New Naqqaliشاهنامه
Critical Commentary · D5.35

Iskandar Goes to Babil and Writes to Arastatilis

F&R English · 48 couplets · 8 commentary entries

Printed verse collation

The chapter in five texts

TextChapter treatment and distinctive choices

Parallel text

English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.

1–6+
To Babil then Iskandar led his force;
The earth lay hidden underneath its course.
He knew his life was ebbing, nearly past,
And darkness on his day was falling fast.
He thought, “No royal scion shall remain
To lead an army over Rum’s domain.
For such a prince might raise the battle sign,
And trample that rich realm, that land of mine.”
He wrote Arastatilis of his will,
And laid before the sage his purpose ill:
To put the heirs of Iran to the sword,
And slay each prince of Kayanian accord,
وزان جایگه سوی بابل کشید
زمین گشت از لشکرش ناپدید
بدانست کش مرگ نزدیک شد
بروبر همی روز تاریک شد
بران بودش اندیشه کاندر جهان
نماند کسی از نژاد مهان
که لشکر کشد جنگ را سوی روم
نهد پی بران خاک آباد بوم
چو مغز اندرین کار خودکامه کرد
هم‌انگه سطالیس را نامه کرد
هرانکس کجا بد ز تخم کیان
بفرمودشان تا ببندد میان
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh41:34
7–12+
Lest one arise to seek the royal seat,
And bring his native Rum to swift defeat.
When they conveyed the letter to the sage,
The sage grew fearful, reading through the page.
He answered quickly, while his lashes shed
Such tears they seemed the pen with which he said:
“Your royal letter reached me,” said the sage;
“Stay now your hand, and turn from wrathful rage.
Abandon this dark purpose while you may,
And give the poor your gifts without delay.
Commit yourself to God; restrain your hand,
And sow good seed wherever you command.
که لشکر کشد جنگ را سوی روم
نهد پی بران خاک آباد بوم
همه روی را سوی درگه کنند
ز بدها گمانیش کوته کنند
چو این نامه بردند نزد حکیم
دل ارسطالیس شد به دو نیم
هم‌اندر زمان پاسخ نامه کرد
ز مژگان تو گفتی سر خامه کرد
که آن نامهٔ شاه گیهان رسید
ز بدکام دستش بباید کشید
ازان بد که کردی میندیش نیز
از اندیشه درویش را بخش چیز
بپرهیز و جان را به یزدان سپار
به گیتی جز از تخم نیکی مکار
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh42:3, sh42:6
13–18+
All men are born to meet the final breath;
No strength or counsel gives escape from death.
No king has borne his kingship to the tomb;
He leaves his crown for others to assume.
Shed not the nobles’ blood along your way,
Lest you be cursed until the Judgment Day.
If Iran has no army to defend
Its soil, no king on whom its chiefs depend,
From Turkistan and Hind their ranks will flow,
From Saklab and from Chin, a countless foe.
Who takes Iran may turn his force on Rum;
What wonder if revenge your home consume?
همه مرگ راییم تا زنده‌ایم
به بیچارگی در سرافگنده‌ایم
نه هرکس که شد پادشاهی ببرد
برفت و بزرگی کسی را سپرد
بپرهیز و خون بزرگان مریز
که نفرین بود بر تو تا رستخیز
و دیگر که چون اندر ایران سپاه
نباشد همان شاه در پیش‌گاه
ز ترک و ز هند و ز سقلاب و چین
سپاه آید از هر سوی هم‌چنین
به روم آید آنکس که ایران گرفت
اگر کین بسیچد نباشد شگفت
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh42:12
19–24+
Let not one breath bring harm upon the line
Of those descended from the Kayanian sign.
Summon the nobles, men of freeborn name,
With gifts and feast and counsel as your aim.
Assign each chief a province to control,
And have their names recorded on a roll.
Record those nobles, freeborn men of worth,
Through whom you freely gained the whole wide earth.
Let none command another in your stead,
And raise no single Shah above their head.
Make Kayanian princes shields for Rum,
So no invading army brings your doom.”
هرآنکس که هست از نژاد کیان
نباید که از باد یابد زیان
بزرگان و آزادگان را بخوان
به بخش و به سور و به رای و به خوان
سزاوار هر مهتری کشوری
بیارای و آغاز کن دفتری
به نام بزرگان و آزادگان
کزیشان جهان یافتی رایگان
یکی را مده بر دگر دستگاه
