Rostam Boasts of His Valor
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Rescue is offered as the foundation of royal authority
Moscow: VI261:726 running text | VI261:727 running text | VI261:728 running text | VI261:729 running text | VI261:730 running text | VI261:732 running text; Mohl: IV311:3117 running text | IV311:3118 running text | IV312:3119 running text | IV312:3120 running text | IV312:3121 running text | IV312:3122 running text; Ganjoor: sh18:1, sh18:2, sh18:3, sh18:4, sh18:5, sh18:7; Khaleghi: V352:728 running text | V353:729 running text | V353:730 running text | V353:731 running text | V353:732 running text | V353:734 running text
Moscow p.261 · Mohl p.311 · Mohl p.312 · Khaleghi p.352 · Khaleghi p.353 · Ganjoor passage
All four make deeds the enduring memorial and require a fair hearing for the old hero. English no time can mar enlarges the claim into permanence of fame. The Mazandaran rescue then tests Esfandiyar’s claim that royal favor created Rostam’s standing. The list of captives and their affliction varies: English follows Mohl’s Shah, Gudarz and Tus with darkened eyes, while Moscow and Ganjoor describe deafening drums and name Giv; Khaleghi gives another combination with Kavus’s eyes. English also follows Mohl by placing restoration before the sorcerers’ deaths. The argument remains counterfactual and competitive: without Rostam’s intervention, royal authority could not have continued in its familiar form.
7–12The rescue catalogue keeps its violence visible
Moscow: VI261:731 running text | VI261:733 running text | VI262:734 running text | VI262:735 running text | VI262:736 running text | VI262:737 running text; Mohl: IV312:3123 running text | IV312:3124 running text | IV312:3125 running text | IV312:3126 running text | IV312:3127 running text | IV312:3128 running text; Ganjoor: sh18:6, sh18:8, sh18:9, sh18:10, sh18:11, sh18:12; Khaleghi: V353:733 running text | V353:735 running text | V353:736 running text | V353:737 running text | V353:738 running text | V353:739 running text
Moscow p.261 · Moscow p.262 · Mohl p.312 · Khaleghi p.353 · Ganjoor passage
All four deny the slain sorcerers an ossuary, grave and shroud. English vault renders the first burial structure broadly while retaining the total exclusion from funeral provision. Rakhsh is the companion through the Seven Stages, but the world-winning force differs: Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi assign it to the sword, whereas Mohl emphasizes the horse’s strength. English follows the former. Hamavaran then brings an army, contrasting with the solitary feat previously recalled. Killing the opposing king and emptying the seat make liberation inseparable from destruction. The repetition of Kavus’s bondage and distress keeps the beneficiary visible, so the catalogue argues royal dependence through particular actions rather than generalized heroic fame.
13–18A chain of survival answers a chain of descent
Moscow: VI262:739 running text | VI262:741 running text | VI262:742 running text | VI262:743 running text | VI262:744 running text | VI262:745 running text; Mohl: IV312:3129 running text | IV312:3130 running text | IV312:3131 running text | IV312:3132 running text | IV312:3133 running text | IV312:3134 running text; Ganjoor: sh18:14, sh18:16, sh18:17, sh18:18, sh18:19, sh18:20; Khaleghi: V354:741 running text | V354:743 running text | V354:744 running text | V354:745 running text | V354:746 running text | V354:747 running text
Moscow p.262 · Mohl p.312 · Khaleghi p.354 · Ganjoor passage
All four place Afrasiab in Iran during the crisis, then give Rostam a solitary night advance seeking fame instead of rest. The banner and Rakhsh’s sound cause flight toward Chin, allowing justice and praise to return. Rostam next makes the royal genealogy conditional: if Kavus had died, Siavash could not have been born, and Khosrow could not have crowned Lohrasp. English follows Mohl in explicitly mentioning Khosrow’s pure mother; the other texts phrase the link differently. The argument does not deny descent. It asserts that heroic rescue enabled descent to continue, converting the prince’s proud family tree into evidence of an unpaid debt to the man he proposes to bind.
