Anooshirvan Orders Nushzad’s Capture
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Authority from the ends of creation
Moscow — VIII99:787 running, VIII99:788 running, VIII99:789 running, VIII99:790 running, VIII99:790 running; VIII99:791 running, VIII99:791 running; VIII99:792 running · Mohl — VI114:796 running, VI114:797 running, VI114:798 running, VI114:799 running, VI114:799 running; VI114:800 running, VI114:800 running; VI114:801 running · Ganjoor — sh21:9 running, sh21:10 running, sh21:11 running, sh21:12 running, sh21:12, sh21:13 running, sh21:13, sh21:14 running · Khaleghi — VII150:800 running, VII150:801 running, VII150:802 running, VII150:803 running, VII150:803 running; VII150:804 running, VII150:804 running; VII151:805 running
Moscow VIII p.99 · Mohl VI p.114 · Ganjoor sh21:9 · Ganjoor sh21:10 · Ganjoor sh21:11 · Ganjoor sh21:12 · Ganjoor sh21:13 · Ganjoor sh21:14 · Khaleghi VII p.150 · Khaleghi VII p.151
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi show a deeply troubled writer starting with the Creator of earth, time, heavenly bodies and royal glory. English keeps the trouble visible through his frown before giving force to the ascending and descending comparisons. The reach from stubble to elephant and ant to Nile is shared, although wording differs in the continuation involving stone and anvil. English repeats the ant and leaves the harder mineral image aside. It makes the divine command apply to souls and denies that earthly hands can wrest authority from God. This opening helps define the separation the king makes later between defending his particular reign and fearing the source of any reign’s authority.
7–12When even the prince must reckon with death
Moscow — VIII99:793 running, VIII99:794 running, VIII99:795 running, VIII99:796 running, VIII99:797 running, VIII99:798 running · Mohl — VI114:802 running, VI114:803 running, VI114:804 running, VI114:805 running, VI114:806 running, VI114:807 running · Ganjoor — sh21:15 running, sh21:16 running, sh21:17 running, sh21:18 running, sh21:19 running, sh21:20 running · Khaleghi — VII151:806 running, VII151:807 running, VII151:808 running, VII151:809 running, VII151:810 running, VII151:811 running
Moscow VIII p.99 · Mohl VI p.114 · Ganjoor sh21:15 · Ganjoor sh21:16 · Ganjoor sh21:17 · Ganjoor sh21:18 · Ganjoor sh21:19 · Ganjoor sh21:20 · Khaleghi VII p.151
The four accounts make the king name the offending letter and the escaped prisoners before reflecting that people are born to die. English keeps the move from a single rebellion to a rule governing every creature. It gives Anooshirvan and Nushzad a compact sequence as the first and last named examples, where the Persian can also express the range from king to son. The gnat and ant bring small creatures alongside larger ones under the claw and beak of death. English keeps the personifying attack but lets the elephant carry the scale of the Persian elephant and rhinoceros. Earth’s buried secrets then prepare the more social inventory of mortality in the next verses.
13–18Buried rank and a son’s death
Moscow — VIII100:799 running, VIII100:800 running, VIII100:801 running, VIII100 checked local gap between vv.801 and 802, VIII100:802 running, VIII100:803 running · Mohl — VI115:808 running, VI115:809 running, VI115:810 running, VI115:811 running, VI115:812 running, VI115:813 running · Ganjoor — sh21:21 running, sh21:22 running, sh21:23 running, Checked local gap after sh21:23, sh21:24 running, sh21:25 running · Khaleghi — VII151:812 running, VII151:813 running, VII151:814 running, VII151 checked local gap between vv.814 and 815, VII151:815 running, VII152:816 running
Moscow VIII p.100 · Mohl VI p.115 · Ganjoor sh21:21 · Ganjoor sh21:22 · Ganjoor sh21:23 · Ganjoor sh21:24 · Ganjoor sh21:25 · Khaleghi VII p.151 · Khaleghi VII p.152
The four texts fill earth with crowns, the blood of riders, wise men and beautiful faces, then ask what headgear can withstand death’s arrow. English extends the leading warriors’ appearance through rings and lets folds of earth hold the dead much as the Persian uses clothing as earth’s figure. Mohl follows the death’s arrow line with a distinct verse about a son’s death. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi move to the people attending the prince and eager for the Shah’s death. English follows Mohl and makes the subject of parental grief explicit. By separating that thought from the supporters’ conduct, the translation shows sympathy that the political argument will later put under strain.