کسی را مخوان بر جهان نیز شاه
سپر کن کیان را همه پیش بوم
چو خواهی که لشکر نیاید به روم
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh42:18
25–30+
When this reply reached great Iskandar’s hand,
He cast aside the slaughter he had planned.
He summoned nobles, freeborn men of worth,
Who showed humanity upon the earth.
He ranked them all according to degree,
And seated each where it was fit to be.
He wrote a covenant that none should claim
The least increase to serve his private aim.
Each ruled the province granted in his name;
As Tribal Kings, they won their lasting fame.
That night Iskandar came to Babil’s gate;
The chiefs rejoiced to see him in his state.
سکندر چو پاسخ بران گونه یافت
به اندیشه و رای دیگر شتافت
بزرگان و آزادگان را ز دهر
کسی را کش از مردمی بود بهر
بفرمود تا پیش او خواندند
به جای سزاوار بنشاندند
یکی عهد بنوشت تا هر یکی
فزونی نجوید ز دهر اندکی
بران نامداران جوینده کام
ملوک طوایف نهادند نام
همان شب سکندر به بابل رسید
مهان را به دیدار خود شاد دید
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh42:24
31–36+
A woman bore a child so strange in frame,
That all who saw it wondered at the same.
A lion’s head, hooved feet, an ox’s tail;
Its human chest and shoulders made them quail.
It died the instant into life it came.
May no new birth prolong that mother’s name.
They bore it swiftly to the world’s great king.
He stared in wonder at that startling thing.
He took it as an omen, dark and dread,
And said: “Let earth conceal this child, now dead.”
He called the readers of the stars to speak,
And asked what sign lay in that creature bleak.
یکی کودک آمد زنی را به شب
بدو ماند هرکس که دیدش عجب
سرش چون سر شیر و بر پای سم
چو مردم بر و کتف و چون گاو دم
بمرد از شگفتی هم‌آنگه که زاد
سزد گر نباشد ازان زن نژاد
ببردند هم در زمان نزد شاه
بدو کرد شاه از شگفتی نگاه
به فالش بد آمد هم‌انگاه گفت
که این بچه در خاک باید نهفت
ز اخترشناسان بسی پیش خواند
وزان کودک مرده چندی براند
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh42:30
37–42+
The star-reader grew grieved at what he knew,
And hid the meaning from the king’s own view.
The Shah warned: “If you hide truth from me,
I shall strike off your heads immediately.
No cloth shall serve as shroud when you are slain;
The lions’ jaws shall hide what may remain.”
The star-reader, when anger seized the king,
Replied: “Renowned lord, hear the news I bring.
You came to birth beneath the Lion’s light;
The Mobadan and chiefs knew this was right.
The lion’s head upon this lifeless birth
Foretells your empire’s head will bow to earth.
ستاره‌شمر زان غمی گشت سخت
بپوشید بر خسرو نیک‌بخت
ز اخترشناسان بپرسید و گفت
که گر هیچ ماند سخن در نهفت
هم‌اکنون ببرم سرانتان ز تن
نیابید جز کام شیران کفن
ستاره‌شمر چون برآشفت شاه
بدو گفت کای نامور پیشگاه
تو بر اختر شیر زادی نخست
بر موبدان و ردان شد درست
سر کودک مرده بینی چو شیر
بگردد سر پادشاهیت زیر
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh42:36
43–48+
The world shall rage in turmoil, till it ends,
And then another to the throne ascends.”
Each star-reader before him spoke the same,
And pointed to this sign to prove the claim.
Iskandar heard, and grief consumed his mind;
His powers of thought and judgment both declined.
He said, “Death has no cure; I fear no call;
My span can neither rise nor shrink at all.”
That very day in Babil he fell ill,
And knew that grievous harm had worked its will.
He called a veteran scribe, a man of art,
And told him all that lay within his heart.
پرآشوب گردد زمین چندگاه
چنین تا نشیند یکی پیشگاه
ستاره‌شمر بیش ازین هرک بود
همی گفت و آن را نشانه نمود
سکندر چو بشنید زان شد غمی
به رای و به مغزش درآمد کمی
چنین گفت کز مرگ خود چاره نیست
مرا دل پر اندیشه زین باره نیست
مرا بیش ازین زندگانی نبود
زمانه نکاهد نخواهد فزود
به بابل هم‌ان روز شد دردمند
بدانست کامد به تنگی گزند
دبیر جهاندیده را پیش خواند
هرانچش به دل بود با او براند
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh42:42

