Caesar’s Locked Casket
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6A diplomatic test in a locked object
Moscow — VIII260:3556 running; VIII260:3557 running, VIII260:3557 running, VIII260:3558 running, VIII260:3559 running, VIII261:3560 running · Mohl — VI232:3651 running; VI232:3652 running, VI232:3652 running, VI232:3653 running, VI232:3654 running, VI232:3655 running · Ganjoor — sh76:1, sh76:2 running, sh76:2 running, sh76:3 running, sh76:4 running, sh76:5 running · Khaleghi — VII381:3601 running; VII381:3602 running, VII381:3602 running, VII381:3603 running, VII381:3604 running, VII382:3605 running
Moscow VIII p.260 · Moscow VIII p.261 · Mohl VI p.232 · Ganjoor sh76:1 · Ganjoor sh76:2 · Ganjoor sh76:3 · Ganjoor sh76:4 · Ganjoor sh76:5 · Khaleghi VII p.381 · Khaleghi VII p.382
The envoy arrives with gifts, a letter and a locked casket. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all set the ability of the Iranian court against a physical prohibition: the answer must come without handling the object or its lock. The English gives the speech two couplets where the Persian introduces the warriors and learned Mobadan in one; that emphasis helps make the challenge one to a court, as well as to a single riddle-solver. “Padlock or the seal” gives memorable detail from the wider encounter. The first promise in all four includes tribute and an additional customary payment. English “yearly tribute” makes the bargain immediately intelligible and leaves the two-part expression unelaborated.
7–12Terms, answer and hospitality
Moscow — VIII261:3561 running, VIII261:3562 running, VIII261:3563 running, VIII261:3564 running, VIII261:3565 running, VIII261:3566 running · Mohl — VI232:3656 running, VI233:3657 running, VI233:3658 running, VI233:3659 running, VI233:3660 running, VI233:3661 running · Ganjoor — sh76:6 running, sh76:7 running, sh76:8 running, sh76:9 running, sh76:10 running, sh76:11 running · Khaleghi — VII382:3606 running, VII382:3607 running, VII382:3608 running, VII382:3609 running, VII382:3610 running, VII382:3611 running
Moscow VIII p.261 · Mohl VI p.232 · Mohl VI p.233 · Ganjoor sh76:6 · Ganjoor sh76:7 · Ganjoor sh76:8 · Ganjoor sh76:9 · Ganjoor sh76:10 · Ganjoor sh76:11 · Khaleghi VII p.382
In the four Persian versions, failure bars the Iranian court from demanding Roman tribute and sending its army. The English keeps both consequences and lets the envoy ask for an answer under the Shah’s own judgment. The reply first appeals to what Yazdan knows, then to divine farr and qualified counsel. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh leave the ruler’s confidence contingent on the right minds. “Sacred farr” keeps the Persian term and helps readers recognize the limit of personal royal competence. The promise of a peaceful week buys time and turns an adversarial test into a visit governed by court etiquette. The English adds wine to the invitation; the four running invitations emphasize gladness and ease.
13–18When the whole council cannot answer
Moscow — VIII261:3567 running, VIII261:3568 running, VIII261:3569 running; VIII261:3570 running, VIII261:3571 running; VIII261:3573 running, VIII261:3572 running · Mohl — VI233:3662 running, VI233:3663 running, VI233:3664 running; VI233:3665 running, VI233:3666 running, VI233:3667 running · Ganjoor — sh76:12 running, sh76:13 running, sh76:14, sh76:15 running, sh77:1, sh77:3 running, sh77:2 running · Khaleghi — VII382:3612 running, VII382:3613 running, VII382:3614 running; VII382:3615 running, VII382:3616 running; VII383:3618 bracketed running, VII383:3617 running
Moscow VIII p.261 · Mohl VI p.233 · Ganjoor sh76:12 · Ganjoor sh76:13 · Ganjoor sh76:14 · Ganjoor sh76:15 · Ganjoor sh77:1 · Ganjoor sh77:3 · Ganjoor sh77:2 · Khaleghi VII p.382 · Khaleghi VII p.383
The English lets collective concentration run over four couplets and pictures the men inspecting the lock, cord and surface. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all move from close inspection to an admission of ignorance. The running texts mention a lock without a key at hand, so the English cord belongs to its staging of the inspection. Ganjoor and Moscow carry a further lament about Bozorgmehr after the Shah identifies him as the one mind able to solve the problem. Khaleghi-Motlagh retains that lament in brackets; Mohl moves from the sage’s name to the gifts. The English spreads the Shah’s distress across the council’s failure and the recollection of the specialist whom he has imprisoned.
