Monzer Seeks Justice from Anooshirvan
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Who actually enters the Shah’s presence
Moscow — VIII76:412 running, VIII76:413 running, VIII76:414 running, VIII76:415 running, VIII76:420 running, VIII76:421 running, VIII76:416 running, VIII76:417 running, VIII76:418 running, VIII76:419 running · Mohl — VI98:409 running, VI98:410 running, VI98:411 running, VI98:412 running, VI98:413 running, VI98:414 running, VI98 checked local gap between vv.412 and 413 · Ganjoor — sh11:1 running, sh11:2 running, sh11:3 running, sh11:4 running, sh11:9 running, sh11:10 running, sh11:5 running, sh11:6 running, sh11:7 running, sh11:8 running · Khaleghi — VII120:425 running, VII120:426 running, VII120:427 running, VII120:428 running, VII120:433 running, VII120:434 running, VII120:429 bracketed running, VII120:430 bracketed running, VII120:431 bracketed running, VII120:432 bracketed running
Moscow VIII p.76 · Mohl VI p.98 · Ganjoor sh11:1 · Ganjoor sh11:2 · Ganjoor sh11:3 · Ganjoor sh11:4 · Ganjoor sh11:9 · Ganjoor sh11:10 · Ganjoor sh11:5 · Ganjoor sh11:6 · Ganjoor sh11:7 · Ganjoor sh11:8 · Khaleghi VII p.120
The armed body on the road to Madain first issues a single rider. All four have him introduce Monzer. Moscow and Ganjoor then narrate the petition, the Shah’s consent, the messenger’s return and Monzer’s gesture to the ground. Khaleghi gives those same four stages in brackets. Mohl’s direct move to Monzer’s arrival supports the pace of the English. In the published version “Behold Monzer” may sound like an identification made as the Arab leader approaches. The more explicit opening in the other three makes the distinction between herald and petitioner unavoidable. The assembled chiefs opening a lane resolves the movement at court in all four.
7–12Monzer tests the king’s duty to his allies
Moscow — VIII77:422 running, VIII77:423 running, VIII77:424 running, VIII77:425 running, VIII77:426 running, VIII77:427 running · Mohl — VI98:415 running, VI98:416 running, VI98:417 running, VI98:418 running, VI98:419 running, VI98:420 running · Ganjoor — sh11:11 running, sh11:12 running, sh11:13 running, sh11:14 running, sh11:15 running, sh11:16 running · Khaleghi — VII120:435 running, VII120:436 running, VII120:437 running, VII120:438 running, VII120:439 running, VII121:440 running
Moscow VIII p.77 · Mohl VI p.98 · Ganjoor sh11:11 · Ganjoor sh11:12 · Ganjoor sh11:13 · Ganjoor sh11:14 · Ganjoor sh11:15 · Ganjoor sh11:16 · Khaleghi VII p.120 · Khaleghi VII p.121
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give the veteran Monzer a speech that repeatedly turns on rank. If the Shah supports brave men, why should Rum exercise sovereignty among desert riders? The English’s “shield and backbone” unpacks the Persian image of protecting the warriors’ backs. It then preserves the boast that Roman armor would prove useless against the riders. The throne line has a difficult phrasing and small differences among witnesses around pride, worth and being headless. English resolves it as a claim that royal stature would befit the Shah on Caesar’s throne. The thought discloses how much further Monzer’s request reaches than a private grievance.
13–17The king chooses someone who can listen
Moscow — VIII77:428 running, VIII77:429 running, VIII77:430 running, VIII77:431 running, VIII77:432 running · Mohl — VI98:421 running, VI98:422 running, VI98:423 running, VI98:424 running, VI98:425 running · Ganjoor — sh11:17 running, sh11:18 running, sh11:19 running, sh11:20 running, sh11:21 running · Khaleghi — VII121:441 running, VII121:442 running, VII121:443 running, VII121:444 running, VII121:445 running
Moscow VIII p.77 · Mohl VI p.98 · Ganjoor sh11:17 · Ganjoor sh11:18 · Ganjoor sh11:19 · Ganjoor sh11:20 · Ganjoor sh11:21 · Khaleghi VII p.121
The anger, appointment and hurried mission are common to all four. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi describe a speaker who can hear or understand the others’ speech. Mohl describes someone able to receive or understand Kisra’s words. The English supplies Caesar’s tongue, a practical reading of how a mission can succeed. All four give the lion, the gur and the salt landscape. English distinguishes the onager through its familiar name and reads the image as an assertion of the hunter’s freedom of movement. The narrator leaves the figurative roles implicit, while the animal comparison gives the envoy a threat memorable enough to transmit.
