Rostam Returns to His Palace
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The tent becomes a witness to competing royal histories
Moscow: VI271:880 running text | VI271:881 running text | VI271:882 running text | VI271:883 running text | VI271:884 running text | VI271:885 running text; Mohl: IV318:3272 running text | IV318:3273 running text | IV318:3274 running text | IV318:3275 running text | IV318:3276 running text | IV318:3277 running text; Ganjoor: sh20:1, sh20:2, sh20:3, sh20:4, sh20:5, sh20:6; Khaleghi: V366:882 running text | V366:883 running text | V366:884 running text | V366:885 running text | V366:886 running text | V366:887 running text
Moscow p.271 · Mohl p.318 · Khaleghi p.366 · Ganjoor passage
All four let Rostam pause at the tent’s entrance and address it as a house of hope. English fame expands that address, while the blessings on Jamshid, Kavus and Khosrow make the structure seem continuous across reigns. The closed door of farr indicts its present occupant rather than the fabric itself. Esfandiyar hears and comes on foot, preserving a degree of ceremonial respect even as he challenges the insult. English man of judgment interprets his address positively. The exchange gives the argument a new object: instead of simply praising their own ancestry, the speakers now dispute which royal past the present tent should honor.
7–12The host turns the guest’s historical praise against him
Moscow: VI271:886 running text | VI271:887 running text | VI271:888 running text | VI271 n17 actual apparatus addition after888 | VI271:889 running text | VI271:890 running text; Mohl: IV318:3278 running text | IV318:3279 running text | IV318:3280 running text | IV318:3281 running text | IV318:3282 running text | IV318:3283 running text; Ganjoor: sh20:7, sh20:8, sh20:9, sh20:10, sh20:11; Khaleghi: V366:888 running text | V366:889 running text | V367:890 running text | V367:891 running text | V367:892 running text | V367:893 running text
Moscow p.271 · Mohl p.318 · Khaleghi p.366 · Khaleghi p.367 · Ganjoor passage
All four use the pun that renames Zabulistan as a land of uproar. English supplies the meaning, allowing readers to hear the rebuke rather than encounter only an unexplained place-name. The satisfied guest’s abuse of the gardener then recasts Rostam’s protest as ingratitude. Esfandiyar reverses the blessing of Jamshid and cites his abandonment of God’s path. That additional unit is running text in Mohl and Khaleghi and an actual apparatus addition in Moscow, with a local gap in Ganjoor. Kavus’s sheltered army and search into divine mysteries follow. English therefore preserves a coherent counterhistory in which royal grandeur can coexist with religious failure and destructive curiosity.
13–18The present court is defended through religious order
Moscow: VI271:891 running text | VI271:892 running text | VI271:893 running text | VI272:894 running text | VI272:895 running text | VI272:896 running text; Mohl: IV318:3284 running text | IV318:3285 running text | IV318:3286 running text | IV318:3287 running text | IV318:3288 running text | IV319:3289 running text; Ganjoor: sh20:12, sh20:13, sh20:14, sh20:15, sh20:16, sh20:17; Khaleghi: V367:894 running text | V367:895 running text | V367:896 running text | V367:897 running text | V367:898 running text | V367:899 running text
Moscow p.271 · Moscow p.272 · Mohl p.318 · Mohl p.319 · Khaleghi p.367 · Ganjoor passage
All four associate Kavus’s reign with turmoil and weapons before contrasting Goshtasb’s court, Jamasp, Zardosht and Bishutan. English gives the council a composed arrangement that makes authority appear supported by wisdom and revelation. Bishutan’s relation to worldly experience differs: Mohl says he seeks neither heat nor cold, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi say he has tasted them. English leaves grief and pleasure behind, following Mohl’s detachment rather than the others’ experience. Esfandiyar then places himself before the court as the reviver of good hearts and terror of evil. This is self-praise within his answer, not a detached judgment that the present court has resolved its moral contradictions.
