Anooshirvan Answers the Mobad
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The old narrator and the prayer that goes unanswered
Moscow — VIII280:3885 running, VIII280:3886 running, VIII280:3886 running; VIII280:3887 running, VIII280:3887 running; VIII280:3888 running, VIII280:3889 running, VIII280:3890 running · Mohl — VI246:4000 running, VI247:4001 running, VI247:4001 running; VI247:4002 running, VI247:4002 running; VI247:4003 running, VI247:4004 running, VI247:4005 running · Ganjoor — sh83:1 running, sh83:2 running, sh83:2, sh83:3 running, sh83:3, sh83:4 running, sh83:5 running, sh83:6 running · Khaleghi — VII409:3929 running, VII409:3930 running, VII409:3930 running; VII409:3931 running, VII409:3931 running; VII409:3932 running, VII410:3933 running, VII410:3934 running
Moscow VIII p.280 · Mohl VI p.246 · Mohl VI p.247 · Ganjoor sh83:1 · Ganjoor sh83:2 · Ganjoor sh83:3 · Ganjoor sh83:4 · Ganjoor sh83:5 · Ganjoor sh83:6 · Khaleghi VII p.409 · Khaleghi VII p.410
The opening has two voices before the Shah is heard: a narrator learned in old speech and the Mobad whose questioning the old account preserves. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh connect the account with the champion and his book. English “Pahlavi account” makes a possible association of the epic idiom explicit. The Persian question asks what a worshipper should request secretly and how a fortunate answer might come, rather than how to approach a formal law. Khaleghi-Motlagh names the maker of time in the lifted-hands verse, while the other witnesses have the world. English “time’s Lord” keeps that larger register and supplies the striking image of the barred door for the Persian man’s tears and furrowed face.
7–12Measure in prayer and an open hand with wealth
Moscow — VIII280:3891 running, VIII280:3892 running, VIII280:3893 running, VIII280:3894 running; VIII280:3895 running, VIII280:3895 running, VIII280:3896 running · Mohl — VI247:4006 running, VI247:4007 running, VI247:4008 running, VI247:4009 running; VI247:4010 running, VI247:4010 running, VI247:4011 running · Ganjoor — sh83:7 running, sh83:8 running, sh83:9 running, sh83:10, sh83:11 running, sh83:11 running, sh83:12 running · Khaleghi — VII410:3935 running, VII410:3936 running, VII410:3937 running, VII410:3938 running; VII410:3939 running, VII410:3939 running, VII410:3940 running
Moscow VIII p.280 · Mohl VI p.247 · Ganjoor sh83:7 · Ganjoor sh83:8 · Ganjoor sh83:9 · Ganjoor sh83:10 · Ganjoor sh83:11 · Ganjoor sh83:12 · Khaleghi VII p.410
All four Persian texts answer the unanswered plea with a rule of proportion. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh describe a heart filled with blood when the request exceeds measure. The English “consuming taint” turns anguish into a moral cost without losing the rule that one should limit the wish itself. The king’s test for generosity likewise deals with surplus. The Persian imagines a man getting scattered wealth without having labored for it, and puts refusal to give between possession and unfitness for the throne. English “gathers gold” makes that unearned windfall less specific. Its “treasure cold” creates a sharp image for the refusal to circulate wealth, the conduct that makes Fortune recede in the following line.
13–18The branches of wisdom and what they nourish
Moscow — VIII280:3897 running, VIII281:3898 running, VIII281:3899 running, VIII281:3900 running, VIII281:3901 running, VIII281:3902 running · Mohl — VI247:4012 running, VI247:4013 running, VI247:4014 running, VI247:4015 running, VI247:4016 running, VI247:4017 running · Ganjoor — sh83:13 running, sh83:14 running, sh83:15 running, sh83:16 running, sh83:17 running, sh83:18 running · Khaleghi — VII410:3941 running, VII410:3942 running, VII410:3943 running, VII410:3944 running, VII411:3945 running, VII411:3946 running
Moscow VIII p.280 · Moscow VIII p.281 · Mohl VI p.247 · Ganjoor sh83:13 · Ganjoor sh83:14 · Ganjoor sh83:15 · Ganjoor sh83:16 · Ganjoor sh83:17 · Ganjoor sh83:18 · Khaleghi VII p.410 · Khaleghi VII p.411
The four running texts ask about the foundation, branches and leaves of wisdom. English “gathers fruit” makes the benefit of learning immediate, while “age by age” brings in duration that the question’s tree only implies. The learned person’s joy and the modesty of someone with good descent belong to the answers of Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh. In the next reply the Persian nurtures wisdom in order to nurture the soul. English “cherishes the wise” makes people the direct beneficiaries of the action. The soul’s gain remains clear in the next couplet. In Khaleghi-Motlagh’s fuller phrasing the lack of wisdom leads to an explicit series of anxieties and injury, close to the English enumeration.
19–24Learning, farr and the interrupted count
Moscow — VIII281:3902 running, VIII281:3903 running, VIII281:3904 running, VIII281:3905 running, VIII281:3906 running, VIII281:3907 running · Mohl — VI247:4017 running, VI247:4018 running, VI247:4019 running, VI247:4020 running, VI247:4021 running, VI247:4022 running · Ganjoor — sh83:18 running, sh83:19 running, sh83:20 running, sh83:21 running, sh83:22 running, sh83:23 running · Khaleghi — VII411:3946 running, VII411:3947 running, VII411:3948 running, VII411:3949 running, VII411:3950 running, VII411:3951 running
Moscow VIII p.281 · Mohl VI p.247 · Ganjoor sh83:18 · Ganjoor sh83:19 · Ganjoor sh83:20 · Ganjoor sh83:21 · Ganjoor sh83:22 · Ganjoor sh83:23 · Khaleghi VII p.411
Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor picture the wise person with farr taking the world beneath his wing. In Khaleghi-Motlagh the same relation takes the form of a test that the ignorant bearer of farr fails. English gives the affirmative combination, with “embrace” for the protective wing. Good name and lineage join wisdom and farr to make four, which heaven remembers in the Persian and appears to bestow in the English. The next answer begins with the aid of the ruler of the world and lists bounty, knowledge and the customs of the throne before the style of later ordinal numbers resumes. The English’s “First” and “Next” bridge that roughness while giving the reader an immediately intelligible sequence.
25–30The order of royal qualifications and the fate of a name
Moscow — VIII281:3908 running, VIII281:3909 running, VIII281:3911 running, VIII281:3910 running, Checked local running-text gap between VIII281:3910 running and VIII281:3911 running, VIII281:3912 running · Mohl — VI247:4023 running, VI247:4024 running, VI247:4025 running, VI248:4026 running, VI248:4027 running, VI248:4028 running · Ganjoor — sh83:24 running, sh83:25 running, sh83:27 running, sh83:26 running, Checked local gap after sh83:26, sh83:28 running · Khaleghi — VII411:3952 running, VII411:3953 running, VII411:3954 running, VII411:3955 running, Checked local running-text gap between VII411:3955 running and VII411:3954 running, VII411:3956 running
Moscow VIII p.281 · Mohl VI p.247 · Mohl VI p.248 · Ganjoor sh83:24 · Ganjoor sh83:25 · Ganjoor sh83:27 · Ganjoor sh83:26 · Ganjoor sh83:28 · Khaleghi VII p.411
In all four versions a ruler gives office to the deserving and refuses to let good or evil remain hidden. The running numbering calls these the sixth and seventh, and calls discriminating between friends and enemies the eighth. English renumbers its selected steps. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh give the eighth item before the statement that farr, wisdom, religion and favorable fortune together deserve the throne. English follows their order, Moscow and Ganjoor the reverse. Mohl also inserts a warning about turning away from these qualities. All four give the worthy ruler paradise and freedom from a bad name after death. The English uses the Mohl warning as a hinge and inverts those promised outcomes for the failed ruler.
31–36Greed, need and the turn toward speech
Moscow — VIII281:3913 running, VIII282:3914 running, VIII282:3915 running, VIII282:3916 running; VIII282:3917 running, VIII282:3918 running, VIII282:3918 running; VIII282:3919 running · Mohl — VI248:4029 running, VI248:4030 running, VI248:4031 running, VI248:4032 running; VI248:4033 running, VI248:4034 running, VI248:4034 running; VI248:4035 running · Ganjoor — sh83:29 running, sh83:30 running, sh83:31 running, sh83:32, sh83:33 running, sh83:34 running, sh83:34, sh83:35 running · Khaleghi — VII412:3957 running, VII412:3958 running, VII412:3959 running, VII412:3960 running; VII412:3961 running, VII412:3962 running, VII412:3962 running; VII412:3963 running
Moscow VIII p.281 · Moscow VIII p.282 · Mohl VI p.248 · Ganjoor sh83:29 · Ganjoor sh83:30 · Ganjoor sh83:31 · Ganjoor sh83:32 · Ganjoor sh83:33 · Ganjoor sh83:34 · Ganjoor sh83:35 · Khaleghi VII p.412
The Persian makes greed and need themselves two demons of bad nature. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh then associate wanting excess with the return of the corresponding demon. English makes the Divs the result of what greed and want do to noble minds, then introduces a positive desire for heaven and successful prayer. The direction matters. The Persian warning is against brimming accumulation and the habits that answer it, whereas the English describes piety that survives a glittering hoard. The following question links words with tears or with rank, treasure and joy across the four texts. By explicitly asking about kinds of speech, the English makes the transition from one moral taxonomy to another audible.
