Zavareh and Faramarz Slay Esfandiyar’s Sons
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The waiting army turns uncertainty into aggression
Moscow: VI282:1055 running text | VI282:1056 running text | VI282:1057 running text | VI282:1058 running text | VI282:1059 running text | VI282:1060 running text; Mohl: IV326:3456 running text | IV326:3457 running text | IV326:3458 running text | IV326:3459 running text | IV326:3460 running text | IV326:3461 running text; Ganjoor: sh23:1, sh23:2, sh23:3, sh23:4, sh23:5, sh23:6; Khaleghi: V381:1063 running text | V381:1064 running text | V381:1065 running text | V381:1066 running text | V381:1067 running text | V381:1068 running text
Moscow p.282 · Mohl p.326 · Khaleghi p.381 · Ganjoor passage
All four prolong the principals’ duel before bringing Zavareh and his vengeful troops forward. His question about Rostam and the Iranians’ silence converts uncertainty into provocation. English caught in Rostam’s grip explains the nahang image as the opponent’s dangerous power, though the Persian metaphor is less explicit about a completed capture. The next assertion differs: English shall not bind agrees with Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi, while Mohl says that the Iranians wish to bind him. The narrator then calls Zavareh’s words unseemly. This judgment matters because the escalation begins with his conduct, before any claim that the young princes have attacked without cause.
7–12Royal obedience receives incompatible textual formulations
Moscow: VI282:1061 running text | VI282:1062 running text | VI282:1063 running text | VI282:1064 running text | VI282:1065 running text | VI282:1066 running text; Mohl: IV326:3462 running text | IV326:3463 running text | IV326:3464 running text | IV326:3465 running text | IV326:3466 running text | IV326:3467 running text; Ganjoor: sh23:7, sh23:8, sh23:9, sh23:10, sh23:11, sh23:12; Khaleghi: V381:1069 running text | V382:1070 running text | V382:1071 running text | V382:1072 running text | V382:1073 running text | V382:1074 running text
Moscow p.282 · Mohl p.326 · Khaleghi p.381 · Khaleghi p.382 · Ganjoor passage
All four introduce Nush Azar as a distinguished young warrior and give him an abusive reply to the Sagzi. English distributes his rider-felling prowess across the introduction and naming, preserving the characterization. His account of obedience then differs consequentially: Mohl supports killing the wicked at royal command; Moscow and Ganjoor speak of doing evil at that command; Khaleghi gives nurture under royal authority. English chooses the morally affirmative formulation rather than the disturbing alternative. The following insult about dogs and appeal to Esfandiyar’s command remain direct speech. They establish the youth’s stated reason for restraint without making his abusive characterization the narrator’s own voice.
13–18A conditional warning is followed by an actual first attack
Moscow: VI282:1067 running text | VI282:1068 running text | VI282:1069 running text | VI283:1070 running text | VI283:1071 running text | VI283:1072 running text; Mohl: IV326:3468 running text | IV326:3469 running text | IV326:3470 running text | IV326:3471 running text | IV326:3472 running text | IV326:3473 running text; Ganjoor: sh23:13, sh23:14, sh23:15, sh23:16, sh23:17, sh23:18; Khaleghi: V382:1075 running text | V382:1076 running text | V382:1077 running text | V382:1078 running text | V382:1079 running text | V382:1080 running text
Moscow p.282 · Moscow p.283 · Mohl p.326 · Khaleghi p.382 · Ganjoor passage
All four make Nush Azar’s threat conditional on the other side initiating an unjust fight. The catalogue of sword, spear and heavy mace gives that warning physical substance without yet describing an attack. Zavareh answers with the command to place bloody crowns on the chiefs, and his advance is followed by the killing of Iranians. English preserves this sequence explicitly before Nush Azar mounts his dun with an Indian sword. The order is crucial to the later accusation of broken faith. The son’s entrance into combat answers deaths already inflicted by Zavareh’s force, rather than independently beginning the general battle that the principals had forbidden.
