Rostam Answers Esfandiyar
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Praise makes a claim upon the prince’s conduct
Moscow: VI240:371 running text | VI240:372 running text | VI240:373 running text | VI240:373 running text | VI240:374 running text | VI240:375 running text | VI240:376 running text | VI240:377 running text | VI240:377 running text; Mohl: IV297:2772 running text | IV297:2773 running text | IV297:2774 running text | IV297:2774 running text | IV297:2775 running text | IV297:2776 running text | IV297:2777 running text | IV297:2778 running text | IV297:2778 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:1, sh10:2, sh10:3, sh10:4, sh10:5, sh10:6, sh10:7; Khaleghi: V323:380 running text | V323:381 running text | V323:382 running text | V323:382 running text | V323:383 running text | V323:384 running text | V323:385 running text | V323:386 running text | V323:386 running text
Moscow p.240 · Mohl p.297 · Khaleghi p.323 · Ganjoor passage
All four introduce Rostam’s answer through reflection, then combine courtesy toward Bahman with an address to Esfandiyar as lion-hearted and renowned. English distributes these units across its opening couplets while keeping the sequence intelligible. Wisdom should examine the foundations of action; valor, success, wealth and esteem therefore create obligations rather than permission to behave badly. English high estate and honors make that social reasoning explicit. The praise is not an unconditional endorsement of the mission. It prepares the warning that present distinction should prevent misconduct, making Esfandiyar’s own reputation the standard against which the threatened treatment of Rostam must be judged.
7–12Measured speech belongs to justice and wisdom
Moscow: VI240:378 running text | VI240:379 running text | VI240:380 running text | VI240:381 running text | VI240:382 running text | VI240:383 running text; Mohl: IV297:2779 running text | IV297:2780 running text | IV297:2781 running text | IV297:2782 running text | IV297:2783 running text | IV297:2784 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:8, sh10:9, sh10:10, sh10:11, sh10:12, sh10:13; Khaleghi: V324:387 running text | V324:388 running text | V324:389 running text | V324:390 running text | V324:391 running text | V324:392 running text
Moscow p.240 · Mohl p.297 · Khaleghi p.324 · Ganjoor passage
Justice and worship are joined in all four, followed by the refusal to take evil by the hand. English keeps that bodily metaphor and the tree without fruit or scent, adding a barren root to complete its image of useless speech. Greed then turns action into prolonged futility; cold is English intensification rather than an additional Persian quality. The advice about measured words answers the threatening message without immediately abandoning courtesy. Praise of Esfandiyar’s superiority over his ancestors follows. English learning agrees with Mohl and Khaleghi’s culture or education term, while Moscow and Ganjoor emphasize prowess in the corresponding place. The distinction affects the qualities praised, not the direction of praise.
13–18A long-desired meeting becomes possible
Moscow: VI240:384 running text | VI240:385 running text | VI241:386 running text | VI241:387 running text | VI241:387 running text | VI241:388 running text | VI241:389 running text; Mohl: IV297:2785 running text | IV297:2786 running text | IV297:2787 running text | IV297:2788 running text | IV297:2788 running text | IV298:2789 running text | IV298:2790 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:14, sh10:15, sh10:16, sh10:17, sh10:18, sh10:19; Khaleghi: V324:393 running text | V324:394 running text | V324:395 running text | V324:396 running text | V324:396 running text | V324:397 running text | V324:398 running text
Moscow p.240 · Moscow p.241 · Mohl p.297 · Mohl p.298 · Khaleghi p.324 · Ganjoor passage
All four spread Esfandiyar’s reputation through Hind, Rum, Chin and the land of sorcerers, with English rearranging the places for its couplet. The thanks for counsel and praise through day and night retain an elaborate courtly register. Rostam recalls praying to see the prince’s face, stature, prowess and affection, then imagines wine shared in honor of the Shah. English your king and mine states the allegiance that makes the desired meeting politically meaningful. Now the wish has been granted, he hastens in supplication. The movement from distant fame to personal encounter offers an alternative to coercion: the prince can receive the honored visitor Rostam already wished to become.