19–24Admiration survives the argument over obedience
Moscow: VI272:897 running text | VI272:898 running text | VI272:899 running text | VI272:900 running text | VI272:902 running text | VI272:903 running text; Mohl: IV319:3290 running text | IV319:3291 running text | IV319:3292 running text | IV319:3293 running text | IV319:3294 running text | IV319:3295 running text; Ganjoor: sh20:18, sh20:19, sh20:20, sh20:21, sh20:23, sh20:24; Khaleghi: V367:900 running text | V368:901 running text | V368:902 running text | V368:903 running text | V368:904 running text | V368:905 running text
Moscow p.272 · Mohl p.319 · Khaleghi p.367 · Khaleghi p.368 · Ganjoor passage
All four have Esfandiyar watch Rostam ride away and admit that valor cannot be hidden. The unprecedented horse and rider, followed by the elephant on Mount Gang, preserve the visual force of the departing hero. English fear of tomorrow’s fall keeps affection inside the prince’s martial confidence. Moscow and Ganjoor include a further conditional unit about armed combat that Mohl lacks locally and Khaleghi prints in apparatus; English has no separate counterpart. The final appeal to the Maker’s command names the constraint that admiration cannot overcome. The prince does not fail to see Rostam’s greatness. He sees it clearly and nevertheless treats obedience as the determining claim on his conduct.
25–30Bishutan proposes a practical form of reconciliation
Moscow: VI272:904 running text | VI272:905 running text | VI272:906 running text | VI272:907 running text | VI272:908 running text | VI272:909 running text; Mohl: IV319:3296 running text | IV319:3297 running text | IV319:3298 running text | IV319:3299 running text | IV319:3300 running text | IV319:3301 running text; Ganjoor: sh20:25, sh20:26, sh20:27, sh20:28, sh20:29, sh20:30; Khaleghi: V368:906 running text | V368:907 running text | V368:908 running text | V368:909 running text | V368:910 running text | V368:911 running text
Moscow p.272 · Mohl p.319 · Khaleghi p.368 · Ganjoor passage
All four first let the prince promise to darken Rostam’s day, then introduce Bishutan’s direct plea to stop. The brother’s insistence that he remains with truth makes repeated counsel a duty rather than mere persistence. His argument from the noble man’s refusal of injury recognizes why bonds cannot produce willing cooperation. A dawn visit without troops supplies a practical alternative. English none beside is narrower than the shared absence of an army and may suggest complete solitude. The proposed happy day and answers to requests restore the language of reciprocal hospitality. Bishutan’s plan therefore addresses conduct and setting, offering a concrete interruption to the cycle of public challenge and threatened humiliation.
31–36The same garden receives incompatible interpretations
Moscow: VI272:910 running text | VI272:911 running text | VI272:912 running text | VI273:913 running text | VI273:914 running text | VI273:915 running text; Mohl: IV319:3302 running text | IV319:3303 running text | IV319:3304 running text | IV319:3305 running text | IV319:3306 running text | IV319:3307 running text; Ganjoor: sh20:31, sh20:32, sh20:33, sh20:34, sh20:35, sh20:36; Khaleghi: V368:912 running text | V368:913 running text | V369:914 running text | V369:915 running text | V369:916 running text | V369:917 running text
Moscow p.272 · Moscow p.273 · Mohl p.319 · Khaleghi p.368 · Khaleghi p.369 · Ganjoor passage
All four praise Rostam’s benefit to great and small and trust his promise, then ask the prince to wash hatred from heart and anger from eyes. English west to east extends the general world reference but preserves the counsel’s inclusive force. Esfandiyar answers with a thorn growing in the rose garden, making his brother’s advice a blemish within an otherwise valued relationship. The appeal to pure religion then casts disagreement as a problem of belief. Calling Bishutan the heart, ear and eye of the heroes intensifies the rebuke: a counselor trusted to perceive and judge is accused of failing precisely those functions. Affection and accusation remain joined within the same familial exchange.