19–24Gifts and an incomplete apology
Moscow — VIII261:3572 running, VIII261:3574 running; VIII261:3575 running, VIII261:3576 running, VIII261:3577 running, VIII262:3578 running, VIII262:3579 running · Mohl — VI233:3667 running, VI233:3668 running; VI233:3669 running, VI233:3670 running, VI233:3671 running, VI233:3672 running, VI233:3673 running · Ganjoor — sh77:2 running, sh77:4, sh77:5 running, sh77:6 running, sh77:7 running, sh77:8 running, sh77:9 running · Khaleghi — VII383:3617 running, VII383:3619 running; VII383:3620 running, VII383:3621 running, VII383:3622 running, VII383:3623 running, VII383:3624 running
Moscow VIII p.261 · Moscow VIII p.262 · Mohl VI p.233 · Ganjoor sh77:2 · Ganjoor sh77:4 · Ganjoor sh77:5 · Ganjoor sh77:6 · Ganjoor sh77:7 · Ganjoor sh77:8 · Ganjoor sh77:9 · Khaleghi VII p.383
The saddle, horse and clothing return the sage to recognizable court service. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh couple the gifts with a message asking him to let the injuries pass. The English makes the saddle golden; the Persian stresses the selected horse and royal equipment. The Shah’s appeal to heaven is immediately followed by his complaint about the other man’s tongue. English “the author of your fallen power” makes that transfer of responsibility unusually direct. When the court later sees the blindness, the ruler openly regrets harming someone innocent. The common sequence gives that later admission a different weight from his speech here, where the failure of the assembly presses him to seek help before he has accepted blame.
25–30Musk, messengers and renewed pain
Moscow — VIII262:3581 running, VIII262:3580 running, VIII262:3582 running, VIII262:3583 running, VIII262:3584 running, VIII262:3585 running · Mohl — VI233:3675 running, VI233:3674 running, VI233:3676 running, VI233:3677 running, VI233:3678 running, VI233:3679 running · Ganjoor — sh77:11 running, sh77:10 running, sh77:12 running, sh77:13 running, sh77:14 running, sh77:15 running · Khaleghi — VII383:3626 running, VII383:3625 running, VII383:3627 running, VII383:3628 running, VII383:3629 running, VII383:3630 running
Moscow VIII p.262 · Mohl VI p.233 · Ganjoor sh77:11 · Ganjoor sh77:10 · Ganjoor sh77:12 · Ganjoor sh77:13 · Ganjoor sh77:14 · Ganjoor sh77:15 · Khaleghi VII p.383
In the Persian running accounts the mention of the sealed, musk-marked casket precedes identification of the Roman priest. English moves the envoy up to make “He brought” immediately clear. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh give the conspicuous musk as the material of the seal. English removes possible ambiguity about the object by describing the lock and musk together, while giving the musk a role in concealing the core. The chain of quoted speakers matters: the Shah reports the envoy, who reports his sovereign. The passage ends with an inward turn. English “Old pain” aptly catches the sense of an old wound renewed by the summons, instead of smoothing over the emotional price of accepting the commission.
31–36A man without sight reads the sky
Moscow — VIII262:3586 running, VIII262:3587 running, VIII262:3588 running, VIII262:3589 running; VIII262:3590 running, VIII262:3591 running · Mohl — VI233:3680 running, VI233:3681 running, VI234:3682 running, VI234:3683 running, VI234:3684 running · Ganjoor — sh77:16 running, sh77:17 running, sh77:18 running, sh77:19, sh77:20 running, sh77:21 running · Khaleghi — VII384:3631 running, VII384:3632 running, VII384:3633 running, VII384:3634 running; VII384:3635 running, VII384:3636 running
Moscow VIII p.262 · Mohl VI p.233 · Mohl VI p.234 · Ganjoor sh77:16 · Ganjoor sh77:17 · Ganjoor sh77:18 · Ganjoor sh77:19 · Ganjoor sh77:20 · Ganjoor sh77:21 · Khaleghi VII p.384
Washing, turning toward the divine and fearing the Shah follow one another in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh; none makes fear incompatible with the man’s innocence. English separates the bodily washing from the still more striking washing of the “inward sight,” preserving the second Persian image of wisdom as water. Mohl compresses dawn and the look toward the stars; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh use a separate verse to describe dawn itself. The English “searched their ordered place” gives the heavens the texture of an inquiry and the trustworthy guide provides the terrestrial check. The pair of actions readies two kinds of perception, at a moment when the narrative already makes the sage’s bodily sight unavailable.
37–42A witness to ordinary life
Moscow — VIII262:3592 running, VIII262:3593 running, VIII262:3594 running, VIII262:3595 running, VIII263:3596 running, VIII263:3597 running · Mohl — VI234:3685 running, VI234:3686 running, VI234:3687 running, VI234:3688 running, VI234:3689 running, VI234:3690 running · Ganjoor — sh77:22 running, sh77:23 running, sh77:24 running, sh77:25 running, sh77:26 running, sh77:27 running · Khaleghi — VII384:3637 running, VII384:3638 running, VII384:3639 running, VII384:3640 running, VII385:3641 running, VII385:3642 running
Moscow VIII p.262 · Moscow VIII p.263 · Mohl VI p.234 · Ganjoor sh77:22 · Ganjoor sh77:23 · Ganjoor sh77:24 · Ganjoor sh77:25 · Ganjoor sh77:26 · Ganjoor sh77:27 · Khaleghi VII p.384 · Khaleghi VII p.385
Bozorgmehr’s instruction sets an observable task, to ask about the person on the road and report the answer. The four Persian texts also tell the helper to avoid asking the name. English “Ask who they are” would permit a name if taken literally; the next dialogue narrows the question to the woman’s situation. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh give the first woman a husband and a child still hidden. “And bear a child within me” preserves the sense directly. The encounter is both a practical substitution for eyesight and the first term in an analogy. The aural weight of her answer lets the blind man direct the inquiry through a companion without having to read a face.
