Bozorgmehr Answers Chess with Nard
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Drawing a second game out of thought
Moscow — VIII211:2712 running, VIII211:2713 running; VIII211 note 4 after v.2714 actual apparatus, VIII211:2713 checked local gap, VIII211:2714 running, VIII211:2715 running · Mohl — VI196:2786 running, VI197:2790 running; VI197:2791 running, VI197:2788 running; VI197:2789 running, VI197:2787 running; VI197:2792 running, VI197:2793 running · Ganjoor — sh63:85 running, sh63:86 running, Checked local gap after sh63:86, sh63:87 running, sh63:88 running · Khaleghi — VII311:2749 running, VII311:2750 running; VII311 note 6 to v.2749 actual apparatus, VII311:2750 checked local gap, VII311:2751 running; VII311 note 6 after v.2749 actual apparatus, VII311:2752 running
Moscow VIII p.211 · Mohl VI p.196 · Mohl VI p.197 · Ganjoor sh63:85 · Ganjoor sh63:86 · Ganjoor sh63:87 · Ganjoor sh63:88 · Khaleghi VII p.311
The initial board and compass give the invented game a tangible beginning. Moscow and Ganjoor then move through the examination of chess to wisdom and the bright heart joining forces. Mohl runs an expanded sequence of reflection, ambition to invent and the dark place that sharpens thought. Khaleghi and Moscow print the dark-place verse as apparatus, and Khaleghi also records an extra reflection. The English exploits the contrast between that darkness and bringing nard to light. The witnesses’ two ivory pieces give a textual anchor for dice, while the English supplies the cubic shape, the generic bone and the thirty dark and light counters.
7–12The camp and its local advantage
Moscow — VIII211:2718 running, VIII211:2717 running, VIII211:2716 running; VIII211:2718 running; VIII211:2720 running, VIII211:2719 running, VIII211:2720 running, VIII211:2721 running · Mohl — VI197:2796 running, VI197:2795 running, VI197:2794 running; VI197:2796 running; VI197:2798 running, VI197:2797 running, VI197:2798 running, VI197:2801 running · Ganjoor — sh63:91 running, sh63:90 running, sh63:89, sh63:91, sh63:93 running, sh63:92 running, sh63:93 running, sh63:94 running · Khaleghi — VII311:2755 running, VII311:2754 running, VII311:2753 running; VII311:2755 running; VII312:2757 running, VII311:2756 running, VII312:2757 running, VII312:2758 running
Moscow VIII p.211 · Mohl VI p.197 · Ganjoor sh63:91 · Ganjoor sh63:90 · Ganjoor sh63:89 · Ganjoor sh63:93 · Ganjoor sh63:92 · Ganjoor sh63:94 · Khaleghi VII p.311 · Khaleghi VII p.312
All four give a divided army, an earth-like four-sided camp and the conflict of two opposing powers. The shared army count is eight divisions. The English reinterprets the spatial design in terms of four seasons and twelve months and lays twelve points on either side. It translates the two-against-one encounter as a condition for taking a lone piece, which brings the military description close to actual play. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi place that encounter before the roaming armies. Mohl places it after them. English uses the rule early to keep the power of the individual pieces intelligible.
13–18Human choice and the wheel of fate
Moscow — VIII211:2721 checked local gap, VIII211:2722 running; VIII211:2723 running; VIII211:2724 running, VIII211:2725 running, VIII212:2727 running; VIII212:2728 running · Mohl — VI197:2801 checked local gap, VI197:2799 running; VI197:2800 running; VI197:2802 running, VI197:2803 running, VI197:2804 running; VI197:2805 running · Ganjoor — Checked local gap after sh63:94, sh63:95, sh63:96, sh63:97 running, sh63:98 running, sh63:100, sh63:101 running · Khaleghi — VII312:2758 checked local gap, VII312:2759 running; VII312:2760 running; VII312:2761 running, VII312:2762 running, VII312:2764 running; VII312:2765 running
Moscow VIII p.211 · Moscow VIII p.212 · Mohl VI p.197 · Ganjoor sh63:94 · Ganjoor sh63:95 · Ganjoor sh63:96 · Ganjoor sh63:97 · Ganjoor sh63:98 · Ganjoor sh63:100 · Ganjoor sh63:101 · Khaleghi VII p.312
English gives the dice a will and then defines chess by foresight and nard by the limits of human control. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi use the rolling battle and the eventual assembly of armies in this passage. The wheel of fate and the explicit comparison of the games’ philosophies have no separate running verses there. The English addition makes nard readable as a model of contingency and gives a reason for this invention to follow chess. The renewed mention of the armies and the presentation to the Shah returns the expanded analogy to the visible objects on the board.