19–24The spear-bearer’s death becomes the occasion for retaliation
Moscow: VI283:1073 running text | VI283:1074 running text | VI283:1075 running text | VI283:1076 running text | VI283:1077 running text | VI283:1078 running text; Mohl: IV326:3474 running text | IV326:3475 running text | IV326:3476 running text | IV326:3477 running text | IV326:3478 running text | IV327:3479 running text; Ganjoor: sh23:19, sh23:20, sh23:21, sh23:22, sh23:23, sh23:24; Khaleghi: V383:1081 running text | V383:1082 running text | V383:1083 running text | V383:1084 running text | V383:1085 running text | V383:1086 running text
Moscow p.283 · Mohl p.326 · Mohl p.327 · Khaleghi p.383 · Ganjoor passage
All four identify Alva by name and prowess before explaining his close service as Rostam’s spear-bearer. That relationship makes his death part of the hero’s own military household, even though Rostam is elsewhere. English cleft to the waist follows Mohl’s bodily detail; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi divide the elephant-like body without that precise endpoint. Zavareh’s response disparages the dead man’s status as a rider while demanding that his killer stand firm. The apparent insult does not cancel the retaliatory action it introduces. English preserves the harsh challenge without supplying a consoling explanation, allowing the contradictory rhetoric of martial grief and pride to remain visible.
25–30One death turns the army’s day and draws in another son
Moscow: VI283:1079 running text | VI283:1080 running text | VI283:1081 running text | VI283:1082 running text | VI284:1083 running text | VI284:1084 running text; Mohl: IV327:3480 running text | IV327:3481 running text | IV327:3482 running text | IV327:3483 running text | IV327:3484 running text | IV327:3485 running text; Ganjoor: sh23:25, sh23:26, sh23:27, sh23:28, sh23:29, sh23:30; Khaleghi: V383:1087 running text | V383:1088 running text | V383:1089 running text | V383:1090 running text | V383:1091 running text | V383:1092 running text
Moscow p.283 · Moscow p.284 · Mohl p.327 · Khaleghi p.383 · Ganjoor passage
All four have Zavareh pierce Nush Azar’s chest and bring his head to the ground. English life at rest interprets the fatal result without making the fallen head a separate decapitation. The army’s reversed day becomes faltering Fortune, giving the collective change a clear English agent. Mehr-e-Nush’s tears, seething heart and foaming lips then move grief into bodily motion. His elephant-like horse is answered by Faramarz’s own elephant comparison and Indian sword. The paired imagery gives the second encounter symmetry while preserving the asymmetry of motive: the prince advances under immediate bereavement, whereas Faramarz enters as the answering champion.
31–36A failed blow explains the fatal loss of the horse
Moscow: VI284:1085 running text | VI284:1086 running text | VI284:1087 running text | VI284:1088 running text | VI284 checked local gap1088–1089; n7 alternate sequence inspected, not this verse | VI284:1089 running text; Mohl: IV327:3486 running text | IV327:3487 running text | IV327:3488 running text | IV327:3489 running text | IV327:3490 running text | IV327:3491 running text; Ganjoor: sh23:31, sh23:32, sh23:33, sh23:34, sh23:35; Khaleghi: V384:1093 running text | V384:1094 running text | V384:1095 running text | V384:1096 running text | V384:1097 running text | V384:1098 running text
Moscow p.284 · Mohl p.327 · Khaleghi p.384 · Ganjoor passage
The four sources surround the young duelists with cries from both armies and distinguish the prince from the champion despite their shared noble bearing. The lion comparison gives their exchanged blows equal ferocity, but the next statement denies Mehr-e-Nush sufficient strength against Faramarz. English then follows an additional running verse in Mohl and Khaleghi that describes his intended blow at the famous opponent. Moscow and Ganjoor lack that verse locally. The sword instead cuts the neck of his own horse. Including the intention makes the accident intelligible as a failed attack, while the checked local gaps remain evidence of a shorter sequence rather than proof of a different killer.
