Rostam and Sa’ad Exchange Letters
87 published English couplets. Rostam’s dispatch to his brother gives way to the letters between Rostam and Sa’ad and the embassy of Shobae Moghireh.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 87 published English couplets. Rostam’s dispatch to his brother gives way to the letters between Rostam and Sa’ad and the embassy of Shobae Moghireh. |
| Moscow | Volume IX, pp. 321–328, vv. 132–219. |
| Mohl | Volume VII, pp. 221–224, vv. 149–237. |
| Ganjoor | Yazdegard §2:111–112, §3:1–36 and §4:1–50. The next published chapter opens with Shobae’s return, which has separate evidence in Mohl and the critical apparatuses. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | Volume VIII, pp. 421–429, vv. 132–220. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Two dispatches and two addressees
Moscow IX321:132 running text, IX321:133 running text, IX321:134 running text, IX321:135 running text, IX321:136 running text, IX321:137 running text · Mohl VII221:149 running text, VII221:150 running text, VII221:151 running text, VII221:152 running text, VII221:153 running text, VII221:154 running text · Ganjoor sh2:111 running poem body, sh2:112 running poem body, sh3:1 running poem body, sh3:2 running poem body, sh3:3 running poem body, sh3:4 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII421:132 running text, VIII421:133 running text, VIII421:134 running text, VIII421:135 running text, VIII421:136 running text, VIII421:137 running text
Moscow IX p.321 · Mohl VII p.221 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §2:111 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §2:112 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:1 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:2 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:3 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:4 · Khaleghi VIII p.421
The English chapter starts inside the Persian account of the letter to Rostam’s brother. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all place its blessing and charge at the end of that dispatch. Each then begins a new movement with the swift messenger to Sa’ad. The English keeps the repeated messenger motif and makes the change of addressee explicit before describing the writing. This helps the reader distinguish the family counsel from the letter of state. White silk and the sun-bright letter are common to the four witnesses. The English gives first the texture of the surface and then the brightness of the written object. Rostam’s paternal descent and office then carry much of the authority of his argument before he confronts Sa’ad with the narrowed world of the war-seeker.
7–12Justice as an argument for kingship
Moscow IX321:138,139 running text, IX321:139 running text, IX321:140 running text, IX321 between vv.140–141 · checked local running gap, IX321:141 running text, IX321:142 running text, IX321:143 running text · Mohl VII221:155,156 running text, VII221:156 running text, VII221:157 running text, VII221:158 running text, VII221:159 running text, VII221:160 running text, VII221:161 running text · Ganjoor sh3:5, sh3:6 running poem body, sh3:6 running poem body, sh3:7 running poem body, Checked local running gap near §3:7, sh3:8 running poem body, sh3:9 running poem body, sh3:10 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII421:138 running text · VIII422:139 running text, VIII422:139 running text, VIII422:140 running text, VIII422 at v.140 · printed apparatus parallel, VIII422:141 running text, VIII422:142 running text, VIII422:143 running text
Moscow IX p.321 · Mohl VII p.221 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:5 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:6 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:7 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:8 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:9 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:10 · Khaleghi VIII p.421 · Khaleghi VIII p.422
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh make reverence for the Creator the ground of the letter and place justice and favor beside the revolving sphere. English moves the heavenly image across two couplets, giving those qualities room to define divine rule before they authorize its earthly counterpart. The prayer for the shah and the claim that his farr binds Ahriman are shared, although Mohl runs a separate praise verse on his radiance that Khaleghi-Motlagh records in the apparatus. The English rein is provisional against a line that clearly gives the sword and crown. Khaleghi-Motlagh records a lasso variant. The English then turns the argument from an account of legitimate power to direct questions, retaining Rostam’s order of an objection to the war before the inquiry about Sa’ad’s ruler and custom.
