Bozorgmehr’s Counsel to Anooshirvan
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Who receives the opening praise
Moscow — VIII193:2394 running, VIII193:2395 running, VIII193:2396 running, VIII193:2397 running, VIII193:2398 running, VIII193:2399 running · Mohl — VI183:2460 running, VI183:2461 running, VI183:2462 running, VI183:2463 running, VI183:2464 running, VI183:2465 running · Ganjoor — sh62:1 running, sh62:2 running, sh62:3 running, sh62:4 running, sh62:5 running, sh62:6 running · Khaleghi — VII286:2426 running, VII286:2427 running, VII286:2428 running, VII286:2429 running, VII286:2430 running, VII287:2431 running
Moscow VIII p.193 · Mohl VI p.183 · Ganjoor sh62:1 · Ganjoor sh62:2 · Ganjoor sh62:3 · Ganjoor sh62:4 · Ganjoor sh62:5 · Ganjoor sh62:6 · Khaleghi VII p.286 · Khaleghi VII p.287
Moscow and Ganjoor open the sage’s words in praise of the creator, while Mohl and Khaleghi praise the sovereign and compare the resulting heart to cheerful spring. English follows the latter reading and locates the change in the king’s heart, making the counsel begin with the effect it has on its listener. The opening assurance against fault-finding still puts the listener under a standard, even while calling him a just judge. All four place the written counsel in Pahlavi on royal paper. English makes it a scroll of counsel for the soul, giving the written thing a shape and anticipating the distinction between outward possession and inward judgment.
7–12A royal document and a reticent sky
Moscow — VIII193:2400 running, VIII193:2401 running, VIII193:2402 running, VIII193:2403 running, VIII193:2404 running, VIII193:2405 running · Mohl — VI183:2466 running, VI184:2467 running, VI184:2468 running, VI184:2469 running, VI184:2470 running, VI184:2471 running · Ganjoor — sh62:7 running, sh62:8 running, sh62:9 running, sh62:10 running, sh62:11 running, sh62:12 running · Khaleghi — VII287:2432 running, VII287:2433 running, VII287:2434 running, VII287:2435 running, VII287:2436 running, VII287:2437 running
Moscow VIII p.193 · Mohl VI p.183 · Mohl VI p.184 · Ganjoor sh62:7 · Ganjoor sh62:8 · Ganjoor sh62:9 · Ganjoor sh62:10 · Ganjoor sh62:11 · Ganjoor sh62:12 · Khaleghi VII p.287
The four Persian texts put the document with the treasurer and say that the Shah may eventually read it. English makes the intended reader exclusive and supplies an interval when his duties are over. The sky, a long-standing dome unwilling to open its lips, follows. English turns that refusal into the slower disclosure of a hidden plan. The change allows a sharp counterpoint with the man who leaves a feast, puts his life in his palm and clears enemies from the land. The English keeps the exposure of his life and the relief from Ahriman, then strengthens rule through public banners. The man’s victories can be displayed even while the great dome hides what he wants to know.
13–18The laborer who acquires enough to lose
Moscow — VIII193:2406 running, VIII193:2407 running, VIII194:2408 running, VIII194:2409 running; VIII194:2410 running, VIII194:2409 running, VIII194:2410 running · Mohl — VI184:2472 running, VI184:2473 running, VI184:2474 running, VI184:2475 running; VI184:2476 running, VI184:2475 running, VI184:2476 running · Ganjoor — sh62:13 running, sh62:14 running, sh62:15 running, sh62:16, sh62:17 running, sh62:16 running, sh62:17 running · Khaleghi — VII287:2438 running, VII287:2439 running, VII287:2440 running, VII287:2441 running; VII287:2442 running, VII287:2441 running, VII287:2442 running
Moscow VIII p.193 · Moscow VIII p.194 · Mohl VI p.184 · Ganjoor sh62:13 · Ganjoor sh62:14 · Ganjoor sh62:15 · Ganjoor sh62:16 · Ganjoor sh62:17 · Khaleghi VII p.287
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi place sons, accumulated wealth and decorated halls in the hypothetical man’s life. They then consider a poor worker in toil who gains name and riches. English makes the poor labor under his hand, so the last stage of acquisition becomes the dependence of wealth on another person’s work. That reading connects to the later concern about a king extracting forced labor, but it changes the person acting in this passage. The four witnesses then deny him a century and leave his wealth to an enemy after he becomes dust. English retains that hostile transfer and spreads the consequences of mortality over several couplets, giving each discarded possession time to register.
19–24The two things that outlive power
Moscow — VIII194:2411 running, VIII194:2412 running, VIII194:2413 running, VIII194:2414 running, VIII194:2415 running · Mohl — VI184:2477 running, VI184:2478 running, VI184:2479 running, VI184:2480 running, VI184:2481 running · Ganjoor — sh62:18 running, sh62:19 running, sh62:20 running, sh62:21 running, sh62:22 running · Khaleghi — VII287:2443 running, VII288:2444 running, VII288:2445 running, VII288:2446 running, VII288:2447 running
Moscow VIII p.194 · Mohl VI p.184 · Ganjoor sh62:18 · Ganjoor sh62:19 · Ganjoor sh62:20 · Ganjoor sh62:21 · Ganjoor sh62:22 · Khaleghi VII p.287 · Khaleghi VII p.288
The four running texts list family, throne, palace, property and army among the things that fail to remain, then ask whether anyone will remember the man after his restless pursuit subsides. English turns that cessation into the end of a chase for prizes. The possible answer is a name left by good conduct, which English makes a growing flower. The figure gives continuing life to the only inheritance the example recognizes. The next Persian couplet specifies choice speech and good deeds, and the English retains the pair. Its bodies and palaces turn to dust, carrying the visual end of the conqueror into the general teaching about the works that can survive him.
25–30Elements that cannot wear words away
Moscow — VIII194 note 19 actual apparatus after v.2415, VIII194:2416 running; VIII194:2417 running, VIII194:2418 running, VIII194:2419 running, VIII194:2420 running, VIII194:2421 running · Mohl — VI184:2482 running, VI184:2483 running; VI184:2484 running, VI184:2485 running, VI184:2486 running, VI184:2487 running, VI184:2488 running · Ganjoor — Checked local gap after sh62:22, sh62:23, sh62:24 running, sh62:25 running, sh62:26 running, sh62:27 running, sh62:28 running · Khaleghi — VII288:2448 running, VII288:2449 running; VII288:2450 running, VII288:2451 running, VII288:2452 running, VII288:2453 running, VII288:2454 running
Moscow VIII p.194 · Mohl VI p.184 · Ganjoor sh62:22 · Ganjoor sh62:23 · Ganjoor sh62:24 · Ganjoor sh62:25 · Ganjoor sh62:26 · Ganjoor sh62:27 · Ganjoor sh62:28 · Khaleghi VII p.288
Mohl and Khaleghi run a verse in which sun, wind, water and earth cannot spoil good name or clean speech. Moscow actually prints it beneath the running line on good words and deeds. Ganjoor continues directly with a wish for the modest and restrained. English retains sun and wind, gives rain a direct place and gathers the elements as a test of enduring reputation. Its command to do no harm and help where due renders the compound of harmlessness and usefulness in the common text especially direct. Once the speaker leaves those words as his memorial, the Shah’s opened heart leads to a question about happiness. The extended elemental comparison gives some reason to trust the counsel still to come.
31–36The innocent person and the two roads
Moscow — VIII194:2422 running, VIII194:2423 running, VIII195:2424 running, VIII195:2424 running; VIII195:2425 running, VIII195:2426 running · Mohl — VI184:2489 running, VI184:2490 running, VI184:2491 running, VI184:2491 running; VI185:2492 running, VI185:2493 running · Ganjoor — sh62:29 running, sh62:30 running, sh62:31 running, sh62:31, sh62:32 running, sh62:33 running · Khaleghi — VII288:2455 running, VII289:2456 running, VII289:2457 running, VII289:2457 running; VII289:2458 running, VII289:2459 running
Moscow VIII p.194 · Moscow VIII p.195 · Mohl VI p.184 · Mohl VI p.185 · Ganjoor sh62:29 · Ganjoor sh62:30 · Ganjoor sh62:31 · Ganjoor sh62:32 · Ganjoor sh62:33 · Khaleghi VII p.288 · Khaleghi VII p.289
The four witnesses identify the fortunate person with innocence and the failure of Ahriman to lead him away. English restates that answer as a person who has never crossed the righteous line, giving the contrast between courses of conduct an image before the next question explicitly asks about them. Bozorgmehr sets obedience to God against the demon’s path. English preserves the claim that the divine command aids one in both worlds and separates the divine farr into its own statement. The Persian also blesses the person of upright pledge or disposition, surrounded by purity and shame. English’s “modest holiness” stresses the ethical bearing suggested by restraint and virtue, following a question framed by competing allegiances.
37–42The guardian and the two uses of a blade
Moscow — VIII195:2427 running, VIII195:2428 running, VIII195:2429 running, VIII195:2430 running, VIII195:2431 running, VIII195:2432 running, VIII195:2433 running · Mohl — VI185:2494 running, VI185:2495 running, VI185:2496 running, VI185:2497 running, VI185:2498 running, VI185:2499 running, VI185:2500 running · Ganjoor — sh62:34 running, sh62:35 running, sh62:36 running, sh62:37 running, sh62:38 running, sh62:39 running, sh62:40 running · Khaleghi — VII289:2460 running, VII289:2461 running, VII289:2462 running, VII289:2463 running, VII289:2464 running, VII289:2465 running, VII289:2466 running
Moscow VIII p.195 · Mohl VI p.185 · Ganjoor sh62:34 · Ganjoor sh62:35 · Ganjoor sh62:36 · Ganjoor sh62:37 · Ganjoor sh62:38 · Ganjoor sh62:39 · Ganjoor sh62:40 · Khaleghi VII p.289
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi make a person’s soul watch over the body and reward that right relation with ease, generosity and straight conduct. English assigns the guardianship to knowledge and gives the ease a more inward character. The texts then say the body receives a share and the soul can be bright after death. A blade and its scabbard exemplify two uses to which one must attend. English treats them as the body and soul, making their interdependence more explicit. The subsequent counsel that reason should rule the soul, and the warning against hearing the proud, make the two comparisons act together, since protecting the body alone cannot keep desire from having the final word.
