Sofrye Learns of Pirooz’s Death
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The choice of a guardian
Moscow — VIII18:206 running, VIII18:207 running, VIII19:208 running, VIII19:209 running, VIII19:209, VIII19:210 running · Mohl — VI55:23 running, VI55:24 running, VI55:25 running, VI55:26 running, VI55:26, VI55:27 running · Ganjoor — sh4:22 running, sh4:23 running, sh4:24 running, sh4:25 running, sh4:25, sh4:26 running · Khaleghi — VII33:22 running, VII33:23 running, VII33:24 running, VII33:25 running, VII33:25, VII33:26 running
Moscow VIII p.18 · Moscow VIII p.19 · Mohl VI p.55 · Ganjoor sh4:22 · Ganjoor sh4:23 · Ganjoor sh4:24 · Ganjoor sh4:25 · Ganjoor sh4:26 · Khaleghi VII p.33
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi turn backward from Balawsh’s accession to Pirooz’s departure for war, when a Pahlavan of judgment and weight was sought. The English expands the commissioning into separate lines about guarding the throne and befriending young Balawsh. Those expansions make the two sides of Sofrye’s authority easy to distinguish: loyalty to the institution and obligation to an individual who may have to occupy it. Shiraz and the commander’s stature belong to the four portraits. The English transfers some of the frontier governor’s stature into a new couplet, preparing the list of territories that will explain how the guardian can later recruit on such a scale.
7–12Mourning and the prospect of retaliation
Moscow — VIII19:210 running, VIII19:211 running, VIII19:212 running, VIII19:213 running, VIII19:214 running, VIII19:215 running · Mohl — VI55:27 running, VI55:28 running, VI55:29 running, VI55:30 running, VI55:31 running, VI55:32 running · Ganjoor — sh4:26 running, sh4:27 running, sh4:28 running, sh4:29 running, sh4:30 running, sh4:31 running · Khaleghi — VII33:26 running, VII33:27 running, VII33:28 running, VII33:29 running; lexical variant month at VII33 note 22, VII33:30 running, VII33:31 running
Moscow VIII p.19 · Mohl VI p.55 · Ganjoor sh4:26 · Ganjoor sh4:27 · Ganjoor sh4:28 · Ganjoor sh4:29 · Ganjoor sh4:30 · Ganjoor sh4:31 · Khaleghi VII p.33
The four witnesses connect the frontier command to news of Pirooz’s death and bring tears, torn garments and uncovered heads together. Mohl gives a month to this mourning, and Khaleghi records that reading in its apparatus. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s running words describe sitting in mourning without setting its length here. English follows Mohl and lets the month delay the change from grief to judgment. Its line about Pirooz spurning good counsel draws out the Persian description of a king without sound judgment or guidance. Sofrye’s question about the young shah then tests whether dynastic succession alone supplies the means for retaliation. The black crown makes the doubt visible.
13–18Mobilization beside a letter of counsel
Moscow — VIII19:216 running, VIII19:217 running, VIII19:218 running, VIII19:219 running, VIII19:220 running; lexical variant blood at VIII19 note 16, VIII19:221 running · Mohl — VI55:33 running, VI55:34 running, VI55:35 running, VI55:36 running, VI55:37 running, VI55:38 running · Ganjoor — sh4:32 running, sh4:33 running, sh4:34 running, sh4:35 running, sh4:36 running, sh4:37 running · Khaleghi — VII33:32 running, VII33:33 running, VII34:34 running, VII34:35 running, VII34:36 running, VII34:37 running
Moscow VIII p.19 · Mohl VI p.55 · Ganjoor sh4:32 · Ganjoor sh4:33 · Ganjoor sh4:34 · Ganjoor sh4:35 · Ganjoor sh4:36 · Ganjoor sh4:37 · Khaleghi VII p.33 · Khaleghi VII p.34
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi bring in the scattered army, the dust and a hundred thousand sword-bearers, followed by silver that puts the troops in good order. English adds the breadth of every land and gives payment a material consequence for soldiers in need. At the next turn, Moscow and Ganjoor give tears in the writer’s eyes, while Mohl and Khaleghi read blood. English preserves the pale face and visible grief with the former wording. The names of Jamshid, Kay Khosrow and Kay Qobad accompany that grief in all four, putting political examples inside a letter composed by a man who can command even while he mourns.
