The Simorgh Comes to Rostam’s Aid
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6A summons made visible
Moscow: VI294:1237 running text | VI294:1238 running text | VI294:1239 running text | VI294:1240 running text | VI294:1241 running text | VI294:1242 running text; Mohl: IV333:3637 running text | IV333:3638 running text | IV333:3639 running text | IV333:3640 running text | IV333:3641 running text | IV333:3642 running text; Ganjoor: sh26:1, sh26:2, sh26:3, sh26:4, sh26:5, sh26:6; Khaleghi: V397:1237 running text | V397:1238 running text | V397:1239 running text | V397:1240 running text | V398:1241 running text | V398:1242 running text
Moscow p.294 · Mohl p.333 · Khaleghi p.397 · Khaleghi p.398 · Ganjoor passage
The feather is a physical means of recalling an earlier promise, not an unexplained arrival of help. All four describe its preservation in brocade, the censers, the partial burning and the fire seen from above. English specifies three people agreeing, following Mohl where Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi say both. The distinction affects the immediate household grouping rather than the mechanics of the summons. The night becoming like a black cloud makes the small signal visible against a dark setting. By retaining the staged preparation, English gives Zal an active role in obtaining assistance and keeps the marvelous event connected to an object he has deliberately safeguarded.
7–12Grief becomes a statement of need
Moscow: VI294:1243 running text | VI294:1244 running text | VI294:1245 running text | VI295:1246 running text | VI295:1247 running text | VI295:1248 running text; Mohl: IV333:3643 running text | IV333:3644 running text | IV334:3645 running text | IV334:3646 running text | IV334:3647 running text | IV334:3648 running text; Ganjoor: sh26:7, sh26:8, sh26:9, sh26:10, sh26:11, sh26:12; Khaleghi: V398:1243 running text | V398:1244 running text | V398:1245 running text | V398:1246 running text | V398:1247 running text | V398:1248 running text
Moscow p.294 · Moscow p.295 · Mohl p.333 · Mohl p.334 · Khaleghi p.398 · Ganjoor passage
All four bring the bird down to the grieving Zal and retain aloes, praise and the censers before the question about his need. These gestures distinguish reverence from the later charge that Zal merely practices hostile sorcery. English makes the tears flowing like blood part of the same appeal. Zal’s answer wishes such misfortune away from any enemy before naming Rostam’s wounded body. This is an account delivered by a distressed father, and its force lies in the movement from ritual greeting to immediate injury. English preserves that movement, allowing the Simorgh’s question to organize the explanation rather than interrupting the narrative with a detached description of the wounds.
13–18The threatened body and the threatened family
Moscow: VI295:1249 running text | VI295:1250 running text | VI295:1251 running text | VI295:1252 running text | VI295:1253 running text | VI295:1254 running text; Mohl: IV334:3649 running text | IV334:3650 running text | IV334:3651 running text | IV334:3652 running text | IV334:3653 running text | IV334:3654 running text; Ganjoor: sh26:13, sh26:14, sh26:15, sh26:16, sh26:17, sh26:18; Khaleghi: V398:1249 running text | V398:1250 running text | V398:1251 running text | V398:1252 running text | V399:1253 running text | V399:1254 running text
Moscow p.295 · Mohl p.334 · Khaleghi p.398 · Khaleghi p.399 · Ganjoor passage
The four passages extend the danger from Rostam’s damaged body to Rakhsh and then to the family’s root and fruit. English keeps the arboreal image of destruction, making Esfandiyar’s campaign a threat to continuity as well as an individual life. The Simorgh responds with comfort and a request to see both the warrior and his horse. The response therefore promises examination before a cure is described. English’s paired presentation matters because the battle has injured a working partnership: healing the rider without restoring his mount would leave the escape incomplete. The subsequent summons answers this practical requirement and gives the change from lament to action a clear sequence.