43–48Who thinks above his station
Moscow — VIII195:2434 running; VIII195:2435 running, VIII195:2436 running, VIII195:2437 running, VIII195:2438 running, VIII195:2439 running, VIII195:2440 running · Mohl — VI185:2501 running; VI185:2502 running, VI185:2503 running, VI185:2504 running, VI185:2505 running, VI185:2506 running, VI185:2507 running · Ganjoor — sh62:41, sh62:42 running, sh62:43 running, sh62:44 running, sh62:45 running, sh62:46 running, sh62:47 running · Khaleghi — VII289:2467 running; VII289:2468 running, VII290:2469 running, VII290:2470 running, VII290:2471 running, VII290:2472 running, VII290:2473 running
Moscow VIII p.195 · Mohl VI p.185 · Ganjoor sh62:41 · Ganjoor sh62:42 · Ganjoor sh62:43 · Ganjoor sh62:44 · Ganjoor sh62:45 · Ganjoor sh62:46 · Ganjoor sh62:47 · Khaleghi VII p.289 · Khaleghi VII p.290
The four texts discuss ingratitude to God and the person who refuses to hear what feeds the soul, namely knowledge. English makes that refusal an image of wisdom starving while desire grows. The Shah then asks which lesser man has the thought of the great. English asks who reaches highest rank, converting an ability that can already exist without rank into a possible route to rank. The answer gives knowledge and power over desire, so the English description of asking for nothing more has the merit of keeping ambition from swallowing the exchange. When the Shah asks about a knowledge that lies hidden, the next answer measures it by refusal to follow the Div off the creator’s road.
49–54An extra warning before naming the ten
Moscow — VIII195 note 29 actual apparatus after v.2440, VIII195:2441 running, VIII196:2442 running, VIII196:2443 running, VIII196:2444 running, VIII196:2444 running; VIII196:2445 running · Mohl — VI185:2508 running, VI185:2509 running, VI185:2510 running, VI185:2511 running, VI185:2512 running, VI185:2512 running; VI185:2513 running · Ganjoor — Checked local gap after sh62:47, sh62:48 running, sh62:49 running, sh62:50 running, sh62:51 running, sh62:51, sh62:52 running · Khaleghi — VII290:2474 bracketed running, VII290:2475 running, VII290:2476 running, VII290:2477 running, VII290:2478 running, VII290:2478 running; VII290:2479 running
Moscow VIII p.195 · Moscow VIII p.196 · Mohl VI p.185 · Ganjoor sh62:47 · Ganjoor sh62:48 · Ganjoor sh62:49 · Ganjoor sh62:50 · Ganjoor sh62:51 · Ganjoor sh62:52 · Khaleghi VII p.290
Mohl prints an independent warning about obeying a foe of soul and wisdom. Khaleghi marks that line with brackets and Moscow actually prints it in its notes. Ganjoor runs directly into the ten Ahrimans. English keeps the extra admonition and interprets the conduct as vain appetite, aligning it with the first named enemy, Greed. The four running lists then proceed through needs and passions to slander, duplicity, bad religion and failure to give thanks. The English names heresy and ingratitude toward grace. The final Persian description includes ingratitude to people and failure to recognize goodness and God. The additional focus on grace links the last item to the divine origin of wisdom, while narrowing its ordinary social application.
55–60Greed, need and the illness of envy
Moscow — VIII196:2446 running, VIII196:2447 running, VIII196:2448 running, VIII196:2449 running, VIII196:2450 running, VIII196:2451 running · Mohl — VI185:2514 running, VI185:2515 running, VI185:2516 running, VI186:2517 running, VI186:2518 running, VI186:2519 running · Ganjoor — sh62:53 running, sh62:54 running, sh62:55 running, sh62:56 running, sh62:57 running, sh62:58 running · Khaleghi — VII290:2480 running, VII290:2481 running, VII290:2482 running, VII291:2483 running, VII291:2484 running, VII291:2485 running
Moscow VIII p.196 · Mohl VI p.185 · Mohl VI p.186 · Ganjoor sh62:53 · Ganjoor sh62:54 · Ganjoor sh62:55 · Ganjoor sh62:56 · Ganjoor sh62:57 · Ganjoor sh62:58 · Khaleghi VII p.290 · Khaleghi VII p.291
The Shah asks which demon is stronger, and the four witnesses agree on Greed. It is a tyrannical, long-practiced figure who cannot be seen satisfied and prepares continually to increase his holdings. English makes the tyranny directly a tyranny of the soul. Need comes next in Persian with blindness and a face yellowed through suffering. English retains the paleness and adds hunger and sleeplessness, a bodily interpretation of want with specific symptoms left open in the witnesses. Envy then becomes an illness without a physician the moment it sees someone unharmed. English makes the stimulus someone else’s prosperity and dramatizes the resulting discord, while preserving the mostly private misery inflicted by another’s good condition.
61–66How the Divs interrupt human relations
Moscow — VIII196:2452 running, VIII196:2453 running, VIII196:2454 running, VIII196:2455 running, VIII196:2456 running, VIII196:2457 running · Mohl — VI186:2520 running, VI186:2521 running, VI186:2522 running, VI186:2523 running, VI186:2524 running, VI186:2525 running · Ganjoor — sh62:59 running, sh62:60 running, sh62:61 running, sh62:62 running, sh62:63 running, sh62:64 running · Khaleghi — VII291:2486 running, VII291:2487 running, VII291:2488 running, VII291:2489 running, VII291:2490 running, VII291:2491 running
Moscow VIII p.196 · Mohl VI p.186 · Ganjoor sh62:59 · Ganjoor sh62:60 · Ganjoor sh62:61 · Ganjoor sh62:62 · Ganjoor sh62:63 · Ganjoor sh62:64 · Khaleghi VII p.291
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give Shame a sharp claw and describe Vengeance as stripping people of sense in anger. English calls the first violent and gives the second the audible consequence of battle cries. The Persian specifically withholds affection and forgiveness in the next line. English makes the resulting face grim and the person loveless. The tale-bearer and two-faced figure then stage the disorders of speech, in which a lie and a friend’s apparent loyalty can lead to conflict between two people. English keeps the bond as the direct object of destruction. That precision matters in a dialogue whose later questions make refusing to abandon another person one of the forms of sound judgment.
67–72Ignorance that cannot tell good from bad
Moscow — VIII196:2458 running, VIII197:2459 running, VIII197:2460 running, VIII197:2461 running, VIII197:2462 running, VIII197:2464 running · Mohl — VI186:2526 running, VI186:2527 running, VI186:2528 running, VI186:2529 running, VI186:2530 running, VI186:2531 running · Ganjoor — sh62:65 running, sh62:66 running, sh62:67 running, sh62:68 running, sh62:69 running, sh62:71 running · Khaleghi — VII291:2492 running, VII291:2493 running, VII291:2494 running, VII291:2495 running, VII292:2496 running, VII292:2497 running
Moscow VIII p.196 · Moscow VIII p.197 · Mohl VI p.186 · Ganjoor sh62:65 · Ganjoor sh62:66 · Ganjoor sh62:67 · Ganjoor sh62:68 · Ganjoor sh62:69 · Ganjoor sh62:71 · Khaleghi VII p.291 · Khaleghi VII p.292
All four versions put ignorance and ingratitude together near the end of the description. A person lacking both sees good and evil as one, a loss of discrimination that the English preserves. English then expands the king’s question into an inquiry about both the attack on the heart and the help that can repel it. The answer’s hand of intellect goes beyond the deeds of Ahriman. The next image makes wisdom a jowshan against the demons’ swords. English keeps that Persian term, useful here because ordinary armor has already figured in the narrative of the reign, then gives the heart an additional fortress. What protects judgment is therefore intelligible in the concrete terms the court uses for danger.
73–78What wisdom remembers on the long road
Moscow — VIII197:2464 running; VIII197:2465 running, VIII197:2465 running, VIII197:2463 running, VIII197:2466 running; VIII197:2467 running, VIII197:2468 running, VIII197:2469 running · Mohl — VI186:2531 running; VI186:2532 running, VI186:2532 running, VI186:2533 running, VI186:2534 running; VI186:2535 running, VI186:2536 running, VI186:2537 running · Ganjoor — sh62:71, sh62:72 running, sh62:72 running, sh62:70 running, sh62:73, sh62:74 running, sh62:75 running, sh62:76 running · Khaleghi — VII292:2497 running; VII292:2498 running, VII292:2498 running, VII292:2499 running, VII292:2500 running; VII292:2501 running, VII292:2502 running, VII292:2503 running
Moscow VIII p.197 · Mohl VI p.186 · Ganjoor sh62:71 · Ganjoor sh62:72 · Ganjoor sh62:70 · Ganjoor sh62:73 · Ganjoor sh62:74 · Ganjoor sh62:75 · Ganjoor sh62:76 · Khaleghi VII p.292
The four editions let intellect retain past speech and nourish the soul with knowledge. English makes its record-keeping and inward light explicit. Moscow and Ganjoor give the long-road blessing before the armor and memory, whereas Mohl and Khaleghi put it afterward. English takes that later place, letting demonstrated abilities explain the value of the guide for the long journey ahead. Good character makes the heart less afraid of the demons and less inclined to circle desire. At the next transition Moscow and Ganjoor introduce enduring words and then name hope. Mohl and Khaleghi name hopeful words in the first verse. English likewise announces hope, making the movement from defense to a positive disposition immediate.
79–84The person who will not sell his way
Moscow — VIII197:2470 running, VIII197:2471 running, VIII197:2472 running, VIII197:2473 running, VIII197:2474 running, VIII197:2475 running · Mohl — VI186:2538 running, VI186:2539 running, VI186:2540 running, VI186:2541 running, VI187:2542 running, VI187:2543 running · Ganjoor — sh62:77 running, sh62:78 running, sh62:79 running, sh62:80 running, sh62:81 running, sh62:82 running · Khaleghi — VII292:2504 running, VII292:2505 running, VII292:2506 running, VII293:2507 running, VII293:2508 running, VII293:2509 running
Moscow VIII p.197 · Mohl VI p.186 · Mohl VI p.187 · Ganjoor sh62:77 · Ganjoor sh62:78 · Ganjoor sh62:79 · Ganjoor sh62:80 · Ganjoor sh62:81 · Ganjoor sh62:82 · Khaleghi VII p.292 · Khaleghi VII p.293
The four versions join wisdom and hope with a straight path and avoiding thoughts of evil. English adds the bow simile to the image of holding straight, and the running word for a bow gives the language a recognizable basis. The passage then lets the person little impressed by treasure have a pleasant life and allows neither hardship, wealth nor concern about another person to divert a worshipper. English makes the limits direct by setting faith above gain. When the sage says the road of God cannot be sold for a thing, the English names profit. The analogy to trade is especially pointed after the preceding picture of wealth as an object one can avoid pursuing.
