Esfandiyar Presses His Claim
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6A royal grievance emerges from the aftermath of celebration
Moscow: VI217:1 running text | VI217:2 running text | VI217:3 running text | VI217:4 running text | VI217:5 running text | VI217:6 running text; Mohl: IV281:2407 running text | IV281:2408 running text | IV281:2409 running text | IV281:2410 running text | IV281:2411 running text | IV282:2412 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:1, sh2:2, sh2:3, sh2:4, sh2:5, sh2:6; Khaleghi: V293:17 running text | V293:18 running text | V293:19 running text; V293:n5 actual day/night variant | V293:20 running text | V293:21 running text | V293:22 running text
Moscow p.217 · Mohl p.281 · Mohl p.282 · Khaleghi p.293 · Ganjoor passage
The nightingale remains the narrator in all four texts, carrying the preceding lyric into a tale grounded in ancient telling. Esfandiyar returns intoxicated and dejected, so the feast has not settled his relation to the king. The maternal image differs: Mohl and Ganjoor hold the son in his mother’s embrace, while Moscow and Khaleghi make dark night embrace her. English follows the former and adds warmth. His charge of wrong then becomes the explicit claim that the rightful crown has been withheld. That explanation anticipates the promise he quotes next. It is the prince’s stated justification, not an independent certification that succession is already legally complete.
7–12The remembered promise becomes a threat of forcible succession
Moscow: VI217:7 running text | VI217:8 running text | VI217:9 running text | VI217:10 running text | VI217:11 running text | VI218:12 running text; VI218:13 running text; Mohl: IV282:2413 running text | IV282:2414 running text | IV282:2415 running text | IV282:2416 running text | IV282:2417 running text | IV282:2418 running text; IV282:2419 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:7, sh2:8, sh2:9, sh2:10, sh2:11, sh2:12, sh2:13; Khaleghi: V293:23 running text | V293:24 running text | V293:25 running text | V293:26 running text | V293:27 running text | V294:28 running text; V294:29 running text
Moscow p.217 · Moscow p.218 · Mohl p.282 · Khaleghi p.293 · Khaleghi p.294 · Ganjoor passage
All four join the sisters’ release, dynastic fame, removal of evil and renewed order to the promised transfer of kingdom, army and treasure. English shame makes captivity’s injury explicit, while hate broadens the moral description of what the prince has purged. Waiting until sunrise initially suggests a formal request before the awakened king. The oath then changes the force of the speech: the son will take the crown against his father’s will. English breaks his pledge interprets the source’s hostile facial response through the remembered promise. This makes the moral accusation clear, but narrows an angry refusal into a more specific accusation of broken faith.
13–18The son’s political vision meets the mother’s practical knowledge
Moscow: VI218:13 running text | VI218:14 running text | VI218:15 running text | VI218:16 running text | VI218:17 running text | VI218:18 running text; Mohl: IV282:2419 running text | IV282:2420 running text | IV282:2421 running text | IV282:2422 running text | IV282:2423 running text | IV282:2424 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:13, sh2:14, sh2:15, sh2:16, sh2:17, sh2:18; Khaleghi: V294:29 running text | V294:30 running text | V294:31 running text | V294:32 running text | V294:33 running text | V294:34 running text
Moscow p.218 · Mohl p.282 · Khaleghi p.294 · Ganjoor passage
The offer to give Iran’s country to Iranians is shared by the four presentations, but its precise political mechanics remain unstated. English let Iran command and people possess develops that phrase without establishing a modern constitutional program. The mother’s promised dignity and the son’s lionlike combat make his plan both familial and martial. Her response is bodily: silk becomes thorns. English cheek expands the source’s bodily location, preserving distress rather than inventing a separate action. She knows the father will not yield the crown, then asks what more her son needs when he already possesses command, counsel, wealth and troops. Her reasoning starts from an appraisal of actual power.
