Ghatfar Defeated, Faghanish Crowned
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6A war heard before it is seen
Moscow — VIII156:1735 running, VIII156:1737 running, VIII156:1738 running, VIII156:1739 running, VIII156:1740 running, VIII156:1741 running, VIII156:1736 running · Mohl — VI155:1789 running, VI155:1791 running, VI155:1792 running, VI155:1793 running, VI155:1794 running, VI155:1795 running, VI155:1790 running · Ganjoor — sh44:176 running, sh45:1 running, sh45:2 running, sh45:3 running, sh45:4 running, sh45:5 running, sh44:177 running · Khaleghi — VII234:1754 running, VII235:1756 running, VII235:1757 running, VII235:1758 running, VII235:1759 running, VII235:1760 running, VII235:1755 running
Moscow VIII p.156 · Mohl VI p.155 · Ganjoor sh44:176 · Ganjoor sh45:1 · Ganjoor sh45:2 · Ganjoor sh45:3 · Ganjoor sh45:4 · Ganjoor sh45:5 · Ganjoor sh44:177 · Khaleghi VII p.234 · Khaleghi VII p.235
In the four accounts, the narrator asks for a mace when war comes into view and then yields authority to an old dehqan. The sources also preserve another line asking what can be told of the Shah, Khan and Heytalians. Their headings fall at different points in this movement. English puts a gorz and shield into one audible call to hear the battle, then gives the speaker a recognizable occupation as rustic bard. The shield is an expansion, and the profession carries some of the Persian dehqan’s claim to inherited knowledge. The dehqan’s comparison grants the Khan wide renown after Anooshirvan. English preserves that exception, setting a dangerous rival in a world with a visible center.
7–12Reputation becomes diplomatic policy
Moscow — VIII156:1741 running, VIII156:1742 running; VIII156:1743 running, VIII156:1744 running, VIII156:1745 running, VIII156:1746 running, VIII157:1747 running · Mohl — VI155:1795 running, VI155:1796 running; VI156:1797 running, VI156:1798 running, VI156:1799 running, VI156:1800 running, VI156:1801 running · Ganjoor — sh45:5 running, sh45:6, sh45:7 running, sh46:1 running, sh46:2 running, sh46:3 running, sh46:4 running · Khaleghi — VII235:1760 running, VII235:1761 running; VII235:1762 running, VII235:1763 running, VII235:1764 running, VII235:1765 running, VII235:1766 running
Moscow VIII p.156 · Moscow VIII p.157 · Mohl VI p.155 · Mohl VI p.156 · Ganjoor sh45:5 · Ganjoor sh45:6 · Ganjoor sh45:7 · Ganjoor sh46:1 · Ganjoor sh46:2 · Ganjoor sh46:3 · Ganjoor sh46:4 · Khaleghi VII p.235
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi locate the Khan beyond Chakh by the Gulzaryun and then describe the circulation of Kisra’s reputation. English uses the repeated idea of movement to connect the distant river to the names and judgments passing across the land. The following counsel gives the Khan time with advisers and with the religious and political figures whose judgment he asks. “Alliance to be signed” anticipates the actual silk letter. The initial Persian desire is for friendship, so the English gives that interest a more formal shape earlier. Once the gifts are made, the Persian stresses their appropriateness to the Shah. English retains the test of royal worth and concentrates its splendor in gold.
13–18One hundred camels and ten silver loads
Moscow — VIII157:1748 running, VIII157:1749 running, VIII157:1750 running, VIII157:1751 running; VIII157 note 8 actual apparatus at v.1751, VIII157:1752 running, VIII157:1753 running · Mohl — VI156:1802 running, VI156:1803 running, VI156:1804 running, VI156:1805 running, VI156:1806 running, VI156:1807 running · Ganjoor — sh46:5 running, sh46:6 running, sh46:7 running, sh46:8 running, sh46:9 running, sh46:10 running · Khaleghi — VII236:1767 running, VII236:1768 running; VII236 note 5 lexical apparatus at v.1768, VII236:1769 running, VII236:1770 running, VII236:1771 running, VII236:1772 running
Moscow VIII p.157 · Mohl VI p.156 · Ganjoor sh46:5 · Ganjoor sh46:6 · Ganjoor sh46:7 · Ganjoor sh46:8 · Ganjoor sh46:9 · Ganjoor sh46:10 · Khaleghi VII p.236
The four running witnesses name horses from Chin, brocade, thrones, crowns, swords and rings, then send assorted valuables on camels. Khaleghi actually prints a variant of one hundred camels, matching the English “Five-score camel-loads.” Thirty thousand Chinese dinars are given in the running texts. At the next line Mohl and Khaleghi give ten camels laden with silver coin, while Moscow and Ganjoor give an additional load of dinars. Moscow records the silver variant below the poem. The English inventory therefore has specific support for its differentiated metals and numbers. Giving the silver a new couplet makes the wealth legible as a calculated embassy rather than a single undifferentiated stream of riches.
