Mahwi of Sur Takes the Throne
57 published English couplets. A report of Yazdegard’s burial reaches Mahwi. He has the king’s regalia, and his counselor supplies a story with which to claim the throne.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 57 published English couplets. A report of Yazdegard’s burial reaches Mahwi. He has the king’s regalia, and his counselor supplies a story with which to claim the throne. |
| Moscow | Volume IX, pp. 368–373, vv. 706–762. |
| Mohl | Volume VII, pp. 245–248, vv. 745–802. |
| Ganjoor | Yazdegard §13:2–10 and §14:1–48. The section starts inside the reflection that follows Yazdegard’s burial and ends with the commander’s invocation of Yazdegard. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | Volume VIII, pp. 473–477, vv. 734–792. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The reckoning of a single breath
Moscow IX368:706 running text, IX368:707 running text, IX368:708 running text, IX369:709 running text, IX369:710 running text, IX369:711 running text · Mohl VII245:745 running text, VII245:746 running text, VII245:747 running text, VII245:748 running text, VII245:749 running text, VII245:750 running text · Ganjoor sh13:2 running poem body, sh13:3 running poem body, sh13:4 running poem body, sh13:5 running poem body, sh13:6 running poem body, sh13:7 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII473:734 running text, VIII473:735 running text, VIII473:736 running text, VIII473:737 running text, VIII473:738 running text, VIII473:739 running text
Moscow IX p.368 · Moscow IX p.369 · Mohl VII p.245 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §13:2 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §13:3 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §13:4 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §13:5 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §13:6 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §13:7 · Khaleghi VIII p.473
The chapter opens with the unresolved problem of justice that followed Yazdegard’s burial. Moscow and Mohl move from the philosopher to the man of faith and then from the failure of their explanations to the need to spend what is at hand. Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh keep the same turn. “No sage has brought an answer” changes a question about what the speaker should ask into a judgment about the answer already given. “Time counts our breaths” then gives the change of subject a measure the reader can feel. The financial balance at the end makes Fortune’s kinship conditional on what life actually costs.
7–12From the hail to the funeral
Moscow IX369:712 running text, IX369:713 running text, IX369:714 running text, IX369 after v.714 · checked local running gap, IX370:715 running text, IX370:716 running text, IX370:717 running text · Mohl VII246:751 running text, VII246:752 running text, VII246:753 running text, VII246:754 running text, VII246:755 running text, VII246:756 running text, VII246:757 running text · Ganjoor sh13:8 running poem body, sh13:9 running poem body, sh13:10 running poem body, Checked local running gap near §13:10, sh14:1 running poem body, sh14:2 running poem body, sh14:3 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII473:740 running text, VIII474:741 running text, VIII474:742 running text, VIII474 after v.742 · checked local running gap, VIII474:743 running text, VIII474:744 running text, VIII474:745 running text
Moscow IX p.369 · Moscow IX p.370 · Mohl VII p.246 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §13:8 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §13:9 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §13:10 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:1 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:2 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:3 · Khaleghi VIII p.473 · Khaleghi VIII p.474
The loss of fuel, wheat and sheep follows the hail in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh. Each item keeps the complaint within an ordinary household after the much larger question about Heaven. Mohl extends the call for wine by a separate verse before the report to Mahwi. The English ends the reflection with “passes on” and makes the arrival of the messenger the next event, following the shorter sequence of the three other texts. Its “mourn his name” identifies the object of grief while the list of clerics and mourners preserves the organized, collective character of the recovery of Yazdegard’s body.
