Anooshirvan’s Decree of Justice
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The measured realm
Moscow — VIII56:56 running, VIII56:57 running, VIII56:58 running, VIII56:59 running, VIII56:60 running, VIII56:61 running · Mohl — VI83:57 running, VI83:58 running, VI83:59 running, VI83:60 running, VI83:61 running, VI83:62 running · Ganjoor — sh2:3 running, sh2:4 running, sh2:5 running, sh2:6 running, sh2:7 running, sh2:8 running · Khaleghi — VII92:69 running, VII92:70 running, VII92:71 running, VII93:72 running, VII93:73 running, VII93:74 running
Moscow VIII p.56 · Mohl VI p.83 · Ganjoor sh2:3 · Ganjoor sh2:4 · Ganjoor sh2:5 · Ganjoor sh2:6 · Ganjoor sh2:7 · Ganjoor sh2:8 · Khaleghi VII p.92 · Khaleghi VII p.93
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi bring knowledgeable men together before the king allots four regions. The English adds rulers, laws and stores to the short phrase about assigning settled cities, making the practical consequences of the division explicit. It keeps the first region’s connection to Khorasan and noble satisfaction. Qum and Isfahan then enter the second region alongside Azar Abadagan. The textual list that follows contains another name beside Armenia, Ardabil and Gil, which the English condenses into the coast and its recognizable places. This choice is effective as geographical orientation, with the Persian line preserving a further name for a reader comparing the lists.
7–12Territory, labor and surplus
Moscow — VIII56:62 running, VIII56:63 running, VIII56:64 running, VIII56:65 running, VIII56:66 running, VIII57:67 running · Mohl — VI83:63 running, VI83:64 running, VI83:65 running, VI84:66 running, VI84:67 running, VI84:68 running · Ganjoor — sh2:9 running, sh2:10 running, sh2:11 running, sh2:12 running, sh2:13 running, sh2:14 running · Khaleghi — VII93:75 running, VII93:76 running, VII93:77 running, VII93:78 running, VII93:79 running, VII93:80 running
Moscow VIII p.56 · Moscow VIII p.57 · Mohl VI p.83 · Mohl VI p.84 · Ganjoor sh2:9 · Ganjoor sh2:10 · Ganjoor sh2:11 · Ganjoor sh2:12 · Ganjoor sh2:13 · Ganjoor sh2:14 · Khaleghi VII p.93
The four versions send the third region from east to west, naming Pars, Ahvaz and the Khazar frontier, then turn to Iraq and Rum in the fourth. English follows both lists and emphasizes a populous, orderly realm. The measure of that order soon becomes how the poor live from their own effort. A dense treasury is spent on them, and praise immediately follows the gift. English “opened up the treasures” makes this release the reverse of simply storing wealth. When the account turns to older kings’ portions of crops and harvest, it gives the reader a clear sense that their precedent touched every landholder.
13–18A tenth and an unfinished reform
Moscow — VIII57:68 running, VIII57:69 running, VIII57:69 running; VIII57:70 running, VIII57:70 running, VIII57:71 running, VIII57:72 running · Mohl — VI84:69 running, VI84:70 running, VI84:70 running; VI84:71 running, VI84:71 running, VI84:72 running, VI84:73 running · Ganjoor — sh2:15 running, sh2:16 running, sh2:16, sh2:17 running, sh2:17 running, sh2:18 running, sh2:19 running · Khaleghi — VII93:81 running, VII93:82 running, VII93:82 running; VII94:83 running, VII94:83 running, VII94:84 running, VII94:85 running
Moscow VIII p.57 · Mohl VI p.84 · Ganjoor sh2:15 · Ganjoor sh2:16 · Ganjoor sh2:17 · Ganjoor sh2:18 · Ganjoor sh2:19 · Khaleghi VII p.93 · Khaleghi VII p.94
A third or a fourth of the produce is the earlier royal portion in all four accounts. Qobad imposes a tenth and means to reduce it, with the accompanying purpose of raising the small toward the standing of the great. English divides the purpose and its thwarting into separate couplets. Its transliterated nahang preserves the uncertain and threatening creature in the sea, while the added dream brings out the vulnerability of the reformer’s plans. The narrative then transfers the opportunity to Kisra. The English names assessment directly as the replacement for the tenth, preparing for the measuring cords and the new royal council.