19–24Royal criticism gives way to a caravan
Moscow — VIII211:2726 running, VIII212:2729 running, VIII212:2730 running, VIII212:2731 running, VIII212:2731 running; VIII212:2732 running, VIII212:2733 running · Mohl — VI197:2806 running, VI197:2807 running, VI197:2808 running, VI197:2809 running, VI197:2809 running; VI197:2810 running, VI197:2811 running · Ganjoor — sh63:99 running, sh63:102 running, sh63:103 running, sh63:104 running, sh63:104, sh63:105 running, sh63:106 running · Khaleghi — VII312:2763 running, VII312:2766 running, VII312:2767 running, VII312:2768 running, VII312:2768 running; VII312:2769 running, VII313:2770 running
Moscow VIII p.211 · Moscow VIII p.212 · Mohl VI p.197 · Ganjoor sh63:99 · Ganjoor sh63:102 · Ganjoor sh63:103 · Ganjoor sh63:104 · Ganjoor sh63:105 · Ganjoor sh63:106 · Khaleghi VII p.312 · Khaleghi VII p.313
The Shah’s praise and reproach stand before the demonstration in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Mohl places them after the demonstration and the Shah’s wonder. English follows that later position, making “now with praise, and now with blame” sound like deliberation on what the king has just seen. The warm wish for the sage’s enduring youth then ends the moment of debate. All four give the sudden order for two thousand camels and the broad geographical inventory. The arrangement across two English couplets makes Iran’s treasury intelligible as a contributor to the shipment, with the domains furnishing its variety.
25–30What the royal letter carries
Moscow — VIII212:2734 running, VIII212:2734 running; VIII212:2735 running, VIII212:2735 running, VIII212:2736 running, VIII212:2737 running, VIII212:2738 running · Mohl — VI198:2812 running, VI198:2812 running; VI198:2813 running, VI198:2813 running, VI198:2814 running, VI198:2815 running, VI198:2816 running · Ganjoor — sh63:107 running, sh63:107, sh63:108 running, sh63:108 running, sh63:109 running, sh63:110 running, sh63:111 running · Khaleghi — VII313:2771 running, VII313:2771 running; VII313:2772 running, VII313:2772 running, VII313:2773 running, VII313:2774 running, VII313:2775 running
Moscow VIII p.212 · Mohl VI p.198 · Ganjoor sh63:107 · Ganjoor sh63:108 · Ganjoor sh63:109 · Ganjoor sh63:110 · Ganjoor sh63:111 · Khaleghi VII p.313
The sequence moves from care over loading to calling the envoy, speaking of wisdom and writing to the Raja. Moscow and Ganjoor fill the letter with wisdom, ease, color and fragrance. Mohl and Khaleghi bring intelligence and counsel into the list, and the English takes its balance and grace from this more courtly verbal register. The invocation of Yazdan and protection from the Div are directly shared. The English salutation reverses the endpoints of the Persian phrase on Ghanooj and Sind, keeping both names while adapting the shape of royal address to the English line.
31–36Chess returned in another form
Moscow — VIII212:2739 running, VIII212:2739 running; VIII212:2740 running, VIII212:2741 running, VIII212:2742 running, VIII212:2743 running, VIII212:2744 running · Mohl — VI198:2817 running, VI198:2817 running; VI198:2818 running, VI198:2819 running, VI198:2820 running, VI198:2821 running, VI198:2822 running · Ganjoor — sh63:112 running, sh63:112, sh63:113 running, sh63:114 running, sh63:115 running, sh63:116 running, sh63:117 running · Khaleghi — VII313:2776 running, VII313:2776 running; VII313:2777 running, VII313:2778 running, VII313:2779 running, VII313:2780 running, VII313:2781 running
Moscow VIII p.212 · Mohl VI p.198 · Ganjoor sh63:112 · Ganjoor sh63:113 · Ganjoor sh63:114 · Ganjoor sh63:115 · Ganjoor sh63:116 · Ganjoor sh63:117 · Khaleghi VII p.313
The letter restates the incoming challenge in a form recognizably answered. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give the request for time, the clear-minded Mobad’s inquiry and the decision to put nard in the place of chess. The English strengthens the religious color with “holy,” where the Persian in context praises the purity of the adviser’s judgment. Its “found its seed” gives the search an organic image in the service of rhyme. Calling the arrival a “challenge hard” spells out what the substitution of games and the gathering of the two thousand loads already imply.
37–42The two possible destinations of the goods
Moscow — VIII213:2745 running, VIII213:2746 running, VIII213:2747 running, VIII213:2748 running, VIII213:2748 running; VIII213:2749 running, VIII213:2749 running · Mohl — VI198:2823 running, VI198:2824 running, VI198:2825 running, VI198:2826 running, VI198:2826 running; VI198:2827 running, VI198:2827 running · Ganjoor — sh63:118 running, sh63:119 running, sh63:120 running, sh63:121 running, sh63:121, sh63:122 running, sh63:122 running · Khaleghi — VII314:2782 running, VII314:2783 running, VII314:2784 running, VII314:2785 running, VII314:2785 running; VII314:2786 running, VII314:2786 running
Moscow VIII p.213 · Mohl VI p.198 · Ganjoor sh63:118 · Ganjoor sh63:119 · Ganjoor sh63:120 · Ganjoor sh63:121 · Ganjoor sh63:122 · Khaleghi VII p.314
The Raja is allowed to keep the Persian cargo if his own wise men find the game. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi then specify an equal number of loaded animals from Ghanooj to accompany the Persian loads if its counselors fail. The English makes each branch explicit and makes “pact” and “bargain” do separate work, capturing both the pledged condition and the proposed exchange. Its phrasing about “keeping” the loads interprets the instruction to transfer them into the Raja’s treasury. The extra closing injunction to let wisdom judge clarifies the standard of proof with the story’s governing word.