13–18The tomb and the seal
Moscow IX370:718 running text, IX370:719 running text, IX370:720 running text, IX370:721 running text, IX370:722 running text, IX370:723 running text · Mohl VII246:758 running text, VII246:759 running text, VII246:760 running text, VII246:761 running text, VII246:762 running text, VII246:763 running text · Ganjoor sh14:4 running poem body, sh14:5 running poem body, sh14:6 running poem body, sh14:7 running poem body, sh14:8 running poem body, sh14:9 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII474:746 running text, VIII474:747 running text, VIII474:748 running text, VIII474:749 running text, VIII474:750 running text, VIII474:751 running text
Moscow IX p.370 · Mohl VII p.246 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:4 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:5 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:6 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:7 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:8 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:9 · Khaleghi VIII p.474
Moscow and Mohl put the construction of the tomb in a garden and carry Mahwi’s question about Iran’s kinship with Rum into the order for reprisals. Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh preserve that sequence. The question in English sounds almost like a defense of precedent. Its position before the order reveals how Mahwi turns the burial into an offense. Searches for a descendant and possession of the royal objects then come together. The Persian explicitly describes the aspirant as a shepherd’s son. The English leaves his social origin unstated here and makes the object of his desire clear by putting “the throne” at the end of the couplet.
19–24The authority written on a ring
Moscow IX370:724 running text, IX370:725 running text, IX370:726 running text, IX370:727 running text, IX370:728 running text, IX371:729 running text · Mohl VII246:764 running text, VII246:765 running text, VII246:766 running text, VII246:767 running text, VII246:768 running text, VII246:769 running text · Ganjoor sh14:10 running poem body, sh14:11 running poem body, sh14:12 running poem body, sh14:13 running poem body, sh14:14 running poem body, sh14:15 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII474:752 running text, VIII474:753 running text, VIII475:754 running text, VIII475:755 running text, VIII475:756 running text, VIII475:757 running text
Moscow IX p.370 · Moscow IX p.371 · Mohl VII p.246 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:10 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:11 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:12 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:13 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:14 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:15 · Khaleghi VIII p.474 · Khaleghi VIII p.475
The different things Mahwi lacks are expressed with varying words for name and resources in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh. The English gives the three claims “treasure, lineage, or fame” so the reader can see why holding the objects is insufficient. In these accounts the ring bears Yazdegard’s name, and wise men and soldiers have distinct parts in recognizing a ruler. “Place no reliance on my ring” makes Mahwi’s assessment of the soldiers particularly precise. The ring belongs to him as a possession at this moment, while the writing that lends the ring authority continues to identify the dead king.
25–30The counselor’s prescription
Moscow IX371:730 running text, IX371:731 running text, IX371:732 running text, IX371:733 running text, IX371:734 running text, IX371:735 running text · Mohl VII246:770 running text, VII246:771 running text, VII246:772 running text, VII246:773 running text, VII247:774 running text, VII247:775 running text · Ganjoor sh14:16 running poem body, sh14:17 running poem body, sh14:18 running poem body, sh14:19 running poem body, sh14:20 running poem body, sh14:21 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII475:758 running text, VIII475:759 running text, VIII475:760 running text, VIII475:761 running text, VIII475:762 running text, VIII475:763 running text
Moscow IX p.371 · Mohl VII p.246 · Mohl VII p.247 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:16 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:17 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:18 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:19 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:20 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:21 · Khaleghi VIII p.475
All four texts place the admission of regicide before the counselor’s reply. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor give conspicuous form to the reply through the broken thread and the image of an antidote. Khaleghi-Motlagh also moves from the torn thread and dead king to the language the counselor recommends. English “soothed his soul” gives the medicine image a subject in the earth and leaves out its sting of poison. The next instruction is sharper. “Sharpen speech with sweetness” helps explain what the counselor offers after saying that the rumor cannot be stopped. Mahwi can still shape the account heard by people whose recognition he needs.