19–24A prospective heir acts as if there were no rival
Moscow — VIII100:804 running, VIII100:805 running, VIII100:806 running, VIII100 checked local gap between vv.806 and 807, VIII100:807 running, VIII100:808 running · Mohl — VI115:814 running, VI115:815 running, VI115:816 running, VI115:817 running, VI115:818 running, VI115:819 running · Ganjoor — sh21:26 running, sh21:27 running, sh21:28 running, Checked local gap after sh21:28, sh21:29 running, sh21:30 running · Khaleghi — VII152:817 running, VII152:818 running, VII152:819 running, VII152 checked local gap between vv.819 and 820, VII152:820 running, VII152:821 running
Moscow VIII p.100 · Mohl VI p.115 · Ganjoor sh21:26 · Ganjoor sh21:27 · Ganjoor sh21:28 · Ganjoor sh21:29 · Ganjoor sh21:30 · Khaleghi VII p.152
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi condemn delight at just kings’ deaths and describe the prince’s withdrawal from judgment in association with a div. The king then says the prince would be the rightful ornament of rule if the throne actually fell vacant. Mohl runs, before this, Nushzad’s boast that there would be no ruler like him while he wore the crown. The other three lack a separate statement there. English follows Mohl and gives the pretension a direct quoted voice. It makes the difference between prospective succession and present usurpation clearer because the prince imagines universal kingship at the very moment his own royal standing is being put at risk.
25–30What the Shah counts as negligible
Moscow — VIII100:809 running, VIII100:810 running, VIII100:812 running, VIII100:811 running, VIII100:813 running, VIII100:814 running · Mohl — VI115:820 running, VI115:821 running, VI115:822 running, VI115:823 running, VI115:824 running, VI115:825 running · Ganjoor — sh21:31 running, sh21:32 running, sh21:34 running, sh21:33 running, sh21:35 running, sh21:36 running · Khaleghi — VII152:822 running, VII152:823 running, VII152:824 running, VII152:825 running, VII152:826 running, VII152:827 running
Moscow VIII p.100 · Mohl VI p.115 · Ganjoor sh21:31 · Ganjoor sh21:32 · Ganjoor sh21:34 · Ganjoor sh21:33 · Ganjoor sh21:35 · Ganjoor sh21:36 · Khaleghi VII p.152
The editions distinguish the religion he condemns, the prince’s followers, and wealth the prince has squandered. Mohl and Khaleghi put the matter of money before the allies. Moscow and Ganjoor place it after the allies are brought into view. English follows the former order, dispensing with material loss before turning to opponents. Its wording of rest and content gives an internal stance to the Persian’s refusal to give the loss weight. The next statement asks the recipient to keep his own heart undisturbed about their behavior. The shift from a ruler diminishing a threat to an officer being told what to feel sets up the distinction in the next passage between human enemies and divine judgment.
31–37The drop from the father’s body
Moscow — VIII100:815 running, VIII100:816 running, VIII101:817 running, VIII101:818 running, VIII101:819 running, VIII101:820 running, VIII101:821 running; VIII101 checked local gap after v.821 · Mohl — VI115:826 running, VI115:827 running, VI115:828 running, VI115:829 running, VI115:830 running, VI115:831 running, VI115:832 running; VI116:833 running · Ganjoor — sh21:37 running, sh21:38 running, sh21:39 running, sh21:40 running, sh21:41 running, sh21:42 running, sh21:43 running · Khaleghi — VII152:828 running, VII153:829 running, VII153:830 running, VII153:831 running, VII153:832 running, VII153:833 running, VII153:834 running; VII153 note 19 actual apparatus after v.834
Moscow VIII p.100 · Moscow VIII p.101 · Mohl VI p.115 · Mohl VI p.116 · Ganjoor sh21:37 · Ganjoor sh21:38 · Ganjoor sh21:39 · Ganjoor sh21:40 · Ganjoor sh21:41 · Ganjoor sh21:42 · Ganjoor sh21:43 · Khaleghi VII p.152 · Khaleghi VII p.153
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi attribute victory and diadem to God, and express the impossibility of giving adequate praise for the gift. The poem then describes a drop of water from the father’s back taking rest elsewhere and awakening as a foe. “Seed” in English states the bodily implication before the drop has become an active antagonist. The king can therefore fear that harm originated with him while professing confidence if divine anger is absent. Mohl adds a running claim of the throne’s support after that profession. Khaleghi prints it as a variant. English concentrates the couplet on the Shah’s fear of God and his indifference to earthly danger.