43–48Three questions become a sequence
Moscow — VIII263:3598 running, VIII263:3599 running, VIII263:3600 running, VIII263:3601 running, VIII263:3602 running, VIII263:3603 running · Mohl — VI234:3691 running, VI234:3692 running, VI234:3693 running, VI234:3694 running, VI234:3695 running, VI234:3696 running · Ganjoor — sh77:28 running, sh77:29 running, sh77:30 running, sh77:31 running, sh77:32 running, sh77:33 running · Khaleghi — VII385:3643 running, VII385:3644 running, VII385:3645 running, VII385:3646 running, VII385:3647 running, VII385:3648 running
Moscow VIII p.263 · Mohl VI p.234 · Ganjoor sh77:28 · Ganjoor sh77:29 · Ganjoor sh77:30 · Ganjoor sh77:31 · Ganjoor sh77:32 · Ganjoor sh77:33 · Khaleghi VII p.385
All four accounts keep the women in the same order. Ganjoor and Moscow make the sage smile or laugh after hearing the first woman; Mohl has him move on, as does the Khaleghi-Motlagh running text. English chooses reflection and the color of the horse, making the passage read as an unfolding deduction. Some of the Persian force lies in the second woman telling the questioner to move on after receiving his answer. The English keeps attention on her marriage and absence of a child. The third woman is asked about a partner, a less prescribed word than the English’s combined “maiden, or a wife.” That tightened English grouping clarifies the pattern the reader will be invited to complete.
49–54The English reveals the inference early
Moscow — VIII263:3604 running, VIII263:3605 running, Checked local gap between VIII263:3605 running and VIII263:3606 running, VIII263:3606 running; VIII263:3607 running, VIII263:3608 running; VIII263:3609 running · Mohl — VI234:3697 running, VI234:3698 running, Checked local gap between VI234:3698 running and VI234:3699 running, VI234:3699 running; VI234:3700 running, VI234:3701 running; VI234:3702 running · Ganjoor — sh77:34 running, sh77:35 running, Checked local gap after sh77:35, sh77:36, sh77:37 running, sh77:38, sh77:39 running · Khaleghi — VII385:3649 running, VII385:3650 running, Checked local gap between VII385:3650 running and VII385:3651 running, VII385:3651 running; VII386:3652 running, VII386:3653 running; VII386:3654 running
Moscow VIII p.263 · Mohl VI p.234 · Ganjoor sh77:34 · Ganjoor sh77:35 · Ganjoor sh77:36 · Ganjoor sh77:37 · Ganjoor sh77:38 · Ganjoor sh77:39 · Khaleghi VII p.385 · Khaleghi VII p.386
The Persian versions give the third woman a refusal and then show Bozorgmehr thinking before he appears at court. In Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh there is no separate running verse that assigns each woman a corresponding pearl at this point. All four save the explicit pierced, half-pierced and undrilled series for the declaration. The English brings the analogy forward, giving readers the sage’s inference before the casket proves it. “Barren bride” reads more conclusively than the woman’s own statement that she has no child. That is a cost of compressing the correspondence into two rhymed couplets. The switch to the ruler’s grief keeps the delayed confirmation from becoming a purely mechanical trick.
55–60Apology and the one assembly
Moscow — VIII263:3608 running; VIII263:3609 running, VIII263:3609 running; VIII263:3610 running, VIII263:3610 running, VIII263:3611 running, VIII263:3612 running; VIII263:3613 running, VIII263:3613 running · Mohl — VI234:3701 running; VI234:3702 running, VI234:3702 running; VI234:3703 running, VI234:3703 running, VI234:3704 running, VI234:3705 running; VI234:3706 running, VI234:3706 running · Ganjoor — sh77:38, sh77:39 running, sh77:39, sh78:1 running, sh78:1 running, sh78:2 running, sh78:3 running · Khaleghi — VII386:3653 running; VII386:3654 running, VII386:3654 running; VII386:3655 running, VII386:3655 running, VII386:3656 running, VII386:3657 running; VII386:3658 running, VII386:3658 running
Moscow VIII p.263 · Mohl VI p.234 · Ganjoor sh77:38 · Ganjoor sh77:39 · Ganjoor sh78:1 · Ganjoor sh78:2 · Ganjoor sh78:3 · Khaleghi VII p.386
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh alike show the ruler breathing out cold air at the sight of the blinded sage and apologizing for hurting a man without guilt. The English gives sorrow and forgiveness full expression across two couplets. Its “owned the unjust pain” is warranted by the Persian designation of the man as innocent. The sequence from apology to the Roman test also lets the restored sage determine the conduct of the examination. The assembly verse is running text in Moscow, Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh. Ganjoor moves from the blessing to the casket set before the Shah and the assembled great. The English’s two-stage call makes the envoy’s public presence unmistakable.
