The Death of Nushzad
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Orders turn into an army on the road
Moscow — VIII104:874 running; VIII104:875 running, VIII104:876 running, VIII104:877 running, VIII104:878 running, VIII104:879 running, VIII104:880 running · Mohl — VI118:890 running; VI118:891 running, VI118:892 running, VI118:893 running, VI118:894 running, VI118:895 running, VI118:896 running · Ganjoor — sh23:2, sh23:3 running, sh23:4 running, sh23:5 running, sh23:6 running, sh23:7 running, sh23:8 running · Khaleghi — VII158:888 running; VII158:889 running, VII158:890 running, VII158:891 running, VII158:892 running, VII158:893 running, VII158:894 running
Moscow VIII p.104 · Mohl VI p.118 · Ganjoor sh23:2 · Ganjoor sh23:3 · Ganjoor sh23:4 · Ganjoor sh23:5 · Ganjoor sh23:6 · Ganjoor sh23:7 · Ganjoor sh23:8 · Khaleghi VII p.158
The four witnesses have the envoy explain the command before giving the letter, then return to his speech after the old man reads it. English combines the handover with its purpose, preserving both information and written authority. The cockcrow and gate instruments put the soldiers in motion out of Madain. Across the sources, Nushzad receives news, gathers troops and pays them. English keeps the payment within his answer to the opposing march. That detail makes the force visibly an organized army operating in parallel to Ram Barzin’s. The ensuing convergence therefore involves officials and trained ranks on both sides, an important setting for Pirooz’s attempt to stop the fight by speech.
7–12Shammas and the armies in motion
Moscow — VIII104:881 running, VIII104:882 running, VIII104:883 running, VIII104:884 running, VIII104:885 running, VIII105:886 running · Mohl — VI118:897 running, VI118:898 running, VI118:899 running, VI118:900 running, VI118:901 running, VI118:902 running · Ganjoor — sh23:9 running, sh23:10 running, sh23:11 running, sh23:12 running, sh24:1 running, sh24:2 running · Khaleghi — VII158:895 running, VII158:896 running, VII158:897 running, VII158:898 running, VII159:899 running, VII159:900 running
Moscow VIII p.104 · Moscow VIII p.105 · Mohl VI p.118 · Ganjoor sh23:9 · Ganjoor sh23:10 · Ganjoor sh23:11 · Ganjoor sh23:12 · Ganjoor sh24:1 · Ganjoor sh24:2 · Khaleghi VII p.158 · Khaleghi VII p.159
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi put senior Christian figures with Roman dignitaries under Shammas. English gives the commands and participants concrete roles, and it preserves the image of hands washed in blood by making them blood-stained veterans. On Nushzad’s side the army moves like a sea stirred by wind. The English’s storm develops the violence of the same movement. Ram Barzin sees the dust and orders the ranks formed to a brass instrument. English uses the familiar karnay and then keeps the press of armored horses and swinging maces. The musical answer from one army to the other gives the greater cloud of dust a cause the reader can follow.
13–18A warrior’s voice breaks through the dust
Moscow — VIII105:887 running, VIII105:888 running, VIII105:889 running, VIII105:890 running, VIII105:891 running, VIII105:892 running · Mohl — VI118:903 running, VI118:904 running, VI119:905 running, VI119:906 running, VI119:907 running, VI119:908 running · Ganjoor — sh24:3 running, sh24:4 running, sh24:5 running, sh24:6 running, sh24:7 running, sh24:8 running · Khaleghi — VII159:901 running, VII159:902 running, VII159:903 running, VII159:904 running, VII159:905 running, VII159:906 running
Moscow VIII p.105 · Mohl VI p.118 · Mohl VI p.119 · Ganjoor sh24:3 · Ganjoor sh24:4 · Ganjoor sh24:5 · Ganjoor sh24:6 · Ganjoor sh24:7 · Ganjoor sh24:8 · Khaleghi VII p.159
The four witnesses let the march split the heart of flint and hide the sun, then bring the prince into view in a Roman helmet. English’s earth made to boil holds on to the extraordinary picture while adding hoofbeats as its physical explanation. A warrior emerges to question who turned the prince from right. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi call him Pirooz Shir, with the form of his name differing in Mohl. English keeps Pirooz and identifies him as old, a status made unmistakable by the prince’s answer and the narrator soon afterward. The focus on a single person speaking is especially clear against a landscape full of undifferentiated horses, dust and armor.
