Rostam Shoots Esfandiyar in the Eyes
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Prayer admits the gravity of the act
Moscow: VI304:1375 running text | VI304:1376 running text | VI304:1377 running text | VI304:1378 running text | VI304:1379 running text | VI304:1380 running text; Mohl: IV339:3772 running text | IV339:3773 running text | IV339:3774 running text | IV339:3775 running text | IV339:3776 running text | IV339:3777 running text; Ganjoor: sh28:1, sh28:2, sh28:3, sh28:4, sh28:5, sh28:6; Khaleghi: V411:1370 running text | V411:1371 running text | V411:1372 running text | V411:1373 running text | V411:1374 running text | V411:1375 running text
Moscow p.304 · Mohl p.339 · Khaleghi p.411 · Ganjoor passage
All four begin with the failure of entreaty and the prepared tamarisk, then turn to the Creator. English’s secret prayer follows Mohl, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi show Rostam turning his head toward heaven. The difference changes the visible gesture without changing the addressee. The invocation names wisdom, glory and strength before asking the divine witness to see the speaker’s life and spirit. English retains the claim that he has tried to turn Esfandiyar from the quarrel. These are Rostam’s grounds for his action, offered in prayer; they should not be converted into an independent declaration that the narrator has already absolved him of the impending death.
7–12A disputed last exchange of arrows
Moscow: VI304:1381 running text | VI304:1382 running text | VI304:1383 running text | VI304:1384 running text | VI304:1385 running text | VI304:1387 running text; Mohl: IV339:3778 running text | IV339:3779 running text | IV339:3780 running text | IV339:3781 running text | IV339:3782 running text | IV339:3783 running text; Ganjoor: sh28:7, sh28:8, sh28:9, sh28:10, sh28:11, sh28:13; Khaleghi: V411:1376 running text | V411:1377 running text | V411:1378 running text | V412:1379 running text | V412:1380 running text | V412:1381 running text
Moscow p.304 · Mohl p.339 · Khaleghi p.411 · Khaleghi p.412 · Ganjoor passage
All four retain the accusation of injustice and the request not to be punished for this transgression. Calling it a transgression preserves moral anxiety even while Rostam argues necessity. The prince then taunts his delay and invokes the arrows of Goshtasb and Lohrasp. Moscow and Ganjoor follow this with an actual shot at Rostam’s helmet; Khaleghi prints that shot in apparatus, while Mohl and English omit it. English consequently passes from the taunt directly to Rostam fitting the fatal shaft. That difference affects the immediate exchange of force. The broader history of attack remains, but the English shot is not explicitly a response to one more arrow fired at this instant.
13–18The loss of sight becomes a collapse of royal presence
Moscow: VI304:1388 running text | VI304:1389 running text | VI304:1390 running text | VI304:1391 running text | VI305:1392 running text | VI305:1393 running text; Mohl: IV339:3784 running text | IV339:3785 running text | IV339:3786 running text | IV339:3787 running text | IV339:3788 running text | IV340:3789 running text; Ganjoor: sh28:14, sh28:15, sh28:16, sh28:17, sh28:18, sh28:19; Khaleghi: V412:1382 running text | V412:1383 running text | V412:1384 running text | V412:1385 running text | V412:1386 running text | V412:1387 running text
Moscow p.304 · Moscow p.305 · Mohl p.339 · Mohl p.340 · Khaleghi p.412 · Ganjoor passage
All four make the struck eye darken the world before the prince, bend his cypress stature and remove wisdom and glory. English preserves this sequence rather than reducing the injury to a physical wound. The fallen bow and grip on the black horse show the body losing its martial command while remaining briefly mounted. The ruby-red dust then changes the battlefield’s visual field. Rostam’s following rebuke interprets the event as the fruit of stubborn pride and recalls the boast of a brazen body. English keeps the rebuke as his speech. Its harshness belongs to the immediate aftermath and will later give way to grief and acknowledgment of the opponent’s unmatched prowess.
