Esfandiyar Makes Excuse to Rostam
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The returning hero is seen by the army
Moscow: VI252:575 running text | VI252:576 running text | VI252:577 running text | VI252:578 running text | VI252:579 running text | VI252:580 running text | VI252:582 running text; Mohl: IV305:2969 running text | IV305:2970 running text | IV305:2971 running text | IV305:2972 running text | IV305:2973 running text | IV305:2974 running text | IV305:2975 running text; Ganjoor: sh14:1, sh14:2, sh14:3, sh14:4, sh14:5, sh14:6, sh14:8; Khaleghi: V339:581 running text | V340:582 running text | V340:583 running text | V340:584 running text | V340:585 running text | V340:586 running text | V340:587 running text
Moscow p.252 · Mohl p.305 · Khaleghi p.339 · Khaleghi p.340 · Ganjoor passage
Mohl supplies the resounding neigh that English substitutes for the bull-headed mace in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s main text. Khaleghi also records the neigh in the apparatus, so the English opening has identifiable textual support. The next movement combines the army’s affection with its comparison to Sam. English iron mountain enlarges the saddle’s iron image, while Ahriman preserves the disturbing force assigned to Rakhsh. The elephant and indigo image remains deliberately striking rather than domesticated into a generic victory. The army’s judgment then turns physical admiration into criticism of kingship: sending such figures against one another appears to expose royal failure, not merely provide a spectacle of heroic strength.
7–12Public blame becomes a personal grievance
Moscow: VI252:583 running text | VI253:584 running text | VI253:586 running text | VI253:587 running text | VI253:588 running text | VI253:589 running text; Mohl: IV305:2976 running text | IV305:2977 running text | IV305:2978 running text | IV306:2979 running text | IV306:2980 running text | IV306:2981 running text; Ganjoor: sh14:9, sh14:10, sh14:12, sh14:13, sh14:14, sh14:15; Khaleghi: V340:588 running text | V340:589 running text | V340:590 running text | V340:591 running text | V340:592 running text | V340:593 running text
Moscow p.252 · Moscow p.253 · Mohl p.305 · Mohl p.306 · Khaleghi p.340 · Ganjoor passage
All four connect the threatened death of the moonlike hero with the pursuit of the crown and then accuse the aging ruler of appetite for treasure and regalia. English names Goshtasb, making the implied target explicit. Esfandiyar’s greeting interrupts that public judgment with formal courtesy, but Rostam immediately returns to the missing summons. The complaint concerns a promise between host and guest, not simply wounded vanity. English wind gives that failed promise an image absent from the corresponding main readings. The final warning against reckless anger toward an old man establishes age as a claim on restraint while leaving Rostam’s own anger fully audible beneath the ceremonial address.
13–18Self-identification precedes the catalogue of victories
Moscow: VI253:590 running text | VI253:591 running text | VI253:592 running text | VI253:593 running text | VI253:594 running text | VI253 checked local gap between594–595; Mohl: IV306:2982 running text | IV306:2983 running text | IV306:2984 running text | IV306:2985 running text | IV306:2986 running text | IV306:2987 running text; Ganjoor: sh14:16, sh14:17, sh14:18, sh14:19, sh14:20; Khaleghi: V341:594 running text | V341:595 running text | V341:596 running text | V341:597 running text | V341:598 running text | V341 checked local gap between598–599
Moscow p.253 · Mohl p.306 · Khaleghi p.341 · Ganjoor passage
All four let Rostam interpret the insult as contempt for courage, counsel and knowledge, before he names himself and his ancestry. The Div passage then differs materially: Moscow’s black Div and confinement of sorcerers support English, while Ganjoor and Khaleghi have the White Div and disappointed sorcerers; Mohl sends the sorcerers into the earth. English hand makes the claw image more human. The babr and lionlike Rakhsh remain common to all four. The additional flight before battle follows Mohl’s running text alone within the checked passages. It therefore strengthens the boast through a particular witness, rather than supplying an unsupported general description of Rostam’s reputation.
19–24The boast becomes an argument for mutual survival
Moscow: VI253:595 running text | VI253:596 running text | VI253:597 running text | VI253:598 running text | VI253:599 running text | VI253:600 running text; Mohl: IV306:2988 running text | IV306:2989 running text | IV306:2990 running text | IV306:2991 running text | IV306:2992 running text | IV306:2993 running text; Ganjoor: sh14:21, sh14:22, sh14:23, sh14:24, sh14:25, sh14:26; Khaleghi: V341:599 running text | V341:600 running text | V341:601 running text | V341:602 running text | V341:603 running text | V342:604 running text
Moscow p.253 · Mohl p.306 · Khaleghi p.341 · Khaleghi p.342 · Ganjoor passage
The four main texts name Kamus and the Khan of Chin before describing removal from the saddle and binding. English distributes capture across two couplets, anticipating the lasso in the first. The guardianship claim varies: English Shahs and Iran follows Mohl, against Moscow and Ganjoor’s Iran and Turan and Khaleghi’s Iran and warriors. This changes the political reach of Rostam’s claim without weakening his assertion of service. He then asks that his appeal not be mistaken for inferiority. The closing fear that Fortune may destroy the prince through his own hand makes the boast serve a warning: restraint protects Esfandiyar as well as Rostam’s honor.