19–24The first speaker’s indictment
Moscow — VIII105 checked local gap after v.892, VIII105:893 running, VIII105:894 running, VIII105:895 running, VIII105:896 running, VIII105:897 running · Mohl — VI119:909 running, VI119:910 running, VI119:911 running, VI119:912 running, VI119:913 running, VI119:914 running · Ganjoor — Checked local gap after sh24:8, sh24:9 running, sh24:10 running, sh24:11 running, sh24:12 running, sh24:13 running · Khaleghi — VII159 checked local gap after v.906, VII159:907 running, VII159:908 running, VII159:909 running, VII159:910 running, VII159:911 running
Moscow VIII p.105 · Mohl VI p.119 · Ganjoor sh24:8 · Ganjoor sh24:9 · Ganjoor sh24:10 · Ganjoor sh24:11 · Ganjoor sh24:12 · Ganjoor sh24:13 · Khaleghi VII p.159
Mohl gives Pirooz a direct warning against fighting the king’s army before the dispute about ancestral faith. The other three running texts go from the opening question to Kioumars, Hushang and Tahmuras. English follows Mohl and makes potential regret the consequence to fear. It then preserves the hostile account of Christ’s death and divine favor as Pirooz’s accusation. The same man invokes Anooshirvan’s success against Caesar, so the speech presses both communal tradition and the military odds on his hearer. The rhetoric is the speaker’s. Nushzad’s later claim that divine glory never left Christ expressly disputes the premise underlying this warning.
25–30The father’s lifetime defines the offense
Moscow — VIII105:898 running, VIII105:899 running, VIII105:900 running, VIII105:901 running, VIII105 note 11 actual apparatus after v.898 · Mohl — VI119:915 running, VI119:916 running, VI119:917 running, VI119:920 running, VI119:918 running, VI119:919 running · Ganjoor — sh24:14 running, sh24:15 running, sh24:16 running, sh24:17 running, Checked local gap after sh24:14 · Khaleghi — VII159:912 running, VII160:913 running, VII160:914 running, VII160:915 running, VII159 note 26 actual apparatus after v.912
Moscow VIII p.105 · Mohl VI p.119 · Ganjoor sh24:14 · Ganjoor sh24:15 · Ganjoor sh24:16 · Ganjoor sh24:17 · Khaleghi VII p.159 · Khaleghi VII p.160
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi pair Nushzad’s impressive body and princely marks with a lack of wisdom. English makes the charge one of neglecting his father’s claim while still enjoying the bearing of an heir. The distinction between succession after death and an attempt against a living father runs in Mohl. Moscow and Khaleghi print additions giving substantially the same point, while Ganjoor moves past this independent argument. English gives the condition two couplets and lets hell make the last threat explicit. That degree of condemnation is an English development. The sharply drawn question about when succession is permissible has clear support in the fuller tradition.
31–36Praise that ends in a demand to dismount
Moscow — VIII105:902 running, VIII105:903 running, VIII106:904 running, VIII106:905 running, VIII106:906 running, VIII106:907 running · Mohl — VI119:921 running, VI119:922 running, VI119:923 running, VI119:924 running, VI119:925 running, VI119:926 running · Ganjoor — sh24:18 running, sh24:19 running, sh24:20 running, sh24:21 running, sh24:22 running, sh24:23 running · Khaleghi — VII160:916 running, VII160:917 running, VII160:918 running, VII160:919 running, VII160:920 running, VII160:921 running
Moscow VIII p.105 · Moscow VIII p.106 · Mohl VI p.119 · Ganjoor sh24:18 · Ganjoor sh24:19 · Ganjoor sh24:20 · Ganjoor sh24:21 · Ganjoor sh24:22 · Ganjoor sh24:23 · Khaleghi VII p.160
The four readings deny that the prince can stand against Kisra even if he has the force of an elephant or a lion. English chooses the lion and then draws on bridle hand, stirrup, body and weapon to show why the young man might appear capable of the impossible. The Persian invokes the painted likenesses of kings and a painter of China. English’s prince beyond what any painter could achieve maintains the impossibly high comparison. It then asks him to discard mace and Roman headgear. Because those were just the objects that made him splendid in battle, the transition from admiration to surrender gives the order a cost the reader can understand.
37–41What Pirooz expects a father to feel
Moscow — VIII106:908 running, VIII106:909 running, VIII106:910 running, VIII106:911 running, VIII106:912 running · Mohl — VI119:927 running, VI119:928 running, VI119:929 running, VI120:930 running, VI120:931 running · Ganjoor — sh24:24 running, sh24:25 running, sh24:26 running, sh24:27 running, sh24:28 running · Khaleghi — VII160:922 running, VII160:923 running, VII160:924 running, VII161:925 running, VII161:926 running
Moscow VIII p.106 · Mohl VI p.119 · Mohl VI p.120 · Ganjoor sh24:24 · Ganjoor sh24:25 · Ganjoor sh24:26 · Ganjoor sh24:27 · Ganjoor sh24:28 · Khaleghi VII p.160 · Khaleghi VII p.161
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi use a cold wind, dark dust and a grieving sun to imagine what harm to the prince would do. English makes the Shah’s sorrow central and moves from that prospect to hostility as seed. The seed language links Pirooz’s advice with the narrator’s early comparison of a son to a plant. The Persian says strife ill becomes a king and anticipates an occasion when the prince will remember Pirooz’s counsel. English gives the other counselors’ advice the force of speaking in vain. The subsequent wound makes remembrance part of the action, so the old man’s prediction becomes an element the story can test.
