Shangul Gives His Daughter to Bahram
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6A victory that provokes fear
Moscow: VII427, running verse2155 | VII427, running verse2156 | VII427, running verse2157 | VII427, running verse2158 | VII427, running verse2159 | VII427, running verse2160; Mohl: VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:2 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:3 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:4 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:5 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:6 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:7 (not Mohl verse numbering); Ganjoor: Running body sh37:2 | Running body sh37:3 | Running body sh37:4 | Running body sh37:5 | Running body sh37:6 | Running body sh37:7; Khaleghi: VI579, running verse2163 | VI579, running verse2164 | VI580, running verse2165 | VI580, running verse2166 | VI580, running verse2167 | VI580, running verse2168
Moscow VII printed p.427 · Mohl VI printed p.23 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi VI printed p.579 · Khaleghi VI printed p.580
Shangul interprets the envoy’s prowess as a future danger to his own reputation and military standing. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all preserve the movement from failed persuasion to fear of what Bahram will report in Iran. The English makes that imagined report blunt: Hind will be said to have no horseman fit for battle. This works as a threatened loss of prestige, not an objective judgment about an entire people. The proposed killing comes from Shangul’s anxious calculation. Keeping his reasoning in direct speech allows readers to hear its self-serving character without requiring the narrator to approve the conclusion that a useful guest must therefore be destroyed.
7–12The counselor’s several objections
Moscow: VII427, running verse2161 | VII427, running verse2162 | VII428, running verse2163 | VII428, running verse2164 | VII428, running verse2165 | VII428, running verse2166; Mohl: VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:8 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:9 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:10 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:11 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:12 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:13 (not Mohl verse numbering); Ganjoor: Running body sh37:8 | Running body sh37:9 | Running body sh37:10 | Running body sh37:11 | Running body sh37:12 | Running body sh37:13; Khaleghi: VI580, running verse2169 | VI580, running verse2170 | VI580, running verse2171 | VI580, running verse2172 | VI580, running verse2173 | VI580, running verse2174
Moscow VII printed p.427 · Moscow VII printed p.428 · Mohl VI printed p.23 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi VI printed p.580
The sage opposes the murder through overlapping arguments: judgment, reputation, responsibility to people and the danger of retaliation. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi retain this sequence. The English presents each objection cleanly, giving the counselor a measured voice against the king’s private panic. Calling the killing senseless conveys the Persian condemnation of ignorance without turning the scene into a modern legal ruling about diplomatic immunity. The threat of Iran’s army is only one part of the response. Before force is mentioned, the sage has already denied that such a plan suits a thoughtful ruler. Practical survival and moral restraint are therefore allied rather than treated as competing motives.
13–18A debt of gratitude and a private summons
Moscow: VII428, running verse2167 | VII428, running verse2168 | VII428, running verse2169 | VII428, running verse2170 | VII428, running verse2171 | VII428, running verse2172; Mohl: VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:14 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:15 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:16 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:17 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:18 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:19 (not Mohl verse numbering); Ganjoor: Running body sh37:14 | Running body sh37:15 | Running body sh37:16 | Running body sh37:17 | Running body sh37:18 | Running body sh37:19; Khaleghi: VI580, running verse2175 | VI580, running verse2176 | VI580, running verse2177 | VI580, running verse2178 | VI581, running verse2179 | VI581, running verse2180
Moscow VII printed p.428 · Mohl VI printed p.23 · Mohl VI printed p.24 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi VI printed p.580 · Khaleghi VI printed p.581
The counselor asks Shangul to repay deliverance with life rather than death, a reversal supported by Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. The English makes that reciprocity especially audible through the repeated opposition of living and killing. The animal catalogue is not uniform: Mohl supports wolf, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi pair the dragon with karg. That difference continues the earlier episode’s textual history rather than introducing a new beast. Shangul’s subsequent silence is not a clear conversion to generosity. His private summons excludes ministers and advisers, preparing another means of keeping Bahram. The English’s secret plan correctly leaves the king’s controlling intention active beneath the apparent change of policy.
