Bahman Releases Zal
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The minister sets a limit to royal vengeance
Moscow: VI349:124 running text | VI349:125 running text | VI350:126 running text | VI350:127 running text | VI350:128 running text | VI350:129 running text; Mohl: V8:109 running text | V8:110 running text | V8:111 running text | V8:112 running text | V8:113 running text | V8:114 running text; Ganjoor: sh4:1, sh4:2, sh4:3, sh4:4, sh4:5, sh4:6; Khaleghi: V480:101 running text | V480:102 running text | V480:103 running text | V480:104 running text | V480:105 running text | V480:106 running text
Moscow p.349 · Moscow p.350 · Mohl p.8 · Khaleghi p.480 · Ganjoor passage
All four give Bishutan the initiative: the minister rises because the killing has made him sick at heart. English turns the address to a king of justice into an explicit demand that justice limit punishment, making the speech’s implication immediate. Its loss in the third couplet simplifies the difficult Persian contrast involving deficiency and rightness or truth; the English does not preserve that verbal opposition. The prohibition of further plunder and killing is nevertheless clear across the four. Fear of God, shame before witnesses and the instability of fortune then supply distinct restraints. English keeps them together, so the argument addresses conscience, public accountability and the king’s own vulnerability rather than relying on sympathy alone.
7–12Two unintended deaths undermine confidence in power
Moscow: VI350:130 running text | VI350:131 running text | VI350:132 running text | VI350:133 running text | VI350:134 running text | VI350:135 running text; Mohl: V8:115 running text | V8:116 running text | V8:117 running text | V8:118 running text | V8:119 running text | V8:120 running text; Ganjoor: sh4:7, sh4:8, sh4:9, sh4:10, sh4:11, sh4:12; Khaleghi: V480:107 running text | V481:108 running text | V481:109 running text | V481:110 running text | V481:111 running text | V481:112 running text
Moscow p.350 · Mohl p.8 · Khaleghi p.480 · Khaleghi p.481 · Ganjoor passage
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi pair Esfandiyar’s journey to Nimruz with Rostam’s hunting expedition to Kabul. Neither man set out intending the death that followed. English preserves the parallel and the coffin and pit images, allowing Bishutan to invoke both families’ losses without declaring them morally equivalent. The warning then turns to Zal’s possible appeal to God: royal good fortune cannot guarantee victory in that court. English’s lawless reign makes the accusation more explicit than the immediate Persian line, which describes the bound elder’s complaint. Returning to Rostam as guardian of the crown links the warning to remembered service and prepares the next, more direct challenge to Bahman’s inherited authority.
13–18The crown is said to depend on the man condemned
Moscow: VI350:136 running text | VI350:137 running text | VI350:138 running text | VI350:139 running text | VI350:140 running text | VI350:141 running text; Mohl: V8:121 running text | V8:122 running text | V8:123 running text | V8:124 running text | V8:125 running text | V8:126 running text; Ganjoor: sh4:13, sh4:14, sh4:15, sh4:16, sh4:17, sh4:18; Khaleghi: V481:113 running text | V481:114 running text | V481:115 running text | V481:116 running text | V481:117 running text | V481:118 running text
Moscow p.350 · Mohl p.8 · Khaleghi p.481 · Ganjoor passage
All four make Bishutan say that Bahman owes his crown to Rostam rather than Goshtasb or Esfandiyar, and extend the argument from Kay Qobad to Kay Khosrow. English preserves the force of this challenge as the minister’s speech. Its world beneath the kings’ feet broadens the Persian image of subordinate great men, while retaining the claim that Rostam’s sword sustained royal power. The demand to release Zal follows from that debt. English’s remorse for past deeds agrees with Mohl and Khaleghi; Moscow and Ganjoor describe remorse in relation to pain and old vengeance. The ensuing proclamation makes the change public, so repentance produces an order that the army can obey.
19–24Release and burial do not end the household’s grief
Moscow: VI350:142 running text | VI350:143 running text | VI350:144 running text | VI350:145 running text | VI350:146 running text | VI351:147 running text; Mohl: V8:127 running text | V8:128 running text | V9:129 running text | V9:130 running text | V9:131 running text | V9:132 running text; Ganjoor: sh4:19, sh4:20, sh4:21, sh4:22, sh4:23, sh4:24; Khaleghi: V481:119 running text | V481:120 running text | V481:121 running text | V481:122 running text | V481:123 running text | V481:124 running text
Moscow p.350 · Moscow p.351 · Mohl p.8 · Mohl p.9 · Khaleghi p.481 · Ganjoor passage
All four prohibit further plunder, release Zal, place the slain man in a tomb at the minister’s request and return the elder to his household. English identifies the unnamed corpse as Faramarz, securely supplied by the preceding execution, and names Rudabeh where the immediate verse describes Zal’s wife. These clarifications help readers follow the participants without adding a separate event. Her lament then addresses Rostam and recalls his descent from Nariman. The rhetorical question about Goshtasb’s kingship measures royal visibility against the hero’s former stature. English preserves that challenge after the formal act of mercy: restoration of Zal’s freedom cannot restore the dead men or cancel the household’s judgment on the king.