38–44Roman affiliation and the cost of a curse
Moscow — VIII101:822 running, VIII101:823 running, VIII101:824 running, VIII101:825 running, VIII101 checked local gap after v.825, VIII101:826 running, VIII101:827 running · Mohl — VI116:834 running, VI116:835 running, VI116:836 running, VI116:837 running, VI116:838 running, VI116:839 running, VI116:840 running · Ganjoor — sh21:44 running, sh21:45 running, sh21:46 running, sh21:47 running, Checked local gap after sh21:47, sh21:48 running, sh21:49 running · Khaleghi — VII153:835 running, VII153:836 running, VII153:837 running, VII153:838 running, VII153 note 29 actual apparatus after v.838, VII153:839 running, VII153:840 running
Moscow VIII p.101 · Mohl VI p.116 · Ganjoor sh21:44 · Ganjoor sh21:45 · Ganjoor sh21:46 · Ganjoor sh21:47 · Ganjoor sh21:48 · Ganjoor sh21:49 · Khaleghi VII p.153
The four running texts link Caesar’s reply to troubled water and describe him and the prince as speaking with one voice and professing one faith. English lets that association make the distant Roman seem present. Mohl then states separately that the worthy son retains his father’s religion and declines vengeance. Khaleghi prints this verse below the text, and Moscow and Ganjoor leave it out at the locus. English follows Mohl and then keeps the ban on cursing the prince found in the surrounding Persian. The imperative reaches beyond courtesy. To curse the son is to curse the royal body he comes from, a principle English makes visible in the blood written on his face.
45–50Capture first and force under condition
Moscow — VIII101:828 running, VIII101:829 running, VIII101:830 running, VIII101:831 running, VIII101:832 running, VIII101:833 running · Mohl — VI116:841 running, VI116:842 running, VI116:843 running, VI116:844 running, VI116:845 running, VI116:846 running · Ganjoor — sh22:1 running, sh22:2 running, sh22:3 running, sh22:4 running, sh22:5 running, sh22:6 running · Khaleghi — VII153:841 running, VII154:842 running, VII154:843 running, VII154:844 running, VII154:845 running, VII154:846 running
Moscow VIII p.101 · Mohl VI p.116 · Ganjoor sh22:1 · Ganjoor sh22:2 · Ganjoor sh22:3 · Ganjoor sh22:4 · Ganjoor sh22:5 · Ganjoor sh22:6 · Khaleghi VII p.153 · Khaleghi VII p.154
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi move from raising an army to restraint in engagement and a stated preference for taking the prince alive. Repentance is the point of capture. English makes killing the last resort, which the subsequent conditional threat then tests. The water that nourished the cypress should be spared the work of rinsing dirt. Read beside the picture of the father as the source of a drop, the water points toward the treatment owed to a son. English retains the elevated tree as a figure for the prince’s claim to dignity. It then moves the pillow of ease and the gorz into the failing conditions for that protection.
51–56The limits of the prince’s protection
Moscow — VIII101:834 running, VIII102:835 running, VIII102:836 running, VIII102:837 running, VIII102:838 running · Mohl — VI116:847 running, VI116:848 running, VI116:849 running, VI116:850 running, VI116:851 running · Ganjoor — sh22:7 running, sh22:8 running, sh22:9 running, sh22:10 running, sh22:11 running · Khaleghi — VII154:847 running, VII154:848 running, VII154:849 running, VII154:850 running, VII154:851 running
Moscow VIII p.101 · Moscow VIII p.102 · Mohl VI p.116 · Ganjoor sh22:7 · Ganjoor sh22:8 · Ganjoor sh22:9 · Ganjoor sh22:10 · Ganjoor sh22:11 · Khaleghi VII p.154
The four running versions measure contempt against the great rank of the man displaying it. English says the desire itself is consuming before it turns to the consequence of shedding blood in battle. The Shah can countenance killing if the prince brings that result on himself. The next verse joins Caesar’s creed to the turning away from his own side’s diadem. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor follow with the abased man chosen for kingship. Khaleghi makes him selected to lead an army. English develops the celestial selection into an account of chosen ruin. The contrast between birth and course of action thereby remains visible even where the office associated with that birth varies.