19–24Counsel about waiting is answered with a hostile maxim
Moscow: VI218:19 running text | VI218:20 running text | VI218:21 running text | VI218:22 running text | VI218:23 running text | VI218:24 running text; Mohl: IV282:2425 running text | IV282:2426 running text | IV282:2427 running text | IV282:2428 running text | IV282:2429 running text | IV282:2430 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:19, sh2:20, sh2:21, sh2:22, sh2:23, sh2:24; Khaleghi: V294:35 running text | V294:36 running text | V294:37 running text | V294:38 running text | V295:39 running text | V295:40 running text
Moscow p.218 · Mohl p.282 · Khaleghi p.294 · Khaleghi p.295 · Ganjoor passage
All four leave the father chiefly the crown and promise the son succession when that father passes. English justly due makes explicit a normative implication of the expected inheritance. The image of a lion girded before his father then presents service as compatible with strength rather than humiliating dependence. Esfandiyar answers by invoking a categorical maxim against telling women secrets or following their advice. English streets makes the public circulation of speech concrete. These assertions belong to his speech. The narrative has just credited his mother with understanding the king’s refusal, so the maxim cannot simply be adopted as the commentary’s judgment of her wisdom.
25–30Withdrawal and royal ambition differ at one decisive verb
Moscow: VI218:25 running text | VI218:26 running text | VI219:27 running text | VI219:28 running text | VI219:29 running text | VI219:30 running text; Mohl: IV282:2431 running text | IV282:2432 running text | IV282:2433 running text | IV282:2434 running text | IV282:2435 running text | IV282:2436 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:25, sh2:26, sh2:27, sh2:28, sh2:29, sh2:30; Khaleghi: V295:41 running text | V295:42 running text; V295:n9 actual positive variant | V295:43 running text | V295:44 running text | V295:45 running text | V295:46 running text
Moscow p.218 · Moscow p.219 · Mohl p.282 · Khaleghi p.295 · Ganjoor passage
The mother’s shame and regret are shared, and English makes the wish for silence explicit. The following movement is textually divided. Mohl and Khaleghi say Esfandiyar did not go before Goshtasb, supporting English; Moscow and Ganjoor say he went. Khaleghi’s actual apparatus records the positive alternative. This single negation determines whether wine and music accompany withdrawal or a visit, so it must not be flattened into agreement. Two days and nights pass before the king learns of the claim. English will not give up strengthens the persistence in the source’s growing desire. Jamasp and Lohrasp’s diviners are then summoned, moving the problem from family dispute to attempted foresight.
31–36The search for knowledge brings the interpreter distress
Moscow: VI219:31 running text | VI219:32 running text | VI219:33 running text | VI219:34 running text | VI219:35 running text | VI219:36 running text; Mohl: IV283:2437 running text | IV283:2438 running text | IV283:2439 running text | IV283:2440 running text | IV283:2441 running text | IV283:2442 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:31, sh2:32, sh2:33, sh2:34, sh2:35, sh2:36; Khaleghi: V295:47 running text | V295:48 running text | V295:49 running text | V296:51 running text | V296:52 running text | V296:53 running text; V296:n6 actual fire-raining variant
Moscow p.219 · Mohl p.283 · Khaleghi p.295 · Khaleghi p.296 · Ganjoor passage
The four texts bring astronomical tables and ask about length of life, flourishing and coronation. These questions concern the son’s future, but they also expose what the father fears losing. The old charts are inspected, and brows and tear-filled lashes turn intellectual discovery into visible suffering. English preserves both bodily signs. The next image differs: Mohl and Khaleghi blame the harm brought by knowledge, supporting English, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor rain fire upon the speaker’s head. Khaleghi’s actual apparatus preserves that fiery reading. The English makes the burden explicitly epistemic; the other image expresses the same calamity through an assault descending from above.