19–24Measurement and cultivation
Moscow — VIII57:73 running, VIII57:74 running, VIII57:75 running; VIII57:76 running, VIII57:77 running, VIII57:78 running · Mohl — VI84:74 running, VI84:75 running, VI84:76 running; VI84:77 running, VI84:78 running, VI84:79 running · Ganjoor — sh2:20 running, sh2:21 running, sh2:22, sh2:23 running, sh2:24 running, sh2:25 running · Khaleghi — VII94:86 running, VII94:87 running, VII94:88 running; VII94:89 running, VII94:90 running, VII94:91 running
Moscow VIII p.57 · Mohl VI p.84 · Ganjoor sh2:20 · Ganjoor sh2:21 · Ganjoor sh2:22 · Ganjoor sh2:23 · Ganjoor sh2:24 · Ganjoor sh2:25 · Khaleghi VII p.94
The land is apportioned and marked with a cord in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. One dirham is named along with the concern that the cultivator should not be distressed. English places the physical survey and the fiscal demand in one couplet, then gives the restraint of the levy another. Royal stores supply seed or a working animal where the cultivator lacks either, so the fiscal reform protects capacity to cultivate. The English makes completion of the crop the goal of that aid. Uncultivated land is excluded from the account, an institutional change that marks the end of the previously described custom.
25–30The orchard rate and the calendar
Moscow — VIII57:79 running, VIII57:80 running, VIII57:81 running, VIII57:82 running, VIII57:83 running, VIII58:84 running; VIII58:85 running · Mohl — VI84:80 running, VI84:81 running, VI84:82 running, VI84:83 running, VI84:84 running, VI84:85 running; VI84:86 running · Ganjoor — sh2:26 running, sh2:27 running, sh2:28 running, sh2:29 running, sh2:30 running, sh2:31, sh2:32 running · Khaleghi — VII94:92 running, VII94:93 running, VII94:94 running, VII94:95 running, VII95:96 running, VII95:97 running; VII95:98 running
Moscow VIII p.57 · Moscow VIII p.58 · Mohl VI p.84 · Ganjoor sh2:26 · Ganjoor sh2:27 · Ganjoor sh2:28 · Ganjoor sh2:29 · Ganjoor sh2:30 · Ganjoor sh2:31 · Ganjoor sh2:32 · Khaleghi VII p.94 · Khaleghi VII p.95
All four editions give fruiting orchard trees a measured levy in relation to ten roots or trees. English keeps the one-in-ten numerical form while leaving the unit after ten unstated, so the trees named in the preceding couplet carry the context. The reference to Mehrgan distinguishes fruit then on the branches from produce of Khordad, which is exempt here. The text then changes tax base to people with money who do not cultivate land. English follows both the stated four-to-ten-dirham range and its year of three installments. The four-month due date makes a concrete rhythm of what might otherwise read as a simple list of rates.
31–36Who can see the account
Moscow — VIII58:86 running, VIII58:87 running, VIII58:88 running, VIII58:89 running, VIII58:90 running; VIII58:91 running · Mohl — VI84:87 running, VI84:88 running, VI84:89 running, VI84:90 running, VI85:91 running; VI85:92 running · Ganjoor — sh2:33 running, sh2:34 running, sh2:35 running, sh2:36 running, sh2:37, sh2:38 running · Khaleghi — VII95:99 running, VII95:100 running, VII95:101 running, VII95:102 running, VII95:103 running; VII95:104 running
Moscow VIII p.58 · Mohl VI p.84 · Mohl VI p.85 · Ganjoor sh2:33 · Ganjoor sh2:34 · Ganjoor sh2:35 · Ganjoor sh2:36 · Ganjoor sh2:37 · Ganjoor sh2:38 · Khaleghi VII p.95
The four Persian accounts exempt the scribes and servants of the shah from the charge just discussed. The next action enumerates dues and assigns three records to the treasury, regional officials and the Mobad. English distinguishes the three ledgers cleanly and gives accountability an active phrase in “answer every test.” The Persian explicitly puts one record in the hands of the treasurer with the minister as keeper, so the oversight is spread through several offices. At the last distribution the Persian also links the priestly recipient to counting the original levies and supervisory authority. The English presents the same structure in terms of who keeps each account.