42–48The son claims his mother’s faith in his own voice
Moscow — VIII106:913 running, VIII106:914 running, VIII106:915 running, VIII106:916 running, VIII106:917 running, VIII106:918 running, VIII106:919 running · Mohl — VI120:932 running, VI120:933 running, VI120:934 running, VI120:935 running, VI120:936 running, VI120:937 running, VI120:938 running · Ganjoor — sh25:1 running, sh25:2 running, sh25:3 running, sh25:4 running, sh25:5 running, sh25:6 running, sh25:7 running · Khaleghi — VII161:927 running, VII161:928 running, VII161:929 running, VII161:930 running, VII161:931 running, VII161:932 running, VII161:933 running
Moscow VIII p.106 · Mohl VI p.120 · Ganjoor sh25:1 · Ganjoor sh25:2 · Ganjoor sh25:3 · Ganjoor sh25:4 · Ganjoor sh25:5 · Ganjoor sh25:6 · Ganjoor sh25:7 · Khaleghi VII p.161
All four give Nushzad’s refusal of quarter and his turn toward his mother’s religion. English begins with disdain, making the speech an answer to Pirooz’s pointed command. The prince then says divine farr did not leave Christ at his death. English renders the persistence of favor visibly as light and retains the departure to God from the dark earth. The poison and remedy figure at the end belongs to the four running texts, with tiryāk as the antidote. English’s nush-daru carries the idea in a word already familiar from the epic. It also lets the young man’s claim that he accepts death issue directly into the arrows he sends.
49–54The prince makes his last advance
Moscow — VIII106:920 running, VIII106:921 running, VIII106:922 running, VIII107:923 running, VIII107:924 running, VIII107:924 running; VIII107:925 running · Mohl — VI120:939 running, VI120:940 running, VI120:941 running, VI120:942 running, VI120:943 running, VI120:943 running; VI120:944 running · Ganjoor — sh25:8 running, sh25:9 running, sh25:10 running, sh25:11 running, sh25:12 running, sh25:12, sh25:13 running · Khaleghi — VII161:934 running, VII161:935 running, VII161:936 running, VII161:937 running, VII162:938 running, VII162:938 running; VII162:939 running
Moscow VIII p.106 · Moscow VIII p.107 · Mohl VI p.120 · Ganjoor sh25:8 · Ganjoor sh25:9 · Ganjoor sh25:10 · Ganjoor sh25:11 · Ganjoor sh25:12 · Ganjoor sh25:13 · Khaleghi VII p.161 · Khaleghi VII p.162
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi turn the answer into arrows, let the drums and horns sound, and compare the commander’s advance to Azargashasp. English takes the commander to be Nushzad, an identification supported by his advance on the Iranian left in the next verse. The earlier visit to the sacred fire makes the simile unusually pointed for a claimant who has left his father’s faith. His success is brief, but the sources name men of standing among those he kills. English uses “lions of the field” to portray their strength and makes Ram Barzin’s change of feeling lead directly to a new order. The prince’s momentum draws a counterstroke.
55–60Arrows, injury and remembered counsel
Moscow — VIII107:925 running, VIII107:926 running, VIII107:927 running, VIII107:928 running · Mohl — VI120:944 running, VI120:945 running, VI120:946 running, VI120:947 running · Ganjoor — sh25:13 running, sh26:1 running, sh26:2 running, sh26:3 running · Khaleghi — VII162:939 running, VII162:939 running; VII162 note 3 actual apparatus around v.939, VII162:940 running, VII162:941 running, VII162:942 running
Moscow VIII p.107 · Mohl VI p.120 · Ganjoor sh25:13 · Ganjoor sh26:1 · Ganjoor sh26:2 · Ganjoor sh26:3 · Khaleghi VII p.162
The four editions liken the arrows to spring hail and then show Nushzad wounded remembering what Pirooz said. English expands the battle between those actions with noise and casualties on both sides. Khaleghi prints additional language on both forces in the apparatus, whose wording warrants a partial comparison. The exact English casualty statement remains unverified. The prince reaches the center of his troops in great pain, and the English makes the arrow and his altered face specify the nature of the wound. He then turns the short Persian judgment on fighting one’s father into two English couplets. Repetition underlines that he now speaks the lesson once directed at him.
