The Second Banquet
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6A second audience and a changed center of attention
Moscow — VIII120:1131 running, VIII120:1132 running, VIII121:1133 running, VIII121:1134 running, VIII121:1135 running, VIII121:1136 running · Mohl — VI130:1173 running, VI130:1174 running, VI130:1175 running, VI130:1176 running, VI130:1177 running, VI130:1178 running · Ganjoor — sh38:1 running, sh38:2 running, sh38:3 running, sh38:4 running, sh38:5 running, sh38:6 running · Khaleghi — VII184:1145 running, VII184:1146 running, VII184:1147 running, VII184:1148 running, VII184:1149 running, VII184:1150 running
Moscow VIII p.120 · Moscow VIII p.121 · Mohl VI p.130 · Ganjoor sh38:1 · Ganjoor sh38:2 · Ganjoor sh38:3 · Ganjoor sh38:4 · Ganjoor sh38:5 · Ganjoor sh38:6 · Khaleghi VII p.184
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi mark the passing of a week before this next meeting. The English opens with that interval, then sets the world’s affairs aside in favor of counsel. That suspension is the act of a king who can choose where to put his time. The group includes the young and the experienced in the Persian, so the learned youth’s position is among different ranks rather than a gathering of his peers. English makes the sages turn toward him as they gather near the throne. The rest of the scene confirms his new position by directing the questions to him.
7–12Labor, the narrow channel and the idle fool
Moscow — VIII121:1137 running, VIII121:1138 running; VIII121:1139 running, VIII121:1140 running, VIII121:1141 running, VIII121:1142 running, VIII121:1143 running · Mohl — VI130:1179 running, VI130:1180 running; VI130:1181 running, VI130:1182 running, VI130:1183 running, VI130:1184 running, VI130:1185 running · Ganjoor — sh38:7 running, sh38:8, sh38:9 running, sh38:10 running, sh38:11 running, sh38:12 running, sh38:13 running · Khaleghi — VII184:1151 running, VII184:1152 running; VII184:1153 running, VII184:1154 running, VII184:1155 running, VII184:1156 running, VII185:1157 running
Moscow VIII p.121 · Mohl VI p.130 · Ganjoor sh38:7 · Ganjoor sh38:8 · Ganjoor sh38:9 · Ganjoor sh38:10 · Ganjoor sh38:11 · Ganjoor sh38:12 · Ganjoor sh38:13 · Khaleghi VII p.184 · Khaleghi VII p.185
The king’s face brightens whenever he sees Bozorgmehr in the shared Persian accounts. The first inquiry turns the scene toward the workings of fate. English separates the burden of effort from the result by giving the scant flow in the channel a couplet of its own. That is a concrete image of livelihood apportioned, set beside the fool among scattered roses. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi use that disparity to bring the discourse to decree and destiny. The published phrase “bounds of its domain” generalizes the uneven dispensation into a limit, which prepares for the answer’s attribution of the star to God.
13–18What raises a person and what makes a person good
Moscow — VIII121:1144 running, VIII121:1145 running, VIII121:1146 running, VIII121:1147 running, VIII122:1148 running, VIII122:1149 running · Mohl — VI130:1186 running, VI130:1187 running, VI130:1188 running, VI130:1189 running, VI130:1190 running, VI130:1191 running · Ganjoor — sh38:14 running, sh38:15 running, sh38:16 running, sh38:17 running, sh38:18 running, sh38:19 running · Khaleghi — VII185:1158 running, VII185:1159 running, VII185:1160 running, VII185:1161 running, VII185:1162 running, VII185:1163 running
Moscow VIII p.121 · Moscow VIII p.122 · Mohl VI p.130 · Ganjoor sh38:14 · Ganjoor sh38:15 · Ganjoor sh38:16 · Ganjoor sh38:17 · Ganjoor sh38:18 · Ganjoor sh38:19 · Khaleghi VII p.185
In the question on attaining an advantage, Moscow and Ganjoor answer with greater knowledge. Mohl and Khaleghi emphasize greater exertion. English follows the knowledge reading and brings it into action in the second line, defensible in light of the shared emphasis on what manifests itself in conduct. The next question asks who deserves goodness and the answer distinguishes gentleness, generosity and worthiness. Humility consists in lowering oneself, while the gift seeks no compensation. Taken together, the questions prevent eminence from being reduced to good fortune. The English sequence presents what a person can do with learning even after the discourse admits limits to effort.