25–30Age supplies a moral as well as a martial claim
Moscow: VI254:601 running text | VI254:602 running text | VI254:603 running text | VI254 n2 actual apparatus addition after603 | VI254:604 running text | VI254:605 running text; Mohl: IV306:2994 running text | IV306:2995 running text | IV306:2996 running text | IV306:2997 running text | IV306:2998 running text | IV306:2999 running text; Ganjoor: sh14:27, sh14:28, sh14:29, sh14:30, sh14:31; Khaleghi: V342:605 running text | V342:606 running text | V342:607 running text | V342:608 running text | V342:609 running text | V342:610 running text
Moscow p.254 · Mohl p.306 · Khaleghi p.342 · Ganjoor passage
All four invoke Sam and the lions that fled him, then make Rostam his surviving memorial. English turns the next address into direct praise of Esfandiyar. The record of a long life differs: Mohl and Khaleghi stress avoidance of evil, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor mention hearing many kinds of speech. English adopts the moral direction and expands suffering into wrinkles. The world-cleansing verse is running text in Mohl and Khaleghi and an actual addition in Moscow’s apparatus; it is locally absent from Ganjoor. Gratitude for a royal peer and the expectation of religious vengeance then place rivalry beside genuine admiration, preventing the speech from becoming mere denunciation.
31–36An excuse preserves courtesy without settling credibility
Moscow: VI254:607 running text | VI254:608 running text | VI254:609 running text | VI254:610 running text | VI254:611 running text | VI254:612 running text; Mohl: IV306:3000 running text | IV306:3001 running text | IV306:3002 running text | IV306:3003 running text | IV307:3004 running text | IV307:3005 running text; Ganjoor: sh14:33, sh14:34, sh14:35, sh14:36, sh14:37, sh14:38; Khaleghi: V342:611 running text | V342:612 running text | V343:613 running text | V343:614 running text | V343:615 running text | V343:616 running text
Moscow p.254 · Mohl p.306 · Mohl p.307 · Khaleghi p.342 · Khaleghi p.343 · Ganjoor passage
All four have Esfandiyar smile or laugh before explaining the missing invitation. English wounded pride states the emotional diagnosis that his following words imply. Heat and the length of the road provide a practical excuse, followed by an intention to visit early and apologize. English graceless deed makes the proposed apology more explicitly an admission of misconduct. The anticipated delight in seeing Zal and Rostam restores the language of friendship. Yet these are the prince’s reported intentions, not a narrator’s independent verification of motive. The admission that Rostam has already made the journey exposes the explanation’s weakness without requiring the analyst to decide whether every courteous phrase is consciously false.
37–42A place at table becomes a claim about rank
Moscow: VI254:613 running text | VI254:614 running text | VI254:615 running text | VI254:616 running text | VI254:617 running text | VI255:618 running text; Mohl: IV307:3006 running text | IV307:3007 running text | IV307:3008 running text | IV307:3009 running text | IV307:3010 running text | IV307:3011 running text; Ganjoor: sh14:39, sh14:40, sh14:41, sh14:42, sh14:43, sh14:44; Khaleghi: V343:617 running text | V343:618 running text | V343:619 running text | V343:620 running text | V343:621 running text | V343:622 running text
Moscow p.254 · Moscow p.255 · Mohl p.307 · Khaleghi p.343 · Ganjoor passage
All four invite Rostam to rest and drink, then place him on the prince’s left while describing his presence as an ornament to the gathering. English retains that contrast between compliment and subordination. Rostam refuses the assigned place and demands the right side; the adjustment remains a dispute about status even though it takes the form of arranging furniture. In the demand to look at him, Mohl’s stature supports English, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi speak of custom. English therefore gives the rebuke a bodily emphasis. The following appeal to prowess and descent makes clear that he understands the seating as an assessment of merit and inherited distinction.
43–46The golden chair accommodates anger without ending it
Moscow: VI255:619 running text | VI255:620 running text | VI255:621 running text | VI255:623 running text; Mohl: IV307:3012 running text | IV307:3013 running text | IV307:3014 running text | IV307:3015 running text; Ganjoor: sh14:45, sh14:46, sh14:47, sh14:49; Khaleghi: V343:623 running text | V343:624 running text | V344:625 running text | V344:626 running text
Moscow p.255 · Mohl p.307 · Khaleghi p.343 · Khaleghi p.344 · Ganjoor passage
All four connect merit and ancestry with generosity and justice, so Rostam’s account of worth extends beyond battlefield strength. English noble start compresses the accompanying farr and lineage language. His wisdom and victory remain intact even if no fitting place is available: the argument separates actual distinction from its recognition by a host. A golden chair is then brought before the royal seat. English at its feet specifies that location more narrowly than the shared wording requires. The final citron does not dissolve the quarrel. All four expressly preserve Rostam’s anger as he sits, leaving the luxurious object and the unresolved affront in the same composed, unsettling picture.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
46 English couplets; Moscow VI252–255:575–623; Mohl IV305–307:2969–3015; Ganjoor sh14:1–49; Khaleghi V339–344:581–626. Mounted return through the golden chair and citron. Next insult begins624/3016/627.