61–66The bishop receives a message for the mother
Moscow — VIII107:929 running, VIII107:930 running, VIII107:931 running, VIII107:932 running, VIII107:933 running · Mohl — VI120:948 running, VI120:949 running, VI120:950 running, VI120:951 running, VI120:952 running · Ganjoor — sh26:4 running, sh26:5 running, sh26:6 running, sh26:7 running, sh26:8 running · Khaleghi — VII162:943 running, VII162:944 running, VII162:945 running, VII162:946 running, VII162:947 running
Moscow VIII p.107 · Mohl VI p.120 · Ganjoor sh26:4 · Ganjoor sh26:5 · Ganjoor sh26:6 · Ganjoor sh26:7 · Ganjoor sh26:8 · Khaleghi VII p.162
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi make the wounded prince call a bishop and express what is in his heart. English gives that second action an independent couplet, creating time to hear the change from battle to a private instruction. An immediate request to send a rider connects the two people who remain able to act for him. The Persian says his day of injustice and justice has ended. English’s rolled scroll makes that ending a material event without reversing either term. His plea that his mother should withhold grief appeals to the law of an impermanent world. It begins a voice of consolation while he is himself still in pain.
67–73Choosing a grave before the lips close
Moscow — VIII107:934 running, VIII107:935 running, VIII107:936 running, VIII107:937 running, VIII107:938 running, VIII107:939 running · Mohl — VI121:953 running, VI121:954 running, VI121:955 running, VI121:956 running, VI121:957 running, VI121:958 running · Ganjoor — sh26:9 running, sh26:10 running, sh26:11 running, sh26:12 running, sh26:13 running, sh27:1 running · Khaleghi — VII163:948 running, VII163:949 running, VII163:950 running, VII163:951 running, VII163:952 running, VII163:953 running
Moscow VIII p.107 · Mohl VI p.121 · Ganjoor sh26:9 · Ganjoor sh26:10 · Ganjoor sh26:11 · Ganjoor sh26:12 · Ganjoor sh26:13 · Ganjoor sh27:1 · Khaleghi VII p.163
The four witnesses let Nushzad distinguish the ordinary approach of death from the pain of knowing his father remains displeased. English makes the father’s anger his chief concern. The next verse opposes a dakhmeh and royal throne to a grave made in Christian fashion. English gives the choice a separate couplet, adding words spoken for the dead where Persian specifies the kind of grave. The rejection of camphor, musk and perfume belongs to the running texts. Retaining those objects shows a particular set of honors being refused. The closed lips then end both the long speech and the chapter’s last chance for the prince to make his wishes known directly.
74–79The battlefield hears of the death
Moscow — VIII108:940 running, VIII108:941 running, VIII108:942 running, VIII108:943 running, VIII108:943 running; VIII108:944 running, VIII108:944 running; VIII108:945 running · Mohl — VI121:959 running, VI121:960 running, VI121:961 running, VI121:962 running, VI121:962 running; VI121:963 running, VI121:963 running; VI121:964 running · Ganjoor — sh27:2 running, sh27:3 running, sh27:4 running, sh27:5 running, sh27:5, sh27:6 running, sh27:6, sh27:7 running · Khaleghi — VII163:954 running, VII163:955 running, VII163:956 running, VII163:957 running, VII163:957 running; VII163:958 running, VII163:958 running; VII164:959 running
Moscow VIII p.108 · Mohl VI p.121 · Ganjoor sh27:2 · Ganjoor sh27:3 · Ganjoor sh27:4 · Ganjoor sh27:5 · Ganjoor sh27:6 · Ganjoor sh27:7 · Khaleghi VII p.163 · Khaleghi VII p.164
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi disperse the prince’s force and describe a champion hurrying to the bedside, the soldiers ceasing to kill or take spoil, and the bishop supporting the dead man’s head. English resolves the rushing figure as Ram Barzin, whose grief the sources name explicitly just afterward. It also supplies the visible posture of kneeling, making the relation between the living officer and dead prince immediate. The stillness about spoil and cheering creates space for lament in the English. As sound returns in wails, the text gives Ram Barzin the task of asking what was said. That is the condition for carrying out the interrupted royal family’s wishes.