19–24What a mourner calls justice
Moscow — VIII19:222 running, VIII19:223 running; lexical variant pain at VIII19 note 20, VIII19:224 running, VIII19:225 running, VIII19:226 running, VIII20:227, VIII20:228 running · Mohl — VI55:39 running, VI55:40 running, VI55:41 running, VI55:42 running, VI56:43 running, VI56:44, VI56:45 running · Ganjoor — sh4:38 running, sh4:39 running, sh4:40 running, sh4:41 running, sh4:42 running, sh4:43, sh4:44 running · Khaleghi — VII34:38 running, VII34:39 running; lexical variant death at VII34 note 11, VII34:40 running, VII34:41 running, VII34:42 running, VII34:43, VII34:44 running
Moscow VIII p.19 · Moscow VIII p.20 · Mohl VI p.55 · Mohl VI p.56 · Ganjoor sh4:38 · Ganjoor sh4:39 · Ganjoor sh4:40 · Ganjoor sh4:41 · Ganjoor sh4:42 · Ganjoor sh4:43 · Ganjoor sh4:44 · Khaleghi VII p.34
Moscow and Ganjoor say that everyone tastes death. Mohl and Khaleghi use the suffering word, with the death reading visible in Khaleghi’s apparatus. English follows the explicit mortality language, emphasizing the advice to choose patience and lasting fame. The wind and breath line then gives an unstable human act two possible names, justice and oppression. English “wrongful death” locates that uncertainty within the immediate cause of grief and narrows the more general Persian contrast. All four next put the march under the ruler’s approval and make the sun and moon lament. The English keeps the change in scale from consolation to a grievance the heavens themselves seem to voice.
25–30The letter as an act of anger
Moscow — VIII20:228 running, VIII20:229 running, VIII20:230 running, VIII20:231 running, VIII20:232 running, VIII20:233 running · Mohl — VI56:45 running, VI56:46 running, VI56:47 running, VI56:48 running, VI56:49 running, VI56:50 running · Ganjoor — sh4:44 running, sh4:45 running, sh4:46 running, sh4:47 running, sh4:48 running, sh4:49 running · Khaleghi — VII34:44 running, VII34:45 running, VII34:46 running, VII34:47 running; lexical variant at VII34 note 37, VII35:48 running, VII35:49 running
Moscow VIII p.20 · Mohl VI p.56 · Ganjoor sh4:44 · Ganjoor sh4:45 · Ganjoor sh4:46 · Ganjoor sh4:47 · Ganjoor sh4:48 · Ganjoor sh4:49 · Khaleghi VII p.34 · Khaleghi VII p.35
The Persian accounts move Sofrye from Zabulistan toward Marv and give him a deliberately chosen, measured speaker before the scribe is called. The English develops that messenger’s potential to soften opponents, making the subsequent rebuke sharper. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor use div-making language for the fox, whereas the Khaleghi running reading makes it habitually troublesome. English draws on the supernatural comparison in the first three and retains the shirt itself as a mourner over the accused. In the source the scribe’s pen is summoned with the image of a resurrection. English shifts that force to work that can stir the heart, then lets the threats supply their own violence.