19–24Recognition before treatment
Moscow: VI295:1255 running text | VI295:1256 running text | VI295:1257 running text | VI295:1258 running text | VI295:1259 running text | VI295:1260 running text; Mohl: IV334:3655 running text | IV334:3656 running text | IV334:3657 running text | IV334:3658 running text | IV334:3659 running text | IV334:3660 running text; Ganjoor: sh26:19, sh26:20, sh26:21, sh26:22, sh26:23, sh26:24; Khaleghi: V399:1255 running text | V399:1256 running text | V399:1257 running text | V399:1258 running text | V399:1259 running text | V399:1260 running text
Moscow p.295 · Mohl p.334 · Khaleghi p.399 · Ganjoor passage
All four have Zal summon Rostam, bring Rakhsh and expose the wounded champion to the bird’s questioning gaze. The question about who struck him is followed by a reproach for seeking combat with Esfandiyar, imagined as putting oneself into fire. English retains the confrontation inside the rescue: supernatural assistance does not amount to unqualified approval of Rostam’s choices. Zal’s appeal to the holy face answers that reproach by returning attention to the endangered household. The sequence preserves distinct speakers and motives. Rostam is the object of examination, the Simorgh judges the danger, and Zal seeks a refuge that the ordinary remedies assembled at home have failed to provide.
25–30A specific healing, with a different account of Sistan
Moscow: VI295:1261 running text | VI296:1262 running text | VI296:1263 running text | VI296:1264 running text | VI296:1265 running text | VI296:1266 running text; Mohl: IV334:3661 running text | IV334:3662 running text | IV334:3663 running text | IV334:3664 running text | IV334:3665 running text | IV334:3666 running text; Ganjoor: sh26:25, sh26:26, sh26:27, sh26:28, sh26:29, sh26:30; Khaleghi: V399:1261 running text | V399:1262 running text | V400:1263 running text | V400:1264 running text | V400:1265 running text | V400:1266 running text
Moscow p.295 · Moscow p.296 · Mohl p.334 · Khaleghi p.399 · Khaleghi p.400 · Ganjoor passage
English’s description of Sistan as the lair of lions and leopards follows Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; Khaleghi instead makes the destruction of Sistan satisfy the Iranian warriors’ desire. The first presents the region through heroic animal imagery, the second through the enemies who threaten it. The root image then returns before the bird examines the injuries. All four explicitly give four arrows removed from Rostam and follow extraction with the beak drawing blood and the feather restoring the wounds. English preserves those concrete operations. The cure is marvelous in agency but carefully narrated as a sequence, so restoration does not erase the physical severity of the preceding combat.
31–36Recovery has time, materials and a second patient
Moscow: VI296:1267 running text | VI296:1268 running text | VI296:1269 running text | VI296:1270 running text | VI296:1271 running text | VI296:1272 running text; Mohl: IV334:3667 running text | IV334:3668 running text | IV334:3669 running text | IV335:3670 running text | IV335:3671 running text | IV335:3672 running text; Ganjoor: sh26:31, sh26:32, sh26:33, sh26:34, sh26:35, sh26:36; Khaleghi: V400:1267 running text | V400:1268 running text | V400:1269 running text | V400:1270 running text | V400:1271 running text | V400:1272 running text
Moscow p.296 · Mohl p.334 · Mohl p.335 · Khaleghi p.400 · Ganjoor passage
English’s instruction to rest for one week follows Mohl’s definite duration. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi say an indefinite while, so the English creates a firmer interval than those main texts warrant. All four retain a feather moistened with milk and then turn to Rakhsh, with six arrows removed from his neck. His recovered voice and the hero’s delighted response make the horse an active sign of restored strength. At the renewed address English follows the elephant epithet of Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor, while Khaleghi has a high mountain. Both images magnify the hero, but the animal comparison also recalls the living force that has just returned to rider and mount.
