Shapur and the Daughter of Mehrak
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The hunt reaches the village
Moscow: VII166–169 ardeshir 202 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 203 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 204 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 205 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 206 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 207 running text; Mohl: V175 ardeshir running text; English 1, aligned reference 202 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 2, aligned reference 203 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 3, aligned reference 204 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 4, aligned reference 205 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 5, aligned reference 206 | V175 ardeshir running text; English 6, aligned reference 207; Ganjoor: sh7:1 running poem body | sh7:2 running poem body | sh7:3 running poem body | sh7:4 running poem body | sh7:5 running poem body | sh7:6 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI207–210 Ardeshir 200 running text (bracketed) | VI207–210 Ardeshir 201 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 202 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 203 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 204 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 205 running text
Moscow printed p.166 · Mohl printed p.175 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.207
The opening names Mehrak’s daughter before Shapur sees her, placing the reader ahead of the prince in the recognition scene. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi support the transition into the hunt and the substantial village household. Khaleghi places the opening transition before the internal heading, a small boundary difference rather than the loss of its text. The English’s grove, hall and palace prevent the setting from becoming an undifferentiated poor cottage. The chief can shelter a royal fugitive with dignity. Shapur’s movement away from the king’s company also creates the practical privacy needed for a meeting whose consequences Ardeshir has tried to forbid.
7–12Hospitality and useful knowledge
Moscow: VII166–169 ardeshir 208 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 209 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 210 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 211 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 212 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 213 running text; Mohl: V176 ardeshir running text; English 7, aligned reference 208 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 8, aligned reference 209 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 9, aligned reference 210 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 10, aligned reference 211 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 11, aligned reference 212 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 12, aligned reference 213; Ganjoor: sh7:7 running poem body | sh7:8 running poem body | sh7:9 running poem body | sh7:10 running poem body | sh7:11 running poem body | sh7:12 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI207–210 Ardeshir 206 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 207 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 208 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 209 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 210 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 211 running text
Moscow printed p.166 · Mohl printed p.176 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.207
The maiden’s first intervention is practical: she distinguishes the brackish village water from the cold, sweet water in the well. The English gives her initiative, speech and competence before Shapur asks who she is. All four editions support the greeting and offer to draw water. Her moonlike appearance belongs to conventional praise, but the work she is doing is materially important to the encounter. The scene does not depend on beauty alone attracting a prince. Knowledge of the place, concern for the thirsty horse and confidence with the well’s equipment establish a capable person whose social identity the prince has not yet understood.
13–18A courteous offer becomes a test of strength
Moscow: VII166–169 ardeshir 214 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 215 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 216 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 217 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 218 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 219 running text; Mohl: V176 ardeshir running text; English 13, aligned reference 214 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 14, aligned reference 215 | V175–177 ardeshir running text; English 15, aligned reference 216 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 16, aligned reference 217 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 17, aligned reference 218 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 18, aligned reference 219; Ganjoor: sh7:13 running poem body | sh7:14 running poem body | sh7:15 running poem body | sh7:16 running poem body | sh7:17 running poem body | sh7:18 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI207–210 Ardeshir 212 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 213 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 214 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 215 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 216 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 217 running text
Moscow printed p.166 · Mohl printed p.175 · Mohl printed p.176 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.207
Shapur tries to spare the maiden labor by assigning it to a servant. The English keeps the sequence from courtesy to withdrawal and then to the servant’s difficulty, so the coming comparison is generated by an ordinary task. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi support the heavy bucket, rope and wheel. The prince’s assumption that attendants should perform the work is socially intelligible, but the failed attempt exposes his incomplete estimate of the woman’s strength. Nothing in this passage requires a magical well or supernatural equipment. Its narrative work depends on the contrast between the apparent ease of her repeated labor and the servant’s inability to reproduce it.