57–62A servant’s saying and the unstable sky
Moscow — VIII102:839 running, VIII102:840 running, VIII102:841 running, VIII102:842 running, VIII102:843 running, VIII102:844 running · Mohl — VI116:852 running, VI116:853 running, VI116:854 running, VI116:855 running, VI116:856 running, VI116:857 running · Ganjoor — sh22:12 running, sh22:13 running, sh22:14 running, sh22:15 running, sh22:16 running, sh22:17 running · Khaleghi — VII154:852 running, VII154:853 running, VII155:854 running, VII155:855 running, VII155:856 running, VII155:857 running
Moscow VIII p.102 · Mohl VI p.116 · Ganjoor sh22:12 · Ganjoor sh22:13 · Ganjoor sh22:14 · Ganjoor sh22:15 · Ganjoor sh22:16 · Ganjoor sh22:17 · Khaleghi VII p.154 · Khaleghi VII p.155
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi name Mehr-e-Nush and describe his wool clothing. English presents him as a thoughtful servant and gives him a clear direct utterance against a son who welcomes his father’s death. The letter then shifts from that personal breach to darkness and light, fire and water, ease and hardship. English reads the turning sky’s change from kernel to skin or shell as another warning about reliance on temporary favor. Its formulation brings men into that image before the Persian’s following verse about being raised high. The hues and scents then become fickle gifts, drawing the king’s immediate trouble toward a more general judgment of success.
63–68How the letter speaks of the Christian troops
Moscow — VIII102:845 running, VIII102:846 running, VIII102:847 running, VIII102:848 running, VIII102:849 running, VIII102:850 running · Mohl — VI117:858 running, VI117:859 running, VI117:860 running, VI117:861 running, VI117:862 running, VI117:863 running · Ganjoor — sh22:18 running, sh22:19 running, sh22:20 running, sh22:21 running, sh22:22 running, sh22:23 running · Khaleghi — VII155:858 running, VII155:859 running, VII155:860 running, VII155:861 running, VII155:862 running, VII155:863 running
Moscow VIII p.102 · Mohl VI p.117 · Ganjoor sh22:18 · Ganjoor sh22:19 · Ganjoor sh22:20 · Ganjoor sh22:21 · Ganjoor sh22:22 · Ganjoor sh22:23 · Khaleghi VII p.155
The four witnesses compare the rebel force to wind and play before turning to Christians who have gone against the king on account of their faith. English makes them people who rose for their faith and then has the Shah interpret that decision by their own standards. The Persian connects sharp speech to another person’s distress. English makes the implicit injunction explicit and gives speech the power to wound. The next line puts disregard of Christ’s judgment beside the Cross. English reads that relation as enmity toward the Cross. The argument belongs to the letter’s persuasion. Later in the narrative, Pirooz and the prince will give different descriptions of the same religious divide.
69–74What may be said and done to a captive prince
Moscow — VIII102:851 running, VIII103:852 running, VIII103:853 running, VIII103 checked local gap after v.853, VIII103:854 running · Mohl — VI117:864 running, VI117:865 running, VI117:866 running, VI117:867 running, VI117:868 running, VI117:869 running · Ganjoor — sh22:24 running, sh22:25 running, sh22:26 running, Checked local gap after sh22:26, sh22:27 running · Khaleghi — VII155:864 running, VII156:865 running, VII156:866 running, VII156:866/1 bracketed running, VII156:866/2 bracketed running, VII156:867 running
Moscow VIII p.102 · Moscow VIII p.103 · Mohl VI p.117 · Ganjoor sh22:24 · Ganjoor sh22:25 · Ganjoor sh22:26 · Ganjoor sh22:27 · Khaleghi VII p.155 · Khaleghi VII p.156
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi distinguish the rest of the army and then forbid repeating the king’s disparaging words in front of his son. Mohl continues with separate lines about grief and injury. Khaleghi has two bracketed counterparts, with the turn toward right at the beginning and even a tear in the prince’s clothing explicitly contemplated. Moscow and Ganjoor go directly to the household’s veiled women and their feared reaction. English keeps the paired prohibitions against reproach and harm, with a flame for the life grief might extinguish. Placing the household’s danger after them makes the costs of public punishment extend to family members outside the battle.