19–24The refusal of bonds exposes the cost of pleading
Moscow: VI262:748 running text | VI262:749 running text | VI262 checked local interval749–751; different heaven-threat750 | VI263:751 running text | VI263:752 running text; Mohl: IV312:3135 running text | IV312:3136 running text | IV312:3137 running text | IV312:3138 running text | IV312:3139 running text | IV312:3140 running text; Ganjoor: sh18:23, sh18:24, sh18:26, sh18:27; Khaleghi: V354:750 running text | V354:751 running text | V354 n21 actual apparatus addition after752 | V354 n21 actual apparatus variant addition after752; different negative wording | V355:753 running text | V355:754 running text
Moscow p.262 · Moscow p.263 · Mohl p.312 · Khaleghi p.354 · Khaleghi p.355 · Ganjoor passage
All four reject the thought that even heaven can bind Rostam. English then follows Mohl’s two additional running units about royal regalia depending on him and the prince’s Kayanian standing; the corresponding Moscow and Ganjoor interval instead threatens heaven with the mace. Khaleghi’s apparatus actually prints alternative lines, but its negative wording about royal descent must not be called identical to Mohl. English also omits Mohl’s description of the prince as new. The closing claim that no such speech was endured through a long life is shared. Pleading itself becomes humiliating, explaining why continued courtesy is felt as a loss of stature rather than a simple path to agreement.
25–30Praise conceals the first physical trial
Moscow: VI263:753 running text | VI263:754 running text | VI263:755 running text | VI263:756 running text | VI263:757 running text | VI263:758 running text; Mohl: IV312:3141 running text | IV312:3142 running text | IV312:3143 running text | IV313:3144 running text | IV313:3145 running text | IV313:3146 running text; Ganjoor: sh18:28, sh18:29, sh18:30, sh18:31, sh18:32, sh18:33; Khaleghi: V355:755 running text | V355:756 running text | V355:757 running text | V355:758 running text | V355:759 running text | V355:760 running text
Moscow p.263 · Mohl p.312 · Mohl p.313 · Khaleghi p.355 · Ganjoor passage
All four let Esfandiyar laugh and seize Rostam’s hand while praising the body that matches its reputation. The elephant, lion and dragon comparisons make apparent admiration a preparation for testing strength. English twisting waist follows Mohl and Khaleghi, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor emphasize the moment of grasping the mace. The squeeze occurs within the speech, so conversation and assault remain deliberately difficult to separate. Yellow fluid from the nails registers injury while Rostam’s laughter and stillness deny his opponent a visible surrender. English joke interprets that laughter, but the shared text establishes control under pain more securely than it establishes genuine amusement or absence of resentment.
31–36The returned grip reverses the compliment’s force
Moscow: VI263:759 running text | VI263:760 running text | VI263:761 running text | VI263:762 running text | VI263:763 running text | VI263:764 running text; Mohl: IV313:3147 running text | IV313:3148 running text | IV313:3149 running text | IV313:3150 running text | IV313:3151 running text | IV313:3152 running text; Ganjoor: sh18:34, sh18:35, sh18:36, sh18:37, sh18:38, sh18:39; Khaleghi: V355:761 running text | V355:762 running text | V356:763 running text | V356:764 running text | V356:765 running text | V356:766 running text
Moscow p.263 · Mohl p.313 · Khaleghi p.355 · Khaleghi p.356 · Ganjoor passage
All four reverse the grip and let Rostam address the prince as a worshipper of God. Blessing Goshtasb for such a son repeats the form of courteous praise while strength turns it into a counterattack. English preserves the sequence of the reddening face, bloody fluid at the nails and contracted brows, keeping the pain visible beneath ceremony. The contrast with Rostam’s earlier stillness makes the contest asymmetrical without requiring a numerical measure of strength. Esfandiyar’s subsequent laughter restores his public composure. It does not erase the bodily signs just narrated, and the commentary therefore treats the laugh as part of the contest rather than proof that neither man was hurt.
37–42Mercy is promised only after enforced submission
Moscow: VI263:765 running text | VI263:766 running text | VI263:767 running text | VI264:768 running text | VI264:769 running text | VI264:770 running text; Mohl: IV313:3153 running text | IV313:3154 running text | IV313:3155 running text | IV313:3156 running text | IV313:3157 running text | IV313:3158 running text; Ganjoor: sh18:40, sh18:41, sh18:42, sh18:43, sh18:44, sh18:45; Khaleghi: V356:767 running text | V356:768 running text | V356:769 running text | V356:770 running text | V356:771 running text | V356:772 running text
Moscow p.263 · Moscow p.264 · Mohl p.313 · Khaleghi p.356 · Ganjoor passage
All four oppose wine today to painful combat tomorrow and then threaten unhorsing, binding and presentation before the Shah. English black steed is supported by Moscow, Mohl and Khaleghi, against the anomalous word in Ganjoor’s corresponding line. The promise to report no observed guilt follows the threat, making the prince’s proposed mercy conditional on submission. Intercession, relief and treasure do not remove that condition. English every point at stake expands the settlement language but retains the offer’s essential structure. The contradiction is therefore dramatic rather than merely lexical: Esfandiyar promises to protect the honor of a man after performing the very public humiliation that man has declared intolerable.