61–66The illuminated heart and the straight back
Moscow — VIII263:3614 running, VIII264:3615 running, VIII264:3616 running, VIII264:3617 running, VIII264:3618 running, VIII264:3619 running · Mohl — VI235:3707 running, VI235:3708 running, VI235:3709 running, VI235:3710 running, VI235:3711 running, VI235:3712 running · Ganjoor — sh78:4 running, sh78:5 running, sh78:6 running, sh78:7 running, sh78:8 running, sh78:9 running · Khaleghi — VII386:3659 running, VII386:3660 running, VII386:3661 running, VII386:3662 running, VII386:3663 running, VII387:3664 running
Moscow VIII p.263 · Moscow VIII p.264 · Mohl VI p.235 · Ganjoor sh78:4 · Ganjoor sh78:5 · Ganjoor sh78:6 · Ganjoor sh78:7 · Ganjoor sh78:8 · Ganjoor sh78:9 · Khaleghi VII p.386 · Khaleghi VII p.387
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh connect the solution with knowledge given by Yazdan and the refusal to touch the lock. They also carry the bodily contrast between eyes that no longer see and an inward eye that is bright. English “Discerning light is breastplate to my soul” combines the light with the Persian second hemistich’s defense of the soul by knowledge. The court’s response returns to outward signs, where the king’s heart refreshes like a spring flower and the weight of thought leaves his back straight. The English rose and winter rain extend the seasonal image while “no longer bent” retains the bodily logic of a ruler relieved by someone else’s judgment.
67–72The envoy repeats the challenge before witnesses
Moscow — VIII264:3620 running, VIII264:3621 running; VIII264:3622 running, VIII264:3622 running, VIII264:3623 running; VIII264:3624 running, VIII264:3625 running · Mohl — VI235:3713 running, VI235:3714 running; VI235:3715 running, VI235:3715 running, VI235:3716 running; VI235:3717 running, VI235:3718 running · Ganjoor — sh78:10 running, sh78:11, sh78:12 running, sh78:12 running, sh78:13, sh78:14 running, sh78:15 running · Khaleghi — VII387:3665 running, VII387:3666 running; VII387:3667 running, VII387:3667 running, VII387:3668 running; VII387:3669 running, VII387:3670 running
Moscow VIII p.264 · Mohl VI p.235 · Ganjoor sh78:10 · Ganjoor sh78:11 · Ganjoor sh78:12 · Ganjoor sh78:13 · Ganjoor sh78:14 · Ganjoor sh78:15 · Khaleghi VII p.387
The English turns the Shah’s brief instruction into a public call to repeat the envoy’s purpose before the nobles. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh provide the seated grandees and the command that the envoy deliver the message and hear the answer. Their envoy also offers a maxim on kingship beyond war, pairing knowledge and wisdom with reputation and honor. The English uses his words principally to ask for an answer worthy of royal power; the maxim’s contrast between war and rule becomes less explicit. “Serve your throne from every distant way” makes the broad reach of courtly talent vivid. In the Persian the people outside the court are the Shah’s well-wishers around the world.
73–78The terms of a fair answer
Moscow — VIII264:3626 running, VIII264:3627 running, VIII264:3628 running, VIII264:3629 running, VIII265:3630 running, VIII265:3631 running · Mohl — VI235:3719 running, VI235:3720 running, VI235:3721 running, VI235:3722 running, VI235:3723 running, VI235:3724 running · Ganjoor — sh78:16 running, sh78:17 running, sh78:18 running, sh78:19 running, sh78:20 running, sh78:21 running · Khaleghi — VII387:3671 running, VII387:3672 running, VII388:3673 running, VII388:3674 running, VII388:3675 running, VII388:3676 running
Moscow VIII p.264 · Moscow VIII p.265 · Mohl VI p.235 · Ganjoor sh78:16 · Ganjoor sh78:17 · Ganjoor sh78:18 · Ganjoor sh78:19 · Ganjoor sh78:20 · Ganjoor sh78:21 · Khaleghi VII p.387 · Khaleghi VII p.388
The four Persian accounts pair a visible lock and seal with an answer that must state clearly what remains hidden. The English’s “words by tested wisdom as their guide” captures the insistence that knowledge must be expressed, and makes the proof more than a guess followed by luck. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh describe tribute and levy in the renewed pledge. “Ally and as friend” clarifies the intended diplomatic accommodation while adding a relationship the Persian fiscal language does not name. Bozorgmehr then blesses the ruler and invokes the divine. The English prioritizes fortune’s favor; the Persian blessing also attaches particular value to a king who is just and able to judge speech.
