Malika Betrays Tair and Shapur Triumphs
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Hospitality becomes a means of capture
Moscow: VII224–226 zolaktaf verse81, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse82, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse83, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse84, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse85, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse86, running text; Mohl: V217–218 running text; English1, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference81 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English2, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference82 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English3, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference83 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English4, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference84 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English5, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference85 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English6, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference86 (not Mohl verse numbering); Ganjoor: Running poem body; Khaleghi: VI296–299 Shapur80, running text | VI296–299 Shapur81, running text | VI296–299 Shapur82, running text | VI296–299 Shapur83, running text | VI296–299 Shapur84, running text | VI296–299 Shapur85, running text
Moscow printed p.224 · Mohl printed p.217 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.296
The golden dawn opens preparations for an action that will occur after dark. Across Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi, Malika gains access to stores and distributes food, wine and fragrant plants before instructing the cupbearer. English’s language of winning assistance gives the process a persuasive quality; the Persian sequence also emphasizes her command over keys and servants. The feast is therefore double in function: outwardly generous, inwardly designed to disable resistance. Retaining the food and flowers matters because intoxication does not arrive as an isolated trick. It is embedded in a complete performance of care for the chiefs whose vigilance she intends to overcome.
7–12Sleep changes the balance of power
Moscow: VII224–226 zolaktaf verse87, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse88, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse89, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse90, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse91, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse92, running text; Mohl: V217–218 running text; English7, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference87 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English8, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference88 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English9, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference89 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English10, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference90 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English11, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference91 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English12, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference92 (not Mohl verse numbering); Ganjoor: Running poem body; Khaleghi: VI296–299 Shapur86, running text | VI296–299 Shapur87, running text | VI296–299 Shapur88, running text | VI296–299 Shapur89, running text | VI296–299 Shapur90, running text | VI296–299 Shapur91, running text
Moscow printed p.224 · Mohl printed p.217 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.296
Malika’s instructions aim at collective incapacity, and the cupbearer’s declaration of obedience establishes who controls the immediate means. All four presentations then move through sunset, Tair’s ceremonial drinking and his sleep after one watch. English retains the watch as a measured interval, making the plan’s execution more precise than a vague statement that everyone became drunk. Naming the Ghassanids before drinking also gives Tair a moment of dynastic self-assertion just before he loses control. The surrounding sleepers are vulnerable because the fortress’s ordinary hierarchy has been diverted from within. The passage’s suspense depends on coordinated obedience, not on wine acting independently of human design.
13–18A signal answers the waiting army
Moscow: VII224–226 zolaktaf verse93, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse94, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse95, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse96, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse97, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse98, running text; Mohl: V217–218 running text; English13, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference93 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English14, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference94 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English15, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference95 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English16, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference96 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English17, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference97 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English18, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference98 (not Mohl verse numbering); Ganjoor: Running poem body; Khaleghi: VI296–299 Shapur92, running text | VI296–299 Shapur93, running text | VI296–299 Shapur94, running text | VI296–299 Shapur95, running text | VI296–299 Shapur96, running text | VI296–299 Shapur97, running text
Moscow printed p.224 · Mohl printed p.217 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.296
The secret opening of the gate and the visible light give Shapur a reliable signal. English preserves the contrast between whispered action inside and his readiness outside, which is common to the four presentations. Waking fortune is an apt rendering because the personified good luck stands opposite the literal sleeping defenders. Malika is then placed in the women’s quarters before the assault develops. That order matters to the promised marriage and to her immediate safety, but it does not turn the subsequent killing into part of her spoken bargain. The narrative distinguishes the access she supplies from the military decisions Shapur makes after entry.
19–24Victory does not erase resistance
Moscow: VII224–226 zolaktaf verse99, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse100, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse101, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse102, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse103, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse104, running text; Mohl: V217–218 running text; English19, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference99 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English20, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference100 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English21, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference101 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English22, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference102 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English23, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference103 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English24, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference104 (not Mohl verse numbering); Ganjoor: Running poem body; Khaleghi: VI296–299 Shapur98, running text | VI296–299 Shapur99, running text | VI296–299 Shapur100, running text | VI296–299 Shapur101, running text | VI296–299 Shapur102, running text | VI296–299 Shapur103, running text
Moscow printed p.224 · Mohl printed p.217 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.296
The English keeps a useful complication in the capture: some defenders are helplessly asleep, while others wake and fight without turning away. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi likewise distinguish these groups. Consequently the taking of the fortress is neither a wholly unopposed entry nor a conventional battle between equally prepared armies. English generalizes the number of drunken sleepers into an uncountable mass, where the paired Persian specifies more than a thousand. Tair’s nakedness then concentrates the collective defeat into one exposed body. The seizure of old treasure reinforces the transfer of power, but the passage’s strongest reversal is the ruler reduced to compulsory movement before his captor.