85–90The fault in an otherwise hopeful list
Moscow — VIII198:2476 running, VIII198:2477 running, VIII198:2478 running, VIII198:2479 running, VIII198:2480 running, VIII198:2481 running · Mohl — VI187:2544 running, VI187:2545 running, VI187:2546 running, VI187:2547 running, VI187:2548 running, VI187:2549 running · Ganjoor — sh62:83 running, sh62:84 running, sh62:85 running, sh62:86 running, sh62:87 running, sh62:88 running · Khaleghi — VII293:2510 running, VII293:2511 running, VII293:2512 running, VII293:2513 running, VII293:2514 running, VII293:2515 running
Moscow VIII p.198 · Mohl VI p.187 · Ganjoor sh62:83 · Ganjoor sh62:84 · Ganjoor sh62:85 · Ganjoor sh62:86 · Ganjoor sh62:87 · Ganjoor sh62:88 · Khaleghi VII p.293
The sources ask which of the ten leads toward good and give precedence to reason, then kindness, contentment and hope. English preserves that progress and gives hope a specific use in toil, which is that it protects against despair. The last Persian example changes the quality under discussion to Greed, afflicted because treasure never satisfies it. English instead says that toil is hardest to bear. That shift attaches suffering to continual effort rather than appetite without limit. The Persian contrast is more local because it tests contentment against a recognizable opposing desire. English makes the line a practical warning about exhaustion, along a sequence that still regards a kindly disposition as a continuing source of honor.
91–96The bracketed exchange on merit
Moscow — VIII198:2482 running; VIII198:2483 bracketed running, VIII198:2484 bracketed running, VIII198:2485 bracketed running; VIII198:2486 bracketed running, VIII198:2487 bracketed running, VIII198:2488 bracketed running, VIII198:2489 running · Mohl — VI187:2550 running; VI187:2551 running, VI187:2552 running, VI187:2553 running; VI187:2554 running, VI187:2555 running, VI187:2556 running, VI187:2557 running · Ganjoor — sh62:89, sh62:90 running, sh62:91 running, sh62:92, sh62:93 running, sh62:94 running, sh62:95 running, sh62:96 running · Khaleghi — VII293:2516 running; VII293:2517 running, VII293:2518 running, VII293:2519 running; VII293:2520 running, VII294:2521 running, VII294:2522 running, VII294:2523 running
Moscow VIII p.198 · Mohl VI p.187 · Ganjoor sh62:89 · Ganjoor sh62:90 · Ganjoor sh62:91 · Ganjoor sh62:92 · Ganjoor sh62:93 · Ganjoor sh62:94 · Ganjoor sh62:95 · Ganjoor sh62:96 · Khaleghi VII p.293 · Khaleghi VII p.294
The four witnesses give an exchange on accomplishments, the innocent path, and the precedence of reason and education. Moscow retains the six consecutive verses in brackets. Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give the same run in their running sequences without that typographical reservation. English includes all these questions and answers. Its “true to noble birth” applies the upright path to inherited status, while the Persian question initially asks which accomplishment makes the seeker great. The sage’s soft voice in the narrative became a quality of the ideal sage in English. This helps form a coherent character portrait out of the exchange, which then chooses knowledge as the best cultivation and gives wisdom priority over the special accomplishments.
97–102A possession one inherits and one learns
Moscow — VIII198:2490 running, VIII198:2491 running, VIII198:2492 running, VIII198:2493 running, VIII198:2494 running, VIII198 note 28 actual apparatus after v.2494 · Mohl — VI187:2558 running, VI187:2559 running, VI187:2560 running, VI187:2561 running, VI187:2562 running, VI187:2563 running · Ganjoor — sh62:97 running, sh62:98 running, sh62:99 running, sh62:100 running, sh62:101 running, Checked local gap after sh62:101 · Khaleghi — VII294:2524 running, VII294:2525 running, VII294:2526 running, VII294:2527 running, VII294:2528 running, VII294:2529 running
Moscow VIII p.198 · Mohl VI p.187 · Ganjoor sh62:97 · Ganjoor sh62:98 · Ganjoor sh62:99 · Ganjoor sh62:100 · Ganjoor sh62:101 · Khaleghi VII p.294
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi say the knowledgeable person does not reach for status by taking wealth as his instrument. English names the result as freedom from hollow fame. Evil action then becomes intellect’s opponent, and the next question asks which has greater value, cultivation or native endowment and descent. English clarifies this with the opposition of learning and birth. Mohl and Khaleghi run a separate couplet in which education adorns the soul and speaking about birth comes easily. Moscow prints the verse in its apparatus and Ganjoor continues without it. English retains both elements of the longer reading, bringing a concrete type of self-praise within an argument otherwise carried by abstract terms.
103–108Wisdom as a garment God gives
Moscow — VIII199:2495 running, VIII199:2496 running, VIII199:2497 running, VIII199:2498 running, VIII199:2499 running, VIII199:2500 running · Mohl — VI187:2564 running, VI187:2565 running, VI187:2566 running, VI188:2567 running, VI188:2568 running, VI188:2569 running · Ganjoor — sh62:102 running, sh62:103 running, sh62:104 running, sh62:105 running, sh62:106 running, sh62:107 running · Khaleghi — VII294:2530 running, VII294:2531 running, VII294:2532 running, VII294:2533 running, VII294:2534 running, VII294:2535 running
Moscow VIII p.199 · Mohl VI p.187 · Mohl VI p.188 · Ganjoor sh62:102 · Ganjoor sh62:103 · Ganjoor sh62:104 · Ganjoor sh62:105 · Ganjoor sh62:106 · Ganjoor sh62:107 · Khaleghi VII p.294
The four running texts say that birth without capability is feeble and that cultivation keeps the soul sound. English makes learning the necessary companion to rank and sets an empty claim of birth against a healthy soul. The next question distinguishes polishing the soul from the qualities that honor the body. Reason itself is a divine robe of honor in the reply. English’s “robe of grace” keeps the ceremonial sense of the image, with the added suggestion that evil cannot penetrate it. The sage says the accomplished person astonished by himself need not be admired for that accomplishment. English gives that conclusion a sharper social consequence by withholding credit for skill when conceit undermines it.
109–114Toil enters the question, capability the answer
Moscow — VIII199:2501 running, VIII199:2502 running, VIII199:2503 running; VIII199:2504 running, VIII199:2504 running, VIII199:2505 running, VIII199:2506 running · Mohl — VI188:2570 running, VI188:2571 running, VI188:2572 running; VI188:2573 running, VI188:2573 running, VI188:2574 running, VI188:2575 running · Ganjoor — sh62:108 running, sh62:109 running, sh62:110, sh62:111 running, sh62:111 running, sh62:112 running, sh62:113 running · Khaleghi — VII294:2536 running, VII295:2537 running, VII295:2538 running; VII295:2539 running, VII295:2539 running, VII295:2540 running, VII295:2541 running
Moscow VIII p.199 · Mohl VI p.188 · Ganjoor sh62:108 · Ganjoor sh62:109 · Ganjoor sh62:110 · Ganjoor sh62:111 · Ganjoor sh62:112 · Ganjoor sh62:113 · Khaleghi VII p.294 · Khaleghi VII p.295
The four Persian texts allow a combination of pedigree, giving, knowledge and justice to be diminished by bad character, then ask whether effort or fortune gives greatness. English preserves both the weakness of external or inherited qualities and the question about work. In the answer Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi introduce honar alongside fortune. English repeats toil rather than shifting to acquired capability or merit. That repetition makes the reply logically symmetrical, at the cost of the new term that the Persian places in it. The simile of soul and body remains apt because one partner can appear and the other remain concealed. English keeps their dependence even as it changes the identity of one of the partners.
115–120How much of greatness can be seen
Moscow — VIII199:2507 running, VIII199:2508 running, VIII199:2509 running, VIII199:2510 running, VIII199:2511 running, VIII199:2512 running · Mohl — VI188:2576 running, VI188:2577 running, VI188:2578 running, VI188:2579 running, VI188:2580 running, VI188:2581 running · Ganjoor — sh62:114 running, sh62:115 running, sh62:116 running, sh62:117 running, sh62:118 running, sh62:119 running · Khaleghi — VII295:2542 running, VII295:2543 running, VII295:2544 running, VII295:2545 running, VII295:2546 running, VII295:2547 running
Moscow VIII p.199 · Mohl VI p.188 · Ganjoor sh62:114 · Ganjoor sh62:115 · Ganjoor sh62:116 · Ganjoor sh62:117 · Ganjoor sh62:118 · Ganjoor sh62:119 · Khaleghi VII p.295
The four witnesses describe the bodily frame as covering or support, say that effort needs fortunate guidance, and then compare the world to a remembered dream or wind. English gives the body a more active role as the instrument of toil. It also lets good fortune rise, a visible change that fits the preceding doubt about how hard work wins a crown. In the dream, awakening takes away both the image of joy and the image of grief. English follows that balance and gives the disappearance the time of dawn. The king then asks whom people praise. The answer begins with the man who decorates the throne and has force by fortune, but continues in the following claim about conduct.
