passage
The reused horse, cart and box connect this trial with the dragon episode. English sword-lined recalls their construction rather than translating a newly repeated specification. Both primaries and Ganjoor then place praise of the Creator after the hero’s pause in thought. Khaleghi lacks that couplet in running text but prints its wording as an actual apparatus addition; the distinction preserves positive evidence without misrepresenting its position. The bird sees the box with army and horn behind it. English hearing regularizes the source’s awkward seeing of a cry. The descent as a dark cloud makes the bird’s scale palpable before contact with the trap, without proving that an actual eclipse has occurred.
31–36The trap wounds a parent before its young
Moscow: VI181:262 running text | VI181:263 running text | VI181:264 running text | VI182:265 running text | VI182:266 running text | VI182:267 running text; Mohl: IV256:1800 running text | IV256:1801 running text | IV256:1802 running text | IV256:1803 running text | IV256:1804 running text | IV256:1805 running text; Ganjoor: sh6:30, sh6:31, sh6:32, sh6:33, sh6:34, sh6:35; Khaleghi: V242:261 running text | V242:262 running text | V242:263 running text | V242:264 running text | V242:265 running text | V242:266 running text; V242:n24 actual horse variants
Moscow p.181 · Moscow p.182 · Mohl p.256 · Khaleghi p.242 · Ganjoor passage
The attempt to seize the cart compares the Simorgh to a leopard taking prey, and all four retain that intention before the blades work. English wings and feathers concentrates on plumage where the source names feet and wings. The primaries’ struggling beak and claws support its beating action, while Khaleghi’s different sucking wording remains separately recorded. The young then cry and shed tears of blood. Their shadows in English have Mohl and Khaleghi support against Moscow and Ganjoor’s fear or awe. Mohl also names the horse in the blood-washing line. English horses expands that singular detail, so textual support for the animal does not establish the plural independently.
37–42Human action ends in divine acknowledgment
Moscow: VI182:268 running text | VI182:269 running text | VI182:270 running text | VI182:271 running text | VI182:272 running text | VI182:273 running text; Mohl: IV256:1806 running text | IV256:1807 running text | IV256:1808 running text | IV256:1809 running text | IV256:1810 running text | IV256:1811 running text; Ganjoor: sh6:36, sh6:37, sh6:38, sh6:39, sh6:40, sh6:41; Khaleghi: V242:267 running text | V242:268 running text | V242:269 running text | V243:270 running text | V243:271 running text | V243:272 running text
Moscow p.182 · Mohl p.256 · Khaleghi p.242 · Khaleghi p.243 · Ganjoor passage
The prince emerges with armor and an Indian sword, and all four sharpen the imbalance through bird against nahang. English jowshan gives the armor a more particular name than the local zereh. Its bird of magic art interprets the source’s resourceful or artful bird, whose helplessness supplies the wordplay; sorcery should not be inferred from that adjective alone. The thanksgiving next attributes power over beasts to the moon’s Lord. English over ill abstracts those adversaries into evil, while grace names the guidance expressed in the prayer. The shared address to the just judge preserves the dependence that frames the victory, even as the English makes its moral implications more explicit.
43–47The returning army measures the victory
Moscow: VI182:274 running text; VI182:275 running text | VI182:275 running text | VI182:276 running text | VI182:277 running text | VI182:278 running text; VI182:279 running text; Mohl: IV256:1812 running text; IV256:1813 running text | IV256:1813 running text | IV256:1814 running text | IV256:1815 running text | IV256:1816 running text; IV257:1817 running text; Ganjoor: sh6:42, sh6:43, sh6:44, sh6:45, sh6:46, sh6:47; Khaleghi: V243:273 running text; V243:274 running text | V243:274 running text | V243:275 running text | V243:276 running text | V243:277 running text; V243:278 running text
Moscow p.182 · Mohl p.256 · Mohl p.257 · Khaleghi p.243 · Ganjoor passage
The karnay announces Bishutan’s approach with the royal tent, equipment, son and Iranian grandees. All four preserve the list, which English distributes across two couplets without introducing a second arrival. The enormous carcass then hides the plain, and the feather-covered landscape turns the earlier flying mountain into a fallen obstacle. English gore has Mohl support where Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi chiefly repeat feathers and plumage. The prince’s bloodied body and moon-surpassing face create a deliberate visual contrast: the glory of the victor remains visible through the violence. English strength and grace summarizes the chiefs’ praise rather than supplying an additional act of combat.
48–50The captive’s grief precedes the renewed feast
Moscow: VI182:280 running text; VI183:281 running text | VI183:282 running text | VI183:283 running text; Mohl: IV257:1818 running text; IV257:1819 running text | IV257:1820 running text | IV257:1821 running text; Ganjoor: sh6:48, sh6:49, sh6:50, sh6:51; Khaleghi: V243:279 running text; V243:280 running text | V243:281 running text | V243:282 running text
Moscow p.182 · Moscow p.183 · Mohl p.257 · Khaleghi p.243 · Ganjoor passage
Gorgsar’s reaction interrupts public acclaim with trembling, pallor and pain. Mohl gives weeping where Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give running, so English tears have a primary textual basis. Livid interprets the source’s yellow face, and fear supplies an emotion beside the more directly expressed grief. These distinctions matter because his reaction need not be reduced to admiration of the hero. The tent, assembled champions, silk and wine then restore the social pattern that opened the chapter. All four retain that return to a meal. English dine makes the purpose explicit without adding a new ceremonial occasion or identifying a geographical site for the encampment.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
C7.6 contains50 published English couplets, from prostration through the silk-spread meal. Moscow VI180–183:233–283, Mohl IV255–257:1771–1821 and Ganjoor sh6:1–51 supply51 running units each. Khaleghi V239–243:233–282 supplies50; the praise after258 is printed in actual241n21. The next summons of Gorgsar begins C7.7.