19–24A silk letter takes an armed route
Moscow — VIII157:1754 running, VIII157:1755 running, VIII157:1756 running, VIII157:1757 running, VIII157:1758 running, VIII157:1759 running · Mohl — VI156:1808 running, VI156:1809 running, VI156:1810 running, VI156:1811 running, VI156:1812 running, VI156:1813 running · Ganjoor — sh46:11 running, sh47:1 running, sh47:2 running, sh47:3 running, sh47:4 running, sh47:5 running · Khaleghi — VII236:1773 running, VII236:1774 running, VII236:1775 running, VII236:1776 running, VII236:1777 running, VII236:1778 running
Moscow VIII p.157 · Mohl VI p.156 · Ganjoor sh46:11 · Ganjoor sh47:1 · Ganjoor sh47:2 · Ganjoor sh47:3 · Ganjoor sh47:4 · Ganjoor sh47:5 · Khaleghi VII p.236
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give a silk letter and compare the writing to the Arzhang or an orthographic form of that name. The English “according to his country’s way” retains the national marker and passes over the analogy to a particular visual book or exemplar. The blessing carried on that sumptuous object is immediately exposed to the road crowded with weapons. English creates the same reversal by making the envoy run through dangerous territory. The extended line from Sughd to the Jihun explains how Ghatfar can intercept a correspondence between two other rulers. His council with experienced soldiers mirrors the preceding council that assembled the letter, and the parallel lets the reader weigh both charges of prudence.
25–30The feared alliance and the chosen raid
Moscow — VIII157:1760 running; VIII157:1761 running, VIII157:1761 running, VIII157:1762 running, VIII157:1763 running, VIII157:1764 running, VIII157:1765 running · Mohl — VI156:1814 running; VI156:1815 running, VI156:1815 running, VI156:1816 running, VI156:1817 running, VI156:1818 running, VI156:1819 running · Ganjoor — sh47:6, sh47:7 running, sh47:7 running, sh47:8 running, sh47:9 running, sh47:10 running, sh47:11 running · Khaleghi — VII236:1779 running; VII237:1780 running, VII237:1780 running, VII237:1781 running, VII237:1782 running, VII237:1783 running, VII237:1784 running
Moscow VIII p.157 · Mohl VI p.156 · Ganjoor sh47:6 · Ganjoor sh47:7 · Ganjoor sh47:8 · Ganjoor sh47:9 · Ganjoor sh47:10 · Ganjoor sh47:11 · Khaleghi VII p.236 · Khaleghi VII p.237
All four running texts give Ghatfar an omen of misfortune, a hypothetical friendship and the prospect that his realm will be ruined. English repeats the conditional with successive “If” clauses and makes a threat from two directions more explicit than the Persian. That spatial reading suits a state lying across the envoy’s route. The common speech then moves quickly from fear to the need for one raid and for disposing of the messenger. With “let not the envoy’s life or gifts remain,” English makes the intended destruction of both objects sound decisive. The subsequent account has the gifts seized as booty. The gifts change hands and their value survives, while the diplomatic purpose of their movement collapses.