37–42The report carries the sons’ deaths into the fathers’ duel
Moscow: VI284:1090 running text | VI284:1091 running text | VI284:1092 running text | VI284:1093 running text | VI284:1094 running text | VI284:1095 running text; Mohl: IV327:3492 running text | IV327:3493 running text | IV327:3494 running text | IV327:3495 running text | IV327:3496 running text | IV327:3497 running text; Ganjoor: sh23:36, sh23:37, sh23:38, sh23:39, sh23:40, sh23:41; Khaleghi: V384:1099 running text | V384:1100 running text | V384:1101 running text | V384:1102 running text | V384:1103 running text | V384:1104 running text
Moscow p.284 · Mohl p.327 · Khaleghi p.384 · Ganjoor passage
All four have Faramarz kill the dismounted Mehr-e-Nush and turn the battlefield’s earth ruby-red. English preserves both the tactical vulnerability and the precious-color image. Bahman then sees the corpse against flower-red ground and brings the news to the place where the principal combat still burns. The repeated color imagery makes the report arise from a witnessed scene rather than rumor. Naming both sons gathers separate combats into one paternal loss. The final contrast between Esfandiyar fighting and his children lying under dust is not merely informational: it makes the continuation of his duel appear painfully disconnected from the destruction of his household.
43–48Grief becomes an accusation grounded in the covenant
Moscow: VI284:1096 running text | VI284:1097 running text | VI285:1098 running text | VI285:1099 running text | VI285:1100 running text | VI285:1101 running text; Mohl: IV327:3498 running text | IV327:3499 running text | IV327:3500 running text | IV327:3501 running text | IV327:3502 running text | IV327:3503 running text; Ganjoor: sh23:42, sh23:43, sh23:44, sh23:45, sh23:46, sh23:47; Khaleghi: V385:1105 running text | V385:1106 running text | V385:1107 running text | V385:1108 running text | V385:1109 running text | V385:1110 running text
Moscow p.284 · Moscow p.285 · Mohl p.327 · Khaleghi p.385 · Ganjoor passage
All four let Bahman predict lasting disgrace before showing Esfandiyar’s anger and tears together. English gives grief and rage separate bodily locations, retaining the Persian distribution across heart, brain and eyes. The father’s accusation then recalls the actual agreement: Rostam had promised not to bring troops into the fight. The appeal to shame before God and to final accounting turns the breach into more than a tactical disadvantage. Oath-breakers cannot win public praise. The passage therefore supplies grounds for Esfandiyar’s charge, even though it has not established that Rostam ordered Zavareh’s advance. English preserves that distinction by allowing the denial to follow rather than preempting the accusation.
49–54Rostam denies command and offers his own household in payment
Moscow: VI285:1102 running text | VI285:1103 running text | VI285:1104 running text | VI285:1115 running text | VI285:1116 running text | VI285:1117 running text; Mohl: IV328:3504 running text | IV328:3505 running text | IV328:3506 running text | IV328:3507 running text | IV328:3508 running text | IV328:3509 running text; Ganjoor: sh23:48, sh23:49, sh23:50, sh23:51, sh23:52, sh23:53; Khaleghi: V385:1111 running text | V385:1112 running text | V385:1113 running text | V385:1114 running text | V386:1115 running text | V386:1116 running text
Moscow p.285 · Mohl p.328 · Khaleghi p.385 · Khaleghi p.386 · Ganjoor passage
English follows Mohl’s negative wording in saying that the killers will not turn from folly; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi instead say they have turned back, leaving the precise accusation differently shaped. Rostam’s trembling branch image and oath then agree across the witnesses. He denies both ordering and approving the attack. His proposed remedy is concrete: the brother responsible and Faramarz will be brought with bound hands. English retains the conditional responsibility of the brother rather than declaring every participant equally guilty. The offer also exposes the cost of reconciliation, since Rostam proposes for his own kin the very bonds he has refused for himself.