25–30Rudabeh’s curse changes the atmosphere of departure
Moscow: VI351:148 running text | VI351:149 running text | VI351:150 running text | VI351:151 running text | VI351:152 running text | VI351:153 running text; Mohl: V9:133 running text | V9:134 running text | V9:135 running text | V9:136 running text | V9:137 running text | V9:138 running text; Ganjoor: sh4:25, sh4:26, sh4:27, sh4:28, sh4:29, sh4:30; Khaleghi: V481:125 running text | V482:126 running text | V482:127 running text | V482:128 running text | V482:129 running text | V482:130 running text
Moscow p.351 · Mohl p.9 · Khaleghi p.481 · Khaleghi p.482 · Ganjoor passage
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi retain Rudabeh’s inventory of ruin: plundered wealth, captive Zal and a son killed by arrows. English leaves the captivity inside her lament even though the narration has already released Zal; the speech gathers the injuries rather than supplying a new chronological report. Its curse against Esfandiyar’s line is correspondingly severe. Bishutan’s pallor shows the effect of hearing her before he addresses the young king with the new-moon comparison. English’s newly bright crown makes that image explicitly royal. The request to leave at dawn is tactful but urgent: all four call the situation difficult and weighty, so the departure follows an emotional and political disturbance rather than a settled reconciliation.
31–36A just return retains an unresolved remainder
Moscow: VI351:154 running text | VI351:155 running text | VI351:156 running text | VI351:160 running text | VI351:161 running text | VI351:162 running text; Mohl: V9:139 running text | V9:140 running text | V9:141 running text | V9:142 running text | V9:143 running text | V9:144 running text; Ganjoor: sh4:31, sh4:32, sh4:33, sh4:37, sh4:38, sh4:39; Khaleghi: V482:131 running text | V482:132 running text | V482:134 running text | V482:135 running text | V482:136 running text | V482:137 running text
Moscow p.351 · Mohl p.9 · Khaleghi p.482 · Ganjoor passage
All four bless the king, urge a short stay in Zal’s house, announce departure at dawn and end with royal rule and gifts that leave some people glad and others grieving. English follows Mohl’s shorter departure sequence. Moscow and Ganjoor add three units; Khaleghi retains the command to move in bracketed running text and prints two further units in actual apparatus. English also omits the closing apostrophe found in Moscow and Ganjoor and printed in Khaleghi’s apparatus. Its vast wealth and gold intensify the less specific dirhams of the gift line. Yet it preserves the divided response, preventing the assertion of renewed justice from erasing the injuries just narrated.
Source record and limits
Scope and boundaries
36 English couplets; Moscow VI349–351:124–163; Mohl V8–9:109–144; Ganjoor sh4:1–40; Khaleghi V480–482:101–137 including bracketed133 and actual apparatus. Bishutan’s intervention through mixed responses to royal gifts; source-only closing apostrophe allocated.
Moscow evidence
Running124–163 individually inspected. Departure157–159 and closing apostrophe163 are source-only relative to English.
Mohl evidence
Running109–144 individually inspected. Checked141→142 lacks three departure units;144→145 lacks closing apostrophe. This shorter sequence corresponds to English.
Ganjoor evidence
All40 units allocated:36 English correspondences plus source-only34–36 and40. Captivity inside Rudabeh’s lament is retained after narrated release.
Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence
Running101–137 inspected, with133 bracketed and ordered before134. Actual482n14 prints the two additional departure units;482n27 prints the closing apostrophe. Bracketed running text is not mislabeled apparatus.
Interpretive limits
English simplifies the difficult deficiency/rightness formulation in couplet3 and broadens some images. Rudabeh’s curse and Bishutan’s account of royal indebtedness remain attributed speech. No appendix evidence invoked.
Moscow printed p.349 · Moscow printed p.350 · Moscow printed p.351
Mohl printed p.8 · Mohl printed p.9
Khaleghi printed p.480 · Khaleghi printed p.481 · Khaleghi printed p.482
D1.4 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VI349:124 running text | V8:109 running text |
| 2 | VI349:125 running text | V8:110 running text |
| 3 | VI350:126 running text | V8:111 running text |
| 4 | VI350:127 running text | V8:112 running text |
| 5 | VI350:128 running text | V8:113 running text |
| 6 | VI350:129 running text | V8:114 running text |
| 7 | VI350:130 running text | V8:115 running text |
| 8 | VI350:131 running text | V8:116 running text |
| 9 | VI350:132 running text | V8:117 running text |
| 10 | VI350:133 running text | V8:118 running text |
| 11 | VI350:134 running text | V8:119 running text |
| 12 | VI350:135 running text | V8:120 running text |
| 13 | VI350:136 running text | V8:121 running text |
| 14 | VI350:137 running text | V8:122 running text |
| 15 | VI350:138 running text | V8:123 running text |
| 16 | VI350:139 running text | V8:124 running text |
| 17 | VI350:140 running text | V8:125 running text |
| 18 | VI350:141 running text | V8:126 running text |
| 19 | VI350:142 running text | V8:127 running text |
| 20 | VI350:143 running text | V8:128 running text |
| 21 | VI350:144 running text | V9:129 running text |
| 22 | VI350:145 running text | V9:130 running text |
| 23 | VI350:146 running text | V9:131 running text |
| 24 | VI351:147 running text | V9:132 running text |
| 25 | VI351:148 running text | V9:133 running text |
| 26 | VI351:149 running text | V9:134 running text |
| 27 | VI351:150 running text | V9:135 running text |
| 28 | VI351:151 running text | V9:136 running text |
| 29 | VI351:152 running text | V9:137 running text |
| 30 | VI351:153 running text | V9:138 running text |
| 31 | VI351:154 running text | V9:139 running text |
| 32 | VI351:155 running text | V9:140 running text |
| 33 | VI351:156 running text | V9:141 running text |
| 34 | VI351:160 running text | V9:142 running text |
| 35 | VI351:161 running text | V9:143 running text |
| 36 | VI351:162 running text | V9:144 running text |
New Naqqali