19–24Boasting gives way to bodily collapse
Moscow: VI305:1395 running text | VI305:1396 running text | VI305:1397 running text | VI305:1398 running text | VI305:1399 running text | VI305:1400 running text; Mohl: IV340:3790 running text | IV340:3791 running text | IV340:3792 running text | IV340:3793 running text | IV340:3794 running text | IV340:3795 running text; Ganjoor: sh28:21, sh28:22, sh28:23, sh28:24, sh28:25, sh28:26; Khaleghi: V413:1389 running text | V413:1390 running text | V413:1391 running text | V413:1392 running text | V413:1393 running text | V413:1394 running text
Moscow p.305 · Mohl p.340 · Khaleghi p.413 · Ganjoor passage
English follows Mohl in omitting Rostam’s intervening comparison with the arrows he himself endured. Moscow and Ganjoor give eight in that source-only verse; Khaleghi gives a much larger total. The English therefore reaches the single decisive arrow and the mother’s future grief with less extended self-comparison. All four then show the prince falling, recovering consciousness and drawing out the bloodied shaft. English’s listening despite lost sight clarifies the remaining capacity for speech without suggesting recovery from the injury. News reaches Bahman as the darkening of royal farr. The narrative moves from Rostam’s interpretation of victory to the household’s recognition that something more than a duel has been lost.
25–30The news becomes a shared bodily grief
Moscow: VI305:1401 running text | VI305:1402 running text | VI305:1403 running text | VI305:1404 running text | VI305:1405 running text | VI306:1406 running text; Mohl: IV340:3796 running text | IV340:3797 running text | IV340:3798 running text | IV340:3799 running text | IV340:3800 running text | IV340:3801 running text; Ganjoor: sh28:27, sh28:28, sh28:29, sh28:30, sh28:31, sh28:32; Khaleghi: V413:1395 running text | V413:1396 running text | V413:1397 running text | V413:1398 running text | V413:1399 running text | V414:1400 running text
Moscow p.305 · Moscow p.306 · Mohl p.340 · Khaleghi p.413 · Khaleghi p.414 · Ganjoor passage
All four have Bahman tell Bishutan and bring both on foot to the fallen champion. English’s darkened world follows Mohl, while Moscow and Ganjoor describe hearts torn by pain and Khaleghi makes the world dreadful through the event. The elephant image remains a scale for the magnitude of the fall. At the body, the arrow is visible in the prince’s hand, connecting the reported calamity to its physical cause. Bishutan tears his robe and scatters dust; Bahman presses his face into warm blood. English preserves these different gestures, so collective grief is not merely announced. The relatives encounter the wound through touch, sight and acts of mourning.
31–36Bishutan asks why virtue does not secure survival
Moscow: VI306:1407 running text | VI306:1408 running text | VI306:1409 running text | VI306:1410 running text | VI306:1411 running text | VI306:1412 running text; Mohl: IV340:3802 running text | IV340:3803 running text | IV340:3804 running text | IV340:3805 running text | IV340:3806 running text | IV340:3807 running text; Ganjoor: sh28:33, sh28:34, sh28:35, sh28:36, sh28:37, sh28:38; Khaleghi: V414:1401 running text | V414:1402 running text | V414:1403 running text | V414 checked local gap1403–1404; no corresponding main unit | V414:1404 running text | V414:1405 running text
Moscow p.306 · Mohl p.340 · Khaleghi p.414 · Ganjoor passage
The four presentations place the question about the world’s secret in Bishutan’s mouth and recall Esfandiyar’s service to the faith and removal of idolatry. English preserves the contrast with the wicked person who lives long without battle’s harm. The explicit verse about destruction in youth is running text in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; Khaleghi has a checked local gap between the account of religious service and the wicked man. The contrast still exists there, but the English makes premature death especially direct. These claims remain part of a grieving brother’s argument. Their emotional force does not require treating his idealized portrait as an exhaustive judgment of every action the prince has taken.
37–42The lament enlarges the wounded figure
Moscow: VI306:1413 running text | VI306:1414 running text | VI306:1415 running text | VI306:1416 running text | VI306:1417 running text | VI306:1418 running text; Mohl: IV340:3808 running text | IV340:3809 running text | IV340:3810 running text | IV340:3811 running text | IV340:3812 running text | IV340:3813 running text; Ganjoor: sh28:39, sh28:40, sh28:41, sh28:42, sh28:43, sh28:44; Khaleghi: V414:1406 running text | V414:1407 running text | V414:1408 running text | V414:1409 running text | V414:1410 running text | V414:1411 running text
Moscow p.306 · Mohl p.340 · Khaleghi p.414 · Ganjoor passage
All four let the two young men cradle the prince and wipe away blood before Bishutan’s lament renews the imagery of mountain, lion, elephant and Nile. English retains the questions about who could overthrow such force. The sequence magnifies the loss through different forms of solidity and power rather than offering a literal inventory of injuries. Blood on the face and grief in the heart keep the lament attached to the body held before the speakers. The evil-eye question then seeks an explanation beyond ordinary combat. English presents it as a question within mourning, leaving its tension with the claim that evil should strike evildoers exposed rather than resolving it for the reader.