43–48Greeting, letter and spoken message
Moscow — VIII213:2750 running, VIII213:2752 running, VIII213:2751 running, VIII213:2753 running, VIII213:2754 running, VIII213:2756 running · Mohl — VI198:2828 running, VI198:2829 running, VI198:2830 running, VI198:2831 running, VI198:2832 running, VI198:2833 running · Ganjoor — sh63:123 running, sh63:125 running, sh63:124 running, sh63:126 running, sh63:127 running, sh63:129 running · Khaleghi — VII314:2787 running, VII314:2788 running, VII314:2789 running, VII314:2790 running, VII314:2791 running, VII314:2792 running
Moscow VIII p.213 · Mohl VI p.198 · Ganjoor sh63:123 · Ganjoor sh63:125 · Ganjoor sh63:124 · Ganjoor sh63:126 · Ganjoor sh63:127 · Ganjoor sh63:129 · Khaleghi VII p.314
The departure at sunrise is shared. Moscow and Ganjoor mention the Brahman’s guidance before the cargo, letter and board. Mohl and Khaleghi reverse those lines, which gives the English sequence its clean departure, baggage and arrival. “Watchful and on guard” turns the Persian’s sense of honor, shame and contest into a visible demeanor. At the throne all four give the praise in Pahlavi and the presentation of the royal letter. English then gives the oral message its own couplet. The three actions show the different roles of courtly greeting, written authority and the explanation an envoy delivers in person.
49–54From a flowering face to the terms
Moscow — VIII213:2756 running, VIII213:2755 running, VIII213:2758 running, VIII213:2757 running, VIII213:2759 running · Mohl — VI198:2833 running, VI198:2834 running, VI198:2835 running, VI198:2836 running, VI199:2837 running · Ganjoor — sh63:129 running, sh63:128 running, sh63:131 running, sh63:130 running, sh63:132 running · Khaleghi — VII314:2792 running, VII315:2793 running, VII315:2794 running, VII315:2795 running, VII315:2796 running
Moscow VIII p.213 · Mohl VI p.198 · Mohl VI p.199 · Ganjoor sh63:129 · Ganjoor sh63:128 · Ganjoor sh63:131 · Ganjoor sh63:130 · Ganjoor sh63:132 · Khaleghi VII p.314 · Khaleghi VII p.315
The Indian ruler’s face opens like a flower when the message arrives. Moscow and Ganjoor have the fuller chess report ahead of that reaction and place the recollection about nard before the details of counseling and play. Mohl and Khaleghi put the flowering face first, then the report and the later recollection. English adopts that latter arrangement and gives its early pleasure time to register before the next change of face. It expands the inventory of chess, exertion and loads into stakes and expected gains. The Persian instruction to read and remain just becomes a direct injunction to keep the pact.
55–60Courtesy while the answer is sought
Moscow — VIII213:2760 running, VIII213:2761 running, VIII214:2762 running, VIII214:2763 running, VIII214:2764 running, VIII214:2765 running · Mohl — VI199:2838 running, VI199:2839 running, VI199:2840 running, VI199:2841 running, VI199:2842 running, VI199:2843 running · Ganjoor — sh63:133 running, sh63:134 running, sh63:135 running, sh63:136 running, sh63:137 running, sh63:138 running · Khaleghi — VII315:2797 running, VII315:2798 running, VII315:2799 running, VII315:2800 running, VII315:2801 running, VII315:2802 running
Moscow VIII p.213 · Moscow VIII p.214 · Mohl VI p.199 · Ganjoor sh63:133 · Ganjoor sh63:134 · Ganjoor sh63:135 · Ganjoor sh63:136 · Ganjoor sh63:137 · Ganjoor sh63:138 · Khaleghi VII p.315
The Raja’s pallor makes the combined news of chess and nard legible as a reversal. The four running accounts then provide an official, suitable lodging, a pleasant hall and music and wine. English retains that restraint in host and guest relations, and the gracious welcome strengthens it. The week is the same span the Shah earlier claimed, so the resumed conference gives the test its symmetrical timetable. The Persian selects young and old for their aptitude. English’s emphasis on elders at the summons narrows that picture and then names shrewdness as the qualification used for the week’s scrutiny.