19–24The grants place past service beside present coercion
Moscow: VI241:390 running text | VI241:391 running text | VI241:392 running text | VI241:393 running text | VI241:394 running text | VI241:395 running text; Mohl: IV298:2791 running text | IV298:2792 running text | IV298:2793 running text | IV298:2794 running text | IV298:2795 running text | IV298:2796 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:20, sh10:21, sh10:22, sh10:23, sh10:24, sh10:25; Khaleghi: V325:399 running text | V325:400 running text | V325:401 running text | V325:402 running text | V325:403 running text | V325:404 running text
Moscow p.241 · Mohl p.298 · Khaleghi p.325 · Ganjoor passage
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all offer a visit without troops to hear the king’s command. That concession is paired with the royal grants extending from Kay Khosrow back to Kay Qobad, so English preserves the retrospective order rather than silently modernizing it. Rostam asks that his deeds and suffering be examined. English battles won gives a military form to the more general record of goodness and hardship, appropriate to the speaker but still an expansion. The question about chains as wages then exposes the contradiction between acknowledged service and current treatment. It is an appeal to the monarchy’s own history, not a declaration that royal authority has no claim upon him.
25–30Submission is offered beside proof of strength
Moscow: VI241:396 running text | VI241:397 running text | VI241:398 running text | VI241:399 running text | VI241:400 running text | VI241:401 running text; Mohl: IV298:2797 running text | IV298:2798 running text | IV298:2799 running text | IV298:2800 running text | IV298:2801 running text | IV298:2802 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:26, sh10:27, sh10:28, sh10:29, sh10:30, sh10:31; Khaleghi: V325:405 running text | V325:406 running text | V325:407 running text | V325:408 running text | V325:409 running text | V326:410 running text
Moscow p.241 · Mohl p.298 · Khaleghi p.325 · Khaleghi p.326 · Ganjoor passage
All four prefer nonexistence or a brief life to such a reward, which English renders directly as birth and early death. The offer to come in leopard skin with a halter varies in its foot and binding language; Mohl most clearly supports the English arrival on foot. Mohl also supplies breaking the elephant’s neck, where Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi bind it. The guilt condition requires equal care: Moscow and Ganjoor support English guilt becoming apparent, while Mohl and Khaleghi print a difficult negative. English thus combines support from different witnesses. The gesture of submission remains surrounded by reminders of overwhelming strength, and the warning against hurtful speech limits how far courtesy can be pressed.
31–36Impossible images draw the limit of coercion
Moscow: VI241:402 running text | VI242:403 running text | VI242:404 running text | VI242:405 running text | VI242:406 running text | VI242:407 running text; Mohl: IV298:2803 running text | IV298:2804 running text | IV298:2805 running text | IV298:2806 running text | IV298:2807 running text | IV298:2808 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:32, sh10:33, sh10:34, sh10:35, sh10:36, sh10:37; Khaleghi: V326:411 running text | V326:412 running text | V326:413 running text | V326:414 running text | V326:415 running text | V326:416 running text
Moscow p.241 · Moscow p.242 · Mohl p.298 · Khaleghi p.326 · Ganjoor passage
The uncageable wind and the swimming limit are common, but the intervening proverb differs substantially. Mohl supports English finding a way through fire; Moscow’s main text has a negative finding construction with fire, whereas Ganjoor and Khaleghi give wisdom. English moon likewise follows Mohl against the other three main texts’ sun. The fox and lion contrast remains shared. These images lead into the direct warning against strife and the assertion that no one has fettered Rostam. Finally Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi explicitly reject Greed as a right-hand Div, while Moscow warns against improper conduct. English therefore preserves a supported sequence without representing it as unanimous wording.
37–42The invitation gives reconciliation a practical form
Moscow: VI242:408 running text | VI242:409 running text | VI242:410 running text | VI242:411 running text | VI242:412 running text | VI242:413 running text; Mohl: IV298:2809 running text | IV298:2810 running text | IV298:2811 running text | IV298:2812 running text | IV298:2813 running text | IV299:2814 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:38, sh10:39, sh10:40, sh10:41, sh10:42, sh10:43; Khaleghi: V326:417 running text | V326:418 running text | V326:419 running text | V327:420 running text | V327:421 running text | V327:422 running text
Moscow p.242 · Mohl p.298 · Mohl p.299 · Khaleghi p.326 · Khaleghi p.327 · Ganjoor passage
All four counsel against wrath, vengeance and viewing the world through youthful eyes. The river crossing then leads toward a feast under divine blessing. English recombines the household invitation, the memory of serving Kay Qobad, present joy in the prince and the appeal against distance across two couplets. The resulting order remains coherent and does not lose a source unit. A two-month stay for the army gives hospitality a concrete duration. Men and animals can rest, while enemies become blind with envy. The invitation thus offers a public display of alliance as well as private enjoyment, answering the threat of compulsory submission with an honorable, visible relationship.