80–85The bishop repeats the conditions for burial
Moscow — VIII108:945 running, VIII108:946 running, VIII108:947 running, VIII108:948 running, VIII108:949 running, VIII108:950 running · Mohl — VI121:964 running, VI121:965 running, VI121:966 running, VI121:967 running, VI121:968 running, VI121:969 running · Ganjoor — sh27:7 running, sh27:8 running, sh27:9 running, sh27:10 running, sh27:11 running, sh27:12 running · Khaleghi — VII164:959 running, VII164:960 running, VII164:961 running, VII164:962 running, VII164:963 running, VII164:964 running
Moscow VIII p.108 · Mohl VI p.121 · Ganjoor sh27:7 · Ganjoor sh27:8 · Ganjoor sh27:9 · Ganjoor sh27:10 · Ganjoor sh27:11 · Ganjoor sh27:12 · Khaleghi VII p.164
The bishop’s account in all four specifies the mother as the only person who should see the exposed form, rejects perfumes and royal display, and puts a shroud and Christian grave in her hands. English describes the head as exposed to the sky, narrowing the broader Persian reference to his form or body while preparing the scene of the mother’s arrival. The crown and Roman brocade return as signs of the rank he no longer wants displayed. The English’s final couplet preserves the bishop’s joining of the soul with Christ and distinguishes the prince’s death from death on the Cross. It makes the bishop’s consolation the final judgment heard beside the body.
86–90A whole community bears the coffin
Moscow — VIII108:951 running, VIII108:952 running, VIII108:953 running, VIII109:954 running, VIII109:955 running · Mohl — VI121:970 running, VI121:971 running, VI121:972 running, VI121:973 running, VI121:974 running · Ganjoor — sh27:13 running, sh27:14 running, sh27:15 running, sh27:16 running, sh27:17 running · Khaleghi — VII164:965 running, VII165:966 running, VII165:967 running, VII165:968 running, VII165:969 running
Moscow VIII p.108 · Moscow VIII p.109 · Mohl VI p.121 · Ganjoor sh27:13 · Ganjoor sh27:14 · Ganjoor sh27:15 · Ganjoor sh27:16 · Ganjoor sh27:17 · Khaleghi VII p.164 · Khaleghi VII p.165
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi describe the Christian community disfiguring faces in grief, then extend the gathering to men and women of the town. English adds the mourners gathered round the bier before giving the youth’s body and affection for him their own couplet. The four texts give the procession three farsangs and say the coffin was borne by hand. English’s “hand by hand” gives this a possible rhythm of shared labor. As soon as his mother hears, her crown comes to earth and she is out from behind the curtain. Those movements make private grief visible within the collective ceremony, even before the new screen is raised.
91–96Dust, wind and the rose that carries poison
Moscow — VIII109:956 running, VIII109:957 running, VIII109:958 running, VIII109:959 running, VIII109:960 running, VIII109:961 running · Mohl — VI121:975 running, VI121:976 running, VI121:977 running, VI122:978 running, VI122:979 running, VI122:980 running · Ganjoor — sh27:18 running, sh27:19 running, sh27:20 running, sh27:21 running, sh28:1 running, sh28:2 running · Khaleghi — VII165:970 running, VII165:971 running, VII165:972 running, VII165:973 running, VII165:974 running, VII165:975 running
Moscow VIII p.109 · Mohl VI p.121 · Mohl VI p.122 · Ganjoor sh27:18 · Ganjoor sh27:19 · Ganjoor sh27:20 · Ganjoor sh27:21 · Ganjoor sh28:1 · Ganjoor sh28:2 · Khaleghi VII p.165
The four witnesses bring the grieving mother into a gathering, raise a shelter for her, give the mourners dust on their heads, and return the body to earth. English explains the enclosure by shielding her from the crowd. It then retains wind as the prince’s origin but interprets his final passage more explicitly as death. Shared grief in Gund-e-Shapur precedes the narrator’s charge against greed. The image of a beautiful flower concealing poison looks back to the earlier rose and thorn without repeating their immediate family judgment. English’s imperative to seek escape lets the response be a practical choice after the impossibility of prolonging life has been shown.
97–101Counsel, pleasure and the verse on Ali
Moscow — VIII109:962 running, VIII109:963 running, VIII109:964 running, VIII109:965 running, VIII109:966 bracketed running · Mohl — VI122:981 running, VI122:982 running, VI122:983 running, VI122:984 running, VI122:985 running · Ganjoor — sh28:3 running, sh28:4 running, sh28:5 running, sh28:6 running, sh28:7 running · Khaleghi — VII165:976 running, VII166:977 running, VII166:978 running, VII166:979 running, VII166:980 bracketed running
Moscow VIII p.109 · Mohl VI p.122 · Ganjoor sh28:3 · Ganjoor sh28:4 · Ganjoor sh28:5 · Ganjoor sh28:6 · Ganjoor sh28:7 · Khaleghi VII p.165 · Khaleghi VII p.166
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi put fidelity and right conduct next to counsel against excessive grief, then make room for pleasure without drunkenness. English renders the red or yellow wine image as simply a cup, making permission to drink carry the thought. Its words about receiving wisdom also turn the admonition about speaking idly into a responsibility of the listener. The Ali verse runs in Mohl and Ganjoor and is bracketed in Moscow and Khaleghi. English keeps intercession explicit on Judgment Day. Coming after the Christian prince’s burial, the invocation belongs to the narrator’s address rather than to the last words of any character.