19–24Gendered insult and inferred lineage
Moscow: VII166–169 ardeshir 220 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 221 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 222 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 223 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 224 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 225 running text; Mohl: V176 ardeshir running text; English 19, aligned reference 220 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 20, aligned reference 221 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 21, aligned reference 222 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 22, aligned reference 223 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 23, aligned reference 224 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 24, aligned reference 225; Ganjoor: sh7:19 running poem body | sh7:20 running poem body | sh7:21 running poem body | sh7:22 running poem body | sh7:23 running poem body | sh7:24 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI207–210 Ardeshir 218 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 219 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 220 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 221 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 222 running text | VI208 Ardeshir 222/223: checked local gap; notes 32–33 are word variants, not these additional verses
Moscow printed p.166 · Mohl printed p.176 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.207 · Khaleghi printed p.208
“You half a woman” preserves the force of Shapur’s gendered rebuke rather than smoothing it into a neutral criticism of weakness. The irony is that the woman has just supplied the standard of superior performance. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor continue to an explicit inference of Kayanian descent from her strength. Khaleghi has the lifting and praise but a checked local gap for the two following Moscow units; the nearby word variants do not print those missing couplets. The English therefore has primary support for its fuller reasoning, while the four editions should not be described as uniformly stating the same explicit genealogical conclusion here.
25–30Recognition travels in both directions
Moscow: VII166–169 ardeshir 226 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 227 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 228 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 229 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 230 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 231 running text; Mohl: V176 ardeshir running text; English 25, aligned reference 226 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 26, aligned reference 227 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 27, aligned reference 228 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 28, aligned reference 229 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 29, aligned reference 230 | V176 ardeshir running text; English 30, aligned reference 231; Ganjoor: sh7:25 running poem body | sh7:26 running poem body | sh7:27 running poem body | sh7:28 running poem body | sh7:29 running poem body | sh7:30 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI208 Ardeshir 222/223: checked local gap; notes 32–33 are word variants, not these additional verses | VI207–210 Ardeshir 223 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 224 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 225 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 226 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 227 running text
Moscow printed p.166 · Mohl printed p.176 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.207 · Khaleghi printed p.208
The maiden’s blessing reveals that she already knows Shapur’s identity, while he is still trying to discover hers. Her explanation invokes reports of his truth, strength and generosity. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor supply the fuller return-and-blessing sequence; Khaleghi resumes at the blessing after a local gap, as the register records. The English’s Nile comparison makes lavish giving vivid and preserves the river’s place in the praise. The claim that water could become milk is likewise laudatory language attached to the prince’s presence, not a narrated transformation of the well. Her knowledge creates a reciprocal recognition scene rather than a one-sided royal examination.
31–36Appearance against the offered genealogy
Moscow: VII166–169 ardeshir 232 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 233 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 234 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 235 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 236 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 237 running text; Mohl: V176 ardeshir running text; English 31, aligned reference 232 | V177 ardeshir running text; English 32, aligned reference 233 | V177 ardeshir running text; English 33, aligned reference 234 | V177 ardeshir running text; English 34, aligned reference 235 | V175–177 ardeshir running text; English 35, aligned reference 236 | V177 ardeshir running text; English 36, aligned reference 237; Ganjoor: sh7:31 running poem body | sh7:32 running poem body | sh7:33 running poem body | sh7:34 running poem body | sh7:35 running poem body | sh7:36 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI207–210 Ardeshir 228 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 229 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 230 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 231 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 232 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 233 running text
Moscow printed p.166 · Mohl printed p.175 · Mohl printed p.176 · Mohl printed p.177 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.207
The comparison with Bahman places Shapur within an established heroic and royal model before he presses the maiden about her own descent. The English retains her claim to be the chief’s daughter and his refusal to accept it. All four editions support this exchange. The prince’s reasoning treats body, bearing and beauty as signs that disclose noble birth, an assumption belonging to the narrative’s social imagination rather than an independently valid test of ancestry. “No farmer’s daughter” sharpens the hierarchy in familiar English. The consequence is that concealment becomes harder precisely because the attributes that protected her dignity also make her cover story seem implausible to him.
37–42Disclosure requires a promise of safety
Moscow: VII166–169 ardeshir 238 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 239 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 240 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 241 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 242 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 243 running text; Mohl: V177 ardeshir running text; English 37, aligned reference 238 | V177 ardeshir running text; English 38, aligned reference 239 | V177 ardeshir running text; English 39, aligned reference 240 | V177 ardeshir running text; English 40, aligned reference 241 | V177 ardeshir running text; English 41, aligned reference 242 | V177 ardeshir running text; English 42, aligned reference 243; Ganjoor: sh7:37 running poem body | sh7:38 running poem body | sh7:39 running poem body | sh7:40 running poem body | sh7:41 running poem body | sh7:42 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI207–210 Ardeshir 234 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 235 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 236 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 237 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 238 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 239 running text
Moscow printed p.166 · Mohl printed p.177 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.207
The maiden does not reveal her lineage until she has asked for protection from Ardeshir’s anger. The English makes that danger explicit and then preserves the prince’s assurance that friends do not encounter hatred in his household. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi support the request, promise and identification as Mehrak’s daughter. The promise is significant because Shapur has not yet obtained his father’s agreement to this alliance. Her disclosure therefore rests on his personal undertaking. Naming the pious intermediary and the village chief also reminds the reader that survival has required a network of protection, rather than occurring through royal favor alone.