37–42Royal disobedience is made a religious impossibility
Moscow: VI273:916 running text | VI273:917 running text | VI273:918 running text | VI273:919 running text | VI273:920 running text | VI273:921 running text; Mohl: IV319:3308 running text | IV319:3309 running text | IV319:3310 running text | IV319:3311 running text | IV319:3312 running text | IV319:3313 running text; Ganjoor: sh20:37, sh20:38, sh20:39, sh20:40, sh20:41, sh20:42; Khaleghi: V369:918 running text | V369:919 running text | V369:920 running text | V369:921 running text | V369:922 running text | V369:923 running text
Moscow p.273 · Mohl p.319 · Khaleghi p.369 · Ganjoor passage
All four ask how a supposedly wise course can injure the Shah, then make that injury waste the brothers’ labor and disgrace Zardosht’s faith. The assertion that disobedience leads to hell converts a political instruction into an ultimate sanction. English keeps this logic explicit rather than moderating it into simple loyalty. The prince’s restatement of Bishutan’s advice as a demand to sin is argumentative, not an exact quotation of what the brother proposed. His refusal follows from that restatement. The promise to break Bishutan’s fear then changes the subject from the justice of the command to confidence in survival, leaving the earlier objection to coercion unanswered.
43–48Confidence in fame confronts the brother’s grief
Moscow: VI273:922 running text | VI273:923 running text | VI273:924 running text | VI273:925 running text | VI273:926 running text | VI273:927 running text; Mohl: IV320:3314 running text | IV320:3315 running text | IV320:3316 running text | IV320:3317 running text | IV320:3318 running text | IV320:3319 running text; Ganjoor: sh20:43, sh20:44, sh20:45, sh20:46, sh20:47, sh20:48; Khaleghi: V369:924 running text | V370:925 running text | V370:926 running text | V370:927 running text | V370:928 running text | V370:929 running text
Moscow p.273 · Mohl p.320 · Khaleghi p.369 · Khaleghi p.370 · Ganjoor passage
All four join appointed death with the survival of a great name, allowing Esfandiyar to answer fear without promising literal immortality. English clawed nahang follows Mohl where the other three main texts have a leopard. Mace and bow likewise follows Mohl against their arrow and bow. Bishutan’s accusation that the Div has entered the heart answers the prince’s claim of religious certainty with a rival diagnosis of delusion. His final gesture differs sharply among witnesses: English follows Mohl’s torn garment; Moscow and Ganjoor fragment the spoken counsel, while Khaleghi tears a shroud. The choice makes grief bodily and immediate without introducing the shroud’s more explicit anticipation of death.
49–51Uncertainty outlasts the prince’s assertions
Moscow: VI273:928 running text | VI273:929 running text | VI273:930 running text; Mohl: IV320:3320 running text | IV320:3321 running text | IV320:3322 running text; Ganjoor: sh20:49, sh20:50, sh20:51; Khaleghi: V370:930 running text | V370:931 running text | V370:932 running text
Moscow p.273 · Mohl p.320 · Khaleghi p.370 · Ganjoor passage
All four let Bishutan ask how fear can be removed while he feels himself breaking apart. The matched warriors and lions make the result unknowable from prowess alone: each is formidable enough to destroy the other. English whose back will be pressed to earth gives the shared image a clear physical outcome while leaving the winner unidentified. The prince’s silence then replaces his earlier certainty. Pain and swelling pride coexist in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor’s head image, followed by English; Khaleghi gives a lip full of wind. Neither version supplies a reconciliation. The scene ends with counsel exhausted and emotion unresolved, preparing the parallel distress at Rostam’s own household.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
51 English couplets; Moscow VI271–273:880–930; Mohl IV318–320:3272–3322; Ganjoor sh20:1–51; Khaleghi V366–370:882–932. Tent exchange and Bishutan’s counsel through the prince’s silence. Homecoming begins931/3323/933.
Moscow evidence
Running880–930 inspected. Actual271n17 supports English10. Main901 is source-only; main894 experience,923 leopard,925 arrow,927 fragmented speech differ from English.
Mohl evidence
Running3272–3322 inspected. Extra3281 Jamshid’s impiety; checked gap3293–3294 for Ganjoor22. Main3287 detachment,3315 nahang,3317 mace,3319 torn garment support English. Reprint imprint remains unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
All51 allocated; source-only22, local gap9–10 for English10. The repeated numbers do not imply identical boundary content with other witnesses.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
Running882–932 inspected. Extra891 Jamshid’s impiety; actual368n7 contains Ganjoor22. Main929 shroud differs from Mohl garment and Moscow/Ganjoor speech. Main932 lip rather than head. No appendix evidence or exhaustive apparatus agreement claimed.