37–42From useful and measured speech to the disputed fourth kind
Moscow — VIII282:3920 running, VIII282:3921 running, VIII282:3922 running, VIII282:3923 running, VIII282:3924 running, VIII282:3925 running; VIII282:3926 running · Mohl — VI248:4036 running, VI248:4037 running, VI248:4038 running, VI248:4039 running, VI248:4040 running, VI248:4041 running; VI248:4042 running · Ganjoor — sh83:36 running, sh83:37 running, sh83:38 running, sh83:39 running, sh83:40 running, sh83:41, sh83:42 running · Khaleghi — VII412:3964 running, VII412:3965 running, VII412:3966 running, VII412:3967 running, VII413:3968 running, VII413:3969 running; VII413:3970 running
Moscow VIII p.282 · Mohl VI p.248 · Ganjoor sh83:36 · Ganjoor sh83:37 · Ganjoor sh83:38 · Ganjoor sh83:39 · Ganjoor sh83:40 · Ganjoor sh83:41 · Ganjoor sh83:42 · Khaleghi VII p.412 · Khaleghi VII p.413
All four witnesses give useful, harmless speech first and then associate a measured speaker with a prepared heart and words that remain. The English “passed away” explicates the contrast between what lasts in language and what happens to its speaker. The third kind in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor is timely speech, a quality also present in Khaleghi-Motlagh even where the ordinal is less explicit. English’s wit and laughter are one way to imagine a speaker who retains honor by knowing the moment. The essential divergence comes in the fourth kind. The four Persian texts praise a heart-pleasing, judicious storyteller who can cover old or new matter. The English recasts continuance and completion of a story as passing the time idly.
43–48The fifth speaker and the limits of learning
Moscow — VIII282:3927 running; VIII282:3928 running, VIII282:3929 running, VIII282:3929 running; VIII282:3931 running, VIII282:3930 running; VIII282:3931 running, VIII283:3932 running · Mohl — VI248:4043 running; VI248:4044 running, VI248:4045 running, VI248:4045 running; VI248:4046 running, VI248:4046 running; VI248:4047 running, VI248:4048 running · Ganjoor — sh83:43, sh83:44 running, sh83:45 running, sh83:45, sh83:47 running, sh83:46, sh83:47 running, sh83:48 running · Khaleghi — VII413:3971 running; VII413:3972 running, VII413:3973 running, VII413:3973 running; VII413:3974 running, VII413:3974 running; VII413:3975 running, VII413:3976 running
Moscow VIII p.282 · Moscow VIII p.283 · Mohl VI p.248 · Ganjoor sh83:43 · Ganjoor sh83:44 · Ganjoor sh83:45 · Ganjoor sh83:47 · Ganjoor sh83:46 · Ganjoor sh83:48 · Khaleghi VII p.413
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh describe the fifth speaker as warm, sweet in speech and soft in voice. His woven words satisfy the desire of the heart. English changes both his means and his result by making him a liar whose words ruin kingdoms and whose soul is burned. There is a real ethical contrast with the earlier harmless speech in the English, but the Persian builds a cumulative portrait of effective utterance. The adjacent learning question then depicts a soul kindled by knowledge. Order varies in the exchanges about learning from others and reaching its end. English gathers that material into one increasingly urgent inquiry, closing with the Persian’s direct claim that learning is dearer than crown and throne.
49–54A treasure that survives the person who keeps it
Moscow — VIII283:3933 running, VIII283:3934 running, VIII283:3935 running, VIII283:3936 running, VIII283:3937 running, VIII283:3938 running · Mohl — VI248:4049 running, VI248:4050 running, VI249:4051 running, VI249:4052 running, VI249:4053 running, VI249:4054 running · Ganjoor — sh83:49 running, sh83:50 running, sh83:51 running, sh83:52 running, sh83:53 running, sh83:54 running · Khaleghi — VII413:3977 running, VII413:3978 running, VII414:3979 running, VII414:3980 running, VII414:3981 running, VII414:3982 running
Moscow VIII p.283 · Mohl VI p.248 · Mohl VI p.249 · Ganjoor sh83:49 · Ganjoor sh83:50 · Ganjoor sh83:51 · Ganjoor sh83:52 · Ganjoor sh83:53 · Ganjoor sh83:54 · Khaleghi VII p.413 · Khaleghi VII p.414
The Mobad says he has seen no learner who need hear nothing further from the wise. The English frames this as an imagined declaration about an extraordinary mind and hears no such declaration. All four Persian running accounts ask who becomes sated with treasure before earth covers him, then say the door, pearl or distinction of knowledge stands higher than treasure. English drops that compact image and retains the comparison. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all give speech a survival as a reminder of its speaker. “When flesh and fortunes fail” makes the contrast corporeal and economic at once. The closing question returns the wisdom of advanced age to the question of whether an old person can still learn.
55–60Aging well and remembering the vanished kings
Moscow — VIII283:3939 running, VIII283:3940 running, VIII283:3941 running, VIII283:3942 running, VIII283:3943 running, VIII283:3944 running · Mohl — VI249:4055 running, VI249:4056 running, VI249:4057 running, VI249:4058 running, VI249:4059 running, VI249:4060 running · Ganjoor — sh83:55 running, sh83:56 running, sh83:57 running, sh83:58 running, sh83:59 running, sh83:60 running · Khaleghi — VII414:3983 running, VII414:3984 running, VII414:3985 running, VII414:3986 running, VII414:3987 running, VII414:3988 running
Moscow VIII p.283 · Mohl VI p.249 · Ganjoor sh83:55 · Ganjoor sh83:56 · Ganjoor sh83:57 · Ganjoor sh83:58 · Ganjoor sh83:59 · Ganjoor sh83:60 · Khaleghi VII p.414
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh contrast learned age with foolish youth, although the wording about a young person’s learning or the earth of his grave varies. English “inward spirit” develops what the old person keeps when his calendar years advance. The Mobad’s question about recalling kings comes with a cold breath from the liver or heart. English takes it as the king’s fearful sigh. The running response invokes the custom of departure and then the harsh fact of leaving the world after holding it by sword and justice. English says coming to the throne and rising to leave in two parallel movements. That gives a clear shape to the regret even where the earlier Persian lines vary in who recalls the kings and how often.
61–66Deeds, few words and prayer before the fire
Moscow — VIII283:3945 running, VIII283:3946 running, VIII283:3947 running, VIII283:3948 running, VIII283:3949 running, VIII284:3950 running · Mohl — VI249:4061 running, VI249:4062 running, VI249:4063 running, VI249:4064 running, VI249:4065 running, VI249:4066 running · Ganjoor — sh83:61 running, sh83:62 running, sh83:63 running, sh83:64 running, sh83:65 running, sh83:66 running · Khaleghi — VII414:3989 running, VII415:3990 running, VII415:3991 running, VII415:3992 running, VII415:3993 running, VII415:3994 running
Moscow VIII p.283 · Moscow VIII p.284 · Mohl VI p.249 · Ganjoor sh83:61 · Ganjoor sh83:62 · Ganjoor sh83:63 · Ganjoor sh83:64 · Ganjoor sh83:65 · Ganjoor sh83:66 · Khaleghi VII p.414 · Khaleghi VII p.415
The Mobad asks why the king used to speak more freely about recent and ancient affairs. The Persian reply in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh puts enough words against the search for effect through deeds. English “deeds must prove” catches that movement and makes the deeds a test of prior speech. The prayer question then has a pointed textual difference. Moscow and Ganjoor refer to being before the kings just mentioned. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh expressly say before the fire. The English names the sacred fire, so this concrete ritual detail has independent running-text support. The longer praise and greater supplication then lead to a reply shared across the four, that Yazdan raises the worshipper out of the dust.
67–72The worshipper’s obligation and the favor of the sphere
Moscow — VIII284:3951 running, VIII284:3952 running, VIII284:3953 running, VIII284:3954 running, VIII284:3955 running, VIII284:3956 running · Mohl — VI249:4067 running, VI249:4068 running, VI249:4069 running, VI249:4070 running, VI249:4071 running, VI249:4072 running · Ganjoor — sh83:67 running, sh83:68 running, sh83:69 running, sh83:70 running, sh83:71 running, sh83:72 running · Khaleghi — VII415:3995 running, VII415:3996 running, VII415:3997 running, VII415:3998 running, VII415:3999 running, VII415:4000 running
Moscow VIII p.284 · Mohl VI p.249 · Ganjoor sh83:67 · Ganjoor sh83:68 · Ganjoor sh83:69 · Ganjoor sh83:70 · Ganjoor sh83:71 · Ganjoor sh83:72 · Khaleghi VII p.415
The running accounts grant the worshipper influence with the turning sky and make the world serve him. English “the gift He gave” places the emphasis on delegation. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh also warn that the worshipper who fails to know the gift’s worth deserves continued harm. The English “meager breath” makes insufficient thanks the specific failure. The next petitioner contrasts the king’s gains with the ill-wishers’ bloody hearts. Knowledge is the gain in Moscow and Ganjoor, while Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh give joy, as the English does. The English then turns the Persian rival’s abandonment of evil into weeping defeat, personifying what the king’s farr is supposed to accomplish.
73–78From the mace to prudence at sixty
Moscow — VIII284:3957 running, VIII284:3958 running, VIII284:3959 running, VIII284:3960 running, VIII284:3961 running, VIII284:3962 running · Mohl — VI249:4073 running, VI249:4074 running, VI249:4075 running, VI250:4076 running, VI250:4077 running, VI250:4078 running · Ganjoor — sh83:73 running, sh83:74 running, sh83:75 running, sh83:76 running, sh83:77 running, sh83:78 running · Khaleghi — VII415:4001 running, VII415:4002 running, VII415:4003 running, VII416:4004 running, VII416:4005 running, VII416:4006 running
Moscow VIII p.284 · Mohl VI p.249 · Mohl VI p.250 · Ganjoor sh83:73 · Ganjoor sh83:74 · Ganjoor sh83:75 · Ganjoor sh83:76 · Ganjoor sh83:77 · Ganjoor sh83:78 · Khaleghi VII p.415 · Khaleghi VII p.416
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all have the king’s mace in the line that precedes the contrast of east and west. In the second phrase some read his throne or royal splendor and others his purpose or onset. English keeps the heavy mace vividly aloft and puts both kinds of authority into “my might.” The Mobad then compares quick attack in the east with patience and delay in the west. No military geography is needed to follow the king’s explanation, which contrasts a young man untroubled by anticipated pain with the need for forbearance at sixty. The English “gentler road” brings that practical change in conduct into the metaphorical language of a lifetime’s journey.