37–42Submission and the prince’s exceptional status
Moscow: VI296:1273 running text | VI296:1274 running text | VI297:1275 running text | VI297:1276 running text | VI297 n7 actual addition after1276 | VI297:1280 running text; Mohl: IV335:3673 running text | IV335:3674 running text | IV335:3675 running text | IV335:3676 running text | IV335:3677 running text | IV335:3678 running text; Ganjoor: sh26:37, sh26:38, sh26:39, sh26:40, sh26:44; Khaleghi: V401:1273 running text | V401:1274 running text | V401:1275 running text | V401:1276 running text | V401 n15 actual addition after1276 | V401:1280 running text
Moscow p.296 · Moscow p.297 · Mohl p.335 · Khaleghi p.401 · Ganjoor passage
Rostam explains that bonds are harder to accept than death, while the Simorgh argues that lowering his head to Esfandiyar need not be shameful. English’s additional appeal to divine farr is Mohl running text and is physically printed in the apparatus of Moscow and Khaleghi; Ganjoor has a checked local gap. It must not be confused with agreement of all four main texts. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi instead also retain three units about the prince’s uniqueness, avoiding him, and his killing of the bird’s mate. English and Mohl lack those units here. The omission removes a personal injury from the Simorgh’s explanation and leaves royal status more prominent in the advice.
43–48The remedy remains conditional on failed persuasion
Moscow: VI297:1281 running text | VI297 n17 actual addition after1281 | VI297:1282 running text | VI297:1283 running text | VI297:1284 running text | VI297:1285 running text; Mohl: IV335:3679 running text | IV335:3680 running text | IV335:3681 running text | IV335:3682 running text | IV335:3683 running text | IV335:3684 running text; Ganjoor: sh26:45, sh26:46, sh26:47, sh26:48, sh26:49; Khaleghi: V401:1281 running text | V402:1282 running text | V402:1283 running text | V402:1284 running text | V402:1285 running text | V402:1286 running text
Moscow p.297 · Mohl p.335 · Khaleghi p.401 · Khaleghi p.402 · Ganjoor passage
English keeps the prohibition on seeking superiority and follows Mohl and Khaleghi in the explicit instruction to offer body and life in tomorrow’s plea; Moscow prints that instruction in its apparatus, while Ganjoor has a local gap. All four then make the alternative remedy depend on Esfandiyar’s appointed end and his refusal of persuasion. Rostam’s joy centers on release from the thought of bonds, and his promise of obedience answers the condition. This is not yet an instruction to attack immediately. The sequence reserves a space for supplication before the fatal method becomes available, which makes the next encounter’s renewed pleading integral to the plan rather than an inconsistency.
49–54Aid carries a prophecy of lasting cost
Moscow: VI297:1286 running text | VI297:1287 running text | VI297:1288 running text | VI298:1289 running text | VI298 n3 actual addition after1289 | VI298:1290 running text; Mohl: IV335:3685 running text | IV335:3686 running text | IV335:3687 running text | IV335:3688 running text | IV335:3689 running text | IV335:3690 running text; Ganjoor: sh26:50, sh26:51, sh26:52, sh26:53, sh26:54; Khaleghi: V402:1287 running text | V402:1288 running text | V402:1289 running text | V402:1290 running text | V402:1291 running text | V402:1292 running text
Moscow p.297 · Moscow p.298 · Mohl p.335 · Khaleghi p.402 · Ganjoor passage
All four say that whoever spills Esfandiyar’s blood will suffer an adverse fate, continuing pain and loss of wealth, with hardship beyond death. English preserves the warning before the promised wonder. The explicit consent condition follows Mohl and Khaleghi running text and actual Moscow apparatus; Ganjoor has no separate corresponding unit at this point. The promise to stop evil speech therefore follows disclosure of consequences, not an assurance of uncomplicated victory. English’s ordering makes Rostam’s acceptance consequential: he receives a means of survival while learning that its use may damage the remainder of his life. The healing and the weapon cannot be read as a cancellation of the tragedy’s costs.