37–42From the register to the royal letter
Moscow — VIII58:92 running, VIII58:93 running, VIII58:94 running, VIII58:95 running, VIII58:97 running, VIII58:96 running · Mohl — VI85:93 running, VI85:94 running, VI85:95 running, VI85:96 running, VI85:98 running, VI85:97 running · Ganjoor — sh2:39 running, sh2:40 running, sh2:41 running, sh3:1 running, sh3:3 running, sh3:2 running · Khaleghi — VII95:105 running, VII95:106 running, VII95:107 running, VII96:108 running, VII96:110 running, VII96:109 running
Moscow VIII p.58 · Mohl VI p.85 · Ganjoor sh2:39 · Ganjoor sh2:40 · Ganjoor sh2:41 · Ganjoor sh3:1 · Ganjoor sh3:3 · Ganjoor sh3:2 · Khaleghi VII p.95 · Khaleghi VII p.96
Watchers are dispersed in the four running narratives to keep good and bad from remaining hidden from the king. English preserves that practical instrument beside the broader claim that ruined places become flourishing again. The sheep and wolf at the drinking place then offer an image of security shared by small and great. English gives fearlessness to both animals, broadening the scene’s force. The shift to the letter preserves the named Pahlavi medium, followed by the day Bahram and month Khordad. Persian identifies the writer before specifying the date. English reverses those introductory actions and so gives the formal address a more distinct opening.
43–48From the royal tree to the Maker
Moscow — VIII58:98 running, VIII58:99 running, VIII59:100 running, VIII59:101 running, VIII59:102 running, VIII59:103 running · Mohl — VI85:99 running, VI85:100 running, VI85:101 running, VI85:102 running, VI85:103 running, VI85:104 running · Ganjoor — sh3:4 running, sh3:5 running, sh3:6 running, sh3:7 running, sh3:8 running, sh3:9 running · Khaleghi — VII96:111 running, VII96:112 running, VII96:113 running, VII96:114 running, VII96:115 running, VII96:116 running
Moscow VIII p.58 · Moscow VIII p.59 · Mohl VI p.85 · Ganjoor sh3:4 · Ganjoor sh3:5 · Ganjoor sh3:6 · Ganjoor sh3:7 · Ganjoor sh3:8 · Ganjoor sh3:9 · Khaleghi VII p.96
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi call Kisra a fruitful branch of Qobad’s tree before naming his stewards of dues and tribute. The English retains that image and extends the throne’s shadow toward the officers, lending the address a connection to the protection that will be tested later. Its greeting recognizes merit and descent, both present in Persian. Praise of the world’s maker then makes a fresh beginning partway through the letter. The English turns the knowledgeable man’s thankfulness into a habitual art. God’s independence and awareness of what is hidden define an exacting model for the human administration that has just been described.
49–54Independence, judgment and the ant
Moscow — VIII59:104 running, VIII59:105 running, VIII59:106 running, VIII59:107 running, VIII59:108 running, VIII59:109 running · Mohl — VI85:105 running, VI85:106 running, VI85:107 running, VI85:108 running, VI85:109 running, VI85:110 running · Ganjoor — sh3:10 running, sh3:11 running, sh3:12 running, sh3:13 running, sh3:14 running, sh3:15 running · Khaleghi — VII96:117 running, VII96:118 running, VII96:119 running, VII96:120 running, VII96:121 running, VII96:122 running
Moscow VIII p.59 · Mohl VI p.85 · Ganjoor sh3:10 · Ganjoor sh3:11 · Ganjoor sh3:12 · Ganjoor sh3:13 · Ganjoor sh3:14 · Ganjoor sh3:15 · Khaleghi VII p.96
Raising a person and making him free of want are linked in all four witnesses. The shah then defines his own arbitration as a commission from the true judge. English gives special force to the equality of king and subject before that higher authority. The scale contracts from the lowest earth and highest sphere to the ant’s foot itself. The miniature witness keeps the theological claim from being the preserve of royal emblems and thunderous signs. English retains that change of scale. Its moral darkness gives a visual consequence to the Persian distortion and defect that the Div brings into otherwise straight command.
55–60A garden and the reach of kingship
Moscow — VIII59:110 running, VIII59:111 running, VIII59:112 running, VIII59:113 running, VIII59:114 running, VIII59:115 running · Mohl — VI85:111 running, VI85:112 running, VI85:113 running, VI85:114 running, VI86:115 running, VI86:116 running · Ganjoor — sh3:16 running, sh3:17 running, sh3:18 running, sh3:19 running, sh3:20 running, sh3:21 running · Khaleghi — VII96:123 running, VII97:124 running, VII97:125 running, VII97:126 running, VII97:127 running, VII97:128 running
Moscow VIII p.59 · Mohl VI p.85 · Mohl VI p.86 · Ganjoor sh3:16 · Ganjoor sh3:17 · Ganjoor sh3:18 · Ganjoor sh3:19 · Ganjoor sh3:20 · Ganjoor sh3:21 · Khaleghi VII p.96 · Khaleghi VII p.97
The shah imagines possessing only a garden, residence and treasure, and says his heart would still seek justice and affection in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English makes the garden grove and palace his hypothetical allotment, setting private resources against the reach of the actual realm. It then preserves the two directions used to indicate kingship’s extent, from east to west and from sun to dark earth. That authority creates an obligation that grows with its scope. The poor shepherd and wide field bring the political argument into a vivid example of negligence. English makes total exposure explicit by saying no sheep escape.