79–84Counsel and largess in the second part of life
Moscow — VIII284:3963 running, VIII284:3964 running, VIII284:3965 running, VIII284:3966 running, VIII284:3967 running, VIII284:3968 running · Mohl — VI250:4079 running, VI250:4080 running, VI250:4081 running, VI250:4082 running, VI250:4083 running, VI250:4084 running · Ganjoor — sh83:79 running, sh83:80 running, sh83:81 running, sh83:82 running, sh83:83 running, sh83:84 running · Khaleghi — VII416:4007 running, VII416:4008 running, VII416:4009 running, VII416:4010 running, VII416:4011 running, VII416:4012 running
Moscow VIII p.284 · Mohl VI p.250 · Ganjoor sh83:79 · Ganjoor sh83:80 · Ganjoor sh83:81 · Ganjoor sh83:82 · Ganjoor sh83:83 · Ganjoor sh83:84 · Khaleghi VII p.416
The king’s younger strengths and present knowledge, counsel, and distribution of treasure belong to all four editions. His claim that the revolving sphere is his battle armor also belongs to the Persian. English turns that broad image into a breastplate where he stands, making protection personal. The next question contrasts the long speech of former rulers with his shorter speech and greater justice in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh. English gives him shorter speech and more secrets, carrying the previous division between public and private matter into that line. The running answer places divine help before freedom from care. English keeps that order and recasts having the Creator as an ally as trusting the Creator’s decree.
85–90Fear, prudent conduct and the royal cup
Moscow — VIII285:3969 running, VIII285:3970 running, VIII285:3971 running, VIII285:3972 running, VIII285:3973 running · Mohl — VI250:4085 running, VI250:4086 running, VI250:4087 running, VI250:4088 running, VI250:4089 running · Ganjoor — sh83:85 running, sh83:86 running, sh83:87 running, sh83:88 running, sh83:89 running · Khaleghi — VII416:4013 running, VII416:4014 running, VII416:4015 running, VII416:4016 running, VII417:4017 running
Moscow VIII p.285 · Mohl VI p.250 · Ganjoor sh83:85 · Ganjoor sh83:86 · Ganjoor sh83:87 · Ganjoor sh83:88 · Ganjoor sh83:89 · Khaleghi VII p.416 · Khaleghi VII p.417
The English makes “The Maker guards this kingdom” resolve a difficult reference to whoever has been made the world’s guardian. The four Persian accounts surround the point with divine support and a ruler who does not burden his body with pain. The next answer on harm and wisdom is compact. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh connect knowledge with refusing needless fear, though their construction differs. English makes prudent conduct an active defense. At the banquet the Persian rulers fail to remember their good name over the cup. The English supplies drunken pleasure as the cause. This reads well against the king’s ensuing claim that his name has overcome the cup, a local opposition more substantial than the general claim that prior kings could feast in peace.
91–96Facing Time and deciding what medicine can do
Moscow — VIII285:3974 running, VIII285:3975 running; VIII285:3976 running, VIII285:3977 running, VIII285:3978 running, VIII285:3979 running, VIII285:3980 running; VIII285:3981 running · Mohl — VI250:4090 running, VI250:4091 running; VI250:4092 running, VI250:4093 running, VI250:4094 running, VI250:4095 running, VI250:4096 running; VI250:4097 running · Ganjoor — sh83:90 running, sh83:91, sh83:92 running, sh83:93 running, sh83:94 running, sh83:95 running, sh83:96, sh83:97 running · Khaleghi — VII417:4018 running, VII417:4019 running; VII417:4020 running, VII417:4021 running, VII417:4022 running, VII417:4023 running, VII417:4024 running; VII417:4025 running
Moscow VIII p.285 · Mohl VI p.250 · Ganjoor sh83:90 · Ganjoor sh83:91 · Ganjoor sh83:92 · Ganjoor sh83:93 · Ganjoor sh83:94 · Ganjoor sh83:95 · Ganjoor sh83:96 · Ganjoor sh83:97 · Khaleghi VII p.417
The running texts oppose the king’s name to his cup and describe his spirit facing, receiving or accepting Time. English makes Time a servant to his spirit, which reverses the direction of accommodation and heightens royal mastery. The adjacent medical answer limits that mastery. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all say the person whose time has not come is kept by the turning of time, regardless of treatment. Once departure is at hand, caution cannot turn time back. The English renders the medical argument as a concise conditional and adds the image of heaven withholding a final decree. That imagery makes the two stages clear while also showing the limits of the earlier assertion that Time itself serves the king.
97–102Praise, fear and a household that survives
Moscow — VIII285:3980 running; VIII285:3981 running, VIII285:3982 running, VIII285:3983 running, VIII285:3984 running, VIII285:3985 running, VIII286:3986 running · Mohl — VI250:4096 running; VI250:4097 running, VI250:4098 running, VI250:4099 running, VI250:4100 running, VI251:4101 running, VI251:4102 running · Ganjoor — sh83:96, sh83:97 running, sh83:98 running, sh83:99 running, sh83:100 running, sh83:101 running, sh83:102 running · Khaleghi — VII417:4024 running; VII417:4025 running, VII417:4026 running, VII417:4027 running, VII417:4028 running, VII418:4029 running, VII418:4030 running
Moscow VIII p.285 · Moscow VIII p.286 · Mohl VI p.250 · Mohl VI p.251 · Ganjoor sh83:96 · Ganjoor sh83:97 · Ganjoor sh83:98 · Ganjoor sh83:99 · Ganjoor sh83:100 · Ganjoor sh83:101 · Ganjoor sh83:102 · Khaleghi VII p.417 · Khaleghi VII p.418
The Mobad hears the king praise the Maker and sees him remain worried. The king’s heart agrees with the turning sphere in the four Persian witnesses. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh make fear a motive for inflated praise and say one should not look for the secret of the subject’s heart. English converts this restraint into a declared wish to see through public flattery. That change makes the ruler more investigative, in keeping with the earlier chapter’s reporting system, but alters the answer’s parting statement. The question about children then moves from political speech to private continuity. English explicitly says memory and mind, effectively drawing out the Persian claim that someone who leaves a child will not go hidden.
103–108What children and contentment keep people from doing
Moscow — VIII286:3987 running, VIII286:3988 running, VIII286:3989 running, VIII286:3990 running, VIII286:3991 running, VIII286:3992 running · Mohl — VI251:4103 running, VI251:4104 running, VI251:4105 running, VI251:4106 running, VI251:4107 running, VI251:4108 running · Ganjoor — sh83:103 running, sh83:104 running, sh83:105 running, sh83:106 running, sh83:107 running, sh83:108 running · Khaleghi — VII418:4031 running, VII418:4032 running, VII418:4033 running, VII418:4034 running, VII418:4035 running, VII418:4036 running
Moscow VIII p.286 · Mohl VI p.251 · Ganjoor sh83:103 · Ganjoor sh83:104 · Ganjoor sh83:105 · Ganjoor sh83:106 · Ganjoor sh83:107 · Ganjoor sh83:108 · Khaleghi VII p.418
All four texts join sweetness from a child to avoiding evil and a less painful departure, with the child seeing the parent’s pale face. English adds a tear to specify the tender human end of the scene. The next answer puts Time’s reins into the hand of the worshipper. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh explain the relative ease of such a life by the absence of striving for excess. English “needing no more gold” turns the excess into a tangible economic temptation. The separate question about good deeds asks why there can still be regret. The English anticipates the thankless recipient before the Persian answer names him, making the transition to the price of intending good unusually direct.
109–114The market where good deeds survive death
Moscow — VIII286:3993 running, VIII286:3994 running, VIII286:3995 running, VIII286:3996 running, VIII286:3997 running, VIII286:3998 running · Mohl — VI251:4109 running, VI251:4110 running, VI251:4111 running, VI251:4112 running, VI251:4113 running, VI251:4114 running · Ganjoor — sh83:109 running, sh83:110 running, sh83:111 running, sh83:112 running, sh83:113 running, sh83:114 running · Khaleghi — VII418:4037 running, VII418:4038 running, VII418:4039 running, VII418:4040 running, VII418:4041 running, VII419:4042 running
Moscow VIII p.286 · Mohl VI p.251 · Ganjoor sh83:109 · Ganjoor sh83:110 · Ganjoor sh83:111 · Ganjoor sh83:112 · Ganjoor sh83:113 · Ganjoor sh83:114 · Khaleghi VII p.418 · Khaleghi VII p.419
The last reply about helping the ungrateful yields to a harder question: if good and bad people alike die, what is the value of doing good? The Persian gives the evildoer’s erased name and Time counting the righteous person’s breath or tracks, with lexical variation. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh give good conduct a ready market, the image English places explicitly in the human mind. Their answer says the upright dead person has not really died and has committed his soul to Yazdan. English lets the body die and the name remain. This practical expansion joins the closing lines of the chapter, where remembrance of justice becomes the evidence for how a ruler can outlive his physical reign.
115–120The pain that king and subject alike leave behind
Moscow — VIII286:3999 running; VIII286:4000 running, VIII286:4001 running, VIII286:4002 running, VIII287:4003 running, Checked local running-text gap between VIII287:4003 running and VIII287:4004 running, VIII287:4004 running · Mohl — VI251:4115 running, VI251:4116 running, VI251:4117 running, VI251:4118 running, VI251:4119 running, VI251:4120 running · Ganjoor — sh83:115, sh83:116 running, sh83:117 running, sh83:118 running, sh83:119 running, Checked local gap after sh83:119, sh83:120 running · Khaleghi — VII419:4043 running; VII419:4044 running, VII419:4045 running, VII419:4046 running, VII419:4047 running, Checked local running-text gap between VII419:4047 running and VII419:4048 running, VII419:4048 running
Moscow VIII p.286 · Moscow VIII p.287 · Mohl VI p.251 · Ganjoor sh83:115 · Ganjoor sh83:116 · Ganjoor sh83:117 · Ganjoor sh83:118 · Ganjoor sh83:119 · Ganjoor sh83:120 · Khaleghi VII p.419
Moscow and Ganjoor put a bad life’s beginning and end before the line saying that a bad name prevents rest. Khaleghi-Motlagh includes both, while Mohl moves straight to the failure of rest. English joins the diagnosis and the bad memory in one couplet. The imperfectly clear Persian question about what is above or worse than death becomes an explicit statement that death is the worst ill, followed by the possibility of a pure soul after leaving earth. Mohl then gives the additional assurance that both Shah and subject pass from the world’s fear and pain, as the English does. The other three running accounts move from mourning a life of fear to the comparison between kinds of distress.
