Rostam Battles Sa’ad and Is Slain
35 published English couplets. Shobae returns to Sa’ad. The battle turns on thirst and the combat of the two commanders. The fugitives reach Yazdegard, and Farrokhzad leads a further sortie.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 35 published English couplets. Shobae returns to Sa’ad. The battle turns on thirst and the combat of the two commanders. The fugitives reach Yazdegard, and Farrokhzad leads a further sortie. |
| Moscow | Volume IX, pp. 328–332, vv. 220–250. |
| Mohl | Volume VII, pp. 224–226, vv. 238–276. |
| Ganjoor | Yazdegard §5:1–28 and §6:1–3, with Mohl’s added opening lines. The next published chapter opens on §6:4. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | Volume VIII, pp. 429–433, vv. 221–253. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The messenger and the two arrays
Moscow IX328 near v.220 · checked local running gap · IX328 after v.219 · return in printed apparatus, IX328:220 running text · IX328 after v.219 · mobilization in printed apparatus, IX328:220,221 running text, IX328:221 running text, IX328 near v.221 · checked local running gap · IX328 at v.221 · parallel in printed apparatus · Mohl VII224:238 running text, VII225:239,240 running text, VII225:240,241 running text, VII225:241 running text, VII225:242,243 running text, VII225:244 running text · Ganjoor Checked local running gap near §5:1, sh5:1 running poem body, sh5:1, sh5:2 running poem body, sh5:2 running poem body, Checked local running gap near §5:2 · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII429 near v.221 · checked local running gap · VIII429 after v.220 · return in printed apparatus, VIII429:221 running text · VIII429 after v.220 · mobilization in printed apparatus, VIII429:221,222 running text, VIII429:222 running text, VIII429 near v.222 · checked local running gap · VIII429 at v.222 · parallel in printed apparatus
Moscow IX p.328 · Mohl VII p.224 · Mohl VII p.225 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:1 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:2 · Khaleghi VIII p.429
Ganjoor starts the battle with the sounding of the instrument, as the Moscow and Khaleghi-Motlagh running passages do. Their apparatuses print related verses about Shobae’s return, the orders and the joining of the hosts. Mohl places one wind-swift return verse at the close of the exchange and gives the preparation, report and meeting in the following running battle passage. The English draws on these fuller materials and divides the return from its reported effect, with the order and thunderous report occurring in separate pairs. The sea-like motion and deafening din remain vivid from the main sequence in all four. English lets that motion come to a halt as the armies place their feet, a contrast the Mohl fighting line makes explicit.
7–12A glint against lapis and an army without water
Moscow IX328:222 running text, IX328:223,224 running text, IX328:224 running text · IX328 at v.224 · water in printed variants · IX329 upper apparatus · armor parallel, IX329:225 running text, IX329:226 running text, IX329:227 running text · Mohl VII225:245 running text, VII225:246,247 running text, VII225:247,248 running text, VII225:249 running text, VII225:250 running text, VII225:251 running text · Ganjoor sh5:3 running poem body, sh5:4, sh5:5 running poem body, sh5:5 running poem body, sh5:6 running poem body, sh5:7 running poem body, sh5:8 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII429:223 running text, VIII429:224,225 running text, VIII429:225 running text · VIII430:226 running text · VIII429:225 water · VIII430:226 heavy armor, VIII430:227 running text, VIII430:228 running text, VIII430:229 running text
Moscow IX p.328 · Moscow IX p.329 · Mohl VII p.225 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:3 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:4 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:5 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:6 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:7 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:8 · Khaleghi VIII p.429 · Khaleghi VIII p.430
Moscow and Ganjoor compare brilliant lances with fire beyond a lapis veil. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh give a star against lapis, closer to the English’s stars across the night. The English keeps the dark view by putting both the leaden dust and the sudden light within a single pair. Spear points fail against helmets and the struggle lasts three days in all four. The shortage of water and burden of heavy gear run in Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh, with related materials in Moscow’s apparatus. Ganjoor moves directly from the duration to the men and horses exhausted with thirst. English gives the battle’s effect a sequence from supplies and equipment to Rostam’s mouth, then to people and horses eating moist clay, a detail common to the four running accounts.