43–46Marriage within the protected household
Moscow: VII166–169 ardeshir 244 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 245 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 246 running text | VII166–169 ardeshir 247 running text; Mohl: V177 ardeshir running text; English 43, aligned reference 244 | V177 ardeshir running text; English 44, aligned reference 245 | V177 ardeshir running text; English 45, aligned reference 246 | V177 ardeshir running text; English 46, aligned reference 247; Ganjoor: sh7:43 running poem body | sh7:44 running poem body | sh7:45 running poem body | sh7:46 running poem body; Khaleghi: VI207–210 Ardeshir 240 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 241 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 242 running text | VI207–210 Ardeshir 243 running text
Moscow printed p.166 · Mohl printed p.177 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.207
Drawing water is explained as a consequence of concealment, and the prince’s decision turns the refuge into the place of marriage. The English preserves the chief’s participation and the explicit reference to the rites of fire worshippers. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi support that religious designation; it should neither be removed as awkward nor expanded into a detailed ceremony the passage does not describe. The chief’s role also prevents the scene from reading as a purely private seizure of the maiden. The marriage answers Kayd’s prediction, but Ardeshir remains uninformed. The household union is accomplished before the political reconciliation that will eventually acknowledge it.
Source record and limits
English
46 published English couplets, preserved with their published wording, punctuation and order. The published chapter determines the English boundary. Published D7.5: 46 English couplets. Declared reference: ardeshir, Moscow/Ganjoor alignment 202–247; edition-specific numbering is identified separately.
Moscow
Moscow edition, volume VII (1968), printed pp.166–169; ardeshir reference verses 202–247. Each English unit has an individual running, actual-apparatus or checked-local-gap account. Additional transitions retain their preceding-reign locators. Additional Persian units are kept separate from English units.
Mohl
Jules Mohl, volume V, printed pp.175–177. Individual running counterparts are identified by the English unit and the paired Persian reference; these alignment numbers are not asserted to be Mohl’s printed verse numbers. Longer running passages, reorderings and changes of heading are stated in the register and notes.
Ganjoor
ardeshir digital poem body, individually linked by subdivision and couplet anchor. The paired Persian normally follows this digital running reference. Where it has a checked local gap, the row labels an independently transcribed printed counterpart or a deliberately limited excerpt. No missing verse is reconstructed from the English.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VI, printed pp.207–210, with relocated transitions and apparatus at the separately stated pages. Running text, actual printed additional verses, actual variant wording, and inspected local gaps are distinct evidence classes. An addition notice alone is not counted as a counterpart.
Evidence boundaries
No appendix evidence is claimed. A checked local gap applies to the specified narrative junction, not to every manuscript, appendix or occurrence elsewhere. A relocated passage is identified as running text in its actual position. Unverified readings and narrower English interpretations remain explicitly qualified. Printed excerpts use readable Unicode spacing; they are not diplomatic reproductions of typography. Single-hemistich excerpts are labelled as such.
Consequential readings
English 24: Explicit Kayanian inference in Moscow/Mohl/Ganjoor; checked Khaleghi local gap. Nearby word variants are not these extra verses. English 25: Return-to-prince unit has a checked Khaleghi local gap before the blessing.
Additional Persian units
All declared Moscow/Ganjoor reference units are allocated to English counterparts; actual additional printed evidence is classified separately.