121–126Knowledge sharpens regret
Moscow — VIII199:2513 running, VIII200:2514 running, VIII200:2515 running, VIII200:2516 running, VIII200:2517 running, VIII200:2518 running · Mohl — VI188:2582 running, VI188:2583 running, VI188:2584 running, VI188:2585 running, VI188:2586 running, VI188:2587 running · Ganjoor — sh62:120 running, sh62:121 running, sh62:122 running, sh62:123 running, sh62:124 running, sh62:125 running · Khaleghi — VII295:2548 running, VII295:2549 running, VII295:2550 running, VII295:2551 running, VII296:2552 running, VII296:2553 running
Moscow VIII p.199 · Moscow VIII p.200 · Mohl VI p.188 · Ganjoor sh62:120 · Ganjoor sh62:121 · Ganjoor sh62:122 · Ganjoor sh62:123 · Ganjoor sh62:124 · Ganjoor sh62:125 · Khaleghi VII p.295 · Khaleghi VII p.296
The sources require justice and a good name from the powerful ruler and say that a vicious poor man obtains neither satisfaction nor paradise. English keeps the contrast between courtly success through conduct and poverty that cannot be repaired by a reward hereafter. Then the sage identifies the unlucky person as a knowing man made yellow-faced by his own bad acts. The English describes “learned men brought low,” turning the expressive pallor into grief that may arise from circumstances. The Persian choice gives knowledge a punitive capability, since the person can recognize what he has done. The next question about contentment follows naturally in both versions, though the English makes the audience’s response to suffering more sympathetic.
127–132Gentleness as conduct under reproach
Moscow — VIII200:2519 running, VIII200:2520 running, VIII200:2521 running, VIII200:2522 running, VIII200:2523 running, VIII200:2524 running · Mohl — VI188:2588 running, VI188:2589 running, VI188:2590 running, VI188:2591 running, VI189:2592 running, VI189:2593 running · Ganjoor — sh62:126 running, sh62:127 running, sh62:128 running, sh62:129 running, sh62:130 running, sh62:131 running · Khaleghi — VII296:2554 running, VII296:2555 running, VII296:2556 running, VII296:2557 running, VII296:2558 running, VII296:2559 running
Moscow VIII p.200 · Mohl VI p.188 · Mohl VI p.189 · Ganjoor sh62:126 · Ganjoor sh62:127 · Ganjoor sh62:128 · Ganjoor sh62:129 · Ganjoor sh62:130 · Ganjoor sh62:131 · Khaleghi VII p.296
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi associate contentment with refusing to love or depend on the revolving sky. The English refusal to fix one’s eye on it makes attention itself the dangerous action, keeping the image without insisting what kind of dependence is meant. The next exchange asks about the gentle person and then the place of the fault-finder. English makes the reason for tears and strife more explicit. In the Persian, restraint, shame, skill and judgment are seen together in the person who turns from quarrel. English keeps the connection between manners and counsel. This allows the virtues of a private individual to serve as an answer to a public question about the kinds of people from whom there is hope.
133–138The known duties and the hidden world
Moscow — VIII200:2525 running, VIII200:2526 running, VIII200:2527 running, VIII200:2528 running, VIII200:2529 running, VIII200:2530 running · Mohl — VI189:2594 running, VI189:2595 running, VI189:2596 running, VI189:2597 running, VI189:2598 running, VI189:2599 running · Ganjoor — sh62:132 running, sh62:133 running, sh62:134 running, sh62:135 running, sh62:136 running, sh62:137 running · Khaleghi — VII296:2560 running, VII296:2561 running, VII296:2562 running, VII296:2563 running, VII296:2564 running, VII296:2565 running
Moscow VIII p.200 · Mohl VI p.189 · Ganjoor sh62:132 · Ganjoor sh62:133 · Ganjoor sh62:134 · Ganjoor sh62:135 · Ganjoor sh62:136 · Ganjoor sh62:137 · Khaleghi VII p.296
The four running versions give the industrious person ears that receive knowledge and immediately ask about things hidden, their good and their evil. English keeps the continuity by letting the sage listen well without having certainty about what cannot be seen. The Persian admits the abundance of crooked or empty claims and gives dust as the one known destination. English’s “final bed” makes the destination bodily and lets the question about a world beyond it remain open. The following question concerns what sustains an inhabited place. English gives a throne and frontier additional prominence. The Persian answer that a settled place stands through a ruler’s justice agrees with the core English claim and recalls the cultivated places of the march.
139–144The elder who remembers experience
Moscow — VIII200:2531 running, VIII200:2532 running, VIII201:2533 running, VIII201:2534 running, VIII201:2535 running, VIII201:2536 running · Mohl — VI189:2600 running, VI189:2601 running, VI189:2602 running, VI189:2603 running, VI189:2604 running, VI189:2605 running · Ganjoor — sh62:138 running, sh62:139 running, sh62:140 running, sh62:141 running, sh62:142 running, sh62:143 running · Khaleghi — VII296:2566 running, VII296:2567 running, VII297:2568 running, VII297:2569 running, VII297:2570 running, VII297:2571 running
Moscow VIII p.200 · Moscow VIII p.201 · Mohl VI p.189 · Ganjoor sh62:138 · Ganjoor sh62:139 · Ganjoor sh62:140 · Ganjoor sh62:141 · Ganjoor sh62:142 · Ganjoor sh62:143 · Khaleghi VII p.296 · Khaleghi VII p.297
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi put discernment, public esteem and the increase of honor through knowledge into the king’s question. The sage answers with the knowledgeable old person whose learning rests on experience. English’s “patient eye” interprets how that experience can work, making observation more important than seniority alone. The question of who can enjoy life then gives a different set of conditions. In Persian the answer joins safety from fear with having silver and gold. English makes the wealth sufficient and distributes it over a lifetime, adjusting an inventory to a measure of security. The next question about deserving praise takes such an answer further by asking what inner conduct makes a person acceptable to others.
145–150The bright face under lost hope
Moscow — VIII201:2537 running, VIII201:2538 running, VIII201:2539 running, VIII201:2540 running, VIII201:2541 running, VIII201:2542 running · Mohl — VI189:2606 running, VI189:2607 running, VI189:2608 running, VI189:2609 running, VI189:2610 running, VI189:2611 running · Ganjoor — sh62:144 running, sh62:145 running, sh62:146 running, sh62:147 running, sh62:148 running, sh62:149 running · Khaleghi — VII297:2572 running, VII297:2573 running, VII297:2574 running, VII297:2575 running, VII297:2576 running, VII297:2577 running
Moscow VIII p.201 · Mohl VI p.189 · Ganjoor sh62:144 · Ganjoor sh62:145 · Ganjoor sh62:146 · Ganjoor sh62:147 · Ganjoor sh62:148 · Ganjoor sh62:149 · Khaleghi VII p.297
The four accounts link public approval to hiding need and curbing envy, vengeance or related impulses. English turns the list into inward enemies and emphasizes self-command. The question about patience then gives a person whose hope is gone and yet who resembles the sun. Moscow and Ganjoor point toward a mind brightened or sunlight breaking through, while Mohl and Khaleghi allow the comparison to appear on the countenance beside lost fortune. English explicitly brightens the face. Its treatment of the other example as a person with little time who starts a great task keeps the contrast between circumstance and initiative. The next question about someone worn out by grief provides a foil to both forms of persistence.
151–156The injuries fortune cannot repair
Moscow — VIII201:2543 running, VIII201:2544 running, VIII201:2545 running, VIII201:2546 running, VIII201:2547 running, VIII201:2548 running · Mohl — VI189:2612 running, VI189:2613 running, VI189:2614 running, VI189:2615 running, VI189:2616 running, VI190:2617 running · Ganjoor — sh62:150 running, sh62:151 running, sh62:152 running, sh62:153 running, sh62:154 running, sh62:155 running · Khaleghi — VII297:2578 running, VII297:2579 running, VII297:2580 running, VII297:2581 running, VII298:2582 running, VII298:2583 running
Moscow VIII p.201 · Mohl VI p.189 · Mohl VI p.190 · Ganjoor sh62:150 · Ganjoor sh62:151 · Ganjoor sh62:152 · Ganjoor sh62:153 · Ganjoor sh62:154 · Ganjoor sh62:155 · Khaleghi VII p.297 · Khaleghi VII p.298
The four Persian texts give the man fallen from his throne and desperate of fortune as the clearest case of sorrow. English generalizes the loss so that any great decline in prospects can stand in for the fall of the ruler. The dialogue then distinguishes the person without wisdom and the wealthy one without a child. English keeps those different causes of pain. The upright knowledgeable man who must serve a fool provides another case, more public than either private grief. In English such men yield when fools dominate the field, extending individual subjection to a political condition. The next question tests the same pattern by asking how a person with a good name and capacity might be brought to despair.
157–162Pardon and the dark cap at death
Moscow — VIII202:2549 running, VIII202:2550 running, VIII202:2551 running, VIII202:2552 running, VIII202:2553 running, VIII202:2554 running · Mohl — VI190:2618 running, VI190:2619 running, VI190:2620 running, VI190:2621 running, VI190:2622 running, VI190:2623 running · Ganjoor — sh62:156 running, sh62:157 running, sh62:158 running, sh62:159 running, sh62:160 running, sh62:161 running · Khaleghi — VII298:2584 running, VII298:2585 running, VII298:2586 running, VII298:2587 running, VII298:2588 running, VII298:2589 running
Moscow VIII p.202 · Mohl VI p.190 · Ganjoor sh62:156 · Ganjoor sh62:157 · Ganjoor sh62:158 · Ganjoor sh62:159 · Ganjoor sh62:160 · Ganjoor sh62:161 · Khaleghi VII p.298
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi answer despair with falling from a great undertaking, then ask who has neither reputation nor adornment and yet is fit for kindness. English makes failed designs matter even if a man retains resources, and gives a clearer name to the compassion asked of the wise. The sage names the sinner and the poor person without means. English preserves both need and fault, which is important because the next example turns to someone apparently secure in power. The Persian places a dark cap upon the king at death. English makes it descend and seal his course, treating the cap as a final reversal of the crown he was otherwise able to wear.