102–105From the monarch in the story to Mahmud
Moscow — VIII109 note 20 actual apparatus after v.966, VIII109 checked local gap after v.966 and before the Bozorgmehr transition · Mohl — VI122:986 running, VI122:987 running, VI122:988 running, VI122:989 running · Ganjoor — Checked local gap after sh28:7 · Khaleghi — VII166 note 17 actual apparatus after v.980
Moscow VIII p.109 · Mohl VI p.122 · Ganjoor sh28:7 · Khaleghi VII p.166
The last four English couplets follow Mohl’s running sequence and Khaleghi’s actually printed apparatus. Moscow’s apparatus has the sovereign blessing, while Ganjoor ends the numbered section with Ali. English preserves the change in addressee by passing from a general prayer for the world’s king to Mahmud named directly. The crown that props up heaven here gives the living patron a cosmic image comparable to the earlier language of royalty. Then the narrator asks for personal benefit when his verses are heard. Keeping that request separate from the fate of Nushzad shows how the poet’s hope of material and remembered acknowledgment has entered the telling at its edge.
Source record and limits
English
105 published English couplets. Ganjoor passages: Anooshirvan §23: 2–12, Anooshirvan §24: 1–28, Anooshirvan §25: 1–13, Anooshirvan §26: 1–13, Anooshirvan §27: 1–21, Anooshirvan §28: 1–7. The English text follows the published verse and chapter divisions.
Moscow
The 1970 Moscow edition, volume VIII, printed pages 104–109. The source register identifies the individual running verses and any printed apparatus cited.
Mohl
Jules Mohl’s Persian text, volume VI, printed pages 118–122. The running sequence includes some lines here that Moscow and Khaleghi give in their apparatus.
Ganjoor
Anooshirvan §23: 2–12, Anooshirvan §24: 1–28, Anooshirvan §25: 1–13, Anooshirvan §26: 1–13, Anooshirvan §27: 1–21, Anooshirvan §28: 1–7. The Persian column gives the corresponding running verses and identifies where Mohl supplies an independent couplet for a local Ganjoor gap.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Djalal Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VII, printed pages 158–166. Square brackets mark verses retained in the main text with explicit editorial reservation. Printed additions have their own locators.
Dying speech, witnesses and the closing panegyric
Pirooz’s indictment of Nushzad’s faith is answered by the prince before the fighting. The prince speaks to the bishop about his burial, and the bishop recounts his instructions after his death. A separate coda includes the verse on Ali, bracketed in Moscow and Khaleghi, followed by Mohl’s praise of the ruler and of Mahmud. Khaleghi actually prints these further verses below the running text. Moscow prints the blessing of the sovereign.
Consequential readings
English 17. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi run Pirooz Shir. Mohl names him Pirooz Shamr in its running line. English names him Pirooz and makes his age explicit, as the scene later does. English 19. Mohl gives a separate warning to avoid battle with the Shah’s troops, lest the prince come to regret it. The other running texts pass from his opening question to the charge of abandoning ancestral religion. English 21. This religious denunciation is Pirooz’s in the four texts. Nushzad gives a contrary account of Christ later in the same scene. English 29. Mohl runs the question about a living father and a son seeking the royal seat. Moscow actually prints a variant in notes and Khaleghi gives it as the first of three recorded additions. English 30. Mohl runs the distinction between succession after death and war in the father’s lifetime. Moscow and Khaleghi print a corresponding addition. The gates of hell are an English development. English 46. In reply to Pirooz, Nushzad explicitly says that divine farr did not leave Christ at his death in all four. The English puts the positive statement into an image of light. English 48. The shared poison and remedy image names tiryāk, an antidote. The English’s nush-daru gives it a term readers have encountered elsewhere in the epic. English 56. English prolongs the battle’s noise and the general clash beside the arrows and injury. Khaleghi prints additional battle wording in the apparatus at this point. The precise English picture of casualties on both sides remains unverified. English 62. The expression of what is in the prince’s heart occupies the second half of the verse in which he calls the bishop. English gives it a couplet of its own. English 70. The dying prince rejects the dakhmeh and throne in all four. An ordinary grave according to Christian custom is then set against these royal provisions. English 75. The unstated subject of the rush to the bedside is resolved as Ram Barzin in English, consistent with his named distress a few verses later. English 81. The bishop says that only the mother should see the exposed form. English specifies the head and the open sky after the Persian’s broader injunction. English 89. Three farsangs is explicit in all four. The coffin is borne by hand, an image English makes into the successive movement of mourners. English 101. The Ali invocation runs in Mohl and Ganjoor and is bracketed in Moscow and Khaleghi. English 102. The blessing of the sovereign runs in Mohl. Moscow and Khaleghi print the couplet in their apparatus. Ganjoor ends the episode’s counsel with the invocation to Ali. English 103. This verse of the panegyric runs in Mohl and is actually printed by Khaleghi in the apparatus after the Ali invocation. The checked Moscow and Ganjoor sequence contains no separate counterpart for this verse. English 104. This verse of the panegyric runs in Mohl and is actually printed by Khaleghi in the apparatus after the Ali invocation. The checked Moscow and Ganjoor sequence contains no separate counterpart for this verse. English 105. This verse of the panegyric runs in Mohl and is actually printed by Khaleghi in the apparatus after the Ali invocation. The checked Moscow and Ganjoor sequence contains no separate counterpart for this verse.