43–48Hunting and treasure extend the offer
Moscow: VI242:414 running text | VI242:415 running text | VI242:416 running text | VI242:417 running text | VI242:418 running text | VI242:419 running text; Mohl: IV299:2815 running text | IV299:2816 running text | IV299:2817 running text | IV299:2818 running text | IV299:2819 running text | IV299:2820 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:44, sh10:45, sh10:46, sh10:47, sh10:48, sh10:49; Khaleghi: V327:423 running text | V327:424 running text | V327:425 running text | V327:426 running text | V327:427 running text | V327:428 running text
Moscow p.242 · Mohl p.299 · Khaleghi p.327 · Ganjoor passage
All four join field game and water birds to the prospect of a long visit, but English wait resolves the elliptical Persian phrase about taking haste into leisure. That interpretation remains provisional rather than a literal equivalence. Rostam then offers to watch the prince’s sword against lion or leopard, allowing Esfandiyar room to display prowess instead of merely hearing Rostam’s own claims. Departure brings the opening of old treasure gained by sword and hand. English preserves the freedom to choose and distribute the rest, followed by the plea not to darken the day. The generosity is extensive, yet it does not include an unqualified acceptance of chains.
49–52The journey to court preserves a question for the king
Moscow: VI243:421 running text | VI243:422 running text | VI243:423 running text | VI243:424 running text | VI243:425 running text; Mohl: IV299:2821 running text | IV299:2822 running text | IV299:2823 running text | IV299:2824 running text | IV299:2825 running text; Ganjoor: sh10:51, sh10:52, sh10:53, sh10:54, sh10:55; Khaleghi: V327:430 running text | V327:431 running text | V327:432 running text | V328:433 running text | V328:434 running text
Moscow p.243 · Mohl p.299 · Khaleghi p.327 · Khaleghi p.328 · Ganjoor passage
All four offer to ride beside the prince when he returns to the Shah, then soften royal anger through apology and gestures of homage. English combines the departure condition with the rein-to-rein journey, keeping both the voluntary approach and the shared road. Immediately before this, Moscow has an injunction about the old warrior and delay, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give money to troops and reject harshness, and Mohl has a checked local gap; English omits that unit. The closing question nevertheless remains in every witness: why must Rostam’s feet be bound? Bahman is charged to remember everything, so the answer ends as a complete diplomatic message rather than an unconditional surrender.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
52 English couplets. Moscow VI240–243:371–425; Mohl IV297–299:2772–2825; Ganjoor esfandyar/sh10:1–55; Khaleghi V323–328:380–434. From Rostam’s reflection to the command that Bahman remember and report. Next return begins Moscow426/Mohl2826/Khaleghi435.
Moscow evidence
Running371–425 inspected individually. Main398 foot/binding differs from Mohl;399 binds the elephant;400 has guilt becoming apparent. Main403 has negative finding with fire,404 sun,407 an impropriety warning and420 an old-warrior/delay injunction. These are not harmonized to the English or other editions.
Mohl evidence
Running2772–2825 inspected individually. Main2799 supports on foot and leopard skin;2800 breaking the elephant’s neck;2801 has the difficult negative guilt condition;2804 fire and positive finding;2805 moon;2808 Greed as Div. Checked local gap between2819–2820 for the extra injunction. Reprint imprint remains unverified.
Ganjoor evidence
All55 units allocated once with shared references where English redistributes material. Unit50 is source-only. Main28 foot/binding,29 bound elephant,30 apparent guilt,33 wisdom,34 sun,37 Greed and50 troop payment/temperance are distinguished from English and other main readings.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
Running380–434 inspected. Main392 supports learning;407 foot/binding differs from Mohl;408 binds elephant;409 prints negative niamad;412 wisdom;413 sun;416 Greed;429 troop payment and rejection of harshness. No appendix evidence or exhaustive apparatus agreement is claimed. The printed main readings are kept distinct from variant alternatives.