75–80A palace under guard and a separate punishment
Moscow — VIII103:855 running, VIII103:856 running, VIII103:857 running, VIII103:858 running, VIII103:859 running, VIII103:860 running · Mohl — VI117:870 running, VI117:871 running, VI117:872 running, VI117:873 running, VI117:874 running, VI117:875 running · Ganjoor — sh22:28 running, sh22:29 running, sh22:30 running, sh22:31 running, sh22:32 running, sh22:33 running · Khaleghi — VII156:868 running, VII156:869 running, VII156:870 running, VII156:871 running, VII156:872 running, VII156:873 running
Moscow VIII p.103 · Mohl VI p.117 · Ganjoor sh22:28 · Ganjoor sh22:29 · Ganjoor sh22:30 · Ganjoor sh22:31 · Ganjoor sh22:32 · Ganjoor sh22:33 · Khaleghi VII p.156
All four witnesses provide a place of detention, access to the treasury, women, food and furnishings, and then turn to Iranian border officers who have joined the revolt. English makes the confinement relatively comfortable. Its final explanation of those comforts interprets a repeated prohibition on scarcity as a statement about what the prince is fit for. The treatment of the Iranian officials differs sharply in the king’s order. The English retains the named office of marzban and the physical threat of cutting through the waist. Their role as men who held an obligation to Iran helps explain the rapid transition between a provision for a son’s household and a severe demand against officials.
81–86Forgotten favors and a verse about former service
Moscow — VIII103:861 running, VIII103:862 running, VIII103:863 running, VIII103 note 26 actual apparatus after v.863, VIII103:864 running, VIII103:865 running · Mohl — VI117:876 running, VI117:877 running, VI117:878 running, VI117:879 running, VI117:880 running, VI117:881 running · Ganjoor — sh22:34 running, sh22:35 running, sh22:36 running, Checked local gap after sh22:36, sh22:37 running, sh22:38 running · Khaleghi — VII156:874 running, VII156:875 running, VII157:876 running, VII157:877 running, VII157:878 running, VII157:879 running
Moscow VIII p.103 · Mohl VI p.117 · Ganjoor sh22:34 · Ganjoor sh22:35 · Ganjoor sh22:36 · Ganjoor sh22:37 · Ganjoor sh22:38 · Khaleghi VII p.156 · Khaleghi VII p.157
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi pair the enemies of kingship with the nahang and describe the secret hostility of opponents as Ahriman’s work. Nushzad serves as the example of goodness forgotten. The English then explicitly calls his opponents former watchmen. Moscow’s actual apparatus has that word. The comparable Mohl and Khaleghi running lines call them pious men or ungrateful people, respectively, and connect them to fear of the Shah’s penalty. Ganjoor lacks the separate line. The English keeps the station by which they might once have been identified and then turns from previous service to the now intolerable act of insulting a member of the royal house.
87–90Protecting the son’s standing in public
Moscow — VIII103:866 running, VIII103:867 running, VIII103:868 running, VIII104:869 running · Mohl — VI117:882 running, VI118:883 running, VI118:884 running, VI118:885 running · Ganjoor — sh22:39 running, sh22:40 running, sh22:41 running, sh22:42 running · Khaleghi — VII157:880 running, VII157:881 running, VII157:882 running, VII157:883 running
Moscow VIII p.103 · Moscow VIII p.104 · Mohl VI p.117 · Mohl VI p.118 · Ganjoor sh22:39 · Ganjoor sh22:40 · Ganjoor sh22:41 · Ganjoor sh22:42 · Khaleghi VII p.157
The four editions return to the father’s body as the source of the son’s rank, even after the narrator of the letter has condemned his conduct. English makes the source visible as a resemblance in the face. The king names his own heart a witness, giving private recognition force in the instruction to his officer. The next pair of verses links speech and wrongful treatment with a punishment before an assembly. English preserves the severe image of a branded tongue and sets it squarely in public. The contrast with silence around Nushzad is pointed. People outside the royal household can be made an example precisely because the household itself is to be protected from hostile speech.