79–84Evidence before the seal is opened
Moscow — VIII265:3632 running, VIII265:3633 running, VIII265:3634 running, VIII265:3635 running, VIII265:3636 running, VIII265:3637 running · Mohl — VI235:3725 running, VI235:3726 running, VI235:3727 running, VI235:3728 running, VI235:3729 running, VI235:3730 running · Ganjoor — sh78:22 running, sh78:23 running, sh78:24 running, sh78:25 running, sh78:26 running, sh78:27 running · Khaleghi — VII388:3677 running, VII388:3678 running, VII388:3679 running, VII388:3680 running, VII388:3681 running, VII388:3682 running
Moscow VIII p.265 · Mohl VI p.235 · Ganjoor sh78:22 · Ganjoor sh78:23 · Ganjoor sh78:24 · Ganjoor sh78:25 · Ganjoor sh78:26 · Ganjoor sh78:27 · Khaleghi VII p.388
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh name the deity through sun and moon, then give him knowledge of what is manifest and what is secret. English makes this opposition visual with shadow and light, linking it with the sage’s blindness. It next declares the three pearls and gives their exact conditions. “Never known the iron’s way” makes drilling physically concrete just as the Persian says the last has never encountered iron. The second pearl is only half-drilled; the subtle middle condition is what makes the answer convincing. The Roman then produces the key. The four Persian sequences use an inner case and silk; English “a case lay wrapped inside” suggests the case’s wrapping, while the silk is described within the case in the Persian.
85–90The Shah awards pearls and hears the older story
Moscow — VIII265:3638 running, VIII265:3639 running, VIII265:3640 running, VIII265:3641 running, VIII265:3642 running; VIII265:3643 running, VIII265:3644 running; VIII265:3645 running; VIII265:3646 running · Mohl — VI235:3731 running, VI236:3732 running, VI236:3733 running, VI236:3734 running, VI236:3735 running; VI236:3736 running, VI236:3737 running; VI236:3738 running; VI236:3739 running · Ganjoor — sh78:28 running, sh78:29 running, sh78:30 running, sh79:1 running, sh79:2, sh79:3 running, sh79:4, sh79:5, sh79:6 running · Khaleghi — VII388:3683 running, VII389:3684 running, VII389:3685 running, VII389:3686 running, VII389:3687 running; VII389:3688 running, VII389:3689 running; VII389:3690 running; VII389:3691 running
Moscow VIII p.265 · Mohl VI p.235 · Mohl VI p.236 · Ganjoor sh78:28 · Ganjoor sh78:29 · Ganjoor sh78:30 · Ganjoor sh79:1 · Ganjoor sh79:2 · Ganjoor sh79:3 · Ganjoor sh79:4 · Ganjoor sh79:5 · Ganjoor sh79:6 · Khaleghi VII p.388 · Khaleghi VII p.389
The repeated inventory and the rain of jewels are common to the four sources. The English “intact” works best as a claim that all the objects are accounted for, since the next couplet preserves the two different drillings. Moscow and Mohl, with Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh, then put pearls into the sage’s mouth as a reward. In the earlier scene the king falsely inferred an act of swallowing. That verbal and bodily echo gives the gift its force even before Bozorgmehr recalls the black bird. The English also keeps the shame and question of why the king wronged someone loyal. It compresses the Persian recounting into one couplet, which opens room for a new kind of proof in the next English lines.
91–96A recovery scene in English and a speech about fate
Moscow — Checked local gap between VIII265:3646 running and VIII265:3647 running, VIII265:3647 running, VIII265:3648 running; VIII265:3649 running, VIII265:3649 running, VIII266:3650 running · Mohl — Checked local gap between VI236:3739 running and VI236:3740 running, VI236:3740 running, VI236:3741 running; VI236:3742 running, VI236:3742 running, VI236:3743 running · Ganjoor — Checked local gap after sh79:6, sh79:7 running, sh79:8, sh79:9 running, sh79:9 running, sh79:10 running · Khaleghi — Checked local gap between VII389:3691 running and VII389:3692 running, VII389:3692 running, VII389:3693 running; VII389:3694 running, VII389:3694 running, VII389:3695 running
Moscow VIII p.265 · Moscow VIII p.266 · Mohl VI p.236 · Ganjoor sh79:6 · Ganjoor sh79:7 · Ganjoor sh79:8 · Ganjoor sh79:9 · Ganjoor sh79:10 · Khaleghi VII p.389
The English summons huntsmen and opens the raven’s crop, making the accused man’s innocence demonstrable to the court. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh move from the remembered armlet and black bird to the sage’s words about what had to happen. The adjacent verse apparatus and Khaleghi-Motlagh’s quotation from Bondari are consistent with the bird swallowing the jewels; they do not verify hunters cutting it open. As an English narrative choice this makes a symmetrical pair of physical proofs, the opened case and the recovered old pearls. It also changes the order of moral recognition: the Persian apology precedes the testing of the casket. Both versions close the conversation by linking events to fate and wishing joy to the king.