13–18Two armies give way to two men
Moscow IX329 near v.227 · checked local running gap · IX329 at v.227 · casualty report in printed apparatus, IX329:228 running text, IX329:229 running text, IX329:230,231 running text, IX329:232 running text, IX329:232,233 running text · Mohl VII225:252 running text, VII225:253 running text, VII225:254 running text, VII225:255,256 running text, VII225:257 running text, VII225:257,258 running text · Ganjoor Checked local running gap near §5:8, sh5:9 running poem body, sh5:10 running poem body, sh5:11, sh5:12 running poem body, sh5:13 running poem body, sh5:13, sh5:14 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII430 near v.229 · checked local running gap · VIII430 at v.229 · casualty report in printed apparatus, VIII430:230 running text, VIII430:231 running text, VIII430:232,233 running text, VIII430:234 running text, VIII430:234,235 running text
Moscow IX p.329 · Mohl VII p.225 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:8 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:9 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:10 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:11 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:12 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:13 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:14 · Khaleghi VIII p.430
The sight of fallen chiefs before the duel is explicit in Mohl, with parallels in the apparatuses of Moscow and Khaleghi-Motlagh. Ganjoor takes the troops from the thirst directly into the noise from both commanders. The English retains the pause over the fallen before matching the two voices and having both chiefs draw out from the center. At their place of encounter Moscow and Ganjoor give a tall cypress. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh give a steep height, which the English makes rocky and shadowed. The shared thunder comparison then moves from both sides to Rostam’s own shout. The attack on the horse and its headlong fall separate man from mount, and English makes that distinction visible across its paired lines.
19–24A fight the dust hides
Moscow IX329:234 running text, IX329:235 running text, IX330:236 running text, IX330:236,237 running text, IX330:237,238 running text, IX330:239 running text · Mohl VII225:259 running text, VII225:260 running text, VII225:261 running text, VII225:261 running text · VII226:262 running text, VII226:262,263 running text, VII226:264 running text · Ganjoor sh5:15 running poem body, sh5:16 running poem body, sh5:17 running poem body, sh5:17, sh5:18 running poem body, sh5:18, sh5:19 running poem body, sh5:20 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII430:236 running text, VIII430:237 running text, VIII431:238 running text, VIII431:238,239 running text, VIII431:239,240 running text, VIII431:241 running text
Moscow IX p.329 · Moscow IX p.330 · Mohl VII p.225 · Mohl VII p.226 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:15 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:16 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:17 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:18 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:19 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:20 · Khaleghi VIII p.430 · Khaleghi VIII p.431
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh run the raised sharp sword and the image of resurrection, which gives the English day of Doom its scale. The next action is knowledge withheld by dust. The English renders the intention to strike off the head before the mutual loss of sight and then gives the dismount its own couplet. The halter and waist make the resulting position clearer. The first obscurity is caused by dust. When Sa’ad strikes the helmet and blood reaches Rostam’s face, the loss of sight becomes personal rather than general. English follows that ordering from the four running texts. Keeping both causes distinct matters because the narrative turns on how the fighter who had the initiative can become unable to see his opponent.
