Katayun Counsels Esfandiyar
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5A mother’s warning follows the public confrontation
Moscow: VI227:151 running text | VI227:152 running text | VI227:153 running text | VI227:154 running text | VI227:155 running text; Mohl: IV288:2556 running text | IV288:2557 running text | IV288:2558 running text | IV288:2559 running text | IV288:2560 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:1, sh5:2, sh5:3, sh5:4, sh5:5; Khaleghi: V306:164 running text | V306:165 running text | V306:166 running text | V306:167 running text | V306:168 running text
Moscow p.227 · Mohl p.288 · Khaleghi p.306 · Ganjoor passage
All four introduce Katayun with tears and anger after she hears of the expedition. English much moved softens the explicit anger, while its address to a crown of warriors follows the heroic emphasis of Mohl and Khaleghi rather than Moscow and Ganjoor’s royal ancestry. Bahman is the source of her information in every version. The rose garden and Zabul form a pointed contrast between present safety and the journey ahead. The sword and mace belong grammatically to Rostam’s epithet as their lord; English in hand makes that ownership less distinct. Her appeal to maternal counsel nevertheless remains direct, and haste is already characterized as a movement toward evil.
6–10Rostam’s remembered deeds make the danger concrete
Moscow: VI227:156 running text | VI227:157 running text | VI227:158 running text | VI227:161 running text | VI227:163 running text; Mohl: IV288:2561 running text | IV288:2562 running text | IV288:2563 running text | IV288:2564 running text | IV288:2565 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:6, sh5:7, sh5:8, sh5:11, sh5:13; Khaleghi: V306:169 running text | V306:170 running text | V306:171 running text | V306:172 running text | V306:174 running text
Moscow p.227 · Mohl p.288 · Khaleghi p.306 · Ganjoor passage
Katayun’s catalogue measures the opponent through extraordinary violence. Mohl and Khaleghi make the Nile seem slight beside his elephantine force, supporting English scorn; Moscow and Ganjoor instead make a Nile of blood flow across the earth. The White Div, Hamavaran and vengeance for Siavash are shared. The Hamavaran killing claim is retained as her speech, without independently correcting or harmonizing earlier narrative. Moscow and Ganjoor also include two verses about Sohrab dying at his father’s hand; Khaleghi prints them in actual apparatus and Mohl has a local gap. English follows Mohl’s shorter sequence. The warning that nobody is born crowned then denies that royal ambition should require surrendering life.
11–15The crown is weighed against alternatives to death
Moscow: VI227:162 running text | VI227:164 running text | VI228:165 running text | VI228:166 running text | VI228:167 running text; Mohl: IV288:2566 running text | IV288:2567 running text | IV288:2568 running text | IV288:2569 running text | IV288:2570 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:12, sh5:14, sh5:15, sh5:16, sh5:17; Khaleghi: V306:173 running text | V306:175 running text | V306:176 running text | V307:177 running text | V307:178 running text
Moscow p.227 · Moscow p.228 · Mohl p.288 · Khaleghi p.306 · Khaleghi p.307 · Ganjoor passage
All four curse the throne and crown together with killing, tumult and plunder. English they have sown gives these objects explicit causal responsibility. Its placement after the birth maxim follows Mohl; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi place the curse first. The mother then offers practical reasons to wait: the father is old, the son young and strong, and the army looks toward him. English disgrace narrows a warning about bodily calamity in anger. Other places exist besides Sistan, so refusing this route need not end his life’s possibilities. The plea about both worlds becomes mourning in life and after death, an intelligible but more specifically emotional interpretation of maternal abasement.
16–21Acknowledging injustice does not release him from obedience
Moscow: VI228:168 running text | VI228:169 running text | VI228:170 running text | VI228:171 running text | VI228:172 running text | VI228:173 running text; Mohl: IV288:2571 running text | IV288:2572 running text | IV288:2573 running text | IV288:2574 running text | IV288:2575 running text | IV288:2576 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:18, sh5:19, sh5:20, sh5:21, sh5:22, sh5:23; Khaleghi: V307:179 running text | V307:180 running text | V307:181 running text | V307:182 running text | V307:183 running text | V307:184 running text
Moscow p.228 · Mohl p.288 · Khaleghi p.307 · Ganjoor passage
Esfandiyar does not dispute Rostam’s worth. All four compare the recitation of his deeds with Zand, affirm his beneficence and call binding him an evil unworthy of kings. English sacred explains the authority of the comparison, while wrong and shame preserve the moral force of the refusal. Yet the prince immediately asks his mother not to break his heart, treating further opposition as a threat to his own life. His final question joins obedience to the king with preserving royal standing. English kingship makes the succession motive more explicit. The conflict therefore persists inside his answer: he can recognize that the command is wrong without accepting that he may abandon it.
22–27Fate and bodily vulnerability answer each other
Moscow: VI228:174 running text | VI228:175 running text | VI228:176 running text | VI228:177 running text | VI228:177 running text | VI228:178 running text | VI228:179 running text; Mohl: IV289:2577 running text | IV289:2578 running text | IV289:2579 running text | IV289:2580 running text | IV289:2580 running text | IV289:2581 running text | IV289:2582 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:24, sh5:25, sh5:26, sh5:27, sh5:28, sh5:29; Khaleghi: V307:185 running text | V307:186 running text | V308:187 running text | V308:188 running text | V308:188 running text | V308:189 running text | V308:190 running text
Moscow p.228 · Mohl p.289 · Khaleghi p.307 · Khaleghi p.308 · Ganjoor passage
The appointed end in Zabul and the star drawing him there appear in all four. English broadens the star into heaven, retaining the surrender to destiny. The promise not to speak harshly if Rostam obeys is likewise shared in sense, although Khaleghi’s main text phrases the condition as not turning from the command and identifies an editorial emendation in actual apparatus. Katayun answers with bloody tears and torn hair, not assent. Her elephant imagery stresses both her son’s power and his vulnerability before another greater force. English distributes this warning across several couplets, preserving the insistence on companions and the striking image of carrying one’s life on one’s own shoulder.