18–24A limit requested by a universal ruler
Moscow — VIII77:433 running, VIII77:434 running, VIII77:435 running, VIII77:436 running, VIII77:437 running, VIII77:438 running, VIII77:439 running · Mohl — VI98:426 running, VI98:427 running, VI99:428 running, VI99:429 running, VI99:430 running, VI99:431 running, VI99:432 running · Ganjoor — sh11:22 running, sh11:23 running, sh11:24 running, sh11:25 running, sh11:26 running, sh11:27 running, sh11:28 running · Khaleghi — VII121:446 running, VII121:447 running, VII121:448 running, VII121:449 running, VII121:450 running, VII121:451 running, VII122:452 running
Moscow VIII p.77 · Mohl VI p.98 · Mohl VI p.99 · Ganjoor sh11:22 · Ganjoor sh11:23 · Ganjoor sh11:24 · Ganjoor sh11:25 · Ganjoor sh11:26 · Ganjoor sh11:27 · Ganjoor sh11:28 · Khaleghi VII p.121 · Khaleghi VII p.122
The message demands that Caesar take justice from Monzer, recognize right and left, and think before striking Arabs. From that practical injunction the four texts turn to the cosmological span from bull to fish and then to steel softening into wax. English carries the scale upward in “earth and heaven.” The capitalization of “Pisces” puts a zodiacal gloss on an image broad enough to invoke the cosmic fish without fixing a constellation. The political claim is made by a ruler who allots regions and promises enough protection that even the wind will be kept away. That small wind image holds care and dominion together.
25–28The answer first takes the form of evasion
Moscow — VIII78:440 running, VIII78:441 running, VIII78:441 running; VIII78:442 running, VIII78:442 running · Mohl — VI99:433 running, VI99:434 running, VI99:434 running; VI99:435 running, VI99:435 running · Ganjoor — sh11:29 running, sh11:30 running, sh11:30, sh11:31 running, sh11:31 running · Khaleghi — VII122:453 running, VII122:454 running, VII122:454 running; VII122:455 running, VII122:455 running
Moscow VIII p.78 · Mohl VI p.99 · Ganjoor sh11:29 · Ganjoor sh11:30 · Ganjoor sh11:31 · Khaleghi VII p.122
The messenger in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi comes like a rushing wind. “Torrents” in the English changes the element while preserving speed and force before the stillness of the audience. The emperor receives the words but turns away from justice and responds with deception. The Persian height and descent image makes his failure to imagine a fall both moral and political. English unpacks the action in several couplets, making it possible to distinguish the evasive character of the reply from the threat that follows. The addition of Roman pride names the stake that the contrast between high position and possible decline already implies.
29–37Two rulers threaten to remake the landscape
Moscow — VIII78:443 running, VIII78:444 running, VIII78:445 running; VIII78:446 running, VIII78:446 running, VIII78:447 running, VIII78:448 running, VIII78:449 running, VIII78:450 running, VIII78:451 running · Mohl — VI99:436 running, VI99:437 running, VI99:438 running; VI99:439 running, VI99:439 running, VI99:440 running, VI99:441 running, VI99:442 running, VI99:443 running, VI99:444 running · Ganjoor — sh11:32 running, sh11:33 running, sh11:34, sh11:35 running, sh11:35 running, sh11:36 running, sh11:37 running, sh11:38 running, sh11:39 running, sh11:40 running · Khaleghi — VII122:456 running, VII122:457 running, VII122:458 running; VII122:459 running, VII122:459 running, VII122:460 running, VII122:461 running, VII122:462 running, VII122:463 running, VII122:464 running
Moscow VIII p.78 · Mohl VI p.99 · Ganjoor sh11:32 · Ganjoor sh11:33 · Ganjoor sh11:34 · Ganjoor sh11:35 · Ganjoor sh11:36 · Ganjoor sh11:37 · Ganjoor sh11:38 · Ganjoor sh11:39 · Ganjoor sh11:40 · Khaleghi VII p.122
All four let Caesar dismiss Monzer’s report and offer a counterthreat scaled from flattening heights to making sea from desert. The words concerning a possible complaint from the field can be heard differently depending on the speaker’s construction, but the enlargement is unmistakable. The English makes Caesar answer any spearman’s complaint and lets the envoy carry the threats back. The Shah then invokes authority over war and covenant before ending with the memorable drinker who puts both hands into fire. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all use that image. Keeping both hands sharpens the connection between Caesar’s overreaching grasp and the harm he brings on himself.