Moscow evidence
Printed180–183 equals PDF180–183. All51 running units were inspected. Main245 has lion/cloud height,266 fear or awe,267 blood on box/cart,277 repeated plumage and281 running in distress. The arrow boast250 is running text, as is praise259. Selected variants are distinguished from the complete running sequence.
Mohl evidence
Printed255–257 equals PDF261–263. Main1783 has leopard and claw;1788 contains the arrow boast.1797 prints praise before the bird sees the cart.1804 gives shadows,1805 blood on the horse,1815 blood across the landscape and1819 weeping. These readings support particular English choices. The specific reprint imprint remains unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
All51 poem-body units of sh6 are allocated, with overlapping references where English redistributes material. The reference retains fear or awe in34 and running in49, rather than silently substituting English-supported Mohl readings. No separate Persian unit is inferred merely from the English division.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
Printed239–243 equals PDF255–259. The running sequence233–282 omits praise between258–259; actual241n21 prints the full addition. Main263 differs in beak action;265 gives shadows;266 names box/cart while actual242n24 records horse alternatives.280 gives running. No appendix evidence is used; selected apparatus does not constitute an exhaustive diplomatic collation.
Interpretive limits
The offspring are not explicitly killed in this passage. The bird’s artfulness does not by itself identify sorcery. English horses plural, jowshan and over ill go beyond the specificity of their local Persian wording. No identification with Zal’s beneficent Simorgh or zoological species is established by this passage. The metaphorical scale and supernatural effects remain narrative evidence, not physical measurements.
Moscow printed p.180 · Moscow printed p.181 · Moscow printed p.182 · Moscow printed p.183
Mohl printed p.255 · Mohl printed p.256 · Mohl printed p.257
Khaleghi printed p.239 · Khaleghi printed p.240 · Khaleghi printed p.241 · Khaleghi printed p.242 · Khaleghi printed p.243
C7.6 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI180:233 running text | IV255:1771 running text |
| 2 | VI180:234 running text | IV255:1772 running text |
| 3 | VI180:235 running text | IV255:1773 running text |
| 4 | VI180:236 running text; VI180:237 running text | IV255:1774 running text; IV255:1775 running text |
| 5 | VI180:237 running text | IV255:1775 running text |
| 6 | VI180:238 running text | IV255:1776 running text |
| 7 | VI180:239 running text | IV255:1777 running text |
| 8 | VI180:240 running text | IV255:1778 running text |
| 9 | VI180:241 running text | IV255:1779 running text |
| 10 | VI180:242 running text; VI180:243 running text | IV255:1780 running text; IV255:1781 running text |
| 11 | VI180:243 running text | IV255:1781 running text |
| 12 | VI180:244 running text | IV255:1782 running text |
| 13 | VI180:245 running text | IV255:1783 running text |
| 14 | VI180:246 running text | IV255:1784 running text |
| 15 | VI180:247 running text | IV255:1785 running text |
| 16 | VI181:248 running text | IV255:1786 running text |
| 17 | VI181:249 running text | IV255:1787 running text |
| 18 | VI181:250 running text | IV255:1788 running text |
| 19 | VI181:251 running text | IV255:1789 running text |
| 20 | VI181:252 running text | IV255:1790 running text |
| 21 | VI181:253 running text | IV255:1791 running text |
| 22 | VI181:254 running text | IV256:1792 running text |
| 23 | VI181:254 running text; VI181:255 running text | IV256:1792 running text; IV256:1793 running text |
| 24 | VI181:255 running text; VI181:256 running text | IV256:1793 running text; IV256:1794 running text |
| 25 | VI181:256 running text; VI181:257 running text | IV256:1794 running text; IV256:1795 running text |
| 26 | VI181:257 running text; VI181:258 running text | IV256:1795 running text; IV256:1796 running text |
| 27 | VI181:258 running text | IV256:1796 running text |
| 28 | VI181:259 running text | IV256:1797 running text |
| 29 | VI181:260 running text | IV256:1798 running text |
| 30 | VI181:261 running text | IV256:1799 running text |
| 31 | VI181:262 running text | IV256:1800 running text |
| 32 | VI181:263 running text | IV256:1801 running text |
| 33 | VI181:264 running text | IV256:1802 running text |
| 34 | VI182:265 running text | IV256:1803 running text |
| 35 | VI182:266 running text | IV256:1804 running text |
| 36 | VI182:267 running text | IV256:1805 running text |
| 37 | VI182:268 running text | IV256:1806 running text |
| 38 | VI182:269 running text | IV256:1807 running text |
| 39 | VI182:270 running text | IV256:1808 running text |
| 40 | VI182:271 running text | IV256:1809 running text |
| 41 | VI182:272 running text | IV256:1810 running text |
| 42 | VI182:273 running text | IV256:1811 running text |
| 43 | VI182:274 running text; VI182:275 running text | IV256:1812 running text; IV256:1813 running text |
| 44 | VI182:275 running text | IV256:1813 running text |
| 45 | VI182:276 running text | IV256:1814 running text |
| 46 | VI182:277 running text | IV256:1815 running text |
| 47 | VI182:278 running text; VI182:279 running text | IV256:1816 running text; IV257:1817 running text |
| 48 | VI182:280 running text; VI183:281 running text | IV257:1818 running text; IV257:1819 running text |
| 49 | VI183:282 running text | IV257:1820 running text |
| 50 | VI183:283 running text | IV257:1821 running text |
New Naqqali