Bahman Delivers Esfandiyar’s Message
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6A colossal diner seen from above
Moscow: VI236:315 running text | VI237:316 running text | VI237:317 running text | VI237:318 running text | VI237:319 running text | VI237:320 running text; Mohl: IV294:2716 running text | IV295:2717 running text | IV295:2718 running text | IV295:2719 running text | IV295:2720 running text | IV295:2721 running text; Ganjoor: sh9:1, sh9:2, sh9:3, sh9:4, sh9:5, sh9:6; Khaleghi: V319:323 running text | V319:324 running text | V319:325 running text; V319 n14 actual Bistoon variant | V319:326 running text | V319:327 running text | V319:328 running text
Moscow p.236 · Moscow p.237 · Mohl p.294 · Mohl p.295 · Khaleghi p.319 · Ganjoor passage
Moscow and Mohl make Rostam a man like Bistoon, seated with a tree in his hand. English preserves the mountain comparison but changes seated to stood; the later refusal to move does not settle that difference. Ganjoor and Khaleghi instead describe guides seated there, while Khaleghi’s actual apparatus prints the Bistoon reading. The tree carries a skewered wild ass, explaining English sapling as a practical interpretation of its size rather than a separate botanical fact. Wine, the attending son and Rakhsh in the meadow complete the scene in all four sources. English brightness and watchfulness enrich the picture without changing its extraordinary domestic calm.
7–11Admiration becomes an attempted ambush
Moscow: VI237:321 running text | VI237:322 running text | VI237:323 running text | VI237:324 running text | VI237:325 running text; Mohl: IV295:2722 running text | IV295:2723 running text | IV295:2724 running text | IV295:2725 running text | IV295:2726 running text; Ganjoor: sh9:7, sh9:8, sh9:9, sh9:10, sh9:11; Khaleghi: V319:329 running text | V319:330 running text | V319:331 running text | V319:332 running text | V319:333 running text
Moscow p.237 · Mohl p.295 · Khaleghi p.319 · Ganjoor passage
All four move from Bahman’s comparison with dawn’s sun to fear that Esfandiyar cannot withstand Rostam. The thought is politically filial: his father’s possible defeat prompts the decision to kill before an encounter can occur. English loss of glory states the reputational consequence more fully, while fatal field adds an ominous quality. The imagined grief of Zal and Rudabeh remains explicit in every source, so this is no harmless trial of strength. Bahman loosens the rock himself. English unaware correctly draws out the ambush, although the Persian concentrates on making Rostam lifeless with one stone rather than directly naming his lack of warning.
12–16The smallest movement answers the greatest threat
Moscow: VI237:326 running text | VI237:327 running text | VI237:328 running text | VI237:329 running text | VI237:330 running text; Mohl: IV295:2727 running text | IV295:2728 running text | IV295:2729 running text | IV295:2730 running text | IV295:2731 running text; Ganjoor: sh9:12, sh9:13, sh9:14, sh9:15, sh9:16; Khaleghi: V319:334 running text | V319:335 running text | V320:336 running text | V320:337 running text | V320:338 running text
Moscow p.237 · Mohl p.295 · Khaleghi p.319 · Khaleghi p.320 · Ganjoor passage
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi share the same sequence: Zavareh sees and hears the stone, cries out, and Rostam neither moves nor puts down the wild ass. Dust darkens the mountain as the boulder approaches. English dimmed daylight broadens that local obscuration, but retains the delay that makes the response spectacular. The Persian heel becomes one kick, an effective English action that preserves the disproportion between effort and result. Praise comes from brother and son. The scene therefore establishes superiority through composure as much as muscular force: the meal continues while the attempted killing is disposed of almost incidentally, without a narrated recognition of the attacker.
17–21Fear of defeat widens into fear for Iran
Moscow: VI237:331 running text | VI237:332 running text | VI237:333 running text | VI238:334 running text | VI238:335 running text; Mohl: IV295:2732 running text | IV295:2733 running text | IV295:2734 running text | IV295:2735 running text | IV295:2736 running text; Ganjoor: sh9:17, sh9:18, sh9:19, sh9:20, sh9:21; Khaleghi: V320:339 running text | V320:340 running text | V320:341 running text | V320:342 running text | V320:343 running text
Moscow p.237 · Moscow p.238 · Mohl p.295 · Khaleghi p.320 · Ganjoor passage
All four make Bahman reflect that battle with this man could disgrace Esfandiyar and that accommodation would be better. English peace makes the practical direction of madara explicit without requiring a formal treaty. The next anxiety is larger: if Rostam wins, he could take Iran. English names the implied victor clearly, making the political inference easier to follow. Bahman descends in thought on his swift horse. All four then include a report of the marvel to the mobad and an easier route, a unit absent from English. That omission shortens the transition but also removes the only immediate report of what he has witnessed before the reception.