55–60A journey with a shortened meditation
Moscow: VI298:1291 running text | VI298:1292 running text | VI298:1298 running text | VI298:1299 running text | VI298:1302 running text | VI298:1300 running text; Mohl: IV335:3691 running text | IV335:3692 running text | IV335:3693 running text | IV335:3694 running text | IV336:3695 running text | IV336:3696 running text; Ganjoor: sh26:55, sh26:56, sh26:62, sh26:63, sh26:66, sh26:64; Khaleghi: V402:1293 running text | V403:1294 running text | V403:1295 running text | V403:1296 running text | V403:1299 running text | V403:1297 running text
Moscow p.298 · Mohl p.335 · Mohl p.336 · Khaleghi p.402 · Khaleghi p.403 · Ganjoor passage
The dagger and Rakhsh prepare the journey to the sea in all four presentations. Moscow and Ganjoor insert a five-unit speech about mortality, reputation and the departed kings Fereydoon and Hushang; Khaleghi prints that speech in actual apparatus, while Mohl and English pass directly from preparation to the journey. English thus keeps the action moving instead of restating the calculation of death and fame. Its placement of the tamarisk before the dry path follows Mohl’s order. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi place the path and the feather’s touch before the tree. The different sequence changes the order of discovery but retains the bird as the necessary guide.
61–66The weapon must be made
Moscow: VI298:1301 running text | VI298:1303 running text | VI298:1304 running text | VI298:1305 running text | VI298:1306 running text | VI298:1307 running text; Mohl: IV336:3697 running text | IV336:3698 running text | IV336:3699 running text | IV336:3700 running text | IV336:3701 running text | IV336:3702 running text; Ganjoor: sh26:65, sh26:67, sh26:68, sh26:69, sh26:70, sh26:71; Khaleghi: V403:1298 running text | V403:1300 running text | V403:1301 running text | V403:1302 running text | V403:1303 running text | V404:1304 running text
Moscow p.298 · Mohl p.336 · Khaleghi p.403 · Khaleghi p.404 · Ganjoor passage
All four direct attention to a particular branch, describe the prince’s doom in that wood, and give instructions for straightening, pointing and feathering it. English retains the practical work rather than treating the tamarisk as a weapon already prepared. The branch’s thin base and thicker upper growth make selection part of the bird’s specialized knowledge. Cutting it and returning from the sea complete the first stage; its final preparation will occur in the following chapter. English’s movement through these operations links the impending fatal shot to deliberate craftsmanship. The marvelous guidance identifies the material and its use, while Rostam must still carry out the physical acts that turn a branch into an arrow.
67–72The last appeal precedes the shot
Moscow: VI299:1308 running text | VI299:1309 running text | VI299:1310 running text | VI299:1311 running text | VI299:1312 running text | VI299:1313 running text | VI299:1314 running text; Mohl: IV336:3703 running text | IV336:3704 running text | IV336:3705 running text | IV336:3706 running text | IV336:3707 running text | IV336:3708 running text | IV336:3709 running text; Ganjoor: sh26:72, sh26:73, sh26:74, sh26:75, sh26:76, sh26:77, sh26:78; Khaleghi: V404:1305 running text | V404:1306 running text | V404:1307 running text | V404:1308 running text | V404:1309 running text | V404:1310 running text | V404:1311 running text
Moscow p.299 · Mohl p.336 · Khaleghi p.404 · Ganjoor passage
All four keep the Simorgh as guide on the return and renew the instruction to address Esfandiyar when he comes seeking battle. English compresses the approaching prince and the initial request into one couplet, then retains sweet speech, remembrance of past service and the condition that he refuse excuses. Only then does the instruction reach the bow and wine-treated wood. This ordering matters because the proposed weapon is not presented as the first resort of the restored warrior. The account makes persuasion a required stage of the same plan. English’s compression reduces the number of lines without removing that ethical and narrative sequence, which the next chapter will enact at length.