31–36Lineage, submission, and the terms of vengeance
Moscow — VIII20:234, VIII20:235 running, VIII20:236 running; lexical variant dog at VIII20 note 16, VIII20:237 running, VIII20:238 running; lexical variant color and scent at VIII20 note 23, VIII20:239, VIII20:240 running · Mohl — VI56:51, VI56:52 running, VI56:53 running, VI56:54 running, VI56:55 running, VI56:56, VI56:57 running · Ganjoor — sh4:50, sh4:51 running, sh4:52 running, sh4:53 running, sh4:54 running, sh4:55, sh4:56 running · Khaleghi — VII35:50, VII35:51 running, VII35:52 running; lexical variant dog at VII35 note 9, VII35:53 running, VII35:54 running, VII35:55, VII35:56 running
Moscow VIII p.20 · Mohl VI p.56 · Ganjoor sh4:50 · Ganjoor sh4:51 · Ganjoor sh4:52 · Ganjoor sh4:53 · Ganjoor sh4:54 · Ganjoor sh4:55 · Ganjoor sh4:56 · Khaleghi VII p.35
The four accounts connect a slain king, his descent from Bahram and the new feud, while the rebuke invokes what the recipient’s forebears owed this house. Mohl explicitly gives a fawning dog, a reading also visible in the Moscow and Khaleghi apparatus. English makes the insult visual through the lowered animal. In the threat to the Heytalians, its “sign nor trace” follows the color-and-scent idiom in Mohl and Khaleghi. Moscow and Ganjoor name the loss of crown and place in their running texts. English therefore broadens the menace even before the next lines threaten descendants, although its demand to recover prisoners and possessions remains explicit in the shared narrative.
37–42The messenger’s disputed homage
Moscow — VIII20:240, VIII20:241 running, VIII20:242 running, VIII21:244 running; lexical variant at VIII21 notes 1–4, VIII21:245 running, VIII21:246 running, VIII21:247, VIII21:248 running, VIII20:243 running · Mohl — VI56:57, VI56:58 running, VI56:59 running, VI56:60 running, VI56:61 running, VI56:62 running, VI56:63, VI56:64 running, VI56 checked local gap between vv.59 and 60 · Ganjoor — sh4:56, sh4:57 running, sh4:58 running, sh4:60 running, sh4:61 running, sh4:62 running, sh4:63, sh4:64 running, sh4:59 running · Khaleghi — VII35:56, VII35:57 running, VII35:58 running, VII35:60 running, VII35:61 running, VII36:62 running, VII36:63, VII36:64 running, VII35:59 running
Moscow VIII p.20 · Moscow VIII p.21 · Mohl VI p.56 · Ganjoor sh4:56 · Ganjoor sh4:57 · Ganjoor sh4:58 · Ganjoor sh4:60 · Ganjoor sh4:61 · Ganjoor sh4:62 · Ganjoor sh4:63 · Ganjoor sh4:64 · Ganjoor sh4:59 · Khaleghi VII p.35 · Khaleghi VII p.36
Mohl’s threat puts the end beneath the army’s feet, while the other running formulations place it beneath the speaker’s own step or beneath dust. English follows the military scale of Mohl while leaving the soul’s exact referent open. The messenger then changes the scene from threatened action to conduct at another ruler’s throne. Khaleghi says he withholds homage, in agreement with English. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor have him perform it even though he arrives disturbed. The English consequently makes contempt a public gesture before the letter is read. The positive reading allows an agitated envoy to observe the outward form of court behavior while carrying its opposite in writing.
43–48A scribe finds weapons in the words
Moscow — VIII21:249 running, VIII21:250 running, VIII21:251 running, VIII21:252, VIII21:253 running, VIII21:254, VIII21:255 running · Mohl — VI56:65 running, VI56:66 running, VI56:67 running, VI57:68, VI57:69 running, VI57:70, VI57:71 running · Ganjoor — sh4:65 running, sh4:66 running, sh4:67 running, sh4:68, sh4:69 running, sh4:70, sh4:71 running · Khaleghi — VII36:65 running, VII36:66 running, VII36:67 running, VII36:68, VII36:69 running, VII36:70, VII36:71 running
Moscow VIII p.21 · Mohl VI p.56 · Mohl VI p.57 · Ganjoor sh4:65 · Ganjoor sh4:66 · Ganjoor sh4:67 · Ganjoor sh4:68 · Ganjoor sh4:69 · Ganjoor sh4:70 · Ganjoor sh4:71 · Khaleghi VII p.36
In Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi the secretary reports what the letter is full of by naming weapons, and Khoshnavaz responds promptly. English turns this into a hoard and gives it both scimitar and sword where the Persian enumerates mace, blade and arrow. The conceit makes the written threat felt before the second letter can replace it with argument. The answer begins with fear of God and the turns of time, and invokes fidelity to inherited agreements. The English maintains the contrast between the first letter’s weapons and the reply’s claim of documentary authority. Khoshnavaz thereby speaks as an interested defender of the covenant whose existence both sides invoke.