43–48The feast’s instruments are replaced by weapons
Moscow: VI264:771 running text | VI264:772 running text | VI264:773 running text | VI264:774 running text | VI264:775 running text | VI264:776 running text; Mohl: IV313:3159 running text | IV313:3160 running text | IV313:3161 running text | IV313:3162 running text | IV313:3163 running text | IV313:3164 running text; Ganjoor: sh18:46, sh18:47, sh18:48, sh18:49, sh18:50, sh18:51; Khaleghi: V356:773 running text | V357:774 running text | V357:775 running text | V357:776 running text | V357:777 running text | V357:778 running text
Moscow p.264 · Mohl p.313 · Khaleghi p.356 · Khaleghi p.357 · Ganjoor passage
All four have Rostam laugh and promise more than enough battle, then question the prince’s experience of combat and the heavy mace’s wind. English this aspect of the sky follows Mohl’s positive formulation, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi say other than this. The ensuing substitutions remain clear across the witnesses: vengeance replaces red wine, drums replace strings, and blade and mace become the greeting. English bow follows Mohl and Khaleghi where Moscow and Ganjoor have combat alongside lasso and ambush. These substitutions turn the existing feast into a verbal battlefield, making the threatened rupture imaginable through the very objects and sounds that currently hold the company together.
49–54Rostam answers captivity with an alternative coronation
Moscow: VI264:777 running text | VI264:778 running text | VI264:779 running text | VI264:780 running text | VI264:781 running text | VI264:782 running text; Mohl: IV313:3165 running text | IV313:3166 running text | IV313:3167 running text | IV313:3168 running text | IV314:3169 running text | IV314:3170 running text; Ganjoor: sh18:52, sh18:53, sh18:54, sh18:55, sh18:56, sh18:57; Khaleghi: V357:779 running text | V357:780 running text | V357:781 running text | V357:782 running text | V357:783 running text | V357:784 running text
Moscow p.264 · Mohl p.313 · Mohl p.314 · Khaleghi p.357 · Ganjoor passage
All four promise a meeting of man against man, followed by lifting Esfandiyar from the saddle and carrying him to Zal. English embrace preserves the bodily closeness of the capture while allowing the next movement toward hospitality. The ivory throne, Qobad’s crown and opened treasures make this a rival settlement rather than a bare threat of defeat. English raise your crown in worth explains the heavenly elevation image in terms of prestige. The offer provides royal distinction and support for the army without requiring Rostam’s bondage. Yet it still assumes that Rostam can physically compel the prince first; its generosity therefore remains entangled with the same contest of mastery it seeks to resolve.
55–59Future service is offered from a position of strength
Moscow: VI264:783 running text | VI265:784 running text | VI265:785 running text | VI265:786 running text | VI265:787 running text; Mohl: IV314:3171 running text | IV314:3172 running text | IV314:3173 running text | IV314:3174 running text | IV314:3175 running text; Ganjoor: sh18:58, sh18:59, sh18:60, sh18:61, sh18:62; Khaleghi: V358:785 running text | V358:786 running text | V358:787 running text | V358:788 running text | V358:789 running text
Moscow p.264 · Moscow p.265 · Mohl p.314 · Khaleghi p.358 · Ganjoor passage
All four bring Rostam joyfully before the Shah after the proposed coronation. His promise places Goshtasb under an obligation of gratitude; English earn gratitude softens that leverage into deserved recognition. Renewing the warrior’s belt recalls service to earlier Kayanians, while clearing thorns from the garden gives the alliance a restorative image. The final claim differs in scope: Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor deny anyone life against the pair, whereas Khaleghi explicitly names an evil person. English against us makes opposition the condition and avoids an indiscriminate threat to everyone. The imagined partnership ends the speech with extraordinary confidence, but it remains Rostam’s proposal, not an agreement accepted by Esfandiyar.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
59 English couplets; Moscow VI261–265:726–787; Mohl IV311–314:3117–3175; Ganjoor sh18:1–62; Khaleghi V352–358:728–789. Rostam’s reply through proposed royal partnership. Feast begins788/3176/790.
Moscow evidence
Running726–787 inspected. Ganjoor13,15,21,22,25 are source-only. English21–22 absent from checked749–751 interval, which includes heaven-threat750. Captives729 and sword733 distinguished from Mohl.
Mohl evidence
Running3117–3175 inspected. Reordered restoration3122 before sorcerers3123. Local gaps for Ganjoor13,15,21,22,25; additional3137–3138 support English21–22. Main3144 turning waist,3161 this turn of heaven,3162 bow. Reprint imprint unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
All62 units allocated; source-only13,15,21,22,25. English21–22 absent in checked24–26 interval; different heaven-threat25 present. Main41 sepah differs from three printed black-steed readings.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
Running728–789 inspected. Actual apparatus354n21 prints alternatives supporting comparison at English21–22, but its royal-descent wording differs from Mohl. Main758 turning waist,776 bow,789 evil person. No appendix evidence used; no exhaustive apparatus agreement claimed.
