Ardeshir Writes to Kayd of Hind
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Power without repose
Moscow: VII164–166 ardeshir 160 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 161 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 162 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 163 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 164 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 165 running text; Mohl: V174 ardeshir running text; English 1, aligned reference 160 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 2, aligned reference 161 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 3, aligned reference 162 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 4, aligned reference 163 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 5, aligned reference 164 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 6, aligned reference 165; Ganjoor: sh6:1 running poem body | sh6:2 running poem body | sh6:3 running poem body | sh6:4 running poem body | sh6:5 running poem body | sh6:6 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI204–207 Ardeshir 158 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 159 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 160 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 161 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 162 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 163 running text
Moscow printed p.164 · Mohl printed p.174 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.204
Shapur’s growth has secured a royal future, but Ardeshir still cannot find the peace he expects conquest to bring. The English gives the repetition of provincial resistance a clear rhythm: suppression in one place is followed by revolt elsewhere. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi support this restlessness and the king’s appeal to the Creator. His prayer treats possession of the whole world as the condition for undistracted worship, a revealing connection between devotion and ambition. The evil eye around Shapur belongs to the protection of a precious heir; it does not explain the political unrest that occupies the remainder of the opening.
7–12Seeking counsel outside the court
Moscow: VII164–166 ardeshir 166 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 167 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 168 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 169 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 171 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 172 running text; Mohl: V174 ardeshir running text; English 7, aligned reference 166 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 8, aligned reference 167 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 9, aligned reference 168 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 10, aligned reference 169 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 11, aligned reference 171 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 12, aligned reference 172; Ganjoor: sh6:7 running poem body | sh6:8 running poem body | sh6:9 running poem body | sh6:10 running poem body | sh6:12 running poem body | sh6:13 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI204–207 Ardeshir 164 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 165 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 166 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 167 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 169 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 170 running text
Moscow printed p.164 · Mohl printed p.174 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.204
The minister recommends Kayd because knowledge of celestial courses might answer what military success has not resolved. The English presents the journey to Hind as a search for counsel rather than an expedition of conquest. All four editions support the sage’s role and the gifts sent with the envoy. The promise to reward a successful messenger appears as a separate Persian reference unit without a separate published English couplet; its existence should not be concealed by a forced one-to-one mapping. Horses, gold and Chinese silk mark the importance of the embassy, while the youth’s judgment matters as much as his ability to transport them.
13–18The question put to Kayd
Moscow: VII164–166 ardeshir 173 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 174 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 175 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 176 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 177 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 178 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 179 running text; Mohl: V174 ardeshir running text; English 13, aligned reference 173 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 14, aligned reference 174 | V174–175 ardeshir running text; English 15, aligned reference 175,176 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 16, aligned reference 177 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 17, aligned reference 178 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 18, aligned reference 179; Ganjoor: sh6:14 running poem body | sh6:15 running poem body | sh6:16, sh6:17 running poem body | sh6:18 running poem body | sh6:19 running poem body | sh6:20 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI204–207 Ardeshir 171 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 172 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 173 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 174 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 175 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 176 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 177 running text
Moscow printed p.164 · Mohl printed p.174 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.204
Ardeshir asks when he may stop fighting and whether further expenditure can achieve the desired peace. The English combines the adjacent Persian alternatives into one couplet at the point where continued toil is rejected if its goal is impossible. That compression should not be mistaken for a missing event. Moscow and Ganjoor retain the fuller sequence, while Mohl and Khaleghi provide the corresponding consultation. The envoy’s complete report gives Kayd access to the king’s private concern as well as his formal question. The narrative thereby treats interpretation as dependent on communication, not as a prediction uttered without knowing what the ruler seeks.
19–24Indian tables and an unwelcome union
Moscow: VII164–166 ardeshir 180 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 181 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 182 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 183 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 184 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 185 running text; Mohl: V174 ardeshir running text; English 19, aligned reference 180 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 20, aligned reference 181 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 21, aligned reference 182 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 22, aligned reference 183 | V174 ardeshir running text; English 23, aligned reference 184 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 24, aligned reference 185; Ganjoor: sh6:21 running poem body | sh6:22 running poem body | sh6:23 running poem body | sh6:24 running poem body | sh6:25 running poem body | sh6:26 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI204–207 Ardeshir 178 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 179 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 180 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 181 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 182 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 183 running text
Moscow printed p.164 · Mohl printed p.174 · Mohl printed p.175 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.204
The English’s Indian tables have a specific basis in Mohl’s zīj-e Hendi. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi instead give Roman astronomical tables at this point, although Kayd himself remains in Hind. The difference concerns the attribution of the tables, not whether an astrolabe and calculation appear in the consultation. Kayd’s answer joins the fortunes of Ardeshir’s house to Mehrak’s line. “Peace shall bless his throne” makes the prediction immediately intelligible, but its condition overturns the king’s understanding of security: the enemy family must become kin. The following chapters develop that paradox through actions taken to prevent precisely the union predicted here.