49–54Khoshnavaz assigns responsibility
Moscow — VIII21:256 running, VIII21:257 running, VIII21:257, VIII21:258 running, VIII21:258 running, VIII21:259 running, VIII21:260 running · Mohl — VI57:72 running, VI57:73 running, VI57:73, VI57:74 running, VI57:74 running, VI57:75 running, VI57:76 running · Ganjoor — sh4:72 running, sh4:73 running, sh4:73, sh4:74 running, sh4:74 running, sh4:75 running, sh4:76 running · Khaleghi — VII37:72 running, VII37:73 running, VII37:73, VII37:74 running, VII37:74 running, VII37:75 running, VII37:76 running
Moscow VIII p.21 · Mohl VI p.57 · Ganjoor sh4:72 · Ganjoor sh4:73 · Ganjoor sh4:74 · Ganjoor sh4:75 · Ganjoor sh4:76 · Khaleghi VII p.37
All four sources give Khoshnavaz a rebuttal in which Pirooz pressed the battle, his star became disordered and the earth seemed to grasp his foot. English casts the opponents’ motives as revenge and self-protection. That wording follows the polarity of the speaker’s account and also recalls Sofrye’s revenge claim in the preceding letter. The sentence that the enemy did not desire Pirooz’s death remains a partisan assertion within the answer. English’s image of treading a treaty into dust brings out the following Persian image of casting truth underfoot and connects it to the earth that appeared to seize Pirooz during his attack.
55–60The response on the road
Moscow — VIII21:261 running, VIII22:262 running; lexical variant treasure at VIII22 note 2, VIII22:263 running, VIII22:264, VIII22:265 running, VIII22:266 running, VIII22:267 running · Mohl — VI57:77 running, VI57:78 running, VI57:79 running, VI57:80, VI57:81 running, VI57:82 running, VI57:83 running · Ganjoor — sh4:77 running, sh4:78 running, sh4:79 running, sh4:80, sh4:81 running, sh4:82 running, sh4:83 running · Khaleghi — VII37:77 running, VII37:78 running, VII37:79 running, VII37:80, VII37:81 running, VII37:82 running, VII38:83 running
Moscow VIII p.21 · Moscow VIII p.22 · Mohl VI p.57 · Ganjoor sh4:77 · Ganjoor sh4:78 · Ganjoor sh4:79 · Ganjoor sh4:80 · Ganjoor sh4:81 · Ganjoor sh4:82 · Ganjoor sh4:83 · Khaleghi VII p.37 · Khaleghi VII p.38
Moscow and Ganjoor’s challenge says war and warriors have suffered no diminution. Mohl and Khaleghi explicitly give treasure and fighting men, and Moscow’s actual note records the treasure variant. English turns those resources into a roll in which no man or coin is missing. The reader then hears the week of travel, Sofrye’s abuse and the horn and brazen instrument in quick succession, a progression present in all four. The English makes the road the army’s home in the closing couplet. That image preserves the source’s figurative transition from a formal challenge to a force in motion and makes a distant place such as Kashmihan part of sustained travel.
Source record and limits
English
60 published English couplets. Ganjoor reference: Yazdegard, subdivision 4, verses 22–83. The English preserves the published order, spelling and punctuation.
Moscow
Moscow critical edition, 1970, vol. VIII, printed pp. 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, running verses 206–267. Verse numbering continues from the preceding reign. Printed additions and alternative wording have their own locators. Shared references mark English expansion or redistribution of source clauses.
