Bozorgmehr Interprets the Dream
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The change of face and the authority of dreams
Moscow — VIII109 note 20 and VIII110 continuation actual apparatus, VIII110:967 running, VIII110:968 running, VIII110:969 running, VIII110:970 running, VIII110:971 running · Mohl — VI122:990 running, VI122:991 running, VI122:992 running, VI122:993 running, VI122:994 running, VI122:995 running · Ganjoor — Checked local gap before sh29:1, sh29:1 running, sh29:2 running, sh29:3 running, sh29:4 running, sh30:1 running · Khaleghi — VII166 note 17 actual apparatus, VII167:981 running, VII167:982 running, VII167:983 running, VII167:984 running, VII167:985 running
Moscow VIII p.109 · Moscow VIII p.110 · Mohl VI p.122 · Ganjoor sh29:1 · Ganjoor sh29:2 · Ganjoor sh29:3 · Ganjoor sh29:4 · Ganjoor sh30:1 · Khaleghi VII p.166 · Khaleghi VII p.167
Mohl opens the episode by offering a new face of the story. Moscow and Khaleghi print forms of this transition below their running text. Ganjoor begins directly with the defense of dreams. The English opening takes its cue from Mohl and specifies the grief and battle of the preceding narrative, giving the transition a direction the Persian leaves implicit. The following appeal to prophecy is shared by the four accounts. Their mirror image, fire seen in water, makes inward clarity a condition of seeing. The English preserves that paradox and prepares for the court's inability to interpret the dream.
7–12The king’s table in the dream
Moscow — VIII110:972 running, VIII110:973 running, VIII110:974 running, VIII110:975 running; VIII110 note 18 actual apparatus, VIII110:976 running; VIII110:977 running, VIII111:978 running · Mohl — VI122:996 running, VI122:997 running, VI122:998 running, VI122:999 running, VI122:1000 running; VI123:1001 running, VI123:1002 running · Ganjoor — sh30:2 running, sh30:3 running, sh30:4 running, sh30:5 running, sh30:6, sh31:1 running, sh31:2 running · Khaleghi — VII167:986 running, VII167:987 running, VII167:988 running, VII168:989 running; VII168 note 2 actual apparatus at v.989, VII168:990 running; VII168:991 running, VII168:992 running
Moscow VIII p.110 · Moscow VIII p.111 · Mohl VI p.122 · Mohl VI p.123 · Ganjoor sh30:2 · Ganjoor sh30:3 · Ganjoor sh30:4 · Ganjoor sh30:5 · Ganjoor sh30:6 · Ganjoor sh31:1 · Ganjoor sh31:2 · Khaleghi VII p.167 · Khaleghi VII p.168
The royal tree and the boar belong to the same dream in all four witnesses. The first image makes the Shah receptive to music and wine. The second transfers access to royal wine to a creature whose teeth signal danger. The running line usually gives the boar’s demand for a cup or wine. The actual addition printed by Moscow and Khaleghi has it drink with him, which supports the English action more directly. The English then assigns the fear to the waking king. Taurus and the morning bird call provide a firmer sequence of time than the English epithet “dream-born” alone would convey.
13–18Ignorance and the cost of inquiry
Moscow — VIII111:979 running, VIII111:980 running, VIII111:981 running, VIII111:982 running, VIII111:983 running, VIII111:984 running · Mohl — VI123:1003 running, VI123:1004 running, VI123:1005 running, VI123:1006 running, VI123:1007 running, VI123:1008 running · Ganjoor — sh31:3 running, sh31:4 running, sh31:5 running, sh31:6 running, sh31:7 running, sh31:8 running · Khaleghi — VII168:993 running, VII168:994 running, VII168:995 running, VII169:996 running, VII169:997 running, VII169:998 running
Moscow VIII p.111 · Mohl VI p.123 · Ganjoor sh31:3 · Ganjoor sh31:4 · Ganjoor sh31:5 · Ganjoor sh31:6 · Ganjoor sh31:7 · Ganjoor sh31:8 · Khaleghi VII p.168 · Khaleghi VII p.169
The court gathers its religious and learned officials, but the Shah receives no useful interpretation. In Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi the narrator steps back to defend admitting ignorance before returning to the king’s problem. The English maintains that change of voice by first speaking generally and then naming Anooshirvan. It reads the failure as a reason to search rather than a reason to dismiss the dream. The silver already enters at the point of dispatch, before the promised amount is named. Rendering it as provision for a quest lets the next couplets explain its ultimate purpose without losing the distinction.