61–66The eighth and the ninth days
Moscow — VIII214:2766 running, VIII214:2767 running, VIII214:2768 running, VIII214:2771 running, VIII214:2769 running, VIII214:2770 running · Mohl — VI199:2844 running, VI199:2845 running, VI199:2846 running, VI199:2849 running, VI199:2847 running, VI199:2848 running · Ganjoor — sh63:139 running, sh63:140 running, sh63:141 running, sh63:144 running, sh63:142 running, sh63:143 running · Khaleghi — VII315:2803 running, VII315:2804 running, VII315:2805 running, VII316:2808 running, VII316:2806 running, VII316:2807 running
Moscow VIII p.214 · Mohl VI p.199 · Ganjoor sh63:139 · Ganjoor sh63:140 · Ganjoor sh63:141 · Ganjoor sh63:144 · Ganjoor sh63:142 · Ganjoor sh63:143 · Khaleghi VII p.315 · Khaleghi VII p.316
The eighth-day acknowledgment of failure and ninth-day arrival are shared. Moscow and Ganjoor give distress to the Mobads after Bozorgmehr says he has no authority to stay. Mohl and Khaleghi name the Raja as the troubled party before the ninth day, and English takes both the subject and its place in the narrative from that wording. English “discerning soul” gives the Persian alignment of wisdom and spirit a direct human role in understanding the counters. The message that the Shah gave no leave to linger turns an epistemic defeat into enforced diplomatic closure.
67–72Making the pieces answer
Moscow — VIII214:2772 running, VIII214:2773 running, VIII214:2774 running, VIII214:2775 running, VIII214:2774 running; VIII214:2775 running, VIII214:2776 running · Mohl — VI199:2850 running, VI199:2851 running, VI199:2852 running, VI199:2853 running, VI199:2852 running; VI199:2853 running, VI199:2854 running · Ganjoor — sh63:145 running, sh63:146 running, sh63:147 running, sh63:148 running, sh63:147, sh63:148 running, sh63:149 running · Khaleghi — VII316:2809 running, VII316:2810 running, VII316:2811 running, VII316:2812 running, VII316:2811 running; VII316:2812 running, VII316:2813 running
Moscow VIII p.214 · Mohl VI p.199 · Ganjoor sh63:145 · Ganjoor sh63:146 · Ganjoor sh63:147 · Ganjoor sh63:148 · Ganjoor sh63:149 · Khaleghi VII p.316
The learned men acknowledge their ignorance, and the sage makes the game intelligible by spreading the board and showing its motions. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi make the Mobads’ faces open when he sits, in marked reversal of the earlier expressions of dismay. The English gives the spectators a more solemn face and places its visual release in the later wonder of the whole gathering. Its separate lines on motions and campaign read the army as a model for procedure. The Persian compactly puts the general, battle formation and the king’s command together and leaves interpretation of particular moves to the demonstration.
73–78Learning across subjects
Moscow — VIII214:2777 running, VIII214:2778 running, VIII214:2779 running, VIII215:2780 running, VIII215:2781 running · Mohl — VI199:2855 running, VI199:2856 running, VI199:2857 running, VI199:2858 running, VI199:2859 running · Ganjoor — sh63:150 running, sh63:151 running, sh63:152 running, sh63:153 running, sh63:154 running · Khaleghi — VII316:2814 running, VII316:2815 running, VII316:2816 running, VII317:2817 running, VII317:2818 running
Moscow VIII p.214 · Moscow VIII p.215 · Mohl VI p.199 · Ganjoor sh63:150 · Ganjoor sh63:151 · Ganjoor sh63:152 · Ganjoor sh63:153 · Ganjoor sh63:154 · Khaleghi VII p.316 · Khaleghi VII p.317
The rulers and counselors acclaim the sage and then test him on a variety of subjects. All four Persian texts present his adequate answers before the collective cry naming the eloquent and learned man. The English ending to that speech makes him wisdom’s custodian and adds a positive metaphor to the shared declaration that his knowledge exceeds the two games. “Holy sage” also interprets the direct designation as a Mobad of pure religion. The move from interrogation to tribute shows that the host’s acknowledgment attaches to the intellectual capacity of the envoy as well as to the board lying before them.
79–84Gift, tribute and returned loads
Moscow — VIII215:2782 running, VIII215:2783 running, VIII215:2784 running, VIII215:2785 running, VIII215:2788 running, VIII215:2786 running · Mohl — VI200:2860 running, VI200:2861 running, VI200:2862 running, VI200:2863 running, VI200:2866 running, VI200:2864 running · Ganjoor — sh63:155 running, sh63:156 running, sh63:157 running, sh63:158 running, sh63:161 running, sh63:159 running · Khaleghi — VII317:2819 running, VII317:2820 running, VII317:2821 running, VII317:2822 running, VII317:2823 running, VII317:2824 running
Moscow VIII p.215 · Mohl VI p.200 · Ganjoor sh63:155 · Ganjoor sh63:156 · Ganjoor sh63:157 · Ganjoor sh63:158 · Ganjoor sh63:161 · Ganjoor sh63:159 · Khaleghi VII p.317
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give the perfumed goods, gold, clothing and figured cups before the annual tribute and individual gifts. English supplies silver and leaves the cups implicit within the richness of the return. Its presentation of the crown and robe keeps separate the public obligation and the personal honor paid to the sage. The departure from Ghanooj sits before the returned loads and the description of the unparalleled caravan in Khaleghi and English. The other three place the departure after those details. That shift lets the English follow the moving caravan as an image of the doubled settlement.