121–126Grief as a weight and freedom from it as wealth
Moscow — VIII287:4005 running, VIII287:4006 running, Checked local running-text gap between VIII287:4006 running and VIII287:4007 running, VIII287:4007 running · Mohl — VI251:4121 running, VI251:4122 running, VI251:4123 running, VI251:4124 running, VI251:4125 running · Ganjoor — sh83:121 running, sh83:122 running, Checked local gap after sh83:122, sh83:123 running · Khaleghi — VII419:4049 running, VII419:4050 running, Checked local running-text gap between VII419:4050 running and VII419:4051 running, VII419:4051 running
Moscow VIII p.287 · Mohl VI p.251 · Ganjoor sh83:121 · Ganjoor sh83:122 · Ganjoor sh83:123 · Khaleghi VII p.419
The four witnesses make grief comparable to a mountain and ask whether there can be fear apart from grief. The English adds anger to make three emotional burdens and then gathers them under grief. Mohl separately asks how people can be released from the tearful business of the world and answers through the knowledge that leaves the knowing man at ease. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh move directly to the person whose treasure is greatest, without running that exchange locally. All four make ease or the absence of distress the form of treasure that wins. English “greater treasure than the rest possess” makes the comparison explicit and leaves money behind without abandoning the chapter’s recurrent play on what wealth consists in.
127–132Shame, ignorance and concealed wrongdoing
Moscow — VIII287:4008 running, VIII287:4009 running, VIII287:4010 running, Checked local running-text gap between VIII287:4010 running and VIII287:4011 running, VIII287:4011 running, VIII287:4012 running · Mohl — VI252:4126 running, VI252:4127 running, VI252:4128 running, VI252:4129 running, VI252:4130 running, VI252:4131 running · Ganjoor — sh83:124 running, sh83:125 running, sh83:126 running, Checked local gap after sh83:126, sh83:127 running, sh83:128 running · Khaleghi — VII420:4052 running, VII420:4053 running, VII420:4054 running, VII420:4055 running, VII420:4056 running, VII420:4057 running
Moscow VIII p.287 · Mohl VI p.252 · Ganjoor sh83:124 · Ganjoor sh83:125 · Ganjoor sh83:126 · Ganjoor sh83:127 · Ganjoor sh83:128 · Khaleghi VII p.420
The Persian king applies shame and a soft voice to women, then compares male ignorance to a lifelong prison. English preserves the gendered division in the ruler’s words and clarifies the prison as a form of captivity. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh have the additional question about who is less troubled, which Moscow and Ganjoor leave implicit. English supplies “the shameless man.” In the following line Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor describe outward devotion with a body carrying sin, while the critical running text has the different reading without guilt. The English keeps the burden of wrongdoing and makes the absence of shame overt. The following question about right conduct returns to the test of how a person behaves under gain and loss.
133–138Forbearance, giving and striving for Yazdan
Moscow — VIII287:4013 running, VIII287:4014 running, VIII287:4015 running, VIII288:4016 running, VIII288:4017 running, VIII288:4018 running · Mohl — VI252:4132 running, VI252:4133 running, VI252:4134 running, VI252:4135 running, VI252:4136 running, VI252:4137 running · Ganjoor — sh83:129 running, sh83:130 running, sh83:131 running, sh83:132 running, sh83:133 running, sh83:134 running · Khaleghi — VII420:4058 running, VII420:4059 running, VII420:4060 running, VII420:4061 running, VII421:4062 running, VII421:4063 running
Moscow VIII p.287 · Moscow VIII p.288 · Mohl VI p.252 · Ganjoor sh83:129 · Ganjoor sh83:130 · Ganjoor sh83:131 · Ganjoor sh83:132 · Ganjoor sh83:133 · Ganjoor sh83:134 · Khaleghi VII p.420 · Khaleghi VII p.421
All four texts make the upright person refrain from girding himself for evil through profit or loss. The English “toils” sharpens the affirmative conduct found especially in Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh, next to Moscow and Ganjoor’s different wording of the first act. Forbearance heads the list of good dispositions, followed by generosity that expects no return and holy effort born from a clean and wise soul. The English preserves that progression and turns the absence of a return into freedom from concern. In Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh the washing of darkness out of the heart gives the gift an inward consequence. English gives it a quieter emotional one, preparing the questions about what the heart fears and what sort of gift raises the giver.
139–144The worthiness of a recipient and the unruly world
Moscow — VIII288:4019 running, VIII288:4020 running, VIII288:4021 running, VIII288:4022 running, VIII288:4023 running, VIII288:4024 running · Mohl — VI252:4138 running, VI252:4139 running, VI252:4140 running, VI252:4141 running, VI252:4142 running, VI252:4143 running · Ganjoor — sh83:135 running, sh83:136 running, sh83:137 running, sh83:138 running, sh83:139 running, sh83:140 running · Khaleghi — VII421:4064 running, VII421:4065 running, VII421:4066 running, VII421:4067 running, VII421:4068 running, VII421:4069 running
Moscow VIII p.288 · Mohl VI p.252 · Ganjoor sh83:135 · Ganjoor sh83:136 · Ganjoor sh83:137 · Ganjoor sh83:138 · Ganjoor sh83:139 · Ganjoor sh83:140 · Khaleghi VII p.421
The four Persian accounts make one’s own toil and conduct the source of fear. They then advise withholding nothing from worthy people, regardless of profit or loss. English “those whom need may strike” makes need the primary test. The questions on the workings of the world then put the priest’s observation of disordered practices beside the apparent uselessness of the turning wheel. English asks more directly whether people must accept what comes. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh bring the answer to the judge above all judges. English names Yazdan over the ancient sky and lets that explicit hierarchy carry the shift from the mechanics of fortune to the relationship between cosmos, conduct and a divine first cause.
145–150The unpartnered judge and the place of the soul
Moscow — VIII288:4025 running, VIII288:4026 running, VIII288:4027 running, VIII288:4027 running; VIII288:4028 running, VIII288:4028 running, VIII288:4029 running · Mohl — VI252:4144 running, VI252:4145 running, VI252:4146 running, VI252:4146 running; VI252:4147 running, VI252:4147 running, VI252:4148 running · Ganjoor — sh83:141 running, sh83:142 running, sh83:143 running, sh83:143, sh83:144 running, sh83:144 running, sh83:145 running · Khaleghi — VII421:4070 running, VII421:4071 running, VII421:4072 running, VII421:4072 running; VII422:4073 running, VII422:4073 running, VII422:4074 running
Moscow VIII p.288 · Mohl VI p.252 · Ganjoor sh83:141 · Ganjoor sh83:142 · Ganjoor sh83:143 · Ganjoor sh83:144 · Ganjoor sh83:145 · Khaleghi VII p.421 · Khaleghi VII p.422
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh all tell the listener to ascribe good and evil to the power without a partner, whose work has neither end nor beginning. English fleshes out the command “Be” as the act by which judgment, rule and law come into existence. In Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor the declaration of enduring being is comparatively straightforward. Khaleghi-Motlagh’s second hemistich uses the difficult relation between being and nonbeing. The English follows the clearer line of continuous being. The next question changes scale, treating a body as the soul’s temporary house. “Which of the two feels pain” turns the lodging image into a precise inquiry about which occupant of that arrangement suffers.
151–156Pain in the body and weariness in desire
Moscow — VIII288:4030 running, VIII289:4031 running, VIII289:4032 running, VIII289:4033 running, VIII289:4034 running · Mohl — VI252:4149 running, VI252:4150 running, VI253:4151 running, VI253:4152 running, VI253:4153 running · Ganjoor — sh83:146 running, sh83:147 running, sh83:148 running, sh83:149 running, sh83:150 running · Khaleghi — VII422:4075 running, VII422:4076 running, VII422:4077 running, VII422:4078 running, VII422:4079 running
Moscow VIII p.288 · Moscow VIII p.289 · Mohl VI p.252 · Mohl VI p.253 · Ganjoor sh83:146 · Ganjoor sh83:147 · Ganjoor sh83:148 · Ganjoor sh83:149 · Ganjoor sh83:150 · Khaleghi VII p.422
The Persian locates bodily pain in the skin or physical casing while its living core remains. All four witnesses then deny the body understanding once life has passed. English’s additional description of dissolution develops that consequence through an image of order failing. The Mobad next asks from whom greed and need can be hidden. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh say a sage does well to keep the two away or apart, and agree that greed can never be sated with treasure. The English says the wise can discern need and makes greed’s agent its slave. “Past all boundary and measure” usefully returns to the opening maxim on excessive prayer, bringing the chapter’s two vocabularies of restraint together.
157–162Which ruler deserves praise after death?