13–18Baggage and the image of the king
Moscow IX322:144 running text, IX322:145 running text, IX322:146 running text, IX322:147 running text, IX322:148 running text, IX322:149 running text · Mohl VII221:162 running text, VII221:163 running text, VII221:164 running text, VII221:165 running text, VII222:166 running text, VII222:167 running text · Ganjoor sh3:11 running poem body, sh3:12 running poem body, sh3:13 running poem body, sh3:14 running poem body, sh3:15 running poem body, sh3:16 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII422:144 running text, VIII422:145 running text, VIII422:146 running text, VIII422:147 running text, VIII422:148 running text, VIII422:149 running text
Moscow IX p.322 · Mohl VII p.221 · Mohl VII p.222 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:11 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:12 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:13 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:14 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:15 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:16 · Khaleghi VIII p.422
All four running texts use the contrast between a bare commander and host and a shah with inherited resources. Bread that leaves the eater hungry makes the taunt sharper in Persian. The English’s water and absence of steeds are provisional at that verse, which names elephants, throne and baggage. The English then sets ordinary life in Iran against possession of another ruler’s crown. That division makes a political demand out of lists that could otherwise sound merely material. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all portray the shah through inherited kingship, comparison with the moon, and stature above those of other monarchs. The final image of silver teeth in a feast gives the English a personal detail to place beside wealth and sovereign rank.
19–24What royal plenty can buy
Moscow IX322:150 running text, IX322:151 running text, IX322:152 running text, IX322:153,154 running text, IX322:155 running text, IX323:156 running text · Mohl VII222:168 running text, VII222:169 running text, VII222:170 running text, VII222:171,172 running text, VII222:173 running text, VII222:174 running text · Ganjoor sh3:17 running poem body, sh3:18 running poem body, sh3:19 running poem body, sh3:20, sh3:21 running poem body, sh3:22 running poem body, sh3:23 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII422:150 running text, VIII423:151 running text, VIII423:152 running text, VIII423:153,154 running text, VIII423:155 running text, VIII423:156 running text
Moscow IX p.322 · Moscow IX p.323 · Mohl VII p.222 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:17 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:18 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:19 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:20 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:21 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:22 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:23 · Khaleghi VIII p.422 · Khaleghi VIII p.423
In Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh Rostam says that rewarding the heads of the Arab host would scarcely diminish the treasury. The English’s phrasing about buying them keeps the extravagance, which the annual food comparison then tests on everyday terms. The running number covers the royal hunting animals together. English retains the bells, gold and earrings, so the scale is shown through ornament as well as appetite. All four put the cost of feeding hounds and cheetahs beside the negligible account the shah makes of it. That calculation gives the turn to shame and presumption a material foundation. By moving from the ruler’s hunting establishment to a question about Sa’ad’s desire for the throne, the English keeps the boasts inside the letter’s bargaining strategy.
25–30An envoy before an ultimatum
Moscow IX323:157 running text, IX323:158 running text, IX323:159 running text, IX323:160 running text, IX323:161 running text, IX323:162 running text · Mohl VII222:175 running text, VII222:176 running text, VII222:177 running text, VII222:178 running text, VII222:179 running text, VII222:180 running text · Ganjoor sh3:24 running poem body, sh3:25 running poem body, sh3:26 running poem body, sh3:27 running poem body, sh3:28 running poem body, sh3:29 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII423:157 running text, VIII423:158 running text, VIII423:159 running text, VIII423:160 running text, VIII423:161 running text, VIII424:162 running text
Moscow IX p.323 · Mohl VII p.222 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:24 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:25 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:26 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:27 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:28 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:29 · Khaleghi VIII p.423 · Khaleghi VIII p.424
The four running versions leave room for an intermediary if the opposing demand has a proportion and substance. English makes the envoy’s ability to speak and bear a difficult question the emphasis, carrying the experience and valor of the Persian across two lines. The question about who directed Sa’ad to the Kayanian throne then tests the legitimacy of his claim. Rostam’s own offer to send a rider to the king remains conditional on this path of speech. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh then place the warning about war beside praise of Anooshirvan. The English keeps that sequence. Descent gains weight from the ancestor’s justice, with the memorable claim that the old could become young under his rule giving form to what the genealogy is meant to prove.