19–24Marriage as a condition of remaining
Moscow: VII428, running verse2173 | VII428, running verse2174 | VII428, running verse2175 | VII428, running verse2176 | VII428, running verse2177 | VII428, running verse2178; Mohl: VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:20 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:21 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:22 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:23 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:24 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:25 (not Mohl verse numbering); Ganjoor: Running body sh37:20 | Running body sh37:21 | Running body sh37:22 | Running body sh37:23 | Running body sh37:24 | Running body sh37:25; Khaleghi: VI581, running verse2181 | VI581, running verse2182 | VI581, running verse2183 | VI581, running verse2184 | VI581, running verse2185 | VI581, running verse2186
Moscow VII printed p.428 · Mohl VI printed p.24 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi VI printed p.581
Shangul’s offer combines a daughter, military command and a prohibition on departure. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi preserve the essential linkage: kinship is meant to keep the visitor in Hind. The English makes the coercive condition unmistakable through the explicit denial of leave to return home. Its account of Bahram’s thoughts then places throne, ancestry, shame and battle beside one another. This is a calculation made by a concealed king, not simply the hesitation of an unranked suitor. The English statement that he cannot hope to win a fight develops the Persian refusal or impossibility of conflict; it should be read as an explanatory interpretation of his constrained position.
25–30The lion inside the fox’s net
Moscow: VII428, running verse2178; VII428, running verse2179 | VII428, running verse2179; VII428, running verse2180 | VII428, running verse2180 | VII429, running verse2181 | VII429, running verse2182 | VII429, running verse2183; Mohl: VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:25 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:26 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:27 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:28 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:29 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:30 (not Mohl verse numbering); Ganjoor: Running body sh37:25, sh37:26 | Running body sh37:26, sh37:27 | Running body sh37:27 | Running body sh37:28 | Running body sh37:29 | Running body sh37:30; Khaleghi: VI581, running verse2186; VI581, running verse2187 | VI581, running verse2187; VI581, running verse2188 | VI581, running verse2188 | VI581, running verse2189 | VI582, running verse2190 | VI582, running verse2191
Moscow VII printed p.428 · Moscow VII printed p.429 · Mohl VI printed p.24 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi VI printed p.581 · Khaleghi VI printed p.582 · Moscow VII Appendix V, p458 · Moscow VII Appendix V, p459 · Khaleghi VI579 actual apparatus
The English repeats the absence of shame in accepting the marriage, then connects it to survival and the hope of seeing Iran again. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give these motives in a tighter sequence, ending with the lion caught by the fox. The repetition expands Bahram’s reasoning rather than supplying another independent Persian declaration. The animal image is particularly effective because bodily superiority has already been proved: the lion is trapped through policy, not defeated in combat. Bahram’s consent consequently remains strategic. The invitation to choose among daughters moves the scene toward ceremony, but it does not erase the restriction on departure that made the marriage useful to Shangul.
31–36Choosing Sapinud
Moscow: VII429, running verse2184 | VII429, running verse2185 | VII429, running verse2186 | VII429, running verse2187 | VII429, running verse2188; Mohl: VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:31 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:32 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:33 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:34 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:35 (not Mohl verse numbering); Ganjoor: Running body sh37:31 | Running body sh37:32 | Running body sh37:33 | Running body sh37:34 | Running body sh37:35; Khaleghi: VI582, running verse2192 | VI582, running verse2193 | VI582, running verse2194 | VI582, running verse2195 | VI582, running verse2196
Moscow VII printed p.429 · Mohl VI printed p.24 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi VI printed p.582
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi bring three daughters into the scene, identify Sapinud and describe her through spring, the cypress and the smokeless candle. The English preserves that succession of beauty images while giving the identification and character description separate couplets. Grace, modesty and wit create a more immediately individualized impression than the compressed Persian catalogue. Her suitability for royal fortune is the English narrator’s amplification, not a distinct statement of her political ambitions. At this point the action belongs to Shangul and Bahram: the father presents and gives, and Bahram chooses. Sapinud’s later decisive participation in the escape should not be projected backward as an explicitly narrated choice at this ceremony.