31–36The messenger’s death and the spreading alarm
Moscow — VIII157:1766 running, VIII158:1767 running, VIII158:1768 running, VIII158:1769 running, VIII158:1770 running · Mohl — VI156:1820 running, VI156:1821 running, VI157:1822 running, VI157:1823 running, VI157:1824 running · Ganjoor — sh47:12 running, sh47:13 running, sh47:14 running, sh47:15 running, sh47:16 running · Khaleghi — VII237:1785 running, VII237:1786 running, VII237:1787 running, VII237:1788 running, VII237:1789 running
Moscow VIII p.157 · Moscow VIII p.158 · Mohl VI p.156 · Mohl VI p.157 · Ganjoor sh47:12 · Ganjoor sh47:13 · Ganjoor sh47:14 · Ganjoor sh47:15 · Ganjoor sh47:16 · Khaleghi VII p.237
The four running accounts give the beheading and then the Khan’s knowledge of it. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi have a negative escape form in the line about the rider; Mohl’s printed form permits the positive reading. The English makes a single rider carry the report, a concrete explanation for the speed at which the two scenes connect. The statement that all the guards were killed universalizes the attack beyond the narrowly worded report on the envoy and rider. English then follows the general mobilization in Chin and Khutan. Its added wine alongside sleep extends the loss of ease to feast and rest. The reference to Afrasiab and Arjasp gives the gathering a dynastic memory that returns in Anooshirvan’s council.
37–42Names in the dust of mobilization
Moscow — VIII158:1771 running; VIII158 note 5 lexical apparatus at v.1771, VIII158:1771 running, VIII158:1772 running, VIII158:1773 running; VIII158:1774 running, VIII158:1774 running; VIII158:1775 running, VIII158:1775 running; VIII158:1776 running · Mohl — VI157:1825 running, VI157:1826 running, VI157:1827 running; VI157:1828 running, VI157:1828 running; VI157:1829 running, VI157:1829 running; VI157:1830 running · Ganjoor — sh47:17 running, sh47:18 running, sh48:1, sh48:2 running, sh48:2, sh48:3 running, sh48:3, sh48:4 running · Khaleghi — VII237:1790 running, VII238:1791 running, VII238:1792 running; VII238:1793 running, VII238:1793 running; VII238:1794 running, VII238:1794 running; VII238:1795 running
Moscow VIII p.158 · Mohl VI p.157 · Ganjoor sh47:17 · Ganjoor sh47:18 · Ganjoor sh48:1 · Ganjoor sh48:2 · Ganjoor sh48:3 · Ganjoor sh48:4 · Khaleghi VII p.237 · Khaleghi VII p.238
The vanguard commander takes different written forms. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give the Sanjeh or Senjeh form; Mohl prints a different form, and Moscow also records an Alk-type reading. Elanj has an uncertain precise vocalization. English makes bravery explicit and turns the dust or smoke rising to the sky into an assault on a whole frontier. The river runs the color of blood in the shared sequence. English chooses rose-red, which leaves some uncertainty over whether the color is literal blood or an image of the slaughter. The other side’s regional list includes Balkh, Shiknan, Amuy, Tirmid and Visagard. Khatlan has running support in Khaleghi and Mohl in the place where Moscow and Ganjoor give Suman.
43–48The sky closes above Bukhara
Moscow — VIII158:1777 running, VIII158:1778 running, VIII158:1779 running, VIII158:1780 running; VIII158:1781 running, VIII158:1782 running, VIII158:1783 running · Mohl — VI157:1831 running, VI157:1832 running, VI157:1833 running, VI157:1834 running; VI157:1835 running, VI157:1836 running, VI157:1837 running · Ganjoor — sh48:5 running, sh48:6 running, sh48:7 running, sh48:8, sh48:9 running, sh48:10 running, sh48:11 running · Khaleghi — VII238:1796 running, VII238:1797 running, VII238:1798 running, VII238:1799 running; VII238:1800 running, VII238:1801 running, VII239:1802 running
Moscow VIII p.158 · Mohl VI p.157 · Ganjoor sh48:5 · Ganjoor sh48:6 · Ganjoor sh48:7 · Ganjoor sh48:8 · Ganjoor sh48:9 · Ganjoor sh48:10 · Ganjoor sh48:11 · Khaleghi VII p.238 · Khaleghi VII p.239
The four versions set ants and locusts against the vast range of terrains from which the soldiers came. English preserves both creatures and their sense of density. Next the crossing turns falling swords into a property of the sky itself. English uses rain to make that physical impossibility accessible, while leaving the river unnamed. The sunlight is then compared to the black wing of a bird in the Persian. English exchanges the bird for obscuring dust, a medium that links the sky to the approach to Bukhara. The city bristles with weapons and the armies stop even the wind in the witnesses. These surviving images measure the space taken up by troops before either side gains an advantage.