Couplet commentary

Quoted text · evidence · interpretation
1–6Fear of succession produces a destructive plan
1–6
To Babil then Iskandar led his force;
The earth lay hidden underneath its course.
He knew his life was ebbing, nearly past,
And darkness on his day was falling fast.
He thought, “No royal scion shall remain
To lead an army over Rum’s domain.
For such a prince might raise the battle sign,
And trample that rich realm, that land of mine.”
He wrote Arastatilis of his will,
And laid before the sage his purpose ill:
To put the heirs of Iran to the sword,
And slay each prince of Kayanian accord,
وزان جایگه سوی بابل کشید
زمین گشت از لشکرش ناپدید
بدانست کش مرگ نزدیک شد
بروبر همی روز تاریک شد
بران بودش اندیشه کاندر جهان
نماند کسی از نژاد مهان
که لشکر کشد جنگ را سوی روم
نهد پی بران خاک آباد بوم
چو مغز اندرین کار خودکامه کرد
هم‌انگه سطالیس را نامه کرد
هرانکس کجا بد ز تخم کیان
بفرمودشان تا ببندد میان
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh41:34

Moscow: VII100:1716 running text | VII100:1717 running text | VII100:1718 running text | VII101:1719 running text | VII101:1720 running text | VII100:1718 running text | VII101:1721 running text; Mohl: V124:page-line4 running text | V124:page-line5 running text | V124:page-line6 running text | V124:page-line7 running text | V124:page-line8 running text | V124:page-line6 running text | V124:page-line9 running text; Ganjoor: sh41:34, sh42:1, sh42:2, sh42:3, sh42:4, sh42:2, sh42:5; Khaleghi: VI116:1717 running text | VI116:1718 running text | VI116:1719 running text | VI116:1720 running text | VI116:1721 running text | VI116:1719 running text | VI117:1722 running text

Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi take the army toward Babil and make approaching death the setting for Iskandar’s concern about surviving nobles. English turns that concern into a clearly stated plan to kill Iranian and Kayanian heirs. The local Persian sequence gives the wish that no noble descendant remain, then the summoning of Kayanian men; its murderous implication is confirmed by the sage’s subsequent prohibition on bloodshed. English therefore makes the purpose more explicit than a line-for-line rendering of the summons alone would. The distinction matters: the commentary can defend the interpretation while acknowledging that the translation has redistributed and clarified the reasoning.

7–12The sage’s reply joins restraint to positive action
7–12
Lest one arise to seek the royal seat,
And bring his native Rum to swift defeat.
When they conveyed the letter to the sage,
The sage grew fearful, reading through the page.
He answered quickly, while his lashes shed
Such tears they seemed the pen with which he said:
“Your royal letter reached me,” said the sage;
“Stay now your hand, and turn from wrathful rage.
Abandon this dark purpose while you may,
And give the poor your gifts without delay.
Commit yourself to God; restrain your hand,
And sow good seed wherever you command.
که لشکر کشد جنگ را سوی روم
نهد پی بران خاک آباد بوم
همه روی را سوی درگه کنند
ز بدها گمانیش کوته کنند
چو این نامه بردند نزد حکیم
دل ارسطالیس شد به دو نیم
هم‌اندر زمان پاسخ نامه کرد
ز مژگان تو گفتی سر خامه کرد
که آن نامهٔ شاه گیهان رسید
ز بدکام دستش بباید کشید
ازان بد که کردی میندیش نیز
از اندیشه درویش را بخش چیز
بپرهیز و جان را به یزدان سپار
به گیتی جز از تخم نیکی مکار
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh42:3, sh42:6