22–27Recognition and naming control the reception
Moscow: VI238:337 running text | VI238:338 running text | VI238:339 running text | VI238:340 running text | VI238:341 running text; Mohl: IV295:2738 running text | IV295:2739 running text | IV295:2740 running text | IV295:2741 running text | IV296:2742 running text; Ganjoor: sh9:23, sh9:24, sh9:25, sh9:26, sh9:27; Khaleghi: V320:345 running text | V320:346 running text | V320:347 running text | V320:348 running text | V321:349 running text
Moscow p.238 · Mohl p.295 · Mohl p.296 · Khaleghi p.320 · Khaleghi p.321 · Ganjoor passage
Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi make Rostam ask the mobad about the approaching youth; Moscow’s main text anomalously addresses Bahman himself. English comrade is less specific than mobad but gives the exchange a coherent companion as listener. Rostam guesses royal descent before receiving the name. The welcome with Zavareh and the others is shared, although English formal ranks adds ceremony to the gathering. Dismounting and greeting expand across two English couplets before the condition is stated: without a name, the visitor cannot gain what he seeks. The English generalization about a nameless man preserves the point while sounding more like a standing maxim than an immediate question.
28–33Kinship turns a stranger into a royal guest
Moscow: VI238:342 running text | VI238:343 running text | VI238:344 running text | VI238:345 running text | VI238:346 running text | VI238:347 running text; Mohl: IV296:2743 running text | IV296:2744 running text | IV296:2745 running text | IV296:2746 running text | IV296:2747 running text | IV296:2748 running text; Ganjoor: sh9:28, sh9:29, sh9:30, sh9:31, sh9:32, sh9:33; Khaleghi: V321:350 running text | V321:351 running text | V321:352 running text | V321:353 running text | V321:354 running text | V321:355 running text
Moscow p.238 · Mohl p.296 · Khaleghi p.321 · Ganjoor passage
All four identify Bahman as Esfandiyar’s son, followed by an embrace and an apology for the delayed greeting. English delight is an interpretation of the welcoming action. The company then sits with nobles described as servants or adherents of the king; English chief shifts that allegiance toward the present host. Greetings arrive from the Shah and Iranians, with English adding the prince among their senders. The fire comparison belongs to Esfandiyar’s departure from the royal presence, and the tent stands beside Hirmund under the king’s command in each source. The hospitality therefore does not erase the official mission: its authority remains visible throughout the courteous exchange.
34–39Rostam postpones business in favor of the meal
Moscow: VI238:348 running text | VI238:349 running text | VI238:350 running text | VI238:351 running text | VI238:352 running text | VI239:353 running text; Mohl: IV296:2749 running text | IV296:2750 running text | IV296:2751 running text | IV296:2752 running text | IV296:2753 running text | IV296:2754 running text; Ganjoor: sh9:34, sh9:35, sh9:36, sh9:37, sh9:38, sh9:39; Khaleghi: V321:356 running text | V321:357 running text | V321:358 running text | V321:359 running text | V321:360 running text | V321:361 running text
Moscow p.238 · Moscow p.239 · Mohl p.296 · Khaleghi p.321 · Ganjoor passage
The request to deliver the message is shared, but Rostam’s answer differs. Mohl and Khaleghi address a royal child wearied by the road, directly supporting English. Moscow elevates the child above sun and moon, whereas Ganjoor elevates the king’s command. These are distinct readings, not equivalent paraphrases. All four then defer business until after food with the courteous assurance that the world will be the guest’s to command. Bread, hot roast and recollection of past matters follow. The main texts seat Rostam’s brother and exclude other nobles. Printed additional seating variants in Moscow and Khaleghi belong to apparatus and should not silently enlarge the main-text dining company.