19–24Work, self-knowledge and honest dealings
Moscow — VIII122:1150 running, VIII122:1151 running, VIII122:1152 running, VIII122:1153 running, VIII122:1154 running, VIII122:1155 running · Mohl — VI130:1192 running, VI130:1193 running, VI130:1194 running, VI131:1195 running, VI131:1196 running, VI131:1197 running · Ganjoor — sh38:20 running, sh38:21 running, sh38:22 running, sh38:23 running, sh38:24 running, sh38:25 running · Khaleghi — VII185:1164 running, VII185:1165 running, VII185:1166 running, VII185:1167 running, VII185:1168 running, VII186:1169 running
Moscow VIII p.122 · Mohl VI p.130 · Mohl VI p.131 · Ganjoor sh38:20 · Ganjoor sh38:21 · Ganjoor sh38:22 · Ganjoor sh38:23 · Ganjoor sh38:24 · Ganjoor sh38:25 · Khaleghi VII p.185 · Khaleghi VII p.186
The laboring person is pictured among companions in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. The English broadens their presence into fellowship, then moves to the virtue needed under pressure. The Persian gives seeing one’s own fault and changing one’s way. English adds the attachment to a former habit, conveying the effort involved in amendment. The next answer derives inward ease from patience joined to wisdom. That inner condition has an outward test in upright giving and taking without crookedness. The honest scale is a plausible concretization for the English because the principle is introduced through dealings in which one gives and receives.
25–30Power, perseverance and the two springs
Moscow — VIII122:1156 running, VIII122:1157 running, VIII122:1158 running, VIII122:1159 running, VIII122:1160 running, VIII122:1161 running · Mohl — VI131:1198 running, VI131:1199 running, VI131:1200 running, VI131:1201 running, VI131:1202 running, VI131:1203 running · Ganjoor — sh38:26 running, sh38:27 running, sh38:28 running, sh38:29 running, sh38:30 running, sh38:31 running · Khaleghi — VII186:1170 running, VII186:1171 running, VII186:1172 running, VII186:1173 running, VII186:1174 running, VII186:1175 running
Moscow VIII p.122 · Mohl VI p.131 · Ganjoor sh38:26 · Ganjoor sh38:27 · Ganjoor sh38:28 · Ganjoor sh38:29 · Ganjoor sh38:30 · Ganjoor sh38:31 · Khaleghi VII p.186
Pardoning faults has force because the person under discussion is able to impose a penalty. The English extends that capacity to rule over a land, though the four Persian accounts express it more generally. In Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi, the next answer says a person does not abandon generosity or good disposition under the pressure of appetite, and does not slacken in work when times turn hard. In English the two conditions become the refusal to let craving govern a worthy deed and perseverance in distress. The year with two springs is already Persian, a compact measure of fruitful giving in this world and the next.
31–36A gift without leverage
Moscow — VIII123:1162 running, VIII123:1163 running, VIII123:1164 running, VIII123:1165 running; VIII123:1166 running, VIII123:1167 running, VIII123:1168 running · Mohl — VI131:1204 running, VI131:1205 running, VI131:1206 running, VI131:1207 running; VI131:1208 running, VI131:1209 running, VI132 checked local gap between vv.1209 and 1210 · Ganjoor — sh38:32 running, sh38:33 running, sh38:34 running, sh38:35, sh38:36 running, sh38:37 running, sh38:38 running · Khaleghi — VII186:1176 running, VII186:1177 running, VII186:1178 running, VII187:1179 running; VII187:1180 running, VII187:1181 running, VII187:1182 running
Moscow VIII p.123 · Mohl VI p.131 · Mohl VI p.132 · Ganjoor sh38:32 · Ganjoor sh38:33 · Ganjoor sh38:34 · Ganjoor sh38:35 · Ganjoor sh38:36 · Ganjoor sh38:37 · Ganjoor sh38:38 · Khaleghi VII p.186 · Khaleghi VII p.187
The four texts contrast a generous gift with commerce when the giver reminds the recipient of the obligation. English makes the anticipated payment thanks, a reasonable account of the social return instead of a separate monetary fee. The cypress illustrates becoming worthy by giving where the gift belongs. The unworthy person remains without fragrance even in musk, just as a dry thorn does not yield a rose. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi continue with a separate comparison about asking a deaf person to hear or a mute person to speak. Mohl’s local sequence ends with the thorn and moves directly into the next question, as English does.