61–66At land, at sea and in the market
Moscow — VIII59:116 running, VIII59:117 running, VIII60:118 running, VIII60:119 running, VIII60:120 running, VIII60:121 running · Mohl — VI86:117 running, VI86:118 running, VI86:119 running, VI86:120 running, VI86:121 running, VI86:122 running · Ganjoor — sh3:22 running, sh3:23 running, sh3:24 running, sh3:25 running, sh3:26 running, sh3:27 running · Khaleghi — VII97:129 running, VII97:130 running, VII97:131 running, VII97:132 running, VII97:133 running, VII97:134 running
Moscow VIII p.59 · Moscow VIII p.60 · Mohl VI p.86 · Ganjoor sh3:22 · Ganjoor sh3:23 · Ganjoor sh3:24 · Ganjoor sh3:25 · Ganjoor sh3:26 · Ganjoor sh3:27 · Khaleghi VII p.97
The Persian addresses cultivators, people of the faith and traders, giving the roads and ships and the times of sleeping and waking as their settings. English makes the people of the faith visible at sacred fires, a concrete development of their designation. Pearls and musk are retained as cargo alongside coin in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. The shah measures the wished-for constancy of justice by the sun shining on that community. He also imagines the succession of sons to fathers under a custom in which hidden conduct and public conduct agreed. English renders that agreement as the absence of a deed masked by fraud.
67–72One dirham and the oath
Moscow — VIII60:122 running, VIII60:123 running, VIII60:124 running, VIII60:125 running, VIII60:125 running; VIII60:126 running, VIII60:127 running · Mohl — VI86:123 running, VI86:124 running, VI86:125 running, VI86:126 running, VI86:126 running; VI86:127 running, VI86:128 running · Ganjoor — sh3:28 running, sh3:29 running, sh3:30 running, sh3:31 running, sh3:31, sh3:32 running, sh3:33 running · Khaleghi — VII97:135 running, VII97:136 running, VII97:137 running, VII98:138 running, VII98:138 running; VII98:139 running, VII98:140 running
Moscow VIII p.60 · Mohl VI p.86 · Ganjoor sh3:28 · Ganjoor sh3:29 · Ganjoor sh3:30 · Ganjoor sh3:31 · Ganjoor sh3:32 · Ganjoor sh3:33 · Khaleghi VII p.97 · Khaleghi VII p.98
All four editions make one excess dirham a test of the new system. English duly puts the single coin next to the subject it wrongs. The invocation of Ormozd occurs when the letter is brought to its recipients and has the force of a blessing, which the English keeps before turning to the threat. The penalty invokes divine sanction and the shah’s direct agency. English distributes the oath and the punishment over two couplets, making room for resistance in the image of a shield that cannot protect the wrongdoer. The injunction to follow the document then binds a powerful threat to a repeatable standard.
73–78Taking account of loss
Moscow — VIII60:128 running, VIII60:129 running, VIII60:130 running, VIII60:131 running, VIII60:132 running, VIII60:133 running · Mohl — VI86:129 running, VI86:130 running, VI86:131 running, VI86:132 running, VI86:133 running, VI86:134 running · Ganjoor — sh3:34 running, sh3:35 running, sh3:36 running, sh3:37 running, sh3:38 running, sh3:39 running · Khaleghi — VII98:141 running, VII98:142 running, VII98:143 running, VII98:144 running, VII98:145 running, VII98:146 running
Moscow VIII p.60 · Mohl VI p.86 · Ganjoor sh3:34 · Ganjoor sh3:35 · Ganjoor sh3:36 · Ganjoor sh3:37 · Ganjoor sh3:38 · Ganjoor sh3:39 · Khaleghi VII p.98
The four-month interval returns in the letter as the allowable demand. Then the officials are instructed how to respond when a harvest is damaged by locusts, heat or the failure of New Year’s rain. Mohl and Khaleghi explicitly name snow and wind together. Moscow and Ganjoor’s running line gives wind without explicitly naming snow. The published English follows Mohl for that hazard. Its “full hire” makes the relief sound assured and complete. The source’s express pairing of seed and labor expenses is the foundation for that choice. The expenditure from the treasury offsets a bad season’s loss rather than demanding revenue from crops that failed.