19–24From the empire’s search to a school in Marv
Moscow — VIII111:985 running, VIII111:986 running; VIII111:987 running, VIII111:988 running, VIII111:989 running, VIII111:990 running, VIII111:991 running · Mohl — VI123:1009 running, VI123:1010 running; VI123:1011 running, VI123:1012 running, VI123:1013 running, VI123:1014 running, VI123:1015 running · Ganjoor — sh31:9 running, sh31:10, sh31:11 running, sh31:12 running, sh31:13 running, sh32:1 running, sh32:2 running · Khaleghi — VII169:999 running, VII169:1000 running; VII169:1001 running, VII169:1002 running, VII169:1003 running, VII169:1004 running, VII169:1005 running
Moscow VIII p.111 · Mohl VI p.123 · Ganjoor sh31:9 · Ganjoor sh31:10 · Ganjoor sh31:11 · Ganjoor sh31:12 · Ganjoor sh31:13 · Ganjoor sh32:1 · Ganjoor sh32:2 · Khaleghi VII p.169
The ten thousand units of silver and the destination Marv belong to the shared movement of Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. The English distributes the search criteria across two couplets, making understanding and access to concealed meaning its successive stages. The silver is carried on the king’s behalf and paid to the person who can solve the dream. That transfer makes the trip an inquiry with a public incentive. “Page to page” supplies a visible classroom action for the text’s identification of the teacher with the Zand and Avesta. It also puts the written tradition beside the unusual skill the envoy is seeking.
25–30What the schoolmaster will teach
Moscow — VIII111:992 running, VIII111:993 running, VIII112:994 running, VIII112:995 running, VIII112:996 running, VIII112 note 8 actual apparatus · Mohl — VI123:1016 running, VI123:1017 running, VI123:1018 running; VI123:1019 running, VI123:1020 running, VI123:1021 running, VI123:1022 running · Ganjoor — sh32:3 running, sh32:4 running, sh32:5 running, sh32:6 running, sh32:7 running, Checked local gap after sh32:7 · Khaleghi — VII169:1006 running, VII169:1007 running, VII170:1008 running; VII170 note 3 actual apparatus, VII170:1009 running, VII170:1010 running, VII170 checked local gap around vv.1010–1011
Moscow VIII p.111 · Moscow VIII p.112 · Mohl VI p.123 · Ganjoor sh32:3 · Ganjoor sh32:4 · Ganjoor sh32:5 · Ganjoor sh32:6 · Ganjoor sh32:7 · Khaleghi VII p.169 · Khaleghi VII p.170
The school is audible before Bozorgmehr speaks. All four accounts place a loud or angry master beside an accomplished pupil, and their common reply identifies the master’s domain with the Zand. Mohl gives him an additional couplet about teaching children and limits on what he will say. Moscow prints a related couplet in the apparatus. Khaleghi’s running account and Ganjoor go directly to the boy’s reaction. “I do not dare” gives the master’s professional boundary an emotional color. Mohl also adds the pupil’s descent from inquirers, with a counterpart in Khaleghi’s notes, though the English keeps its portrait focused on the boy’s study.
31–36The child’s claim and the empty stomach
Moscow — VIII112:997 running; VIII112:998 running, VIII112:998 running; VIII112:1002 running, VIII112:999 running, VIII112 checked local gap around vv.999–1000, VIII112:1000 running · Mohl — VI123:1023 running; VI123:1024 running, VI123:1024 running; VI124:1031 running, VI123:1025 running, VI124:1026 running, VI124:1027 running; VI124:1028 running · Ganjoor — sh32:8, sh32:9 running, sh32:9, sh32:13 running, sh32:10 running, Checked local gap after sh32:10, sh32:11 running · Khaleghi — VII170:1011 running; VII170:1012 running, VII170:1012 running; VII171:1016 running, VII170:1013 running, VII170–VII171 checked local gap around vv.1013–1014, VII171:1014 running; VII171 note 3 actual apparatus
Moscow VIII p.112 · Mohl VI p.123 · Mohl VI p.124 · Ganjoor sh32:8 · Ganjoor sh32:9 · Ganjoor sh32:13 · Ganjoor sh32:10 · Ganjoor sh32:11 · Khaleghi VII p.170 · Khaleghi VII p.171
The boy turns from listening to asserting that the dream is his business in all four witnesses. The picture of a face changing color supports the English “blushing,” although the Persian leaves the mixture of excitement and embarrassment open. The English gives the schoolmaster’s challenge two couplets, drawing out the rebuke that the pupil has yet to master his book. The stomach joke is identifiable separately in Mohl. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi run the exchange from the master’s challenge toward the envoy’s intervention. The extra exchange makes the master test the social credibility of his pupil as well as his learning.
37–42Fortune and the audience with the Shah
Moscow — VIII112 note 21 actual apparatus, VIII112:1001 running, VIII112:1002 running, VIII112:1003 running, VIII112:1004 running, VIII112:1005 running · Mohl — VI124:1029 running, VI124:1030 running, VI124:1031 running, VI124:1032 running, VI124:1033 running, VI124:1034 running · Ganjoor — Checked local gap after sh32:11, sh32:12 running, sh32:13 running, sh32:14 running, sh32:15 running, sh32:16 running · Khaleghi — VII171 note 3 actual apparatus, VII171:1015 running, VII171:1016 running, VII171:1017 running, VII171:1018 running, VII171:1019 running
Moscow VIII p.112 · Mohl VI p.124 · Ganjoor sh32:11 · Ganjoor sh32:12 · Ganjoor sh32:13 · Ganjoor sh32:14 · Ganjoor sh32:15 · Ganjoor sh32:16 · Khaleghi VII p.171
Mohl’s envoy asks whether Fortune lit the child’s way, and the printed notes in Moscow and Khaleghi give manuscript support for the thought. Ganjoor’s running envoy offers the simpler possibility that the child may know. The English chooses the fuller opposition between instruction and Fortune, which makes the escort’s subsequent confidence easier to follow. The boy insists on speaking to the Shah himself in all four accounts. He receives a horse, money and what he needs for travel, so the change from classroom to royal audience depends on the envoy’s practical backing. The pheasant image keeps the two travelers moving together.