31–36Who bears the sealed words
Moscow IX323:163 running text, IX323:164 running text, IX323:165 running text, IX323:166 running text, IX323:167 running text, IX323:168 running text · Mohl VII222:181 running text, VII222:182 running text, VII222:183 running text, VII222:184 running text, VII222:185 running text, VII222:186 running text · Ganjoor sh3:30 running poem body, sh3:31 running poem body, sh3:32 running poem body, sh3:33 running poem body, sh3:34 running poem body, sh3:35 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII424:163 running text, VIII424:164 running text, VIII424:165 running text, VIII424:166 running text, VIII424:167 running text, VIII424:168 running text
Moscow IX p.323 · Mohl VII p.222 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:30 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:31 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:32 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:33 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:34 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:35 · Khaleghi VIII p.424
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh keep the appeal to royal ancestry close to the warning against curses. Their language about respect for custom can carry the English address to faith as well as usage. The force of the letter then turns on hearing, sight and judgment. The English makes counsel an active requirement of receiving it, followed by the placing of the actual sealed thing in Pirooz Shapur’s hands. His favorable epithet and the nobles who ride with him characterize the embassy before its armor is described. English draws prominence from making one pair end on the recipient’s standing and the next on the company’s travel. The Persian’s bright-minded companions then supply the hinge to the visible precious materials in the next passage.
37–42Armor meets a cloak
Moscow IX323:168,169 running text, IX323:169 running text, IX324:170 running text, IX324:171 running text, IX324:172 running text, IX324:173 running text · Mohl VII222:186,187 running text, VII222:187 running text, VII222:188 running text, VII223:189 running text, VII223:190 running text, VII223:191 running text · Ganjoor sh3:35, sh3:36 running poem body, sh3:36 running poem body, sh4:1 running poem body, sh4:2 running poem body, sh4:3 running poem body, sh4:4 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII424:168,169 running text, VIII424:169 running text, VIII424:170 running text, VIII424:171 running text, VIII424:172 running text, VIII424:173 running text
Moscow IX p.323 · Moscow IX p.324 · Mohl VII p.222 · Mohl VII p.223 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:35 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §3:36 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:1 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:2 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:3 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:4 · Khaleghi VIII p.424
The English distinguishes the bright spirits of the Persian companions from the brightness of their armor while using the transition common to all four editions. The golden shield and belt keep the entourage legible as a formal embassy. Sa’ad’s party, likened to dust, offers a different display of numbers. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh have the questioning center first on the envoy himself. Mohl’s form also names the troops at this point, a detail that helps the English carry the question from his welfare into the condition of the army. The catalogue of shah, minister, army, commander and country follows. English then narrows the scene to a cloak set out under Pirooz and a pointed assertion about the only companions valuable to Sa’ad’s men.
43–48The shift from speech to reply
Moscow IX324:174 running text, IX324:175 running text, IX324:176,177 running text, IX324:178 running text, IX324:179 running text, IX324:179 running text · IX325:180 running text · Mohl VII223:192 running text, VII223 near v.192 · checked local running gap, VII223:193,194 running text, VII223:195 running text, VII223:196 running text, VII223:196,197 running text · Ganjoor sh4:5 running poem body, sh4:6 running poem body, sh4:7, sh4:8 running poem body, sh4:9 running poem body, sh4:10 running poem body, sh4:10, sh4:11 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII424:174 running text, VIII425:175 (bracketed) running text, VIII425:176,177 running text, VIII425:178 running text, VIII425:179 running text, VIII425:179,180 running text
Moscow IX p.324 · Moscow IX p.325 · Mohl VII p.223 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:5 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:6 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:7 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:8 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:9 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:10 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:11 · Khaleghi VIII p.424 · Khaleghi VIII p.425
Moscow and Ganjoor run Pirooz’s handing over the letter and repeating Rostam’s words. Khaleghi-Motlagh brackets that verse and Mohl goes directly toward the reading. English preserves both the transfer and reception. It then follows Moscow and Ganjoor in making wonder part of the reading of the letter. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh give a different phrasing about the response in the aligned line. Sa’ad’s dislike of boasting about brocade and gold turns into a reply whose catalogue names jinn, human beings and a Hashimite Prophet. All four continue with Oneness, promise, threat and new usages. English groups these into a progression toward pitch, fire and cold, which brings a physical force to the theological distinctions being proposed.