28–32The sons’ participation exposes a second disagreement
Moscow: VI228:180 running text | VI229:181 running text | VI229:182 running text | VI229:183 running text | VI229:184 running text | VI229:185 running text; Mohl: IV289:2583 running text | IV289:2584 running text | IV289:2585 running text | IV289:2586 running text | IV289:2587 running text | IV289:2588 running text; Ganjoor: sh5:30, sh5:31, sh5:32, sh5:33, sh5:34, sh5:35; Khaleghi: V308:191 running text | V308:192 running text | V308:193 running text | V308:194 running text | V308:195 running text | V308:196 running text
Moscow p.228 · Moscow p.229 · Mohl p.289 · Khaleghi p.308 · Ganjoor passage
Katayun calls the resolve Ahriman’s desire and warns against taking children to hell. English snare interprets that desire as a trap. Its denial that a sage would approve follows Mohl and Khaleghi’s negative wording; Moscow’s main clause lacks that negative, and Ganjoor’s positive form remains tied to the prohibition. Esfandiyar insists the boys must go. English idleness generalizes the sources’ more gendered criticism of a young man staying behind the curtain with women. The need for battle experience then combines with reliance on kin and a few riders. Moscow and Ganjoor add two verses of the mother’s continuing grief; Khaleghi prints them in apparatus, while Mohl and English end sooner.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
32 English couplets. Moscow VI227–229:151–187 (37 running units); Mohl IV288–289:2556–2588 (33); Ganjoor esfandyar/sh5:1–37; Khaleghi V306–308:164–196 (33). English ends at the choice of kin and a few riders; Moscow/Ganjoor continue with two maternal-lament units before departure. Next departure: Moscow188/Mohl2589/Khaleghi197.
Moscow evidence
Running151–187 individually inspected. Main156 has the blood-Nile image;159–160 give Sohrab’s death;162 curse precedes163 birth maxim;181 wise-man clause lacks the negative. Final186–187 maternal lament has no English counterpart.
Mohl evidence
Running2556–2588 individually inspected. Main2561 supports the Nile comparison;2565 birth maxim precedes2566 curse;2584 denies wise approval;2586 specifies remaining with women. Sohrab passage and closing maternal lament have checked local gaps at2563–2564 and2588–2589. Reprint imprint unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
All37 units allocated once, with source-only9–10 and36–37 retained. Main6 differs from English Nile comparison;12–13 order differs;33 retains the gendered setting generalized as English idleness.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
Running164–196 individually inspected. Actual306n12 prints the two Sohrab verses and308n25 prints the two maternal-lament verses. Main169 supports the English Nile comparison. Actual307n25 labels the wording of186 an editorial emendation. Main192 denies wise approval;194 keeps the gendered setting. No appendix evidence used.
Interpretive limits
Katayun’s catalogue and her son’s account of education remain character speech. The Hamavaran killing claim is not silently harmonized against earlier episodes. English generalization at31 and compression at32 are visible. Named apparatus evidence is distinguished from running text; local gaps imply no universal absence.
Moscow printed p.227 · Moscow printed p.228 · Moscow printed p.229
Mohl printed p.288 · Mohl printed p.289
Khaleghi printed p.306 · Khaleghi printed p.307 · Khaleghi printed p.308
C8.4 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI227:151 running text | IV288:2556 running text |
| 2 | VI227:152 running text | IV288:2557 running text |
| 3 | VI227:153 running text | IV288:2558 running text |
| 4 | VI227:154 running text | IV288:2559 running text |
| 5 | VI227:155 running text | IV288:2560 running text |
| 6 | VI227:156 running text | IV288:2561 running text |
| 7 | VI227:157 running text | IV288:2562 running text |
| 8 | VI227:158 running text | IV288:2563 running text |
| 9 | VI227:161 running text | IV288:2564 running text |
| 10 | VI227:163 running text | IV288:2565 running text |
| 11 | VI227:162 running text | IV288:2566 running text |
| 12 | VI227:164 running text | IV288:2567 running text |
| 13 | VI228:165 running text | IV288:2568 running text |
| 14 | VI228:166 running text | IV288:2569 running text |
| 15 | VI228:167 running text | IV288:2570 running text |
| 16 | VI228:168 running text | IV288:2571 running text |
| 17 | VI228:169 running text | IV288:2572 running text |
| 18 | VI228:170 running text | IV288:2573 running text |
| 19 | VI228:171 running text | IV288:2574 running text |
| 20 | VI228:172 running text | IV288:2575 running text |
| 21 | VI228:173 running text | IV288:2576 running text |
| 22 | VI228:174 running text | IV289:2577 running text |
| 23 | VI228:175 running text | IV289:2578 running text |
| 24 | VI228:176 running text | VI228:177 running text | IV289:2579 running text | IV289:2580 running text |
| 25 | VI228:177 running text | IV289:2580 running text |
| 26 | VI228:178 running text | IV289:2581 running text |
| 27 | VI228:179 running text | IV289:2582 running text |
| 28 | VI228:180 running text | IV289:2583 running text |
| 29 | VI229:181 running text | IV289:2584 running text |
| 30 | VI229:182 running text | IV289:2585 running text |
| 31 | VI229:183 running text | IV289:2586 running text |
| 32 | VI229:184 running text | VI229:185 running text | IV289:2587 running text | IV289:2588 running text |
New Naqqali