Moscow: VII101:1719 running text | VII101:1722 running text | VII101:1723 running text | VII101:1724 running text | VII101:1725 running text | VII101:1726 running text | VII101:1727 running text; Mohl: V124:page-line7 running text | V124:page-line10 running text | V124:page-line11 running text | V124:page-line12 running text | V124:page-line13 running text | V124:page-line14 running text | V124:page-line15 running text; Ganjoor: sh42:3, sh42:6, sh42:7, sh42:8, sh42:9, sh42:10, sh42:11; Khaleghi: VI116:1720 running text | VI117:1723 running text | VI117:1724 running text | VI117:1725 running text | VI117:1726 running text | VI117:1727 running text | VI117:1728 running text

All four witnesses connect Iskandar’s concern with a possible attack on Rum and describe the sage’s distress on receiving the letter. English7 restates the feared threat while the nearby Persian units describe the summons; the alignment must therefore include the earlier statement of purpose. The tear-like pen image gives the response an emotional urgency beyond administrative advice. English preserves the calls to restrain the hand, give to the poor and sow good seed. The advice replaces the contemplated violence with specific actions rather than merely expressing disapproval. Committing oneself to God also challenges the ruler’s attempt to control the future through eliminating possible successors.

13–18Mortality and strategy support the same prohibition
13–18
All men are born to meet the final breath;
No strength or counsel gives escape from death.
No king has borne his kingship to the tomb;
He leaves his crown for others to assume.
Shed not the nobles’ blood along your way,
Lest you be cursed until the Judgment Day.
If Iran has no army to defend
Its soil, no king on whom its chiefs depend,
From Turkistan and Hind their ranks will flow,
From Saklab and from Chin, a countless foe.
Who takes Iran may turn his force on Rum;
What wonder if revenge your home consume?
همه مرگ راییم تا زنده‌ایم
به بیچارگی در سرافگنده‌ایم
نه هرکس که شد پادشاهی ببرد
برفت و بزرگی کسی را سپرد
بپرهیز و خون بزرگان مریز
که نفرین بود بر تو تا رستخیز
و دیگر که چون اندر ایران سپاه
نباشد همان شاه در پیش‌گاه
ز ترک و ز هند و ز سقلاب و چین
سپاه آید از هر سوی هم‌چنین
به روم آید آنکس که ایران گرفت
اگر کین بسیچد نباشد شگفت
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh42:12

Moscow: VII101:1728 running text | VII101:1729 running text | VII101:1730 running text | VII101:1731 running text | VII102:1732 running text | VII102:1733 running text; Mohl: V124:page-line16 running text | V124:page-line17 running text | V124:page-line18 running text | V124:page-line19 running text | V124:page-line20 running text | V124:page-line21 running text; Ganjoor: sh42:12, sh42:13, sh42:14, sh42:15, sh42:16, sh42:17; Khaleghi: VI117:1729 running text | VI117:1730 running text | VI117:1731 running text | VI117:1732 running text | VI117:1733 running text | VI117:1734 running text

Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi first remind the king that sovereignty cannot be carried beyond death, then warn against the political consequences of destroying Iran’s leadership. English preserves the transition from moral limit to practical calculation. Turkistan, Hind, Saklab and Chin name possible sources of invading forces in the poem’s geography, not a modern forecast. A ruler who takes an undefended Iran may then threaten Rum. The argument answers Iskandar on his own stated concern while refusing the proposed massacre. English’s fuller phrasing about defense makes that logic accessible, but the named regions and the conditional nature of the warning should remain intact.