49–54The catalogue and the promised throne
Moscow IX325:180,181 running text, IX325:181 running text, IX325:182 running text, IX325:183 running text, IX325:184 running text, IX325:185 running text · Mohl VII223:197,198 running text, VII223:198 running text, VII223:199 running text, VII223:200 running text, VII223:201 running text, VII223:202 running text · Ganjoor sh4:11, sh4:12 running poem body, sh4:12 running poem body, sh4:13 running poem body, sh4:14 running poem body, sh4:15 running poem body, sh4:16 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII425:180,181 running text, VIII425:181 running text, VIII425:182 running text, VIII426:183 running text, VIII426:184 running text, VIII426:185 running text
Moscow IX p.325 · Mohl VII p.223 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:11 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:12 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:13 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:14 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:15 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:16 · Khaleghi VIII p.425 · Khaleghi VIII p.426
Moscow and Ganjoor name the houris with paradise and the stream of milk. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh give wine in that running line, while the next verse in all four has the broader catalogue with camphor, water, trees and honey. English places milk and wine together and carries the garden’s details across two couplets, making the imagery cumulative. The promise that the shah may have both worlds and retain the crown and earrings is explicit in the witnesses. The throne in the English has additional support in the prose parallel printed by Khaleghi-Motlagh. Muhammad’s intercession and the distinctive distilled-rosewater comparison run together in the four. English follows them with the garden of affliction, using the opposition between reward and the sowing of hate to close the promise.
55–60A kingdom priced against a hair
Moscow IX325:186 running text, IX325:187 running text, IX325:188 running text, IX325:189 running text, IX325:190 running text, IX325 between vv.190–191 · checked local running gap, IX325:191 running text · Mohl VII223:203 running text, VII223:204 running text, VII223:205 running text, VII223:206 running text, VII223:207 running text, VII223:208 running text, VII223:209 running text · Ganjoor sh4:17 running poem body, sh4:18 running poem body, sh4:19 running poem body, sh4:20 running poem body, sh4:21 running poem body, Checked local running gap near §4:21, sh4:22 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII426:186 running text, VIII426:187 running text, VIII426:188 running text, VIII426:189 running text, VIII426:190 running text, VIII426 at v.190 · printed apparatus parallel, VIII426:191 running text
Moscow IX p.325 · Mohl VII p.223 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:17 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:18 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:19 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:20 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:21 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:22 · Khaleghi VIII p.426
All four contrast the person of Yazdegard and the visible size of his domain with a single hair of a heavenly being. The English lets the catalogue run over a couplet boundary, preserving that sharp disproportion as the end of the sentence. The eyes dazzled in a transient world lead to a more concrete inventory of the ivory throne, hawk, cheetah and signet. These are the possessions in which the addressee is said to trust. Mohl inserts a distinct command to think little of the world and keep to the faith after the image of the cold drink. Khaleghi-Motlagh gives a parallel in the apparatus. Moscow and Ganjoor go on to the threat of fighting. English retains the question about sorrowing over what one holds before immediately naming the narrow grave.