Interpretive limits
English22 drops Mohl’s new; Khaleghi apparatus cannot be equated with that positive lineage statement. Laughter is not proof of painless amusement. Both proposed settlements follow threats of force; neither is an accepted agreement.
Moscow printed p.261 · Moscow printed p.262 · Moscow printed p.263 · Moscow printed p.264 · Moscow printed p.265
Mohl printed p.311 · Mohl printed p.312 · Mohl printed p.313 · Mohl printed p.314
Khaleghi printed p.352 · Khaleghi printed p.353 · Khaleghi printed p.354 · Khaleghi printed p.355 · Khaleghi printed p.356 · Khaleghi printed p.357 · Khaleghi printed p.358
C8.17 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI261:726 running text | IV311:3117 running text |
| 2 | VI261:727 running text | IV311:3118 running text |
| 3 | VI261:728 running text | IV312:3119 running text |
| 4 | VI261:729 running text | IV312:3120 running text |
| 5 | VI261:730 running text | IV312:3121 running text |
| 6 | VI261:732 running text | IV312:3122 running text |
| 7 | VI261:731 running text | IV312:3123 running text |
| 8 | VI261:733 running text | IV312:3124 running text |
| 9 | VI262:734 running text | IV312:3125 running text |
| 10 | VI262:735 running text | IV312:3126 running text |
| 11 | VI262:736 running text | IV312:3127 running text |
| 12 | VI262:737 running text | IV312:3128 running text |
| 13 | VI262:739 running text | IV312:3129 running text |
| 14 | VI262:741 running text | IV312:3130 running text |
| 15 | VI262:742 running text | IV312:3131 running text |
| 16 | VI262:743 running text | IV312:3132 running text |
| 17 | VI262:744 running text | IV312:3133 running text |
| 18 | VI262:745 running text | IV312:3134 running text |
| 19 | VI262:748 running text | IV312:3135 running text |
| 20 | VI262:749 running text | IV312:3136 running text |
| 21 | VI262 checked local interval749–751; different heaven-threat750 | IV312:3137 running text |
| 22 | VI262 checked local interval749–751; different heaven-threat750 | IV312:3138 running text |
| 23 | VI263:751 running text | IV312:3139 running text |
| 24 | VI263:752 running text | IV312:3140 running text |
| 25 | VI263:753 running text | IV312:3141 running text |
| 26 | VI263:754 running text | IV312:3142 running text |
| 27 | VI263:755 running text | IV312:3143 running text |
| 28 | VI263:756 running text | IV313:3144 running text |
| 29 | VI263:757 running text | IV313:3145 running text |
| 30 | VI263:758 running text | IV313:3146 running text |
| 31 | VI263:759 running text | IV313:3147 running text |
| 32 | VI263:760 running text | IV313:3148 running text |
| 33 | VI263:761 running text | IV313:3149 running text |
| 34 | VI263:762 running text | IV313:3150 running text |
| 35 | VI263:763 running text | IV313:3151 running text |
| 36 | VI263:764 running text | IV313:3152 running text |
| 37 | VI263:765 running text | IV313:3153 running text |
| 38 | VI263:766 running text | IV313:3154 running text |
| 39 | VI263:767 running text | IV313:3155 running text |
| 40 | VI264:768 running text | IV313:3156 running text |
| 41 | VI264:769 running text | IV313:3157 running text |
| 42 | VI264:770 running text | IV313:3158 running text |
| 43 | VI264:771 running text | IV313:3159 running text |
| 44 | VI264:772 running text | IV313:3160 running text |
| 45 | VI264:773 running text | IV313:3161 running text |
| 46 | VI264:774 running text | IV313:3162 running text |
| 47 | VI264:775 running text | IV313:3163 running text |
| 48 | VI264:776 running text | IV313:3164 running text |
| 49 | VI264:777 running text | IV313:3165 running text |
| 50 | VI264:778 running text | IV313:3166 running text |
| 51 | VI264:779 running text | IV313:3167 running text |
| 52 | VI264:780 running text | IV313:3168 running text |
| 53 | VI264:781 running text | IV314:3169 running text |
| 54 | VI264:782 running text | IV314:3170 running text |
| 55 | VI264:783 running text | IV314:3171 running text |
| 56 | VI265:784 running text | IV314:3172 running text |
| 57 | VI265:785 running text | IV314:3173 running text |
| 58 | VI265:786 running text | IV314:3174 running text |
| 59 | VI265:787 running text | IV314:3175 running text |
New Naqqali