19–24Divided authority is proposed as protection for Rum
19–24
Let not one breath bring harm upon the line
Of those descended from the Kayanian sign.
Summon the nobles, men of freeborn name,
With gifts and feast and counsel as your aim.
Assign each chief a province to control,
And have their names recorded on a roll.
Record those nobles, freeborn men of worth,
Through whom you freely gained the whole wide earth.
Let none command another in your stead,
And raise no single Shah above their head.
Make Kayanian princes shields for Rum,
So no invading army brings your doom.”
هرآنکس که هست از نژاد کیان
نباید که از باد یابد زیان
بزرگان و آزادگان را بخوان
به بخش و به سور و به رای و به خوان
سزاوار هر مهتری کشوری
بیارای و آغاز کن دفتری
به نام بزرگان و آزادگان
کزیشان جهان یافتی رایگان
یکی را مده بر دگر دستگاه
کسی را مخوان بر جهان نیز شاه
سپر کن کیان را همه پیش بوم
چو خواهی که لشکر نیاید به روم
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh42:18

Moscow: VII102:1734 running text | VII102:1735 running text | VII102:1736 running text | VII102:1737 running text | VII102:1738 running text | VII102:1739 running text; Mohl: V124:page-line22 running text | V124:page-line23 running text | V125:page-line1 running text | V125:page-line2 running text | V125:page-line3 running text | V125:page-line4 running text; Ganjoor: sh42:18, sh42:19, sh42:20, sh42:21, sh42:22, sh42:23; Khaleghi: VI117:1735 running text | VI117:1736 running text | VI117:1737 running text | VI117:1738 running text | VI118:1739 running text | VI118:1740 running text

The four sources recommend protecting Kayanian descendants, summoning nobles, assigning territories and recording the arrangement. English preserves both the register and the injunction against giving one man supremacy over the others. The princes become a shield for Rum through a distribution of power that limits any single successor. The commentary should not mistake this literary explanation for a fully documented constitutional history. English’s orderly sequence makes the proposal appear practical and deliberate, but its purpose remains bound to Iskandar’s anxiety about his own realm. The humane refusal of slaughter and the strategic fragmentation of authority operate together rather than canceling one another.

25–30The king adopts the alternative and reaches Babil
25–30
When this reply reached great Iskandar’s hand,
He cast aside the slaughter he had planned.
He summoned nobles, freeborn men of worth,
Who showed humanity upon the earth.
He ranked them all according to degree,
And seated each where it was fit to be.
He wrote a covenant that none should claim
The least increase to serve his private aim.
Each ruled the province granted in his name;
As Tribal Kings, they won their lasting fame.
That night Iskandar came to Babil’s gate;
The chiefs rejoiced to see him in his state.
سکندر چو پاسخ بران گونه یافت
به اندیشه و رای دیگر شتافت
بزرگان و آزادگان را ز دهر
کسی را کش از مردمی بود بهر
بفرمود تا پیش او خواندند
به جای سزاوار بنشاندند
یکی عهد بنوشت تا هر یکی
فزونی نجوید ز دهر اندکی
بران نامداران جوینده کام
ملوک طوایف نهادند نام
همان شب سکندر به بابل رسید
مهان را به دیدار خود شاد دید
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh42:24

Moscow: VII102:1740 running text | VII102:1741 running text | VII102:1742 running text | VII102:1743 running text | VII102:1744 running text | VII102:1745 running text; Mohl: V125:page-line5 running text | V125:page-line6 running text | V125:page-line7 running text | V125:page-line8 running text | V125:page-line9 running text | V125:page-line10 running text; Ganjoor: sh42:24, sh42:25, sh42:26, sh42:27, sh42:28, sh42:29; Khaleghi: VI118:1741 running text | VI118:1742 running text | VI118:1743 running text | VI118:1744 running text | VI118:1745 running text | VI118:1746 running text

Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi have Iskandar change his purpose, call the nobles and seat them according to rank. English preserves the written covenant restraining each from seeking increase and the name Tribal Kings for the resulting rulers. That phrase renders the text’s moluk-e tavaʾef terminology; it should not be treated as a complete definition of a single modern political institution. The chapter then resumes the journey with the night arrival at Babil. English retains both the administrative act and the welcomed arrival, keeping them distinct from the ominous birth that follows. The change of plan is a narrated decision, not proof that all future conflict has been prevented.