37–42The rule of reciprocity and the time for work
Moscow — VIII123:1169 running, VIII123:1170 running, VIII123:1171 running, VIII123:1172 running, VIII123:1173 running, VIII123:1174 running; VIII123:1175 running · Mohl — VI131:1210 running, VI131:1211 running, VI131:1212 running, VI131:1213 running, VI131:1214 running, VI131:1215 running; VI131:1216 running · Ganjoor — sh38:39 running, sh38:40 running, sh38:41 running, sh38:42 running, sh38:43 running, sh38:44, sh38:45 running · Khaleghi — VII187:1183 running, VII187:1184 running, VII187:1185 running, VII187:1186 running, VII187:1187 running, VII187:1188 running; VII187:1189 running
Moscow VIII p.123 · Mohl VI p.131 · Ganjoor sh38:39 · Ganjoor sh38:40 · Ganjoor sh38:41 · Ganjoor sh38:42 · Ganjoor sh38:43 · Ganjoor sh38:44 · Ganjoor sh38:45 · Khaleghi VII p.187
No one escapes pain in the shared question, so the answer explains what conduct can preserve a good name rather than promising escape. The discipline is to keep away from sin and to test one’s dealings by what one would accept oneself. English makes the positive and negative sides of reciprocity legible as separate couplets. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi extend the thought to an enemy as well as to one’s own person or companions. The next question about exertion and reflection has a practical answer. Thought belongs with wisdom, while the appearance of work demands effort. The English preserves that difference in timing.
43–48Awe and the obligations of good fortune
Moscow — VIII123:1176 running, VIII124:1177 running, VIII124:1178 running, VIII124:1179 running, VIII124:1180 running, VIII124:1181 running · Mohl — VI131:1217 running, VI131:1218 running, VI131:1219 running, VI132:1220 running, VI132:1221 running, VI132:1222 running · Ganjoor — sh38:46 running, sh38:47 running, sh38:48 running, sh38:49 running, sh38:50 running, sh38:51 running · Khaleghi — VII187:1190 running, VII187:1191 running, VII188:1192 running, VII188:1193 running, VII188:1194 running, VII188:1195 running
Moscow VIII p.123 · Moscow VIII p.124 · Mohl VI p.131 · Mohl VI p.132 · Ganjoor sh38:46 · Ganjoor sh38:47 · Ganjoor sh38:48 · Ganjoor sh38:49 · Ganjoor sh38:50 · Ganjoor sh38:51 · Khaleghi VII p.187 · Khaleghi VII p.188
The question on blame involves tears over reprehensible conduct. In response, Bozorgmehr ties moral worth to hope and fear before God. The English image of a holy door gives those feelings a place to be directed, while the four Persian readings establish their object through the deity. The subsequent question makes the speaker ask which dealings of the heavens he would most welcome. The answer identifies safety and freedom from need, then asks the beneficiary to practice the justice already shown to him. The verse therefore treats one’s good portion as a source of obligation. English retains the initial turn from safety to justice.
49–54Patience amid insult, judgment and loss
Moscow — VIII124:1182 running, VIII124:1183 running, VIII124:1185 running, VIII124:1186 running, VIII124:1187 running, VIII124:1188 running · Mohl — VI132:1223 running, VI132:1224 running, VI132:1225 running, VI132:1226 running, VI132:1227 running, VI132:1228 running · Ganjoor — sh38:52 running, sh38:53 running, sh38:55 running, sh38:56 running, sh38:57 running, sh38:58 running · Khaleghi — VII188:1196 running, VII188:1197 running, VII188:1199 running, VII188:1200 running, VII188:1201 running, VII188:1202 running
Moscow VIII p.124 · Mohl VI p.132 · Ganjoor sh38:52 · Ganjoor sh38:53 · Ganjoor sh38:55 · Ganjoor sh38:56 · Ganjoor sh38:57 · Ganjoor sh38:58 · Khaleghi VII p.188
Patience in the answer is legible through the behavior of someone who does not let insolence and anger set his course. The English makes the character pardon faults, recalling the earlier answer on someone able to punish. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi put a question on avoiding harm within this sequence, while Mohl places it later. English proceeds like Mohl from patience to the question about a person who wins the wise man’s approval. The answer limits the grip of grief even when a loved one is laid in dust. It continues the movement from external pressures to an inward capacity for judgment.