73–74Aim, fate and an uncertain epithet
Moscow: VI299:1315 running text | VI299:1316 running text; Mohl: IV336:3710 running text | IV336:3711 running text; Ganjoor: sh26:79, sh26:80; Khaleghi: V404:1312 running text | V405:1313 running text
Moscow p.299 · Mohl p.336 · Khaleghi p.404 · Khaleghi p.405 · Ganjoor passage
The direction toward the eyes is shared, as is the difficult gaz-parast expression. Its presence supports the English wording but does not by itself establish a precise historical cult or an explanation of the prince’s vulnerability. That semantic question remains open here. The closing agency differs: Moscow and Ganjoor make fate carry the arrow to the eyes while the heart is full of anger; Mohl and Khaleghi invoke evil fortune if the prince does not heed counsel. English follows the latter conditional force. It therefore links the fatal outcome to refusal of the warning, while still placing the decisive event under fortune rather than attributing success solely to archery.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
74 English couplets; Moscow VI294–299:1237–1316; Mohl IV333–336:3637–3711; Ganjoor sh26:1–80; Khaleghi V397–405:1237–1313. Simorgh summons through instruction to aim at the eyes. Ganjoor81–84 belong to C8.26.
Moscow evidence
All80 running units inspected. Actual297n7 divine farr,297n17 tomorrow’s plea,298n3 consent conditional checked individually. Main1277–1279 and1293–1297 are source-only against English. Closing1316 differs from Mohl/Khaleghi.
Mohl evidence
All75 running units3637–3711 inspected. Definite week3667; divine farr3677; plea3680; consent3689. Checked gaps3677–3678 for other sources’ three-unit speech and3692–3693 for mortality speech. Tree3695 precedes path3696. Reprint imprint unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
All80 declared units uniquely allocated, including source-only41–43 and57–61. Additional printed-site units81–84 excluded here and carried to C8.26. Local gaps individually labeled for fuller English/Mohl passages.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
All77 running1237–1313 inspected. Divine farr actual401n15; plea1282 and consent1291 running. Five-unit mortality speech actual403n1, not running. No appendix claim; no exhaustive apparatus agreement.
Interpretive limits
Gaz-parast is retained without a speculative cult explanation. One week is Mohl-specific; source-only mate and mortality speeches materially distinguish the presentations.
Moscow printed p.294 · Moscow printed p.295 · Moscow printed p.296 · Moscow printed p.297 · Moscow printed p.298 · Moscow printed p.299
Mohl printed p.333 · Mohl printed p.334 · Mohl printed p.335 · Mohl printed p.336
Khaleghi printed p.397 · Khaleghi printed p.398 · Khaleghi printed p.399 · Khaleghi printed p.400 · Khaleghi printed p.401 · Khaleghi printed p.402 · Khaleghi printed p.403 · Khaleghi printed p.404 · Khaleghi printed p.405
C8.25 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI294:1237 running text | IV333:3637 running text |
| 2 | VI294:1238 running text | IV333:3638 running text |
| 3 | VI294:1239 running text | IV333:3639 running text |
| 4 | VI294:1240 running text | IV333:3640 running text |
| 5 | VI294:1241 running text | IV333:3641 running text |
| 6 | VI294:1242 running text | IV333:3642 running text |
| 7 | VI294:1243 running text | IV333:3643 running text |
| 8 | VI294:1244 running text | IV333:3644 running text |
| 9 | VI294:1245 running text | IV334:3645 running text |
| 10 | VI295:1246 running text | IV334:3646 running text |
| 11 | VI295:1247 running text | IV334:3647 running text |
| 12 | VI295:1248 running text | IV334:3648 running text |
| 13 | VI295:1249 running text | IV334:3649 running text |