43–48The lament is shorter and the answer more cosmic
Moscow: VI306:1420 running text | VI306:1419 running text | VI306:1421 running text | VI306:1422 running text | VI307:1427 running text | VI307:1428 running text; Mohl: IV341:3814 running text | IV341:3815 running text | IV341:3816 running text | IV341:3817 running text | IV341:3818 running text | IV341:3819 running text; Ganjoor: sh28:46, sh28:45, sh28:47, sh28:48, sh28:53, sh28:54; Khaleghi: V415:1412 running text | V415:1413 bracketed running text | V415:1414 running text | V415:1415 running text | V415:1420 running text | V415:1421 running text
Moscow p.306 · Moscow p.307 · Mohl p.341 · Khaleghi p.415 · Ganjoor passage
English follows Mohl and Khaleghi in placing heart, wisdom and faith before the lost festive voice; Moscow and Ganjoor reverse those units. Khaleghi marks the festive-voice unit as bracketed running text. After the image of the fallen hero, Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi retain four more units cursing the throne, Goshtasb and Jamasp; Mohl and English pass directly to Esfandiyar’s answer. English also follows Mohl in assigning his share to moon and heavens, where the other main texts name crown and throne. Together these choices shorten the overt political accusation and give the prince’s immediate response a broader language of allotted fate.
49–54An account of life before the final reckoning
Moscow: VI307:1429 running text | VI307:1430 running text | VI307:1431 running text | VI307:1432 running text | VI307:1433 running text | VI307:1434 running text | VI307:1435 running text; Mohl: IV341:3820 running text | IV341:3821 running text | IV341:3822 running text | IV341:3823 running text | IV341:3824 running text | IV341:3825 running text | IV341:3826 running text; Ganjoor: sh28:55, sh28:56, sh28:57, sh28:58, sh28:59, sh28:60, sh28:61; Khaleghi: V415:1422 running text | V416:1423 running text | V416:1424 running text | V416:1425 running text | V416:1426 running text | V416:1427 running text | V416:1428 running text
Moscow p.307 · Mohl p.341 · Khaleghi p.415 · Khaleghi p.416 · Ganjoor passage
English’s living body follows Mohl and Khaleghi against the slain body in Moscow and Ganjoor. The general statement about dust as a bed thus reaches beyond the present wound. The departed kings and ancestors establish that no one remains, with two Persian ancestry units compressed into one English couplet. All four then let Esfandiyar review visible and hidden labors, the divine purpose he intended and the restraint of Ahriman. English retains this self-account as the dying prince’s speech. It gives him room to state what his career meant to him, while the surrounding dispute over compulsion and responsibility prevents that statement from settling every question raised by his death.
55–60The prince distinguishes the weapon from martial superiority
Moscow: VI307:1436 running text | VI307:1437 running text | VI307:1438 running text | VI307:1439 running text | VI308:1440 running text | VI308:1441 running text; Mohl: IV341:3827 running text | IV341:3828 running text | IV341:3829 running text | IV341:3830 running text | IV341:3831 running text | IV341:3832 running text; Ganjoor: sh28:62, sh28:63, sh28:64, sh28:65, sh28:66, sh28:67; Khaleghi: V416:1429 running text | V416:1430 running text | V416:1431 running text | V416:1432 running text | V417:1433 running text | V417:1434 running text
Moscow p.307 · Moscow p.308 · Mohl p.341 · Khaleghi p.416 · Khaleghi p.417 · Ganjoor passage
All four make Time’s claws close off escape and preserve the hope of reaping in Paradise what has been sown. Esfandiyar then denies that Rostam’s ordinary prowess killed him, points to the wood in his hand and names the Simorgh, Rostam’s resourcefulness and Zal’s spells. English keeps the distinction between defeat by strength and defeat through extraordinary means. This is the wounded prince’s explanation, not an additional narrator’s account of how the cure or weapon worked. Rostam’s tears immediately answer it. The movement from earlier taunt to grief allows the opponent’s claim to affect him without requiring either man to abandon the language through which he understands the battle.