55–60The barren willow and defects of rule
Moscow — VIII124:1189 running, VIII124:1190 running, VIII124:1191 running; VIII124:1192 running, VIII124:1192 running; VIII125:1193 running, VIII125:1194 running, VIII125:1195 running · Mohl — VI132:1229 running, VI132:1230 running, VI132:1231 running; VI132:1232 running, VI132:1232 running; VI132:1233 running, VI132:1234 running, VI132:1235 running · Ganjoor — sh38:59 running, sh38:60 running, sh38:61, sh38:62 running, sh38:62, sh38:63 running, sh38:64 running, sh38:65 running · Khaleghi — VII189:1203 running, VII189:1204 running, VII189:1205 running; VII189:1206 running, VII189:1206 running; VII189:1207 running, VII189:1208 running, VII189:1209 running
Moscow VIII p.124 · Moscow VIII p.125 · Mohl VI p.132 · Ganjoor sh38:59 · Ganjoor sh38:60 · Ganjoor sh38:61 · Ganjoor sh38:62 · Ganjoor sh38:63 · Ganjoor sh38:64 · Ganjoor sh38:65 · Khaleghi VII p.189
The willow’s want of fruit is the four accounts’ figure for hoping for what is unavailable. English closes the private counsel with that figure before asking about defects in a sovereign. The enumeration gives fear of an enemy, constriction in giving, dismissal of sound advice and continual unrest. The English makes advice especially urgent in proximity to an enemy, where the underlying Persian connects disregard of a wise man to a time of battle or trouble. It carries the fourth defect into the king’s inability to allow his own mind repose, preserving the practical damage caused by the failure to rest.
61–66The noble man’s faults and the place of truth
Moscow — VIII125:1196 running, VIII125:1197 running, VIII125:1198 running, VIII125:1199 running, VIII124:1184 running, VIII125 checked local gap around vv.1199–1200 and the earlier question at VIII124 v.1184 · Mohl — VI132:1236 running, VI132:1237 running, VI132:1239 running, VI132:1238 running, VI132:1240 running, VI132:1241 running · Ganjoor — sh38:66 running, sh38:67 running, sh38:68 running, sh38:69 running, sh38:54 running, Checked local gap after sh38:69 · Khaleghi — VII189:1210 running, VII189:1211 running, VII189:1212 running, VII189:1213 running, VII188:1198 running, VII189–VII190 checked local gap around vv.1213–1214 and the earlier question at VII188 v.1198
Moscow VIII p.125 · Moscow VIII p.124 · Mohl VI p.132 · Ganjoor sh38:66 · Ganjoor sh38:67 · Ganjoor sh38:68 · Ganjoor sh38:69 · Ganjoor sh38:54 · Khaleghi VII p.189 · Khaleghi VII p.188 · Khaleghi VII p.190
The faults named include deceit, injustice and needlessly wounding an upright person. The Persian also has going against the sovereign, for which “longs to seize the helm” is a developed English interpretation. Mohl moves the question on avoiding harm to this point and immediately gives an affirmative reply about the truthful speaker’s sound judgment. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi have the question earlier and lack this separate affirmation next to the warning about the shameless tongue. English follows Mohl in both placement and inclusion. That order makes truthful judgment the answer’s principle before Bozorgmehr turns to specific ways of behaving under provocation.