43–48The uncovered face beneath the tree
Moscow — VIII112:1006 running, VIII112:1007 running, VIII112:1008 running, VIII112:1009 running; VIII113:1010 running, VIII113:1011 running, VIII113:1012 running · Mohl — VI124:1035 running, VI124:1036 running, VI124:1037 running, VI124:1038 running; VI124:1040 running; VI124:1039 running, VI124:1041 running, VI124:1042 running · Ganjoor — sh33:1 running, sh33:2 running, sh33:3 running, sh33:4, sh33:5 running, sh33:6 running, sh33:7 running · Khaleghi — VII171:1020 running, VII171:1021 running, VII171:1022 running, VII172:1023 running; VII172:1024 running; VII172 note 3 actual apparatus, VII172:1025 running, VII172:1026 running
Moscow VIII p.112 · Moscow VIII p.113 · Mohl VI p.124 · Ganjoor sh33:1 · Ganjoor sh33:2 · Ganjoor sh33:3 · Ganjoor sh33:4 · Ganjoor sh33:5 · Ganjoor sh33:6 · Ganjoor sh33:7 · Khaleghi VII p.171 · Khaleghi VII p.172
The stop at water and a tree in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi creates the conditions for one traveler to sleep while the other watches. The English adds the calm of the retreat before presenting the snake’s action in close sequence. The Persian already gives the cover over the face, the snake pulling it away, and its inspection from head to foot. Mohl adds the envoy’s thoughts keeping him awake, and Khaleghi prints a parallel under the preceding line. The English keeps him plainly awake and makes the opening of the cover the scene’s central gesture, anticipating the uncovering at court.
49–54The envoy’s inference and report
Moscow — VIII113:1013 running, VIII113:1014 running, VIII113:1015 running, VIII113:1016 running; VIII113:1017 running, VIII113:1018 running, VIII113:1019 running · Mohl — VI124:1043 running, VI124:1044 running, VI124:1045 running, VI124:1046 running; VI124:1047 running, VI124:1048 running, VI125:1049 running · Ganjoor — sh33:8 running, sh33:9 running, sh33:10 running, sh33:11, sh33:12 running, sh33:13 running, sh33:14 running · Khaleghi — VII172:1027 running, VII172:1028 running, VII172:1029 running, VII172:1030 running; VII172:1031 running, VII172:1032 running, VII173:1033 running
Moscow VIII p.113 · Mohl VI p.124 · Mohl VI p.125 · Ganjoor sh33:8 · Ganjoor sh33:9 · Ganjoor sh33:10 · Ganjoor sh33:11 · Ganjoor sh33:12 · Ganjoor sh33:13 · Ganjoor sh33:14 · Khaleghi VII p.172 · Khaleghi VII p.173
When the snake disappears the English connects its departure to the boy waking in alarm. The shared Persian sequence gives the disturbance and disappearance, while some wording makes hearing the disturbance more explicit than seeing it. The envoy invokes God and infers a future of eminence in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. His account to the court reconstructs the route and returns to the pheasant comparison, this time for his own search in Marv. The English also gives a blessing that Fortune keep the reign young, a fitting use of Persian praise that couples a watchful sovereign with continuing good fortune.
55–60A prediction the court can test
Moscow — VIII113:1020 running, VIII113:1021 running, VIII113:1022 running; VIII113:1023 running, VIII113:1024 running; VIII113:1025 running, VIII114:1026 running, VIII114:1027 running · Mohl — VI125:1050 running, VI125:1051 running, VI125:1052 running; VI125:1053 running, VI125:1054 running; VI125:1055 running, VI125:1056 running, VI125:1057 running · Ganjoor — sh33:15 running, sh33:16 running, sh34:1, sh34:2 running, sh34:3, sh34:4 running, sh34:5 running, sh34:6 running · Khaleghi — VII173:1034 running, VII173:1035 running, VII173:1036 running; VII173:1037 running, VII173:1038 running; VII173:1039 running, VII173:1040 running, VII173:1041 running
Moscow VIII p.113 · Moscow VIII p.114 · Mohl VI p.125 · Ganjoor sh33:15 · Ganjoor sh33:16 · Ganjoor sh34:1 · Ganjoor sh34:2 · Ganjoor sh34:3 · Ganjoor sh34:4 · Ganjoor sh34:5 · Ganjoor sh34:6 · Khaleghi VII p.173
The envoy presents two grounds for taking the youth seriously: his claim to interpret the dream and the extraordinary incident on the road. The four accounts then move from the Shah’s recitation to a testable assertion about a disguised man in the private chambers. The published English adds the inward beat of listening and pondering, supported by the Persian sense that hearing the dream fills the youth with what he has to say. Clearing outsiders matters because the test concerns the royal household. “Measured tread” makes visible the instruction that those in the women’s quarters pass before the king one by one.