97–101The work that remains when ceremony ends
Moscow — VIII266:3651 running, VIII266:3652 running, VIII266:3653 running, VIII266:3654 running, VIII266:3655 running · Mohl — VI236:3744 running, VI236:3745 running, VI236:3746 running, VI236:3747 running, VI236:3748 running · Ganjoor — sh79:11 running, sh79:12 running, sh79:13 running, sh79:14 running, sh79:15 running · Khaleghi — VII389:3696 running, VII390:3697 running, VII390:3698 running, VII390:3699 running, VII390:3700 running
Moscow VIII p.266 · Mohl VI p.236 · Ganjoor sh79:11 · Ganjoor sh79:12 · Ganjoor sh79:13 · Ganjoor sh79:14 · Ganjoor sh79:15 · Khaleghi VII p.389 · Khaleghi VII p.390
The last English couplets distinguish visible acts of rule from the minister’s continual burden of wealth, troops, complaints and redress. Moscow and Ganjoor continue through these maxims; Mohl puts his new heading after them. Khaleghi-Motlagh begins his headed section on rescripts before the first maxim, and his apparatus quotes Bondari on the minister’s role in making the king’s affairs sound. English adds calm and peace to express what the king gains and the sage loses. The Persian closes on the strain placed on the minister’s heart and soul by household or government management and treasure. Keeping the maxims in the casket chapter extends the cost of dependence beyond the moment at which the king fills the adviser’s mouth with pearls.
Source record and limits
English
101 published English couplets. Ganjoor passages: Anooshirvan §76: 1–15, Anooshirvan §77: 1–39, Anooshirvan §78: 1–30, Anooshirvan §79: 1–15. The English text follows the published verse and chapter divisions.
Moscow
The 1970 Moscow edition, volume VIII, printed pages 260–266. The source register identifies the individual running verses and any printed apparatus cited.
Mohl
Jules Mohl’s Persian text, volume VI, printed pages 232–236. The source register distinguishes his wording and order from the corresponding running verses of the other editions.
Ganjoor
Anooshirvan §76: 1–15, Anooshirvan §77: 1–39, Anooshirvan §78: 1–30, Anooshirvan §79: 1–15. The Persian column gives the corresponding running verses. It marks local gaps at English expansions, with the adjacent Persian passage linked. Consequential differences appear under Selected printed readings.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Djalal Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VII, printed pages 381–390. Square brackets mark verses retained in the main text with explicit editorial reservation. Printed additions have their own locators.
The road, the casket and the armlet
The three women supply the conditions that the later declaration identifies in the pearls. The English makes the analogy explicit on the road. The four Persian witnesses and Bondari as quoted in the critical apparatus support the sage’s memory of a bird swallowing the jewels. The English adds an independent recovery and confirmation scene.
Consequential readings
English 6. The Persian promises tribute and what is customary in addition. English terms it yearly. The envoy renews his pledge before the court. English 12. The printed invitation is to stay a week and be at ease. English adds wine. English 17. Ganjoor and Moscow give another image of the Shah’s distress after he names the one man who can answer. Khaleghi-Motlagh retains that verse in brackets. Mohl moves directly to the restorative gifts. English 23. The Shah makes the sage’s tongue a cause of his anger. His acknowledgment of an innocent man comes later, after he sees the blindness. English 38. All four describe an inquiry without asking names. English preserves the instruction to report the replies and leaves the anonymity implicit. English 50. All four record the sage thinking about the replies and then taking the road to court. The published English brings the explanation of the three omens forward. English 51. Checked local gap between the sage’s pondering and his arrival. The wives’ replies occur at Ganjoor §77:27,31 and the pearl conditions at §78:25. Bringing each reply and pearl together here makes explicit the inference. English 52. Checked local gap in this position. The third woman’s reply is at Ganjoor §77:34 and the undrilled pearl at §78:25. The analogy is part of the English exposition. English 56. The king’s apology for injury to an innocent man is running text in all four editions. English places the admission directly before the explanation of Caesar’s challenge. English 59. Moscow, Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh explicitly call for an assembly with Caesar’s envoy and the Mobadan. The corresponding Ganjoor passage moves from the blessing to placement of the casket. English 63. The first hemistich contrasts lost sight with the bright eye of the heart. The second likens knowledge to armor. The English keeps both ideas. English 75. The renewed promise names tribute and levy. English makes the diplomatic relationship explicit with “ally and as friend.” English 85. “Intact” can mean that the jewels are all present, but two are already drilled. English gives their exact condition the following couplet. English 90. Bozorgmehr tells the Shah about the armlet, black bird, jewel and royal sleep. The surrounding running text does not call witnesses or describe recovering the jewels. English 91. Checked local gap: the four running texts move from the sage’s account to his words about fate. The neighboring printed apparatus and the cited Bondari passage provide no independent witness or opened crop. English 92. Checked local gap: the recovered three pearls and public vindication are a detail of the English. The Persian narrative has already expressed the king’s admission of innocence before the test. English 97. Khaleghi-Motlagh prints the new heading before these maxims. Moscow and Ganjoor continue through them; Mohl places his next heading after the last maxim. New Naqqali keeps the maxims in the casket chapter.
Limits of the evidence
Running text, bracketed running text, actual printed apparatus and checked local gaps indicate distinct kinds of support. Local gaps concern the specified passage. The selected record also identifies any Bondari prose quoted in the printed apparatus. The provenance of English details without a verified counterpart remains unverified.