37–41A treasury placed in the bride’s hands
Moscow: VII429, running verse2189 | VII429, running verse2190 | VII429, running verse2191 | VII429, running verse2192 | VII429, running verse2193; Mohl: VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:36 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:37 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:38 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:39 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:40 (not Mohl verse numbering); Ganjoor: Running body sh37:36 | Running body sh37:37 | Running body sh37:38 | Running body sh37:39 | Running body sh37:40; Khaleghi: VI582, running verse2197 | VI582, running verse2198 | VI582, running verse2199 | VI582, running verse2200 | VI582, running verse2201
Moscow VII printed p.429 · Mohl VI printed p.24 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi VI printed p.582
The treasury key is a small but consequential detail preserved by Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. The English keeps the key’s recipient unmistakably the bride, distinguishing her wealth from the subsequent rewards distributed to Bahram’s companions. This prevents the gifts from becoming one undifferentiated transfer to the hero. The catalogue of money and aromatic substances gives the settlement material weight, while the decorated hall and invited notables turn a private arrangement into public recognition. The English’s generous treatment of each man as a friend adds interpersonal warmth to the giving. It does not establish that the court’s earlier suspicions have vanished, particularly when Shangul’s original reason for the marriage was to secure Bahram’s continued presence.
42–43Wine within crystal
Moscow: VII429, running verse2194 | VII429, running verse2195; Mohl: VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:41 (not Mohl verse numbering) | VI25, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:42 (not Mohl verse numbering); Ganjoor: Running body sh37:41 | Running body sh37:42; Khaleghi: VI582, running verse2202 | VI582, running verse2203
Moscow VII printed p.429 · Mohl VI printed p.24 · Mohl VI printed p.25 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi VI printed p.582
The week of celebration and the image of Sapinud with Bahram as wine in a crystal cup occur in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. The English gives the simile a complete closing couplet, making it the chapter’s final visual impression. Brightness, containment and the visible union of vessel and wine bring the newly married pair into a single image. The comparison need not be decoded into a fixed assignment of wife as wine and husband as cup beyond what the syntax permits. More securely, it offers harmony after coercion and calculation. That lyrical close is effective precisely because the reader still knows that the marriage has not settled Bahram’s desire to return to Iran.
Source record and limits
English
43 published English couplets, preserving wording, punctuation and order. Published D10.32: 43 English couplets. Declared Ganjoor reference: bahgoor global alignment units 2154–2194, with subdivision and couplet anchors retained separately.
Moscow
Moscow edition, volume VII (1968), printed pp.427–429. Individual English counterparts identify running verses, actual additional apparatus verses or checked local gaps. Reference anchors identify sense individually; shared units, actual apparatus additions and local gaps remain separate.
Mohl
Jules Mohl, printed pages VI23; VI24; VI25. This batch uses volume VI throughout, printed pp22–42. Each English unit is accounted for separately by sense, with its paired Persian anchor or independently transcribed additional passage. The alignment numbers are not Mohl’s printed verse numbers. Shared Persian units and additional running verses are distinguished in the individual accounts.
Ganjoor
Ferdowsi, Shahnameh, bahgoor digital running body. The displayed Persian ordinarily follows this reference, whose complete declared extent is accounted for. Additional printed counterparts use limited independent transcriptions. Multiple English rows can share one source verse; they are not represented as independent Persian additions.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VI, printed pp.579–582. Individual accounts distinguish running text, bracketed running text, actual apparatus verses and checked local gaps. Paired reference numbers are alignment aids, not a claim of identical edition numbering. Actual addition text, rather than an unprinted addition notice, supports the additional passages described here.