Interpretive limits
English has mixed witness support rather than one uniformly followed edition. Apparent guilt versus negative niamad is unresolved in the divergent main readings; English is supported by Moscow/Ganjoor. English43 wait is an interpretive resolution of the hunting invitation and remains provisional. No unprinted variant is used as verification.
Moscow printed p.240 · Moscow printed p.241 · Moscow printed p.242 · Moscow printed p.243
Mohl printed p.297 · Mohl printed p.298 · Mohl printed p.299
Khaleghi printed p.323 · Khaleghi printed p.324 · Khaleghi printed p.325 · Khaleghi printed p.326 · Khaleghi printed p.327 · Khaleghi printed p.328
C8.9 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI240:371 running text | IV297:2772 running text |
| 2 | VI240:372 running text | VI240:373 running text | IV297:2773 running text | IV297:2774 running text |
| 3 | VI240:373 running text | VI240:374 running text | IV297:2774 running text | IV297:2775 running text |
| 4 | VI240:375 running text | IV297:2776 running text |
| 5 | VI240:376 running text | VI240:377 running text | IV297:2777 running text | IV297:2778 running text |
| 6 | VI240:377 running text | IV297:2778 running text |
| 7 | VI240:378 running text | IV297:2779 running text |
| 8 | VI240:379 running text | IV297:2780 running text |
| 9 | VI240:380 running text | IV297:2781 running text |
| 10 | VI240:381 running text | IV297:2782 running text |
| 11 | VI240:382 running text | IV297:2783 running text |
| 12 | VI240:383 running text | IV297:2784 running text |
| 13 | VI240:384 running text | IV297:2785 running text |
| 14 | VI240:385 running text | IV297:2786 running text |
| 15 | VI241:386 running text | VI241:387 running text | IV297:2787 running text | IV297:2788 running text |
| 16 | VI241:387 running text | IV297:2788 running text |
| 17 | VI241:388 running text | IV298:2789 running text |
| 18 | VI241:389 running text | IV298:2790 running text |
| 19 | VI241:390 running text | IV298:2791 running text |
| 20 | VI241:391 running text | IV298:2792 running text |
| 21 | VI241:392 running text | IV298:2793 running text |
| 22 | VI241:393 running text | IV298:2794 running text |
| 23 | VI241:394 running text | IV298:2795 running text |
| 24 | VI241:395 running text | IV298:2796 running text |
| 25 | VI241:396 running text | IV298:2797 running text |
| 26 | VI241:397 running text | IV298:2798 running text |
| 27 | VI241:398 running text | IV298:2799 running text |
| 28 | VI241:399 running text | IV298:2800 running text |
| 29 | VI241:400 running text | IV298:2801 running text |
| 30 | VI241:401 running text | IV298:2802 running text |
| 31 | VI241:402 running text | IV298:2803 running text |
| 32 | VI242:403 running text | IV298:2804 running text |
| 33 | VI242:404 running text | IV298:2805 running text |
| 34 | VI242:405 running text | IV298:2806 running text |
| 35 | VI242:406 running text | IV298:2807 running text |
| 36 | VI242:407 running text | IV298:2808 running text |
| 37 | VI242:408 running text | IV298:2809 running text |
| 38 | VI242:409 running text | IV298:2810 running text |
| 39 | VI242:410 running text | VI242:411 running text | IV298:2811 running text | IV298:2812 running text |
| 40 | VI242:410 running text | VI242:411 running text | IV298:2811 running text | IV298:2812 running text |
| 41 | VI242:412 running text | IV298:2813 running text |
| 42 | VI242:413 running text | IV299:2814 running text |
| 43 | VI242:414 running text | IV299:2815 running text |
| 44 | VI242:415 running text | IV299:2816 running text |
| 45 | VI242:416 running text | IV299:2817 running text |
| 46 | VI242:417 running text | IV299:2818 running text |
| 47 | VI242:418 running text | IV299:2819 running text |
| 48 | VI242:419 running text | IV299:2820 running text |
| 49 | VI243:421 running text | VI243:422 running text | IV299:2821 running text | IV299:2822 running text |
| 50 | VI243:423 running text | IV299:2823 running text |
| 51 | VI243:424 running text | IV299:2824 running text |
| 52 | VI243:425 running text | IV299:2825 running text |
New Naqqali