Limits of the evidence
Running text, bracketed running text, actual printed apparatus and checked local gaps indicate distinct kinds of support. Local gaps concern the specified passage. No appendix reading is invoked. The geographical and institutional terms describe the poem’s account.
Source-only verses
Moscow VIII p.104 · Moscow VIII p.105 · Moscow VIII p.106 · Moscow VIII p.107 · Moscow VIII p.108 · Moscow VIII p.109
Mohl VI p.118 · Mohl VI p.119 · Mohl VI p.120 · Mohl VI p.121 · Mohl VI p.122
Khaleghi VII p.158 · Khaleghi VII p.159 · Khaleghi VII p.160 · Khaleghi VII p.161 · Khaleghi VII p.162 · Khaleghi VII p.163 · Khaleghi VII p.164 · Khaleghi VII p.165 · Khaleghi VII p.166
Selected printed readings
- Mohl VI119:909 running · مکن رزم با لشکر شهریار
Mohl gives Pirooz’s separate warning. - Moscow VIII105 note 11 actual apparatus · پدر زنده و پور جویای گاه
The actual additional reading imagines a living father and a son seeking the throne. - Khaleghi VII161:931 running · نه فرّ جهاندار ازو گشته شد
Nushzad insists that divine farr did not turn from Christ. - Moscow VIII107:937 running · مکن دخمه و تخت و رنج دراز
The dying prince rejects the dakhmeh and throne. - Khaleghi VII165:968 running · سه فرسنگ بر دست بگذاشتند
The coffin is borne by hand for three farsangs. - Moscow VIII109:966 bracketed running · اگر در دلت هیچ حبّ علیست
Moscow brackets the verse on Ali. - Mohl VI122:987 running · جهاندار محمود جویای حمد
Mohl gives the praise of Mahmud in running verse. - Khaleghi VII166 note 17 actual apparatus · سر تاج او شد ستون سپهر
The image of the crown as the pillar of the sky is present in the printed addition.
D13.19 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII104:874 running; VIII104:875 running | VI118:890 running; VI118:891 running |
| 2 | VIII104:876 running | VI118:892 running |
| 3 | VIII104:877 running | VI118:893 running |
| 4 | VIII104:878 running | VI118:894 running |
| 5 | VIII104:879 running | VI118:895 running |
| 6 | VIII104:880 running | VI118:896 running |
| 7 | VIII104:881 running | VI118:897 running |
| 8 | VIII104:882 running | VI118:898 running |
| 9 | VIII104:883 running | VI118:899 running |
| 10 | VIII104:884 running | VI118:900 running |
| 11 | VIII104:885 running | VI118:901 running |
| 12 | VIII105:886 running | VI118:902 running |
| 13 | VIII105:887 running | VI118:903 running |
| 14 | VIII105:888 running | VI118:904 running |
| 15 | VIII105:889 running | VI119:905 running |
| 16 | VIII105:890 running | VI119:906 running |
| 17 | VIII105:891 running | VI119:907 running |
| 18 | VIII105:892 running | VI119:908 running |
| 19 | VIII105 checked local gap after v.892 | VI119:909 running |
| 20 | VIII105:893 running | VI119:910 running |
| 21 | VIII105:894 running | VI119:911 running |
| 22 | VIII105:895 running | VI119:912 running |
| 23 | VIII105:896 running | VI119:913 running |
| 24 | VIII105:897 running | VI119:914 running |
| 25 | VIII105:898 running | VI119:915 running |
| 26 | VIII105:899 running | VI119:916 running |
| 27 | VIII105:900 running | VI119:917 running |
| 28 | VIII105:901 running | VI119:920 running |
| 29 | VIII105 note 11 actual apparatus after v.898 | VI119:918 running |
| 30 | VIII105 note 11 actual apparatus after v.898 | VI119:919 running |
| 31 | VIII105:902 running | VI119:921 running |
| 32 | VIII105:903 running | VI119:922 running |
| 33 | VIII106:904 running | VI119:923 running |
| 34 | VIII106:905 running | VI119:924 running |
| 35 | VIII106:906 running | VI119:925 running |
| 36 | VIII106:907 running | VI119:926 running |
| 37 | VIII106:908 running | VI119:927 running |
| 38 | VIII106:909 running | VI119:928 running |