49–54Iron speaks and civilians watch
Moscow — VIII158:1784 running, VIII159:1785 running, VIII159:1786 running, VIII159:1787 running, VIII159:1788 running · Mohl — VI157:1838 running, VI157:1839 running, VI157:1840 running, VI157:1841 running, VI157:1842 running · Ganjoor — sh48:12 running, sh48:13 running, sh48:14 running, sh48:15 running, sh48:16 running · Khaleghi — VII239:1803 running, VII239:1804 running, VII239:1805 running, VII239:1806 running, VII239:1807 running
Moscow VIII p.158 · Moscow VIII p.159 · Mohl VI p.157 · Ganjoor sh48:12 · Ganjoor sh48:13 · Ganjoor sh48:14 · Ganjoor sh48:15 · Ganjoor sh48:16 · Khaleghi VII p.239
The Persian joins gleaming swords, the swing of heavy maces and a complaint or marvel that iron seems to have a tongue. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all sustain the mingling of sight and sound. English gives the iron an audible ring and fills the air with steel, with less emphasis on its apparent ability to speak. The next wind and black dust abruptly absorb the light. In the four accounts the watchers’ faces are wet, and children, men and women appear in one communal image. The English spreads fear across adults and children. The question about which side sun and moon will favor keeps the spectators looking at the very sky their eyes can scarcely see.
55–60Seven days and the eighth
Moscow — VIII159:1789 running, VIII159:1790 running, VIII159:1791 running, VIII159:1792 running, VIII159:1793 running, VIII159:1794 running · Mohl — VI157:1843 running, VI157:1844 running, VI157:1845 running, VI157:1846 running, VI158:1847 running, VI158:1848 running · Ganjoor — sh48:17 running, sh48:18 running, sh48:19 running, sh48:20 running, sh49:1 running, sh49:2 running · Khaleghi — VII239:1808 running, VII239:1809 running, VII239:1810 running, VII239:1811 running, VII239:1812 running, VII239:1813 running
Moscow VIII p.159 · Mohl VI p.157 · Mohl VI p.158 · Ganjoor sh48:17 · Ganjoor sh48:18 · Ganjoor sh48:19 · Ganjoor sh48:20 · Ganjoor sh49:1 · Ganjoor sh49:2 · Khaleghi VII p.239
All four measure the stand-off as a week, then place Ghatfar’s reversal on the eighth day. English explicitly says neither side could gain its aim in the first period. The Persian image has the forces face one another and gives the balanced standoff a physical position. Blood staining stone and dust the color of the redbud carries the English couplet with particular precision, as does the startling image of an eagle unable to keep dust out of its eyes. The Persian calls the darkness a lapis-colored night. English says midnight, strengthening the time of day and losing the mineral hue. The wound that years will be needed to bind lets the aftermath outlast the scene of violence.
61–66The defeated describe their conquerors
Moscow — VIII159:1796 running, VIII159:1795 running, VIII159:1797 running; VIII159:1798 running, VIII159:1799 running, VIII159:1800 running, VIII159:1801 running; VIII160:1802 running · Mohl — VI158:1850 running, VI158:1849 running, VI158:1851 running; VI158:1852 running, VI158:1853 running, VI158:1854 running, VI158:1855 running; VI158:1856 running · Ganjoor — sh49:4 running, sh49:3 running, sh49:5, sh49:6 running, sh49:7 running, sh49:8 running, sh49:9, sh49:10 running · Khaleghi — VII240:1815 running, VII239:1814 running, VII240:1816 running; VII240:1817 running, VII240:1818 running, VII240:1819 running, VII240:1820 running; VII240:1821 running
Moscow VIII p.159 · Moscow VIII p.160 · Mohl VI p.158 · Ganjoor sh49:4 · Ganjoor sh49:3 · Ganjoor sh49:5 · Ganjoor sh49:6 · Ganjoor sh49:7 · Ganjoor sh49:8 · Ganjoor sh49:9 · Ganjoor sh49:10 · Khaleghi VII p.240 · Khaleghi VII p.239
The Persian verse on the survivors calling inwardly on God precedes their scattering among the wounded, killed and bound. English reverses those statements and lets the invocation introduce what the survivors say. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give the enemy the faces of Divs and beasts. The vantage matters because it is the people who have just lost who make human opponents into monsters. English preserves that vantage while giving the absence of thought for good and evil the more specific sound of a warrior’s code. Dragon faces and leopard claws are separated by other images in the Persian. The English combines the creatures into one readily visible body and substitutes the stone of mountains for the elevated target of the spears.