163–168A healthy heart and a single wish
Moscow — VIII202:2555 running, VIII202:2556 running, VIII202:2557 running, VIII202:2558 running, VIII202:2559 running, VIII202:2560 running · Mohl — VI190:2624 running, VI190:2625 running, VI190:2626 running, VI190:2627 running, VI190:2628 running, VI190:2629 running · Ganjoor — sh62:162 running, sh62:163 running, sh62:164 running, sh62:165 running, sh62:166 running, sh62:167 running · Khaleghi — VII298:2590 running, VII298:2591 running, VII298:2592 running, VII298:2593 running, VII298:2594 running, VII299:2595 running
Moscow VIII p.202 · Mohl VI p.190 · Ganjoor sh62:162 · Ganjoor sh62:163 · Ganjoor sh62:164 · Ganjoor sh62:165 · Ganjoor sh62:166 · Ganjoor sh62:167 · Khaleghi VII p.298 · Khaleghi VII p.299
Repentance in the four texts belongs to a heart shaken by its ingratitude to God, and a second dissatisfied person has worked much for ungrateful people. English gives that service an added distance across lands. The Shah then asks what benefits the body and is dear to the heart. Moscow and Ganjoor start the answer with a sick person, whereas Mohl and Khaleghi give the healthy condition. English chooses health, making joy characteristic of that condition and fear of losing it an addition. All four then make restored health the sole wish of the person who experiences weakness through pain. Read with that second example, the English contrast gives good fortune a concrete measure more evident when it disappears.
169–174What a person wants after health returns
Moscow — VIII202:2561 running, VIII202:2562 running, VIII202:2563 running, VIII202:2564 running, VIII202:2565 running, VIII203:2566 running · Mohl — VI190:2630 running, VI190:2631 running, VI190:2632 running, VI190:2633 running, VI190:2634 running, VI190:2635 running · Ganjoor — sh62:168 running, sh62:169 running, sh62:170 running, sh62:171 running, sh62:172 running, sh62:173 running · Khaleghi — VII299:2596 running, VII299:2597 running, VII299:2598 running, VII299:2599 running, VII299:2600 running, VII299:2601 running
Moscow VIII p.202 · Moscow VIII p.203 · Mohl VI p.190 · Ganjoor sh62:168 · Ganjoor sh62:169 · Ganjoor sh62:170 · Ganjoor sh62:171 · Ganjoor sh62:172 · Ganjoor sh62:173 · Khaleghi VII p.299
The sources ask what desire exceeds the others, then answer with freedom from need when a person has standing. English makes recovery from sickness the starting condition of the question, joining it closely to the preceding case. The Persian allows the healthy person who has no pressing want to follow the heart’s desire. English’s move from thought to deed makes the result a form of action rather than only relief. The next question names the cares of the heart, and the reply gives three cases that a wise guide should distinguish. English sets them out as separate dangers, beginning with harm that may come to an innocent person. The thread is how quickly security can become anxious attention to an unknown day.
175–180The heart fears a friend and an unjust king
Moscow — VIII203:2567 running, VIII203:2568 running, VIII203:2569 running, VIII203:2570 running, VIII203:2571 running, VIII203:2572 running · Mohl — VI190:2636 running, VI190:2637 running, VI190:2638 running, VI190:2639 running, VI190:2640 running, VI190:2641 running · Ganjoor — sh62:174 running, sh62:175 running, sh62:176 running, sh62:177 running, sh62:178 running, sh62:179 running · Khaleghi — VII299:2602 running, VII299:2603 running, VII299:2604 running, VII299:2605 running, VII299:2606 running, VII299:2607 running
Moscow VIII p.203 · Mohl VI p.190 · Ganjoor sh62:174 · Ganjoor sh62:175 · Ganjoor sh62:176 · Ganjoor sh62:177 · Ganjoor sh62:178 · Ganjoor sh62:179 · Khaleghi VII p.299
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi describe a fraudulent friend who would take the person’s brain, blood or flesh. English keeps the image of physical extraction and a seeming friendship. The third fear is an unjust ruler who takes forced labor from a working man or oppresses the upright. English generalizes the ruler’s failure to distinguishing right from wrong, making it a fault of judgment. The Persian specifies a consequence of that failure for a subject. A world brightened by a just king supplies the counterpoint and leads to the question about right religion. English’s appeal to a steadfast mind retains loyalty to God, with life and death extending what the Persian gives as continual remembrance.
181–186Faith as something one can refuse to sell
Moscow — VIII203:2573 running, VIII203:2574 running, VIII203:2575 running, VIII203:2576 running, VIII203:2577 running, VIII203:2578 running · Mohl — VI191:2642 running, VI191:2643 running, VI191:2644 running, VI191:2645 running, VI191:2646 running, VI191:2647 running · Ganjoor — sh62:180 running, sh62:181 running, sh62:182 running, sh62:183 running, sh62:184 running, sh62:185 running · Khaleghi — VII299:2608 running, VII300:2609 running, VII300:2610 running, VII300:2611 running, VII300:2612 running, VII300:2613 running
Moscow VIII p.203 · Mohl VI p.191 · Ganjoor sh62:180 · Ganjoor sh62:181 · Ganjoor sh62:182 · Ganjoor sh62:183 · Ganjoor sh62:184 · Ganjoor sh62:185 · Khaleghi VII p.299 · Khaleghi VII p.300
The Persian first urges distance from crooked action and fear of the creator, then gives both ears to the divine command. Mohl and Khaleghi explicitly describe people who do not sell religion. Moscow and Ganjoor give a different expression around clamorous conduct. English takes the sale metaphor, recalling an earlier instruction not to trade God’s way for any object. The next question asks which of those entitled to command is worthy of the throne. The four answers put justice beside wisdom, counsel, shame and merit. English supplies watchfulness, then passes to old friends who speak as one. The sequence ties limits on a king’s use of his office to familiar limits on a person’s use of trust.
187–192The person who does not leave a friend in trouble
Moscow — VIII203:2579 running, VIII203:2580 running, VIII203:2581 running, VIII203:2582 running, VIII203:2583 running, VIII203:2584 running · Mohl — VI191:2648 running, VI191:2649 running, VI191:2650 running, VI191:2651 running, VI191:2652 running, VI191:2653 running · Ganjoor — sh62:186 running, sh62:187 running, sh62:188 running, sh62:189 running, sh62:190 running, sh62:191 running · Khaleghi — VII300:2614 running, VII300:2615 running, VII300:2616 running, VII300:2617 running, VII300:2618 running, VII300:2619 running
Moscow VIII p.203 · Mohl VI p.191 · Ganjoor sh62:186 · Ganjoor sh62:187 · Ganjoor sh62:188 · Ganjoor sh62:189 · Ganjoor sh62:190 · Ganjoor sh62:191 · Khaleghi VII p.300
All four texts give the worth of a friend through free-hearted conduct and giving another person his due. English retains both generosity and justice and makes sharing a burden the point of the next verse. The Persian person comes to the rescue in difficulty even when others exert pressure. English makes the person’s distress part of his changing fortune. The Shah then asks about the friend who seems one with a person from brain to skin. English’s blood and skin keeps the bond bodily. The sage makes the opposite of fidelity a heart willing to sever itself, while the better companion is kinder and more constructive. English keeps those measures just before the next question asks how a person earns enemies.
193–198Speech, an enduring friend and an enduring act
Moscow — VIII204:2585 running, VIII204:2586 running, VIII204:2587 running, VIII204:2590 running, VIII204:2589 running, VIII204:2588 running · Mohl — VI191:2654 running, VI191:2655 running, VI191:2656 running, VI191:2659 running, VI191:2658 running, VI191:2657 running · Ganjoor — sh62:192 running, sh62:193 running, sh62:194 running, sh62:197 running, sh62:196 running, sh62:195 running · Khaleghi — VII300:2620 running, VII300:2621 running, VII301:2622 running, VII301:2625 running, VII301:2624 running, VII301:2623 running
Moscow VIII p.204 · Mohl VI p.191 · Ganjoor sh62:192 · Ganjoor sh62:193 · Ganjoor sh62:194 · Ganjoor sh62:197 · Ganjoor sh62:196 · Ganjoor sh62:195 · Khaleghi VII p.300 · Khaleghi VII p.301
The Persian condemns conceit and adds the closed fist and harsh greed in Moscow and Ganjoor. Mohl and Khaleghi have the harsh voice, a reading English uses to make hostility heard aloud. The next two questions distinguish the constant friend and what always lasts. The running texts answer the first through good action that will not leave a good friend. They give the enduring companion or wise soul characteristics of the second answer. English draws one answer forward and places the answer about good action later. That local redistribution makes the reader hear enduring friendship before reflecting on the lasting action, and gives the threshold to the next question a different kind of permanence.
199–204What can be broader than the heavens
Moscow — VIII204:2591 running, VIII204:2592 running, VIII204:2593 running, VIII204:2594 running, VIII204:2595 running, VIII204:2596 running · Mohl — VI191:2660 running, VI191:2661 running, VI191:2662 running, VI191:2663 running, VI191:2664 running, VI191:2665 running · Ganjoor — Checked local gap after sh62:197, sh62:198 running, sh62:199 running, sh62:200 running, sh62:201 running, sh62:202 running · Khaleghi — VII301:2626 running, VII301:2627 running, VII301:2628 running, VII301:2629 running, VII301:2630 running, VII301:2631 running
Moscow VIII p.204 · Mohl VI p.191 · Ganjoor sh62:197 · Ganjoor sh62:198 · Ganjoor sh62:199 · Ganjoor sh62:200 · Ganjoor sh62:201 · Ganjoor sh62:202 · Khaleghi VII p.301
Moscow, Mohl and Khaleghi independently ask what shines brightest and is a crown on the head. Ganjoor has a local gap where the English preserves that question. The answer in the running traditions gives the knowing soul authority over desires. English makes this conquest of passion the ability of a sage’s mind. The next Persian comparison then names the generous hand of a king and the heart of a person who worships God. English gives pardoning grace and inward wisdom, applying generosity more particularly to clemency. The final answer warns about trusting wealth to the impious. English preserves the object transferred and the king who can decide whether another person merits it.