Interpretive limits
The tent speeches present rival evaluations of kingship. English29 none beside narrows without an army. Bishutan’s advice is not itself a direct demand to sin; that is the prince’s hostile restatement.
Moscow printed p.271 · Moscow printed p.272 · Moscow printed p.273
Mohl printed p.318 · Mohl printed p.319 · Mohl printed p.320
Khaleghi printed p.366 · Khaleghi printed p.367 · Khaleghi printed p.368 · Khaleghi printed p.369 · Khaleghi printed p.370
C8.19 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI271:880 running text | IV318:3272 running text |
| 2 | VI271:881 running text | IV318:3273 running text |
| 3 | VI271:882 running text | IV318:3274 running text |
| 4 | VI271:883 running text | IV318:3275 running text |
| 5 | VI271:884 running text | IV318:3276 running text |
| 6 | VI271:885 running text | IV318:3277 running text |
| 7 | VI271:886 running text | IV318:3278 running text |
| 8 | VI271:887 running text | IV318:3279 running text |
| 9 | VI271:888 running text | IV318:3280 running text |
| 10 | VI271 n17 actual apparatus addition after888 | IV318:3281 running text |
| 11 | VI271:889 running text | IV318:3282 running text |
| 12 | VI271:890 running text | IV318:3283 running text |
| 13 | VI271:891 running text | IV318:3284 running text |
| 14 | VI271:892 running text | IV318:3285 running text |
| 15 | VI271:893 running text | IV318:3286 running text |
| 16 | VI272:894 running text | IV318:3287 running text |
| 17 | VI272:895 running text | IV318:3288 running text |
| 18 | VI272:896 running text | IV319:3289 running text |
| 19 | VI272:897 running text | IV319:3290 running text |
| 20 | VI272:898 running text | IV319:3291 running text |
| 21 | VI272:899 running text | IV319:3292 running text |
| 22 | VI272:900 running text | IV319:3293 running text |
| 23 | VI272:902 running text | IV319:3294 running text |
| 24 | VI272:903 running text | IV319:3295 running text |
| 25 | VI272:904 running text | IV319:3296 running text |
| 26 | VI272:905 running text | IV319:3297 running text |
| 27 | VI272:906 running text | IV319:3298 running text |
| 28 | VI272:907 running text | IV319:3299 running text |
| 29 | VI272:908 running text | IV319:3300 running text |
| 30 | VI272:909 running text | IV319:3301 running text |
| 31 | VI272:910 running text | IV319:3302 running text |
| 32 | VI272:911 running text | IV319:3303 running text |
| 33 | VI272:912 running text | IV319:3304 running text |
| 34 | VI273:913 running text | IV319:3305 running text |
| 35 | VI273:914 running text | IV319:3306 running text |
| 36 | VI273:915 running text | IV319:3307 running text |
| 37 | VI273:916 running text | IV319:3308 running text |
| 38 | VI273:917 running text | IV319:3309 running text |
| 39 | VI273:918 running text | IV319:3310 running text |
| 40 | VI273:919 running text | IV319:3311 running text |
| 41 | VI273:920 running text | IV319:3312 running text |
| 42 | VI273:921 running text | IV319:3313 running text |
| 43 | VI273:922 running text | IV320:3314 running text |
| 44 | VI273:923 running text | IV320:3315 running text |
| 45 | VI273:924 running text | IV320:3316 running text |
| 46 | VI273:925 running text | IV320:3317 running text |
| 47 | VI273:926 running text | IV320:3318 running text |
| 48 | VI273:927 running text | IV320:3319 running text |
| 49 | VI273:928 running text | IV320:3320 running text |
| 50 | VI273:929 running text | IV320:3321 running text |
| 51 | VI273:930 running text | IV320:3322 running text |
New Naqqali