85–90Testimony freely given
Moscow — VIII215:2787 running, VIII215:2789 running, VIII215:2790 running, VIII215:2791 running, VIII215:2792 running · Mohl — VI200:2865 running, VI200:2867 running, VI200:2868 running, VI200:2869 running, VI200:2870 running · Ganjoor — sh63:160 running, sh63:162 running, sh63:163 running, sh63:164 running, sh63:165 running · Khaleghi — VII317:2825 running, VII317:2826 running, VII317:2827 running, VII317:2828 running, VII317:2829 running
Moscow VIII p.215 · Mohl VI p.200 · Ganjoor sh63:160 · Ganjoor sh63:162 · Ganjoor sh63:163 · Ganjoor sh63:164 · Ganjoor sh63:165 · Khaleghi VII p.317
The unprecedented caravan carries documents as well as goods. All four describe a letter in an Indian hand on silk and make the Raja and the great men give their testimony without fear. The English distributes the script and fabric across consecutive couplets and makes the testimony clearly theirs. It extends the celestially vast knowledge by imagining earthly stores running dry. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi make the sky the treasurer of the counselor’s knowledge. The difference in grammatical agency matters because the preceding extraordinary wealth is being measured against the more enduring resource that won it.
91–96The finer points of payment and return
Moscow — VIII215:2793 running, VIII215:2794 running, VIII215:2795 running, VIII216:2796 running, VIII216:2797 running, VIII216:2798 running · Mohl — VI200:2871 running, VI200:2872 running, VI200:2873 running, VI200:2874 running, VI200:2875 running, VI200:2876 running · Ganjoor — sh63:166 running, sh63:167 running, sh63:168 running, sh63:169 running, sh63:170 running, sh63:171 running · Khaleghi — VII317:2830 running, VII318:2831 running, VII318:2832 running, VII318:2833 running, VII318:2834 running, VII318:2835 running
Moscow VIII p.215 · Moscow VIII p.216 · Mohl VI p.200 · Ganjoor sh63:166 · Ganjoor sh63:167 · Ganjoor sh63:168 · Ganjoor sh63:169 · Ganjoor sh63:170 · Ganjoor sh63:171 · Khaleghi VII p.317 · Khaleghi VII p.318
Annual tribute and the pledged stakes are set out in adjacent verses in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. The English distinguishes the recurring payment from the consequences of the games and keeps the promise to send more if required. When the account returns to Iran, the news of success draws notables from city and army to greet the sage. English casts the welcome as publicly recognizable triumph and retains the analogy with a victorious ruler. That analogy repays the military language of both board games without asserting that the caravan returns from an actual campaign.
97–102The embrace and Yazdegard’s reading
Moscow — VIII216:2799 running, VIII216:2800 running, VIII216:2801 running, VIII216:2802 running, VIII216:2803 running, VIII216:2804 running · Mohl — VI200:2877 running, VI200:2878 running, VI200:2879 running, VI200:2880 running, VI200:2881 running, VI200:2882 running · Ganjoor — sh63:172 running, sh63:173 running, sh63:174 running, sh63:175 running, sh63:176 running, sh63:177 running · Khaleghi — VII318:2836 running, VII318:2837 running, VII318:2838 running, VII318:2839 running, VII318:2840 running, VII318:2841 running
Moscow VIII p.216 · Mohl VI p.200 · Ganjoor sh63:172 · Ganjoor sh63:173 · Ganjoor sh63:174 · Ganjoor sh63:175 · Ganjoor sh63:176 · Ganjoor sh63:177 · Khaleghi VII p.318
At the throne the four running accounts give the Shah’s praise to Bozorgmehr and then the king’s embrace. The English syntax points the initial praise in the opposite direction, to the Shah from the wise counselor. It clearly preserves the king’s embrace and questions in the next couplet. The words of the traveler about vigilant fortune and the favor of heaven make an apt transition to the Raja’s testimony. All four name Yazdegard as the scribe called to read and end the moment in collective amazement. The letter thus renews in Iran the public recognition produced by the demonstration in Hind.
103–108Giving thanks and turning to Talkhand
Moscow — VIII216:2805 running, VIII216:2806 running, VIII216:2807 running, VIII216:2809 running, VIII216:2808 running, VIII216:2810 running · Mohl — VI200:2883 running, VI200:2884 running, VI201:2885 running, VI201:2886 running, VI201:2887 running, VI201:2888 running · Ganjoor — sh63:178 running, sh63:179 running, sh63:180 running, sh63:182 running, sh63:181 running, sh63:183 running · Khaleghi — VII318:2842 running, VII319:2843 running, VII319:2844 running, VII319:2846 running, VII319:2845 running, VII319:2847 running
Moscow VIII p.216 · Mohl VI p.200 · Mohl VI p.201 · Ganjoor sh63:178 · Ganjoor sh63:179 · Ganjoor sh63:180 · Ganjoor sh63:182 · Ganjoor sh63:181 · Ganjoor sh63:183 · Khaleghi VII p.318 · Khaleghi VII p.319
The Shah’s gratitude in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi names wisdom and the recognition of good. The English refocuses it on God giving the ruler a sage and on the attachment of the nobles to his crown. Mohl places praise of the Lord of sun and moon before the promise of a greater marvel, as the English does. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi place it after the promise. All four name Talkhand and chess in the last verse, which justifies the English’s overt turn to an older account. The second chapter ends with the storyteller preparing that transition.