25–30The armies discover what has happened
Moscow IX330:240 running text, IX330:241 running text, IX330:242 running text, IX330 after v.242 · IX394 Appendix XV vv.1–5, IX330:243 running text, IX331:244,245 running text, IX331:245 running text, IX331 after v.245 · printed apparatus parallels on losses · Mohl VII226:265 running text, VII226:266 running text, VII226:267 running text, VII226 after v.267 · checked local running gap for the five-verse passage, VII226:268 running text, VII226:269,270 running text, VII226:270 running text, VII226:271 running text · Ganjoor sh5:21 running poem body, sh5:22 running poem body, sh5:23 running poem body, Checked local running gap near §5:23, sh5:24 running poem body, sh5:25, sh5:26 running poem body, sh5:26 running poem body, Checked local running gap near §5:26 · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII431:242 running text, VIII431:243 running text, VIII431:244 running text, VIII431 at v.245 · five-verse apparatus parallel, VIII431:245 running text, VIII431:246 running text · VIII432:247 running text, VIII432:247 running text, VIII432 at v.247 · casualty variants in apparatus
Moscow IX p.330 · Moscow IX p.331 · Moscow IX p.394 · Mohl VII p.226 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:21 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:22 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:23 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:24 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:25 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:26 · Khaleghi VIII p.431 · Khaleghi VIII p.432
The four running texts throw Rostam to the ground after the further strike. The word paired with the neck varies between the upper body and the head or top, and the English gives chest and neck. The lack of knowledge in both armies then makes the search necessary. English keeps the discovery at a distance before describing the wounds. Moscow Appendix XV and the Khaleghi-Motlagh apparatus print a further Iranian attack near this point. Mohl and Ganjoor keep the direct path to the discovery there. Mohl later adds a separate casualty verse, which English leaves outside the movement from flight to exhaustion. All four count a measure of kings as full. The stilled bodies explicitly seen by survivors remain provisional as a reading of this measure, although the surrounding account gives abundant deaths.
31–35From Kadisiya toward another battle
Moscow IX331:246 running text, IX331:247 running text, IX331 after v.247 · printed apparatus parallel, IX332:248 running text, IX332:249 running text, IX332:250 running text · Mohl VII226:272 running text, VII226:273 running text, VII226 after v.273 · checked local running gap, VII226:274 running text, VII226:275 running text, VII226:276 running text · Ganjoor sh5:27 running poem body, sh5:28 running poem body, Checked local running gap near §5:28, sh6:1 running poem body, sh6:2 running poem body, sh6:3 running poem body · Khaleghi-Motlagh VIII432:248 running text, VIII432:249 running text, VIII432:250 running text, VIII432:251 running text, VIII433:252 running text, VIII433:253 running text
Moscow IX p.331 · Moscow IX p.332 · Mohl VII p.226 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:27 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §5:28 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §6:1 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §6:2 · Ganjoor Yazdegard §6:3 · Khaleghi VIII p.432 · Khaleghi VIII p.433
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh bring the fleeing force to Yazdegard in Baghdad with day and night marking the urgency. English turns those times into unbroken movement before changing the subject to Farrokhzad. Khaleghi-Motlagh runs an additional line about both sides entering Karkh after the gathering, with a Moscow apparatus parallel. Mohl and Ganjoor pass to Farrokhzad’s arrival from or into the Arvand, as does Moscow’s main sequence. The English chooses from and marks the change in agency with Farrokhzad’s tears and anger. The charge in Karkh and movement out to the plain are then given in all four. English adds the shield as the image of resistance and ends this chapter with the fresh sortie. The dust and Iranian defeat consequently open the next published chapter.
Source record and limits
F&R English
35 published English couplets. Shobae returns to Sa’ad. The battle turns on thirst and the combat of the two commanders. The fugitives reach Yazdegard, and Farrokhzad leads a further sortie.
Moscow
Volume IX, pp. 328–332, vv. 220–250.
Mohl
Volume VII, pp. 224–226, vv. 238–276.
Ganjoor
Yazdegard §5:1–28 and §6:1–3, with Mohl’s added opening lines. The next published chapter opens on §6:4.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Volume VIII, pp. 429–433, vv. 221–253.
Consequential readings and limits
The narration follows Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh in giving the steep height. Moscow and Ganjoor give a tall cypress. The surviving men seeing stilled bodies at E10.4.30 remains provisional.