67–72Gentle speech and the safety of a household
Moscow — VIII125:1200 running, VIII125:1201 running, VIII125:1202 running, VIII125 checked local gap between vv.1202 and 1203, VIII125:1203 running, VIII125:1204 running · Mohl — VI132:1242 running, VI132:1243 running, VI132:1244 running, VI133:1245 running, VI133:1246 running, VI133:1247 running · Ganjoor — sh38:70 running, sh38:71 running, sh38:72 running, Checked local gap after sh38:72, sh38:73 running, sh38:74 running · Khaleghi — VII190:1214 running, VII190:1215 running, VII190:1216 running, VII190 checked local gap between vv.1216 and 1217, VII190:1217 running, VII190:1218 running
Moscow VIII p.125 · Mohl VI p.132 · Mohl VI p.133 · Ganjoor sh38:70 · Ganjoor sh38:71 · Ganjoor sh38:72 · Ganjoor sh38:73 · Ganjoor sh38:74 · Khaleghi VII p.190
Bozorgmehr counsels against a shameless tongue and look and preferring a shout to gentle speech. English turns the preference into an exchange so the cost of losing gentleness is clear. The four texts then move to a question about the secure person. Mohl gives a separate expansion about stewardship of one’s life, the benefit to relations and the outcome of one’s work. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi pass straight to the answer on recognizing God. English follows the fuller Mohl sequence. This makes the answer’s theology address an explicit household problem, and the following counsel shows how that recognition is put into practice.
73–78Obedience, subsistence and teaching the young
Moscow — VIII125:1205 running, VIII125:1206 running, VIII126:1207 running; VIII126:1208 running, VIII126:1208 running, VIII126:1209 running, VIII126:1210 running · Mohl — VI133:1248 running, VI133:1249 running, VI133:1250 running; VI133:1251 running, VI133:1251 running, VI133:1252 running, VI133:1253 running · Ganjoor — sh38:75 running, sh38:76 running, sh38:77, sh38:78 running, sh38:78 running, sh38:79 running, sh38:80 running · Khaleghi — VII190:1219 running, VII190:1220 running, VII190:1221 running; VII190:1222 running, VII190:1222 running, VII190:1223 running, VII190:1224 running
Moscow VIII p.125 · Moscow VIII p.126 · Mohl VI p.133 · Ganjoor sh38:75 · Ganjoor sh38:76 · Ganjoor sh38:77 · Ganjoor sh38:78 · Ganjoor sh38:79 · Ganjoor sh38:80 · Khaleghi VII p.190
The shared reply puts the Shah’s command beside the care of one’s own person and the exclusion of greed. It then broadens responsibility to kin, the poor and the education of children. The English keeps these planes close together and gives the children teachers rather than turning instruction into a vague aspiration. At the same time, the warning against leaving the world to fools occupies part of a Persian verse that English opens into its own couplet. The advice to a father follows the son’s readiness to receive instruction. This pairing makes obedience a condition that calls for kindness from the person in authority.
79–84Memory, means and social standing
Moscow — VIII126:1211 running, VIII126:1212 running, VIII126:1213 running, VIII126:1214 running, VIII126:1214 running; VIII126:1215 running, VIII126:1215 running · Mohl — VI133:1254 running, VI133:1255 running, VI133:1256 running, VI133:1257 running, VI133:1257 running; VI133:1258 running, VI133:1258 running · Ganjoor — sh38:81 running, sh38:82 running, sh38:83 running, sh38:84 running, sh38:84, sh38:85 running, sh38:85 running · Khaleghi — VII191:1225 running, VII191:1226 running, VII191:1227 running, VII191:1228 running, VII191:1228 running; VII191:1229 running, VII191:1229 running
Moscow VIII p.126 · Mohl VI p.133 · Ganjoor sh38:81 · Ganjoor sh38:82 · Ganjoor sh38:83 · Ganjoor sh38:84 · Ganjoor sh38:85 · Khaleghi VII p.191
The noble son is dear as life to his father and keeps the father’s name alive afterward in all four witnesses. English makes that survival audible with a brief statement attributed to the son. The question about money follows questions about a different kind of inheritance, but the answer begins with the fact that people honor wealth and hold poverty cheap. English gives the social conditions separate halves of a couplet and expands into the good that wealth can do. The Persian tests a person’s disposition by the use of wealth, allowing the published translation to make use, rather than abundance by itself, reveal character.