Source record and limits
English
108 published English couplets. Ganjoor passages: Anooshirvan §63: 85–183. The English text follows the published verse and chapter divisions.
Moscow
The 1970 Moscow edition, volume VIII, printed pages 211–216. The source register identifies the individual running verses and any printed apparatus cited.
Mohl
Jules Mohl’s Persian text, volume VI, printed pages 196–201. Mohl’s running text includes additional verses in the reception, chess lineup and invention of nard. The register distinguishes these from material printed in other editions’ apparatus.
Ganjoor
Anooshirvan §63: 85–183. The Persian column gives the corresponding running verses and identifies where Mohl supplies a reading for a local Ganjoor gap. Consequential differences also appear under Selected printed readings.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Djalal Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VII, printed pages 311–319. Square brackets mark verses retained in the main text with explicit editorial reservation. Printed additions have their own locators.
Rules, reciprocity and the caravan
The Persian invents a board game through the imagery of opposed armies, camps and local numerical advantage. The English articulates the interplay of chance and skill in its own additional verses. The returned caravan combines the original loads, the Raja’s contributions and annual tribute, and the order of the surrounding narrative varies across the editions.
Consequential readings
English 2. Mohl runs the dark-place verse before the consideration of chess. Moscow and Khaleghi print it beneath the poem. Ganjoor shares the consideration of Indian chess but gives no separate dark-place couplet. English 3. Mohl runs the wish for a new game that will astonish the wise and resist quick solution. The other running texts move from tools and study to the making of nard. English 4. Mohl’s preceding reflection makes a deliberate art of thought. The other running accounts also join wisdom to a bright heart before introducing nard. Khaleghi prints an additional reflection in the apparatus. English 5. The nearby running couplet describes two items of ivory and teak-colored appearance. It does not supply a total of thirty counters or describe fifteen of either kind. English 6. The two ivory pieces support the reading of a pair of dice. Cubic shape and generic bone are explicit in the English. The local Persian wording says ivory. English 7. The Persian calls the camp four-sided and earth-like. English makes the four sides into seasons. The printed line supports the fourfold layout. English 8. The shared verse divides two armies into eight parts. The English assigns twelve points on either side and explicitly likens them to months. Those numbers and the calendar analogy are separate from the verse’s eightfold division. English 12. The two-against-one rule runs immediately before the roaming forces in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Mohl places it after the movement across plain and mountain. English 13. All four give fighters acting under command, with capture conditioned by their relation on the board. A separate maxim opposing player skill and the dice is a local gap in the Persian running passages. English 14. The shared verses juxtapose the two games and make the board a battlefield. The explicit distinction between human chess and heaven-governed nard supplies a conceptual bridge in the English. English 15. The wheel of fate and its decree articulate the analogy in the English. The corresponding running lines place the hosts on the march, without a separate verse pairing wheel and die. English 19. The praise-and-reproach verse precedes the exhibition in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Mohl follows the exhibition and royal astonishment with it. English likewise introduces it after the exhibition. English 29. The Persian salutation names the waters of Ghanooj and Sind as geographical limits. The English reverses the direction of address and retains both endpoints. English 47. All four use Pahlavi for the spoken praise and then give the royal letter. The distinction between praise, formal document and oral royal message is useful to retain. English 50. Mohl and Khaleghi put the Raja’s flowering face before the detailed report and give a form of بار, a load, in the report. English follows that order and incorporates both the stakes and the exertion. English 53. The report on nard precedes the pieces and counselors in Moscow and Ganjoor. Mohl and Khaleghi place it after those details, like the English. English 64. Mohl and Khaleghi make the Raja the troubled party before the ninth day. Moscow and Ganjoor give the dismay to the Mobads after the demand to end the delay. English 79. The running lists include camphor, ambergris, aloe, gold, garments and figured cups. English uses silver from its broader gift vocabulary and leaves the cups out. English 83. Khaleghi puts the sage’s departure from Ghanooj before the returned loads and extraordinary caravan, as does the English. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor place the departure after the caravan. English 90. The Persian makes the sky the keeper or treasurer of the minister’s knowledge. English makes the sky the treasury itself, then adds the comparison with depleted earthly stores. English 97. All four place the king’s blessing upon Bozorgmehr at the throne. The English grammar assigns the spoken praise to the counselor, changing the direction of the exchange. English 104. Kisra gives thanks for wisdom and recognition of good in the running texts. English instead makes the gift explicitly the presence of a wise servant. English 106. Mohl puts the thanks to the Lord of sun and moon before the verse promising a greater marvel. The other three give the promise first. English follows Mohl’s order.