Moscow evidence
Running575–623 inspected. English28 supported by actual p254n2 addition after603. Checked gap594–595 for flight before battle. Main593 black Div and confinement support English16. No appendix evidence used.
Mohl evidence
Running2969–3015 inspected individually. Neigh2969; fleeing enemies2987; Shahs and Iran2990; world-cleansing2997; stature3010. Checked gaps for Ganjoor7,11,32,48. Reprint imprint unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
All49 units accounted for; source-only7,11,32,48. English3 combines3–4. Checked local gaps after20 and29 for English18 and28.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
Running581–626 inspected. Actual additions for Ganjoor7 at340n9,11 at340n18,32 at342n13,48 at344n3. World-cleansing608 is running text. Flight before battle absent from checked598–599 interval. No appendix evidence or exhaustive apparatus agreement claimed.
Interpretive limits
English wrinkles, iron mountain, windlike promise and chair at the royal seat’s feet add specificity. The prince’s account of his intention is reported speech, not independent proof. The opening neigh and black Div follow different primary witnesses.
Moscow printed p.252 · Moscow printed p.253 · Moscow printed p.254 · Moscow printed p.255
Mohl printed p.305 · Mohl printed p.306 · Mohl printed p.307
Khaleghi printed p.339 · Khaleghi printed p.340 · Khaleghi printed p.341 · Khaleghi printed p.342 · Khaleghi printed p.343 · Khaleghi printed p.344
C8.13 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI252:575 running text | IV305:2969 running text |
| 2 | VI252:576 running text | IV305:2970 running text |
| 3 | VI252:577 running text | VI252:578 running text | IV305:2971 running text | IV305:2972 running text |
| 4 | VI252:579 running text | IV305:2973 running text |
| 5 | VI252:580 running text | IV305:2974 running text |
| 6 | VI252:582 running text | IV305:2975 running text |
| 7 | VI252:583 running text | IV305:2976 running text |
| 8 | VI253:584 running text | IV305:2977 running text |
| 9 | VI253:586 running text | IV305:2978 running text |
| 10 | VI253:587 running text | IV306:2979 running text |
| 11 | VI253:588 running text | IV306:2980 running text |
| 12 | VI253:589 running text | IV306:2981 running text |
| 13 | VI253:590 running text | IV306:2982 running text |
| 14 | VI253:591 running text | IV306:2983 running text |
| 15 | VI253:592 running text | IV306:2984 running text |
| 16 | VI253:593 running text | IV306:2985 running text |
| 17 | VI253:594 running text | IV306:2986 running text |
| 18 | VI253 checked local gap between594–595 | IV306:2987 running text |
| 19 | VI253:595 running text | IV306:2988 running text |
| 20 | VI253:596 running text | IV306:2989 running text |
| 21 | VI253:597 running text | IV306:2990 running text |
| 22 | VI253:598 running text | IV306:2991 running text |
| 23 | VI253:599 running text | IV306:2992 running text |
| 24 | VI253:600 running text | IV306:2993 running text |
| 25 | VI254:601 running text | IV306:2994 running text |
| 26 | VI254:602 running text | IV306:2995 running text |
| 27 | VI254:603 running text | IV306:2996 running text |
| 28 | VI254 n2 actual apparatus addition after603 | IV306:2997 running text |
| 29 | VI254:604 running text | IV306:2998 running text |
| 30 | VI254:605 running text | IV306:2999 running text |
| 31 | VI254:607 running text | IV306:3000 running text |
| 32 | VI254:608 running text | IV306:3001 running text |
| 33 | VI254:609 running text | IV306:3002 running text |
| 34 | VI254:610 running text | IV306:3003 running text |
| 35 | VI254:611 running text | IV307:3004 running text |
| 36 | VI254:612 running text | IV307:3005 running text |
| 37 | VI254:613 running text | IV307:3006 running text |
| 38 | VI254:614 running text | IV307:3007 running text |
| 39 | VI254:615 running text | IV307:3008 running text |
| 40 | VI254:616 running text | IV307:3009 running text |
| 41 | VI254:617 running text | IV307:3010 running text |
| 42 | VI255:618 running text | IV307:3011 running text |
| 43 | VI255:619 running text | IV307:3012 running text |
| 44 | VI255:620 running text | IV307:3013 running text |
| 45 | VI255:621 running text | IV307:3014 running text |
| 46 | VI255:623 running text | IV307:3015 running text |
New Naqqali