55–60The proposed exchange is rejected through rank and animal imagery
Moscow: VI285:1118 running text | VI285:1119 running text | VI285:1120 running text | VI285:1121 running text | VI285:1122 running text | VI285:1123 running text; Mohl: IV328:3510 running text | IV328:3511 running text | IV328:3512 running text | IV328:3513 running text | IV328:3514 running text | IV328:3515 running text; Ganjoor: sh23:54, sh23:55, sh23:56, sh23:57, sh23:58, sh23:59; Khaleghi: V386:1117 running text | V386:1118 running text | V386:1119 running text | V386:1120 running text | V386:1121 running text | V386:1122 running text
Moscow p.285 · Mohl p.328 · Khaleghi p.386 · Ganjoor passage
All four offer the killers as payment for the sons, followed by Esfandiyar’s refusal to exchange peacocks for snakes. English preserves the animal hierarchy as his spoken judgment rather than endorsing it as an impartial valuation of lives. Royal custom is invoked to reject the substitution, and the threat returns directly to Rostam. The image of thighs and Rakhsh mingled by arrows like milk and water makes bodily destruction grotesquely inseparable from the beloved mount. The concluding servant/master distinction explains the political lesson the prince intends. His vengeance is directed not only toward a bereaved father’s satisfaction but toward the restoration of an asserted hierarchy.
61–64Capture and death become the two alternatives to further speech
Moscow: VI286:1124 running text | VI286 n3 actual apparatus addition after1124 | VI286:1125 running text | VI286:1126 running text; Mohl: IV328:3516 running text | IV328:3517 running text | IV328:3518 running text | IV328:3519 running text; Ganjoor: sh23:60, sh23:61, sh23:62; Khaleghi: V386:1123 running text | V386 n24 actual apparatus addition after1123 | V386:1124 running text | V386:1125 running text
Moscow p.286 · Mohl p.328 · Khaleghi p.386 · Ganjoor passage
All four threaten to bind Rostam if he survives and deliver him immediately to the Shah. English also includes the alternative that death by arrows will avenge both sons. That verse is running text in Mohl and actual apparatus in Moscow and Khaleghi, with a checked gap in Ganjoor. Rostam’s answer rejects continued speech as a loss of honor and turns toward God. English goodness follows Mohl’s affirmative term, whereas Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi name guidance in both good and bad. The closing appeal therefore preserves a religious turn while narrowing the other readings’ broader formulation of divine guidance at the moment when negotiation ends.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
64 English couplets; Moscow VI282–286:1055–1104 then printed1115–1126 (62 running couplets; a ten-number jump); Mohl IV326–328:3456–3519; Ganjoor sh23:1–62; Khaleghi V381–386:1063–1125. Army intervention through Rostam’s appeal to God. Next archery begins Moscow1127/Mohl3520/Khaleghi1126.
Moscow evidence
All62 running couplets inspected. Printed numbering jumps from1104 to1115 on285; locators preserve that numbering. English35 absent in checked1088–1089;284n7 prints an alternate sequence, not the same intended-blow verse. Actual286n3 supplies English62. No appendix evidence used.
Mohl evidence
All64 running3456–3519 inspected. Main3490 supplies the intended sword blow and3517 the death alternative. Main3504 negative refusal to turn and3519 goodness support English against other main readings. Consulted reprint imprint remains unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
All62 reference units allocated. Local gaps34–35 and60–61 recorded separately. Main10 doing evil,48 turned back and62 good/bad differ from English choices.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
Running1063–1125 inspected. Main1097 intended blow is running evidence;386n24 death alternative is actual apparatus. Main1072 nurture differs from Mohl’s slaying. No exhaustive apparatus or appendix agreement claimed.
Interpretive limits
The narrative places Zavareh’s attack before the princes’ intervention, but does not show Rostam ordering it. The peacock/snake valuation and servant/master hierarchy are the prince’s claims. English49 negative versus other main turned-back wording remains a local qualification.