31–36An extraordinary birth becomes a feared sign
31–36
A woman bore a child so strange in frame,
That all who saw it wondered at the same.
A lion’s head, hooved feet, an ox’s tail;
Its human chest and shoulders made them quail.
It died the instant into life it came.
May no new birth prolong that mother’s name.
They bore it swiftly to the world’s great king.
He stared in wonder at that startling thing.
He took it as an omen, dark and dread,
And said: “Let earth conceal this child, now dead.”
He called the readers of the stars to speak,
And asked what sign lay in that creature bleak.
یکی کودک آمد زنی را به شب
بدو ماند هرکس که دیدش عجب
سرش چون سر شیر و بر پای سم
چو مردم بر و کتف و چون گاو دم
بمرد از شگفتی هم‌آنگه که زاد
سزد گر نباشد ازان زن نژاد
ببردند هم در زمان نزد شاه
بدو کرد شاه از شگفتی نگاه
به فالش بد آمد هم‌انگاه گفت
که این بچه در خاک باید نهفت
ز اخترشناسان بسی پیش خواند
وزان کودک مرده چندی براند
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh42:30

Moscow: VII102:1746 running text | VII102:1747 running text | VII102:1748 running text | VII102:1749 running text | VII103:1750 running text | VII103:1751 running text; Mohl: V125:page-line11 running text | V125:page-line12 running text | V125:page-line13 running text | V125:page-line14 running text | V125:page-line15 running text | V125:page-line16 running text; Ganjoor: sh42:30, sh42:31, sh42:32, sh42:33, sh42:34, sh42:35; Khaleghi: VI118:1747 running text | VI118:1748 running text | VI118:1749 running text | VI118:1750 running text | VI118:1751 running text | VI118:1752 running text

All four witnesses describe a newborn with a lion-like head, hoofed feet, a human chest and shoulders, and an ox-like tail, followed immediately by death. English preserves the composite body and the narrator’s harsh wish concerning further offspring. That wish belongs to the text and is not adopted as a judgment on a real mother or disabled child. Iskandar’s ominous interpretation and instruction to bury the body precede his consultation of star-readers. The sequence matters because fear is already present before expert explanation. English keeps the king’s response visible, showing how the court turns an extraordinary narrated event into a prediction about political power.

37–42Threat forces the interpretation into the open
37–42
The star-reader grew grieved at what he knew,
And hid the meaning from the king’s own view.
The Shah warned: “If you hide truth from me,
I shall strike off your heads immediately.
No cloth shall serve as shroud when you are slain;
The lions’ jaws shall hide what may remain.”
The star-reader, when anger seized the king,
Replied: “Renowned lord, hear the news I bring.
You came to birth beneath the Lion’s light;
The Mobadan and chiefs knew this was right.
The lion’s head upon this lifeless birth
Foretells your empire’s head will bow to earth.
ستاره‌شمر زان غمی گشت سخت
بپوشید بر خسرو نیک‌بخت
ز اخترشناسان بپرسید و گفت
که گر هیچ ماند سخن در نهفت
هم‌اکنون ببرم سرانتان ز تن
نیابید جز کام شیران کفن
ستاره‌شمر چون برآشفت شاه
بدو گفت کای نامور پیشگاه
تو بر اختر شیر زادی نخست
بر موبدان و ردان شد درست
سر کودک مرده بینی چو شیر
بگردد سر پادشاهیت زیر
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh42:36