205–210A dry brick and an unkind employer
Moscow — VIII204:2597 running, VIII204:2598 running, VIII204:2599 running; VIII204:2600 running, VIII204:2600 running, VIII204:2601 running, VIII204:2602 running · Mohl — VI191:2666 running, VI192:2667 running, VI192:2668 running; VI192:2669 running, VI192:2669 running, VI192:2670 running, VI192:2671 running · Ganjoor — sh62:203 running, sh62:204 running, sh62:205, sh62:206 running, sh62:206 running, sh62:207 running, sh62:208 running · Khaleghi — VII301:2632 running, VII301:2633 running, VII301:2634 running; VII301:2635 running, VII301:2635 running, VII301:2636 running, VII302:2637 running
Moscow VIII p.204 · Mohl VI p.191 · Mohl VI p.192 · Ganjoor sh62:203 · Ganjoor sh62:204 · Ganjoor sh62:205 · Ganjoor sh62:206 · Ganjoor sh62:207 · Ganjoor sh62:208 · Khaleghi VII p.301 · Khaleghi VII p.302
The four versions say that treating a thankless person well is like throwing a dry brick into water. English makes it dissolve in rain, keeping the cost of giving effort to something that cannot hold it. The king then asks about toil that reduces appetite for wealth. The sage wishes him joy before explaining that the servant of an ill-tempered king ceases to want health, life or treasure. English replaces part of that interposed blessing with a more immediate focus on the servant. The following question of wonder then receives the answer that the business of heaven is altogether astonishing. English chooses the revolving sky, a visual image that supplies the background for the two examples of fortune to follow.
211–216The crown that reaches a cloud
Moscow — VIII204:2603 running, VIII205:2604 running, VIII205:2605 running, VIII205:2606 running, VIII205:2607 running, VIII205:2608 running · Mohl — VI192:2672 running, VI192:2673 running, VI192:2674 running, VI192:2675 running, VI192:2676 running, VI192:2677 running · Ganjoor — sh62:209 running, sh62:210 running, sh62:211 running, sh62:212 running, sh62:213 running, sh62:214 running · Khaleghi — VII302:2638 running, VII302:2639 running, VII302:2640 running, VII302:2641 running, VII302:2642 running, VII302:2643 running
Moscow VIII p.204 · Moscow VIII p.205 · Mohl VI p.192 · Ganjoor sh62:209 · Ganjoor sh62:210 · Ganjoor sh62:211 · Ganjoor sh62:212 · Ganjoor sh62:213 · Ganjoor sh62:214 · Khaleghi VII p.302
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi present a man whose headgear touches a black cloud even though he cannot tell right hand from left. English keeps that vertical excess and makes the inability to understand increase or decrease a matter of his own gain and loss. The Persian makes it a problem of giving, more specifically a ruler’s ability to manage largess. A person who can speak of the motions and amount of the heavens receives hardship in the counterexample. English gives him detailed causal knowledge without changing his vulnerability to fortune. The exchange then moves from the difficulties assigned by the sky to the weight of sin, which the English compares to lead and the Persian calls stone.
217–222A harsh ruler and divided public blame
Moscow — VIII205:2609 running, VIII205:2610 running, VIII205:2611 running, VIII205:2612 running; VIII205:2613 running, VIII205:2614 running, VIII205:2615 running; VIII205:2616 running · Mohl — VI192:2678 running, VI192:2679 running, VI192:2680 running, VI192:2681 running; VI192:2682 running, VI192:2683 running, VI192:2684 running; VI192:2685 running · Ganjoor — sh62:215 running, sh62:216 running, sh62:217 running, sh62:218, sh62:219 running, sh62:220 running, sh62:221, sh62:222 running · Khaleghi — VII302:2644 running, VII302:2645 running, VII302:2646 running, VII302:2647 running; VII302:2648 running, VII302:2649 running, VII303:2650 running; VII303:2651 running
Moscow VIII p.205 · Mohl VI p.192 · Ganjoor sh62:215 · Ganjoor sh62:216 · Ganjoor sh62:217 · Ganjoor sh62:218 · Ganjoor sh62:219 · Ganjoor sh62:220 · Ganjoor sh62:221 · Ganjoor sh62:222 · Khaleghi VII p.302 · Khaleghi VII p.303
The list in all four versions starts with a ruler’s harshness and conflict with innocent people, then the wealthy man who is stingy over nourishment and clothing. English makes persecution an especially explicit act of the first and lets the wealthy miser clutch his possessions. The Persian goes on to name shameless speech by women, harshness also by good men and pride among the poor. English compresses those separate judgments into a shorter catalogue, retaining the poor man’s pride and the king’s capacity to lie. The last question returns to the armor that wisdom could make earlier. It asks what good can lighten the soul and be used as jowshan, so the metaphor protects judgment after the list has named the habits that destroy it.
223–228Who benefits from restraining anger
Moscow — VIII205:2617 running, VIII205:2618 running, VIII205:2619 running, VIII205:2620 running; VIII206:2621 running, VIII206:2622 running, VIII206:2623 running · Mohl — VI192:2686 running, VI192:2687 running, VI192:2688 running, VI192:2690 running; VI192:2689 running, VI192:2691 running, VI193:2692 running · Ganjoor — sh62:223 running, sh62:224 running, sh62:225 running, sh62:226, sh62:227 running, sh62:228 running, sh62:229 running · Khaleghi — VII303:2652 running, VII303:2653 running, VII303:2654 running, VII303:2656 running; VII303:2655 running, VII303:2657 running, VII303:2658 running
Moscow VIII p.205 · Moscow VIII p.206 · Mohl VI p.192 · Mohl VI p.193 · Ganjoor sh62:223 · Ganjoor sh62:224 · Ganjoor sh62:225 · Ganjoor sh62:226 · Ganjoor sh62:227 · Ganjoor sh62:228 · Ganjoor sh62:229 · Khaleghi VII p.303
The four texts give praise for effort in good or right religion and recognition to one who thanks Yazdan. English makes an unwounded person the consequence of striving for good, extending the armor image. The last questions about action and restraint also occur in different orders. Mohl and Khaleghi put the question about what to command before the question about withholding the hand. Moscow and Ganjoor give the reverse. The answer commands holding anger in check, with innocent people in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor and people full of sin in Khaleghi. English keeps mastery of anger without specifying the beneficiaries. It follows with a plea to keep the soul alert and to do good while there is strength.
229–232The poet at the threshold of chess
Moscow — VIII206:2624 running, VIII206:2625 running, VIII206:2626 running, VIII206:2627 running · Mohl — VI193:2693 running, VI193:2694 running, VI193:2695 running, VI193:2696 running · Ganjoor — sh62:230 running, sh62:231 running, sh62:232 running, sh62:233 running · Khaleghi — VII303:2659 running, VII303:2660 running, VII303:2661 running, VII303:2662 running
Moscow VIII p.206 · Mohl VI p.193 · Ganjoor sh62:230 · Ganjoor sh62:231 · Ganjoor sh62:232 · Ganjoor sh62:233 · Khaleghi VII p.303
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give the soul’s sunlight as the consequence of setting down resentment and taking up hope. English gives good deeds that brightening action, linking the end to their endurance near the opening. The appetite for sin then gives illusory pleasure in the four texts, and English preserves both sweetness and the necessity of leaving it. The narrator thanks the Lord of sun and moon for release from the king and Bozorgmehr. English ends their counsel, emphasizes the fatigue of speaking and lets the body rest. In the Persian the fatigue is itself the transition to telling the story of chess. Retaining the source locators makes both the chapter ending and its place in the longer telling visible.
Source record and limits
English
232 published English couplets. Ganjoor passages: Anooshirvan §62: 1–233. The English text follows the published verse and chapter divisions.
Moscow
The 1970 Moscow edition, volume VIII, printed pages 193–206. The source register identifies the individual running verses and any printed apparatus cited.
Mohl
Jules Mohl’s Persian text, volume VI, printed pages 183–193. The running sequence contains independent verses on these topics. The source register records where an edition also prints related manuscript wording.
Ganjoor
Anooshirvan §62: 1–233. The Persian column gives the corresponding running verses and identifies where Mohl supplies an independent couplet for a local Ganjoor gap.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Djalal Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VII, printed pages 286–303. Square brackets mark verses retained in the main text with explicit editorial reservation. Printed additions have their own locators.
The sequence of questions and answers
The register follows the English order. Its locators retain an independent warning, actual additions and certain rearrangements. Moscow brackets a run of six verses in the exchange on conduct, wisdom and education. Mohl and Khaleghi give separate running support to several verses absent at the corresponding place in Ganjoor. The final Persian couplet turns toward chess, where the English foregrounds fatigue.
Consequential readings
English 3. Moscow and Ganjoor give praise to the creator. Mohl and Khaleghi have praise of the king and the heart like spring, supporting the imagery chosen by the English. English 15. The running Persian presents a poor or needy person laboring and acquiring renown and treasure. English makes the poor toil under a wealthy person. English 25. Mohl and Khaleghi run the verse on sun, wind, water and earth. Moscow prints it beneath the poem and Ganjoor has a local gap after the good-speech verse. English 37. The running Persian makes the soul guardian of the body. English gives the guardianship to knowledge. English 40. The verse gives a blade and scabbard as two uses. The English extends the metaphor to the preservation of soul and body. English 45. The Persian question asks which of the lesser people thinks like a great one. English asks who reaches the highest rank. English 49. Mohl runs an independent warning about obeying what is hostile to soul and wisdom. Khaleghi brackets it and Moscow prints the line beneath the poem. Ganjoor proceeds directly to the ten Divs. English 54. The Persian counts the one who shows no gratitude to people, recognizes no good and has no knowledge of God. English closes with ingratitude to divine grace. English 58. The Persian Need is seen blind and yellow-faced through grief. English retains paleness and develops sleepless hunger. English 72. Wisdom protects against the demon’s sword as a jowshan. The English fortress adds a second protective image. English 75. Mohl and Khaleghi put the blessing on the long road after armor and memory. Moscow and Ganjoor give it before those two lines. English 77. Mohl and Khaleghi introduce words of hope. Moscow and Ganjoor introduce abiding words and proceed to hope in the next couplet. English 90. All four make Greed the afflicted quality, because it never feels full of treasure. English turns the passage into a statement about toil. English 91. The English relates innocence to noble birth. The running virtue answers mention keeping to the path and remaining innocent. Moscow retains the answer in brackets. English 102. The independent couplet runs in Mohl and Khaleghi and is printed by Moscow. It gives cultivated learning as adornment of the soul and sets speaking of birth against it. English 113. The common formula names Fortune and honar, acquired capability or merit. English repeats toil from the question as one of the paired elements. English 125. The Persian names the knowledgeable person made yellow-faced by his own bad conduct; English directs sympathy toward learned people brought low. English 148. Moscow and Ganjoor put hope lost beside sunlight or the brightening of the mind. Mohl and Khaleghi place the countenance in relation to fortune and sunlight. The English makes the face visible. English 167. Moscow and Ganjoor run an unwell person in the first answer. Mohl and Khaleghi run the healthy condition. The English chooses health and then treats sickness as the contrary case. English 176. The running third fear is the unjust ruler’s demand for forced labor or its equivalent from a worker. English generalizes to the inability to judge right and wrong. English 182. Mohl and Khaleghi run the one who will not sell religion; Moscow and Ganjoor use other wording. The English explicitly adopts the sale metaphor. English 194. Mohl and Khaleghi use a harsh voice. Moscow and Ganjoor instead give harsh greed; the constrained fist remains part of the image. English 196. The lasting companion’s qualities come from the next question’s answer in the Persian sequence. The register preserves that local relocation. English 198. The answer about good deeds remaining by a good friend precedes the next question in the Persian. English uses it to answer what lasts. English 199. Moscow, Mohl and Khaleghi run an independent question about what shines brightest and crowns the head. Ganjoor joins the otherwise separated answers without that question. English 202. The Persian pairs a king’s open hand with the heart of a worshipper. English makes the pair clemency and inward wisdom. English 212. The running Persian pairs inability to tell right from left with inability to judge increase or decrease in giving. English makes the second an assessment of gain and loss. English 226. Mohl and Khaleghi reverse the two question verses relative to Moscow and Ganjoor. English 227. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor give the innocent in the second hemistich. Khaleghi runs the guilty. English keeps the instruction to restrain anger and leaves the distinction implicit. English 229. The four copies connect setting aside resentment and taking up hope with the soul shining like the sun. The English makes good action the cause of its light. English 231. The Persian narrator thanks the Lord of the sun and moon for being released from Bozorgmehr and the Shah. English generalizes to the end of their counsel. English 232. The four texts explicitly call for the tale of chess next. English names the labor of the narrative and ends on bodily rest.