91–94What the seal carries to Ram Barzin
Moscow — VIII104:870 running, VIII104:871 running, VIII104:872 running, VIII104:873 running · Mohl — VI118:886 running, VI118:887 running, VI118:888 running, VI118:889 running · Ganjoor — sh22:43 running, sh22:44 running, sh22:45 running, sh23:1 running · Khaleghi — VII157:884 running, VII157:885 running, VII157:886 running, VII157:887 running
Moscow VIII p.104 · Mohl VI p.118 · Ganjoor sh22:43 · Ganjoor sh22:44 · Ganjoor sh22:45 · Ganjoor sh23:1 · Khaleghi VII p.157
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi end the letter by condemning anyone who waits for the ruler’s weakness so that he can act with malice. The glory and crown at the end put the justice claimed in the first verses of the letter back into political terms. English gives the contemplated weakening its own moment in “the coming hour” before naming opposition to the state. The Persian ends the letter, puts its seal on it, and sends a messenger away. English anticipates the courier’s destination from the first lines of the next action. That overlap makes the dispatch an immediate bridge to an officer charged with converting qualifications into action.
Source record and limits
English
94 published English couplets. Ganjoor passages: Anooshirvan §21: 9–49, Anooshirvan §22: 1–45, Anooshirvan §23: 1–1. The English text follows the published verse and chapter divisions.
Moscow
The 1970 Moscow edition, volume VIII, printed pages 99–104. The source register identifies the individual running verses and any printed apparatus cited.
Mohl
Jules Mohl’s Persian text, volume VI, printed pages 114–118. The running sequence includes some lines here that Moscow and Khaleghi give in their apparatus.
Ganjoor
Anooshirvan §21: 9–49, Anooshirvan §22: 1–45, Anooshirvan §23: 1–1. The Persian column gives the corresponding running verses and identifies where Mohl supplies an independent couplet for a local Ganjoor gap.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Djalal Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VII, printed pages 150–157. Square brackets mark verses retained in the main text with explicit editorial reservation. Printed additions have their own locators.
One letter, several levels of judgment
The letter defines the king’s authority through gratitude to God. It treats Nushzad’s person, his household, the Iranian frontier officials and the people who malign the prince through different commands. Mohl has separate passages on the danger of grief and harm to Nushzad. Khaleghi has two bracketed counterparts before the appeal about the veiled women. Moscow actually prints the watchmen verse that appears with different wording in Mohl and Khaleghi.
Consequential readings
English 16. The reference to a son’s death runs in Mohl alone at this locus. The other three move from the point of death’s arrow to the faction around Nushzad. English 22. Mohl gives a separate first-person pretension to rule without rival. The other running texts move from the instability of the decision to the standing Nushzad has destroyed. English 27. Mohl and Khaleghi put the wasted wealth before reckoning with those who followed the prince. Moscow and Ganjoor put it after. English 35. The Persian’s drop of water from the father’s back acquires its full sense in the next line when it wakes up as an enemy. English makes seed explicit. English 37. Mohl adds a further running assertion of the throne’s support. Khaleghi actually prints the corresponding manuscript line after the verse, while Moscow and Ganjoor move straight on to the associates. English 42. Mohl runs an explicit statement that the best son takes his father’s faith and does not seek vengeance. Khaleghi prints that same point in its notes. The other running versions give the adjacent condemnation of weak judgment. English 47. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi state that capture is better than killing, in the hope of repentance. The later permission to kill depends on the prince’s conduct. English 55. The debased noble is chosen to kingship in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor. Khaleghi gives leadership of an army. English develops the implied humiliation. English 61. The sky’s changeable treatment is expressed with kernel and skin or shell. English separates the alternation from the following verse about being raised to high position. English 67. The prohibition on wounding through speech is the English’s contextual interpretation. The Persian wording connects sharp speech with causing distress. The next verse declares that the rebels disregard Christ’s judgment. English 72. Mohl runs a plea against adding to the son’s grief, with a corresponding bracketed verse in Khaleghi. Moscow and Ganjoor move directly to the royal household. English 73. Mohl runs an order against harm to his person and damage in battle; Khaleghi gives a bracketed comparison specifying a tear in his shirt. Moscow and Ganjoor have a checked local gap. English 74. The reaction of the veiled women is pictured as self-destructive. The published second half gives the feared consequence for the household. English 84. Moscow prints the separate watchmen verse in actual apparatus. Mohl runs a corresponding line describing pious men, and Khaleghi runs a variant calling them ungrateful. Fear of punishment is shared across those three forms. English 90. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all put the branding in front of an assembly. The public form of the sanction is integral to the order.