Consequential readings
English15: Wolf and dragon: MohlVI23 supports wolf; Moscow2169/Ganjoor/Khaleghi2177 use karg for the earlier beast. English25: Shared no-shame and survival reasoning expanded across English24–26; no separate additional source verse claimed. English35: Royal-fortune suitability interprets the compact description of Sapinud; her explicit consent is not narrated at this ceremony.
Evidence boundaries
A checked local gap means that the specified local sequence lacks a separate counterpart; it is not a claim of absence throughout every manuscript. Actual apparatus verses, lexical variants and running text have different evidentiary status. Moscow Appendix V pp458–459 and Khaleghi579n2 provide actual additional lion-man narrative at the D10.31/32 boundary. This is separate evidence without an English counterpart, not a substitute for the dragon’s running verses. Single-hemistich excerpts are intentionally limited and do not reconstruct missing text from English. Modern geographical or historical identifications remain outside the scope of this local collation.
Additional Persian units
All declared digital reference units are allocated. Extra printed evidence remains separately labeled.
Additional episode
Moscow Appendix V printed pp458–459 actually prints29 additional lion-man verses after verse2154; Khaleghi VI579 note2 prints related additional narrative. These are distinct from the main running sequence. No independent English counterpart is present. Mohl VI23–24 and Ganjoor’s corresponding local transition do not narrate this encounter. The appendix is evidence of a longer narrative, not support for an otherwise unprinted individual dragon-fight verse.
Moscow printed p.427 · Moscow printed p.428 · Moscow printed p.429
Khaleghi printed p.579 · Khaleghi printed p.580 · Khaleghi printed p.581 · Khaleghi printed p.582
Mohl VI printed p.23 · Mohl VI printed p.24 · Mohl VI printed p.25
Moscow VII Appendix V, p458 · Moscow VII Appendix V, p459 · Khaleghi VI579 apparatus
D10.32 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VII427, running verse2155 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:2 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 2 | VII427, running verse2156 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:3 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 3 | VII427, running verse2157 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:4 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 4 | VII427, running verse2158 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:5 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 5 | VII427, running verse2159 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:6 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 6 | VII427, running verse2160 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:7 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 7 | VII427, running verse2161 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:8 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 8 | VII427, running verse2162 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:9 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 9 | VII428, running verse2163 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:10 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 10 | VII428, running verse2164 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:11 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 11 | VII428, running verse2165 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:12 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 12 | VII428, running verse2166 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:13 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 13 | VII428, running verse2167 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:14 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 14 | VII428, running verse2168 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:15 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 15 | VII428, running verse2169 | VI23, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:16 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 16 | VII428, running verse2170 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:17 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 17 | VII428, running verse2171 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:18 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 18 | VII428, running verse2172 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:19 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 19 | VII428, running verse2173 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:20 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 20 | VII428, running verse2174 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:21 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 21 | VII428, running verse2175 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:22 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 22 | VII428, running verse2176 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:23 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 23 | VII428, running verse2177 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:24 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 24 | VII428, running verse2178 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:25 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 25 | VII428, running verse2178; VII428, running verse2179 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:25 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 26 | VII428, running verse2179; VII428, running verse2180 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:26 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 27 | VII428, running verse2180 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:27 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 28 | VII429, running verse2181 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:28 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 29 | VII429, running verse2182 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:29 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 30 | VII429, running verse2183 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:30 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 31 | VII429, running verse2184 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:31 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 32 | VII429, running verse2185 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:32 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 33 | VII429, running verse2186 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:33 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 34 | VII429, running verse2187 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:34 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 35 | VII429, running verse2187 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:34 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 36 | VII429, running verse2188 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:35 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 37 | VII429, running verse2189 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:36 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 38 | VII429, running verse2190 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:37 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 39 | VII429, running verse2191 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:38 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 40 | VII429, running verse2192 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:39 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 41 | VII429, running verse2193 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:40 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 42 | VII429, running verse2194 | VI24, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:41 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 43 | VII429, running verse2195 | VI25, running counterpart by sense; anchor sh37:42 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
New Naqqali