Moscow IX p.328 · Moscow IX p.329 · Moscow IX p.330 · Moscow IX p.331 · Moscow IX p.332 · Moscow IX p.394
Mohl VII p.224 · Mohl VII p.225 · Mohl VII p.226
Khaleghi VIII p.429 · Khaleghi VIII p.430 · Khaleghi VIII p.431 · Khaleghi VIII p.432 · Khaleghi VIII p.433
Selected printed readings
- Mohl VII p.224 v.238 · Running text · Shobae’s return · تو گفتی که با باد همباز گشت
The swift return appears before the new battle heading. - Mohl VII p.225 vv.242–243 · Running text · report and order · چو شعبه بیامد بنزدیک سعد
The critical editions print parallels below their main texts. - Khaleghi VIII p.429 v.225b · Running text · water · بر ایرانیان بر ببود آب تنگ
Mohl has the water shortage too. Moscow records variants in the apparatus. - Mohl VII p.225 v.252b · Running text · chiefs killed · سر نامداران همه کشته دید
The parallel is printed in the apparatuses of the critical editions. - Khaleghi VIII p.430 v.232b · Running text · high ground · به زیر یکی تند بالا شدند
Mohl gives the steep place as well. Moscow and Ganjoor give the cypress. - Moscow IX p.329 v.230b · Running text · cypress · به زیر یکی سرو بالا شدند
The printed Moscow reading places the duel beneath a cypress. - Moscow IX p.394 Appendix XV v.1 · Appendix · further advance · یکی حمله بردند ایرانیان
The alternative narrative briefly returns to the armies before reporting the discovery. - Khaleghi VIII p.432 v.247b · Running text · full measure · پر آمد ز شاهان جهان را قفیز
Qafiz gives a concrete measure for the world’s capacity.
E10.4 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IX328 near v.220 · checked local running gap · IX328 after v.219 · return in printed apparatus | VII224:238 running text |
| 2 | IX328:220 running text · IX328 after v.219 · mobilization in printed apparatus | VII225:239,240 running text |
| 3 | IX328:220,221 running text | VII225:240,241 running text |
| 4 | IX328:221 running text | VII225:241 running text |
| 5 | IX328 near v.221 · checked local running gap · IX328 at v.221 · parallel in printed apparatus | VII225:242,243 running text |
| 6 | IX328 near v.221 · checked local running gap · IX328 at v.221 · parallel in printed apparatus | VII225:244 running text |
| 7 | IX328:222 running text | VII225:245 running text |
| 8 | IX328:223,224 running text | VII225:246,247 running text |
| 9 | IX328:224 running text · IX328 at v.224 · water in printed variants · IX329 upper apparatus · armor parallel · IX p.329 | VII225:247,248 running text |
| 10 | IX329:225 running text | VII225:249 running text |
| 11 | IX329:226 running text | VII225:250 running text |
| 12 | IX329:227 running text | VII225:251 running text |
| 13 | IX329 near v.227 · checked local running gap · IX329 at v.227 · casualty report in printed apparatus | VII225:252 running text |
| 14 | IX329:228 running text | VII225:253 running text |
| 15 | IX329:229 running text | VII225:254 running text |
| 16 | IX329:230,231 running text | VII225:255,256 running text |
| 17 | IX329:232 running text | VII225:257 running text |
| 18 | IX329:232,233 running text | VII225:257,258 running text |
| 19 | IX329:234 running text | VII225:259 running text |
| 20 | IX329:235 running text | VII225:260 running text |
| 21 | IX330:236 running text | VII225:261 running text |
| 22 | IX330:236,237 running text | VII225:261 running text · VII226:262 running text · VII p.226 |
| 23 | IX330:237,238 running text | VII226:262,263 running text |
| 24 | IX330:239 running text | VII226:264 running text |
| 25 | IX330:240 running text | VII226:265 running text |
| 26 | IX330:241 running text | VII226:266 running text |
| 27 | IX330:242 running text | VII226:267 running text |
| 28 | IX330:243 running text | VII226:268 running text |
| 29 | IX331:244,245 running text | VII226:269,270 running text |
| 30 | IX331:245 running text | VII226:270 running text |
| 31 | IX331:246 running text | VII226:272 running text |
| 32 | IX331:247 running text | VII226:273 running text |
| 33 | IX332:248 running text | VII226:274 running text |
| 34 | IX332:249 running text | VII226:275 running text |
| 35 | IX332:250 running text | VII226:276 running text |
New Naqqali