37–42Jamasp recalls Zarir before naming the new danger
Moscow: VI219:37 running text | VI219:39 running text | VI219:38 running text | VI219:40 running text | VI219:41 running text | VI219:42 running text; Mohl: IV283:2443 running text | IV283:2444 running text | IV283:2445 running text | IV283:2446 running text | IV283:2447 running text | IV283:2448 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:37, sh2:39, sh2:38, sh2:40, sh2:41, sh2:42; Khaleghi: V296:54 running text | V296:55 running text | V296:56 running text | V296:57 running text | V296:58 running text | V296:59 running text
Moscow p.219 · Mohl p.283 · Khaleghi p.296 · Ganjoor passage
All four make the sage wish he had died before Zarir’s catastrophe. Mohl and Khaleghi place the sight of the fallen body before the counterfactual wish for paternal killing; Moscow and Ganjoor reverse those units. English follows Mohl and Khaleghi, giving the remembered corpse immediate prominence. The praise of Esfandiyar then deepens the coming loss. Here too the wording divides: Mohl and Khaleghi deny fear in battle, while Moscow and Ganjoor deny an equal opponent. English fears no foe follows the former. Cleansing the world and dividing the dragon remain shared achievements, making the prophecy threaten a hero whose success has appeared almost unlimited.
43–48The demand for a prediction also threatens its speaker
Moscow: VI220:43 running text | VI220:44 running text | VI220:46 running text | VI220:45 running text | VI220:47 running text | VI220:48 running text; Mohl: IV283:2449 running text | IV283:2450 running text | IV283:2451 running text | IV283:2452 running text | IV283:2453 running text | IV283:2454 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:43, sh2:44, sh2:46, sh2:45, sh2:47, sh2:48; Khaleghi: V296:60 running text | V297:61 running text | V297:62 running text | V297:63 running text | V297:64 running text | V297:65 running text; V297:n9 actual warning variant
Moscow p.220 · Mohl p.283 · Khaleghi p.296 · Khaleghi p.297 · Ganjoor passage
All four announce future grief before the king presses for a precise answer. Mohl and Khaleghi place the comparison with Zarir before the hurried inquiry, matching English, while Moscow and Ganjoor reverse that order. English drink our fill develops the tasting of bitterness and makes the prediction sensuous. The final response in this group is consequentially divided. Both give the bad-time response to Jamasp, but Khaleghi explicitly asks about misfortune falling upon himself, as English does. Mohl does not name that personal object. Moscow and Ganjoor instead warn the king not to slight the day. Actual apparatus records the competing wording. The English thus gives the interpreter a personal stake in speaking, rather than only a warning directed outward.
49–54The king tests whether giving up power could avert death
Moscow: VI220:49 running text | VI220:50 running text; VI220:51 running text | VI220:51 running text; VI220:52 running text | VI220:52 running text | VI220:53 running text | VI220:54 running text; VI220:55 running text; Mohl: IV283:2455 running text | IV283:2456 running text; IV283:2457 running text | IV283:2457 running text; IV283:2458 running text | IV283:2458 running text | IV283:2459 running text | IV283:2460 running text; IV283:2461 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:49, sh2:50, sh2:51, sh2:52, sh2:53, sh2:54, sh2:55; Khaleghi: V297:66 running text | V297:67 running text; V297:68 running text | V297:68 running text; V297:69 running text | V297:69 running text | V297:70 running text | V298:71 running text; V298:72 running text
Moscow p.220 · Mohl p.283 · Khaleghi p.297 · Khaleghi p.298 · Ganjoor passage
Every presentation locates the death in Zabulistan at the hand of Zal’s son. Goshtasb then considers transferring the crown so that the prince need not go there. English fatal road interprets the condition through the prophecy, while its added travel clause explains why Kabulistan is also named. The transition is freer: English then think summarizes differing questions and warnings rather than closely rendering either. What follows in all four is a challenge to escape from time, expressed through the revolving heaven and a sharp-clawed dragon. English combines two Persian units into one couplet and keeps strength and wisdom together as powers unable to guarantee deliverance.