85–90A useless jewel, a useful ruler and genuine wealth
Moscow — VIII126:1216 running, VIII126:1217 running, VIII126:1218 running, VIII126:1219 running, VIII126:1220 running, VIII126:1221 running · Mohl — VI133:1259 running, VI133:1260 running, VI133:1261 running, VI133:1262 running, VI133:1263 running, VI133:1264 running · Ganjoor — sh38:86 running, sh38:87 running, sh38:88 running, sh38:89 running, sh38:90 running, sh38:91 running · Khaleghi — VII191:1230 running, VII191:1231 running, VII191:1232 running, VII191:1233 running, VII191:1234 running, VII191:1235 running
Moscow VIII p.126 · Mohl VI p.133 · Ganjoor sh38:86 · Ganjoor sh38:87 · Ganjoor sh38:88 · Ganjoor sh38:89 · Ganjoor sh38:90 · Ganjoor sh38:91 · Khaleghi VII p.191
The Persian treats the unused stone and royal jewel as equivalent, so English calls attention to hoarding as a way of destroying the distinction. In the inquiry about the best sovereign, all four accounts set the security of an upright person against the bad person’s fear of his voice. The English earth at rest under the throne gives political order a physical consequence. The next question turns the distinction back toward wealth and poverty. The rich man is content with what he has been given by God. That response returns material resources to their relation to judgment and conduct after the account of good government.
91–93Greed, wonder and the end of the second banquet
Moscow — VIII126:1222 running, VIII127:1223 running · Mohl — VI133:1265 running, VI133:1266 running · Ganjoor — sh38:92 running, sh38:93 running · Khaleghi — VII191:1236 running, VII192:1237 running
Moscow VIII p.126 · Moscow VIII p.127 · Mohl VI p.133 · Ganjoor sh38:92 · Ganjoor sh38:93 · Khaleghi VII p.191 · Khaleghi VII p.192
Greed is the distress that makes a person poor even in an inquiry framed around riches, while contentment makes the apparent reverse possible. The English puts greed last in Bozorgmehr’s answer, completing the argument before the listeners react. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi close the assembly’s reaction in a single couplet. English separates the court’s wonder from its praise, giving the young speaker the weight of a formal assent at the end of this chapter. Mohl, Moscow and Khaleghi begin the third gathering immediately afterward, and the Ganjoor division likewise closes here before the next banquet. The English boundary preserves that interval.
Source record and limits
English
93 published English couplets. Ganjoor passages: Anooshirvan §38: 1–93. The English text follows the published verse and chapter divisions.
Moscow
The 1970 Moscow edition, volume VIII, printed pages 120–127. The source register identifies the individual running verses and any printed apparatus cited.
Mohl
Jules Mohl’s Persian text, volume VI, printed pages 130–133. The running sequence includes some lines here that Moscow and Khaleghi give in their apparatus.
Ganjoor
Anooshirvan §38: 1–93. The Persian column gives the corresponding running verses and identifies where Mohl supplies an independent couplet for a local Ganjoor gap.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Djalal Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VII, printed pages 184–192. Square brackets mark verses retained in the main text with explicit editorial reservation. Printed additions have their own locators.
The order of the questions
Mohl places a question about avoiding harm immediately before a reply set in terms of truth. The English adopts this arrangement. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi run the related question several verses earlier. These three also preserve a separate deaf-and-mute analogy following the dry thorn.
Consequential readings
English 15. Moscow and Ganjoor answer with the person who knows more. Mohl and Khaleghi place the accent on greater exertion. English follows the knowledge reading and keeps the shared emphasis on its practical effect. English 18. Humility lowers the head and giving is detached from advantage. English uses the pairing to develop an account of service. English 30. The sources describe fruit in two worlds through the image of a year bringing two springs. English brings the comparison forward by making it close the question. English 36. English divides the musk and thorn imagery across two couplets. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also give a separate analogy without a corresponding English verse. Mohl proceeds to the next question. English 50. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi place a general question about what keeps a person from harm here. Mohl runs the corresponding question closer to its answer, where English also places it. English 65. English puts this question near the reply on verbal conduct, as Mohl does. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give it earlier in the exchange. English 66. Mohl gives explicit truthful speech as an introductory answer. The other texts give the adjacent injunction concerning the tongue, the look and the tone of voice. English 70. Mohl expands the question with care of one’s life and kin and a guarded outcome. The other texts pass straight to the answer on knowing God. English 91. The Persian describes greed as the greatest distress at the end of the question about poverty. English makes discontent and greed form the answer’s concluding contrast. English 93. The group’s wonder and praise close the banquet in a single couplet in all four. English gives each reaction a separate couplet.