Moscow — VIII289:4035 running, Checked local running-text gap between VIII289:4035 running and VIII289:4036 running, VIII289:4036 running, VIII289:4037 running, VIII289:4038 running, VIII289:4039 running · Mohl — VI253:4154 running, VI253:4155 running, VI253:4156 running, VI253:4157 running, VI253:4158 running, VI253:4159 running · Ganjoor — sh83:151 running, Checked local gap after sh83:151, sh83:152 running, sh83:153 running, sh83:154 running, sh83:155 running · Khaleghi — VII422:4080 running, Checked local running-text gap between VII422:4080 running and VII423:4081 running, VII423:4081 running, VII423:4082 running, VII423:4083 running, VII423:4084 running
Moscow VIII p.289 · Mohl VI p.253 · Ganjoor sh83:151 · Ganjoor sh83:152 · Ganjoor sh83:153 · Ganjoor sh83:154 · Ganjoor sh83:155 · Khaleghi VII p.422 · Khaleghi VII p.423
The chief question asks which king excels in understanding, counsel, custom and faith. Mohl alone in this local running sequence adds a distinct address asking whom one should praise after his death. The English gives that question its own couplet. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh proceed from the initial question to the description of a pious, upright ruler. All four make him grateful to his maker, a giver of hope to the good and fear to the wicked, and a king who equips his army from his own property. English “foils the plots” actively develops the Persian act of directing his trouble or effort toward the ill-wisher. The criterion shifts from piety to material responsibility without abandoning either.
163–168Sages, enemies and the starting point of worship
Moscow — VIII289:4040 running, VIII289:4041 running, VIII289:4042 running, VIII289:4043 running, VIII289:4044 running, VIII289:4045 running · Mohl — VI253:4160 running, VI253:4161 running, VI253:4162 running, VI253:4163 running, VI253:4164 running, VI253:4165 running · Ganjoor — sh83:156 running, sh83:157 running, sh83:158 running, sh83:159 running, sh83:160 running, sh83:161 running · Khaleghi — VII423:4085 running, VII423:4086 running, VII423:4087 running, VII423:4088 running, VII423:4089 running, VII423:4090 running
Moscow VIII p.289 · Mohl VI p.253 · Ganjoor sh83:156 · Ganjoor sh83:157 · Ganjoor sh83:158 · Ganjoor sh83:159 · Ganjoor sh83:160 · Ganjoor sh83:161 · Khaleghi VII p.423
The advice to consult the wise and keep good and evil from an enemy appears in all four Persian accounts. English makes the hidden thing “his secrets,” a broad but intelligible condensation. The transition then asks what worship consists in and who inclines toward Yazdan through good. Khaleghi-Motlagh’s answer starts with a seeker of finer points, where Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor have a difficult phrase beginning with a dark disposition. English “meanings finely spun” takes the next image, a single fine hair or point, as its main cue. The four proceed to divine oneness and the paradox of both security in God and fear of God. English resolves the juxtaposition by attaching each emotion to a different course of conduct.
169–174The world’s hidden mind and the conduct of worship
Moscow — VIII289:4046 running, VIII289:4047 running, VIII289:4048 running, VIII290:4049 running, VIII290:4050 running, VIII290:4051 running · Mohl — VI253:4166 running, VI253:4167 running, VI253:4168 running, VI253:4169 running, VI253:4170 running, VI253:4171 running · Ganjoor — sh83:162 running, sh83:163 running, sh83:164 running, sh83:165 running, sh83:166 running, sh83:167 running · Khaleghi — VII423:4091 running, VII423:4092 running, VII423:4093 running, VII423:4094 running, VII423:4095 running, VII424:4096 running
Moscow VIII p.289 · Moscow VIII p.290 · Mohl VI p.253 · Ganjoor sh83:162 · Ganjoor sh83:163 · Ganjoor sh83:164 · Ganjoor sh83:165 · Ganjoor sh83:166 · Ganjoor sh83:167 · Khaleghi VII p.423 · Khaleghi VII p.424
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh promise honor to the good-hearted seeker of the road and put the evildoer’s baggage or soul in Hell. English preserves that destination, with the body’s burden standing for the moral weight of conduct. The world that conceals its secrets is inhospitable to unwarranted confidence. English “do not feel settled” also recalls the body as a temporary lodging. The four then give religion, wisdom as the heart’s teacher, and separation from the guilty. English turns the warning against being deceived by Time into “do not let fortune make a fool of you,” giving practical force to an otherwise abstract relation. The pairing of self-discipline and company makes this stretch of advice broader than a statement of belief alone.
175–180Choosing lasting company over passing pleasure
Moscow — VIII290:4052 running, VIII290:4053 running, Checked local running-text gap between VIII290:4053 running and VIII290:4054 running, VIII290:4054 running, VIII290:4055 running, VIII290:4056 running · Mohl — VI253:4172 running, VI253:4173 running, VI253:4174 running, VI253:4175 running, VI254:4176 running, VI254:4177 running · Ganjoor — sh83:168 running, sh83:169 running, Checked local gap after sh83:169, sh83:170 running, sh83:171 running, sh83:172 running · Khaleghi — VII424:4097 running, VII424:4098 running, VII424:4099 bracketed running, VII424:4100 running, VII424:4101 running, VII424:4102 running
Moscow VIII p.290 · Mohl VI p.253 · Mohl VI p.254 · Ganjoor sh83:168 · Ganjoor sh83:169 · Ganjoor sh83:170 · Ganjoor sh83:171 · Ganjoor sh83:172 · Khaleghi VII p.424
All four have the next world, companionship with the wise, and joy that lasts. The negative construction around sorrow for the next world is difficult, and the English changes it into an active request to consider that world. Mohl then explicitly says that worldly joy passes and a discerning person does not count it. Khaleghi-Motlagh prints the related verse in brackets. Moscow and Ganjoor give knowledge and judgment immediately after the company of the wise, so the extra contrast there remains a local running gap. English retains that distinction and then speaks of an old world and a young hearer. The final warning about being intoxicated by joy, music and bad company adds ordinary social behavior to the counsel of moderation.
181–186What to pardon, what to share and what to guard
Moscow — VIII290:4057 running, VIII290:4058 running, VIII290:4059 running, VIII290:4060 running, VIII290:4061 running, VIII290:4062 running · Mohl — VI254:4178 running, VI254:4179 running, VI254:4180 running, VI254:4181 running, VI254:4182 running, VI254:4183 running · Ganjoor — sh83:173 running, sh83:174 running, sh83:175 running, sh83:176 running, sh83:177 running, sh83:178 running · Khaleghi — VII424:4103 running, VII424:4104 running, VII424:4105 running, VII424:4106 running, VII424:4107 running, VII424:4108 running
Moscow VIII p.290 · Mohl VI p.254 · Ganjoor sh83:173 · Ganjoor sh83:174 · Ganjoor sh83:175 · Ganjoor sh83:176 · Ganjoor sh83:177 · Ganjoor sh83:178 · Khaleghi VII p.424
The four Persian versions say to turn away from what cannot last and to pardon what can be pardoned. The English reads the second instruction through giving, a sense made attractive by the next command to withhold nothing from a friend. The extraordinary eye, brain and skin make the command more costly than a general exhortation to benevolence. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh then give the two friends no need of a mediator. English translates that shared principle directly, and keeps the immediate warning about an enemy as a contrast with such trust. The final contrast sets worth, shame and fitness against a tongue that proves stronger than merit, making “boasting” an expressive name for that imbalance.
187–192How to answer a provocation without matching it
Moscow — VIII290:4063 running, VIII291:4064 running, VIII291:4065 running, VIII291:4066 running, VIII291:4067 running, VIII291:4068 running · Mohl — VI254:4184 running, VI254:4185 running, VI254:4186 running, VI254:4187 running, VI254:4188 running, VI254:4189 running · Ganjoor — sh83:179 running, sh83:180 running, sh83:181 running, sh83:182 running, sh83:183 running, sh83:184 running · Khaleghi — VII425:4109 running, VII425:4110 running, VII425:4111 running, VII425:4112 running, VII425:4113 running, VII425:4114 running
Moscow VIII p.290 · Moscow VIII p.291 · Mohl VI p.254 · Ganjoor sh83:179 · Ganjoor sh83:180 · Ganjoor sh83:181 · Ganjoor sh83:182 · Ganjoor sh83:183 · Ganjoor sh83:184 · Khaleghi VII p.425
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh do not identify riches with rank or a lack of possessions with contempt. English makes high position thin air and applies the other side of the distinction to a poor man in distress. The analogy extends to speech: if a suspicious person exceeds measure, one should answer with measured, fresh and kindly words. In the four Persian sequences, modesty or regard is closely followed by an admission of regret, with room for different agents in the difficult line. English supplies the other speaker’s return and appeal for pardon. The passage then returns from a quarrel to idleness, suggesting that restraint is active work, as purposive as doing a task rather than sitting idle.
193–198Patience, diligence and praise beyond the proper measure
Moscow — VIII291:4069 running; VIII291:4070 running, VIII291:4071 running, VIII291:4072 running, VIII291:4073 running, VIII291:4074 running, VIII291:4075 running · Mohl — VI254:4190 running, VI254:4191 running, VI254:4192 running, VI254:4193 running, VI254:4194 running, VI254:4195 running · Ganjoor — sh83:185, sh83:186 running, sh83:187 running, sh83:188 running, sh83:189 running, sh83:190 running, sh83:191 running · Khaleghi — VII425:4115 running; VII425:4116 running, VII425:4117 running, VII425:4118 running, VII425:4119 running, VII426:4120 running, VII426:4121 running
Moscow VIII p.291 · Mohl VI p.254 · Ganjoor sh83:185 · Ganjoor sh83:186 · Ganjoor sh83:187 · Ganjoor sh83:188 · Ganjoor sh83:189 · Ganjoor sh83:190 · Ganjoor sh83:191 · Khaleghi VII p.425 · Khaleghi VII p.426
The English’s call to diligence and learning condenses more than one Persian injunction in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh. Mohl gives the positive call to work and heed knowledge without the separate preceding verse on work and shame. All four then warn against actions whose end is regret and command pity for a sufferer. The wise man makes the heart forbearing and knows the measure of his own skill. That link lets the last Persian couplet ask what happens if a friend praises him beyond this measure. English changes the praise to help that his friends bestow. Its “worth and eminence” keeps the upward movement, but the loss of excess praise makes the verdict more straightforwardly favorable than the running text’s caution.