61–66Recognition replaces the victor’s boast
Moscow: VI308:1442 running text | VI308:1443 running text | VI308:1444 running text | VI308:1445 running text | VI308:1447 running text | VI308:1446 running text; Mohl: IV341:3833 running text | IV341:3834 running text | IV341:3835 running text | IV341:3836 running text | IV341:3837 running text | IV341:3838 running text; Ganjoor: sh28:68, sh28:69, sh28:70, sh28:71, sh28:73, sh28:72; Khaleghi: V417:1435 running text | V417:1436 running text | V417:1437 running text | V417:1438 running text | V417:1440 running text | V417:1439 running text
Moscow p.308 · Mohl p.341 · Khaleghi p.417 · Ganjoor passage
English’s statement of his own suffering follows Mohl; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi address the other man’s share of suffering in the corresponding line. All four then have Rostam affirm the prince’s truthfulness and unmatched standing among the warriors he has faced. English retains both the praise and the confession of helplessness. It follows Mohl in placing the search for a remedy before the admission of being driven back by the prince’s bow and bodily strength, while the other main texts reverse those units. Either sequence denies a straightforward victory of superior force. The English confession gives the earlier accusation of extraordinary assistance a substantial acknowledgment from the man who used it.
67–70The bow holds fate and the story holds a name
Moscow: VI308:1448 running text | VI308:1449 running text | VI308:1450 running text | VI308:1451 running text; Mohl: IV342:3839 running text | IV342:3840 running text | IV342:3841 running text | IV342:3842 running text; Ganjoor: sh28:74, sh28:75, sh28:76, sh28:77; Khaleghi: V417:1441 running text | V417:1442 running text | V417:1443 running text | V418:1444 running text
Moscow p.308 · Mohl p.342 · Khaleghi p.417 · Khaleghi p.418 · Ganjoor passage
All four let Rostam describe placing the prince’s allotted time in the bow and ask whether tamarisk could have worked if further days remained. English preserves the attempt to explain human action through mortality without erasing the act of aiming and releasing. The shared statement that caution cannot win another breath then generalizes the limit. In the final line English’s darkened tale follows Mohl, Moscow and Ganjoor, while Khaleghi names the tamarisk arrow in the tale. The closing distinction between wood as pretext and Rostam as the remembered name keeps responsibility unsettled: fate may explain the event, but the human agent expects to remain attached to its telling.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
70 English couplets; Moscow VI304–308:1375–1451; Mohl IV339–342:3772–3842; Ganjoor sh28:1–77; Khaleghi V411–418:1370–1444, including bracketed1413. Fatal shot through Rostam’s final explanation. Next1452/3843/1445.
Moscow evidence
77 running units individually inspected. Source-only1386 final shot,1394 endured-arrow boast,1423–1426 extended lament. Order of1419–1420 and1446–1447 differs from English/Mohl.
Mohl evidence
71 running3772–3842 inspected. Checked gaps3782–3783,3789–3790,3817–3818 account for six source-only units elsewhere. English51 compresses3822–3823. Reprint imprint unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
All77 units uniquely allocated; source-only12,20,49–52. English43–44 and65–66 reverse pairs in this reference; English51 compresses57–58.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
75 numbered running1370–1444 inspected, including bracketed1413. Final helmet shot actual412n5; young-death verse checked local gap1403–1404. Extended lament1416–1419 running. No appendix claim or exhaustive apparatus agreement.
Interpretive limits
Prayers, accusations of magic, idealizing lament and explanations by fate remain attributed speech. English61 follows Mohl’s first-person suffering; final darkness differs from Khaleghi’s tamarisk wording.