Mohl
Jules Mohl’s Persian text, vol. VI, printed pp. 55, 56, 57, Balawsh running verses 23–83. Verse numbering restarts at the opening of Balawsh’s reign. Its distinct sequence and readings are retained in the register.
Ganjoor
The running poem at 4:22–83 supplies the Persian column where a counterpart is present. Every verse in that range is represented. When Ganjoor has a local gap, the register identifies the printed Persian presented instead.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Djalal Khaleghi-Motlagh, vol. VII, printed pp. 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, running verses 22–83 for the applicable reign. Bracketed running text is identified separately from material printed below the line.
Consequential readings
English 10. Mohl gives a month in the mourning line. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi run the sitting in mourning without a number here. Khaleghi’s apparatus records a month. English 14. A hundred thousand sword-bearers appears in the four Persian running lines. The English addition “from every land” amplifies the sudden convergence. English 17. English tears match Moscow and Ganjoor’s water. Mohl and Khaleghi give blood in the eyes, recorded also in Moscow’s apparatus. English 20. The English chooses death with Moscow and Ganjoor. The two other running lines say pain or suffering, with death also recorded in the apparatus. English 28. Khaleghi’s running fox is habitually troublesome. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor use div-making wording that supplies the English comparison with the Divs. English 33. Mohl explicitly gives a fawning dog. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi have a flatterer in their running lines, with dog in the printed Moscow and Khaleghi alternatives. The Persian instrument is the kous. English 35. The English “neither sign nor trace” follows the force of Mohl and Khaleghi’s color-and-scent idiom. Moscow and Ganjoor threaten the Heytalian crown and place. English 39. Mohl puts ruin beneath the army’s feet. The other running forms give the earth or dust beneath the speaker’s step. The soul’s appeal remains, while its exact referent is qualified in the English. English 41. English withholds homage as Khaleghi does. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor say the envoy offered homage even though he came agitated. English 56. English preserves troops and treasure as in Mohl and Khaleghi. Moscow and Ganjoor’s running lines name war and warriors, with treasure in the actual Moscow lexical alternatives. English 58. English instruments specify the sounding of the bull-horn and brazen resonator, while the letter first makes Sofrye curse.
Evidence classes
Running text, bracketed running text, actual apparatus and checked local gaps refer to distinct kinds of evidence. A local gap is bounded by the specified passage. The readings above rely on the displayed running texts and actual wording in specified notes. No appendix evidence is invoked. Modern place-name equations and historical reconciliation remain outside the scope of these passages.
Source-only verses
S1. The rhetoric of vengeance pauses for a separate verse about what has been said at length. It runs in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Mohl moves from the sword threat directly to the next verse. There is no independent English couplet for this pause.
Mourning, vengeance and homage
Mohl’s month at VI55:30 and Khaleghi’s withholding of homage at VII36:62 provide different kinds of specificity in the English. The source-only reflection at sh4:59 does not carry its own English couplet. Exact modern identifications of the campaign’s named places fall outside these textual comparisons.
Moscow VIII p.18 · Moscow VIII p.19 · Moscow VIII p.20 · Moscow VIII p.21 · Moscow VIII p.22
Mohl VI p.55 · Mohl VI p.56 · Mohl VI p.57
Khaleghi VII p.33 · Khaleghi VII p.34 · Khaleghi VII p.35 · Khaleghi VII p.36 · Khaleghi VII p.37 · Khaleghi VII p.38
Selected printed readings
- Mohl VI55:30 running · ماهی نشستند با سوگ شاه
Mohl gives a month of mourning. - Khaleghi VII34:36 running · دو دیده پر از خون
Khaleghi gives blood where English has tears. - Khaleghi VII35:54 running · نمانم به هیتالیان رنگ و بوی
The threat uses color and scent for all trace of the people. - Khaleghi VII36:62 running · نبردش نماز
Khaleghi withholds homage. - Mohl VI56:62 running · ببردش نماز
Mohl’s envoy performs homage.