67–72Thorns, fire and the refuge in Iran
Moscow — VIII160:1803 running, VIII160:1804 running; VIII160 note 10 actual apparatus after v.1804, VIII160 note 10 actual apparatus after v.1804, VIII160:1805 running; VIII160 note 10 actual apparatus after v.1804, VIII160:1805 running, VIII160:1806 running; VIII160:1807 running · Mohl — VI158:1857 running, VI158:1858 running; VI158:1859 running, VI158:1859 running; VI158:1860 running, VI158:1860 running; VI158:1861 running, VI158:1861 running, VI158:1862 running; VI158:1863 running · Ganjoor — sh49:11 running, sh49:12 running, Checked local gap after sh49:12, sh49:13 running, sh49:14, sh49:15 running · Khaleghi — VII240:1822 running, VII240:1823 running; VII240:1824 running, VII240:1824 running; VII240:1825 running, VII240:1825 running; VII241:1826 running, VII241:1826 running, VII241:1827 running; VII241:1828 running
Moscow VIII p.160 · Mohl VI p.158 · Ganjoor sh49:11 · Ganjoor sh49:12 · Ganjoor sh49:13 · Ganjoor sh49:14 · Ganjoor sh49:15 · Khaleghi VII p.240 · Khaleghi VII p.241
The first two Persian couplets of the portrait keep the mounts saddled, describe sleep on snow, feed the horses thorns and give two men awake for one asleep. English retains saddles, thorns and readiness. Mohl and Khaleghi then make the riders charge all night and throw themselves into fire, without sleep or food, so that only a Div would fight them. Moscow actually prints both verses in its apparatus. Ganjoor moves directly from watchfulness to the proposed refuge in Iran. English distributes the two extra verses over successive couplets, and its “no need for food or life” converts the already uncanny deprivation into the witnesses’ impression that the riders have transcended ordinary vulnerability.
73–77Seeking a serviceable king
Moscow — VIII160:1808 running, VIII160:1809 running, VIII160:1814 running, VIII160:1810 running, VIII160:1810 running; VIII160:1811 running · Mohl — VI158:1864 running, VI158:1865 running, VI158:1870 running, VI158:1866 running, VI158:1866 running; VI158:1867 running · Ganjoor — sh49:16 running, sh49:17 running, sh49:22 running, sh49:18 running, sh49:18, sh49:19 running · Khaleghi — VII241:1829 running, VII241:1830 running, VII241:1835 running, VII241:1831 running, VII241:1831 running; VII241:1832 running
Moscow VIII p.160 · Mohl VI p.158 · Ganjoor sh49:16 · Ganjoor sh49:17 · Ganjoor sh49:22 · Ganjoor sh49:18 · Ganjoor sh49:19 · Khaleghi VII p.241
The speakers offer an alternative if Ghatfar will not submit. In the four running witnesses they want a fighter of desirable stock who will please Anooshirvan. The terms put pedigree, military ability and relations with Iran in the same decision. English brings in the lord of Chaghaniyan here, using the identification that the Persian gives several verses later. The earlier recognition makes the plan easier to follow. It also reduces the moment during which the injured people seem free to choose among several men. Their proposed envoy is to tell Anooshirvan of the Khan’s affairs. English gives that proposal a visible object and ensures the story of the larger rivalry travels into the next chapter.