40–45Appetite becomes a teasing measure of prowess
Moscow: VI239:354 running text | VI239:355 running text | VI239:356 running text; VI239 n10 actual hundredfold variant | VI239:357 running text | VI239:358 running text | VI239:359 running text; Mohl: IV296:2755 running text | IV296:2756 running text | IV296:2757 running text | IV296:2758 running text | IV296:2759 running text | IV296:2760 running text; Ganjoor: sh9:40, sh9:41, sh9:42, sh9:43, sh9:44, sh9:45; Khaleghi: V322:362 running text | V322:363 running text | V322:364 running text | V322:365 running text | V322:366 running text | V322:367 running text
Moscow p.239 · Mohl p.296 · Khaleghi p.322 · Ganjoor passage
The whole wild ass is Rostam’s customary portion in all four, and Bahman’s small intake sets up the joke. Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi explicitly supply the hundredfold comparison followed by English; Moscow’s main wording differs, with hundred actually present in its apparatus. English life’s pleasant things broadens a pointed claim about royal standing and food. The question about passing the Seven Stages is addressed to Bahman even though the feat belongs to his father; the English retains that teasing compression rather than repairing it through an invented speaker change. The following spear question connects appetite and battle directly, inviting Bahman to defend a different model of royal conduct.
46–50Royal restraint answers heroic abundance
Moscow: VI239:360 running text | VI239:361 running text | VI239:362 running text | VI239:363 running text | VI239:364 running text; Mohl: IV296:2761 running text | IV296:2762 running text | IV296:2763 running text | IV296:2764 running text | IV296:2765 running text; Ganjoor: sh9:46, sh9:47, sh9:48, sh9:49, sh9:50; Khaleghi: V322:368 running text | V322:369 running text | V322:370 running text | V322:371 running text | V322:372 running text
Moscow p.239 · Mohl p.296 · Khaleghi p.322 · Ganjoor passage
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi oppose excessive talk and excessive eating to the discipline expected of royal descent. English loose of tongue makes the first fault moral as well as quantitative. Little food, greater toil and battle, and life held on the palm preserve the answer’s compact ethic. Rostam’s laughter and declaration that manhood should not be hidden keep the exchange competitive without turning it into an open quarrel. English pride interprets that assertion. The gold cup and remembrance of freeborn men then move the contest into drinking; the second cup invites Bahman to choose whom to honor, retaining a measure of agency within the host’s exuberant hospitality.
51–55The cup unsettles the guest before business resumes
Moscow: VI239:365 running text | VI239:366 running text | VI239:367 running text | VI239:368 running text | VI240:369 running text | VI240:370 running text; Mohl: IV296:2766 running text | IV297:2767 running text | IV297:2768 running text | IV297:2769 running text | IV297:2770 running text | IV297:2771 running text; Ganjoor: sh9:51, sh9:52, sh9:53, sh9:54, sh9:55, sh9:56; Khaleghi: V322:373 running text | V323:374 running text | V323:375 running text | V323:376 running text | V323:378 running text | V323:379 running text
Moscow p.239 · Moscow p.240 · Mohl p.296 · Mohl p.297 · Khaleghi p.322 · Khaleghi p.323 · Ganjoor passage
All four show Bahman fearing the wine and Zavareh drinking first, followed by a blessing upon the royal child. None of these main lines explicitly explains the fear, so suspicion of poison or a religious prohibition would exceed the evidence. English then continues Bahman’s wonder at Rostam, where Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor describe distress and delay over the wine and Khaleghi emphasizes constrained drinking. This is a meaningful softening of the guest’s discomfort. Wonder at the hero’s eating and bodily power follows in all four. They mount and the message is delivered; Khaleghi additionally prints a bracketed rising-from-the-meal verse, which remains distinct from the common closing pair.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
55 English couplets. Moscow VI236–240:315–370; Mohl IV294–297:2716–2771; Ganjoor esfandyar/sh9:1–56; Khaleghi V319–323:323–379, with a bracketed meal-ending verse (377) before378. From ascent to delivery of the message. Next answer starts Moscow371/Mohl2772/Khaleghi380.
Moscow evidence
Running315–370 inspected individually. Bistoon and seated occur in317. Main338 addresses Bahman rather than the mobad. Main349 elevates the royal child above sun/moon; main356 differs from the hundredfold reading actually printed in239 n10. Additional seating in239 n3 is actual apparatus. Distress over wine remains in367.
Mohl evidence
Running2716–2771 inspected individually. Bistoon2718, mobad2739, weary royal child2750, hundredfold2757 and distress over wine2768 are running readings. No appendix evidence is used. Reprint imprint remains unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
All56 units allocated once;22 is source-only,26 is shared by English25–26 and55–56 combine at English55. Main3 has seated guides,35 king’s command,42 hundredfold and53 distress/delay over wine.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
Running323–379 inspected. Bistoon is actual apparatus319 n14 rather than main325. Main357 supports weary traveler;364 hundredfold;375 distress and constrained drinking. Actual apparatus321 n23 adds dining participants. An bracketed rising-from-meal verse precedes377; it has no counterpart at the checked Moscow368–370/Mohl2769–2771/Ganjoor54–56 boundaries. No appendix evidence or exhaustive apparatus agreement is claimed.