38–44A supporting king puts a number on his aid
Moscow — VIII78:452 running, VIII78:453 running, VIII78:454 running, VIII78:455 running, VIII78:455 running; VIII79:456 running, VIII79:456 running, VIII79:457 running · Mohl — VI99:445 running, VI99:446 running, VI99:447 running, VI99:448 running, VI99:448 running; VI99:449 running, VI99:449 running, VI99:450 running · Ganjoor — sh12:1 running, sh12:2 running, sh12:3 running, sh12:4 running, sh12:4, sh12:5 running, sh12:5 running, sh12:6 running · Khaleghi — VII123:465 running, VII123:466 running, VII123:467 running, VII123:468 running, VII123:468 running; VII123:469 running, VII123:469 running, VII123:470 running
Moscow VIII p.78 · Moscow VIII p.79 · Mohl VI p.99 · Ganjoor sh12:1 · Ganjoor sh12:2 · Ganjoor sh12:3 · Ganjoor sh12:4 · Ganjoor sh12:5 · Ganjoor sh12:6 · Khaleghi VII p.123
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give the instrument call, darkened surroundings, the choice of thirty thousand sword-bearing horsemen, and the order to put troops under Monzer. The different drum terms in English let the mobilization move from summons to courtly sound. In the Shah’s speech the desert spearmen remain a mobilizable group alongside the force just put at Monzer’s disposal. English’s frontier emphasis makes the geography of retaliation plain. The final assurance hinges on the Shah being both sovereign and backer in the quarrel. That double relation makes sense of his willingness to send his own words to Caesar as well as soldiers to his ally.
45–47The boast between army and letter
Moscow — VIII79 note 8 actual apparatus after v.457, VIII79:458 running, VIII79:459 running · Mohl — VI99:451 running, VI99:452 running, VI100:453 running · Ganjoor — Checked local gap after sh12:6, sh12:7 running, sh12:8 running · Khaleghi — VII123 note 19 actual apparatus after v.470, VII123:471 running, VII123:472 running
Moscow VIII p.79 · Mohl VI p.99 · Mohl VI p.100 · Ganjoor sh12:6 · Ganjoor sh12:7 · Ganjoor sh12:8 · Khaleghi VII p.123
Mohl’s running text pauses after the pledge of backing to say that Rum and the Romans are as a handful of dust before the Shah. Moscow prints the matching additional line under its actual note 8 and Khaleghi prints a counterpart under note 19, naming Caesar in its first half. Ganjoor proceeds directly to the court’s envoy. Published English uses “legions” to make the boast military and supplies a sword. The Persian line’s image does not expressly name a sword. The next two English couplets keep the story’s practical divergence between threats and diplomacy. A smooth-tongued courier and a written letter are still expected to avert harm.
Source record and limits
English
47 published English couplets. Ganjoor passages: Anooshirvan §11: 1–40, Anooshirvan §12: 1–8. The English text follows the published verse and chapter divisions.
Moscow
The 1970 Moscow edition, volume VIII, printed pages 76–79. The source register identifies the individual running verses and any printed apparatus cited.
Mohl
Jules Mohl’s Persian text, volume VI, printed pages 98–100. The running sequence includes some lines here that Moscow and Khaleghi give in their apparatus.
Ganjoor
Anooshirvan §11: 1–40, Anooshirvan §12: 1–8. The Persian column gives the corresponding running verses and identifies where Mohl supplies an independent couplet for a local Ganjoor gap.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Djalal Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VII, printed pages 120–123. Square brackets mark verses retained in the main text with explicit editorial reservation. Printed additions have their own note locators.
Petition, message and mobilization
An unnamed rider introduces Monzer, who speaks against Caesar after reaching the Shah. The four additional verses retained by Moscow, Ganjoor and bracketed in Khaleghi enlarge the formal reception. The English joins Mohl in moving directly to the meeting. Mohl’s separate boast about Rum has printed apparatus support in Moscow and Khaleghi.
Consequential readings
English 5. Mohl runs directly from the rider’s introduction to Monzer’s arrival. Moscow and Ganjoor run the four intervening verses. Khaleghi prints all four in square brackets. English 17. The four witnesses use gur and shur. English identifies the prey as the onager and renders the salt landscape as a salt marsh, then adds an explicit claim that the lion cannot be curbed. English 23. The Persian’s upper and lower cosmic bounds are the bull and fish. English’s capitalized “Pisces” makes the fish look like an explicit constellation, which these lines do not require. English 25. All four use the wind for the outward messenger. English uses torrents. The second messenger movement later in the chapter uses dust or a dust-like image in English. English 45. Mohl runs this boast. Moscow and Khaleghi print it in the apparatus, with a lexical difference in the first hemistich. Ganjoor passes directly from the shah’s support to the envoy. English adds a sword in its second line.