61–66A reply acquires a human carrier
Moscow IX326:192 running text, IX326:193 running text, IX326:194 running text · IX326 at v.194 · separate envoy verse in apparatus, IX326:195 running text, IX326:196 running text, IX326:197 running text · Mohl VII223:210 running text, VII223:211 running text, VII223:212 running text, VII223:213 running text, VII224:214 running text, VII224:215 running text · Ganjoor sh4:23 running poem body, sh4:24 running poem body, sh4:25 running poem body, sh4:26 running poem body, sh4:27 running poem body, sh4:28 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII426:192 running text, VIII426:193 running text, VIII427:194,195 running text, VIII427:196 running text, VIII427:197 running text, VIII427:198 running text
Moscow IX p.326 · Mohl VII p.223 · Mohl VII p.224 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:23 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:24 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:25 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:26 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:27 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:28 · Khaleghi VIII p.426 · Khaleghi VIII p.427
The four running sequences counterpose paradise and hell, ask the recipient to choose, and then translate the choice into an actual dispatch with the sealing of the sheet. English separates the decision from the courteous wish and seal, allowing the argument to finish before the envoy enters. Moscow and Ganjoor give Shobae’s declaration about going to Rostam. Mohl’s wording moves to his departure, and Khaleghi-Motlagh also runs an additional envoy verse for which Moscow has an apparatus parallel. In English the volunteer’s own speech makes him responsible for carrying the reply. In the description that reaches Rostam, the torn garment, slender blade and lack of horse stand out. The witnesses include an observation about his eyes that English leaves outside the portrait.
67–72The decorated space of an embassy
Moscow IX326:198 running text, IX326:199 running text, IX326:200 running text, IX326:201 running text, IX326:202,203 running text, IX326:203,204 running text · Mohl VII224:216 running text, VII224:217 running text, VII224:218 running text, VII224:219 running text, VII224:220,221 running text, VII224:221,222 running text · Ganjoor sh4:29 running poem body, sh4:30 running poem body, sh4:31 running poem body, sh4:32 running poem body, sh4:33, sh4:34 running poem body, sh4:34, sh4:35 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII427:199 running text, VIII427:200 running text, VIII427:201 running text, VIII427:202 running text, VIII427:203,204 running text, VIII427:204,205 running text
Moscow IX p.326 · Mohl VII p.224 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:29 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:30 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:31 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:32 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:33 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:34 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:35 · Khaleghi VIII p.427
A brocade pavilion and fabric worked in Chinese gold are common to Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh. English places the fabrics as tent decoration and carpet, giving a spatial arrangement to the materials without turning their appearance into another episode. The crowd arrives like ants and locusts while Rostam’s golden seat sets him apart from it. The witnesses count the Iranians at sixty. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh give lions in the description of these fighters, while Moscow and Ganjoor emphasize mounted or fighting men. The English’s imagery of lions and iron fits the first pair, then lets gold shoes, violet clothing and earrings provide the factual splendor. The separate arrival at the dressed tent makes that entire description the setting for a deliberate act of refusal.
73–78Shobae sits in dust
Moscow IX326:204 running text · IX327:205 running text, IX327:205,206 running text, IX327:206 running text, IX327:207 running text, IX327:208 running text, IX327:209 running text · Mohl VII224:222,223 running text, VII224:223,224 running text, VII224:224 running text, VII224:225 running text, VII224:226 running text, VII224:227 running text · Ganjoor sh4:35, sh4:36 running poem body, sh4:36, sh4:37 running poem body, sh4:37 running poem body, sh4:38 running poem body, sh4:39 running poem body, sh4:40 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII427:205,206 running text, VIII427:206 running text · VIII428:207 running text, VIII428:207 running text, VIII428:208 running text, VIII428:209 running text, VIII428:210 running text
Moscow IX p.326 · Moscow IX p.327 · Mohl VII p.224 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:35 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:36 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:37 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:38 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:39 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:40 · Khaleghi VIII p.427 · Khaleghi VIII p.428
The four running sequences give the envoy’s walking on bare ground, use of his sword for support, and sitting with no special regard for the general. English divides those actions into successive pairs. Refusing the furnished approach first gives meaning to the later refusal to look up, while the cane image keeps his slow progress visible. When Rostam greets him, the courtly wish for a healthy soul and body receives a conditional answer. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh run the phrase for peace if the faith is accepted, and Moscow gives prose support in the notes while its running text and Ganjoor make the ambassador say he would be glad. The English uses the peace form, sharpening the act of offering a condition before the brows and pallor show Rostam’s reaction.