Limits of the evidence
Running text, bracketed running text, actual printed apparatus and checked local gaps indicate distinct kinds of support. Local gaps concern the specified passage. No appendix reading is invoked. The geographical and institutional terms describe the poem’s account.
Source-only verses
S1. The Persian passage gives an independent warning about the boastful person arriving in the other world confessing, while pain remains below. English moves directly to ingratitude and desire.
Moscow VIII p.193 · Moscow VIII p.194 · Moscow VIII p.195 · Moscow VIII p.196 · Moscow VIII p.197 · Moscow VIII p.198 · Moscow VIII p.199 · Moscow VIII p.200 · Moscow VIII p.201 · Moscow VIII p.202 · Moscow VIII p.203 · Moscow VIII p.204 · Moscow VIII p.205 · Moscow VIII p.206
Mohl VI p.183 · Mohl VI p.184 · Mohl VI p.185 · Mohl VI p.186 · Mohl VI p.187 · Mohl VI p.188 · Mohl VI p.189 · Mohl VI p.190 · Mohl VI p.191 · Mohl VI p.192 · Mohl VI p.193
Khaleghi VII p.286 · Khaleghi VII p.287 · Khaleghi VII p.288 · Khaleghi VII p.289 · Khaleghi VII p.290 · Khaleghi VII p.291 · Khaleghi VII p.292 · Khaleghi VII p.293 · Khaleghi VII p.294 · Khaleghi VII p.295 · Khaleghi VII p.296 · Khaleghi VII p.297 · Khaleghi VII p.298 · Khaleghi VII p.299 · Khaleghi VII p.300 · Khaleghi VII p.301 · Khaleghi VII p.302 · Khaleghi VII p.303
Selected printed readings
- Khaleghi VII286:2428 running · یکی آفرین کرد بر شهریار / که دل شد به کردار خرم بهار
The praise reaches the king and the heart becomes like spring. - Moscow VIII194 note 19 actual apparatus · ز خورشید وز باد وز آب و خاک / نگردد تبه نام و گفتار پاک
The elements cannot ruin good name and pure speech. - Khaleghi VII290:2474 bracketed running · کسی را همی خیره فرمان برد / که خصم روانست و آن خرد
Khaleghi retains the warning as bracketed running text. - Moscow VIII197:2464 running · ز شمشیر دیوان خرد جوشنست
Wisdom is armor against the demons’ sword. - Moscow VIII198:2483 bracketed running · نگردد بود با تنی بیگناه
The bracketed answer associates remaining on the path with innocence. - Moscow VIII198 note 28 actual apparatus · که فرهنگ آرایش جان بود / ز گوهر سخن گفتن آسان بود
Cultivation adorns the soul and speaking of birth is easy. - Khaleghi VII298:2594 running · چنین داد پاسخ که چون تندرست
Khaleghi begins from the healthy condition. - Khaleghi VII300:2609 running · وز ایشان نباشد کسی دینفروش
The text gives the explicit sale-of-faith image. - Moscow VIII204:2591 running · بدو گفت کسری چه روشنترست / که بر تارک هر کسی افسرست
An independent question precedes the answer about the wise soul. - Khaleghi VII303:2657 running · که از پرگناهان بخوابند چشم
Khaleghi gives people full of sin in the second half-line. - Moscow VIII206:2627 running · چو این کار دلگیرت آمد ببن / ز شطرنج باید که رانی سخن
The narrator calls for the chess story.
E1.13 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII193:2394 running | VI183:2460 running |
| 2 | VIII193:2395 running | VI183:2461 running |
| 3 | VIII193:2396 running | VI183:2462 running |
| 4 | VIII193:2397 running | VI183:2463 running |
| 5 | VIII193:2398 running | VI183:2464 running |
| 6 | VIII193:2399 running | VI183:2465 running |
| 7 | VIII193:2400 running | VI183:2466 running |
| 8 | VIII193:2401 running | VI184:2467 running |
| 9 | VIII193:2402 running | VI184:2468 running |
| 10 | VIII193:2403 running | VI184:2469 running |
| 11 | VIII193:2404 running | VI184:2470 running |
| 12 | VIII193:2405 running | VI184:2471 running |
| 13 | VIII193:2406 running | VI184:2472 running |
| 14 | VIII193:2407 running | VI184:2473 running |
| 15 | VIII194:2408 running | VI184:2474 running |
| 16 | VIII194:2409 running; VIII194:2410 running | VI184:2475 running; VI184:2476 running |
| 17 | VIII194:2409 running | VI184:2475 running |
| 18 | VIII194:2410 running | VI184:2476 running |
| 19 | VIII194:2411 running | VI184:2477 running |
| 20 | VIII194:2412 running | VI184:2478 running |
| 21 | VIII194:2413 running | VI184:2479 running |
| 22 | VIII194:2414 running | VI184:2480 running |
| 23 | VIII194:2415 running | VI184:2481 running |
| 24 | VIII194:2415 running | VI184:2481 running |
| 25 | VIII194 note 19 actual apparatus after v.2415 | VI184:2482 running |
| 26 | VIII194:2416 running; VIII194:2417 running | VI184:2483 running; VI184:2484 running |
| 27 | VIII194:2418 running | VI184:2485 running |
| 28 | VIII194:2419 running | VI184:2486 running |
| 29 | VIII194:2420 running | VI184:2487 running |
| 30 | VIII194:2421 running | VI184:2488 running |
| 31 | VIII194:2422 running | VI184:2489 running |
| 32 | VIII194:2422 running | VI184:2489 running |
| 33 | VIII194:2423 running | VI184:2490 running |
| 34 | VIII195:2424 running | VI184:2491 running |
| 35 | VIII195:2424 running; VIII195:2425 running | VI184:2491 running; VI185:2492 running · VI p.185 |
| 36 | VIII195:2426 running | VI185:2493 running |
| 37 | VIII195:2427 running | VI185:2494 running |
| 38 | VIII195:2428 running | VI185:2495 running |
| 39 | VIII195:2429 running | VI185:2496 running |
| 40 | VIII195:2430 running | VI185:2497 running |
| 41 | VIII195:2431 running | VI185:2498 running |
| 42 | VIII195:2432 running | VI185:2499 running |
| 43 | VIII195:2434 running; VIII195:2435 running | VI185:2501 running; VI185:2502 running |
| 44 | VIII195:2436 running | VI185:2503 running |
| 45 | VIII195:2437 running | VI185:2504 running |
| 46 | VIII195:2438 running | VI185:2505 running |
| 47 | VIII195:2439 running | VI185:2506 running |
| 48 | VIII195:2440 running | VI185:2507 running |
| 49 | VIII195 note 29 actual apparatus after v.2440 | VI185:2508 running |
| 50 | VIII195:2441 running | VI185:2509 running |
| 51 | VIII196:2442 running | VI185:2510 running |
| 52 | VIII196:2443 running | VI185:2511 running |
| 53 | VIII196:2444 running | VI185:2512 running |
| 54 | VIII196:2444 running; VIII196:2445 running | VI185:2512 running; VI185:2513 running |
| 55 | VIII196:2446 running | VI185:2514 running |
| 56 | VIII196:2447 running | VI185:2515 running |
| 57 | VIII196:2448 running | VI185:2516 running |
| 58 | VIII196:2449 running | VI186:2517 running |
| 59 | VIII196:2450 running | VI186:2518 running |
| 60 | VIII196:2451 running | VI186:2519 running |
| 61 | VIII196:2452 running | VI186:2520 running |
| 62 | VIII196:2453 running | VI186:2521 running |
| 63 | VIII196:2454 running | VI186:2522 running |
| 64 | VIII196:2455 running | VI186:2523 running |
| 65 | VIII196:2456 running | VI186:2524 running |
| 66 | VIII196:2457 running | VI186:2525 running |
| 67 | VIII196:2458 running | VI186:2526 running |
| 68 | VIII197:2459 running | VI186:2527 running |
| 69 | VIII197:2460 running | VI186:2528 running |
| 70 | VIII197:2461 running | VI186:2529 running |
| 71 | VIII197:2462 running | VI186:2530 running |
| 72 | VIII197:2464 running | VI186:2531 running |
| 73 | VIII197:2464 running; VIII197:2465 running | VI186:2531 running; VI186:2532 running |
| 74 | VIII197:2465 running | VI186:2532 running |
| 75 | VIII197:2463 running | VI186:2533 running |
| 76 | VIII197:2466 running; VIII197:2467 running | VI186:2534 running; VI186:2535 running |
| 77 | VIII197:2468 running | VI186:2536 running |
| 78 | VIII197:2469 running | VI186:2537 running |
| 79 | VIII197:2470 running | VI186:2538 running |
| 80 | VIII197:2471 running | VI186:2539 running |
| 81 | VIII197:2472 running | VI186:2540 running |
| 82 | VIII197:2473 running | VI186:2541 running |
| 83 | VIII197:2474 running | VI187:2542 running |
| 84 | VIII197:2475 running | VI187:2543 running |
| 85 | VIII198:2476 running | VI187:2544 running |
| 86 | VIII198:2477 running | VI187:2545 running |
| 87 | VIII198:2478 running | VI187:2546 running |
| 88 | VIII198:2479 running | VI187:2547 running |
| 89 | VIII198:2480 running | VI187:2548 running |
| 90 | VIII198:2481 running | VI187:2549 running |