55–58Different placements preserve the question of how death will come
Moscow: VI220:56 running text | VI219:n11 actual apparatus after33; VI220:56–57 running gap | VI220:57 running text | VI220:58 running text; Mohl: IV284:2462 running text | IV284:2463 running text | IV284:2464 running text | IV284:2465 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:56, sh2:57, sh2:58; Khaleghi: V298:73 running text | V296:50 relocated running question | V298:74 running text | V298:75 running text
Moscow p.219 · Moscow p.220 · Mohl p.284 · Khaleghi p.296 · Khaleghi p.298 · Ganjoor passage
The inevitability of what must happen is shared, but the verse about death by a great man’s hand or Soroush beside a sleeper is not placed uniformly. Mohl prints it here; Khaleghi prints it earlier as part of the inquiry; Moscow preserves it in actual apparatus after the coronation question. Ganjoor has a checked local gap here. English follows Mohl’s placement and softens death into final sleep. Its thicket of thought likewise follows Mohl and Khaleghi against Moscow and Ganjoor’s occupation with grief. The closing judgment is shared: evil thought and revolving time teach Goshtasb evil. Fatality does not erase that explicit judgment on his developing intention.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
58 published English couplets. Moscow VI217–220:1–58 after the separately numbered lyric prelude; Mohl IV281–284:2407–2465 (59 running units); Ganjoor esfandyar/sh2:1–58; Khaleghi V293–298:17–75 (59 running units). Khaleghi50 corresponds to English56 in relocated running text. The next chapter begins Moscow59/Mohl2466/Khaleghi76 at dawn.
Moscow evidence
Volume VI printed217–220 equals PDF217–220. Running1–58 begins after the16-unit prelude already translated in C7.15. Main26 says he went to Goshtasb;36 rains fire;41 denies an equal opponent;48 warns against slighting the day. Actual219n11 prints the death-mode couplet after33. It is not running text here.
Mohl evidence
Persian volume IV printed281–284 equals PDF287–290. Running2407–2465 includes the death-mode verse2463. Main2409 supports maternal embrace;2432 negative visit;2442 harmful knowledge;2447 absence of fear;2454 Jamasp’s bad-time response;2464 the thicket image. Zarir’s corpse and the later inquiry have their own ordering. The particular reprint imprint remains unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
All58 units of esfandyar/sh2 are allocated once, including shared references when English splits or combines a Persian unit. Its positive visit26 and warning48 remain visible despite the English alternatives. No death-mode verse occurs between56 and57; this is a checked local gap, not a claim about every manuscript.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
Volume V printed293–298 equals PDF309–314. Running17–75 continues the numbering after the prelude. Main42 has the negative visit;50 has the relocated death-mode question;53 harmful knowledge;58 absence of fear;65 Jamasp’s personal question;74 the thicket. Actual293n5,295n9,296n6 and297n9 document selected alternatives. These are actual inspected readings, not inferred from notices of additions. No appendix evidence is used.
Interpretive limits
The promise is quoted by the prince and his claim remains a claim. His misogynistic maxim is character speech; the mother’s knowledge is independently narrated. Giving Iran to Iranians does not identify a constitutional system. Soroush’s presence is a poetic death image. Only identified apparatus readings are invoked; no exhaustive apparatus or volume-wide appendix absence is claimed.