79–84Land held under the royal shadow
Moscow — VIII60:134 running, VIII60:135 running; VIII60:136 running, VIII61:137 running, VIII61:138 running, VIII61:139 running, VIII61:140 running · Mohl — VI86:135 running, VI86:136 running; VI86:137 running, VI86:138 running, VI87:139 running, VI87:140 running, VI87:141 running · Ganjoor — sh3:40 running, sh3:41, sh3:42 running, sh3:43 running, sh3:44 running, sh3:45 running, sh3:46 running · Khaleghi — VII98:147 running, VII98:148 running; VII99:149 running, VII99:150 running, VII99:151 running, VII99:152 running, VII99:153 running
Moscow VIII p.60 · Moscow VIII p.61 · Mohl VI p.86 · Mohl VI p.87 · Ganjoor sh3:40 · Ganjoor sh3:41 · Ganjoor sh3:42 · Ganjoor sh3:43 · Ganjoor sh3:44 · Ganjoor sh3:45 · Ganjoor sh3:46 · Khaleghi VII p.98 · Khaleghi VII p.99
All four witnesses attend to land whose owner has died without kin. Leaving it wasted would make a public accusation possible, and English aptly places the shame in the mouths of people who wish the shah ill. Because God has put the ruler beyond personal want, treasury goods are available to address the damage. The Persian connects that responsibility to the shade of the king’s farr. English develops it as the shelter of a wing and an arm, making protectiveness active. The threat of hanging reaches both high and low officers, which matches the text’s distinction of rank and its indifference to rank in the penalty.
85–90The treasury of justice
Moscow — VIII61:141 running; VIII61:142 running, VIII61:143 running; VIII61:144 running, VIII61:144 running, VIII61:145 running, VIII61:147 running, VIII61:149 running, VIII61:146 running, VIII61:148 running · Mohl — VI87:142 running; VI87:143 running, VI87:144 running; VI87:145 running, VI87:145 running, VI87:146 running, VI87:148 running, VI87:150 running, VI87:147 running, VI87:149 running · Ganjoor — sh3:47, sh3:48 running, sh3:49, sh3:50 running, sh3:50 running, sh3:51 running, sh3:53 running, sh3:55 running, sh3:52 running, sh3:54 running · Khaleghi — VII99:154 running; VII99:155 running, VII99:156 running; VII99:157 running, VII99:157 running, VII99:158 running, VII99:160 running, VII100:162 running, VII99:159 running, VII99:161 running
Moscow VIII p.61 · Mohl VI p.87 · Ganjoor sh3:47 · Ganjoor sh3:48 · Ganjoor sh3:49 · Ganjoor sh3:50 · Ganjoor sh3:51 · Ganjoor sh3:53 · Ganjoor sh3:55 · Ganjoor sh3:52 · Ganjoor sh3:54 · Khaleghi VII p.99 · Khaleghi VII p.100
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi contrast former rulers and their officials with the shah’s claim that his own treasury is justice and his army the men of the land. English “wealth no thief can hold” tells the reader why justice is a different kind of possession. That extension works with the refusal to set the royal gaze on coins. The accountable steward defends right and honors inherited standing, while the commander who sells people for silver or gold is excluded. English takes this harsh condition seriously through “barters men.” The court before the Mobad then offers an institutional setting where accounts can be examined.
91–96The leopard and the cleansing water
Moscow — VIII61:150 running, VIII61:151 running, VIII61:152 running, VIII61:153 running, VIII61:154 running, VIII61:155 running · Mohl — VI87:151 running, VI87:152 running, VI87:153 running, VI87:154 running, VI87:155 running, VI87:156 running · Ganjoor — sh3:56 running, sh3:57 running, sh3:58 running, sh3:59 running, sh3:60 running, sh3:61 running · Khaleghi — VII100:163 running, VII100:164 running, VII100:165 running, VII100:166 running, VII100:167 running, VII100:168 running
Moscow VIII p.61 · Mohl VI p.87 · Ganjoor sh3:56 · Ganjoor sh3:57 · Ganjoor sh3:58 · Ganjoor sh3:59 · Ganjoor sh3:60 · Ganjoor sh3:61 · Khaleghi VII p.100
False speech costs the officer favor, and all four running sequences compare the unjust man and the leopard. English keeps the repudiation of cruelty and puts the two in one place, making their moral proximity clear. The counterweight is a person who seeks God’s road and washes a dark soul in the water of wisdom. English combines bathing and cleansing with a ray, keeping the purification but shifting part of its physical figure to light. The seed that will reap paradise gives a second concrete measure of service. It follows an appointment at court and praise from the priests, linking reward here and reward beyond the court.