D11.4.2 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII18:206 running | VI55:23 running |
| 2 | VIII18:207 running | VI55:24 running |
| 3 | VIII18:207 running | VI55:24 running |
| 4 | VIII19:208 running | VI55:25 running |
| 5 | VIII19:209 running | VI55:26 running |
| 6 | VIII19:209, VIII19:210 running | VI55:26, VI55:27 running |
| 7 | VIII19:210 running | VI55:27 running |
| 8 | VIII19:211 running | VI55:28 running |
| 9 | VIII19:212 running | VI55:29 running |
| 10 | VIII19:213 running | VI55:30 running |
| 11 | VIII19:214 running | VI55:31 running |
| 12 | VIII19:215 running | VI55:32 running |
| 13 | VIII19:216 running | VI55:33 running |
| 14 | VIII19:217 running | VI55:34 running |
| 15 | VIII19:218 running | VI55:35 running |
| 16 | VIII19:219 running | VI55:36 running |
| 17 | VIII19:220 running; lexical variant blood at VIII19 note 16 | VI55:37 running |
| 18 | VIII19:221 running | VI55:38 running |
| 19 | VIII19:222 running | VI55:39 running |
| 20 | VIII19:223 running; lexical variant pain at VIII19 note 20 | VI55:40 running |
| 21 | VIII19:224 running | VI55:41 running |
| 22 | VIII19:225 running | VI55:42 running |
| 23 | VIII19:226 running | VI56:43 running |
| 24 | VIII20:227, VIII20:228 running | VI56:44, VI56:45 running |
| 25 | VIII20:228 running | VI56:45 running |
| 26 | VIII20:229 running | VI56:46 running |
| 27 | VIII20:230 running | VI56:47 running |
| 28 | VIII20:231 running | VI56:48 running |
| 29 | VIII20:232 running | VI56:49 running |
| 30 | VIII20:233 running | VI56:50 running |
| 31 | VIII20:234, VIII20:235 running | VI56:51, VI56:52 running |
| 32 | VIII20:234, VIII20:235 running | VI56:51, VI56:52 running |
| 33 | VIII20:236 running; lexical variant dog at VIII20 note 16 | VI56:53 running |
| 34 | VIII20:237 running | VI56:54 running |
| 35 | VIII20:238 running; lexical variant color and scent at VIII20 note 23 | VI56:55 running |
| 36 | VIII20:239, VIII20:240 running | VI56:56, VI56:57 running |
| 37 | VIII20:240, VIII20:241 running | VI56:57, VI56:58 running |
| 38 | VIII20:242 running | VI56:59 running |
| 39 | VIII21:244 running; lexical variant at VIII21 notes 1–4 | VI56:60 running |
| 40 | VIII21:245 running | VI56:61 running |
| 41 | VIII21:246 running | VI56:62 running |
| 42 | VIII21:247, VIII21:248 running | VI56:63, VI56:64 running |
| 43 | VIII21:249 running | VI56:65 running |
| 44 | VIII21:250 running | VI56:66 running |
| 45 | VIII21:251 running | VI56:67 running |
| 46 | VIII21:252, VIII21:253 running | VI57:68, VI57:69 running |
| 47 | VIII21:254, VIII21:255 running | VI57:70, VI57:71 running |
| 48 | VIII21:254, VIII21:255 running | VI57:70, VI57:71 running |
| 49 | VIII21:256 running | VI57:72 running |
| 50 | VIII21:257 running | VI57:73 running |
| 51 | VIII21:257, VIII21:258 running | VI57:73, VI57:74 running |
| 52 | VIII21:258 running | VI57:74 running |
| 53 | VIII21:259 running | VI57:75 running |
| 54 | VIII21:260 running | VI57:76 running |
| 55 | VIII21:261 running | VI57:77 running |
| 56 | VIII22:262 running; lexical variant treasure at VIII22 note 2 | VI57:78 running |
| 57 | VIII22:263 running | VI57:79 running |
| 58 | VIII22:264, VIII22:265 running | VI57:80, VI57:81 running |
| 59 | VIII22:266 running | VI57:82 running |
| 60 | VIII22:267 running | VI57:83 running |
New Naqqali