Limits of the evidence
Running text, bracketed running text, actual printed apparatus and checked local gaps indicate distinct kinds of support. Local gaps concern the specified passage. No appendix reading is invoked. The geographical and institutional terms describe the poem’s account.
Source-only verses
S1. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi run a separate analogy about asking a deaf person to hear or a mute person to speak. Mohl and English proceed directly to the question on living honorably.
Moscow VIII p.120 · Moscow VIII p.121 · Moscow VIII p.122 · Moscow VIII p.123 · Moscow VIII p.124 · Moscow VIII p.125 · Moscow VIII p.126 · Moscow VIII p.127
Mohl VI p.130 · Mohl VI p.131 · Mohl VI p.132 · Mohl VI p.133
Khaleghi VII p.184 · Khaleghi VII p.185 · Khaleghi VII p.186 · Khaleghi VII p.187 · Khaleghi VII p.188 · Khaleghi VII p.189 · Khaleghi VII p.190 · Khaleghi VII p.191 · Khaleghi VII p.192
Selected printed readings
- Khaleghi VII185:1160 running · چنین گفت کانکس که کوشندهتر
Khaleghi names the one who strives harder. - Moscow VIII122:1161 running · به سالی دو بارش بهار آورد
A year that brings two springs figures bounty in both worlds. - Mohl VI132:1241 running · چنین گفت کان کو بود راستگوی
Mohl makes truthful speech an independent answer. - Mohl VI133:1250 running · بر افزودن توشهٔ درویش را
Providing for the poor appears beside kin and education. - Mohl VI133:1259 running · همان سنگ و آن گوهر شاهوار
A royal jewel and a stone are equivalent when kept idle. - Mohl VI133:1266 running · همه هم زبان آفرین خواندند
One Persian verse gives both the listeners’ wonder and their praise.
D13.20.3 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII120:1131 running | VI130:1173 running |
| 2 | VIII120:1132 running | VI130:1174 running |
| 3 | VIII121:1133 running | VI130:1175 running |
| 4 | VIII121:1134 running | VI130:1176 running |
| 5 | VIII121:1135 running | VI130:1177 running |
| 6 | VIII121:1136 running | VI130:1178 running |
| 7 | VIII121:1137 running | VI130:1179 running |
| 8 | VIII121:1138 running; VIII121:1139 running | VI130:1180 running; VI130:1181 running |
| 9 | VIII121:1140 running | VI130:1182 running |
| 10 | VIII121:1141 running | VI130:1183 running |
| 11 | VIII121:1142 running | VI130:1184 running |
| 12 | VIII121:1143 running | VI130:1185 running |
| 13 | VIII121:1144 running | VI130:1186 running |
| 14 | VIII121:1145 running | VI130:1187 running |
| 15 | VIII121:1146 running | VI130:1188 running |
| 16 | VIII121:1147 running | VI130:1189 running |
| 17 | VIII122:1148 running | VI130:1190 running |
| 18 | VIII122:1149 running | VI130:1191 running |
| 19 | VIII122:1150 running | VI130:1192 running |
| 20 | VIII122:1151 running | VI130:1193 running |
| 21 | VIII122:1152 running | VI130:1194 running |
| 22 | VIII122:1153 running | VI131:1195 running |
| 23 | VIII122:1154 running | VI131:1196 running |
| 24 | VIII122:1155 running | VI131:1197 running |
| 25 | VIII122:1156 running | VI131:1198 running |
| 26 | VIII122:1157 running | VI131:1199 running |
| 27 | VIII122:1158 running | VI131:1200 running |
| 28 | VIII122:1159 running | VI131:1201 running |
| 29 | VIII122:1160 running | VI131:1202 running |
| 30 | VIII122:1161 running | VI131:1203 running |
| 31 | VIII123:1162 running | VI131:1204 running |
| 32 | VIII123:1163 running | VI131:1205 running |
| 33 | VIII123:1164 running | VI131:1206 running |