61–66A first inspection that finds nobody
Moscow — VIII114:1028 running, VIII114:1029 running; VIII114:1030 running, VIII114:1030 running; VIII114:1031 running, VIII114:1031 running; VIII114:1032 running, VIII114:1032 running, VIII114:1033 running · Mohl — VI125:1058 running, VI125:1059 running; VI125:1060 running, VI125:1060 running; VI125:1061 running, VI125:1061 running; VI125:1062 running, VI125:1062 running, VI125:1063 running · Ganjoor — sh34:7 running, sh34:8, sh34:9 running, sh34:9, sh34:10 running, sh34:10, sh34:11 running, sh34:11 running, sh34:12 running · Khaleghi — VII173:1042 running, VII174:1043 running; VII174:1044 running, VII174:1044 running; VII174:1045 running, VII174:1045 running; VII174:1046 running, VII174:1046 running, VII174:1047 running
Moscow VIII p.114 · Mohl VI p.125 · Ganjoor sh34:7 · Ganjoor sh34:8 · Ganjoor sh34:9 · Ganjoor sh34:10 · Ganjoor sh34:11 · Ganjoor sh34:12 · Khaleghi VII p.173 · Khaleghi VII p.174
The youth imagines asking the daring intruder how he reached the lion’s bed. In all four witnesses the implied lion is made explicit by the Shah’s own lion-like rage when the first inspection fails. The English shifts the earlier image to a lion’s den, a change that strengthens the contrast between an outsider’s audacity and the danger of entering a protected interior. Perfume, color and lowering of the gaze help explain why the first examination fails. The four accounts distinguish the women’s passing from the interpreter’s certainty that a youth is present. The English keeps the king’s demand for proof in view.
67–72A second passage and the hidden youth
Moscow — VIII114:1034 running; VIII114 note 13 actual apparatus, VIII114 note 13 actual apparatus, VIII114:1035 running; VIII114:1036 running, VIII114:1036 running; VIII114:1037 running, VIII114:1038 running, VIII114:1039 running · Mohl — VI125:1067 running; VI125:1064 running; VI125:1065 running, VI125:1066 running, VI125:1068 running; VI125:1069 running, VI125:1069 running; VI125:1070 running, VI125:1071 running, VI125:1072 running · Ganjoor — sh34:13 running, Checked local gap after sh34:13, sh34:14, sh34:15 running, sh34:15, sh34:16 running, sh34:17 running, sh34:18 running · Khaleghi — VII174:1048 running; VII174 note 6 actual apparatus, VII174 note 6 actual apparatus, VII174:1049 running; VII174:1050 running, VII174:1050 running; VII174:1051 running, VII174:1052 running, VII174:1053 running
Moscow VIII p.114 · Mohl VI p.125 · Ganjoor sh34:13 · Ganjoor sh34:14 · Ganjoor sh34:15 · Ganjoor sh34:16 · Ganjoor sh34:17 · Ganjoor sh34:18 · Khaleghi VII p.174
The request to remove the covering from the faces belongs to the shared episode. Mohl makes a distinct event of the order to bring the women back, and Moscow and Khaleghi print corresponding evidence naming attendants. “Eunuchs” is the English understanding of those attendants in the royal women’s quarters. The unfolding test also clarifies why the youth’s cypress stature can coexist with willow-like trembling. Ganjoor shares the young man’s revelation and the identification of one woman as the daughter of the chief of Chach. Calling her a warden’s daughter gives that rank a more specific English office than the Persian establishes.
73–78Service, affection and a contested kinship
Moscow — VIII115:1040 running, VIII115:1041 running, VIII115:1042 running, VIII115:1043 running, VIII115:1044 running, VIII115:1045 running · Mohl — VI125:1073 running, VI126:1074 running, VI126:1075 running, VI126:1076 running, VI126:1077 running; VI126:1078 running, VI126:1079 running · Ganjoor — sh34:19 running, sh34:20 running, sh34:21 running, sh34:22 running, sh34:23 running, sh34:24 running · Khaleghi — VII175:1054 running, VII175 note 6 actual apparatus, VII175:1055 running, VII175:1056 running, VII175:1057 running, VII175:1058 running
Moscow VIII p.115 · Mohl VI p.125 · Mohl VI p.126 · Ganjoor sh34:19 · Ganjoor sh34:20 · Ganjoor sh34:21 · Ganjoor sh34:22 · Ganjoor sh34:23 · Ganjoor sh34:24 · Khaleghi VII p.175
The description of the youth joins scent and beauty to the affection shown at home. The English makes his love for the girl explicit as the motive for following her. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor run the comparison to a servant, with Khaleghi printing it as an addition. All four give her claim that she and the younger man share a mother. Mohl adds that they have different fathers, so the more precise English relationship has independent support in its running text. The denial of wrongdoing and the explanation of shame are her defense before the Shah, whose next action exposes its failure.