78–82Acclamation across the lines of war
Moscow — VIII160:1811 running; VIII160:1812 running, VIII160:1813 running, VIII160:1814 running, VIII160:1815 running, VIII160:1816 running · Mohl — VI158:1867 running; VI158:1868 running, VI158:1869 running, VI158:1870 running, VI158:1871 running, VI159:1872 running · Ganjoor — sh49:19, sh49:20 running, sh49:21 running, sh49:22 running, sh49:23 running, sh49:24 running · Khaleghi — VII241:1832 running; VII241:1833 running, VII241:1834 running, VII241:1835 running, VII241:1836 running, VII241:1837 running
Moscow VIII p.160 · Mohl VI p.158 · Mohl VI p.159 · Ganjoor sh49:19 · Ganjoor sh49:20 · Ganjoor sh49:21 · Ganjoor sh49:22 · Ganjoor sh49:23 · Ganjoor sh49:24 · Khaleghi VII p.241
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi say Anooshirvan has imposed tax and tribute on the Caesars, and that nobody can match his power. The English “broke his might” makes the claim sound more like a single overthrow than recurring payment. The transition from that speech to the Heytalian assembly includes children, men and women together, an image of consensus the English preserves. All four call Faghanish well-born and give him treasure and troops, material reasons why his nomination can become effective. The Khan himself joins the Heytalian magnates in acclaiming him in the Persian. English names chiefs and warriors alone, bringing the accession to a more local conclusion and leaving the victorious neighbor less visibly involved in the new rule.
Source record and limits
English
82 published English couplets. Ganjoor passages: Anooshirvan §44: 176–177, Anooshirvan §45: 1–7, Anooshirvan §46: 1–11, Anooshirvan §47: 1–18, Anooshirvan §48: 1–20, Anooshirvan §49: 1–24. The English text follows the published verse and chapter divisions.
Moscow
The 1970 Moscow edition, volume VIII, printed pages 156–160. The source register identifies the individual running verses and any printed apparatus cited.
Mohl
Jules Mohl’s Persian text, volume VI, printed pages 155–159. The running sequence contains independent verses on these topics. The source register records where an edition also prints related manuscript wording.
Ganjoor
Anooshirvan §44: 176–177, Anooshirvan §45: 1–7, Anooshirvan §46: 1–11, Anooshirvan §47: 1–18, Anooshirvan §48: 1–20, Anooshirvan §49: 1–24. The Persian column gives the corresponding running verses and identifies where Mohl supplies an independent couplet for a local Ganjoor gap.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Djalal Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VII, printed pages 234–241. Square brackets mark verses retained in the main text with explicit editorial reservation. Printed additions have their own locators.
Gifts, names and the night fighters
The gift inventory has genuine alternative readings. A hundred camels is a printed lexical variant; ten silver loads are a full running reading in Mohl and Khaleghi. Verse numbering remains local to each edition. The two disputed night-fighting couplets are separately located in Moscow’s actual apparatus and in Mohl and Khaleghi running text.
Consequential readings
English 14. The four running texts load goods onto camels without this count. Khaleghi prints the variant “hundred camels.” English 16. Mohl and Khaleghi run ten camels loaded from the treasury with silver coins; Moscow and Ganjoor give an additional load of dinars. English 19. The four running texts give writing on silk and compare its appearance to the Arzhang of Chin. The English conveys a Chinese manner of writing. English 32. The running Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi line has the negative najast after the envoy is beheaded. Mohl prints the variant be-jast reading here, permitting a rider’s escape. The next verse has the news reach the Khan. English 37. The commander’s name varies. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give Sanjeh or Senjeh, while Mohl’s separate form is graphically different and the Moscow apparatus prints an Alk-type form. The precise English vocalization Elanj is unverified. English 44. The Turk or Terek river name is visible in the Persian beside the simile of a sky raining swords. English retains the simile. English 66. Dragon faces, elevated spears and leopard claws occupy two running verses. English brings both animals into one line and gives the spears a mountain target. English 68. The mount eats thorns and one rider sleeps while two keep watch. The night-raiding detail also has support in the following verse in Mohl and Khaleghi. English 69. Mohl and Khaleghi print the two verses in the poem; Moscow prints both in its notes. Ganjoor goes directly from the riders keeping watch to the proposal to seek Iran. English 70. The challenge that only a Div could meet occurs in Mohl and Khaleghi running text and Moscow apparatus. The inability to resist the Khan is in all four running texts. English 75. The details specific to the lord of Chaghan belong to the later running nomination. English identifies him in advance within the survivors’ proposal. English 82. All four running texts include the Khan among those acclaiming Faghanish. English puts the emphasis on collective local support.