31–36The daughter in the counterfeit commission
Moscow IX371:736 running text, IX371:737 running text, IX371:738 running text, IX371:739 running text, IX371:740 running text · IX371 v.740 n.24 · daughter variant printed in apparatus, IX371:741 running text · Mohl VII247:776 running text, VII247:777 running text, VII247:778 running text, VII247:779 running text, VII247:780 running text, VII247:781 running text · Ganjoor sh14:22 running poem body, sh14:23 running poem body, sh14:24 running poem body, sh14:25 running poem body, sh14:26 running poem body, sh14:27 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII475:764 running text, VIII475:765 running text, VIII475:766 running text, VIII475:767 running text, VIII476:768 running text, VIII476:769 running text
Moscow IX p.371 · Mohl VII p.247 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:22 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:23 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:24 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:25 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:26 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:27 · Khaleghi VIII p.475 · Khaleghi VIII p.476
Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh explicitly name a daughter kept from the Arabs in the words the counselor scripts for Mahwi. Moscow prints the daughter in the apparatus, while its running verse and Ganjoor say the king has nothing but “this.” “One daughter only left to me” therefore recovers an attested claim and gives a precise person to the danger the speech invokes. Every version encloses this line within advice on what Mahwi is to say. The English carefully keeps it inside Yazdegard’s alleged speech, so the information remains part of Mahwi’s strategy for acquiring trust. It does not resolve the subsequent inquiry about who survived.
37–42A claim its hearers refuse to own
Moscow IX371:742 running text, IX371:743 running text, IX371:744 running text, IX372:745 running text, IX372:746 running text, IX372:747 running text · Mohl VII247:782 running text, VII247:783 running text, VII247:784 running text, VII247:785 running text, VII247:786 running text, VII247:787 running text · Ganjoor sh14:28 running poem body, sh14:29 running poem body, sh14:30 running poem body, sh14:31 running poem body, sh14:32 running poem body, sh14:33 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII476:770 running text, VIII476:771 running text, VIII476:772 running text, VIII476:773 running text, VIII476:774 running text, VIII476:775 running text
Moscow IX p.371 · Moscow IX p.372 · Mohl VII p.247 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:28 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:29 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:30 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:31 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:32 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:33 · Khaleghi VIII p.476
The hearers’ disbelief is explicit in Moscow and Mohl, as it is in Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh. The Persian Pahlevan assigns the matter back to Mahwi whether the words are true or false. The English “you bear it in your name” adds a formulation that fits a scene about whose name makes a claim binding. If the ring’s inscription has denied Mahwi authority, the commander at least declines to lend him another person’s name. The poem allows the claim to circulate after exposing it to the public within the hall. That is what makes the shift to Mahwi’s actual occupation of the throne disturbing.
43–48Government by distribution
Moscow IX372:748 running text, IX372:749 running text, IX373 between vv.749–750 · checked local running gap, IX372:750 running text, IX372:751 running text, IX372:752 running text, IX372:753 running text · Mohl VII247:788 running text, VII247:789 running text, VII247 between vv.789–790 · checked local running gap, VII247:790 running text, VII247:791 running text, VII247:792 running text, VII247:793 running text · Ganjoor sh14:34 running poem body, sh14:35 running poem body, Checked local running gap near §14:35, sh14:36 running poem body, sh14:37 running poem body, sh14:38 running poem body, sh14:39 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII476:776 running text, VIII476:777 running text, VIII476:778 running text, VIII476:779 running text, VIII477:780 running text, VIII477:781 running text, VIII477:782 running text
Moscow IX p.372 · Moscow IX p.373 · Mohl VII p.247 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:34 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:35 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:36 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:37 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:38 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:39 · Khaleghi VIII p.476 · Khaleghi VIII p.477
Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor connect acquisition of Khorasan to afsun and then to distributing lands and favors. Khaleghi-Motlagh also has a separate verse about summoning someone born to bad stock amid this distribution. The English “through his own deceit” assigns a clear role to the false report just heard. The eldest son’s lands, Balkh and Herat, then offer a concrete example of how the distribution works. The movement from named places to raising the wicked preserves the distinction between a specific allocation of property and the more general selection of people who will carry the ruler’s wishes into practice.