79–84A throne seen or imagined
Moscow IX327:210 running text, IX327:211 running text, IX327:212 running text · IX327 at v.212 · throne and fortune alternatives in apparatus, IX327:213 running text, IX327:214 running text, IX327:215 running text, IX327:216 running text · Mohl VII224:228 running text, VII224:229 running text, VII224:230 running text, VII224:231 running text, VII224:232 running text, VII224:233 running text, VII224:234 running text · first-person variant · Ganjoor sh4:41 running poem body, sh4:42 running poem body, sh4:43 running poem body, sh4:44 running poem body, sh4:45 running poem body, sh4:46 running poem body, sh4:47 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII428:211 running text, VIII428:212 running text, VIII428:213 running text · VIII428 at v.213 · throne and fortune alternatives in apparatus, VIII428:214 running text, VIII428:215 running text, VIII428:216 running text, VIII428:217 running text
Moscow IX p.327 · Mohl VII p.224 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:41 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:42 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:43 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:44 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:45 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:46 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:47 · Khaleghi VIII p.428
The four accounts place the reading between Rostam’s outward anger and what he tells the envoy to say in reply. The denial of royal title is explicit. Mohl then gives the seeing of Rostam’s throne and fortune and points to the desire for his throne that follows. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh have a different first hemistich, with related throne and fortune alternatives in the critical apparatuses. This makes Mohl the nearest running support for the English, although darkening interprets the fortune in that context. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh name a Sasanian crown in the following hypothetical. Mohl uses a more general crown of kings. English preserves the dynasty’s name and carries the debate from qualifications for rule to the unfavorable star and the day of disaster.
85–87The last words before battle
Moscow IX327:217 running text, IX328:218 running text, IX328:219 running text · Mohl VII224:235 running text, VII224:236 running text, VII224:237 running text · Ganjoor sh4:48 running poem body, sh4:49 running poem body, sh4:50 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII428:218 running text, VIII428:219 running text, VIII429:220 running text
Moscow IX p.327 · Moscow IX p.328 · Mohl VII p.224 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:48 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:49 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §4:50 · Khaleghi VIII p.428 · Khaleghi VIII p.429
Before the crooked sphere, Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh each have a verse about the old and new faiths. The pronouns vary, particularly Mohl’s first-person opening. The English proceeds from fortune to the harsh sphere, so that the dispatch ends with the distinction between honorable death and an enemy’s pleasure. The retained order still moves from misfortune to the practical impossibility of more talk when fighting is at hand. The line about going back cheerfully carries the peculiar courtesy of the Persian dismissal even at the point of conflict. All four place the saying about death with a name at the end of this speech. English makes honor carry the value of that name, preparing the transition to Shobae’s return and the battle.
Source record and limits
F&R English
87 published English couplets. Rostam’s dispatch to his brother gives way to the letters between Rostam and Sa’ad and the embassy of Shobae Moghireh.
Moscow
Volume IX, pp. 321–328, vv. 132–219.
Mohl
Volume VII, pp. 221–224, vv. 149–237.
Ganjoor
Yazdegard §2:111–112, §3:1–36 and §4:1–50. The next published chapter opens with Shobae’s return, which has separate evidence in Mohl and the critical apparatuses.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Volume VIII, pp. 421–429, vv. 132–220.