25–30The daughter enthroned beside the victor
Moscow: VII224–226 zolaktaf verse105, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse106, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse107, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse108, running text | VII225 apparatus note14, actual additional verse1 | VII225 apparatus note14, actual additional verse2; Mohl: V217–218 running text; English25, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference105 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English26, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference106 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English27, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference107 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English28, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference108 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 additional running counterpart for English29; see paired excerpt | V217–218 additional running counterpart for English30; see paired excerpt; Ganjoor: Running poem body | Checked local gap after zolaktaf/sh4:28; Khaleghi: VI296–299 Shapur104, running text | VI296–299 Shapur105, running text | VI296–299 Shapur106, running text | VI296–299 Shapur107, running text | VI298 Shapur108 running text | VI298 Shapur109 running text
Moscow printed p.224 · Moscow printed p.225 · Mohl printed p.217 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.296 · Khaleghi printed p.298
English distributes the dawn, turquoise throne and audience across adjacent couplets, so the two opening units should be read together rather than judged as isolated word-for-word matches. Mohl and Khaleghi give the daughter’s seating and her father’s appearance in their running narratives; Moscow prints the two corresponding verses in its actual apparatus, while Ganjoor has a checked local gap. The addition makes the contrast exceptionally visible: Malika is adorned and seated, Tair bareheaded and bound. English’s emphasis on her public splendor sharpens that contrast without inventing the scene. The father sees the political result of her choice before he is allowed to interpret it aloud.
31–36A warning answered by an older grievance
Moscow: VII224–226 zolaktaf verse109, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse110, running text | VII225 Shapur111 running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse112, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse113, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse114, running text; Mohl: V217–218 running text; English31, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference109 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English32, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference110 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 additional running counterpart for English33; see paired excerpt | V217–218 running text; English34, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference111 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English35, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference112 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English36, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference113 (not Mohl verse numbering); Ganjoor: Running poem body | Checked local gap after zolaktaf/sh4:30; Khaleghi: VI296–299 Shapur110, running text | VI296–299 Shapur111, running text | VI299 Shapur112 running text | VI296–299 Shapur113, running text | VI296–299 Shapur114, running text | VI296–299 Shapur115, running text
Moscow printed p.224 · Moscow printed p.225 · Mohl printed p.217 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.296 · Khaleghi printed p.299
Tair interprets the disaster as his daughter’s treachery and warns Shapur against outsiders. Moscow and Khaleghi retain that warning in running text, as does Mohl; Ganjoor passes over the separate warning verse. English then makes Shapur name Narsi’s daughter Nusha, recalling the earlier abduction clearly. At this later speech, however, the checked four-source local wording calls the abducted woman Bahram’s daughter. The English therefore harmonizes a genealogical tension rather than simply reproducing this passage. Its clarity has a cost: readers no longer encounter the source’s change of paternal identification. The death order follows the revived grievance, not an acceptance of Tair’s warning about Malika.
37–42The epithet is explained through mutilation
Moscow: VII224–226 zolaktaf verse115, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse116, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse117, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse118, running text | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse119, running text | VII226 apparatus note8, actual additional verse; Mohl: V217–218 running text; English37, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference114 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English38, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference115 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English39, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference116 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English40, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference117 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 running text; English41, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference118 (not Mohl verse numbering) | V217–218 additional running counterpart for English42; see paired excerpt; Ganjoor: Running poem body | Checked local gap after zolaktaf/sh4:38; Khaleghi: VI296–299 Shapur116, running text | VI296–299 Shapur117, running text | VI296–299 Shapur118, running text | VI296–299 Shapur119, running text | VI296–299 Shapur120, running text | VI299 Shapur121 running text
Moscow printed p.224 · Moscow printed p.226 · Mohl printed p.217 · Ganjoor passage · Khaleghi printed p.296 · Khaleghi printed p.299
The sources connect the name Zul-Aktaf with the tearing of shoulders, and English retains that disturbing explanation for the Arab captives. It changes the preceding treatment of Tair: the Persian counterpart also tears his shoulders from his back, whereas English concentrates on dragging his head through blood. The distinction matters because the individual execution and the collective mutilation are related but not identical acts. The final taxation verse is running text in Mohl and Khaleghi, an actual addition in Moscow’s apparatus, and locally absent in Ganjoor. Its inclusion makes survival lead to continuing subjection. The analyst must attribute this punitive logic to the narrative rather than endorse its collective violence.
Source record and limits
English
42 published English couplets, with their exact wording, punctuation and order. Published D8.1.3: 42 English couplets. Declared Ganjoor reference: zolaktaf, global reference units81–118; subdivision anchors and edition-specific numbers remain separate.
Moscow
Moscow edition, volume VII (1968), printed pp.224–226. Each English couplet has an individual running, actual-apparatus or checked-local-gap account. Shapur numbering is one greater than the Ganjoor global sequence from reference111 onward because Moscow retains the separate warning to Shapur. Prior-reign transitions have their own locators.
Mohl
Jules Mohl, volume V, printed pp.217–218. Individual counterparts are identified by English number and paired Persian reference within these printed bounds. Reference alignment numbers are not asserted to be Mohl’s printed verse numbers. Longer running passages and shared or reordered units are explicitly distinguished.