25–30Hearing an answer without accepting it
Moscow: VII164–166 ardeshir 186 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 187 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 188 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 189 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 190 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 191 running text; Mohl: V175 ardeshir running text; English 25, aligned reference 186 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 26, aligned reference 187 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 27, aligned reference 188 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 28, aligned reference 189 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 29, aligned reference 190 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 30, aligned reference 191; Ganjoor: sh6:27 running poem body | sh6:28 running poem body | sh6:29 running poem body | sh6:30 running poem body | sh6:31 running poem body | sh6:32 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI204–207 Ardeshir 184 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 185 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 186 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 187 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 188 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 189 running text
Moscow printed p.164 · Mohl printed p.175 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.204
The embassy ends with gifts and an instruction to transmit the whole answer. The English keeps Kayd’s conditional confidence separate from Ardeshir’s hostile reception. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi support the change in the king’s face and his refusal of the proposed kinship. “God forbid” expresses his rejection, not the narrator’s cancellation of the prediction. This distinction is crucial because the eventual marriage will occur without his approval. The scene’s failure is therefore not a failure of communication: the messenger reports the counsel, and the king understands enough of it to react against the very family connection on which peace is said to depend.
31–36A prediction answered with a death order
Moscow: VII164–166 ardeshir 192 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 193 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 194 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 195 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 196 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 197 running text; Mohl: V175 ardeshir running text; English 31, aligned reference 192 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 32, aligned reference 193 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 33, aligned reference 194 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 34, aligned reference 195 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 35, aligned reference 196 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 36, aligned reference 197; Ganjoor: sh6:33 running poem body | sh6:34 running poem body | sh6:35 running poem body | sh6:36 running poem body | sh6:37 running poem body | sh6:38 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI204–207 Ardeshir 190 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 191 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 192 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 193 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 194 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 195 running text
Moscow printed p.164 · Mohl printed p.175 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.204
Ardeshir treats incorporation of the enemy household as an invitation to renewed war. The English preserves his anger over spent treasure and effort before the search order turns against Mehrak’s surviving daughter. The four editions support the threat of burning; this is not merely a figurative statement of disapproval. The wide list of destinations enlarges the king’s intended reach, while Jahram supplies the concrete point of pursuit. “The dust shall weep” intensifies the cruelty through the reaction of the ground itself. The passage should remain beside the earlier promises of justice, because the narrative allows royal fear to produce a command those promises cannot comfortably excuse.
37–40A refuge outside royal sight
Moscow: VII164–166 ardeshir 198 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 199 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 200 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 201 running text; Mohl: V175 ardeshir running text; English 37, aligned reference 198 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 38, aligned reference 199 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 39, aligned reference 200 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 40, aligned reference 201; Ganjoor: sh6:39 running poem body | sh6:40 running poem body | sh6:41 running poem body | sh6:42 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI204–207 Ardeshir 196 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 197 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 198 running text | VI204–207 Ardeshir 199 running text
Moscow printed p.164 · Mohl printed p.175 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.204
The girl’s concealment in the village chief’s household answers a direct threat, not an unexplained preference for rural life. The English retains both refuge and honorable treatment, providing the conditions for Shapur’s later encounter at the well. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give her growth in beauty and discernment, so the cypress image carries more than visual ornament. Her hidden lineage will eventually be inferred through bearing and strength, but it remains socially dangerous knowledge. The short ending suspends the king’s search and keeps the protected daughter alive beyond his immediate reach. Her future importance is known to the reader before it is known to Shapur.
Source record and limits
English
40 published English couplets, preserved with their published wording, punctuation and order. The published chapter determines the English boundary. Published D7.4: 40 English couplets. Declared reference: ardeshir, Moscow/Ganjoor alignment 160–201; edition-specific numbering is identified separately.
Moscow
Moscow edition, volume VII (1968), printed pp.164–166; ardeshir reference verses 160–201. Each English unit has an individual running, actual-apparatus or checked-local-gap account. Additional transitions retain their preceding-reign locators. Additional Persian units are kept separate from English units.
Mohl
Jules Mohl, volume V, printed pp.174–175. Individual running counterparts are identified by the English unit and the paired Persian reference; these alignment numbers are not asserted to be Mohl’s printed verse numbers. Longer running passages, reorderings and changes of heading are stated in the register and notes.