199–202Truthful worship and the one straight road
Moscow — VIII291:4076 running, VIII291:4077 running, VIII291:4078 running; VIII292:4079 running, VIII292:4080 running · Mohl — VI254:4196 running, VI254:4197 running, VI254:4198 running, VI254:4199 running · Ganjoor — sh83:192 running, sh83:193 running, sh83:194, sh83:195 running, sh83:196 running · Khaleghi — VII426:4122 running, VII426:4123 running, VII426:4124 running; VII426:4125 running, VII426:4126 running
Moscow VIII p.291 · Moscow VIII p.292 · Mohl VI p.254 · Ganjoor sh83:192 · Ganjoor sh83:193 · Ganjoor sh83:194 · Ganjoor sh83:195 · Ganjoor sh83:196 · Khaleghi VII p.426
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh put scattered wealth beside right worship and truthful practice. English “left behind” makes that wealth a possession relinquished at life’s end, though the Persian concerns how a religious person regards its dispersal. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh separately connect the man of faith with leaves or branches, recalling the earlier language of wisdom. Mohl passes directly from truthful practice to the declaration of one road. English keeps that directness and turns the wish for a just ruler into a direct address to the Shah. Its promise of a memory burning bright puts the opening lesson on measure in prayer beside a final measure for sovereign conduct.
203–205A name that remains young
Moscow — VIII292:4081 running, VIII292:4081 · end of running passage, note 11 cross-reference; VIII433, Appendix V · printed appendix evidence · Mohl — VI254:4200 running, VI255:4201 running, VI255:4202 running · Ganjoor — sh83:197 running, Checked local gap after sh83:197 · Khaleghi — VII427:4127 running, VII427:4127 · end of running passage, note 4 · actual apparatus
Moscow VIII p.292 · Moscow VIII p.433 · Mohl VI p.254 · Mohl VI p.255 · Ganjoor sh83:197 · Khaleghi VII p.427
All four sources say that Anooshirvan is dust while his name remains young. The English foregrounds justice as the reason and expands the closure by two couplets. Mohl runs these additional verses, connecting good deeds to the king’s lasting name and saying that the wise bless his soul while the sphere and earth stand. Moscow’s running text ends with the youthful name. Appendix V prints a longer alternative with praise that lasts for the same earthly and heavenly span. Khaleghi-Motlagh prints comparable material below his running text in manuscript variants. Ganjoor ends at the youthful name. The English thus carries the chapter from a public reputation earned by right action to the voices of sages who can assess the king’s judgment.
Source record and limits
English
205 published English couplets. Ganjoor passages: Anooshirvan §83: 1–197. The English text follows the published verse and chapter divisions.
Moscow
The 1970 Moscow edition, volume VIII, printed pages 280–292. The source register identifies the running verses and the specific apparatus or Appendix V evidence cited.
Mohl
Jules Mohl’s Persian text, volume VI, printed pages 246–255. The source register distinguishes his wording and order from the corresponding running verses of the other editions.
Ganjoor
Anooshirvan §83: 1–197. The Persian column gives the corresponding running verses. When Ganjoor has a local gap, a labeled Mohl reading supplies the Persian where available. Adjacent passages stay linked.
Khaleghi-Motlagh
Djalal Khaleghi-Motlagh, volume VII, printed pages 409–427. Square brackets mark verses retained in the main text with explicit editorial reservation. Printed additions have their own locators.
The order of the questions and the ending
The four running texts share a sequence of questions with different wordings and several independent additions. Mohl preserves a separate warning against neglecting the royal virtues, the question about escaping grief and the invitation to praise a ruler after death. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh also preserve the question about who is least distressed and an extra verse on fleeting joy. The latter is bracketed in Khaleghi-Motlagh. The common running ending is the verse on Anooshirvan’s still-young name. Mohl continues with two verses, and related material is printed in Moscow Appendix V and Khaleghi-Motlagh’s apparatus.
Consequential readings
English 2. The Persian frame invokes the daftar or book of the champion. The English identifies it as a Pahlavi account. The Persian epithet for the elder and for the book evokes the language of the old epic tradition. English 5. Khaleghi-Motlagh calls on the maker of time, while the Ganjoor and Moscow running text give the maker of the world. Mohl likewise uses the world. English combines the appeal with “time’s Lord.” English 10. The four running accounts distinguish treasure obtained without personal effort from the miser who refuses to give from it. The English describes a man who gathers and hoards it. English 16. The Persian speaks of cultivating wisdom so as to nurture one’s soul. English “cherishes the wise” makes the beneficiaries of the verb people. English 20. Moscow, Ganjoor and Mohl speak of the wise man joined with farr holding the world under his wing. Khaleghi-Motlagh makes the same relation a negative test, the ignorant man with farr cannot hold the world. English 24. The Persian retains the list’s ordinal jumps, giving a first principle and then explicitly naming the sixth, seventh and eighth. The English counts its selected steps more continuously. English 27. Moscow and Ganjoor put the eighth principle after the four qualifications. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh put discriminating friend from foe before the qualifications, as does the English. English 29. Mohl adds a negative consequence for turning away from these qualities. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh proceed from the qualifications or harmless rule to the good name that survives death. English 30. The Persian says no bad name remains after the qualifying king dies and he will find paradise. English turns both outcomes into punishments for the person who lacks the qualifications. English 33. The Persian wish concerns excess and the return of the corresponding demon; it does not name a wish for heaven. English changes it to the repulsion of temptation through a wish for heaven. English 34. The running verses concern baseness and the accumulation of wealth or the desperate parallel with a demon. The English makes the pious man’s prayer resist temptation. The specific image of prayer defeating Ahriman has no verified separate counterpart here. English 41. The running verse names a speaker who knows or seeks the right occasion and thereby keeps his honor. The English foregrounds wit and laughter. English 42. The Persian king calls the fourth speaker heart-pleasing and possessed of judgment. The English recasts the storytelling as idle speech. English 43. The fifth speaker is warm, sweet-tongued and gentle-voiced in the four running texts. Falsehood and its political consequences in the English are not present in this local Persian classification. English 44. The interwoven Persian words satisfy the desire of the heart. The English turns the consequence into lasting shame and damnation. Its Hell motif recurs at .170 with different, direct Persian support. English 59. The position of “not” and the agency of remembered custom vary. The running line makes leaving a world held by sword and justice emotionally difficult, anchored by the following couplet. English 64. Moscow and Ganjoor have prayers before them, referring to the kings just named. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh explicitly give “before the fire.” English 70. Moscow and Ganjoor have an increase in knowledge. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh give an increase in joy, the term used by the English. English 77. The convergence on sixty and taking a seat before forbearance belongs to all four running witnesses. English 83. The running verses compare fewer words and more justice. English preserves the fewer words and changes the second part to more secrets. English 87. Ganjoor’s wise person neither keeps nor harbors fear of harm. The editions vary in the construction. The English presents prudence as an active defense. English 91. In the running Persian the spirit has come forward to meet or accept Time. The English reverses the relation by making Time serve his spirit. English 100. The Persian says praise should not exceed what exists and that the ruler does not search out what subjects hide in their hearts. English instead expresses a wish to know those hearts. English 115. Mohl continues directly to the failure of rest caused by a bad reputation. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh also give a separate verse making badness at the beginning and the end explicit. English 119. Mohl has the additional remark that Shah and subject alike pass from the world’s fear and pain. The other running texts move to the next question without this separate line. English 123. This additional question about release from worldly causes of tears runs in Mohl. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh move from grief and fear to the question about treasure. English 124. Mohl’s separate answer makes knowledge a condition of ease. The neighboring running sequences of Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh have no separate question and answer at this point. English 130. Mohl and Khaleghi-Motlagh have a separate question about who is least distressed. Moscow and Ganjoor proceed with the following verse. The English turns the answer toward shamelessness. English 131. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor describe an outward turn to Yazdan with a body burdened by sin. Khaleghi-Motlagh’s running text reads without guilt. The English follows the first three for the burden of sin. English 144. The sky gives the scale of comparison. The Persian question and reply identify someone beyond it, who judges the judges of the world. English 149. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor say he was, is, and will be while existence persists. Khaleghi-Motlagh’s second half has a differently worded formula including existence and nonexistence. English 153. The displayed running verses give sensation or reason only while life is present. Dissolution’s separate hand is the English’s restatement of the lifeless body. English 158. Mohl adds the explicit question as to which former sovereign merits praise after his death, closely matching the English. English 165. Khaleghi-Motlagh describes the seeker of fine points. Ganjoor, Moscow and Mohl begin the answer with dark disposition. The image of fineness or hair occurs in all four. English 177. Mohl runs a separate statement that worldly pleasure passes. Khaleghi-Motlagh runs the corresponding version in brackets. Moscow and Ganjoor pass directly from the company of the wise to knowledge and counsel. English 181. The running second half urges pardon for what admits of pardon. English interprets the passage as measured generosity, then turns to openhanded friendship. English 187. The Persian refuses to credit wealth as rank or poverty as baseness. The English’s “high station as thin air” stresses the worthlessness of rank itself. English 191. The running Persian predicts eventual regret after the reply or the shame one brings upon oneself. The English makes the other speaker’s return and request for pardon explicit. English 198. The Persian clause is conditional on a friend praising the man above the measured estimate just given. English changes praise to concrete help and joins it to increased eminence. English 204. Mohl continues after the verse about the freshness of Anooshirvan’s name with a pair on his righteous deeds and lasting name. Moscow prints a longer alternative in Appendix V. Khaleghi-Motlagh prints the corresponding material in his apparatus. Ganjoor ends with the freshness of the name. English 205. Mohl’s last couplet says blessings will reach his soul as long as heaven and earth endure. Moscow Appendix V and the longer alternative actually printed by Khaleghi-Motlagh give related wording. Mohl explicitly names the wise as the people who bless him, which gives direct support for the English sages.