Moscow printed p.217 · Moscow printed p.218 · Moscow printed p.219 · Moscow printed p.220
Mohl printed p.281 · Mohl printed p.282 · Mohl printed p.283 · Mohl printed p.284
Khaleghi printed p.293 · Khaleghi printed p.294 · Khaleghi printed p.295 · Khaleghi printed p.296 · Khaleghi printed p.297 · Khaleghi printed p.298
C8.1 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI217:1 running text | IV281:2407 running text |
| 2 | VI217:2 running text | IV281:2408 running text |
| 3 | VI217:3 running text | IV281:2409 running text |
| 4 | VI217:4 running text | IV281:2410 running text |
| 5 | VI217:5 running text | IV281:2411 running text |
| 6 | VI217:6 running text | IV282:2412 running text |
| 7 | VI217:7 running text | IV282:2413 running text |
| 8 | VI217:8 running text | IV282:2414 running text |
| 9 | VI217:9 running text | IV282:2415 running text |
| 10 | VI217:10 running text | IV282:2416 running text |
| 11 | VI217:11 running text | IV282:2417 running text |
| 12 | VI218:12 running text; VI218:13 running text | IV282:2418 running text; IV282:2419 running text |
| 13 | VI218:13 running text | IV282:2419 running text |
| 14 | VI218:14 running text | IV282:2420 running text |
| 15 | VI218:15 running text | IV282:2421 running text |
| 16 | VI218:16 running text | IV282:2422 running text |
| 17 | VI218:17 running text | IV282:2423 running text |
| 18 | VI218:18 running text | IV282:2424 running text |
| 19 | VI218:19 running text | IV282:2425 running text |
| 20 | VI218:20 running text | IV282:2426 running text |
| 21 | VI218:21 running text | IV282:2427 running text |
| 22 | VI218:22 running text | IV282:2428 running text |
| 23 | VI218:23 running text | IV282:2429 running text |
| 24 | VI218:24 running text | IV282:2430 running text |
| 25 | VI218:25 running text | IV282:2431 running text |
| 26 | VI218:26 running text | IV282:2432 running text |
| 27 | VI219:27 running text | IV282:2433 running text |
| 28 | VI219:28 running text | IV282:2434 running text |
| 29 | VI219:29 running text | IV282:2435 running text |
| 30 | VI219:30 running text | IV282:2436 running text |
| 31 | VI219:31 running text | IV283:2437 running text |
| 32 | VI219:32 running text | IV283:2438 running text |
| 33 | VI219:33 running text | IV283:2439 running text |
| 34 | VI219:34 running text | IV283:2440 running text |
| 35 | VI219:35 running text | IV283:2441 running text |
| 36 | VI219:36 running text | IV283:2442 running text |
| 37 | VI219:37 running text | IV283:2443 running text |
| 38 | VI219:39 running text | IV283:2444 running text |
| 39 | VI219:38 running text | IV283:2445 running text |
| 40 | VI219:40 running text | IV283:2446 running text |
| 41 | VI219:41 running text | IV283:2447 running text |
| 42 | VI219:42 running text | IV283:2448 running text |
| 43 | VI220:43 running text | IV283:2449 running text |
| 44 | VI220:44 running text | IV283:2450 running text |
| 45 | VI220:46 running text | IV283:2451 running text |
| 46 | VI220:45 running text | IV283:2452 running text |
| 47 | VI220:47 running text | IV283:2453 running text |
| 48 | VI220:48 running text | IV283:2454 running text |
| 49 | VI220:49 running text | IV283:2455 running text |
| 50 | VI220:50 running text; VI220:51 running text | IV283:2456 running text; IV283:2457 running text |
| 51 | VI220:51 running text; VI220:52 running text | IV283:2457 running text; IV283:2458 running text |
| 52 | VI220:52 running text | IV283:2458 running text |
| 53 | VI220:53 running text | IV283:2459 running text |
| 54 | VI220:54 running text; VI220:55 running text | IV283:2460 running text; IV283:2461 running text |
| 55 | VI220:56 running text | IV284:2462 running text |
| 56 | VI219:n11 actual apparatus after33; VI220:56–57 running gap | IV284:2463 running text |
| 57 | VI220:57 running text | IV284:2464 running text |
| 58 | VI220:58 running text | IV284:2465 running text |
New Naqqali