| 39 | VIII106:910 running | VI119:929 running |
| 40 | VIII106:911 running | VI120:930 running |
| 41 | VIII106:912 running | VI120:931 running |
| 42 | VIII106:913 running | VI120:932 running |
| 43 | VIII106:914 running | VI120:933 running |
| 44 | VIII106:915 running | VI120:934 running |
| 45 | VIII106:916 running | VI120:935 running |
| 46 | VIII106:917 running | VI120:936 running |
| 47 | VIII106:918 running | VI120:937 running |
| 48 | VIII106:919 running | VI120:938 running |
| 49 | VIII106:920 running | VI120:939 running |
| 50 | VIII106:921 running | VI120:940 running |
| 51 | VIII106:922 running | VI120:941 running |
| 52 | VIII107:923 running | VI120:942 running |
| 53 | VIII107:924 running | VI120:943 running |
| 54 | VIII107:924 running; VIII107:925 running | VI120:943 running; VI120:944 running |
| 55 | VIII107:925 running | VI120:944 running |
| 56 | VIII107:925 running | VI120:944 running |
| 57 | VIII107:926 running | VI120:945 running |
| 58 | VIII107:927 running | VI120:946 running |
| 59 | VIII107:928 running | VI120:947 running |
| 60 | VIII107:928 running | VI120:947 running |
| 61 | VIII107:929 running | VI120:948 running |
| 62 | VIII107:929 running | VI120:948 running |
| 63 | VIII107:930 running | VI120:949 running |
| 64 | VIII107:931 running | VI120:950 running |
| 65 | VIII107:932 running | VI120:951 running |
| 66 | VIII107:933 running | VI120:952 running |
| 67 | VIII107:934 running | VI121:953 running |
| 68 | VIII107:935 running | VI121:954 running |
| 69 | VIII107:936 running | VI121:955 running |
| 70 | VIII107:937 running | VI121:956 running |
| 71 | VIII107:937 running | VI121:956 running |
| 72 | VIII107:938 running | VI121:957 running |
| 73 | VIII107:939 running | VI121:958 running |
| 74 | VIII108:940 running | VI121:959 running |
| 75 | VIII108:941 running | VI121:960 running |
| 76 | VIII108:942 running | VI121:961 running |
| 77 | VIII108:943 running | VI121:962 running |
| 78 | VIII108:943 running; VIII108:944 running | VI121:962 running; VI121:963 running |
| 79 | VIII108:944 running; VIII108:945 running | VI121:963 running; VI121:964 running |
| 80 | VIII108:945 running | VI121:964 running |
| 81 | VIII108:946 running | VI121:965 running |
| 82 | VIII108:947 running | VI121:966 running |
| 83 | VIII108:948 running | VI121:967 running |
| 84 | VIII108:949 running | VI121:968 running |
| 85 | VIII108:950 running | VI121:969 running |
| 86 | VIII108:951 running | VI121:970 running |
| 87 | VIII108:952 running | VI121:971 running |
| 88 | VIII108:953 running | VI121:972 running |
| 89 | VIII109:954 running | VI121:973 running |
| 90 | VIII109:955 running | VI121:974 running |
| 91 | VIII109:956 running | VI121:975 running |
| 92 | VIII109:957 running | VI121:976 running |
| 93 | VIII109:958 running | VI121:977 running |
| 94 | VIII109:959 running | VI122:978 running |
| 95 | VIII109:960 running | VI122:979 running |
| 96 | VIII109:961 running | VI122:980 running |
| 97 | VIII109:962 running | VI122:981 running |
| 98 | VIII109:963 running | VI122:982 running |
| 99 | VIII109:964 running | VI122:983 running |
| 100 | VIII109:965 running | VI122:984 running |
| 101 | VIII109:966 bracketed running | VI122:985 running |
| 102 | VIII109 note 20 actual apparatus after v.966 | VI122:986 running |
| 103 | VIII109 checked local gap after v.966 and before the Bozorgmehr transition | VI122:987 running |
| 104 | VIII109 checked local gap after v.966 and before the Bozorgmehr transition | VI122:988 running |
| 105 | VIII109 checked local gap after v.966 and before the Bozorgmehr transition | VI122:989 running |
New Naqqali