Limits of the evidence
Running text, bracketed running text, actual printed apparatus and checked local gaps indicate distinct kinds of support. Local gaps concern the specified passage. No appendix reading is invoked. The geographical and institutional terms describe the poem’s account.
Source-only verses
S1. A second transition asks what the speaker will say about the three rulers. Its placement relative to the rubric differs, and English uses a single call to hear the story.
Moscow VIII p.156 · Moscow VIII p.157 · Moscow VIII p.158 · Moscow VIII p.159 · Moscow VIII p.160
Mohl VI p.155 · Mohl VI p.156 · Mohl VI p.157 · Mohl VI p.158 · Mohl VI p.159
Khaleghi VII p.234 · Khaleghi VII p.235 · Khaleghi VII p.236 · Khaleghi VII p.237 · Khaleghi VII p.238 · Khaleghi VII p.239 · Khaleghi VII p.240 · Khaleghi VII p.241
Selected printed readings
- Khaleghi VII236 note 5 lexical apparatus · صد هیون
The hundred-camel variant is actually printed. - Mohl VI156:1805 running · بیاورد و با هدیهها یار کرد / ده اشتر ز گنج درم بار کرد
Ten camels loaded with silver coin. - Moscow VIII157 note 8 actual apparatus · ده اشتر ز گنج درم بار
Moscow gives the silver-load reading in its notes. - Khaleghi VII236:1773 running · نبشتند برسان آرتنگ چین / سوی شاه با صد هزار آفرین
The written greeting explicitly invokes a visual model. - Moscow VIII158:1771 running · سپهدار خاقان چین سنجه بود / همی بآسمان بر زد از خاک دود
The commander has a distinct running name here. - Moscow VIII160 note 10 actual apparatus · همه شب جز از کشتن و تاختن / تن خویش را بآتش انداختن
The riders spend the night killing and charging. - Khaleghi VII240:1825 running · نبود و ندانست کس خواب و خورد / مگر دیو جوید ازیشان نبرد
Only a Div would seek to fight them. - Moscow VIII160:1816 running · بزرگان هیتال و خاقان چین / بشاهی برو خواندند آفرین
Both the Heytalian grandees and the Khan acclaim Faghanish.
E1.4 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII156:1735 running | VI155:1789 running |
| 2 | VIII156:1737 running | VI155:1791 running |
| 3 | VIII156:1738 running | VI155:1792 running |
| 4 | VIII156:1739 running | VI155:1793 running |
| 5 | VIII156:1740 running | VI155:1794 running |
| 6 | VIII156:1741 running | VI155:1795 running |
| 7 | VIII156:1741 running | VI155:1795 running |
| 8 | VIII156:1742 running; VIII156:1743 running | VI155:1796 running; VI156:1797 running · VI p.156 |
| 9 | VIII156:1744 running | VI156:1798 running |
| 10 | VIII156:1745 running | VI156:1799 running |
| 11 | VIII156:1746 running | VI156:1800 running |
| 12 | VIII157:1747 running | VI156:1801 running |
| 13 | VIII157:1748 running | VI156:1802 running |
| 14 | VIII157:1749 running | VI156:1803 running |
| 15 | VIII157:1750 running | VI156:1804 running |
| 16 | VIII157:1751 running; VIII157 note 8 actual apparatus at v.1751 | VI156:1805 running |
| 17 | VIII157:1752 running | VI156:1806 running |
| 18 | VIII157:1753 running | VI156:1807 running |
| 19 | VIII157:1754 running | VI156:1808 running |
| 20 | VIII157:1755 running | VI156:1809 running |
| 21 | VIII157:1756 running | VI156:1810 running |
| 22 | VIII157:1757 running | VI156:1811 running |
| 23 | VIII157:1758 running | VI156:1812 running |
| 24 | VIII157:1759 running | VI156:1813 running |
| 25 | VIII157:1760 running; VIII157:1761 running | VI156:1814 running; VI156:1815 running |
| 26 | VIII157:1761 running | VI156:1815 running |
| 27 | VIII157:1762 running | VI156:1816 running |