79–84From the girl’s defense to public deterrence
Moscow — VIII115:1046 running, VIII115 checked local gap around vv.1046–1047, VIII115:1047 running; VIII115:1048 running, VIII115:1048 running; VIII115:1049 running, VIII115:1050 running, VIII115:1051 running; VIII115:1052 running · Mohl — VI126:1080 running, VI126:1081 running, VI126:1082 running; VI126:1083 running, VI126:1083 running; VI126:1084 running, VI126:1085 running, VI126:1086 running; VI126:1087 running · Ganjoor — sh34:25 running, Checked local gap after sh34:25, sh34:26, sh35:1 running, sh35:1, sh35:2 running, sh35:3 running, sh35:4, sh35:5 running · Khaleghi — VII175:1059 running, VII175 checked local gap around vv.1059–1060, VII175:1060 running; VII175:1061 running, VII175:1061 running; VII175:1062 running, VII175:1063 running, VII176:1064 running; VII176:1065 running
Moscow VIII p.115 · Mohl VI p.126 · Ganjoor sh34:25 · Ganjoor sh34:26 · Ganjoor sh35:1 · Ganjoor sh35:2 · Ganjoor sh35:3 · Ganjoor sh35:4 · Ganjoor sh35:5 · Khaleghi VII p.175 · Khaleghi VII p.176
The order to the executioner and the hanging inside the royal quarters run in all four witnesses. Mohl also separately says the king knew what she said was false. Where Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi picture the hanging through inverted bodies, blood and guilt, Mohl openly gives the purpose of discouraging another offense. That phrase supports the English warning, although “the people of the land” enlarges its audience beyond what Mohl states. The next movement from punishment to gifts is sharp in the Persian as well. The English retains the physical reward and ties it to the king’s recognition of the youth’s discernment.
85–90From the roll to an institution of learning
Moscow — VIII115:1053 running, VIII115:1054 running, VIII115:1055 running, VIII115:1056 running, VIII115:1057 running, VIII116:1058 running · Mohl — VI126:1088 running, VI126:1089 running, VI126:1090 running, VI126:1091 running, VI126:1092 running, VI126:1093 running · Ganjoor — sh35:6 running, sh36:1 running, sh36:2 running, sh36:3 running, sh36:4 running, sh36:5 running · Khaleghi — VII176:1066 running, VII176:1067 running, VII176:1068 running, VII176:1069 running, VII176:1070 running, VII176:1071 running
Moscow VIII p.115 · Moscow VIII p.116 · Mohl VI p.126 · Ganjoor sh35:6 · Ganjoor sh36:1 · Ganjoor sh36:2 · Ganjoor sh36:3 · Ganjoor sh36:4 · Ganjoor sh36:5 · Khaleghi VII p.176
The record of Bozorgmehr’s name in the royal register turns success in one case into a standing role among the Mobadan. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi move through the young man’s rising fortunes to a description of the Shah’s own disposition. The English explicitly names the Shah in the couplet on justice, which helps after several references to the boy’s prosperity. The running texts give seventy learned speakers maintained at court. The old English counting phrase preserves their number. The women’s quarters and scholarly establishment thus receive the same count in the story, with distinct functions and consequences in their respective scenes.
91–94How the Shah uses his leisure
Moscow — VIII116:1059 running, VIII116:1060 running, VIII116:1061 running, VIII116:1062 running · Mohl — VI126:1094 running, VI126:1095 running, VI126:1096 running, VI126:1097 running · Ganjoor — sh36:6 running, sh36:7 running, sh36:8 running, sh36:9 running · Khaleghi — VII176:1072 running, VII176:1073 running, VII176:1074 running, VII176:1075 running
Moscow VIII p.116 · Mohl VI p.126 · Ganjoor sh36:6 · Ganjoor sh36:7 · Ganjoor sh36:8 · Ganjoor sh36:9 · Khaleghi VII p.176
The shared passage uses the king’s time away from government to explain how unusually good teachers are available to Bozorgmehr. The list of occupations differs among the printed texts. Moscow and Ganjoor include wine and the drinking companion. Khaleghi’s running reading gives hunting, and Mohl has warfare, the most immediate support for the English fight. The picture of the Shah decking his heart with knowledge carries over the Persian image of adornment. The young man has beauty and cleverness as well as an aptitude for speaking. Setting him among astrologers and priests identifies the range of training that brings him to the banquet.