| 91 | VIII198:2482 running; VIII198:2483 bracketed running | VI187:2550 running; VI187:2551 running |
| 92 | VIII198:2484 bracketed running | VI187:2552 running |
| 93 | VIII198:2485 bracketed running; VIII198:2486 bracketed running | VI187:2553 running; VI187:2554 running |
| 94 | VIII198:2487 bracketed running | VI187:2555 running |
| 95 | VIII198:2488 bracketed running | VI187:2556 running |
| 96 | VIII198:2489 running | VI187:2557 running |
| 97 | VIII198:2490 running | VI187:2558 running |
| 98 | VIII198:2491 running | VI187:2559 running |
| 99 | VIII198:2492 running | VI187:2560 running |
| 100 | VIII198:2493 running | VI187:2561 running |
| 101 | VIII198:2494 running | VI187:2562 running |
| 102 | VIII198 note 28 actual apparatus after v.2494 | VI187:2563 running |
| 103 | VIII199:2495 running | VI187:2564 running |
| 104 | VIII199:2496 running | VI187:2565 running |
| 105 | VIII199:2497 running | VI187:2566 running |
| 106 | VIII199:2498 running | VI188:2567 running |
| 107 | VIII199:2499 running | VI188:2568 running |
| 108 | VIII199:2500 running | VI188:2569 running |
| 109 | VIII199:2501 running | VI188:2570 running |
| 110 | VIII199:2502 running | VI188:2571 running |
| 111 | VIII199:2503 running; VIII199:2504 running | VI188:2572 running; VI188:2573 running |
| 112 | VIII199:2504 running | VI188:2573 running |
| 113 | VIII199:2505 running | VI188:2574 running |
| 114 | VIII199:2506 running | VI188:2575 running |
| 115 | VIII199:2507 running | VI188:2576 running |
| 116 | VIII199:2508 running | VI188:2577 running |
| 117 | VIII199:2509 running | VI188:2578 running |
| 118 | VIII199:2510 running | VI188:2579 running |
| 119 | VIII199:2511 running | VI188:2580 running |
| 120 | VIII199:2512 running | VI188:2581 running |
| 121 | VIII199:2513 running | VI188:2582 running |
| 122 | VIII200:2514 running | VI188:2583 running |
| 123 | VIII200:2515 running | VI188:2584 running |
| 124 | VIII200:2516 running | VI188:2585 running |
| 125 | VIII200:2517 running | VI188:2586 running |
| 126 | VIII200:2518 running | VI188:2587 running |
| 127 | VIII200:2519 running | VI188:2588 running |
| 128 | VIII200:2520 running | VI188:2589 running |
| 129 | VIII200:2521 running | VI188:2590 running |
| 130 | VIII200:2522 running | VI188:2591 running |
| 131 | VIII200:2523 running | VI189:2592 running |
| 132 | VIII200:2524 running | VI189:2593 running |
| 133 | VIII200:2525 running | VI189:2594 running |
| 134 | VIII200:2526 running | VI189:2595 running |
| 135 | VIII200:2527 running | VI189:2596 running |
| 136 | VIII200:2528 running | VI189:2597 running |
| 137 | VIII200:2529 running | VI189:2598 running |
| 138 | VIII200:2530 running | VI189:2599 running |
| 139 | VIII200:2531 running | VI189:2600 running |
| 140 | VIII200:2532 running | VI189:2601 running |
| 141 | VIII201:2533 running | VI189:2602 running |
| 142 | VIII201:2534 running | VI189:2603 running |
| 143 | VIII201:2535 running | VI189:2604 running |
| 144 | VIII201:2536 running | VI189:2605 running |
| 145 | VIII201:2537 running | VI189:2606 running |
| 146 | VIII201:2538 running | VI189:2607 running |
| 147 | VIII201:2539 running | VI189:2608 running |
| 148 | VIII201:2540 running | VI189:2609 running |
| 149 | VIII201:2541 running | VI189:2610 running |
| 150 | VIII201:2542 running | VI189:2611 running |
| 151 | VIII201:2543 running | VI189:2612 running |
| 152 | VIII201:2544 running | VI189:2613 running |
| 153 | VIII201:2545 running | VI189:2614 running |
| 154 | VIII201:2546 running | VI189:2615 running |
| 155 | VIII201:2547 running | VI189:2616 running |
| 156 | VIII201:2548 running | VI190:2617 running |
| 157 | VIII202:2549 running | VI190:2618 running |
| 158 | VIII202:2550 running | VI190:2619 running |
| 159 | VIII202:2551 running | VI190:2620 running |
| 160 | VIII202:2552 running | VI190:2621 running |
| 161 | VIII202:2553 running | VI190:2622 running |
| 162 | VIII202:2554 running | VI190:2623 running |
| 163 | VIII202:2555 running | VI190:2624 running |
| 164 | VIII202:2556 running | VI190:2625 running |
| 165 | VIII202:2557 running | VI190:2626 running |
| 166 | VIII202:2558 running | VI190:2627 running |
| 167 | VIII202:2559 running | VI190:2628 running |
| 168 | VIII202:2560 running | VI190:2629 running |
| 169 | VIII202:2561 running | VI190:2630 running |
| 170 | VIII202:2562 running | VI190:2631 running |
| 171 | VIII202:2563 running | VI190:2632 running |
| 172 | VIII202:2564 running | VI190:2633 running |
| 173 | VIII202:2565 running | VI190:2634 running |
| 174 | VIII203:2566 running | VI190:2635 running |
| 175 | VIII203:2567 running | VI190:2636 running |
| 176 | VIII203:2568 running | VI190:2637 running |
| 177 | VIII203:2569 running | VI190:2638 running |
| 178 | VIII203:2570 running | VI190:2639 running |
| 179 | VIII203:2571 running | VI190:2640 running |
| 180 | VIII203:2572 running | VI190:2641 running |
| 181 | VIII203:2573 running | VI191:2642 running |
| 182 | VIII203:2574 running | VI191:2643 running |
| 183 | VIII203:2575 running | VI191:2644 running |
| 184 | VIII203:2576 running | VI191:2645 running |
| 185 | VIII203:2577 running | VI191:2646 running |
| 186 | VIII203:2578 running | VI191:2647 running |
| 187 | VIII203:2579 running | VI191:2648 running |
| 188 | VIII203:2580 running | VI191:2649 running |
| 189 | VIII203:2581 running | VI191:2650 running |
| 190 | VIII203:2582 running | VI191:2651 running |
| 191 | VIII203:2583 running | VI191:2652 running |
| 192 | VIII203:2584 running | VI191:2653 running |
| 193 | VIII204:2585 running | VI191:2654 running |
| 194 | VIII204:2586 running | VI191:2655 running |
| 195 | VIII204:2587 running | VI191:2656 running |
| 196 | VIII204:2590 running | VI191:2659 running |
| 197 | VIII204:2589 running | VI191:2658 running |
| 198 | VIII204:2588 running | VI191:2657 running |
| 199 | VIII204:2591 running | VI191:2660 running |
| 200 | VIII204:2592 running | VI191:2661 running |
| 201 | VIII204:2593 running | VI191:2662 running |
| 202 | VIII204:2594 running | VI191:2663 running |
| 203 | VIII204:2595 running | VI191:2664 running |
| 204 | VIII204:2596 running | VI191:2665 running |
| 205 | VIII204:2597 running | VI191:2666 running |
| 206 | VIII204:2598 running | VI192:2667 running |
| 207 | VIII204:2599 running; VIII204:2600 running | VI192:2668 running; VI192:2669 running |
| 208 | VIII204:2600 running | VI192:2669 running |
| 209 | VIII204:2601 running | VI192:2670 running |
| 210 | VIII204:2602 running | VI192:2671 running |
| 211 | VIII204:2603 running | VI192:2672 running |
| 212 | VIII205:2604 running | VI192:2673 running |
| 213 | VIII205:2605 running | VI192:2674 running |
| 214 | VIII205:2606 running | VI192:2675 running |
| 215 | VIII205:2607 running | VI192:2676 running |
| 216 | VIII205:2608 running | VI192:2677 running |
| 217 | VIII205:2609 running | VI192:2678 running |
| 218 | VIII205:2610 running | VI192:2679 running |
| 219 | VIII205:2611 running | VI192:2680 running |
| 220 | VIII205:2612 running; VIII205:2613 running | VI192:2681 running; VI192:2682 running |
| 221 | VIII205:2614 running | VI192:2683 running |
| 222 | VIII205:2615 running; VIII205:2616 running | VI192:2684 running; VI192:2685 running |
| 223 | VIII205:2617 running | VI192:2686 running |
| 224 | VIII205:2618 running | VI192:2687 running |
| 225 | VIII205:2619 running | VI192:2688 running |
| 226 | VIII205:2620 running; VIII206:2621 running · VIII p.206 | VI192:2690 running; VI192:2689 running |
| 227 | VIII206:2622 running | VI192:2691 running |
| 228 | VIII206:2623 running | VI193:2692 running |
| 229 | VIII206:2624 running | VI193:2693 running |
| 230 | VIII206:2625 running | VI193:2694 running |
| 231 | VIII206:2626 running | VI193:2695 running |
| 232 | VIII206:2627 running | VI193:2696 running |
New Naqqali