Consequential readings and limits
The published English includes details supported by different witnesses, including Mohl’s conditional greeting of peace and throne and fortune reading. The rein at E10.3.10 and water and absence of steeds at E10.3.14 remain provisional at their aligned verses.
Moscow IX p.321 · Moscow IX p.322 · Moscow IX p.323 · Moscow IX p.324 · Moscow IX p.325 · Moscow IX p.326 · Moscow IX p.327 · Moscow IX p.328
Mohl VII p.221 · Mohl VII p.222 · Mohl VII p.223 · Mohl VII p.224
Khaleghi VIII p.421 · Khaleghi VIII p.422 · Khaleghi VIII p.423 · Khaleghi VIII p.424 · Khaleghi VIII p.425 · Khaleghi VIII p.426 · Khaleghi VIII p.427 · Khaleghi VIII p.428 · Khaleghi VIII p.429
Selected printed readings
- Moscow IX p.321 v.132 · Running text · prior letter · چو نامه به مهر اندر آورد گفت
The dispatch to the brother is still being completed. - Khaleghi VIII p.421 v.135 · Running text · writing surface · یکی نامهیی بر حریر سپید
The next dispatch goes to Sa’ad. - Moscow IX p.322 v.151 · Running text · count of hunting animals · سگ و یوز و بازش ده و دو هزار
The count applies to the three kinds of animals together. - Khaleghi VIII p.425 v.175 · Bracketed running text · delivery · گرانمایه پیروز نامه بداد
Mohl has a checked local gap. - Mohl VII p.223 v.197b · Running text · wine and milk · ز فردوس و جوی می و جوی شیر
Mohl puts wine beside milk, where the Moscow and Ganjoor line names houris. - Khaleghi VIII p.427 v.194 · Running text · intermediary · فرستادهی سعد وقاص رفت
This additional verse precedes the naming of Shobae. - Khaleghi VIII p.427 v.202 · Running text · combatants as lions · سواران و شیران روز نبرد
Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh both give the lion reading. - Mohl VII p.224 v.226b · Running text · conditional peace · اگر دین پذیری علیک السلام
Khaleghi-Motlagh has a corresponding running line. - Mohl VII p.224 v.230a · Running text · throne and fortune · بدیدی سر تخت و بخت مرا
The other main sequences differ, with variants in the critical apparatuses.
E10.3 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IX321:132 running text | VII221:149 running text |
| 2 | IX321:133 running text | VII221:150 running text |
| 3 | IX321:134 running text | VII221:151 running text |
| 4 | IX321:135 running text | VII221:152 running text |
| 5 | IX321:136 running text | VII221:153 running text |
| 6 | IX321:137 running text | VII221:154 running text |
| 7 | IX321:138,139 running text | VII221:155,156 running text |
| 8 | IX321:139 running text | VII221:156 running text |
| 9 | IX321:140 running text | VII221:157 running text |
| 10 | IX321:141 running text | VII221:159 running text |
| 11 | IX321:142 running text | VII221:160 running text |
| 12 | IX321:143 running text | VII221:161 running text |
| 13 | IX322:144 running text | VII221:162 running text |
| 14 | IX322:145 running text | VII221:163 running text |
| 15 | IX322:146 running text | VII221:164 running text |
| 16 | IX322:147 running text | VII221:165 running text |
| 17 | IX322:148 running text | VII222:166 running text |
| 18 | IX322:149 running text | VII222:167 running text |
| 19 | IX322:150 running text | VII222:168 running text |
| 20 | IX322:151 running text | VII222:169 running text |
| 21 | IX322:152 running text | VII222:170 running text |
| 22 | IX322:153,154 running text | VII222:171,172 running text |
| 23 | IX322:155 running text | VII222:173 running text |
| 24 | IX323:156 running text | VII222:174 running text |
| 25 | IX323:157 running text | VII222:175 running text |
| 26 | IX323:158 running text | VII222:176 running text |
| 27 | IX323:159 running text | VII222:177 running text |
| 28 | IX323:160 running text | VII222:178 running text |