95–97Medicine, statecraft and effective speech
Moscow — VIII116:1063 running, VIII116 checked local gap between vv.1063 and 1064 · Mohl — VI126:1098 running; VI127:1099 running, VI127:1099 running; VI127:1100 running, VI127:1100 running · Ganjoor — sh36:10 running, Checked local gap after sh36:10 · Khaleghi — VII177:1076 running; VII177 note 3 actual apparatus, VII177 note 3 actual apparatus
Moscow VIII p.116 · Mohl VI p.126 · Mohl VI p.127 · Ganjoor sh36:10 · Khaleghi VII p.177
In all four witnesses Bozorgmehr surpasses those who instructed him, including the philosophers. Moscow and Ganjoor then move into the first banquet. Mohl continues with exceptional knowledge of the stars, medicine, the arrangement of affairs and apt speech. Khaleghi prints corresponding Persian lines beneath the running text, alongside a distinct notice of Bondari’s Arabic account of the preceding material. The English breaks the branches of learning into separate couplets. Its “manners” interprets the notion of arrangement alongside sound judgment rather broadly. The combined emphasis on learning and practical speech gives the next scene a reason to test him in the presence of experienced men.
Source record and limits
English
97 published English couplets. Ganjoor passages: Anooshirvan §29: 1–4, Anooshirvan §30: 1–6, Anooshirvan §31: 1–13, Anooshirvan §32: 1–16, Anooshirvan §33: 1–16, Anooshirvan §34: 1–26, Anooshirvan §35: 1–6, Anooshirvan §36: 1–10. The English text follows the published verse and chapter divisions.
Moscow
The 1970 Moscow edition, volume VIII, printed pages 109–116. The source register identifies the individual running verses and any printed apparatus cited.
Mohl
Jules Mohl’s Persian text, volume VI, printed pages 122–127. The running sequence includes some lines here that Moscow and Khaleghi give in their apparatus.
Ganjoor
Anooshirvan §29: 1–4, Anooshirvan §30: 1–6, Anooshirvan §31: 1–13, Anooshirvan §32: 1–16, Anooshirvan §33: 1–16, Anooshirvan §34: 1–26, Anooshirvan §35: 1–6, Anooshirvan §36: 1–10. The Persian column gives the corresponding running verses and identifies where Mohl supplies an independent couplet for a local Ganjoor gap.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Djalal Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VII, printed pages 166–177. Square brackets mark verses retained in the main text with explicit editorial reservation. Printed additions have their own locators.
Dream and discovery
The young interpreter puts his explanation to a test before the king. Mohl’s fuller sequence supplies several details of the schoolroom and the discovery that surface in the English. Khaleghi records a number of related verses in the apparatus, including the closing pair on medicine and statecraft. Moscow supplies apparatus evidence for the order to the attendants and for the boar actually drinking.
Consequential readings
English 1. A new face or subject marks the transition in Mohl. Moscow and Khaleghi print the transition in their notes. Ganjoor starts directly with counsel on dreams. English 10. The main Persian lines give the boar’s demand for a cup or wine. English has it drink, an act represented in a manuscript reading printed in Moscow and Khaleghi. English 11. The sun in Taurus fixes the hour at which the Shah wakes. The traditional identification of chagāv as a lark is used in the English. English 27. Mohl supplements the portrait with Bozorgmehr’s descent from inquirers. Khaleghi prints a related line below the text. English 30. The separate reply about teaching children runs in Mohl. Moscow prints a related couplet while the other running accounts confine the teacher’s reply to the Zand. English 35. The teacher’s joke about interpreting dreams on an empty stomach runs in Mohl. In the other texts the envoy replies to the teacher’s scolding. English 36. The envoy’s admonition leads in Mohl to a separate line about the turning of the age and outward dress. A version of that line is printed by Khaleghi. English 37. Mohl has the envoy attribute the boy’s knowledge to Fortune. Moscow and Khaleghi print variants of the claim. English 46. Mohl adds a line on the sleepless envoy thinking about the gifted boy before seeing the snake. Khaleghi prints a corresponding line. English 67. Mohl makes the youth explicitly call the dream true and asks for another passage uncovered. The other witnesses speak of revealing the face. English 68. Mohl runs a separate order to the attendants. Moscow and Khaleghi actually print variants. The face is made explicit in the neighboring request, while the attendants’ title is rendered as eunuchs in English. English 72. The girl is the daughter of the chief of Chach. The specific office “warden” is an English interpretation of the rank. English 74. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor run the simile of the young man serving the girl like a slave. Khaleghi prints the corresponding verse as an addition. English 77. A shared mother is in all four running texts. Mohl gives the different fathers in a separate verse, supporting the more explicit English account. English 80. Mohl separately says the Shah knew her words were false. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi move to the king’s amazement and order. English 83. Mohl makes deterrence explicit. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi emphasize the manner of the hanging and the guilt of the pair. English 91. Mohl gives wine and warfare and Khaleghi runs hunting. Moscow and Ganjoor give wine and the cup-bearer or drinking companion. English follows the war reading at the end of its list. English 95. The running texts describe Bozorgmehr’s surpassing his teachers. Mohl and the additions printed by Khaleghi single out knowledge of the stars. English 96. Mohl runs the additional lines naming medicine, practical government and effective speech. Khaleghi prints corresponding Persian verses after v.1076. English 97. Mohl runs the additional lines naming medicine, practical government and effective speech. Khaleghi prints corresponding Persian verses after v.1076.