Moscow printed p.166 · Moscow printed p.167 · Moscow printed p.168 · Moscow printed p.169
Mohl printed p.175 · Mohl printed p.176 · Mohl printed p.177
Khaleghi printed p.207 · Khaleghi printed p.208 · Khaleghi printed p.209 · Khaleghi printed p.210
D7.5 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VII166–169 ardeshir 202 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 1, aligned reference 202 |
| 2 | VII166–169 ardeshir 203 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 2, aligned reference 203 |
| 3 | VII166–169 ardeshir 204 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 3, aligned reference 204 |
| 4 | VII166–169 ardeshir 205 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 4, aligned reference 205 |
| 5 | VII166–169 ardeshir 206 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 5, aligned reference 206 |
| 6 | VII166–169 ardeshir 207 running text | V175 ardeshir running text; English 6, aligned reference 207 |
| 7 | VII166–169 ardeshir 208 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 7, aligned reference 208 |
| 8 | VII166–169 ardeshir 209 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 8, aligned reference 209 |
| 9 | VII166–169 ardeshir 210 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 9, aligned reference 210 |
| 10 | VII166–169 ardeshir 211 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 10, aligned reference 211 |
| 11 | VII166–169 ardeshir 212 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 11, aligned reference 212 |
| 12 | VII166–169 ardeshir 213 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 12, aligned reference 213 |
| 13 | VII166–169 ardeshir 214 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 13, aligned reference 214 |
| 14 | VII166–169 ardeshir 215 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 14, aligned reference 215 |
| 15 | VII166–169 ardeshir 216 running text | V175–177 ardeshir running text; English 15, aligned reference 216 |
| 16 | VII166–169 ardeshir 217 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 16, aligned reference 217 |
| 17 | VII166–169 ardeshir 218 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 17, aligned reference 218 |
| 18 | VII166–169 ardeshir 219 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 18, aligned reference 219 |
| 19 | VII166–169 ardeshir 220 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 19, aligned reference 220 |
| 20 | VII166–169 ardeshir 221 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 20, aligned reference 221 |
| 21 | VII166–169 ardeshir 222 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 21, aligned reference 222 |
| 22 | VII166–169 ardeshir 223 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 22, aligned reference 223 |
| 23 | VII166–169 ardeshir 224 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 23, aligned reference 224 |
| 24 | VII166–169 ardeshir 225 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 24, aligned reference 225 |
| 25 | VII166–169 ardeshir 226 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 25, aligned reference 226 |
| 26 | VII166–169 ardeshir 227 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 26, aligned reference 227 |
| 27 | VII166–169 ardeshir 228 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 27, aligned reference 228 |
| 28 | VII166–169 ardeshir 229 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 28, aligned reference 229 |
| 29 | VII166–169 ardeshir 230 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 29, aligned reference 230 |
| 30 | VII166–169 ardeshir 231 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 30, aligned reference 231 |
| 31 | VII166–169 ardeshir 232 running text | V176 ardeshir running text; English 31, aligned reference 232 |
| 32 | VII166–169 ardeshir 233 running text | V177 ardeshir running text; English 32, aligned reference 233 |
| 33 | VII166–169 ardeshir 234 running text | V177 ardeshir running text; English 33, aligned reference 234 |
| 34 | VII166–169 ardeshir 235 running text | V177 ardeshir running text; English 34, aligned reference 235 |
| 35 | VII166–169 ardeshir 236 running text | V175–177 ardeshir running text; English 35, aligned reference 236 |
| 36 | VII166–169 ardeshir 237 running text | V177 ardeshir running text; English 36, aligned reference 237 |
| 37 | VII166–169 ardeshir 238 running text | V177 ardeshir running text; English 37, aligned reference 238 |
| 38 | VII166–169 ardeshir 239 running text | V177 ardeshir running text; English 38, aligned reference 239 |
| 39 | VII166–169 ardeshir 240 running text | V177 ardeshir running text; English 39, aligned reference 240 |
| 40 | VII166–169 ardeshir 241 running text | V177 ardeshir running text; English 40, aligned reference 241 |
| 41 | VII166–169 ardeshir 242 running text | V177 ardeshir running text; English 41, aligned reference 242 |
| 42 | VII166–169 ardeshir 243 running text | V177 ardeshir running text; English 42, aligned reference 243 |
| 43 | VII166–169 ardeshir 244 running text | V177 ardeshir running text; English 43, aligned reference 244 |
| 44 | VII166–169 ardeshir 245 running text | V177 ardeshir running text; English 44, aligned reference 245 |
| 45 | VII166–169 ardeshir 246 running text | V177 ardeshir running text; English 45, aligned reference 246 |
| 46 | VII166–169 ardeshir 247 running text | V177 ardeshir running text; English 46, aligned reference 247 |
New Naqqali