Limits of the evidence
Running text, bracketed running text, actual printed apparatus and checked local gaps indicate distinct kinds of support. Local gaps concern the specified passage. Moscow Appendix V and Bondari’s Arabic prose quoted in the critical apparatus have separate labels. English details with no established local counterpart are identified in the notes.
Source-only verses
Moscow VIII p.280 · Moscow VIII p.281 · Moscow VIII p.282 · Moscow VIII p.283 · Moscow VIII p.284 · Moscow VIII p.285 · Moscow VIII p.286 · Moscow VIII p.287 · Moscow VIII p.288 · Moscow VIII p.289 · Moscow VIII p.290 · Moscow VIII p.291 · Moscow VIII p.292 · Moscow VIII p.433
Mohl VI p.246 · Mohl VI p.247 · Mohl VI p.248 · Mohl VI p.249 · Mohl VI p.250 · Mohl VI p.251 · Mohl VI p.252 · Mohl VI p.253 · Mohl VI p.254 · Mohl VI p.255
Khaleghi VII p.409 · Khaleghi VII p.410 · Khaleghi VII p.411 · Khaleghi VII p.412 · Khaleghi VII p.413 · Khaleghi VII p.414 · Khaleghi VII p.415 · Khaleghi VII p.416 · Khaleghi VII p.417 · Khaleghi VII p.418 · Khaleghi VII p.419 · Khaleghi VII p.420 · Khaleghi VII p.421 · Khaleghi VII p.422 · Khaleghi VII p.423 · Khaleghi VII p.424 · Khaleghi VII p.425 · Khaleghi VII p.426 · Khaleghi VII p.427
Selected printed readings
- Khaleghi VII410:3933 running · یکی دست برداشته بآسمان / همیخواهد از کردگار زمان
“Maker of time” in the critical running text helps explain the English “time’s Lord.” - Khaleghi VII411:3947 running · چنین داد پاسخ که نادان به فر / نگیرد جهان سر به سر زیر پر
The critical reading says an ignorant bearer of farr cannot take the world under his wing. - Mohl VI247:4025 running · به هشتم که دشمن بداند ز دوست / بیآزاری از شهریاران نکوست
The eighth item in the running list precedes the four conditions of a worthy ruler in Mohl. - Mohl VI248:4027 running · وگر زین هنرها نمایی دوری / همانا که یابیش بیآبروی
The negative consequence in Mohl gives the English a local parallel for its turn from royal merit to disgrace. - Khaleghi VII413:3969 running · چهارم که دانا دلآرای خواند / سراینده را مرد بارای خواند
The Persian names a pleasing speaker and regards him as judicious. - Moscow VIII282:3927 running · به پنجم که باشد سخنگوی گرم / به شیرین سخن هم به آواز نرم
The fifth kind is associated with a sweet, gentle voice. The English gives this place to falsehood. - Mohl VI249:4064 running · نبودی چنین پیش آتش دراز
Mohl explicitly places prayer before the fire. Khaleghi-Motlagh has the same essential phrase. - Khaleghi VII415:3992 running · بپرسید هنگام شاهان نماز / نبودی چنین پیش آتش دراز
The critical edition names the fire in the second hemistich. - Mohl VI249:4070 running · کز آن مر ترا رامش افزونترست / دل بدسگالان پر از خونترست
Increased joy is the counterpart to the ill-wishers’ bloody hearts. - Moscow VIII284:3967 running · شما را سخن کمتر و داد بیش / فزون داری از نامداران پیش
The comparison is fewer words and more justice. - Moscow VIII285:3984 running · ستایش نشاید فزون زآنک هست / نجوییم راز دل زیردست
The speaker says praise should stay proportional and that he does not seek the subject’s hidden thoughts. - Mohl VI251:4123 running · بپرسید رستن از ینها به چیست / که بر کار گیتی بباید گریست
Mohl separately asks how one escapes the misery occasioned by worldly affairs. - Mohl VI251:4124 running · چنین داد پاسخ که دانش بود / که داننده دایم به رامش بود
Knowledge, and the ease it gives the wise, answers the separate question. - Khaleghi VII420:4055 running · بپرسید مردم که نستوهتر / چنین گفت کان کو بیاندوهتر
The question and answer use a comparison between being less troubled and less grieved. - Khaleghi VII420:4056 running · بگرود به یزدان و تن بیگناه / بدی بر دل خویش کرده تباه
The critical text describes the body as guiltless. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor describe the body as carrying sin. - Mohl VI253:4155 running · کرا دانی ای شهریار زمین / پس از مرگ بر که کنیم آفرین
Mohl explicitly asks which earlier king should be blessed after his death. - Khaleghi VII424:4099 bracketed running · که این رامش اندر زمان بگذرد / مهندس مر او را همینشمرد
The warning that joy passes stands in brackets in the critical running text. - Moscow VIII292:4081 running · چنان هم که از داد نوشینروان / کجا خاک شد نام ماندش جوان
The main account ends with the justice of Anooshirvan and the youth of his name after his death. - Mohl VI255:4201 running · به کردار نیکو بود بیگمان / چنین نام او زنده در هر زمان
The moral action and the survival of the name are explicit. - Moscow VIII433, Appendix V · printed appendix evidence · ز کردار نیکو بود بیگمان / چنین زین نام او زنده جاودان
An alternate verse about good conduct and lasting reputation is printed in Appendix V. - Mohl VI255:4202 running · بود تا به جایست چرخ و زمین / ابر جانش از بخردان آفرین
Mohl names the wise people who bless his soul as long as the sphere and earth endure. - Moscow VIII433, Appendix V · printed appendix evidence · همی تا به جایست چرخ و زمین / ز هر کس به جانش بود آفرین
The appendix uses a wider group of mourners or well-wishers. - Khaleghi VII427 note 4 after 4127 · actual apparatus · بود تا به جایست چرخ و زمین / ابر جانش از بخردان آفرین
The critical apparatus prints this end wish with witness variants, including readings that widen the blessing beyond the wise.
E3.5 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | VIII280:3885 running | VI246:4000 running |
| 2 | VIII280:3886 running | VI247:4001 running |
| 3 | VIII280:3886 running; VIII280:3887 running | VI247:4001 running; VI247:4002 running |
| 4 | VIII280:3887 running; VIII280:3888 running | VI247:4002 running; VI247:4003 running |
| 5 | VIII280:3889 running | VI247:4004 running |
| 6 | VIII280:3890 running | VI247:4005 running |
| 7 | VIII280:3891 running | VI247:4006 running |
| 8 | VIII280:3892 running | VI247:4007 running |
| 9 | VIII280:3893 running | VI247:4008 running |
| 10 | VIII280:3894 running; VIII280:3895 running | VI247:4009 running; VI247:4010 running |
| 11 | VIII280:3895 running | VI247:4010 running |
| 12 | VIII280:3896 running | VI247:4011 running |
| 13 | VIII280:3897 running | VI247:4012 running |
| 14 | VIII281:3898 running | VI247:4013 running |
| 15 | VIII281:3899 running | VI247:4014 running |
| 16 | VIII281:3900 running | VI247:4015 running |
| 17 | VIII281:3901 running | VI247:4016 running |
| 18 | VIII281:3902 running | VI247:4017 running |
| 19 | VIII281:3902 running | VI247:4017 running |
| 20 | VIII281:3903 running | VI247:4018 running |
| 21 | VIII281:3904 running | VI247:4019 running |
| 22 | VIII281:3905 running | VI247:4020 running |
| 23 | VIII281:3906 running | VI247:4021 running |
| 24 | VIII281:3907 running | VI247:4022 running |
| 25 | VIII281:3908 running | VI247:4023 running |
| 26 | VIII281:3909 running | VI247:4024 running |
| 27 | VIII281:3911 running | VI247:4025 running |
| 28 | VIII281:3910 running | VI248:4026 running |
| 29 | Checked local running-text gap between VIII281:3910 running and VIII281:3911 running | VI248:4027 running |
| 30 | VIII281:3912 running | VI248:4028 running |
| 31 | VIII281:3913 running | VI248:4029 running |
| 32 | VIII282:3914 running | VI248:4030 running |
| 33 | VIII282:3915 running | VI248:4031 running |
| 34 | VIII282:3916 running; VIII282:3917 running | VI248:4032 running; VI248:4033 running |
| 35 | VIII282:3918 running | VI248:4034 running |
| 36 | VIII282:3918 running; VIII282:3919 running | VI248:4034 running; VI248:4035 running |
| 37 | VIII282:3920 running | VI248:4036 running |
| 38 | VIII282:3921 running | VI248:4037 running |
| 39 | VIII282:3922 running | VI248:4038 running |
| 40 | VIII282:3923 running | VI248:4039 running |
| 41 | VIII282:3924 running | VI248:4040 running |
| 42 | VIII282:3925 running; VIII282:3926 running | VI248:4041 running; VI248:4042 running |
| 43 | VIII282:3927 running; VIII282:3928 running | VI248:4043 running; VI248:4044 running |
| 44 | VIII282:3927 running; VIII282:3928 running | VI248:4043 running; VI248:4044 running |
| 45 | VIII282:3929 running | VI248:4045 running |
| 46 | VIII282:3929 running; VIII282:3931 running | VI248:4045 running; VI248:4046 running |
| 47 | VIII282:3930 running; VIII282:3931 running | VI248:4046 running; VI248:4047 running |
| 48 | VIII283:3932 running | VI248:4048 running |
| 49 | VIII283:3933 running | VI248:4049 running |
| 50 | VIII283:3934 running | VI248:4050 running |
| 51 | VIII283:3935 running | VI249:4051 running |
| 52 | VIII283:3936 running | VI249:4052 running |
| 53 | VIII283:3937 running | VI249:4053 running |
| 54 | VIII283:3938 running | VI249:4054 running |
| 55 | VIII283:3939 running | VI249:4055 running |