Limits of the evidence
Running text, bracketed running text, actual printed apparatus and checked local gaps indicate distinct kinds of support. Local gaps concern the specified passage. No appendix reading is invoked. The geographical and institutional terms describe the poem’s account.
Source-only verses
Moscow VIII p.109 · Moscow VIII p.110 · Moscow VIII p.111 · Moscow VIII p.112 · Moscow VIII p.113 · Moscow VIII p.114 · Moscow VIII p.115 · Moscow VIII p.116
Mohl VI p.122 · Mohl VI p.123 · Mohl VI p.124 · Mohl VI p.125 · Mohl VI p.126 · Mohl VI p.127
Khaleghi VII p.166 · Khaleghi VII p.167 · Khaleghi VII p.168 · Khaleghi VII p.169 · Khaleghi VII p.170 · Khaleghi VII p.171 · Khaleghi VII p.172 · Khaleghi VII p.173 · Khaleghi VII p.174 · Khaleghi VII p.175 · Khaleghi VII p.176 · Khaleghi VII p.177
Selected printed readings
- Mohl VI122:990 running · یکی تازهتر برگشاییم چهر
The transition promises a fresh turn in the narrative. - Moscow VIII110 note 18 actual apparatus · همی خورد با او به یک جای می
This manuscript addition explicitly has the boar drinking with the king. - Mohl VI123:1022 running · بیاموزم این کودکان را همی
The schoolmaster limits his responsibility to teaching. - Mohl VI124:1026 running · شکم گرسنه چون گزارش کنی
The teacher makes the empty stomach a point of mockery. - Moscow VIII114 note 13 actual apparatus · بفرمود پس خادمان را که زود
The order to the attendants appears among the printed additions. - Khaleghi VII175 note 6 actual apparatus · بسان یکی بنده در پیش اوی
The printed couplet compares the boy to a slave in attendance. - Mohl VI126:1078 running · پدر ما جدا مادر ما یکست
The woman explicitly distinguishes the fathers. - Mohl VI126:1085 running · بدان تا دگر کس نجوید گناه
The narrator gives deterrence as the purpose of the hanging. - Mohl VI126:1094 running · ز داد و دهش وز می و کارزار
Mohl’s list gives warfare. - Khaleghi VII177 note 3 actual apparatus · ز رای و پزشکی ز کس بس نبود
This edited apparatus reading names the art of medicine.
D13.20.1 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII109 note 20 and VIII110 continuation actual apparatus · VIII p.110 | VI122:990 running |
| 2 | VIII110:967 running | VI122:991 running |
| 3 | VIII110:968 running | VI122:992 running |
| 4 | VIII110:969 running | VI122:993 running |
| 5 | VIII110:970 running | VI122:994 running |
| 6 | VIII110:971 running | VI122:995 running |
| 7 | VIII110:972 running | VI122:996 running |
| 8 | VIII110:973 running | VI122:997 running |
| 9 | VIII110:974 running | VI122:998 running |
| 10 | VIII110:975 running; VIII110 note 18 actual apparatus | VI122:999 running |
| 11 | VIII110:976 running; VIII110:977 running | VI122:1000 running; VI123:1001 running · VI p.123 |
| 12 | VIII111:978 running | VI123:1002 running |
| 13 | VIII111:979 running | VI123:1003 running |
| 14 | VIII111:980 running | VI123:1004 running |
| 15 | VIII111:981 running | VI123:1005 running |
| 16 | VIII111:982 running | VI123:1006 running |
| 17 | VIII111:983 running | VI123:1007 running |
| 18 | VIII111:984 running | VI123:1008 running |
| 19 | VIII111:985 running | VI123:1009 running |
| 20 | VIII111:986 running; VIII111:987 running | VI123:1010 running; VI123:1011 running |
| 21 | VIII111:988 running | VI123:1012 running |
| 22 | VIII111:989 running | VI123:1013 running |
| 23 | VIII111:990 running | VI123:1014 running |
| 24 | VIII111:991 running | VI123:1015 running |
| 25 | VIII111:992 running | VI123:1016 running |
| 26 | VIII111:993 running | VI123:1017 running |
| 27 | VIII112:994 running | VI123:1018 running; VI123:1019 running |
| 28 | VIII112:995 running | VI123:1020 running |
| 29 | VIII112:996 running | VI123:1021 running |
| 30 | VIII112 note 8 actual apparatus | VI123:1022 running |
| 31 | VIII112:997 running; VIII112:998 running | VI123:1023 running; VI123:1024 running |
| 32 | VIII112:998 running; VIII112:1002 running | VI123:1024 running; VI124:1031 running · VI p.124 |
| 33 | VIII112:999 running | VI123:1025 running |
| 34 | VIII112:999 running | VI123:1025 running |