Ganjoor
zolaktaf digital running poem body, cited by subdivision and individual couplet anchor. The paired Persian normally follows this reference. Additional printed counterparts are independently transcribed; limited excerpts are labeled. No Persian verse is reconstructed from the English. Shared-reference English rows are not independent additional Persian verses.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VI, printed pp.296–299. Running, bracketed running, actual additional verses, word variants and checked local gaps are separately identified. An addition notice alone is not evidence for an individual counterpart.
Consequential readings
English25: Shared adjacent sense allocation with English26: dawn, throne and audience. English26: Shared adjacent sense allocation with English25. English34: PROVISIONAL GENEALOGICAL HARMONIZATION: English Narsi/Nusha recalls the earlier episode; local Moscow/Mohl/Ganjoor/Khaleghi speech says Bahram’s daughter. English37: English omits the local tearing of Tair’s shoulders and concentrates on dragging his head; collective shoulder mutilation follows separately.
Evidence boundaries
A checked local gap concerns the specified narrative junction, not absence from every witness or every occurrence. The printed-page ranges identify the inspected passage; verse numbers belong to the specified edition and reign. A single-hemistich excerpt is a deliberately limited transcription, not a complete replacement for an unprinted verse. Modern historical, geographical and doctrinal identifications are not certified merely by narrative agreement.
Additional Persian units
All declared Ganjoor reference units are allocated. Edition-specific additional evidence remains distinguished from the declared digital running reference.
Moscow printed p.224 · Moscow printed p.225 · Moscow printed p.226
Mohl printed p.217 · Mohl printed p.218
Khaleghi printed p.296 · Khaleghi printed p.297 · Khaleghi printed p.298 · Khaleghi printed p.299
D8.1.3 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse81, running text | V217–218 running text; English1, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference81 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 2 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse82, running text | V217–218 running text; English2, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference82 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 3 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse83, running text | V217–218 running text; English3, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference83 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 4 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse84, running text | V217–218 running text; English4, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference84 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 5 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse85, running text | V217–218 running text; English5, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference85 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 6 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse86, running text | V217–218 running text; English6, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference86 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 7 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse87, running text | V217–218 running text; English7, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference87 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 8 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse88, running text | V217–218 running text; English8, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference88 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 9 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse89, running text | V217–218 running text; English9, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference89 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 10 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse90, running text | V217–218 running text; English10, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference90 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 11 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse91, running text | V217–218 running text; English11, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference91 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 12 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse92, running text | V217–218 running text; English12, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference92 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 13 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse93, running text | V217–218 running text; English13, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference93 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 14 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse94, running text | V217–218 running text; English14, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference94 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 15 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse95, running text | V217–218 running text; English15, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference95 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 16 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse96, running text | V217–218 running text; English16, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference96 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 17 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse97, running text | V217–218 running text; English17, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference97 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 18 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse98, running text | V217–218 running text; English18, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference98 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 19 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse99, running text | V217–218 running text; English19, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference99 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 20 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse100, running text | V217–218 running text; English20, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference100 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 21 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse101, running text | V217–218 running text; English21, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference101 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 22 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse102, running text | V217–218 running text; English22, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference102 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 23 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse103, running text | V217–218 running text; English23, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference103 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 24 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse104, running text | V217–218 running text; English24, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference104 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 25 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse105, running text | V217–218 running text; English25, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference105 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 26 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse106, running text | V217–218 running text; English26, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference106 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 27 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse107, running text | V217–218 running text; English27, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference107 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 28 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse108, running text | V217–218 running text; English28, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference108 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 29 | VII225 apparatus note14, actual additional verse1 | V217–218 additional running counterpart for English29; see paired excerpt |
| 30 | VII225 apparatus note14, actual additional verse2 | V217–218 additional running counterpart for English30; see paired excerpt |
| 31 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse109, running text | V217–218 running text; English31, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference109 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 32 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse110, running text | V217–218 running text; English32, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference110 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 33 | VII225 Shapur111 running text | V217–218 additional running counterpart for English33; see paired excerpt |
| 34 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse112, running text | V217–218 running text; English34, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference111 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 35 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse113, running text | V217–218 running text; English35, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference112 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 36 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse114, running text | V217–218 running text; English36, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference113 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 37 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse115, running text | V217–218 running text; English37, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference114 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 38 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse116, running text | V217–218 running text; English38, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference115 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 39 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse117, running text | V217–218 running text; English39, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference116 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 40 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse118, running text | V217–218 running text; English40, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference117 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 41 | VII224–226 zolaktaf verse119, running text | V217–218 running text; English41, sense-aligned with zolaktaf reference118 (not Mohl verse numbering) |
| 42 | VII226 apparatus note8, actual additional verse | V217–218 additional running counterpart for English42; see paired excerpt |
New Naqqali