Moscow: VII103:1752 running text | VII103:1753 running text | VII103:1754 running text | VII103:1754 running text | VII103:1755 running text | VII103:1756 running text | VII103:1757 running text; Mohl: V125:page-line17 running text | V125:page-line18 running text | V125:page-line19 running text | V125:page-line19 running text | V125:page-line20 running text | V125:page-line21 running text | V125:page-line22 running text; Ganjoor: sh42:36, sh42:37, sh42:38, sh42:38, sh42:39, sh42:40, sh42:41; Khaleghi: VI119:1753 running text | VI119:1754 running text | VI119:1755 running text | VI119:1755 running text | VI119:1756 running text | VI119:1757 running text | VI119:1758 running text

Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi make the star-reader hesitate and conceal the meaning before Iskandar threatens decapitation and exposure to lions. English38–39 expand a shared Persian threat across two couplets while preserving its cruelty. The answer then connects the king’s birth under the Lion with the newborn’s lion-like head and the impending fall of royal power. This is the court’s interpretation within the narrative, not a scientifically established relationship between astrology and death. English’s clear causal phrasing makes the omen intelligible, but readers should retain the distinction between the poem’s symbolic reasoning and independent evidence about the events it predicts.

43–48Agreement among interpreters precedes illness
43–48
The world shall rage in turmoil, till it ends,
And then another to the throne ascends.”
Each star-reader before him spoke the same,
And pointed to this sign to prove the claim.
Iskandar heard, and grief consumed his mind;
His powers of thought and judgment both declined.
He said, “Death has no cure; I fear no call;
My span can neither rise nor shrink at all.”
That very day in Babil he fell ill,
And knew that grievous harm had worked its will.
He called a veteran scribe, a man of art,
And told him all that lay within his heart.
پرآشوب گردد زمین چندگاه
چنین تا نشیند یکی پیشگاه
ستاره‌شمر بیش ازین هرک بود
همی گفت و آن را نشانه نمود
سکندر چو بشنید زان شد غمی
به رای و به مغزش درآمد کمی
چنین گفت کز مرگ خود چاره نیست
مرا دل پر اندیشه زین باره نیست
مرا بیش ازین زندگانی نبود
زمانه نکاهد نخواهد فزود
به بابل هم‌ان روز شد دردمند
بدانست کامد به تنگی گزند
دبیر جهاندیده را پیش خواند
هرانچش به دل بود با او براند
Ganjoor Ganjoor sh42:42

Moscow: VII103:1758 running text | VII103:1759 running text | VII103:1760 running text | VII103:1761 running text | VII103:1762 running text | VII103:1763 running text | VII103:1764 running text; Mohl: V125:page-line23 running text | V125:page-line24 running text | V125:page-line25 running text | V126:page-line1 running text | V126:page-line2 running text | V126:page-line3 running text | V126:page-line4 running text; Ganjoor: sh42:42, sh42:43, sh42:44, sh42:45, sh42:46, sh43:1, sh43:2; Khaleghi: VI119:1759 running text | VI119:1760 running text | VI119:1761 running text | VI119:1762 running text | VI119:1763 running text | VI119:1764 running text | VI119:1765 running text

All four sources predict a period of turmoil followed by another ruler, then make the interpreters agree on the sign. English preserves the king’s grief and decline in judgment before his declaration that death cannot be escaped or the allotted span altered. English46 combines two Persian units, concentrating resignation into a single couplet. The illness and summons of a scribe belong to the next Persian division but remain within this published English chapter. Their inclusion prepares the letter to his mother without repeating its opening in the following commentary. The narrative has moved from attempts to control succession toward a personal acknowledgment that his own end is near.

Source record and limits

Scope and boundaries

48 English couplets; Ganjoor41:34,42:1–46,43:1–2. Moscow VII100–103:1716–1764; Mohl V124 line4 through V126 line4; Khaleghi VI116–119:1717–1765. Ends at summons of the scribe, before letter content.

Moscow evidence

Running1716–1764 individually inspected. Intended elimination in1718 and sage’s prohibition1730 contextualize summons1721–22; English6–7 explicitly redistribute the purpose. Composite birth1746–48 and threat1753–54 remain narrated evidence.