Moscow printed p.304 · Moscow printed p.305 · Moscow printed p.306 · Moscow printed p.307 · Moscow printed p.308
Mohl printed p.339 · Mohl printed p.340 · Mohl printed p.341 · Mohl printed p.342
Khaleghi printed p.411 · Khaleghi printed p.412 · Khaleghi printed p.413 · Khaleghi printed p.414 · Khaleghi printed p.415 · Khaleghi printed p.416 · Khaleghi printed p.417 · Khaleghi printed p.418
C8.27 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI304:1375 running text | IV339:3772 running text |
| 2 | VI304:1376 running text | IV339:3773 running text |
| 3 | VI304:1377 running text | IV339:3774 running text |
| 4 | VI304:1378 running text | IV339:3775 running text |
| 5 | VI304:1379 running text | IV339:3776 running text |
| 6 | VI304:1380 running text | IV339:3777 running text |
| 7 | VI304:1381 running text | IV339:3778 running text |
| 8 | VI304:1382 running text | IV339:3779 running text |
| 9 | VI304:1383 running text | IV339:3780 running text |
| 10 | VI304:1384 running text | IV339:3781 running text |
| 11 | VI304:1385 running text | IV339:3782 running text |
| 12 | VI304:1387 running text | IV339:3783 running text |
| 13 | VI304:1388 running text | IV339:3784 running text |
| 14 | VI304:1389 running text | IV339:3785 running text |
| 15 | VI304:1390 running text | IV339:3786 running text |
| 16 | VI304:1391 running text | IV339:3787 running text |
| 17 | VI305:1392 running text | IV339:3788 running text |
| 18 | VI305:1393 running text | IV340:3789 running text |
| 19 | VI305:1395 running text | IV340:3790 running text |
| 20 | VI305:1396 running text | IV340:3791 running text |
| 21 | VI305:1397 running text | IV340:3792 running text |
| 22 | VI305:1398 running text | IV340:3793 running text |
| 23 | VI305:1399 running text | IV340:3794 running text |
| 24 | VI305:1400 running text | IV340:3795 running text |
| 25 | VI305:1401 running text | IV340:3796 running text |
| 26 | VI305:1402 running text | IV340:3797 running text |
| 27 | VI305:1403 running text | IV340:3798 running text |
| 28 | VI305:1404 running text | IV340:3799 running text |
| 29 | VI305:1405 running text | IV340:3800 running text |
| 30 | VI306:1406 running text | IV340:3801 running text |
| 31 | VI306:1407 running text | IV340:3802 running text |
| 32 | VI306:1408 running text | IV340:3803 running text |
| 33 | VI306:1409 running text | IV340:3804 running text |
| 34 | VI306:1410 running text | IV340:3805 running text |
| 35 | VI306:1411 running text | IV340:3806 running text |
| 36 | VI306:1412 running text | IV340:3807 running text |
| 37 | VI306:1413 running text | IV340:3808 running text |
| 38 | VI306:1414 running text | IV340:3809 running text |
| 39 | VI306:1415 running text | IV340:3810 running text |
| 40 | VI306:1416 running text | IV340:3811 running text |
| 41 | VI306:1417 running text | IV340:3812 running text |
| 42 | VI306:1418 running text | IV340:3813 running text |
| 43 | VI306:1420 running text | IV341:3814 running text |
| 44 | VI306:1419 running text | IV341:3815 running text |
| 45 | VI306:1421 running text | IV341:3816 running text |
| 46 | VI306:1422 running text | IV341:3817 running text |
| 47 | VI307:1427 running text | IV341:3818 running text |
| 48 | VI307:1428 running text | IV341:3819 running text |
| 49 | VI307:1429 running text | IV341:3820 running text |
| 50 | VI307:1430 running text | IV341:3821 running text |
| 51 | VI307:1431 running text | VI307:1432 running text | IV341:3822 running text | IV341:3823 running text |
| 52 | VI307:1433 running text | IV341:3824 running text |
| 53 | VI307:1434 running text | IV341:3825 running text |
| 54 | VI307:1435 running text | IV341:3826 running text |
| 55 | VI307:1436 running text | IV341:3827 running text |
| 56 | VI307:1437 running text | IV341:3828 running text |
| 57 | VI307:1438 running text | IV341:3829 running text |
| 58 | VI307:1439 running text | IV341:3830 running text |
| 59 | VI308:1440 running text | IV341:3831 running text |
| 60 | VI308:1441 running text | IV341:3832 running text |
| 61 | VI308:1442 running text | IV341:3833 running text |
| 62 | VI308:1443 running text | IV341:3834 running text |
| 63 | VI308:1444 running text | IV341:3835 running text |
| 64 | VI308:1445 running text | IV341:3836 running text |
| 65 | VI308:1447 running text | IV341:3837 running text |
| 66 | VI308:1446 running text | IV341:3838 running text |
| 67 | VI308:1448 running text | IV342:3839 running text |
| 68 | VI308:1449 running text | IV342:3840 running text |
| 69 | VI308:1450 running text | IV342:3841 running text |
| 70 | VI308:1451 running text | IV342:3842 running text |
New Naqqali