| 35 | VIII112 checked local gap around vv.999–1000 | VI124:1026 running |
| 36 | VIII112:1000 running | VI124:1027 running; VI124:1028 running |
| 37 | VIII112 note 21 actual apparatus | VI124:1029 running |
| 38 | VIII112:1001 running | VI124:1030 running |
| 39 | VIII112:1002 running | VI124:1031 running |
| 40 | VIII112:1003 running | VI124:1032 running |
| 41 | VIII112:1004 running | VI124:1033 running |
| 42 | VIII112:1005 running | VI124:1034 running |
| 43 | VIII112:1006 running | VI124:1035 running |
| 44 | VIII112:1007 running | VI124:1036 running |
| 45 | VIII112:1008 running | VI124:1037 running |
| 46 | VIII112:1009 running; VIII113:1010 running · VIII p.113 | VI124:1038 running; VI124:1040 running; VI124:1039 running |
| 47 | VIII113:1011 running | VI124:1041 running |
| 48 | VIII113:1012 running | VI124:1042 running |
| 49 | VIII113:1013 running | VI124:1043 running |
| 50 | VIII113:1014 running | VI124:1044 running |
| 51 | VIII113:1015 running | VI124:1045 running |
| 52 | VIII113:1016 running; VIII113:1017 running | VI124:1046 running; VI124:1047 running |
| 53 | VIII113:1018 running | VI124:1048 running |
| 54 | VIII113:1019 running | VI125:1049 running |
| 55 | VIII113:1020 running | VI125:1050 running |
| 56 | VIII113:1021 running | VI125:1051 running |
| 57 | VIII113:1022 running; VIII113:1023 running | VI125:1052 running; VI125:1053 running |
| 58 | VIII113:1024 running; VIII113:1025 running | VI125:1054 running; VI125:1055 running |
| 59 | VIII114:1026 running | VI125:1056 running |
| 60 | VIII114:1027 running | VI125:1057 running |
| 61 | VIII114:1028 running | VI125:1058 running |
| 62 | VIII114:1029 running; VIII114:1030 running | VI125:1059 running; VI125:1060 running |
| 63 | VIII114:1030 running; VIII114:1031 running | VI125:1060 running; VI125:1061 running |
| 64 | VIII114:1031 running; VIII114:1032 running | VI125:1061 running; VI125:1062 running |
| 65 | VIII114:1032 running | VI125:1062 running |
| 66 | VIII114:1033 running | VI125:1063 running |
| 67 | VIII114:1034 running; VIII114 note 13 actual apparatus | VI125:1067 running; VI125:1064 running; VI125:1065 running |
| 68 | VIII114 note 13 actual apparatus | VI125:1066 running |
| 69 | VIII114:1035 running; VIII114:1036 running | VI125:1068 running; VI125:1069 running |
| 70 | VIII114:1036 running; VIII114:1037 running | VI125:1069 running; VI125:1070 running |
| 71 | VIII114:1038 running | VI125:1071 running |
| 72 | VIII114:1039 running | VI125:1072 running |
| 73 | VIII115:1040 running | VI125:1073 running |
| 74 | VIII115:1041 running | VI126:1074 running |
| 75 | VIII115:1042 running | VI126:1075 running |
| 76 | VIII115:1043 running | VI126:1076 running |
| 77 | VIII115:1044 running | VI126:1077 running; VI126:1078 running |
| 78 | VIII115:1045 running | VI126:1079 running |
| 79 | VIII115:1046 running | VI126:1080 running |
| 80 | VIII115 checked local gap around vv.1046–1047 | VI126:1081 running |
| 81 | VIII115:1047 running; VIII115:1048 running | VI126:1082 running; VI126:1083 running |
| 82 | VIII115:1048 running; VIII115:1049 running | VI126:1083 running; VI126:1084 running |
| 83 | VIII115:1050 running | VI126:1085 running |
| 84 | VIII115:1051 running; VIII115:1052 running | VI126:1086 running; VI126:1087 running |
| 85 | VIII115:1053 running | VI126:1088 running |
| 86 | VIII115:1054 running | VI126:1089 running |
| 87 | VIII115:1055 running | VI126:1090 running |
| 88 | VIII115:1056 running | VI126:1091 running |
| 89 | VIII115:1057 running | VI126:1092 running |
| 90 | VIII116:1058 running | VI126:1093 running |
| 91 | VIII116:1059 running | VI126:1094 running |
| 92 | VIII116:1060 running | VI126:1095 running |
| 93 | VIII116:1061 running | VI126:1096 running |
| 94 | VIII116:1062 running | VI126:1097 running |
| 95 | VIII116:1063 running | VI126:1098 running; VI127:1099 running · VI p.127 |
| 96 | VIII116 checked local gap between vv.1063 and 1064 | VI127:1099 running; VI127:1100 running |
| 97 | VIII116 checked local gap between vv.1063 and 1064 | VI127:1100 running |
New Naqqali