Source-only verses
Moscow VIII p.260 · Moscow VIII p.261 · Moscow VIII p.262 · Moscow VIII p.263 · Moscow VIII p.264 · Moscow VIII p.265 · Moscow VIII p.266
Mohl VI p.232 · Mohl VI p.233 · Mohl VI p.234 · Mohl VI p.235 · Mohl VI p.236
Khaleghi VII p.381 · Khaleghi VII p.382 · Khaleghi VII p.383 · Khaleghi VII p.384 · Khaleghi VII p.385 · Khaleghi VII p.386 · Khaleghi VII p.387 · Khaleghi VII p.388 · Khaleghi VII p.389 · Khaleghi VII p.390
Selected printed readings
- Khaleghi VII382:3605 running · فرستیم باژ ار بگویند راست / جز از باژ چیزی که آیین ماست
The first bargain pairs tribute with what is customary. - Khaleghi VII383:3618 bracketed running · شد از درد دانا دلش پر از درد / برو پر ز چین کرد و رخساره زرد
The verse on the king’s grief is bracketed in the main text. - Khaleghi VII383:3625 running · یکی درج زرین سرش بسته خشک / نهاده برو قفل و مهری ز مشک
The casket is golden, with a lock and a seal of musk. - Moscow VIII263:3605–3606 running · چو بشنید بوزرجمهر این سخن / نگر تا چه اندیشه افگند بن
The sage thinks after hearing the third reply. The next running verse has him travel to court. - Mohl VI234:3705 running · یکی انجمن باید از بخردان / فرستادهٔ قیصر و موبدان
Mohl makes the assembly and the Roman envoy explicit, as do Moscow and Khaleghi-Motlagh. Ganjoor’s local reading begins with the next verse. - Khaleghi VII386:3661 running · اگر دیده شد چشم دل روشنست / روان را ز دانش همان جوشنست
The bright inward eye and the armor of knowledge are paired in a single verse. - Khaleghi VII388:3680 running · یکی سفته و دیگری نیمشفت / دگر آنک آهن ندیدهست جفت
The public answer specifies the drilled, half-drilled and undrilled pearls. - Moscow VIII265:3646 running · از آن بند بازوی و مرغ سیاه / از اندیشهٔ گوهر و خواب شاه
The reminiscence includes the armlet, the bird and the Shah’s sleep. The following running verse turns to fate. - Khaleghi VII389, note 21 to 3689–3691 · Bondari prose in actual apparatus · و التقاطه جواهر الدملج و ابتلاعه إياها
The bird picks up the armlet jewels and swallows them. The quoted evidence here stops with the retelling. The notes that follow concern fate and the closing prayer. - Khaleghi VII389:3696 running · اگرچند باشد سرافراز شاه / به دستور گردد دلآرای گاه
The new printed heading precedes this maxim. The published English keeps it at the end of the casket chapter.
E3.2 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII260:3556 running; VIII260:3557 running | VI232:3651 running; VI232:3652 running |
| 2 | VIII260:3557 running | VI232:3652 running |
| 3 | VIII260:3558 running | VI232:3653 running |
| 4 | VIII260:3558 running | VI232:3653 running |
| 5 | VIII260:3559 running | VI232:3654 running |
| 6 | VIII261:3560 running | VI232:3655 running |
| 7 | VIII261:3561 running | VI232:3656 running |
| 8 | VIII261:3562 running | VI233:3657 running |
| 9 | VIII261:3563 running | VI233:3658 running |
| 10 | VIII261:3564 running | VI233:3659 running |
| 11 | VIII261:3565 running | VI233:3660 running |
| 12 | VIII261:3566 running | VI233:3661 running |
| 13 | VIII261:3567 running | VI233:3662 running |
| 14 | VIII261:3567 running | VI233:3662 running |
| 15 | VIII261:3568 running | VI233:3663 running |
| 16 | VIII261:3569 running; VIII261:3570 running | VI233:3664 running; VI233:3665 running |
| 17 | VIII261:3571 running; VIII261:3573 running | VI233:3666 running |
| 18 | VIII261:3572 running | VI233:3667 running |
| 19 | VIII261:3572 running | VI233:3667 running |
| 20 | VIII261:3574 running; VIII261:3575 running | VI233:3668 running; VI233:3669 running |
| 21 | VIII261:3576 running | VI233:3670 running |
| 22 | VIII261:3577 running | VI233:3671 running |
| 23 | VIII262:3578 running | VI233:3672 running |
| 24 | VIII262:3579 running | VI233:3673 running |
| 25 | VIII262:3581 running | VI233:3675 running |
| 26 | VIII262:3580 running | VI233:3674 running |
| 27 | VIII262:3582 running | VI233:3676 running |
| 28 | VIII262:3583 running | VI233:3677 running |
| 29 | VIII262:3584 running | VI233:3678 running |
| 30 | VIII262:3585 running | VI233:3679 running |
| 31 | VIII262:3586 running | VI233:3680 running |
| 32 | VIII262:3587 running | VI233:3681 running |
| 33 | VIII262:3588 running | VI234:3682 running |
| 34 | VIII262:3589 running; VIII262:3590 running | VI234:3683 running |