| 14 | VI295:1250 running text | IV334:3650 running text |
| 15 | VI295:1251 running text | IV334:3651 running text |
| 16 | VI295:1252 running text | IV334:3652 running text |
| 17 | VI295:1253 running text | IV334:3653 running text |
| 18 | VI295:1254 running text | IV334:3654 running text |
| 19 | VI295:1255 running text | IV334:3655 running text |
| 20 | VI295:1256 running text | IV334:3656 running text |
| 21 | VI295:1257 running text | IV334:3657 running text |
| 22 | VI295:1258 running text | IV334:3658 running text |
| 23 | VI295:1259 running text | IV334:3659 running text |
| 24 | VI295:1260 running text | IV334:3660 running text |
| 25 | VI295:1261 running text | IV334:3661 running text |
| 26 | VI296:1262 running text | IV334:3662 running text |
| 27 | VI296:1263 running text | IV334:3663 running text |
| 28 | VI296:1264 running text | IV334:3664 running text |
| 29 | VI296:1265 running text | IV334:3665 running text |
| 30 | VI296:1266 running text | IV334:3666 running text |
| 31 | VI296:1267 running text | IV334:3667 running text |
| 32 | VI296:1268 running text | IV334:3668 running text |
| 33 | VI296:1269 running text | IV334:3669 running text |
| 34 | VI296:1270 running text | IV335:3670 running text |
| 35 | VI296:1271 running text | IV335:3671 running text |
| 36 | VI296:1272 running text | IV335:3672 running text |
| 37 | VI296:1273 running text | IV335:3673 running text |
| 38 | VI296:1274 running text | IV335:3674 running text |
| 39 | VI297:1275 running text | IV335:3675 running text |
| 40 | VI297:1276 running text | IV335:3676 running text |
| 41 | VI297 n7 actual addition after1276 | IV335:3677 running text |
| 42 | VI297:1280 running text | IV335:3678 running text |
| 43 | VI297:1281 running text | IV335:3679 running text |
| 44 | VI297 n17 actual addition after1281 | IV335:3680 running text |
| 45 | VI297:1282 running text | IV335:3681 running text |
| 46 | VI297:1283 running text | IV335:3682 running text |
| 47 | VI297:1284 running text | IV335:3683 running text |
| 48 | VI297:1285 running text | IV335:3684 running text |
| 49 | VI297:1286 running text | IV335:3685 running text |
| 50 | VI297:1287 running text | IV335:3686 running text |
| 51 | VI297:1288 running text | IV335:3687 running text |
| 52 | VI298:1289 running text | IV335:3688 running text |
| 53 | VI298 n3 actual addition after1289 | IV335:3689 running text |
| 54 | VI298:1290 running text | IV335:3690 running text |
| 55 | VI298:1291 running text | IV335:3691 running text |
| 56 | VI298:1292 running text | IV335:3692 running text |
| 57 | VI298:1298 running text | IV335:3693 running text |
| 58 | VI298:1299 running text | IV335:3694 running text |
| 59 | VI298:1302 running text | IV336:3695 running text |
| 60 | VI298:1300 running text | IV336:3696 running text |
| 61 | VI298:1301 running text | IV336:3697 running text |
| 62 | VI298:1303 running text | IV336:3698 running text |
| 63 | VI298:1304 running text | IV336:3699 running text |
| 64 | VI298:1305 running text | IV336:3700 running text |
| 65 | VI298:1306 running text | IV336:3701 running text |
| 66 | VI298:1307 running text | IV336:3702 running text |
| 67 | VI299:1308 running text | IV336:3703 running text |
| 68 | VI299:1309 running text | VI299:1310 running text | IV336:3704 running text | IV336:3705 running text |
| 69 | VI299:1311 running text | IV336:3706 running text |
| 70 | VI299:1312 running text | IV336:3707 running text |
| 71 | VI299:1313 running text | IV336:3708 running text |
| 72 | VI299:1314 running text | IV336:3709 running text |
| 73 | VI299:1315 running text | IV336:3710 running text |
| 74 | VI299:1316 running text | IV336:3711 running text |
New Naqqali