97–102The double life of injustice
Moscow — VIII62:156 running, VIII62:157 running, VIII62:158 running, VIII62:159 running, VIII62:160 running, VIII62:161 running · Mohl — VI87:157 running, VI87:158 running, VI87:159 running, VI87:160 running, VI87:161 running, VI87:162 running · Ganjoor — sh3:62 running, sh3:63 running, sh3:64 running, sh3:65 running, sh3:66 running, sh3:67 running · Khaleghi — VII100:169 running, VII100:170 running, VII100:171 running, VII100:172 running, VII100:173 running, VII100:174 running
Moscow VIII p.62 · Mohl VI p.87 · Ganjoor sh3:62 · Ganjoor sh3:63 · Ganjoor sh3:64 · Ganjoor sh3:65 · Ganjoor sh3:66 · Ganjoor sh3:67 · Khaleghi VII p.100
Moscow and Ganjoor begin their harsh metaphor with the poor man’s skin, while Mohl and Khaleghi give flesh. English chooses flesh and then turns the Persian continuation into bitterness and pain. The neighboring comparison with a leopard specifies how shame, custom and faith are lost when a ruler lives from that exploitation. Another open door is mentioned, this time for rectitude, and English makes the door of folly its pointed inverse. Secret misconduct and public justice can look like a workable compromise. The four accounts warn against that divided conduct. English preserves both jurisdictions, saying the deception fails before God and before Anooshirvan.
103–104The legacy of the decree
Moscow — VIII62 checked local gap between vv.161 and 162, VIII62:162 running; VIII62:163 running · Mohl — VI87 checked local gap between vv.162 and 163, VI87:163 running; VI88:164 running · Ganjoor — Checked local gap after sh3:67, sh3:68, sh3:69 running · Khaleghi — VII100 checked local gap between vv.174 and 175, VII100:175 running; VII100:176 running
Moscow VIII p.62 · Mohl VI p.87 · Mohl VI p.88 · Ganjoor sh3:67 · Ganjoor sh3:68 · Ganjoor sh3:69 · Khaleghi VII p.100
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi pass from approval of the man whose life is woven from affection and justice to a reflection on the just ruler’s lasting reputation. English provides a formal closing action for the letter, adding sealing and circulation as a short narrative bridge. The running passages have no distinct dispatch at that point. Their enduring legacy and the blessing on the ruler who keeps the land flourishing supply the closing couplet’s substance. English draws those ideas together as the world’s lasting praise. That compression gives the document a public afterlife immediately before the next chapter takes up the working of the army.
Source record and limits
English
104 published English couplets. Ganjoor passages: Anooshirvan §2: 3–41, Anooshirvan §3: 1–69. The English text follows the published verse and chapter divisions.
Moscow
The 1970 Moscow edition, volume VIII, printed pages 56–62. The lament keeps Qobad’s running numbering. The accession starts a new sequence.
Mohl
Jules Mohl’s Persian text, volume VI, printed pages 83–88. Verse numbering restarts after the lament at Anooshirvan’s accession.
Ganjoor
Anooshirvan §2: 3–41, Anooshirvan §3: 1–69. The Persian column gives the corresponding running verses and identifies where Mohl supplies an independent couplet for a local Ganjoor gap.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Djalal Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VII, printed pages 92–100. The lament begins the reign’s continuous numbering. Printed additions have their own note locators.
Separate stages of the fiscal reform
Earlier kings take a share of the harvest, Qobad reduces it to a tenth, and Kisra introduces assessed liabilities. Orchard trees, the payers with money but no cultivation, and the officials with remitted or excluded duties are separate categories. The letter dates the demand and describes when to waive or replace it with aid.
Consequential readings
English 6. All four name Armenia, Ardabil, and the land of Gil, and print a further name between the measurement verb and Gil. English leaves that name out. English 13. All four contrast a third or fourth share with Qobad’s tenth. English preserves the distinction. English 19. The next source verse adds the condition or purpose that the dehqan should not be distressed. English separates the levy and the protection of the holder. English 23. The vineyard rate is six dirhams in all four. The date plantation’s rate is given by reference to that figure. English 26. The four running verses give one dirham per ten trees or roots here; English leaves the denominator’s unit implicit. English 30. Each installment is due every four months, in contrast to the annual amount just listed. English combines the adjacent running verses. English 41. The date occurs in the verse after the sender’s title, and English places it before the title. English 70. The source oath and physical punishment are in one verse. English develops them in two couplets. English 75. Mohl and Khaleghi explicitly name snow and wind. Moscow and Ganjoor here give a wind reading without that explicit snow. English 78. The treasury provides seed and remuneration for work on land that has suffered loss. The English “full hire” sharpens the commitment. English 97. Khaleghi and Mohl name the poor person’s flesh; Moscow and Ganjoor begin instead with skin. All four continue the grotesque image into the second half. English 103. The sealing and dispatch are English narrative closure. The four running texts pass from the royal blessing to the reflection on a just ruler’s legacy.