| 29 | IX323:161 running text | VII222:179 running text |
| 30 | IX323:162 running text | VII222:180 running text |
| 31 | IX323:163 running text | VII222:181 running text |
| 32 | IX323:164 running text | VII222:182 running text |
| 33 | IX323:165 running text | VII222:183 running text |
| 34 | IX323:166 running text | VII222:184 running text |
| 35 | IX323:167 running text | VII222:185 running text |
| 36 | IX323:168 running text | VII222:186 running text |
| 37 | IX323:168,169 running text | VII222:186,187 running text |
| 38 | IX323:169 running text | VII222:187 running text |
| 39 | IX324:170 running text | VII222:188 running text |
| 40 | IX324:171 running text | VII223:189 running text |
| 41 | IX324:172 running text | VII223:190 running text |
| 42 | IX324:173 running text | VII223:191 running text |
| 43 | IX324:174 running text | VII223:192 running text |
| 44 | IX324:175 running text | VII223 near v.192 · checked local running gap |
| 45 | IX324:176,177 running text | VII223:193,194 running text |
| 46 | IX324:178 running text | VII223:195 running text |
| 47 | IX324:179 running text | VII223:196 running text |
| 48 | IX324:179 running text · IX325:180 running text · IX p.325 | VII223:196,197 running text |
| 49 | IX325:180,181 running text | VII223:197,198 running text |
| 50 | IX325:181 running text | VII223:198 running text |
| 51 | IX325:182 running text | VII223:199 running text |
| 52 | IX325:183 running text | VII223:200 running text |
| 53 | IX325:184 running text | VII223:201 running text |
| 54 | IX325:185 running text | VII223:202 running text |
| 55 | IX325:186 running text | VII223:203 running text |
| 56 | IX325:187 running text | VII223:204 running text |
| 57 | IX325:188 running text | VII223:205 running text |
| 58 | IX325:189 running text | VII223:206 running text |
| 59 | IX325:190 running text | VII223:207 running text |
| 60 | IX325:191 running text | VII223:209 running text |
| 61 | IX326:192 running text | VII223:210 running text |
| 62 | IX326:193 running text | VII223:211 running text |
| 63 | IX326:194 running text · IX326 at v.194 · separate envoy verse in apparatus | VII223:212 running text |
| 64 | IX326:195 running text | VII223:213 running text |
| 65 | IX326:196 running text | VII224:214 running text |
| 66 | IX326:197 running text | VII224:215 running text |
| 67 | IX326:198 running text | VII224:216 running text |
| 68 | IX326:199 running text | VII224:217 running text |
| 69 | IX326:200 running text | VII224:218 running text |
| 70 | IX326:201 running text | VII224:219 running text |
| 71 | IX326:202,203 running text | VII224:220,221 running text |
| 72 | IX326:203,204 running text | VII224:221,222 running text |
| 73 | IX326:204 running text · IX327:205 running text · IX p.327 | VII224:222,223 running text |
| 74 | IX327:205,206 running text | VII224:223,224 running text |
| 75 | IX327:206 running text | VII224:224 running text |
| 76 | IX327:207 running text | VII224:225 running text |
| 77 | IX327:208 running text | VII224:226 running text |
| 78 | IX327:209 running text | VII224:227 running text |
| 79 | IX327:210 running text | VII224:228 running text |
| 80 | IX327:211 running text | VII224:229 running text |
| 81 | IX327:212 running text · IX327 at v.212 · throne and fortune alternatives in apparatus | VII224:230 running text |
| 82 | IX327:213 running text | VII224:231 running text |
| 83 | IX327:214 running text | VII224:232 running text |
| 84 | IX327:215 running text | VII224:233 running text |
| 85 | IX327:217 running text | VII224:235 running text |
| 86 | IX328:218 running text | VII224:236 running text |
| 87 | IX328:219 running text | VII224:237 running text |
New Naqqali