Interpretive limits
English stood differs from seated in the Bistoon readings. The omitted report to the mobad and softened distress over wine are substantive translation differences. Fear of wine is not assigned an unprinted cause. The Stages question retains its teasing attribution to the son.
Moscow printed p.236 · Moscow printed p.237 · Moscow printed p.238 · Moscow printed p.239 · Moscow printed p.240
Mohl printed p.294 · Mohl printed p.295 · Mohl printed p.296 · Mohl printed p.297
Khaleghi printed p.319 · Khaleghi printed p.320 · Khaleghi printed p.321 · Khaleghi printed p.322 · Khaleghi printed p.323
C8.8 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI236:315 running text | IV294:2716 running text |
| 2 | VI237:316 running text | IV295:2717 running text |
| 3 | VI237:317 running text | IV295:2718 running text |
| 4 | VI237:318 running text | IV295:2719 running text |
| 5 | VI237:319 running text | IV295:2720 running text |
| 6 | VI237:320 running text | IV295:2721 running text |
| 7 | VI237:321 running text | IV295:2722 running text |
| 8 | VI237:322 running text | IV295:2723 running text |
| 9 | VI237:323 running text | IV295:2724 running text |
| 10 | VI237:324 running text | IV295:2725 running text |
| 11 | VI237:325 running text | IV295:2726 running text |
| 12 | VI237:326 running text | IV295:2727 running text |
| 13 | VI237:327 running text | IV295:2728 running text |
| 14 | VI237:328 running text | IV295:2729 running text |
| 15 | VI237:329 running text | IV295:2730 running text |
| 16 | VI237:330 running text | IV295:2731 running text |
| 17 | VI237:331 running text | IV295:2732 running text |
| 18 | VI237:332 running text | IV295:2733 running text |
| 19 | VI237:333 running text | IV295:2734 running text |
| 20 | VI238:334 running text | IV295:2735 running text |
| 21 | VI238:335 running text | IV295:2736 running text |
| 22 | VI238:337 running text | IV295:2738 running text |
| 23 | VI238:338 running text | IV295:2739 running text |
| 24 | VI238:339 running text | IV295:2740 running text |
| 25 | VI238:340 running text | IV295:2741 running text |
| 26 | VI238:340 running text | IV295:2741 running text |
| 27 | VI238:341 running text | IV296:2742 running text |
| 28 | VI238:342 running text | IV296:2743 running text |
| 29 | VI238:343 running text | IV296:2744 running text |
| 30 | VI238:344 running text | IV296:2745 running text |
| 31 | VI238:345 running text | IV296:2746 running text |
| 32 | VI238:346 running text | IV296:2747 running text |
| 33 | VI238:347 running text | IV296:2748 running text |
| 34 | VI238:348 running text | IV296:2749 running text |
| 35 | VI238:349 running text | IV296:2750 running text |
| 36 | VI238:350 running text | IV296:2751 running text |
| 37 | VI238:351 running text | IV296:2752 running text |
| 38 | VI238:352 running text | IV296:2753 running text |
| 39 | VI239:353 running text | IV296:2754 running text |
| 40 | VI239:354 running text | IV296:2755 running text |
| 41 | VI239:355 running text | IV296:2756 running text |
| 42 | VI239:356 running text; VI239 n10 actual hundredfold variant | IV296:2757 running text |
| 43 | VI239:357 running text | IV296:2758 running text |
| 44 | VI239:358 running text | IV296:2759 running text |
| 45 | VI239:359 running text | IV296:2760 running text |
| 46 | VI239:360 running text | IV296:2761 running text |
| 47 | VI239:361 running text | IV296:2762 running text |
| 48 | VI239:362 running text | IV296:2763 running text |
| 49 | VI239:363 running text | IV296:2764 running text |
| 50 | VI239:364 running text | IV296:2765 running text |
| 51 | VI239:365 running text | IV296:2766 running text |
| 52 | VI239:366 running text | IV297:2767 running text |
| 53 | VI239:367 running text | IV297:2768 running text |
| 54 | VI239:368 running text | IV297:2769 running text |
| 55 | VI240:369 running text | VI240:370 running text | IV297:2770 running text | IV297:2771 running text |
New Naqqali