49–54A scout with a variable name
Moscow IX372:754 running text, IX372:755 running text, IX372:756 running text, IX372 v.756 to IX373 v.757 · checked local running gap, IX373:757 running text, IX373:758 running text, IX373:759 running text · Mohl VII247:794 running text, VII247:795 running text, VII247:796 running text, VII247 between vv.796–797 · checked local running gap, VII247:797 running text, VII247:798 running text, VII248:799 running text · Ganjoor sh14:40 running poem body, sh14:41 running poem body, sh14:42 running poem body, Checked local running gap near §14:42, sh14:43 running poem body, sh14:44 running poem body, sh14:45 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII477:783 running text, VIII477:784 running text, VIII477:785 running text, VIII477:786 running text, VIII477:787 running text, VIII477:788 running text, VIII477:789 running text
Moscow IX p.372 · Moscow IX p.373 · Mohl VII p.247 · Mohl VII p.248 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:40 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:41 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:42 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:43 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:44 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:45 · Khaleghi VIII p.477
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh bring the judgment about lowered righteousness into payment of the army and movement toward Amuy and Bukhara. Khaleghi-Motlagh adds a running verse introducing a commander who is to seek battle with Bijan. The scout’s written name varies across the printed texts. Khaleghi-Motlagh’s کرسیون is closer to the English “Garsiyun” than Ganjoor’s گرستون, and the verse register keeps the difference visible. “Worldly-wise” conveys the basis on which the scout is trusted. It sets off the deployment of practical knowledge for a regime the preceding verses have described as deliberately lowering people who know how to rule.
55–57Whose vengeance is claimed
Moscow IX373:760 running text, IX373:761 running text, IX373:762 running text · Mohl VII248:800 running text, VII248:801 running text, VII248:802 running text · Ganjoor sh14:46 running poem body, sh14:47 running poem body, sh14:48 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII477:790 running text, VIII477:791 running text, VIII477:792 running text
Moscow IX p.373 · Mohl VII p.248 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:46 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:47 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §14:48 · Khaleghi VIII p.477
Moscow and Mohl put the march to Samarkand and Chakh under the authority of the crown and seal. Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh likewise put the appeal to Yazdegard and the accusation against Bijan inside the commander’s words. The English gives the charge an elevated scale with “seven spheres” and “royal might,” terms that lend the expedition something of Yazdegard’s former reach. It then makes the grievance personal by speaking of the shah’s Fortune. The reader has heard how Mahwi acquired the regalia, so the attribution of Yazdegard’s fall to Bijan exposes what Mahwi’s faction can do with the objects after acquiring them.
Source record and limits
F&R English
57 published English couplets. A report of Yazdegard’s burial reaches Mahwi. He has the king’s regalia, and his counselor supplies a story with which to claim the throne.
Moscow
Volume IX, pp. 368–373, vv. 706–762.
Mohl
Volume VII, pp. 245–248, vv. 745–802.
Ganjoor
Yazdegard §13:2–10 and §14:1–48. The section starts inside the reflection that follows Yazdegard’s burial and ends with the commander’s invocation of Yazdegard.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Volume VIII, pp. 473–477, vv. 734–792.
Consequential readings and limits
Mohl has an extra wine verse. The daughter named in the counselor’s script runs in Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh and appears in Moscow’s apparatus. The scout’s written name varies. Khaleghi-Motlagh has two further running verses during Mahwi’s distribution of favor and deployment of a commander.
Moscow IX p.368 · Moscow IX p.369 · Moscow IX p.370 · Moscow IX p.371 · Moscow IX p.372 · Moscow IX p.373
Mohl VII p.245 · Mohl VII p.246 · Mohl VII p.247 · Mohl VII p.248
Khaleghi VIII p.473 · Khaleghi VIII p.474 · Khaleghi VIII p.475 · Khaleghi VIII p.476 · Khaleghi VIII p.477
Selected printed readings
- Moscow IX p.368 v.706b · Running text · first verse · وگر کینه خواهیم ازین فیلسوف
The Persian poses the question of recourse to a philosopher. - Khaleghi VIII p.474 v.751b · Running text · ancestry · شبانزاده را آرزو کرد گاه
The Persian explicitly identifies Mahwi as a shepherd’s son. - Mohl VII p.246 v.767a · Running text · inscription · بر انگشتری یزدگردست نام
Mahwi names the inscription as an impediment to recognition. - Moscow IX p.371 v.740a · Running text · unspecified object · مرا نیست چیزی جزین در جهان
Moscow’s n.24 gives the daughter variant. - Mohl VII p.247 v.780a · Running text · daughter · مرا نیست جز دختری در جهان
Mohl explicitly names a daughter in the fabricated speech. - Khaleghi VIII p.476 v.768a · Running text · daughter · مرا نیست جز دختری در جهان
Khaleghi-Motlagh agrees on the daughter. - Khaleghi VIII p.477 v.788b · Running text · scout · جهاندیدهیی نام او کرسیون
The manuscript-based spelling is closer to Garsiyun than the form in Ganjoor.