Limits of the evidence
Running text, bracketed running text, actual printed apparatus and checked local gaps indicate distinct kinds of support. Local gaps concern the specified passage. No appendix reading is invoked. The geographical and institutional terms describe the poem’s account.
Source-only verses
S1. The rider says Monzer came to see the shah and kiss the threshold. Khaleghi brackets the verse. S2. The shah welcomes Monzer and treats the house as his. Khaleghi brackets the verse. S3. The envoy kisses the earth and returns with the shah’s words. Khaleghi brackets the verse. S4. Monzer brushes the earth with his face in reverence before entering. Khaleghi brackets the verse.
Moscow VIII p.76 · Moscow VIII p.77 · Moscow VIII p.78 · Moscow VIII p.79
Mohl VI p.98 · Mohl VI p.99 · Mohl VI p.100
Khaleghi VII p.120 · Khaleghi VII p.121 · Khaleghi VII p.122 · Khaleghi VII p.123
Selected printed readings
- Khaleghi VII120:429 bracketed running · بیامد که بیند مگر شاه را
The petition for audience appears in brackets. - Khaleghi VII121:451 running · در گاو تا برج ماهی مراست
Bull and fish express the bounds of the claimed sovereignty. - Mohl VI99:451 running · ز روم و ز رومی مدار ایچ باک
Mohl tells Monzer to have no fear of Rum or the Romans. - Moscow VIII79 note 8 actual apparatus · چه رومی بر من چه یک مشت خاک
The actual apparatus gives the Roman as a handful of dust. - Khaleghi VII123 note 19 actual apparatus · ز روم و ز قیصر مدار ایچ باک
Khaleghi’s printed addition names Caesar in the first hemistich.
D13.8 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII76:412 running | VI98:409 running |
| 2 | VIII76:413 running | VI98:410 running |
| 3 | VIII76:414 running | VI98:411 running |
| 4 | VIII76:415 running | VI98:412 running |
| 5 | VIII76:420 running | VI98:413 running |
| 6 | VIII76:421 running | VI98:414 running |
| 7 | VIII77:422 running | VI98:415 running |
| 8 | VIII77:423 running | VI98:416 running |
| 9 | VIII77:424 running | VI98:417 running |
| 10 | VIII77:425 running | VI98:418 running |
| 11 | VIII77:426 running | VI98:419 running |
| 12 | VIII77:427 running | VI98:420 running |
| 13 | VIII77:428 running | VI98:421 running |
| 14 | VIII77:429 running | VI98:422 running |
| 15 | VIII77:430 running | VI98:423 running |
| 16 | VIII77:431 running | VI98:424 running |
| 17 | VIII77:432 running | VI98:425 running |
| 18 | VIII77:433 running | VI98:426 running |
| 19 | VIII77:434 running | VI98:427 running |
| 20 | VIII77:435 running | VI99:428 running |
| 21 | VIII77:436 running | VI99:429 running |
| 22 | VIII77:437 running | VI99:430 running |
| 23 | VIII77:438 running | VI99:431 running |
| 24 | VIII77:439 running | VI99:432 running |
| 25 | VIII78:440 running | VI99:433 running |
| 26 | VIII78:441 running | VI99:434 running |
| 27 | VIII78:441 running; VIII78:442 running | VI99:434 running; VI99:435 running |
| 28 | VIII78:442 running | VI99:435 running |
| 29 | VIII78:443 running | VI99:436 running |
| 30 | VIII78:444 running | VI99:437 running |
| 31 | VIII78:445 running; VIII78:446 running | VI99:438 running; VI99:439 running |
| 32 | VIII78:446 running | VI99:439 running |
| 33 | VIII78:447 running | VI99:440 running |
| 34 | VIII78:448 running | VI99:441 running |
| 35 | VIII78:449 running | VI99:442 running |
| 36 | VIII78:450 running | VI99:443 running |
| 37 | VIII78:451 running | VI99:444 running |
| 38 | VIII78:452 running | VI99:445 running |
| 39 | VIII78:453 running | VI99:446 running |
| 40 | VIII78:454 running | VI99:447 running |
| 41 | VIII78:455 running | VI99:448 running |
| 42 | VIII78:455 running; VIII79:456 running · VIII p.79 | VI99:448 running; VI99:449 running |
| 43 | VIII79:456 running | VI99:449 running |
| 44 | VIII79:457 running | VI99:450 running |
| 45 | VIII79 note 8 actual apparatus after v.457 | VI99:451 running |
| 46 | VIII79:458 running | VI99:452 running |
| 47 | VIII79:459 running | VI100:453 running |
New Naqqali