Limits of the evidence
Running text, bracketed running text, actual printed apparatus and checked local gaps indicate distinct kinds of support. Local gaps concern the specified passage. No appendix reading is invoked. The geographical and institutional terms describe the poem’s account.
Source-only verses
Moscow VIII p.99 · Moscow VIII p.100 · Moscow VIII p.101 · Moscow VIII p.102 · Moscow VIII p.103 · Moscow VIII p.104
Mohl VI p.114 · Mohl VI p.115 · Mohl VI p.116 · Mohl VI p.117 · Mohl VI p.118
Khaleghi VII p.150 · Khaleghi VII p.151 · Khaleghi VII p.152 · Khaleghi VII p.153 · Khaleghi VII p.154 · Khaleghi VII p.155 · Khaleghi VII p.156 · Khaleghi VII p.157
Selected printed readings
- Mohl VI115:811 running · بر مرگ پسر شاد نبود بسی
Mohl adds the judgment on a son’s death. - Khaleghi VII153:832 running · گر از پشت من رفت یک قطره آب
The king imagines a drop of water from his own body. - Khaleghi VII153 note 29 actual apparatus · پسر آن بود به که دین پدر
The apparatus prints part of the father and son maxim. - Moscow VIII101:830 running · گرفتنش بهتر ز کشتن بود
The king explicitly prefers capture to killing. - Khaleghi VII156:866/2 bracketed running · نباید که آزار یابد تنش
Khaleghi brackets the order to spare his person. - Moscow VIII103 note 26 actual apparatus · همه پیش ازین پاسبانان بدند
The watchmen reading is actually printed in Moscow. - Moscow VIII104:869 running · همه داغ کن بر سر انجمن
The royal letter orders a penalty in front of the assembly.
D13.18 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII99:787 running | VI114:796 running |
| 2 | VIII99:788 running | VI114:797 running |
| 3 | VIII99:789 running | VI114:798 running |
| 4 | VIII99:790 running | VI114:799 running |
| 5 | VIII99:790 running; VIII99:791 running | VI114:799 running; VI114:800 running |
| 6 | VIII99:791 running; VIII99:792 running | VI114:800 running; VI114:801 running |
| 7 | VIII99:793 running | VI114:802 running |
| 8 | VIII99:794 running | VI114:803 running |
| 9 | VIII99:795 running | VI114:804 running |
| 10 | VIII99:796 running | VI114:805 running |
| 11 | VIII99:797 running | VI114:806 running |
| 12 | VIII99:798 running | VI114:807 running |
| 13 | VIII100:799 running | VI115:808 running |
| 14 | VIII100:800 running | VI115:809 running |
| 15 | VIII100:801 running | VI115:810 running |
| 16 | VIII100 checked local gap between vv.801 and 802 | VI115:811 running |
| 17 | VIII100:802 running | VI115:812 running |
| 18 | VIII100:803 running | VI115:813 running |
| 19 | VIII100:804 running | VI115:814 running |
| 20 | VIII100:805 running | VI115:815 running |
| 21 | VIII100:806 running | VI115:816 running |
| 22 | VIII100 checked local gap between vv.806 and 807 | VI115:817 running |
| 23 | VIII100:807 running | VI115:818 running |
| 24 | VIII100:808 running | VI115:819 running |
| 25 | VIII100:809 running | VI115:820 running |
| 26 | VIII100:810 running | VI115:821 running |
| 27 | VIII100:812 running | VI115:822 running |
| 28 | VIII100:811 running | VI115:823 running |
| 29 | VIII100:813 running | VI115:824 running |
| 30 | VIII100:814 running | VI115:825 running |
| 31 | VIII100:815 running | VI115:826 running |
| 32 | VIII100:816 running | VI115:827 running |