Limits of the evidence
Running text, bracketed running text, actual printed apparatus and checked local gaps indicate distinct kinds of support. Local gaps concern the specified passage. No appendix reading is invoked. The geographical and institutional terms describe the poem’s account.
Source-only verses
S1. The king values just conduct above the life of the enemy who covets his realm and throne. S2. A separate maxim specifies the kind of official whose justice, affection and customary conduct will earn respect at court.
Moscow VIII p.56 · Moscow VIII p.57 · Moscow VIII p.58 · Moscow VIII p.59 · Moscow VIII p.60 · Moscow VIII p.61 · Moscow VIII p.62
Mohl VI p.83 · Mohl VI p.84 · Mohl VI p.85 · Mohl VI p.86 · Mohl VI p.87 · Mohl VI p.88
Khaleghi VII p.92 · Khaleghi VII p.93 · Khaleghi VII p.94 · Khaleghi VII p.95 · Khaleghi VII p.96 · Khaleghi VII p.97 · Khaleghi VII p.98 · Khaleghi VII p.99 · Khaleghi VII p.100
Selected printed readings
- Moscow VIII57:68 running · سه یک بود یا چار یک بهر شاه
The preceding royal portion is a third or a quarter. - Khaleghi VII94:91 running · گزیت رز بارور شش درم
The tax on fruitful vines is six dirhams. - Khaleghi VII94:93 running · ز ده بن درمی یک رسیدی به گنج
The unit counted in tens is the tree or root. - Khaleghi VII96:110 running · که بد روز بهرام خردادماه
Bahram day is placed in the month Khordad. - Khaleghi VII98:143 running · وگر برف و باد سپهر بلند
The hazards explicitly include snow and wind. - Moscow VIII60:130 running · دگر تف باد سپهر بلند
Moscow foregrounds wind in the corresponding verse. - Khaleghi VII100:169 running · گر از گوشت درویش باشد خورش
Flesh is named in the first half of the metaphor.
D13.3 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII56:56 running | VI83:57 running |
| 2 | VIII56:57 running | VI83:58 running |
| 3 | VIII56:58 running | VI83:59 running |
| 4 | VIII56:59 running | VI83:60 running |
| 5 | VIII56:60 running | VI83:61 running |
| 6 | VIII56:61 running | VI83:62 running |
| 7 | VIII56:62 running | VI83:63 running |
| 8 | VIII56:63 running | VI83:64 running |
| 9 | VIII56:64 running | VI83:65 running |
| 10 | VIII56:65 running | VI84:66 running |
| 11 | VIII56:66 running | VI84:67 running |
| 12 | VIII57:67 running | VI84:68 running |
| 13 | VIII57:68 running | VI84:69 running |
| 14 | VIII57:69 running | VI84:70 running |
| 15 | VIII57:69 running; VIII57:70 running | VI84:70 running; VI84:71 running |
| 16 | VIII57:70 running | VI84:71 running |
| 17 | VIII57:71 running | VI84:72 running |
| 18 | VIII57:72 running | VI84:73 running |
| 19 | VIII57:73 running | VI84:74 running |
| 20 | VIII57:74 running | VI84:75 running |
| 21 | VIII57:75 running; VIII57:76 running | VI84:76 running; VI84:77 running |
| 22 | VIII57:77 running | VI84:78 running |
| 23 | VIII57:78 running | VI84:79 running |
| 24 | VIII57:78 running | VI84:79 running |
| 25 | VIII57:79 running | VI84:80 running |
| 26 | VIII57:80 running | VI84:81 running |
| 27 | VIII57:81 running | VI84:82 running |
| 28 | VIII57:82 running | VI84:83 running |
| 29 | VIII57:83 running | VI84:84 running |
| 30 | VIII58:84 running; VIII58:85 running | VI84:85 running; VI84:86 running |
| 31 | VIII58:86 running | VI84:87 running |
| 32 | VIII58:87 running | VI84:88 running |
| 33 | VIII58:87 running | VI84:88 running |
| 34 | VIII58:88 running | VI84:89 running |
| 35 | VIII58:89 running | VI84:90 running |
| 36 | VIII58:90 running; VIII58:91 running | VI85:91 running; VI85:92 running |