Limits of the evidence
Running text, bracketed running text, actual printed apparatus and checked local gaps indicate distinct kinds of support. Local gaps concern the specified passage. No appendix reading is invoked. The geographical and institutional terms describe the poem’s account.
Source-only verses
Moscow VIII p.211 · Moscow VIII p.212 · Moscow VIII p.213 · Moscow VIII p.214 · Moscow VIII p.215 · Moscow VIII p.216
Mohl VI p.196 · Mohl VI p.197 · Mohl VI p.198 · Mohl VI p.199 · Mohl VI p.200 · Mohl VI p.201
Khaleghi VII p.311 · Khaleghi VII p.312 · Khaleghi VII p.313 · Khaleghi VII p.314 · Khaleghi VII p.315 · Khaleghi VII p.316 · Khaleghi VII p.317 · Khaleghi VII p.318 · Khaleghi VII p.319
Selected printed readings
- Mohl VI197:2790 running · نگه کرد جایی که تاریکتر / کزو گردد اندیشه باریکتر
The dark setting sharpens thought. The preceding verses amplify the work of invention. - Moscow VIII211 note 4 after v.2714 actual apparatus · نگه کرد جایی که تاریکتر / وزو گردد اندیشه باریکتر
Moscow prints the dark-place couplet in its notes. - Khaleghi VII311 note 6 to v.2749 actual apparatus · نگه کرد جایی که تاریکتر / و زو گردد اندیشه باریکتر
Khaleghi prints the couplet with manuscript variation. - Mohl VI197:2787 running · فرو رفت بسیار و اندیشه کرد / ز اندیشه دل را یکی بیشه کرد
The extended reflection is part of Mohl’s running text. - Khaleghi VII311 note 6 after v.2749 actual apparatus · فرو رفت بسیار و اندیشه کرد / ز اندیشه دل را یکی بیشه کرد
Khaleghi prints that added reflection below the poem. - Moscow VIII211:2715 running · دو مهره بفرمود کردن ز عاج / همه پیکر عاج همرنگ ساج
Two pieces are made of ivory, with the appearance of teak in the second hemistich. - Khaleghi VII311:2754 running · دو لشکر ببخشید بر هشت بهر / همه رزمجویان گیرنده شهر
The division into eight concerns two armies. - Khaleghi VII316:2808 running · دل رای از آن موبدان شد دژم / روان پر ز غم شد برو پر ز خم
The ruler’s distress follows the failed consultation and precedes the ninth day. - Khaleghi VII319:2847 running · برین داستانبر سخن ساختم / به طلخند و شطرنج پرداختم
The narrator names the next story. A separate heading then opens the story of Talkhand and Gav.
E2.2 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII211:2712 running | VI196:2786 running |
| 2 | VIII211:2713 running; VIII211 note 4 after v.2714 actual apparatus | VI197:2790 running; VI197:2791 running |
| 3 | VIII211:2713 checked local gap | VI197:2788 running; VI197:2789 running |
| 4 | VIII211:2714 running | VI197:2787 running; VI197:2792 running |
| 5 | VIII211:2715 running | VI197:2793 running |
| 6 | VIII211:2715 running | VI197:2793 running |
| 7 | VIII211:2718 running | VI197:2796 running |
| 8 | VIII211:2717 running | VI197:2795 running |
| 9 | VIII211:2716 running; VIII211:2718 running; VIII211:2720 running | VI197:2794 running; VI197:2796 running; VI197:2798 running |
| 10 | VIII211:2719 running | VI197:2797 running |
| 11 | VIII211:2720 running | VI197:2798 running |
| 12 | VIII211:2721 running | VI197:2801 running |
| 13 | VIII211:2721 checked local gap | VI197:2801 checked local gap |
| 14 | VIII211:2721 checked local gap | VI197:2801 checked local gap |
| 15 | VIII211:2721 checked local gap | VI197:2801 checked local gap |
| 16 | VIII211:2722 running; VIII211:2723 running; VIII211:2724 running | VI197:2799 running; VI197:2800 running; VI197:2802 running |
| 17 | VIII211:2725 running | VI197:2803 running |
| 18 | VIII212:2727 running; VIII212:2728 running | VI197:2804 running; VI197:2805 running |
| 19 | VIII211:2726 running | VI197:2806 running |
| 20 | VIII212:2729 running | VI197:2807 running |
| 21 | VIII212:2730 running | VI197:2808 running |
| 22 | VIII212:2731 running | VI197:2809 running |
| 23 | VIII212:2731 running; VIII212:2732 running | VI197:2809 running; VI197:2810 running |
| 24 | VIII212:2733 running | VI197:2811 running |
| 25 | VIII212:2734 running | VI198:2812 running |
| 26 | VIII212:2734 running; VIII212:2735 running | VI198:2812 running; VI198:2813 running |
| 27 | VIII212:2735 running | VI198:2813 running |
| 28 | VIII212:2736 running | VI198:2814 running |
| 29 | VIII212:2737 running | VI198:2815 running |