| 34 | VIII123:1165 running; VIII123:1166 running | VI131:1207 running; VI131:1208 running |
| 35 | VIII123:1167 running | VI131:1209 running |
| 36 | VIII123:1167 running | VI131:1209 running |
| 37 | VIII123:1169 running | VI131:1210 running |
| 38 | VIII123:1170 running | VI131:1211 running |
| 39 | VIII123:1171 running | VI131:1212 running |
| 40 | VIII123:1172 running | VI131:1213 running |
| 41 | VIII123:1173 running | VI131:1214 running |
| 42 | VIII123:1174 running; VIII123:1175 running | VI131:1215 running; VI131:1216 running |
| 43 | VIII123:1176 running | VI131:1217 running |
| 44 | VIII124:1177 running | VI131:1218 running |
| 45 | VIII124:1178 running | VI131:1219 running |
| 46 | VIII124:1179 running | VI132:1220 running |
| 47 | VIII124:1180 running | VI132:1221 running |
| 48 | VIII124:1181 running | VI132:1222 running |
| 49 | VIII124:1182 running | VI132:1223 running |
| 50 | VIII124:1183 running | VI132:1224 running |
| 51 | VIII124:1185 running | VI132:1225 running |
| 52 | VIII124:1186 running | VI132:1226 running |
| 53 | VIII124:1187 running | VI132:1227 running |
| 54 | VIII124:1188 running | VI132:1228 running |
| 55 | VIII124:1189 running | VI132:1229 running |
| 56 | VIII124:1190 running | VI132:1230 running |
| 57 | VIII124:1191 running; VIII124:1192 running | VI132:1231 running; VI132:1232 running |
| 58 | VIII124:1192 running; VIII125:1193 running · VIII p.125 | VI132:1232 running; VI132:1233 running |
| 59 | VIII125:1194 running | VI132:1234 running |
| 60 | VIII125:1195 running | VI132:1235 running |
| 61 | VIII125:1196 running | VI132:1236 running |
| 62 | VIII125:1197 running | VI132:1237 running |
| 63 | VIII125:1198 running | VI132:1239 running |
| 64 | VIII125:1199 running | VI132:1238 running |
| 65 | VIII124:1184 running | VI132:1240 running |
| 66 | VIII125 checked local gap around vv.1199–1200 and the earlier question at VIII124 v.1184 · VIII p.124 | VI132:1241 running |
| 67 | VIII125:1200 running | VI132:1242 running |
| 68 | VIII125:1201 running | VI132:1243 running |
| 69 | VIII125:1202 running | VI132:1244 running |
| 70 | VIII125 checked local gap between vv.1202 and 1203 | VI133:1245 running |
| 71 | VIII125:1203 running | VI133:1246 running |
| 72 | VIII125:1204 running | VI133:1247 running |
| 73 | VIII125:1205 running | VI133:1248 running |
| 74 | VIII125:1206 running | VI133:1249 running |
| 75 | VIII126:1207 running; VIII126:1208 running | VI133:1250 running; VI133:1251 running |
| 76 | VIII126:1208 running | VI133:1251 running |
| 77 | VIII126:1209 running | VI133:1252 running |
| 78 | VIII126:1210 running | VI133:1253 running |
| 79 | VIII126:1211 running | VI133:1254 running |
| 80 | VIII126:1212 running | VI133:1255 running |
| 81 | VIII126:1213 running | VI133:1256 running |
| 82 | VIII126:1214 running | VI133:1257 running |
| 83 | VIII126:1214 running; VIII126:1215 running | VI133:1257 running; VI133:1258 running |
| 84 | VIII126:1215 running | VI133:1258 running |
| 85 | VIII126:1216 running | VI133:1259 running |
| 86 | VIII126:1217 running | VI133:1260 running |
| 87 | VIII126:1218 running | VI133:1261 running |
| 88 | VIII126:1219 running | VI133:1262 running |
| 89 | VIII126:1220 running | VI133:1263 running |
| 90 | VIII126:1221 running | VI133:1264 running |
| 91 | VIII126:1222 running | VI133:1265 running |
| 92 | VIII127:1223 running | VI133:1266 running |
| 93 | VIII127:1223 running | VI133:1266 running |
New Naqqali