| 56 | VIII283:3940 running | VI249:4056 running |
| 57 | VIII283:3941 running | VI249:4057 running |
| 58 | VIII283:3942 running | VI249:4058 running |
| 59 | VIII283:3943 running | VI249:4059 running |
| 60 | VIII283:3944 running | VI249:4060 running |
| 61 | VIII283:3945 running | VI249:4061 running |
| 62 | VIII283:3946 running | VI249:4062 running |
| 63 | VIII283:3947 running | VI249:4063 running |
| 64 | VIII283:3948 running | VI249:4064 running |
| 65 | VIII283:3949 running | VI249:4065 running |
| 66 | VIII284:3950 running | VI249:4066 running |
| 67 | VIII284:3951 running | VI249:4067 running |
| 68 | VIII284:3952 running | VI249:4068 running |
| 69 | VIII284:3953 running | VI249:4069 running |
| 70 | VIII284:3954 running | VI249:4070 running |
| 71 | VIII284:3955 running | VI249:4071 running |
| 72 | VIII284:3956 running | VI249:4072 running |
| 73 | VIII284:3957 running | VI249:4073 running |
| 74 | VIII284:3958 running | VI249:4074 running |
| 75 | VIII284:3959 running | VI249:4075 running |
| 76 | VIII284:3960 running | VI250:4076 running |
| 77 | VIII284:3961 running | VI250:4077 running |
| 78 | VIII284:3962 running | VI250:4078 running |
| 79 | VIII284:3963 running | VI250:4079 running |
| 80 | VIII284:3964 running | VI250:4080 running |
| 81 | VIII284:3965 running | VI250:4081 running |
| 82 | VIII284:3966 running | VI250:4082 running |
| 83 | VIII284:3967 running | VI250:4083 running |
| 84 | VIII284:3968 running | VI250:4084 running |
| 85 | VIII285:3969 running | VI250:4085 running |
| 86 | VIII285:3970 running | VI250:4086 running |
| 87 | VIII285:3971 running | VI250:4087 running |
| 88 | VIII285:3972 running | VI250:4088 running |
| 89 | VIII285:3972 running | VI250:4088 running |
| 90 | VIII285:3973 running | VI250:4089 running |
| 91 | VIII285:3974 running | VI250:4090 running |
| 92 | VIII285:3975 running; VIII285:3976 running | VI250:4091 running; VI250:4092 running |
| 93 | VIII285:3977 running | VI250:4093 running |
| 94 | VIII285:3978 running | VI250:4094 running |
| 95 | VIII285:3979 running | VI250:4095 running |
| 96 | VIII285:3980 running; VIII285:3981 running | VI250:4096 running; VI250:4097 running |
| 97 | VIII285:3980 running; VIII285:3981 running | VI250:4096 running; VI250:4097 running |
| 98 | VIII285:3982 running | VI250:4098 running |
| 99 | VIII285:3983 running | VI250:4099 running |
| 100 | VIII285:3984 running | VI250:4100 running |
| 101 | VIII285:3985 running | VI251:4101 running |
| 102 | VIII286:3986 running | VI251:4102 running |
| 103 | VIII286:3987 running | VI251:4103 running |
| 104 | VIII286:3988 running | VI251:4104 running |
| 105 | VIII286:3989 running | VI251:4105 running |
| 106 | VIII286:3990 running | VI251:4106 running |
| 107 | VIII286:3991 running | VI251:4107 running |
| 108 | VIII286:3992 running | VI251:4108 running |
| 109 | VIII286:3993 running | VI251:4109 running |
| 110 | VIII286:3994 running | VI251:4110 running |
| 111 | VIII286:3995 running | VI251:4111 running |
| 112 | VIII286:3996 running | VI251:4112 running |
| 113 | VIII286:3997 running | VI251:4113 running |
| 114 | VIII286:3998 running | VI251:4114 running |
| 115 | VIII286:3999 running; VIII286:4000 running | VI251:4115 running |
| 116 | VIII286:4001 running | VI251:4116 running |
| 117 | VIII286:4002 running | VI251:4117 running |
| 118 | VIII287:4003 running | VI251:4118 running |
| 119 | Checked local running-text gap between VIII287:4003 running and VIII287:4004 running | VI251:4119 running |
| 120 | VIII287:4004 running | VI251:4120 running |
| 121 | VIII287:4005 running | VI251:4121 running |
| 122 | VIII287:4006 running | VI251:4122 running |
| 123 | Checked local running-text gap between VIII287:4006 running and VIII287:4007 running | VI251:4123 running |
| 124 | Checked local running-text gap between VIII287:4006 running and VIII287:4007 running | VI251:4124 running |
| 125 | VIII287:4007 running | VI251:4125 running |
| 126 | VIII287:4007 running | VI251:4125 running |
| 127 | VIII287:4008 running | VI252:4126 running |
| 128 | VIII287:4009 running | VI252:4127 running |
| 129 | VIII287:4010 running | VI252:4128 running |
| 130 | Checked local running-text gap between VIII287:4010 running and VIII287:4011 running | VI252:4129 running |
| 131 | VIII287:4011 running | VI252:4130 running |
| 132 | VIII287:4012 running | VI252:4131 running |
| 133 | VIII287:4013 running | VI252:4132 running |
| 134 | VIII287:4014 running | VI252:4133 running |
| 135 | VIII287:4015 running | VI252:4134 running |
| 136 | VIII288:4016 running | VI252:4135 running |
| 137 | VIII288:4017 running | VI252:4136 running |
| 138 | VIII288:4018 running | VI252:4137 running |
| 139 | VIII288:4019 running | VI252:4138 running |
| 140 | VIII288:4020 running | VI252:4139 running |
| 141 | VIII288:4021 running | VI252:4140 running |
| 142 | VIII288:4022 running | VI252:4141 running |
| 143 | VIII288:4023 running | VI252:4142 running |
| 144 | VIII288:4024 running | VI252:4143 running |
| 145 | VIII288:4025 running | VI252:4144 running |
| 146 | VIII288:4026 running | VI252:4145 running |
| 147 | VIII288:4027 running | VI252:4146 running |
| 148 | VIII288:4027 running; VIII288:4028 running | VI252:4146 running; VI252:4147 running |
| 149 | VIII288:4028 running | VI252:4147 running |
| 150 | VIII288:4029 running | VI252:4148 running |
| 151 | VIII288:4030 running | VI252:4149 running |
| 152 | VIII289:4031 running | VI252:4150 running |
| 153 | VIII289:4031 running | VI252:4150 running |
| 154 | VIII289:4032 running | VI253:4151 running |
| 155 | VIII289:4033 running | VI253:4152 running |
| 156 | VIII289:4034 running | VI253:4153 running |
| 157 | VIII289:4035 running | VI253:4154 running |
| 158 | Checked local running-text gap between VIII289:4035 running and VIII289:4036 running | VI253:4155 running |
| 159 | VIII289:4036 running | VI253:4156 running |
| 160 | VIII289:4037 running | VI253:4157 running |
| 161 | VIII289:4038 running | VI253:4158 running |
| 162 | VIII289:4039 running | VI253:4159 running |
| 163 | VIII289:4040 running | VI253:4160 running |
| 164 | VIII289:4041 running | VI253:4161 running |
| 165 | VIII289:4042 running | VI253:4162 running |
| 166 | VIII289:4043 running | VI253:4163 running |
| 167 | VIII289:4044 running | VI253:4164 running |
| 168 | VIII289:4045 running | VI253:4165 running |
| 169 | VIII289:4046 running | VI253:4166 running |
| 170 | VIII289:4047 running | VI253:4167 running |
| 171 | VIII289:4048 running | VI253:4168 running |
| 172 | VIII290:4049 running | VI253:4169 running |
| 173 | VIII290:4050 running | VI253:4170 running |
| 174 | VIII290:4051 running | VI253:4171 running |
| 175 | VIII290:4052 running | VI253:4172 running |
| 176 | VIII290:4053 running | VI253:4173 running |
| 177 | Checked local running-text gap between VIII290:4053 running and VIII290:4054 running | VI253:4174 running |
| 178 | VIII290:4054 running | VI253:4175 running |
| 179 | VIII290:4055 running | VI254:4176 running |
| 180 | VIII290:4056 running | VI254:4177 running |
| 181 | VIII290:4057 running | VI254:4178 running |
| 182 | VIII290:4058 running | VI254:4179 running |
| 183 | VIII290:4059 running | VI254:4180 running |
| 184 | VIII290:4060 running | VI254:4181 running |
| 185 | VIII290:4061 running | VI254:4182 running |
| 186 | VIII290:4062 running | VI254:4183 running |
| 187 | VIII290:4063 running | VI254:4184 running |
| 188 | VIII291:4064 running | VI254:4185 running |
| 189 | VIII291:4065 running | VI254:4186 running |
| 190 | VIII291:4066 running | VI254:4187 running |
| 191 | VIII291:4067 running | VI254:4188 running |
| 192 | VIII291:4068 running | VI254:4189 running |
| 193 | VIII291:4069 running; VIII291:4070 running | VI254:4190 running |
| 194 | VIII291:4071 running | VI254:4191 running |
| 195 | VIII291:4072 running | VI254:4192 running |
| 196 | VIII291:4073 running | VI254:4193 running |
| 197 | VIII291:4074 running | VI254:4194 running |
| 198 | VIII291:4075 running | VI254:4195 running |
| 199 | VIII291:4076 running | VI254:4196 running |
| 200 | VIII291:4077 running | VI254:4197 running |
| 201 | VIII291:4078 running; VIII292:4079 running · VIII p.292 | VI254:4198 running |
| 202 | VIII292:4080 running | VI254:4199 running |
| 203 | VIII292:4081 running | VI254:4200 running |
| 204 | VIII292:4081 · end of running passage, note 11 cross-reference; VIII433, Appendix V · printed appendix evidence · VIII p.433 | VI255:4201 running |
| 205 | VIII292:4081 · end of running passage, note 11 cross-reference; VIII433, Appendix V · printed appendix evidence · VIII p.433 | VI255:4202 running |
New Naqqali