| 28 | VIII157:1763 running | VI156:1817 running |
| 29 | VIII157:1764 running | VI156:1818 running |
| 30 | VIII157:1765 running | VI156:1819 running |
| 31 | VIII157:1766 running | VI156:1820 running |
| 32 | VIII157:1766 running | VI156:1820 running |
| 33 | VIII158:1767 running | VI156:1821 running |
| 34 | VIII158:1768 running | VI157:1822 running |
| 35 | VIII158:1769 running | VI157:1823 running |
| 36 | VIII158:1770 running | VI157:1824 running |
| 37 | VIII158:1771 running; VIII158 note 5 lexical apparatus at v.1771 | VI157:1825 running |
| 38 | VIII158:1771 running | VI157:1825 running |
| 39 | VIII158:1772 running | VI157:1826 running |
| 40 | VIII158:1773 running; VIII158:1774 running | VI157:1827 running; VI157:1828 running |
| 41 | VIII158:1774 running; VIII158:1775 running | VI157:1828 running; VI157:1829 running |
| 42 | VIII158:1775 running; VIII158:1776 running | VI157:1829 running; VI157:1830 running |
| 43 | VIII158:1777 running | VI157:1831 running |
| 44 | VIII158:1778 running | VI157:1832 running |
| 45 | VIII158:1779 running | VI157:1833 running |
| 46 | VIII158:1780 running; VIII158:1781 running | VI157:1834 running; VI157:1835 running |
| 47 | VIII158:1782 running | VI157:1836 running |
| 48 | VIII158:1783 running | VI157:1837 running |
| 49 | VIII158:1784 running | VI157:1838 running |
| 50 | VIII159:1785 running | VI157:1839 running |
| 51 | VIII159:1786 running | VI157:1840 running |
| 52 | VIII159:1787 running | VI157:1841 running |
| 53 | VIII159:1787 running | VI157:1841 running |
| 54 | VIII159:1788 running | VI157:1842 running |
| 55 | VIII159:1789 running | VI157:1843 running |
| 56 | VIII159:1790 running | VI157:1844 running |
| 57 | VIII159:1791 running | VI157:1845 running |
| 58 | VIII159:1792 running | VI157:1846 running |
| 59 | VIII159:1793 running | VI158:1847 running |
| 60 | VIII159:1794 running | VI158:1848 running |
| 61 | VIII159:1796 running | VI158:1850 running |
| 62 | VIII159:1795 running | VI158:1849 running |
| 63 | VIII159:1797 running; VIII159:1798 running | VI158:1851 running; VI158:1852 running |
| 64 | VIII159:1799 running | VI158:1853 running |
| 65 | VIII159:1800 running | VI158:1854 running |
| 66 | VIII159:1801 running; VIII160:1802 running · VIII p.160 | VI158:1855 running; VI158:1856 running |
| 67 | VIII160:1803 running | VI158:1857 running |
| 68 | VIII160:1804 running; VIII160 note 10 actual apparatus after v.1804 | VI158:1858 running; VI158:1859 running |
| 69 | VIII160 note 10 actual apparatus after v.1804 | VI158:1859 running; VI158:1860 running |
| 70 | VIII160:1805 running; VIII160 note 10 actual apparatus after v.1804 | VI158:1860 running; VI158:1861 running |
| 71 | VIII160:1805 running | VI158:1861 running |
| 72 | VIII160:1806 running; VIII160:1807 running | VI158:1862 running; VI158:1863 running |
| 73 | VIII160:1808 running | VI158:1864 running |
| 74 | VIII160:1809 running | VI158:1865 running |
| 75 | VIII160:1814 running | VI158:1870 running |
| 76 | VIII160:1810 running | VI158:1866 running |
| 77 | VIII160:1810 running; VIII160:1811 running | VI158:1866 running; VI158:1867 running |
| 78 | VIII160:1811 running; VIII160:1812 running | VI158:1867 running; VI158:1868 running |
| 79 | VIII160:1813 running | VI158:1869 running |
| 80 | VIII160:1814 running | VI158:1870 running |
| 81 | VIII160:1815 running | VI158:1871 running |
| 82 | VIII160:1816 running | VI159:1872 running |
New Naqqali