| 30 | VIII212:2738 running | VI198:2816 running |
| 31 | VIII212:2739 running | VI198:2817 running |
| 32 | VIII212:2739 running; VIII212:2740 running | VI198:2817 running; VI198:2818 running |
| 33 | VIII212:2741 running | VI198:2819 running |
| 34 | VIII212:2742 running | VI198:2820 running |
| 35 | VIII212:2743 running | VI198:2821 running |
| 36 | VIII212:2744 running | VI198:2822 running |
| 37 | VIII213:2745 running | VI198:2823 running |
| 38 | VIII213:2746 running | VI198:2824 running |
| 39 | VIII213:2747 running | VI198:2825 running |
| 40 | VIII213:2748 running | VI198:2826 running |
| 41 | VIII213:2748 running; VIII213:2749 running | VI198:2826 running; VI198:2827 running |
| 42 | VIII213:2749 running | VI198:2827 running |
| 43 | VIII213:2750 running | VI198:2828 running |
| 44 | VIII213:2752 running | VI198:2829 running |
| 45 | VIII213:2751 running | VI198:2830 running |
| 46 | VIII213:2753 running | VI198:2831 running |
| 47 | VIII213:2754 running | VI198:2832 running |
| 48 | VIII213:2756 running | VI198:2833 running |
| 49 | VIII213:2756 running | VI198:2833 running |
| 50 | VIII213:2755 running | VI198:2834 running |
| 51 | VIII213:2758 running | VI198:2835 running |
| 52 | VIII213:2758 running | VI198:2835 running |
| 53 | VIII213:2757 running | VI198:2836 running |
| 54 | VIII213:2759 running | VI199:2837 running |
| 55 | VIII213:2760 running | VI199:2838 running |
| 56 | VIII213:2761 running | VI199:2839 running |
| 57 | VIII214:2762 running | VI199:2840 running |
| 58 | VIII214:2763 running | VI199:2841 running |
| 59 | VIII214:2764 running | VI199:2842 running |
| 60 | VIII214:2765 running | VI199:2843 running |
| 61 | VIII214:2766 running | VI199:2844 running |
| 62 | VIII214:2767 running | VI199:2845 running |
| 63 | VIII214:2768 running | VI199:2846 running |
| 64 | VIII214:2771 running | VI199:2849 running |
| 65 | VIII214:2769 running | VI199:2847 running |
| 66 | VIII214:2770 running | VI199:2848 running |
| 67 | VIII214:2772 running | VI199:2850 running |
| 68 | VIII214:2773 running | VI199:2851 running |
| 69 | VIII214:2774 running | VI199:2852 running |
| 70 | VIII214:2775 running | VI199:2853 running |
| 71 | VIII214:2774 running; VIII214:2775 running | VI199:2852 running; VI199:2853 running |
| 72 | VIII214:2776 running | VI199:2854 running |
| 73 | VIII214:2777 running | VI199:2855 running |
| 74 | VIII214:2778 running | VI199:2856 running |
| 75 | VIII214:2779 running | VI199:2857 running |
| 76 | VIII215:2780 running | VI199:2858 running |
| 77 | VIII215:2780 running | VI199:2858 running |
| 78 | VIII215:2781 running | VI199:2859 running |
| 79 | VIII215:2782 running | VI200:2860 running |
| 80 | VIII215:2783 running | VI200:2861 running |
| 81 | VIII215:2784 running | VI200:2862 running |
| 82 | VIII215:2785 running | VI200:2863 running |
| 83 | VIII215:2788 running | VI200:2866 running |
| 84 | VIII215:2786 running | VI200:2864 running |
| 85 | VIII215:2787 running | VI200:2865 running |
| 86 | VIII215:2789 running | VI200:2867 running |
| 87 | VIII215:2790 running | VI200:2868 running |
| 88 | VIII215:2791 running | VI200:2869 running |
| 89 | VIII215:2792 running | VI200:2870 running |
| 90 | VIII215:2792 running | VI200:2870 running |
| 91 | VIII215:2793 running | VI200:2871 running |
| 92 | VIII215:2794 running | VI200:2872 running |
| 93 | VIII215:2795 running | VI200:2873 running |
| 94 | VIII216:2796 running | VI200:2874 running |
| 95 | VIII216:2797 running | VI200:2875 running |
| 96 | VIII216:2798 running | VI200:2876 running |
| 97 | VIII216:2799 running | VI200:2877 running |
| 98 | VIII216:2800 running | VI200:2878 running |
| 99 | VIII216:2801 running | VI200:2879 running |
| 100 | VIII216:2802 running | VI200:2880 running |
| 101 | VIII216:2803 running | VI200:2881 running |
| 102 | VIII216:2804 running | VI200:2882 running |
| 103 | VIII216:2805 running | VI200:2883 running |
| 104 | VIII216:2806 running | VI200:2884 running |
| 105 | VIII216:2807 running | VI201:2885 running |
| 106 | VIII216:2809 running | VI201:2886 running |
| 107 | VIII216:2808 running | VI201:2887 running |
| 108 | VIII216:2810 running | VI201:2888 running |
New Naqqali