| 33 | VIII101:817 running | VI115:828 running |
| 34 | VIII101:818 running | VI115:829 running |
| 35 | VIII101:819 running | VI115:830 running |
| 36 | VIII101:820 running | VI115:831 running |
| 37 | VIII101:821 running; VIII101 checked local gap after v.821 | VI115:832 running; VI116:833 running · VI p.116 |
| 38 | VIII101:822 running | VI116:834 running |
| 39 | VIII101:823 running | VI116:835 running |
| 40 | VIII101:824 running | VI116:836 running |
| 41 | VIII101:825 running | VI116:837 running |
| 42 | VIII101 checked local gap after v.825 | VI116:838 running |
| 43 | VIII101:826 running | VI116:839 running |
| 44 | VIII101:827 running | VI116:840 running |
| 45 | VIII101:828 running | VI116:841 running |
| 46 | VIII101:829 running | VI116:842 running |
| 47 | VIII101:830 running | VI116:843 running |
| 48 | VIII101:831 running | VI116:844 running |
| 49 | VIII101:832 running | VI116:845 running |
| 50 | VIII101:833 running | VI116:846 running |
| 51 | VIII101:834 running | VI116:847 running |
| 52 | VIII102:835 running | VI116:848 running |
| 53 | VIII102:836 running | VI116:849 running |
| 54 | VIII102:837 running | VI116:850 running |
| 55 | VIII102:838 running | VI116:851 running |
| 56 | VIII102:838 running | VI116:851 running |
| 57 | VIII102:839 running | VI116:852 running |
| 58 | VIII102:840 running | VI116:853 running |
| 59 | VIII102:841 running | VI116:854 running |
| 60 | VIII102:842 running | VI116:855 running |
| 61 | VIII102:843 running | VI116:856 running |
| 62 | VIII102:844 running | VI116:857 running |
| 63 | VIII102:845 running | VI117:858 running |
| 64 | VIII102:846 running | VI117:859 running |
| 65 | VIII102:847 running | VI117:860 running |
| 66 | VIII102:848 running | VI117:861 running |
| 67 | VIII102:849 running | VI117:862 running |
| 68 | VIII102:850 running | VI117:863 running |
| 69 | VIII102:851 running | VI117:864 running |
| 70 | VIII103:852 running | VI117:865 running |
| 71 | VIII103:853 running | VI117:866 running |
| 72 | VIII103 checked local gap after v.853 | VI117:867 running |
| 73 | VIII103 checked local gap after v.853 | VI117:868 running |
| 74 | VIII103:854 running | VI117:869 running |
| 75 | VIII103:855 running | VI117:870 running |
| 76 | VIII103:856 running | VI117:871 running |
| 77 | VIII103:857 running | VI117:872 running |
| 78 | VIII103:858 running | VI117:873 running |
| 79 | VIII103:859 running | VI117:874 running |
| 80 | VIII103:860 running | VI117:875 running |
| 81 | VIII103:861 running | VI117:876 running |
| 82 | VIII103:862 running | VI117:877 running |
| 83 | VIII103:863 running | VI117:878 running |
| 84 | VIII103 note 26 actual apparatus after v.863 | VI117:879 running |
| 85 | VIII103:864 running | VI117:880 running |
| 86 | VIII103:865 running | VI117:881 running |
| 87 | VIII103:866 running | VI117:882 running |
| 88 | VIII103:867 running | VI118:883 running |
| 89 | VIII103:868 running | VI118:884 running |
| 90 | VIII104:869 running | VI118:885 running |
| 91 | VIII104:870 running | VI118:886 running |
| 92 | VIII104:871 running | VI118:887 running |
| 93 | VIII104:872 running | VI118:888 running |
| 94 | VIII104:873 running | VI118:889 running |
New Naqqali