| 35 | VIII262:3591 running | VI234:3684 running |
| 36 | VIII262:3591 running | VI234:3684 running |
| 37 | VIII262:3592 running | VI234:3685 running |
| 38 | VIII262:3593 running | VI234:3686 running |
| 39 | VIII262:3594 running | VI234:3687 running |
| 40 | VIII262:3595 running | VI234:3688 running |
| 41 | VIII263:3596 running | VI234:3689 running |
| 42 | VIII263:3597 running | VI234:3690 running |
| 43 | VIII263:3598 running | VI234:3691 running |
| 44 | VIII263:3599 running | VI234:3692 running |
| 45 | VIII263:3600 running | VI234:3693 running |
| 46 | VIII263:3601 running | VI234:3694 running |
| 47 | VIII263:3602 running | VI234:3695 running |
| 48 | VIII263:3603 running | VI234:3696 running |
| 49 | VIII263:3604 running | VI234:3697 running |
| 50 | VIII263:3605 running | VI234:3698 running |
| 51 | Checked local gap between VIII263:3605 running and VIII263:3606 running | Checked local gap between VI234:3698 running and VI234:3699 running |
| 52 | Checked local gap between VIII263:3605 running and VIII263:3606 running | Checked local gap between VI234:3698 running and VI234:3699 running |
| 53 | VIII263:3606 running; VIII263:3607 running | VI234:3699 running; VI234:3700 running |
| 54 | VIII263:3608 running; VIII263:3609 running | VI234:3701 running; VI234:3702 running |
| 55 | VIII263:3608 running; VIII263:3609 running | VI234:3701 running; VI234:3702 running |
| 56 | VIII263:3609 running; VIII263:3610 running | VI234:3702 running; VI234:3703 running |
| 57 | VIII263:3610 running | VI234:3703 running |
| 58 | VIII263:3611 running | VI234:3704 running |
| 59 | VIII263:3612 running; VIII263:3613 running | VI234:3705 running; VI234:3706 running |
| 60 | VIII263:3613 running | VI234:3706 running |
| 61 | VIII263:3614 running | VI235:3707 running |
| 62 | VIII264:3615 running | VI235:3708 running |
| 63 | VIII264:3616 running | VI235:3709 running |
| 64 | VIII264:3617 running | VI235:3710 running |
| 65 | VIII264:3618 running | VI235:3711 running |
| 66 | VIII264:3619 running | VI235:3712 running |
| 67 | VIII264:3620 running | VI235:3713 running |
| 68 | VIII264:3620 running | VI235:3713 running |
| 69 | VIII264:3621 running; VIII264:3622 running | VI235:3714 running; VI235:3715 running |
| 70 | VIII264:3622 running | VI235:3715 running |
| 71 | VIII264:3623 running; VIII264:3624 running | VI235:3716 running; VI235:3717 running |
| 72 | VIII264:3625 running | VI235:3718 running |
| 73 | VIII264:3626 running | VI235:3719 running |
| 74 | VIII264:3627 running | VI235:3720 running |
| 75 | VIII264:3628 running | VI235:3721 running |
| 76 | VIII264:3629 running | VI235:3722 running |
| 77 | VIII265:3630 running | VI235:3723 running |
| 78 | VIII265:3631 running | VI235:3724 running |
| 79 | VIII265:3632 running | VI235:3725 running |
| 80 | VIII265:3633 running | VI235:3726 running |
| 81 | VIII265:3634 running | VI235:3727 running |
| 82 | VIII265:3635 running | VI235:3728 running |
| 83 | VIII265:3636 running | VI235:3729 running |
| 84 | VIII265:3637 running | VI235:3730 running |
| 85 | VIII265:3638 running | VI235:3731 running |
| 86 | VIII265:3639 running | VI236:3732 running |
| 87 | VIII265:3640 running | VI236:3733 running |
| 88 | VIII265:3641 running | VI236:3734 running |
| 89 | VIII265:3642 running; VIII265:3643 running | VI236:3735 running; VI236:3736 running |
| 90 | VIII265:3644 running; VIII265:3645 running; VIII265:3646 running | VI236:3737 running; VI236:3738 running; VI236:3739 running |
| 91 | Checked local gap between VIII265:3646 running and VIII265:3647 running | Checked local gap between VI236:3739 running and VI236:3740 running |
| 92 | Checked local gap between VIII265:3646 running and VIII265:3647 running | Checked local gap between VI236:3739 running and VI236:3740 running |
| 93 | VIII265:3647 running | VI236:3740 running |
| 94 | VIII265:3648 running; VIII265:3649 running | VI236:3741 running; VI236:3742 running |
| 95 | VIII265:3649 running | VI236:3742 running |
| 96 | VIII266:3650 running | VI236:3743 running |
| 97 | VIII266:3651 running | VI236:3744 running |
| 98 | VIII266:3652 running | VI236:3745 running |
| 99 | VIII266:3653 running | VI236:3746 running |
| 100 | VIII266:3654 running | VI236:3747 running |
| 101 | VIII266:3655 running | VI236:3748 running |
New Naqqali