Ganjoor
ardeshir digital poem body, individually linked by subdivision and couplet anchor. The paired Persian normally follows this digital running reference. Where it has a checked local gap, the row labels an independently transcribed printed counterpart or a deliberately limited excerpt. No missing verse is reconstructed from the English.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VI, printed pp.204–207, with relocated transitions and apparatus at the separately stated pages. Running text, actual printed additional verses, actual variant wording, and inspected local gaps are distinct evidence classes. An addition notice alone is not counted as a counterpart.
Evidence boundaries
No appendix evidence is claimed. A checked local gap applies to the specified narrative junction, not to every manuscript, appendix or occurrence elsewhere. A relocated passage is identified as running text in its actual position. Unverified readings and narrower English interpretations remain explicitly qualified. Printed excerpts use readable Unicode spacing; they are not diplomatic reproductions of typography. Single-hemistich excerpts are labelled as such.
Consequential readings
English 15: One English couplet combines two Persian reference units. English 19: Indian astronomical tables follows Mohl; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi have Roman zij.
Additional Persian units
Source-only register rows: S170. These have no separate English counterpart and are excluded from the English-couplet denominator.
Moscow printed p.164 · Moscow printed p.165 · Moscow printed p.166
Mohl printed p.174 · Mohl printed p.175
Khaleghi printed p.204 · Khaleghi printed p.205 · Khaleghi printed p.206 · Khaleghi printed p.207
D7.4 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VII164–166 ardeshir 160 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 1, aligned reference 160 |
| 2 | VII164–166 ardeshir 161 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 2, aligned reference 161 |
| 3 | VII164–166 ardeshir 162 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 3, aligned reference 162 |
| 4 | VII164–166 ardeshir 163 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 4, aligned reference 163 |
| 5 | VII164–166 ardeshir 164 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 5, aligned reference 164 |
| 6 | VII164–166 ardeshir 165 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 6, aligned reference 165 |
| 7 | VII164–166 ardeshir 166 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 7, aligned reference 166 |
| 8 | VII164–166 ardeshir 167 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 8, aligned reference 167 |
| 9 | VII164–166 ardeshir 168 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 9, aligned reference 168 |
| 10 | VII164–166 ardeshir 169 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 10, aligned reference 169 |
| 11 | VII164–166 ardeshir 171 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 11, aligned reference 171 |
| 12 | VII164–166 ardeshir 172 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 12, aligned reference 172 |
| 13 | VII164–166 ardeshir 173 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 13, aligned reference 173 |
| 14 | VII164–166 ardeshir 174 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 14, aligned reference 174 |
| 15 | VII164–166 ardeshir 175 running text | VII164–166 ardeshir 176 running text | V174–175 ardeshir running text; English 15, aligned reference 175,176 |
| 16 | VII164–166 ardeshir 177 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 16, aligned reference 177 |
| 17 | VII164–166 ardeshir 178 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 17, aligned reference 178 |
| 18 | VII164–166 ardeshir 179 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 18, aligned reference 179 |
| 19 | VII164–166 ardeshir 180 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 19, aligned reference 180 |
| 20 | VII164–166 ardeshir 181 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 20, aligned reference 181 |
| 21 | VII164–166 ardeshir 182 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 21, aligned reference 182 |
| 22 | VII164–166 ardeshir 183 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 22, aligned reference 183 |
| 23 | VII164–166 ardeshir 184 running text | V174 ardeshir running text; English 23, aligned reference 184 |
| 24 | VII164–166 ardeshir 185 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 24, aligned reference 185 |
| 25 | VII164–166 ardeshir 186 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 25, aligned reference 186 |
| 26 | VII164–166 ardeshir 187 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 26, aligned reference 187 |
| 27 | VII164–166 ardeshir 188 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 27, aligned reference 188 |
| 28 | VII164–166 ardeshir 189 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 28, aligned reference 189 |
| 29 | VII164–166 ardeshir 190 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 29, aligned reference 190 |
| 30 | VII164–166 ardeshir 191 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 30, aligned reference 191 |
| 31 | VII164–166 ardeshir 192 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 31, aligned reference 192 |
| 32 | VII164–166 ardeshir 193 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 32, aligned reference 193 |
| 33 | VII164–166 ardeshir 194 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 33, aligned reference 194 |
| 34 | VII164–166 ardeshir 195 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 34, aligned reference 195 |
| 35 | VII164–166 ardeshir 196 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 35, aligned reference 196 |
| 36 | VII164–166 ardeshir 197 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 36, aligned reference 197 |
| 37 | VII164–166 ardeshir 198 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 37, aligned reference 198 |
| 38 | VII164–166 ardeshir 199 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 38, aligned reference 199 |
| 39 | VII164–166 ardeshir 200 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 39, aligned reference 200 |
| 40 | VII164–166 ardeshir 201 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 40, aligned reference 201 |
New Naqqali