E10.12 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IX368:706 running text | VII245:745 running text |
| 2 | IX368:707 running text | VII245:746 running text |
| 3 | IX368:708 running text | VII245:747 running text |
| 4 | IX369:709 running text | VII245:748 running text |
| 5 | IX369:710 running text | VII245:749 running text |
| 6 | IX369:711 running text | VII245:750 running text |
| 7 | IX369:712 running text | VII246:751 running text |
| 8 | IX369:713 running text | VII246:752 running text |
| 9 | IX369:714 running text | VII246:753 running text |
| 10 | IX370:715 running text | VII246:755 running text |
| 11 | IX370:716 running text | VII246:756 running text |
| 12 | IX370:717 running text | VII246:757 running text |
| 13 | IX370:718 running text | VII246:758 running text |
| 14 | IX370:719 running text | VII246:759 running text |
| 15 | IX370:720 running text | VII246:760 running text |
| 16 | IX370:721 running text | VII246:761 running text |
| 17 | IX370:722 running text | VII246:762 running text |
| 18 | IX370:723 running text | VII246:763 running text |
| 19 | IX370:724 running text | VII246:764 running text |
| 20 | IX370:725 running text | VII246:765 running text |
| 21 | IX370:726 running text | VII246:766 running text |
| 22 | IX370:727 running text | VII246:767 running text |
| 23 | IX370:728 running text | VII246:768 running text |
| 24 | IX371:729 running text | VII246:769 running text |
| 25 | IX371:730 running text | VII246:770 running text |
| 26 | IX371:731 running text | VII246:771 running text |
| 27 | IX371:732 running text | VII246:772 running text |
| 28 | IX371:733 running text | VII246:773 running text |
| 29 | IX371:734 running text | VII247:774 running text |
| 30 | IX371:735 running text | VII247:775 running text |
| 31 | IX371:736 running text | VII247:776 running text |
| 32 | IX371:737 running text | VII247:777 running text |
| 33 | IX371:738 running text | VII247:778 running text |
| 34 | IX371:739 running text | VII247:779 running text |
| 35 | IX371:740 running text · IX371 v.740 n.24 · daughter variant printed in apparatus | VII247:780 running text |
| 36 | IX371:741 running text | VII247:781 running text |
| 37 | IX371:742 running text | VII247:782 running text |
| 38 | IX371:743 running text | VII247:783 running text |
| 39 | IX371:744 running text | VII247:784 running text |
| 40 | IX372:745 running text | VII247:785 running text |
| 41 | IX372:746 running text | VII247:786 running text |
| 42 | IX372:747 running text | VII247:787 running text |
| 43 | IX372:748 running text | VII247:788 running text |
| 44 | IX372:749 running text | VII247:789 running text |
| 45 | IX372:750 running text | VII247:790 running text |
| 46 | IX372:751 running text | VII247:791 running text |
| 47 | IX372:752 running text | VII247:792 running text |
| 48 | IX372:753 running text | VII247:793 running text |
| 49 | IX372:754 running text | VII247:794 running text |
| 50 | IX372:755 running text | VII247:795 running text |
| 51 | IX372:756 running text | VII247:796 running text |
| 52 | IX373:757 running text | VII247:797 running text |
| 53 | IX373:758 running text | VII247:798 running text |
| 54 | IX373:759 running text | VII248:799 running text |
| 55 | IX373:760 running text | VII248:800 running text |
| 56 | IX373:761 running text | VII248:801 running text |
| 57 | IX373:762 running text | VII248:802 running text |
New Naqqali