Mohl evidence

V124 lines4–23,125 lines1–25,126 lines1–4 inspected. Same sequence of intention, summons, corrective letter, territorial settlement and omen. English threat splits a source unit; final resignation combines two.

Ganjoor evidence

49 declared reference units allocated once across three divisions.42:5–6 describe summons rather than explicitly spelling out English’s repeated slaughter purpose;42:2–3 and14 supply context.43:1–2 illness/scribe included here.

Khaleghi-Motlagh evidence

Running1717–1765 inspected. Local apparatus offers wording and manuscript evidence but is not needed as a substitute for these running counterparts. Political advice and omen remain represented speech; no appendix claim.

Interpretive limits

Murderous purpose is clarified and redistributed by English rather than literally repeated in every adjacent Persian unit. Astrology and bodily marvels are narrative interpretations. Tribal Kings is a translation of the poem’s political designation, not a complete institutional history.

Moscow printed p.100 · Moscow printed p.101 · Moscow printed p.102 · Moscow printed p.103

Mohl printed p.124 · Mohl printed p.125 · Mohl printed p.126

Khaleghi printed p.116 · Khaleghi printed p.117 · Khaleghi printed p.118 · Khaleghi printed p.119

D5.35 · Printed verse collation

English coupletMoscowMohl
1VII100:1716 running textV124:page-line4 running text
2VII100:1717 running textV124:page-line5 running text
3VII100:1718 running textV124:page-line6 running text
4VII101:1719 running textV124:page-line7 running text
5VII101:1720 running textV124:page-line8 running text
6VII100:1718 running text | VII101:1721 running textV124:page-line6 running text | V124:page-line9 running text
7VII101:1719 running text | VII101:1722 running textV124:page-line7 running text | V124:page-line10 running text
8VII101:1723 running textV124:page-line11 running text
9VII101:1724 running textV124:page-line12 running text
10VII101:1725 running textV124:page-line13 running text
11VII101:1726 running textV124:page-line14 running text
12VII101:1727 running textV124:page-line15 running text
13VII101:1728 running textV124:page-line16 running text
14VII101:1729 running textV124:page-line17 running text
15VII101:1730 running textV124:page-line18 running text
16VII101:1731 running textV124:page-line19 running text
17VII102:1732 running textV124:page-line20 running text
18VII102:1733 running textV124:page-line21 running text
19VII102:1734 running textV124:page-line22 running text
20VII102:1735 running textV124:page-line23 running text
21VII102:1736 running textV125:page-line1 running text
22VII102:1737 running textV125:page-line2 running text
23VII102:1738 running textV125:page-line3 running text
24VII102:1739 running textV125:page-line4 running text
25VII102:1740 running textV125:page-line5 running text
26VII102:1741 running textV125:page-line6 running text
27VII102:1742 running textV125:page-line7 running text
28VII102:1743 running textV125:page-line8 running text
29VII102:1744 running textV125:page-line9 running text
30VII102:1745 running textV125:page-line10 running text
31VII102:1746 running textV125:page-line11 running text
32VII102:1747 running textV125:page-line12 running text
33VII102:1748 running textV125:page-line13 running text
34VII102:1749 running textV125:page-line14 running text
35VII103:1750 running textV125:page-line15 running text
36VII103:1751 running textV125:page-line16 running text
37VII103:1752 running textV125:page-line17 running text
38VII103:1753 running text | VII103:1754 running textV125:page-line18 running text | V125:page-line19 running text
39VII103:1754 running textV125:page-line19 running text
40VII103:1755 running textV125:page-line20 running text
41VII103:1756 running textV125:page-line21 running text
42VII103:1757 running textV125:page-line22 running text
43VII103:1758 running textV125:page-line23 running text
44VII103:1759 running textV125:page-line24 running text
45VII103:1760 running textV125:page-line25 running text
46VII103:1761 running text | VII103:1762 running textV126:page-line1 running text | V126:page-line2 running text
47VII103:1763 running textV126:page-line3 running text
48VII103:1764 running textV126:page-line4 running text