Moscow printed p.282 · Moscow printed p.283 · Moscow printed p.284 · Moscow printed p.285 · Moscow printed p.286
Mohl printed p.326 · Mohl printed p.327 · Mohl printed p.328
Khaleghi printed p.381 · Khaleghi printed p.382 · Khaleghi printed p.383 · Khaleghi printed p.384 · Khaleghi printed p.385 · Khaleghi printed p.386
C8.22 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI282:1055 running text | IV326:3456 running text |
| 2 | VI282:1056 running text | IV326:3457 running text |
| 3 | VI282:1057 running text | IV326:3458 running text |
| 4 | VI282:1058 running text | IV326:3459 running text |
| 5 | VI282:1059 running text | IV326:3460 running text |
| 6 | VI282:1060 running text | IV326:3461 running text |
| 7 | VI282:1061 running text | IV326:3462 running text |
| 8 | VI282:1062 running text | IV326:3463 running text |
| 9 | VI282:1063 running text | IV326:3464 running text |
| 10 | VI282:1064 running text | IV326:3465 running text |
| 11 | VI282:1065 running text | IV326:3466 running text |
| 12 | VI282:1066 running text | IV326:3467 running text |
| 13 | VI282:1067 running text | IV326:3468 running text |
| 14 | VI282:1068 running text | IV326:3469 running text |
| 15 | VI282:1069 running text | IV326:3470 running text |
| 16 | VI283:1070 running text | IV326:3471 running text |
| 17 | VI283:1071 running text | IV326:3472 running text |
| 18 | VI283:1072 running text | IV326:3473 running text |
| 19 | VI283:1073 running text | IV326:3474 running text |
| 20 | VI283:1074 running text | IV326:3475 running text |
| 21 | VI283:1075 running text | IV326:3476 running text |
| 22 | VI283:1076 running text | IV326:3477 running text |
| 23 | VI283:1077 running text | IV326:3478 running text |
| 24 | VI283:1078 running text | IV327:3479 running text |
| 25 | VI283:1079 running text | IV327:3480 running text |
| 26 | VI283:1080 running text | IV327:3481 running text |
| 27 | VI283:1081 running text | IV327:3482 running text |
| 28 | VI283:1082 running text | IV327:3483 running text |
| 29 | VI284:1083 running text | IV327:3484 running text |
| 30 | VI284:1084 running text | IV327:3485 running text |
| 31 | VI284:1085 running text | IV327:3486 running text |
| 32 | VI284:1086 running text | IV327:3487 running text |
| 33 | VI284:1087 running text | IV327:3488 running text |
| 34 | VI284:1088 running text | IV327:3489 running text |
| 35 | VI284 checked local gap1088–1089; n7 alternate sequence inspected, not this verse | IV327:3490 running text |
| 36 | VI284:1089 running text | IV327:3491 running text |
| 37 | VI284:1090 running text | IV327:3492 running text |
| 38 | VI284:1091 running text | IV327:3493 running text |
| 39 | VI284:1092 running text | IV327:3494 running text |
| 40 | VI284:1093 running text | IV327:3495 running text |
| 41 | VI284:1094 running text | IV327:3496 running text |
| 42 | VI284:1095 running text | IV327:3497 running text |
| 43 | VI284:1096 running text | IV327:3498 running text |
| 44 | VI284:1097 running text | IV327:3499 running text |
| 45 | VI285:1098 running text | IV327:3500 running text |
| 46 | VI285:1099 running text | IV327:3501 running text |
| 47 | VI285:1100 running text | IV327:3502 running text |
| 48 | VI285:1101 running text | IV327:3503 running text |
| 49 | VI285:1102 running text | IV328:3504 running text |
| 50 | VI285:1103 running text | IV328:3505 running text |
| 51 | VI285:1104 running text | IV328:3506 running text |
| 52 | VI285:1115 running text | IV328:3507 running text |
| 53 | VI285:1116 running text | IV328:3508 running text |
| 54 | VI285:1117 running text | IV328:3509 running text |
| 55 | VI285:1118 running text | IV328:3510 running text |
| 56 | VI285:1119 running text | IV328:3511 running text |
| 57 | VI285:1120 running text | IV328:3512 running text |
| 58 | VI285:1121 running text | IV328:3513 running text |
| 59 | VI285:1122 running text | IV328:3514 running text |
| 60 | VI285:1123 running text | IV328:3515 running text |
| 61 | VI286:1124 running text | IV328:3516 running text |
| 62 | VI286 n3 actual apparatus addition after1124 | IV328:3517 running text |
| 63 | VI286:1125 running text | IV328:3518 running text |
| 64 | VI286:1126 running text | IV328:3519 running text |
New Naqqali