| 37 | VIII58:92 running | VI85:93 running |
| 38 | VIII58:93 running | VI85:94 running |
| 39 | VIII58:94 running | VI85:95 running |
| 40 | VIII58:95 running | VI85:96 running |
| 41 | VIII58:97 running | VI85:98 running |
| 42 | VIII58:96 running | VI85:97 running |
| 43 | VIII58:98 running | VI85:99 running |
| 44 | VIII58:99 running | VI85:100 running |
| 45 | VIII59:100 running | VI85:101 running |
| 46 | VIII59:101 running | VI85:102 running |
| 47 | VIII59:102 running | VI85:103 running |
| 48 | VIII59:103 running | VI85:104 running |
| 49 | VIII59:104 running | VI85:105 running |
| 50 | VIII59:105 running | VI85:106 running |
| 51 | VIII59:106 running | VI85:107 running |
| 52 | VIII59:107 running | VI85:108 running |
| 53 | VIII59:108 running | VI85:109 running |
| 54 | VIII59:109 running | VI85:110 running |
| 55 | VIII59:110 running | VI85:111 running |
| 56 | VIII59:111 running | VI85:112 running |
| 57 | VIII59:112 running | VI85:113 running |
| 58 | VIII59:113 running | VI85:114 running |
| 59 | VIII59:114 running | VI86:115 running |
| 60 | VIII59:115 running | VI86:116 running |
| 61 | VIII59:116 running | VI86:117 running |
| 62 | VIII59:117 running | VI86:118 running |
| 63 | VIII60:118 running | VI86:119 running |
| 64 | VIII60:119 running | VI86:120 running |
| 65 | VIII60:120 running | VI86:121 running |
| 66 | VIII60:121 running | VI86:122 running |
| 67 | VIII60:122 running | VI86:123 running |
| 68 | VIII60:123 running | VI86:124 running |
| 69 | VIII60:124 running | VI86:125 running |
| 70 | VIII60:125 running | VI86:126 running |
| 71 | VIII60:125 running; VIII60:126 running | VI86:126 running; VI86:127 running |
| 72 | VIII60:127 running | VI86:128 running |
| 73 | VIII60:128 running | VI86:129 running |
| 74 | VIII60:129 running | VI86:130 running |
| 75 | VIII60:130 running | VI86:131 running |
| 76 | VIII60:131 running | VI86:132 running |
| 77 | VIII60:132 running | VI86:133 running |
| 78 | VIII60:133 running | VI86:134 running |
| 79 | VIII60:134 running | VI86:135 running |
| 80 | VIII60:135 running; VIII60:136 running | VI86:136 running; VI86:137 running |
| 81 | VIII61:137 running | VI86:138 running |
| 82 | VIII61:138 running | VI87:139 running |
| 83 | VIII61:139 running | VI87:140 running |
| 84 | VIII61:140 running | VI87:141 running |
| 85 | VIII61:141 running; VIII61:142 running | VI87:142 running; VI87:143 running |
| 86 | VIII61:143 running; VIII61:144 running | VI87:144 running; VI87:145 running |
| 87 | VIII61:144 running | VI87:145 running |
| 88 | VIII61:145 running | VI87:146 running |
| 89 | VIII61:147 running | VI87:148 running |
| 90 | VIII61:149 running | VI87:150 running |
| 91 | VIII61:150 running | VI87:151 running |
| 92 | VIII61:151 running | VI87:152 running |
| 93 | VIII61:152 running | VI87:153 running |
| 94 | VIII61:153 running | VI87:154 running |
| 95 | VIII61:154 running | VI87:155 running |
| 96 | VIII61:155 running | VI87:156 running |
| 97 | VIII62:156 running | VI87:157 running |
| 98 | VIII62:157 running | VI87:158 running |
| 99 | VIII62:158 running | VI87:159 running |
| 100 | VIII62:159 running | VI87:160 running |
| 101 | VIII62:160 running | VI87:161 running |
| 102 | VIII62:161 running | VI87:162 running |
| 103 | VIII62 checked local gap between vv.161 and 162 | VI87 checked local gap between vv.162 and 163 |
| 104 | VIII62:162 running; VIII62:163 running | VI87:163 running; VI88:164 running · VI p.88 |
New Naqqali